part of filing a decision. our fdrb is a policy decision. we're moving forward and starteh the oldest and those cases willm oldç to new to make sure that p to get these cases done. because there are a lot of thine balance in terms of issues thato be raised, training issues and . we don't want to wait two or ths before we address the issues. >> are you saying we're going te forward without waiting for theo finalize their review? >> yes. >> commissioner marshall. >> i want to check on one thing. the oiss that you reported on ts evening, if i'm look at the dats correctly, they seem to have all occurred before the new supporty was if place, is that correct? >> i'm not sure what you're ask. >> was it december -- when we pç

that's what i mean. >> 16? >> i'm looking at the dates. >> the send of -- i have to doue check. >> i was looking october 7th. this is just for me. it was 2014. one was january 2015. so my read on it. >> the first ku one, commissiont was adopted december of 2016. last ois 2016 occurred october , 2016. the first oned up the new polic- first one under the new policy s 17-001, january 6th, 2017. doses that address -- does thats it?ç >> i'm looking for that one. >> this report has the summaried dates. >> i was looking at this one. but that's okay.

but you told me. the only one after this will wa- >> you'll see the d.a. process l is accelerating. we received charges decisions f. there is definitely movement fo. as the chief said, there were ae of cases we've since received cg decisions for the formallal notn that went to the fdrb and we stt in the third quarter. >> but that's the discharge, ri? >> the discharges -- the first e cases were discharges that i me. so, yeah, we had one 2017 case s gone through the fdrb.

that is 002 which occurred out f county. so we -- that one was a differe. it was accidental. >> i think i got the answer to y question. >> sorry. >> president turman: thank you. >> secretary kilshaw srkt srkt a director directors report and announcement presentation of stl reports. summary of cases received. adjudication of sustained compl. for september 2017 and companion reports. >> president turman: good evenig director henderson. >> good evening, thank you. we're not going to go over ever. you have the reports in the pact there. you don't need me to read it tot i will highlight -- i want to me of where we are in terms of the.

i'm still working really hard to close out a lot of the older cao that i can focus and prioritize specifically on a lot of those - i mean moreç of the recent andt cases like the officer-involved shootings. the numbers i would point out ie calendar from the second and thd quarter are 2017 numbers. we're now at 545 closed cases. we typically don't close that ms throughout the year. just by comparing, last year wed at this time about 426 cases. a lot of these bigger numbers at of our older cases and 33 or 4 e business way of context are cass outside of the jurisdiction ands run on the cases and those comp. i will keep everyone updated.

in addition to that, the onlyçr news isç that my new chief of e been focused on hires. the department h -- focused on . i brought inç a new chief of st started and she went out to the- she went out to the officer-invd shooting that was in the castroe were talking about earlier. she attended last night's townhd attended her first police commin which was last week.ç well, it was memorable. she'll typically be here moving. the other thing i wanted to flan closing is the 90-day review th. i sent to folks in case anyone s questions on that on the things' been working on for the past 90n the office. i'll try to provide regular updo that in addition so everything t

have to be read in my longer ret the police commission meetings. that's it. >> president turman: any questir director henderson? thank you, director. sockets r.secretary kilshaw. >> secretary: commissioners rep. >> president turman: any reportç >> commission -- >> just so the commissioners knm meeting and talking to the cityy about last week's vote and i hae serious votes whether the vote s valid. the city hall building was lock, people were blocked, not able te in. people were locked out. i went down and got people permy

in. they were not able to stand forc comment. i am bringing that up with the y attorney and i want to let you m working on that. in the last thing, even though d within city hall, i think city y said it's proper, but i questior we announced that that we had me location to the public. it is a public meeting. i'm wondering if there were any violations ever the brown act. >> any other commissioner repor? secretary kilshaw. >> secretary: item 3-d schedulif items identified for future mees action. >> president turman: any announs and scheduling of items? >> i have one item that i have a question about. last week we received an enormof

documents around the administrae # 6 ---96-a quarterly report. there was a lot of data in it. if we get a report about it, anf there is any follow-up by any gi know it goes to the board of sus and mayor's office and dpa and o us. i just don't know then what haps because there is a lot of inforn there. >> who was the question directe? >> anyone who has an answer. >> president turman: seblght rs? >> secretary: you can ask for a. >> there is a human amount of dn there. some of it is positive and somes troubling. there is a tremendous amount.

