>> good afternoon and welcome to the san francisco planning commission regular i'd like to remind the members of the audience that the commission does not tolerate disruptions of any kind. proceedings. and when speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record. i'd like to call roll at this time. commissioner president hillis commissioner vice president richards commissioner fong is present and just left commissioner koppel and commissioner moore we do expect commissioner johnson and commissioner melgar to arrive shortly consideration of items proposed for continuance. items one a and b inclusionary affordable housing fee and requirements proposed for continuance to march 23,

inclusionary affordable housing fee and dwelling unit mix requirements proposed for continuance to march 23, 2017. at the time it was proposed for continuance today to april 6, 2017, and item 2222 sutter street 3rd floor proposed for continuance to april 6, 2017. third floor conditional use authorization proposed proposed for continuance and 214 states street proposed for indefinite continuance. further commissioner under our regular 0 calendar item 10 inclusionary affordable housing program ordinances. informational presentation is proposed for continuance to march 16 i have no other items proposed for continuance there are no speaker cards. >> >> any public comment on the items proposed for

continuan continuance. >> good afternoon my name is paul wormer i'm here on behalf of the coalition torts neighborhoods i'm a delegate to the orientation for the telegraph hill and here 0 request on inclusionary affordable housing fee and requirements proposed for continuance to march 23, 2017. it be extended for a longer than period of time the reason is that the materials at least what we're final have been out for a short period of time and the amount of review necessary given the fact two competing proposals is going to be necessary longer than what is proposed awhile much of the matter have been considered by the controller and by other confirmation analysts there are policy considerations

that i think the community ought to have a chance for input for example, the measures of appropriate income levels have using a hud existence probable not appropriate for san francisco that should be discussed the feathering in of the new proposals over 15 years seemed like a excess period of time to think about that these are examples not meaning to raise an issue but asking for a longer period of time thank you very much >> is there any additional public comment? >> and just to be clear items one ab proposed for continuance to march 23 we're stooerntd that to prevail 26. >> oh, yeah and commissioner vice president richards before i move to continue as

outlined just as a comment if the public speaker public speaker on the continuance on the item we've gone through the hud definitions on the affordable housing density bonus program i think a.d.nychia and if you look at the hearings we've going to move as proposed to continue matters commissioner fong commissioner koppel commissioner moore commissioner vice president richards and commissioner president hillis so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 5 to zero and commissioners under our consent calendar consent calendar, are considered to be routine and may be acted upon by a single roll call vote of the commission. there will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member of the commission, the public, or staff so requests removed from the consent

calendar and considered as a separate item at this or a future hearing. item 4 case 6101 california street aka 207 23rd avenue conditional use authorization and item 5, 404 balboa street conditional use authorization there are no speaker cards. >> okay any members of the public that wants to request 4 or 5 being removed seeing none, public comment is closed. commissioner vice president richards move to approve items 4 and 5. >> a thank you to approve under the consent calendar commissioner fong commissioner koppel commissioner moore commissioner vice president richards and commissioner president hillis so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 5 to zero and places us under commission matters.

item 6 consideration the draft minutes minutes for january under the health commission minutes i'd like to read into the record two during the course first that supervisor tang and commissioner matsuda for the health commission were absent and that the meeting started at 10:11 a.m. not p.m. there are no speaker cards. >> thanks jonas public health on the minutes seeing none, public comment is closed. commissioner moore. >> move to approve with notes correction. >> thank you commissioners on that monoxide emotion to approve as corrected commissioner fong commissioner koppel commissioner moore go commissioner vice president richards and commissioner president hillis so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 5 to and zero and places excuse me - on item

7 commission comments and questions. >> commissioner moore. >> we received an e-mail with a request for an evaluation for the city attorney's office this is the first time we've been asked to do so i look at the forum and had high praise for the city attorney's office but the questions that are asked with completely relevant irrelevant and ask we get a formal recuse from having to fill out the forms we don't spoke on the speech on the extension none of the questions apply to us i'm asking the commission sorority to clarify for the commission we don't have to fill out the former. >> expirations that is the

first time we've been requested as a department or other departments to forward on the surveys to the commissioners as well i think that is booirl you will to you. >> individual commissioners to decide who you answer the tac the survey and whether or not you omit certain of questions from submitting any kind of response i know that director rahaim and myself will be filling out the requester in charge. >> this is a survey to look at the services and it is totally voluntarily. >> i'd like to restate i trust your judgment in terms of you forward to us. >> thanks commissioner vice president richards. >> on tuesdays new york state on the first page welcome to uber and lyft commuters inch through new york an interesting article of inputs of services on new york a couple of facts the

actual speed of the vehicles on surface streets is one more like 15 million pricks jade in the apps in october alone and there were 50 thousand drivers in new york i understand we have $30,000 drivers i caregiver to the gentleman's memo he hbtd last week the director referred to for the un - data collection it underway with the routes of increased new trip generations for the land values hopes to quantify the effects of online vehicles and the amount of parking on delivery companies and hov on developments so manage we've been asking for it

is interesting in the new york times and thank you to the department for quantifying it. the second item you might recall on february 9th we have cases 26 avenue this was a dr because there were two unit that will be altered one unit being 4 thousand please square feet and another one reduced to seven hundred square feet in over the course it came out from the neighbor there was a elderly tenant living in one of the units carl jensen a communication from mr. jensen and want to read it i'm trying to make a point carl on 26 street san francisco dear commissioner president hillis and planning commissioners in the, llc that was presented on 29 i want to clarify i'm a

93-year-old man that lives in the building regarding due to his sdrunsz age i've desired to be in an apartment not to climb up and down the stairs and he writes this is a typewritten letter i did not repeatedly express a desire to be relocated to an part time climbing up and down the stairs is not a big deal if he wishes i'll provide rescinding tenancies for others nearby that was a quote from the project manager or project sponsor it would be nice if some things are repaired but don't wish to move he can live in the property he writes i want to continue to live in the property 1954 this is my home and signed

it i tried to print but because of printer it didn't work why am i reading this my mother is 93 years old and carl is 93 my mother is 93 can't imagine this person has to go through this to live in the future or where it is - carl was found dead in his dpaermentd 3 days ago i can't imagine someone trying to get through the stress it is incredible, incredible i tried to put my mother in that situation i can't imagine where i think this is relevant we got project sponsors history but not two instances in none it living in them and the neighbors have to come and tell used in was

true they were not volunteering it i'll ask the department at least in the addition to the history you have an ask is there anyone living there i'd like to adjourn the meeting in memory of carl jensen it is unfortunate this happened. >> thank you commissioner vice president richards we'll do that no other comment we'll move on to the next item. >> complirz department matters. dowment. >> commissioner >> of appeals and historic preservation commission. >> good afternoon aaron starr manager, legislative affairs. for the planning department first on the land use committee was supervisor kim's to allow the intercontinental was

