sho shooting. awent to the hospital and officer endo seems to be doing fine. it was traumatic for the officers at the hospital and all those involved. i want to thank the members of the police department there to support the officer, his father and mother i will, and all though at the hospital including the command staff and the chief. what do we do? we talk about things in the abstract here. in the hospital after one of the officers has been shot in a shootout, and it's pretty dramatic. it has an impact on you. so i want to thank those officers and the men and women of the department and so proud of them that evening. and then last but not at least, i want to bring everybody's attention that, you know, if you want to see why we have an issue in our system, why the system is broken, you need to log onto captain carl fabry's police department at the tenderloin police station. and they list some incredible things. and i just have to note for people that when you look and you see that people are being

arrested the same location, multiple times, and in violation to stay away orders and released from custody by the judges. the cases are being charged by the d.a.'s offices, and large quantities of heroin, crack cocaine, and methamphetamine, more than the quantities we used to see as prosecutors, mr. henderson and i, and i mean, federal quantities. yet, they still get the stay away order and are back out on the same corner days later and being arrested. if you want to see why the system is broken, but the hard work of the officers, go to the tenderloin police station twitter account. they handle it professionally and it is well done. it is very frustrating for us who are trying to have the delicate balance of making this the safest city. commissioners? any announcements? okay. public comment on line items three -- >> commission announcements. i'm sorry. i apologize. >> line 3d. >> commission announcements and scheduling of items identified

for consideration at future commission meetings. >> >> action. >> i think we have the same thing in mind. we would like to add a discussion with the city attorney regarding legal matters rarting the particular -- regarding a particular memo that we received. >> for the record, commissioner de jesus and commissioner molara agreeing to the same thing. >> and not just for discussion, but to put the item back on the agenda. item djo5.02. >> what is our availability look like that when we'll have most commissioners available? >> if i can jump in, i think we need to have somebody from d.h.r. here as well. somebody who is negotiating 5.0. >> but we can have -- we can't have it in open session. there are two things. one is to bring back, to put

back on the agenda a vote for dgo5.02. as was originally put on the agenda, but we did not accept it as such. and the second piece it sound to me like commissioner hirsch wants to have some clarification from the city attorney to the meet and confer process. >> well, it has to be around a d.g.o.. it can't be a general discussion about legal advice. it is focused on d.g.o. >> if i may interject, deputy city attorney, is we put this on for closed session and advice of counsel from the city attorney's office and if necessary, move to the next step. >> justice as a reminder for items to be in closed session, there has to be a specific authorization by the public meetings act. and so for those, it is just as

a reminder, it is real estate negotiations, there isn't one in general for attorney-client privilege legal advice. it has to fit into something specific. if you are talking about a specific d.g.o. and the idea is to give direction to your negotiator, then you can have a closed session about that in particular. i feel a little off and not entirely sure what the commissioner -- i heard you want to have a discussion about city attorney advice. and i am kind of confused to exactly what it is. >> well, based on the letter, it sound like we have the choice -- several choices, but the one primarily is to put it back on the agenda, to vote again on it, and with the language that was required and we wanted to have a specific questions about the meet and confer process and negotiations. we can have that in a closed

session. >> specifically for to put the item d.g.o.5.02, i can work with commission staff to put that back on to the agenda. to have that give direction to your d.h.r. representative who are engaging in the meeting and confer process, in closed session to address specifically your questions and. and that would have to be done in open session. >> i think the commission has voiced our two needs. and you have explained to us the two vehicle of getting there. we don't need to put it on the agenda tonight with a set date. we could do that through the commission president and vice president today, tomorrow, or another day. i think we need to get that on calendar as soon as reasonably possible. great. any other announcements, commissioners? >> i will be out of town next week. won't be here on the 11th. >> let's coordinate our schedules for that. >> the third meeting of the

month. >> okay. >> can i add for 3d, for the general public, the next meeting for the police commission will be held on wednesday, april 11, here at city hall, room 400 at 5:30 p.m. >> great. now time for public comment with reference to line items 3a, b, c, or d. any public comment with reference to these three line items? hearing none, public comment is now closed. please call the next item. >> line four, discussion and possible action to i a prove the sale of patrol special beat 47 from antoinette candido and beat 3 to patrol special officer alan byard and take other action. >> for the record, i am recused from this matter and turn the gavel over to former president dr. joseph marshall to handle this matter. i'll step out of the room. >> back in the saddle. >> i'm prepared. >> okay.