it would be helpful if somebodyo through the high points and quen some authority. >> who did the report?ñr >> the department. >> the department will have a representative to present that . and we'll schedule it at a futue hearing. >> secretary: commissioner turm, identify aid like to announce ad like to announce a new items. >> i just want to keep on schedg docket, presentation before the commission of the community am . let me know when i can get that. >> any further commission repor? or scheduling of items -- pardo. secretary kilshaw, you had an announcement. >> secretary: for members of th, the commission and department wd the department's medal of valory

november 15th at 6:00 p.m. at te scottish right building 2850-19h avenue. additionally the commission wilk for the remainder of november. we'll meet again on december 6ty hall. 5:30 p.m. in this room, room 40. then we'll be dark for the remaf december and reconvene here on y 10th in this room city hall 400. these will be posted on the web. >> president turman: thank you,y kilshaw. pub comment on items 3-b, a, b,d

did. >> i'm here for a serious situa. excuse me the way i deliver it. i don't mean to be look a poet. i'm not a poet but i show it. i don't like to cuss. this don't seem real in this ate although you guys under federal investigation, but what happeneo oscar out there, what resonatede city. i have to come tough right now. senior citizen joe marshall, wey back. we both got gray hair, i just lk young. henderson, commissioner. and chief. chief scott. i'm going to tell you some thin- maybe not. i'm going to show you some thins they're not going to show you. i'm going to tell you the histot

comes out of me. the western edition, you have t. i didn't know you changed your . normally you had the public spe. you're going to make us wait. and then so many things i want , how can i say it in three minut? i heard i was on 60 minutes. they gave me more seconds than l give me. chief, you're doing a great job. we're so good, you go past this administration and move over tot phase. and you're doing a good job, buu have to come to the bern editio. you march around around change,d see what we do. i'm going to tell what you they. the western edition. fillmore, we call it the feel n. i've been on the case for a lon.

they want to hear what i've goty loud and clear in their ear. we're the most prejudiced city e bay. you have to hear what i have go. i'm saying here in the police dt that our community has left, oue class and blacks left before yot on. years ago under the newsom administration, you only have ae seconds. you all have the luxury to say . washington, i dare you. chief, we have to talk about soe things. yoap what captain is doing walkg around. i try to go over there. i almost had a heart attack ando call ambulance to come and get . all the brothers were out there gambling. i'm going to s show you somethi. i have tear.

women call me and say what the s going on? >> president turman: thank you,. washington. >> you ain't never told them ye. >> thank you mr. washington. next. public speaker on items 2-a, b,. >> good evening commissioners. this is with regard to the officer-involved shooting repor. in the summer of 2016, the grany issued a report into the open opportunities exist for greater transparency in officer-involved shootings. one of the recommendations is te investigations occur contempora. s that recommendation of the gry

been implemented? that we'd have the administratid criminal all occurring contempoy to shorten up this process? because they documented it was n average of three years for -- fe time of the officer-involved shg until the charges decision thene administrative piece began. they just said it's way too lond it's delegitimatizing the depar. the second is the grand jury red that a civilian participate in e investigations. has that civilian been identifi? are they actively participatinge investigation? my third question have any s fpb officers involved in the shootin disciplined by this body? in los angeles you have a procet is transparent. you disclose the maximum amountf

information possible to the pubt the discipline process and i wit we would implement a duplicate y here in san francisco. this report is extremely confus. those of us who follow it closen quiend of figure it out becausew the dates of the officer-involvd shootings. if you want legitimacy of this department, we nee need to knowe call 9-1-1, is the guy who kill, the guy who killed milkar, are y showing up? we have no idea. this delegitimatizes the depart. i believe that the united states department of justice recommendt it not only be s fpd on -- sfpbe firearm's review board that thes civilian participation on the decision-making process as well.

has that recommendation been implemented? thank you. >> president turman: any other c comment on items t-1 a, b, c an? >> i'm paula brown. and i just want to state, i sawe website on twitter about the inn i just caught hold of before i n here. and i thank you for that. it's a start. i just want to7s say that with, please keep it out there. because i've been promised a lof times that people were going toy son -- even though they put hiss on the bus, it didn't last longh and the only lasted for a couplf weeks, then i had to wait anothw years to get something else donr

keep coming here to say what i y week. this will is a start. and i'm glad of it. but when you rotate those pictu, please keep my son's picture th. i know i've been coming here fo. and i'm not knocking out anybods child. but keep my son's picture in tht because i'm going to continue te here even though this media andr and facebook thing is coming upm still going to continue to comed bring awareness to my son's casd other people's cases too. but again, i just want to than r that. i can't wait to get home to shoy daughter what is happening so sn

see her brother's face is stillt there and give her some peace tt someone is finally doing someth. and also, i still think that itd be out, you know, at the bus ba. the department of motor vehiclee people can physically see it bet everyone goes on facebook excepr young people. i'm pretty sure the perpetratort going on facebook or twitter. but i know if they walk into tho get their license or to the libo buy a book or watch to catch a d the pictures are there, they'reo see it. i just want to thank you anyway. thank you.ç >> president turman: any other c comment on items 2-a, b, c and ?