continued to march at the supervisors request and next the general plan amendment for the xhafgsz in the general plan and commissioners you heard this on december 2nd of last year and voted to recommend approval at the land use committee supervisor peskin made opening remarks and hope in the future the chair will schedule those sooner or later since the board has 90 days to vote on the amendment it was tight but due to scheduling conflict of interest of the transfer of committee roles and the land use committee and the need 8 o'clock bring this is to small business commission go after staffs presentation and public comment which there was none supervisor peskin stated his objection not a one-size-fits-all and supervisor tang countered she found another way by removing the concentrations in the general plan it allowed a more

tailored approach to the commercial district so at the current three percent is two restrictive and wanted to work on providing the criteria for the neighborhood commercial district in there is district and the end supervisor farrell and supervisor tang made to motion to move the item forward with a with a positive recommendation it passed with supervisor peskin voting against the item and last on the calle quarto special use district introduced by the mayor and supervisor ronen to one establish eating and drinking establishment is controls that is allowed since the concentration is removed from the general plan and two requires cu for medical service use and the meeting the storefronts into larger than 8 hundred square feet and for replacing the legacy business and 3 to require any use you cu to meet at least 4 of the 6

proposes for establishing the sud you heard this this year where you voted to recommend approval with one modification to exempt the uses from a restaurant from an eating and drinking control and land use hearing 11 speakers none in opposition and the public spoke about the need to preserve the corridor and the quality of 24th street a special plays and mentions that will help the existing businesses stay in proclamation and instead moved it unanimously to recommend to the full board at the full board supervisor kim's ordinance for the art and games passed the second reading the planning administration and health code go amendment will allow the affordable housing project at 950 or arrest 9 -

the baby diaper changing ordinance supported by supervisor tang and co-sponsored by sxesh sxhaesh passed the second reading and little planning for the upper market sponsored by supervisor sheehy essential and introduced by this board pass the first reading and the hearing as a committee of the whole for families with children scheduled tortoise was continued to march 14 next week and finally the general plan amendment to the element was sent to the committee and had the first reading and passed as well so far no introductions. >> thank you mr. starr any questions. >> commissioners the board of appeals met last night no items of interest and the historic preservation commission didn't meet places us in general public comment members of the public

may address the san francisco local agency formation commission periodically pooifks pooifks reached in the meeting. each member of the public may address the commission up to three minutes. i have one speaker card. >> thanks jonas donald. >> commissioners a resident of san francisco a little bit of update in people their against teacher housing advocating not to build near a school and in an interesting quote isn't that parking space or parking lot a beautiful space in trump administration they are

considering $6 billion less and less money towards public housing and subsidized housing also two measure r failed by 22 percent in la and agree the supply and demand is capped the sales hike by a two-thirds vote we elected supervisors over the last two years i haven't seen a piece of legislation that keeps the promise because of supervisors when it comes to funding for homeless programs and building more market-rate a new report from the states non-pacific gas & electric office found local opposition to accommodate the demand for local residents has led to an esteem shortage of housing that drives up the prices the builders need

to double the amount of housing to keep with the job growth in the state of california thank you. >> is there any additional public comment? >> ms. swedish all right. >> hi commissioners tom from the human rights committee i wanted to take for a moment about what we're seeing in the city we're seeing a lot of deaths of seniors in apartment people who are dying while evicted and one of the things i think this raises a question of is what the commission can do and one of the things you can do outlaw the rent-controlled units those seniors live in rent-controlled units one is someone you've heard of at the commission carl jen so son that lived near

church a building where the already failed to tell you about someone in the unit and you continued to june 1st mr. jensen was found dead in his apartment on monday i'm not a doctor but having spoken to him and tried to work with him to stop any evictions of this man that is my belief the stress of a possible displacement from his unit is what killed him he was extremely terrified of leaving his units the last time i spoke to him i was shaking and practical in tears. >> talking about no circumstances under which he'll leave the part time been there since 1954 again 93-year-old you don't take someone of that ample and move them from the place

they've been for a chunk of their lives his death is a huge tragedy in the city but i think it pertains to the fact it we need protection for the seniors elaine turner died being evicted and others iris a one hundred was in critical condition inform icu one days of the eviction it is clear to me that seniors ouch don't survive evictions we need more protection for seniors one way will be by exempting the rent-controlled units from being demolished because seniors live in the rerlgz they live there for a long time so i think that is one thing that commission can do to try to help us stop this what i see as a beginning of the

epidemic of evictions of people in the 70 and 80s and 90s and one hundred-year-old i hope you'll think about that and help us. >> thank you very much. >> ms. swedish. >> it is really sad i never met him mr. jensen thank you commissioner vice president richards so for putting this up the hearing today in his memory i know the neighbors are afraid for him didn't mention him at the hearing about that dr because they felt it could put him in jeopardy i think any age should be upset but 93 i think he worked for i city when a young man a what can you say, i think what tommy said makes sense and commissioner

vice president richards said makes sense those projects come in they have preliminary information should be required to tell the tenants i know like in fourth i talked on fourth and liberty and people were looking to see if anyone is living in the unit when it was merged if you can't get rent-controlled units for the seniors there are things you want to do them the staff the enforcement people want to make sure that none it evicted and make sure part of the site permit and whether they were going to take mr. jennings sons unit behind the garage ambassador 317 i have a 311 with the plans i network to bring them one on jersey i don't think

a 93-year-old live there bus both got evicted one unit behind the garage and one unit upstairs i'll bring the plans next time i come this is an issue there is various approaches to deal with it but certainly one should be could be when a project comes in someone has to sign a form with no tenants living there especially no 93-year-old gentleman. >> thank you, ms. there any additional public comment? >> seeing none, public comment is closed. commissioner vice president richards. >> just two data points one regarding the supply and demand we mentioned this we have 46 thousand affordable housing units in title ready to be built 6 thousand krnl built 40 thousand not being built i want to understand this commission is

not a birthday to creating housing the capital maeshthd and the lack of skilled labors and second i don't recall the source this week i read the 25 percent of san franciscans are going to be older than 62 so 25 percent of the population seniors thank you. >> phoenix's your regular calendar item 10 has been continued which places us on item 11 southern bayfront strategy update. >> good afternoon josh with the planning department staff last may wisp here with the colleagues from the office of economic workforce development to introduce you to the southern bay front an interagency coordination effort and negotiated for the collection of major sites stretching from mission creek stretching to candle stick point and the county line in those projects

will transform our waterfront with new open space and public amenities and housing and jobs and others investment in the intern i've had a couple of presentations on those projects with pier 70 and mission creek and than be that in the efforts this presentation this item today is a quick update on the status of the various plans on the southern bays front what we're heard from the commission and public and an update on the framework guiding the sites with that, i'm going to turn it over to rich from oewd. >> good afternoon, commissioners if i got the screen we're happy screen the back in front of you as josh said to provide an update to the commission on a lot of work in the thinking that is going on the southern bay framework between last may and now how to