>> i have line item 4 been called yet? did he call it yet? yes. okay. involves the sale of -- let me just read this. the three beats. okay. so proceed. >> good evening, commissioners. commissioner scott. before we start, there are two beats that were put together and i would like to have them separated so we're going to vote on each one separately. >> that is fine. >> if we could start with beat 47. and the northern district and the wife of a former patrol special who has since passed away in 2013 wishes to sell the beat. >> speak into the mic. >> we can barely hear you. >> a wishes to spell the beat to special patrol byard and the

paper work was submitted to you. in there is any questions? >> looks of kay to me. -- looks of kay to me. >> i have looks okay to me. i have no questions. >> i'm not familiar with the process. this is the first time i have heard that a beat can be sold. >> we will have to have two separate motions. >> no, yoi don't have any questions at this point. >> okay. just a brief overline. the city is broken up into particular beats that were purchased by patrol specials and they retain ownership of the beat until it is sold. they may or may not be part of the program. if they are not part of the program, they may not work the beat. so this particular beat, i have a map i can put up if you would like -- give you an idea. that particular beat hadn't been worked for some time, so patrol

special byard went to is in the northern district. currently patrol special byard owns beat 96. so the beat adjoins that beat and he would have access to that beat. he doesn't have to travel across the city to make sthur his -- to make sure his clients are afforded quick service from him. >> all right. i am seeing the sale price is $100 is what i am seeing. >> correct. >> just so the public knows. this is not a big money deal. >> and it all depend. this one is for $100. >> okay. >> i think you said the owner is deceased? >> the owner is deceased. so it would have gone to his wife, and as parts of probate and i have spoke within her on the phone and she is elderly and

didn't attend this evening, but i spoke to her and he wishes -- and the sale price is low because when patrol special byard came in in 1977, he worked for her husband, and they had a good relationship, and that is why the price is kind of low. that was when i spoke with her, that was why it was so low. >> so just reading this was on calendar earlier and things to be taken care of in the meantime, and all those things have been dealt with? >> yes, they have. >> all right. so are we moving to approve the sale here tonight? >> correct. >> i need a motion. >> move to approve the sale. >> i second. >> all in favor? >> aye. it's yours. thank you. >> and then the next beat is also in the northern district. >> do you want to read -- did we solve that item yet? >> they are under two separate items. >> there we go. >> is beat 83.

and it is -- >> got it. >> and this beat, the beat owner is a former patrol special delores lovett-menge and the sale price is $20,000 for this beat. and he's completed all the paper work as with the last beat. i assume they were not friend. that is why it is so high. >> i'm sorry? >> i guess they were not friends. >> this is more of a regular price. and on the last beat to give you an idea, it sold for $100,000. >> wow. >> any discussion? i move to approve this item. >> i second that. >> all in favor? >> aye. >> sale is approved. >> thank you. >> thank you.

congratulations. does we come back for item five or is he also out for this item? >> i think he was only out for item four. >> we'll git him back. wherever he is. the discussion and possible action and with the disciplinary and case al-wiad and 20-130 # an

or take other action in necessary action. >> thank you. city council city council lar, please counselar, please state your appearance. >> good evening, officer karla brown. >> commissioner, this is a disciplinary matter assigned to me. we had a meeting and reached a tentative resolution patrol spesh officers don't have the same rights as peace officers and the disciplinary matters an dispositions are held publicly in front of the police commission.

we are the regulating body. at this point, i will ask the prosecuting agency to give us a breakdown of the disposition and where we stand. >> thank you, commissioner. and thank you for your assistance with these cases. we have finally come to the conclusion of the majority of these, so i appreciate your help. officer calhoun wiley in case aw awa aw2013-0305. one was for a violation of working in beat 55 which is actually owned by his daughter and not owned by him. he had owned it in years prior, but it had been transferred to her and not transferred back. in the second specification, he was charged with failure to provide an accurate client list when requested to do so by the

san francisco police department. officer carla brown supervises the cases and making sure the rules are being followen followe are met on a few occasions to discuss the stipulated edition disposition proposal all the par the is are in agreement that the patrol special officer would admit the allegations and specifications one and two as part to have stipulated agreement, revocation of his appointment would be held in advance for a term of three years. and in addition to that, he is going to be ordered by the commission to abide by all of the rules and regulations for patrol special officers and assistants and including specifically adhering to any verbal, written, email, telephonic messages sent by officer brown or any other sworn uniform member of the san