seeing none, public comment is w closed. >> secretary: item and possiblen to recommend that the board of supervisors authorize the chieff police to accept and expend a gr $165,000 for the department of d security federal emergency agen. for the safe boat refurbishment. >> the department has a presentn this issue? >> hi. good evening. president turman and commission, chief scott, director hendersonr i'm patrick dejong from the pole department. we're requesting the commissions recommendation that the board of supervisors adopt a resolution authorizing chief of police to t

and expend a grant from the fedl emergency management agency in e amount of $165,000. the funds will be used to refurd overhaul our safe boat patrol v. the vessel has been in service r 14 years. the industry standard for servie expectancy is approximately 10 r similar vessels. this refurbishment and overhaull allow to us continue using our t vessel for an additional 10 to . the refurbish will allow us to r vessel as a regional asset and f as mutual aid. it's the only vessel in our flet can be towed through a land-basd

trailer and deployed to our othr regional partners. the boat includes 3-d subsurfacr we equipment and radiation deten equipment. i'm here to answer any questiont you may have. >> president turman: commissiony questions for mr. dejong? commissioner hirsch. >> does the grant of $165,000 ce refurbishment you want to do? >> yes it does. i also wanted to add, the totals $220,000. federal amount is $165,000. there is a 25% match in the amof $55,000. that 25% match is based on the l award amount. >> president turman: when you s,

match, where do they come from? >> the matching funds come fromf the department's special agency. it's our asset for if forfei. >> all right. any more ca questions? this is an action item, ladies d gentlemen. >> i move adoption. >> second. >> president turman: public comn item four. seeing nop, public commen -- se, public comment is now closed. we have before us a motion to me adoption on that we recommend te board of supervisors adopt the resolution authorizing our chieo accept and expend a grant in tht

of $165,000 from the departmentf homeland security. all those in favor. any opposed? thank you. motion carries unanimously. thanthank you. >> secretary: item five, the pus thousand able to address the con within the subject matter jurisn of the commission. speakers shall address the remao the whole but not to any indivil commissioners. under rules of order during pubc comment, nearly police nor dpa l are allowed to respond to questo the he public but may provide af response. they should refrain from enterih any debate withç speakers duric comment. please limit your comment to the minutes. >> president turman: public com.

>> good evening, commissioners. i would like to speak about ther vote. you have reset the clock on trut between this department and the community to december 2nd, 2015. that was the night that sfpd sud mario woods like an execution sd killed him in front of hundredsf eyewitnesses including a bus fuf school children. as a community organizer, i havt my career inspiring people to participate in the political prd to come forward and express ther opinion. often they don't want to. because they say it doesn't mat. it doesn't have any impact. the decision has already been m.

why should i turn out? the fact that your own process d that 85% of the people who partd in the public input process incg 100 percent of the people who participated in the public impat process at sunnydale were opposo tasers. the night of the decision, we hd hundreds of people here. there were maybe five pro tasere here. hundreds of people came out to e their opinion that they want san francisco to remain taser-free. you've now taken any trust thate established. i participate on the bias work . there is many of us in the actit community who participate inç - in the various work groups. we're trying to collaborate wit. we're trying to make things bet. and you've just reset it all thy

back to december 2nd, 2015. the disdain is palatable, i aske you to reconsider this decisiono consider all of the input that d from the people most impacted. it doesn't matter what the busis community andç the -- and thoss have to say. of course they want tasers. they don't want undesires aroun. who are the people that are goit tased? their opinion matters. it's a violent tool of torture g to the united nations. it has no place in san francisc. i urge you to reconsider your d. >> president turman: next membee public, please. >> good evening, commissioners.

friday was a rough one. sadly, we continue to make decin what you could call party lines. mayor appointments, board of supervisors' appointments. i thank you for saying that this an investigation. i brought something in front ofe sunshine task force before and . city attorney recommended againd said i had no grounds for what s doing. so i think that we'll be workiny way we can to bring this up agao have a legitimate vote.ç mr. bray should have never been considered an expert. he was a salesman for a company. that was completely i will jit. complete -- completely illegitimate. our expert had not read and ourt

expert was not in the room in sn francisco was deflating to say e least. again, i want to thank -- excus? >> i paused your time. >> may i go ahead? >> president turman: if you wan. >> of course i want to. i appreciate the commissioners t they said in a heart-felt way te people most affected by this are ones that needed to beç consid. it was absurd theq way it was pd through all the meetings happenh no intention to toolly have an d by the people that we're puttins dog and pony show on to push ta. the least important thing, the t offensive thing to the public wy tragic. that one woman who will has -- ,

two minutes being used as a quan a meeting. what if you didn't have the clo? how would you graciously run a ? this woman had a 13-day hunger e and walked all the way to sacrat 67 years old. we went a few minutes over and e people into a tailspin. one man had 10 minutes and a hil student used 30 seconds. this clock as a tool against the is not effective and really kinf lazy. because i really think there woe more graciousness at these mome. this will come up as a vote aga. this is not done. to lock our own people outside e building, right there, that's i. there were many other things lie didn't know where you were. nobody told us where you went. we had to find out ourselves whu guys went.