negotiate those on affordable housing and transportation, and a host of other topic we'll go over relinquishment is an important process we expect you approvals on 3 major development providing 4 thousand units of housing and two to three million square footage the mission creek and mission rock on the calendar is a frorpgs on the basin which we're excited is ready for a district attorney but i want to make a point before i more often those large go negotiated projects several in this part of town as well will be providing the bulk of new housing units and be generally able to provide affordable housing more passion or prejudice and working with the staff and other city staff

to keep those on schedule and through the process in the shortest possible time without skipping on the outreach and vetting this is a reminder of our housing goals and we are in fact, well along the way you can see on the slide since meeting the goals with more than 17 thousand units approved, of course, our thirty thousand goals i will point out that these projects you're part of southern bay are a major source of affordable housing in particular in this case, the built to do workforce housing and so you've seen this slide those are the geographic airs and the one in yellow the southern bay and front we need to focus on planning and the

acceptance of the transmitter of some not all of the industrial character of the waterfront to new mixed use projects this is just a close-up making the point not a blank slate but people work in the planning and thinking bans being sensitive and adding to the neighbors and the community as we go again, just a larger view of all the change that we will see along the southern bay front at least 20 thousand new household are pledges to get 1/3rd affordable the 6 seven hundred number comes from and 38 thousand jobs estimate and more than 5 hundred acres of new open space that the city will see in

for essential future. >> those investments will transform the community into assets for plays to live and work and create from formal industrial land and what we are working towards and have been for sometime to put together a coordinated framework so we are thinking holistically what we're asking for for the developers i made that point all of the projects in front of you 45 in the next few years will be negotiated vementsd we don't want them as one opt but based on the framework we're thinking ahead of the things we're asking for a here's a schedule just to show you what had in store as do everything i can e decision

maker in 2017 and then the other two the formal potrero and the hunters point power plant a year or two behind those this is a big year and, of course, a couple of more within a couple of more years and what i'll do briefly run you through the 5 projects you'll see without too much detail pier 70 which is a joint venture between the port and forest city on a 20 acre site and 16 hundred housing units 60 percent and nine acres of new public space. >> next and in general a chronology order not encloseic is the mission rock the port and

giants 27 acre and one thousand housing 47 affordable and new public space. >> be india basin the privately owned site in the bay area looking 12 hundred housing units 20 plus retail and commercial space and 15 acres of new public space in partnership with rec and park last two are further away in time getting started on community processes the first one is a formal potrero power plant which was known as is n r g but sold by that entity to another exit known as the capital and the land is not known you can include up to 2000 housing units and commercial development and

opportunities for other things including the public space last but not least is the formal hunters point power plant owned by pg&e in the bayview neighborhood and those land uses include up to 12 houses housing units at this point i'm going to turn it over to my colleague mike martin and carli and take you through mainly what are the topic areas we want to negotiate on public benefits and the framework what are we hoping to get from transportation and all the other topics i'll give it over to mike. >> good afternoon, commissioners mike martin in the office of economic workforce development so as mention and outset this is the second time in front of the commission last year, we did presentations

informational and feedback from a number of agencies that are part of the interagency working group that was described that started this may and went through rec and park and sfmta board and the ocii commission we followed that up with a number of the community presentations from interested groups both in terms of tops and locations of those projects that extend though the end of last year into early this year and saw a lot of feedback that helped in drafting the strategy and packing speaking with the project sponsors what we want to see from the agreement this side presents a summary of frequently heard comments affordable housing should be prioritized for the residents and the projects should be contribute to advanced workforce training and target specific employment opportunity at the

project we needed to make that linkage especially, when projects are doing forward thinking not only approaches to construction by end use an opportunity to build out the streetscape improvements should occur ahead of the implementation limit the number of car trips and find a way to get people out of their cars in the impacted areas new open spaces should be public even though their built by public and should feel this is part of their amenity and not new projects obviously the plan for sea level rise and should be designed with forward-looking sustainability we do looter ambitious policymaker and this is the time to implement those ambitious policies

moving there the negotiation a number of topics that those red circles are key clusters of issues we're seeing in the community feedback sections as well as communications that the project manager the rest of the presentation will go 0 through those one at a time we'll start off with the housing affordability not far from people's minds what we've been able to build with the project sponsors the goal and commitment to reach 33 percent of affordability across the projects individual projects may come into above or blow as publish go mentioned those are opportunities we're directing in the wrong direction with the projects things like larger unit sizes for example, and things like more opportunities to find ways to find more income

projects into excuse me - units into those projects because of limited tools for the motor to middle-income families never mind of subsidies the mixed use approaches with the redeploying to find the subsidies in a way to grow that middle to moderate housing and obviously the important thing to fully max maximum the below-market rate to the resident through the neighborhood preference to the approaches through the negotiations with the federal housing urban developments to maximize that and do a really sort of affirm active assert job to market those opportunities for the people that can afford them i'll hand off to carlie to talk about the transportation

aspect of the strategies. >> good afternoon, commissioners carlie sfmta the southern bay front are the beneficiaries of a number of really major transportation projects that have been long in the making and on the verge of being delivered talking about the subway to the t third there in frequencies the transbay terminal the building out of green and the 16 street rapid bus in addition to a number of very locally focused improvements that make those neighborhoods that exist in the areas around the projects safer and more efficient and better for walking and biking and that's the basin most of those projects will be delivered before the majority of the new

development that is coming forward we're really seeing some transformative transportation changes in the area those projects will benefiting from but the transportation obligation each project we're looking how we take now the system that we've been spent a lot of timeing putting in place and making sure that works well and these projects contribute in a positive way so that the people who already live there and who are moving there will be working and visiting the sites are really support north america in their mobility and assess some of the areas wear focused on in the negotiations are combranz core of this area

growth is predicted on the t line working and having capacity those are the kinds of things we'll be looking for from developments will support additional railcars or the signaling to reduce the delays or maintenance and repair facilities and a number of sites will be relying on existing and new bus routes to contribution to the bus routes to make transit reliable are critical we'll be looking for contributions to fill key gaps in the transportation be network there are key gaps in the east west and north-south bike connections and key safety gaps in the industry those are the kind of apps we will work toward and looking for the projects to contribute to the next

generation of transportation investments things like the 16th street ferry landing or other transit are some of the examples what this is what we're looking at in terms of dollars and asking the projects to do things at their own sites to support mobility and assess we've altogether had a long communicates about the important of transportation demand management and will be, of course, acting those projects having robust tdm and working in the spirit of tdm orientals but the size of those projects and the mix of 4ru8dz we'll be looking for opportunity to community-based above and beyond what the tdm has in performance and metrics and potentially more options to be explored additionally we're looking sites

design to support walking, biking, and transit use focusing on near the transit creating or recreating historic grids and also asking the projects to construction their portion of the bay trail through the sites those are the areas of transportation negotiations that we're really looking towards and already working on handing it back to mike martin to talk you, you through other sectors of negotiations thank you. >> commissioners i'll try to move through the rest of the slides briefly and efficiently i guess first to start with open space this area on the projects we're proposing over 5 hundred acres of renovated open space frankly the largest sector of potential open space the city will see half the size of golden

gate park we want to balance the access of the existing neighborhood looking at neighborhood amenities the land and water recreation the location of the waterfronts looking for space for a large recreational area for somewhat that is underserved and designing the spaces their public to all and assessable to the residents and having hopefully despite the fact that each the projects that is different in terms of ownership of the land and what agency is organizing one single stovt for reserving picnic tables and things we're looking that cooperation as part of framework. >> in addition on stability i alluded to earlier those are promotions we're looking forward thinking i think one great example of this is the recent

amendment to the water ordinance looking at large projects to consolidate and more efficient systems looking to comply with the orientals doing so in a different way we're excited about the challenges to learn to try to think about ways to sort of promulgate those more than fully master projects taken together all the sustainability for the southern bay front what achieve exciting outcomes looking at 35 percent reduction of green house gas emissions as compared to existing buildings 42 mill gallons of portable water in the existing buildings and 25 percent of their developed areas dedicated to

open space these may achieve that in a different manner as i mentioned sea level rise it is obviously a key issue each the projects sort of first have not capacity have designs we've been looking with the infrastructure agency to make sure they can withstand the projected 21 sea level rise and related storm and run off they need to have additionally adaptive for the shoreline open spaces not to lose the open space without understanding hopefully to maintain the integrity of the area and follow the lead of the port of san francisco for mission rock and pier 70 included financing mechanisms for future adoption so sea level rise is faster the system will protect the development we'll allergy to have resources available to protect those elements but the areas next to them without existing protection plans a.

>> do you want to take a couple of more minutes to finish up. >> thank you, commissioner very quickly workforce development again as mentioned earlier critically we want to find the training programs for opportunity or opportunity in a timing way not only those projects are making commitments as to hiring local residents but also, they will have supply of local residents and move forward and give those jobs to people that need them in addition a lot of the jobs have excuse me - those projects have trades involved i think have about historically in shortage we can find a way to build that base there will a huge victory for the strategy so in closing the next stems and noted on the -

there we go in the earlier slide that mr. rich showed we want to end in the conversation go back and understand how we're looking at the issues simply again each project may not hit every mark but on a holistic score card and try to make sure they build off and improve so we have something that sticks together in a way that is good i'm sorry if i move back - >> i apologize one slide i skipped not only public services but community facilities lying like impoverishes and health centers we're trying to negotiate the project that the city and relevant agencies can work on to provide the amenities where their needed and also with the help of planning department

looking at the needs of cash areas to see what we can do when we need to the areas of the city with that, i'll close and we'll respond to questions excuse me - >> thank you very much open up for public comment i'm sure commissioners will will have questions any public comment on this item. >> no. >> seeing none, move to commissioners questions. >> commissioner moore. >> it is exciting i love comprehensive large-scale planning and from the city can pride on the northern and central and how the pieces fit together with the eastern neighborhoods, etc. i think we have a strong i love that is comprehensive only one thing did you think about utilities and providing for additional capacity for this, etc. your

nodding great congratulations. >> thank you commissioner melgar. >> thank you. this is really thorough i just had a couple of questions there are a couple of things that are new to me that is the negotiations framework so the community benefits you talk about sea level rise mitigations we benefit this is great and autism with an mta person this is not happening i'm wondering what it looks like and who new york city it and what does that look like and the second thing, too in the affordable housing now including the small site program acquisitions of the 33 percent and wondering what that looks like within the that going into the pot or within a radius of the project or what that looks like.

>> commissioners we're going to divide and conquer two first for the projects themselves they're designed i think are trying to take account of the needs to elevate the built areas but a fixed shoreline basically on the project a scope from the waterline and thinking how the water will vaps because that is not going to be a steady sort steady line moving that site but storms to push it up and out so planting that can handle the emancipation proclamation dictated at the water if they - in addition for those elevated buildings you know what are the additional protections based on the most likely signage after the use of building but take that into into account and what

is needed is the resources to do that adoption we don't know all the things to protect the projects or the areas but we can try to set up the funding mechanisms to the extent they'll pay for the need infrastructure for the future build out so trying to have a flexible strategy as we see it gets higher and high how the assess rise but understanding how those projects will deliver what they need to the folks. >> on the second question about the small site program acquisition for those watching the idea in some cases the developer providing new onsite or paying a fee for the affordable housing are able to

acquire rent-controlled building with the requirement for the mayor's office of housing generally have that are at risk of being you know bought or the tenants evicted or generally where we want to see folks stay in their homes and quasi those as the affordable housing requirement our philosophy has been whether there are policies in place we try to start with these the idea of a development agreement we ousted with our permission to depart from the codes if we can justifies why is it makes sense your question had we had the hearing that was continued but one of the new piece of legislation that is moving through about expand the small site program acquisition as a way of satisfying air force arrangements so this is here like i said, we try to start what we think existing policy is

on the development agreement to the specific question i think i'm correct. i don't know the letter the proposal i think that small site program acquisitions have the radius requirements of identifying housing i think i'm 9 percent correct i'll check if i'm not. >> thank you commissioner vice president richards. >> thank you very much it is nice to get this tied as a high-level with the neutral projects not sure how they relate i agree with commissioner moore and commissioner melgar thank you for your presentation a couple of questions i know that when you look at this in the context of eastern neighborhoods they can have the development agreement and projects come forward and pay fees a portion of whatever the impact was and built and you have the infrastructure come later

years later and sometimes not the question i have on these specifically agreements will there be any deficit making up of the impacts in the eastern neighborhoo neighborhoods. >> part that have may go to your staff i'll try first so a couple sort of comments the first one on the eastern neighborhoods he had like to remind the commission that to we certainly should've, would've, could've been faster i will point out that the time the units are built and occupied from the eastern neighborhoods as opposed to to when their entitled two or three years sometimes longer most of infrastructure probably most of infrastructure called for by the plan will actually be in place

when the units are built i like to caution we're not doing as badly because of the length of time even after the builder inspector and taken time for the unit online and you had presentations in the past most of infrastructure will be there 0 i don't think we're looking to solve deficits i think the presentation that the gentleman made we have a ton of investment in transportation in particular coming to this part of town we mostly trying because those projects you heard about today are large and generally have a lot of needs to make sure we can build on top of the central subway so for the structures to satisfy the needs frankly we don't have a lot of deficits

your staff is tracking that but mostly trying to solve what is coming. >> sure i'll add commissioner on the open space front those projects will be delivered in a substantial amount of open space the reason we see e is in expose of we've been delivering 9 acres for a couple off thousand units those are substantial opportunity that are being delivered to the benefit of the entire community the timing i have to defer to the canyon on the delivery but in terms of making up as you said the deficit some are dmrifr in open space well in expose of projects will need in and of itself do you on the amenities those are providing i think we are talking working on amenities that needed a spill over of