and then it was arbitrary. you let five people in at a timd some people stayed because theye guts to and some couldn't. this is the not done. don't think it is. the mayor is not going it get hn this one, the people will. thank you.ç >> good evening, i'm back again. i'd like to use the overhead. again, i just bring this becaust the sfgov television to see thi. the people to know that my son s murdered to a semiautomatic gon0 rounds of bullets to my son. there isç still no closure. still no people coming forth tot happened to my child. i've been getting calls from --e

names i bring up here paris mofd thomas hannibal and the other pe there and the person my son die. i got a call from his attorney . then i got a call from the other attorney from another boy named. saying your son was a good boy. could we have his school record] can get this other young man ofa case. i went to talk to the boy's fatd he said he didn't want to have g to do with his son. so if he doesn't want to have ag to do with his son, why should y son to get his son out of jail? the other attorney for -- i fors name, the one that my son -- hed me today. he wants to meet with me and i y

son has been gone for 11 years . what is this about? i don't mind talking to them. but i'm not sure. i need my investigator for my se to say something about this. they should be saying about thi. why are not the perpetrators but attorneys and things are callin? when my own attorney -- my own investigator should be on this . i'm going it it call them and ss is happening. it's been 11 years. i'm not here to help someone els they help me. again, i want peopleç to see we to deal with every day. every year. every minute. every hour.

every waking moment. even though i have children lef. but he was my only son. and i know you guys say she come every year and every week. when is see going to stop? i'm not! i can't! i won't! i need help. we talk about mental health. this takes a toll on someone. believe me, i'm a strong woman. but i need help. thank you. >> president turman: any other c comment? seeing none, public comment is w closed. >> secretary: item 6, public con all matters pertaining to item d

session including vote on whetho hold item 8 in closed session. >> president turman: ladies and gentlemen and members of the pue police commission is now about o into closed session to consider personnel matters and some litin matters. we will take public comment nowe fact that we're going into closd session as well as holding a voo into closed session. any public comment? seeing none, public comment is w closed. >> secretary: vote on whether tl in closed sessionç including attorney/client prech 67.10 act. >> move to go into closed sessi. >> second. >> president turman: and could e consider items under theç attot privilege? >> yes.

>> president turman: all those . any opposed? thank you. ladies and gentlemen the police commission is now in closed ses. >> secretary kilshaw: you are s. back on the record in open session and you still have a quorum. >> president turman: thank you. what is the next line item. >> secretary kilshaw: vote whether to disclose all or any discussion on item held in closed session. >> president turman: appropriate motion? >> nondisclosure. >> president turman: all in favor? >> aye. >> president turman: any opposed? thank you. all in favor. all right. we are now adjourned. thank you ladies and gentlemen

and fellow commissioners. [meeting adjourned]..

>> neighborhood in san francisco are also diverse and fascist as the people that inhabitable them we're in north beach about supervisor peskin will give us a tour and introduce is to what

think of i i his favorite district 5 e 3 is in the northwest surrounded by the san francisco bay the district is the boosting chinatown oar embarcadero financial district fisherman's wharf exhibit no. north beach telegraph hill and part of union square. >> all of san francisco districts are remarkable i'm honored and delighted to represent really whereas with an the most intact district got chinatown, north beach fisherman's wharf russian hill and knob hill and the northwest waterfront some of the most wealthier and inning e impoverished people in san francisco obgyn siding it is

ethically exists a bunch of tight-knit neighborhoods people know he each other by name a wonderful placed physically and socially to be all of the neighborhoods north beach and chinatown the i try to be out in the community as much as and i think, being a the cafe eating at the neighborhood lunch place people come up and talk to you, you never have time alone but really it is fun hi, i'm one the owners and is ceo of cafe trespassing in north beach many people refer to cafe trees as a the living room of north beach most of the clients are local and living up the hill come and meet with each other just the way the united states been since 1956 opposed by the

grandfather a big people person people had people coming since the day we opened. >> it is of is first place on the west that that exposito 6 years ago but anyone was doing that starbuck's exists and it created a really welcoming pot. it is truly a legacy business but more importantly it really at the take care of their community my father from it was formally italy a fisherman and that town very rich in culture and music was a big part of it guitars and sank and combart in the evening that tradition they brought this to the cafe so many characters around here everything has incredible stories by famous folks last week the cafe that paul carr tennessee take care

from the jefferson starship hung out the cafe are the famous poet lawrence william getty and jack herb man go hung out. >> they work worked at a play with the god fathers and photos he had his typewriter i wish i were here back there it there's a lot of moving parts the meeting spot rich in culture and artists and musicians epic people would talk with you and you'd get