people in the old eastern neighborhoods like projects that are visiting the amenities the grocery store and all that stuff the capability to handle the whole eastern neighborhoods including the waterfront. >> of course particularly in the open space working with rec and park and the port and our staff i know that looking for instance, in the central waterfront and what is the suit of open space and amenities that are there and gaps and how to identify the kinds of facilities to help to fill the gaps. >> recreational amenities. >> on page 22 there is a bullet called alternative transportation options i mentioned when i had commission comments and questions. what the ridership services on the traffic congestion, etc. i know that is not considered we had a memo something i raised

you know that's one of the things we're not counting for some kind of impact on the congestion and your public transportation around that so - >> thank you, mr. rich for reminding me about the development. >> commissioner koppel. >> thanks mr. president, and thank you to the staff involved i'm impressed with the various report and especially number one, the sustainability i've seen addressed more than seen addressed in any project before low carbon communities alternative inform transportation options all building can say greener and emergency vehicle and ac/dc and energy storage all that stuff

makes for a sustainable development i'm also really glad to hear that the you know city really trying to involve the workforce programs i frequently spoken to the citibuild classroom and talked to kids about a career in the trades in san francisco and literally located a couple of blocks if that and great opportunity for the san franciscans to get those career opportunities and get a chance to work on the newest technologies in san francisco and lastly the xurment of workforce middle-income housing so that kind of brings my pots full circle not only will this be a sustainable development but encourage the san francisco resident to build those projects and eventually give them possibly a place to live maybe

in their existing neighborhoods so very impressed with the report. >> thanks commissioner vice-president richards you. >> and struggle with the parking and on the different projects with the da do you know what the parking percentages will be with the parking spaces. >> it might be key to making everything work. >> i mean it is project by project i think that is probably fair to say no project also parked lower and i think when we get to the southernly projects not to tell people they don't need a car but probably well below one to one and more like one to one on the southernly projects. >> i understand the

transportation demand management network it companies are tdm and by that time hopefully, we know that we can understand better what it will be. >> a followup one of the advantageous of the large site they can take a collective approach to parking and not a building by parking space in - will be centralized garages and the plans are designed such that as time progresses may be one or more will not be needed by the time the build out so create more spaces for housing so their flexible and can be managed in a more thoughtful way than if the project was individually building parking spaces. >> commissioner moore. >> i hope that as looking at the southern project we're starting to look at ripening

solutions and 3w0u8ding we looking at regional sharing of infrastructure that helps cars and individual entitlements to be kept as low as possible. >> thanks. >> just a clarifying question on the privately owned project will they be coming as da. >> the two port promotions will come to you as daas a contribution with the port and the community benefits and the obligations the 3 private projects will be just development agreements the city didn't have a financial interest in the land. >> what's the zoning for the 3 were they rezoned as part of eastern neighborhoods or one pd or whatever. >> the old industrial zoning. >> yeah. >> okay. thank you. >> any other questions no,

thank you for the presentation and the comprehensive approach to these projects commissioners that places us on item 12 india basin informational presentation. >> good morning, commissioner president hillis i'm ed snider of planning department staff i'll quickly hand it over to phil ginsburg and put this we'll focus on a little bit more from the overall waterfront at the india basin 3 general sites the old hunters point pg&e power plant and the other nine hundred

indonesia for the ship rights cottage and associated boat yard and next to that two rec and park properties their developed by rec and park and i7dz that it is pursued as a mixed use development we're very excited to rec and park and build will be publishing arrest eir shortly and focusing on this project looks like right now i'll hand it over to phil ginsburg and michael will provide a presentation on the build projects myself, josh of our department are here to answer questions with others of the oewd. >> thank you, mr. schmidt did

care. >> thank you, commissioners good morning the sequencing of those presentations work the large-scale overall of the plans on the southern waterfront and a lot of you asked questions about the open space we have at&t the opportunity to explore and drill down into one significant open space opportunities that touches the building development project and a couple of the others were referenced in the presentation in a sense to share with you about the work happening at the india basin before i hand it over as precursor era broad and unique partnership and been an honor to work with not just sister

agencies with office of economic workforce development and the san francisco parks alliance and community like a phil randolph and taking that commitment to open space and understanding the importance ever having open space as density increases very seriously i want to set a context here before diving in the reason i'm here this is a very special park opportunity for our city the park system is old one hundred plus jerald you don't get an opportunity to focus on golden gate park or christie field or broadening bridge or millennial i think in any professional career a once in a lifetime the stars are

aligned one .5 acres of open space ken and michael and josh talked about the overall southern waterfront project offering about the opportunity for about 5 hundred and 20 acres of open space this focuses on to drill down about 65 and we're going to get drill down more narrower and focus on 13 acres which is the core elements the india basin but the goal here to create a seamless park for park users that steams in the ned that is the park if you're looking at the presentation that is owning and operating by the park and moving south through the pg&e property along what they're working on shoreline park into india basin open space

i'm not i'm not sure what the diagram is on you see that showing up. >> as you can see moving both the pg&e property i think was mentioned into the large presentation into a park in the india basin shoreline park a park built with over a decade ago into parcels at the nine hundred the hub of the chip building activities and we own and manage called the india basin open space we were moving south that envelopes the built development and bill will talk about their open space projects will be adjacent to the india basin envelope and then when our 5 point the nci i such an amazing opportunity to create

open space so a little bit how we got here this has been planned and studied for decades in different iterations i think this time the stars are aligning for a number of reasons we gave me in our own waterfront construing study to pull this together we relied on a very serious and thoughtful planning effort of folks that thought about that before us that did the studies and - we incorporated that both a workforce that was a community driven with that, and involved stakeholders focus groups and partnered with the outreach apr i helped us to facilitated facilitate that for recommendation across the bayview we're not just building a park for the new unit and density we're building a park

for people that are there now that is an important value for us in the project and to honor our both our social and environment justice to those who are living in that area now so we have a ton of feedback this is a number of different meetings onsite and we ended up with 7 core community priorities for this area that is gathering sprays spaced/amenity and we're supportive of being able to get a cup of coffee and play and fitness preserving the history, restoring and preserving very awesome nature spaces i'll be with you i guess i a media unlawful on a more contentious afternoon this is an important

element of our nature wild spaces everyone was cognizant of sea level rise in the project and people wanted to touch the water so very quickly with respect to gathering spaces and kwoings for port swings and social feeding and plazas and food trucks and pick nick and places to buy snacks and fruits and vegetables with the adults teams and kids we wanted to work with stakeholders to offer active recreation for people to enjoy the escape and kayaking and walking, biking, and fitness equipment all a priority for the community

is historic resources in the area are important here we go we want to really horn the site and celebrate this legacy we have scout scooters small boats that served as a primary part of transportation with the bridges and restore a number of those that contribute to the ship cottage the office building and tool shed as well as there is a very in water shipwreck onsite i talked about the natural areas that is a special place the port did a wonderful job welcoming restoring the natural elements

of this waterfront site so we want to restore the habitat and create more things to thrive in this says that the prior presentation talked about sea level rise wear aware of this location the park is designed to adopt with sea level rise all the major infrastructure will be a lot of the one and 21 year for the site we prop a natural edge along the corridor that will ab scottish water and needing and frankly mitigate the sea level rise the site itself we did hold a a pretty significant where am i here - okay we did hold a significant design competition we got a number of submissions with community

members on the panel that selected the architecture firm with nickel a woman owned well known firm out of seattle so we got a garden walk that goes follows the site shoreline and with picnic tables and play areas as you can see here a little bit this is an incidental of what we're referring to as mandarin way to gather and play with an actual connection to the shore that will include a graph he will beach with you active the graph he will beach will serve as a paddleboard launching area if you can see it in the slide

not two well, an building to provide kayaking and youth programming it is actually out in the water 7 spaces the 8 space is the water itself it allows access to look into the ramp this is amazing these are what we call the sage 0 slope we're reintroducing the planets to the site to have to advanced or enhanced habitat that is the 700 innes i noticed the home of the boat building and a repair yard until the 1990s the remedy amenity have abandoned building we acquired we got c pa funding to help with the planning phase now and we are quite hopeful about

receiving additional funding for remediation so this is the ship rights cottage a historic structure the pin shop and outcome you'll see sketches the cottage at the top left serves as a welcome center with a warm hut coffee cafe the paint shop in the for ground is going to be programmed with boat building and a little bit of mark spirit to the site an outlook public safety lesson with a programable space we - it features the title we had

lands and spaces and new places to gather and play and again, we don't get this opportunity very often it is just amazing waterfront space this is our moment for the next generation of san francisco to build one of the nation's great parks we'll do facts and circumstances in phases it will be extremely expensive this is the recreation of the 700 innes and tackle the shoreline park area and this i love this project for so many reasons this is there are so many public and private and community partners coming together in support of this project and it is just very special i promise to be short and brief i'm done. >> thank you mr. ginsburg.

>> commissioners pleasure to be here this morning this afternoon michael with build we're the project sponsor for the other half of this amazing sited i think it bears pointing out that the site is a combined eir with two separate project buses definitely related projects i want to reiterate what phil said this is absolutely my pleasure to build things that is bold that we teamed up and not only again rec and park and build team up about a ecology with the public trust and san francisco parks alliances and emphasis the india basin association who has been

extremely partner i don't is that lighting with that said i hope that all the commissioners are aware where the site is we sometimes have slide it is washed on the screens we justified and shipyard candle stick point that area is called the india basin the neighborhood is named after the water feature that is india basin the site as it stand is already extraordinary it is super natural because most of what you see was create by post world war ii in the early 19 hundreds felt like san francisco this was after world war ii and we sometimes jokingly called that the east daily city we think this was taken from the glass

excavation and another urban legion this is the straw that broke the camels back the entrepreneurs was hauling out things and dumping into the bay an interesting site it is gone feral and wild on that feral wildness we're embracing and want to keep on moving forward with as phil alluded to this map shows an extraordinary keystone, if you will, one of the best waterfront in the city has to offer on a few occasions go it is called of the southeast i like to call it the broadening bridge park i want to reiterate the data that is an uninterrupted $5 million that is public assess will be all public

assess if we're successful 60 acres of new park lapd's that is equivalent with the broadening bridge park in broadening new york the subject to the eir is the patchwork this is build owns over 17 acres or binding opposites on the red land pursue rec and park owns is the second largest owner with the green the shoreline and the existing india basin open space the india basin shoreline acquired 700 innes and a few unexclaimed paper streets are public right-of-ways none have been accepted all the acidities are consolidated and remapped after the planning process extraordinary planning on the site begins in 1969 when we

pulled together all the various plans over lapsing from sfmta and the redevelopment agency to the planning department to mta we were surprised at the wealth of information our primary document the community vision with the india basin shoreline in 2010 with all of that information we have engaged i think in an extraordinary public process that began started with a phone call from malia cohen who said bill i suggest you find out what we want and work with them we worked with the larger membership by have a india basin working group we've met with consistently for 3 years around the kitchen table i kid you not we've expanded and have

organizations in the broader bayview a bayview working group that is placed a similar role beyond the india basin and presenting to bcdc and to the cca for cac an achieve process also on top of to pull together all the previous work build financially sponsored two comprehensive plans that took all the documents updated them into two online documents we call the india basin transportation action plan a website i'm pleased when you have the time check it out and the ivory master plan was exhaustive run by rec and park along with the nonprofit stakeholders with builds

participation as for our side as for build starred with 5 principles were borrowed from the neighborhood goal one to complete the neighborhood the neighborhood has few amenity within the walking distance and first and foremost for the public life focusing on public life with a building avenue human scale they don't want another mission bay we've gone owl you thought our way for parcel sizes and building types excuse me - cultivate the urban ecology and finally growing a legacy business the stewardship on a plan with rec and park our team i failed to mention o o m and my colleague will talk about their efforts bio a landscape

firm and gail architecture out of san francisco and cop hag they're on the - i'm trying to go fast we have a comprehensive program i want to say one of the number one, major focuses of that is the water a couple of key data points before we get into the design of the site as zoned m-140-x we mapped out in sort of did a presentation with the neighbors showed them what we do if at the followed the zoning none the supervisors or anyone we spoke to said continue forward with the zoning the neighborhood plan you see here has ambitious goals for

open space over 49 percent want to see a open space we see the coverage plan that dedicated 43 percent of site i by concentrating and pulling development off obviously of others this results in a net there of 3 housing unit 1 acres we continued to transfer to the city that will mean that build site from 17 to 14 acres when we are done the marge the zoning looks like development up north of united states pretty you know large blocks typical san francisco grid a lot of development capacity after the exhaust process a village that puts density and two key 14 story

buildings with most of density by the future transit stop it is incredibly well sued bus of typography steep hills to the south west of us and that allows this height to tuck into the hillside and exhaustive hill sites and one typography taken if morgan heights in the basin at the street level now as it is today with the future that is 2, 14 story building and more because of that substantial drop we're able to sustain the views throughout the area. >> i already mentioned the transformation of the shoreline i'm not talk about more but one thing we're louk folks the people that filled this put a lot of fill and then used it as

graph he will and soil for decades we're in an area with compaction with relatively assessable what's the word load bearing layer unlike areas we have to do 200 and 50 not piles our studies show compaction has occurred sea level rise high-level again because of unique aspects believe it or not in the worst case scenario none of the land will be affected we have adoption that leo will speak to briefly and bcdc jurisdiction and some other federal agrees a one hundred foot shoreline banned in the

interjurisdictional good news we're going to continue that as wetland and parkland and proposing to have a wetland mitigation in the 90s part of sfoer so has interesting history and finally here's the geo tech studies the fill and how deep the load bearing is and where we are at before i hand it off i appreciate your patience the project will is one unit and a bunch of these to single-family home townhomes and 250 engross square feet of neighborhoods retail and potential school site and finally i think that commissioner vice president richards asked one-on-one parking and parking for parking the commercial and the public uses this with that said, we believe a significant transform in transportation and so that parking we're building specific

to are adapt able to be converted with that, we have our colleague and, of course, available for questions after. >> thank you, michael on behalf of myself thank you for the opportunity to describe to you a little bit about our thinking and thought processes we went through and developing and evolving this important project it's been said a couple of times india basin is a special place this place is really about where the city meets the wild this characteristic is near and dear to my heart they have numerous community members and the wild is at the heart of proposal the goals been for us to add to the diversity of the wonderful

ranged neighborhood in san francisco by creating a place that is unique to this site a site in the basin your design is based on a careful consideration of the characteristics of the site and the aspirations of the community when we look at the fabric of the existing neighborhood the continuation of the street grid is not an appropriate response when we take the constraint that michael talked about the geo tech technical and have greater assess to the waterfront and mitigate the effects in the strong afternoon wind we developed a concept off set block pattern that will mitigate those winds and be fine-grained to allow for the pedestrian movement through the neighborhoods also by responding to that

geotechnical layer we're able to place the building in such a way for an urban edge that allows for the urban fabric to interlock and body camera one another rather than a hard separating edge when it comes to the movement systems we believe it is violating important that the inner basin is into the fabric we connect the bike and the vehicular fabric through a series of r0u89s that are linking everything from we have the transverse route through the existing stairwells out to the water and it also creates a series of route north and southeast and phase three out like a probated cord at the

intersections of those two systems we're going to create a series of spaces from large wholesale to small-scale for a diverse arrangement people can gather at the heart of all that neighborhood a new public market a place where community events celebrations, weekend market and other kinds of activities that brings the community together will be hosted it's ends will be activated with retail and amenity as you can see here one edge will be directly connected to the green making that apparent where you are in the city a small town triangle maybe a quieter street and something that is important is what a special place that will be in

the immediate relationship between the homes and open space directly connected supportive that had been like no other place in the city there will be a terrace that overlooks the coffee to the north supported with retail again from the terrace you can have panoramic views to the reconcile as well as direct assess you see in the boardwalk people have spoken phil ginsburg and michael spoke about how unique it is to provide that access to the water there will be a beach perched above the shoreline wetland and then the area of the large open space will be really a meadow the land will be skumentd to provide a sense of preparation for the city as you

move to the edge to discover the bay and discover public arts and to have recreation there will be places you will have moments of quote concentration and then the design goes out into the bay looking at the wetland and the title areas and creating really a living shoreline that will also accommodate sea level rise by creating we're creating a series of steps or wetland where the sea level comes to continue to be supported rather than being inundated the movement network underlying principle to create a difference range of route and pathways that gives the neighborhood and the residents a difference range of

activities the two red lines the primary connections from the hillside to the existing stairs along griffith to the waterfront these will obtain supplemented and then there will be the main green line you see moving across the site will be our neighborhood retail streets this will be the heart of all the services and amenity that we have for the broader community we've horde time and time again the neighborhoods really looking for those kicks off services and amenity to give their neighborhood the heart the bicycle need not is carefully cooperated with the north side park to the south and

will include a dedicated median separated two-way class 1 bike parking spaces on indonesniinni >> the bay trail will be aligned through the big green rather than next to streets you're actually able to enjoy the waterfront transit we're fortunate this is compact neighborhood so one bus stop will put the entire neighborhood and the shoreline within a 5 minute walk to transit and then a range of streets that really reflect the different character and needs what they serve and again will be a

pedestrian escalated street and the flats will be a series of shared streets for the neighborhood so taking you through. >> check on time i know you have a lot to cover. >> i have 5 slides left appreciate the time. >> a quick view of the plaza looking down walker where the market and the green is three hundred feet away some of the pedestrian pathways and down the hill with their stairs for intimate spaces and the shared public way through the neighborhood which we see having visually no car traffic in all the place a visual to the bay for the green and then quickly both land use and our parceltion designed to

have up against innis and paper down the homeopathic and the activities and the density as you move towards the water in particular the parcel sizes the larger parcels on innis and by the time you got to the waterfront this will add to the diversity and homes we're going to be having guidelines that will guide and help create a difference character to the architecture and want to say what it mass been important for the project it is really we see that as a very unique and kind of have a new model for how the city interacts with the wild and the bay and give us an opportunity to think about the way we continue to grow our city fabric. >> thank you very much. >> so is that all you're done

with the presentation thanks. >> we'll open up for public comment and then open up for commission comments and questions. >> i have two speaker cards and if others want to speak please line up on the screen side of the room. (calling names). >> good afternoon, commissioners my name is jackie the executive director of the a phil institute which we mentioned a couple of times earlier and i also served over a year with the behaving psych the bay cca that was mentioned that hopefully, this project is able to get in front of you soon but apr i serves the bayview hunters point providing services we do workforce development and new

career development premeditating and over the last year worked with an amazing team rec and park and trust for public land and san francisco parks alliance and outstanding community participates we have over two decades of history in the neighborhood and what we did was design an outreach model we will expand and continue on ongoing communications we're committed to a role to make sure we create transparent around the project so that the community didn't feel as though the surprises you, you know i'm sure you guys heard community frustrations about development and being anxious about being pushed out this is one of the reasons why we made a targeted effort to do door-to-door outreach with greenway tours and roll out

community members get on the sites to see what potential they have we've engaged resident leaders and successors from youth to seniors and residents of all background and captured did difficult community that is our housing authority and but we wanted to talk about the health benefits that come from not only the park but the development overall we received a well-received back from the diverse community members not just in designing the shoreline park park but overall increasing the awareness what is coming to that part of town and some of the comments we've received included will this park and will this development be for the people that actually live here what's the upcoming workforce

activities and the assets and resources will they bring to this part of town we've showed positive aspects of growth and for years those vacant lot is neglected and here a huge opportunity to develop a vibrant walkable community if you guys been 0 out this not walkable or inviting but we're looking forward to continuing to work with the project team and keep our community members involved thank you. >> thank you, ms. flint. >> good afternoon i'm sorry. i'm phil here to speak about the comment of the community engagement and on the india basin so the trust land a national organization with the mission to partner with city organizations and nonprofits and community goes up to help to remote and create the park for

more than 40 years in san francisco partnership with rec and park community groups recently, we completed the hilltop but engaged and brought more than $8 million to this to renovation and partnered with the playground that break ground in the plaza earlier last month that will be a renovation of more than $2 million we've partnered with the community and city to understand what the park spaces the park is the need of that community both the existing community and the community that will be coming there and for the india basin we've partnered with apr i and several other community groups to do a robust community engagement to help us identify the priorities for the parks spaces and to the ideas composition we brought if designers and let the community

voice their opinion and been to community meetings and focus groups really working closely with task force that they reflect the community it's been a wonderful partnership wire excite to see the changes we're looking forward to continuing to partner with rec and park and the community groups to continue this design we're actually engaging in a environmental art groups to work with community groups for the spark to that site with an intern level waiting for the designed to finish and if you have any questions, we'll be happy to answer theming it is an exciting project we look forward to this completed thank you. >> thank you. is there any additional public comment on this item.

>> good afternoon, commissioners my name is impaneling michael i'm a resident and i have a business in india basin several years ago a developer came to our community and enhance speaking to the neighbors now that in and of itself is not unusual all developers talk to neighbors but what is unheard of is that developer listens to the neighbors and as consequence of listening to us with regards to height and bulk your goals in the stated in the neighborhood vision was clear we want logos at the water to rise up to take our building after this the plan before you today calls for low buildings at the water rising up to tall buildings nestled at the not of hill this is pretty

unique in san francisco to see a developer work so enthusiasmly with the community and so i'm happy with the plan as far as height and bulk i'm a enthusiastic supporter because of a reason you've heard others describe the unique and environment of this area india basin is truly a wild space nestled in san francisco all kinds of wildlife didn't exist in golden gate park that is isolated it is separate if san francisco in many ways i personally love waking up and watching the guarantees and the ducks in front of my house i miss the urban amenities that

everyone else in the city has a 3 pointed 2 miles not a day goes but i don't have to get in my car to do something i used to live in the haight i could buy groceries on my way home from work i don't have to get many a war car i'm looking forward to the urban amenity well the towers will provide that early on unlike patrol car that is promising amenities and the square feet by and by i want to enjoy them in any lifetime that will happen if at the build with the retail been the ground floor so as an individual i am enthusiasticly supporting this current iteration thank you very

much. >> thank you, mr. halley is there any additional public comment? >> good afternoon, commissioners my name is alex now day job i'm a research for the local 22 and looking forward to work with build but hearing michael talk lead me to come up one thing as planners one thing we do is almost take that same religious if you are berry of seeing things in the by and by and overtime we never see this stuff we believe it can happen i've been living in the neighborhood for 17 years this is it would be nice to see that coming together but i want to sort of point to this project really for you all as a micro came over of prepare for the worst and hope for the best before this and how it - we

recognize people and makes things more effective that brings things in like an apprenticeship people that are seeing this thing happen are involved on the transportation side more sharing and like real sharing sharing sustainability and shared parking not just ride share thinking and why we drive like michael said there is nothing in the neighborhood that easily assessable you have to drive where else and not only in india basin but on the bay front how is the city in its efforts we live there as well as most of

us that want to move there but do the daily things without getting into a car and it also related 0 infrastructure one of the things from this presentation when go michael presentation i'm sorry - lee's presentation the multiple uses of infrastructure multiple uses the streets and i think that as well can inform everything else happening along the southern waterfront really i guess if i sum up we're looking at projects flexible and changing and market conditions and i hate to use this buzz word one we hear all the time but resilience we don't know what is going to be happening in a few years and be able to have things that can wloefrn the storms that with

adapt and take what they've got coming thank you. >> thank you. is there any additional public comment seeing none, public comment is closed. commissioner johnson. >> hi we'll be saying more about the project in the future i'll keep it short start out by saying yeah. there is 7 year on the cca and it is fantastic to see this some of the conversations other hunters point shipyard and india basin was that black hole between hunters point and pier 70 which even at that time was eventually going to happen but ask who is happening in the india basin right in the middle that is a great project as well or great set of development projects you know hunters point shipyard and maybe doomed and there was not a green answer so wasn't a project i was excited to see everyone

broad-brush strokes and seeing more detail as time community-based organization by but existed to see bill working with the neighborhood and great to see there a lot of thought put into the connectivity like in the beginning talking about how you get even though e people to the rafting waterfront and excited to hear about the talk of greenway a term which goes in and out of favor sometimes you hear about it and sometimes don't i'm glad it is a thing going i have a few questions/thoughts about things i've heard and hopefully, will be take into account in the future discussions of india basin so the first one is on sustainability thank you for bringing that up the last public

candle stick park i think the chariot will swing low before we see this plus they actually discussed it's a pretty high end and sophisticated high-end measure with the cool stuff i wonder for this project will there be connection to some of the measures at hunters point shipyard this is essentially in terms of landmass a continuation of the project so it that would be great to hear from the project sponsor oh, go ahead. >> i love pneumatic trash disposal we can't promise anything but, yes 100 percent we want to push the boundary is the water despite the heavy rainfalls california has huge

issues with water we have an incredible opportunity to build a muni district to all the forward-looking things we'll have a state of the art stone water a treatment system and by the way, part of sea level rise strategy it it their inundated new block of saltwater will take the place of wetland and replace it formed by the stormwater this is a that whole piece that is interesting around habitat and habitat restoration we're investigating 100 percent black water how to harvest and reuse onsite with the current california regulations and perhaps be an importer of water for the vast mop up amount of irrigation that requires water

the good news we're in really fantastic conversations with sfpuc with ocii and rurmdz 5 points will be full 234re7b8gd water facility if they don't it don't make sense to be redundant if this didn't happen we're exploring the feasibility i think that is financially possible to do our own recycled water. >> it a fantastic it is good to hear that and with the hunters point shipyard they had to dig up with all new infrastructure i asked the question it is great to find ways to join forces thank you for that oh, you can sit michael thanks. >> just a couple of other things i'm glad about the facilities because they involve

a lot of approval and funding from other departments and sort of a lot of coordination i'm hoping e hoping that some of the ideas will stand so i know in terms of pool and childcare and fire department and all of those things i'm hoping all the things are on the list i know it can be tough we require funding and coordination so again, i'm existed i think one last comment i'll make in terms of this project is that it's really exciting to hear some of the community and this is ongoing; right? from days in the past really want to see urban amenity and walkable neighborhoods so this is a great opportunity to really demonstrate for the rest of the city what that can look like in the southeast is essentially going to be moving in the center of the city

towards that area in the future you see this is a great opportunity to be a model for what san francisco in the future can look like i'm excited. >> thank you thank you for all your hard work and looking forward to seeing more. >> thank you commissioner moore. >> this is a bright light we approved sea level rise it is great to sit here and this project does there and more than one way and excited to see us stand for the broader spectrum of what needs to be done moving forward i love for us to have projects that exemplifies i believe this project sets a high bar in every way a great team and excited to see the challenges and people challenge each other to raise the bar higher and encourage everyone in

the room including my commissioners in case you haven't done it take time and walk from downtown to the site which i've done twice i had the pleasure of being invited to with two locations that's irrelevant many people that he roof gathering an amazing experience to come to the separately waterfront and the transformation all the way to mission bay and take a break as the park that is absolutely fabulous we see in experience the transformation of the city at our own walking pace i suggest it when you do you'll understand the deputy and sensitivity of what this project is suggesting i wish you could tell you there was a