francisco police department as it relates to his duties a z a patrol special officer. in addition to that, he has agreed to pay a fine of $250 on specification one and $250 on specification two and that donation will be made to the bride memorial church which is here in san francisco of which many are familiar with. and i believe that all parties are in agreement with this stipulated agreement. i have the signed, executed agreement from officer -- patrol special officer wiley, and if you have any questions. >> thank you. mr. bonner? >> yes. i believe the attorney has accurately stated our agreement and we have signed the agreement. >> members of the commission, during the meeting i explained to officer wiley that he does have to respond when officer

brown contacts him regarding the issues. and how many years have you served this city as patrol special officer? >> tell the commission how many. come up to the mic. >> how many years, sir? >> over year. use the mic, sir. >> talk into the mic right there. >> i have 46 years on the street. >> 46 years. >> and patrol special wiley is loved in the bayview and managed the beat out there for many years. we reached this agreement to give him another chance and so long as he goes along with what officer brown and her sergeant who is in the back of the room, i think this is a fair disposition. we chose to dedonation to go to glide. we can't suspend him for a period of time, so there is a lot of work and compliance and i suggest that you would agree to accept this disposition. >> my only question, is we have

had issued with patrols specials adhering to the rules, so everything is in order now. and you are confident that -- >> i am confident because we have officer brown on top of this. everything is in order. guarantee it. >> commissioner, any other further questions? >> madam city attorney. >> before any vote on this item, you need to open it for public comment and i am apologize, but i failed to note that before the last vote. we would need to redo that vote on approving the sales of those specials. >> is there any public comment regarding this disposition with patrol special calvin wiley? hearing none, public comment is closed. >> do i have a motion? >> so moved. >> second. >> thank you, patrol special

wiley. and the copy of the signed document is being presented to police commission secretary killshaw for the san francisco police department. i think i am going to return to the back of the ante room, and dr. marshall again to deal with the issue on public comment regarding the last line item. >> as we call it again? >> where is it? >> item d. item four actually. >> so madam city attorney, if i can ask you -- >> we just need to take public

comment for the motion to sell the beat before and then we'll take the vote again. >> was there any public comment on item number four? hearing none, the motion passes. >> we have to take the vote again. >> so for the first sale, for the first -- what number was the first beat again? >> 93, right? >> >> i was taking public comment on both items at the same time, but we have to separate them. >> public comment on the sale of beat 47, we'll take that separately? any public comment on that? hearing none. it is approved. any public comment on the sale of beat 83? hearing none. >> we have to take the vote again. >> and i need you to retake the vote on each sale. >> okay.

do we have to take the motion again also? >> correct. >> i move to approve the sale on 47. >> second. >> all in favor? aye. and 83. >> i move to approve the sale on 83. >> second. >> all in favor? aye. it is official. correct. thank you. >> item 6, general public comment. the public is welcome to address the commission regarding items that do not appear on the agenda but are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the commission. speakers shall address the

remarks to the commission as a whole and not to individual commissioners or department or d.p.a. personnel,. under police commission rules of order, neither police nor d.p.a. personnel, nor commissioner are required to respond to questions presented by the public, but may provide a brief response. individual commissioners and police and d.p.a. personnel should refrain, however, from entering into any debates or discussion with speakers during public comment. >> thank you very much. general public comment. welcome back. >> thank you for letting me speak. i came to talk about the taser issue specifically. i know there's been several meetings already. and i have come because i believe we still have an opportunity to move the pendulum in our society from that of collective fear to that of

collective bravery. i think one of the ways to do this, although it may only be a drop in the bucket is to spend money where it matters. i don't believe putting more money into weapons is going to help us achieve that goal. i think we need to spend our money on de-escalation, on conflict resolution, on many other things but not on more weapons. i feel that the name of the taser ballot measure which is, i believe, the safer policing initiative, is a lie. i don't see how carrying more weapons makes anyone safer. i don't think it's too late to reverse the ed situation.

and we're all here. the only thing holding us up is ourselves. i don't think it's too late to reers is the decision and i think it should be left off the ballot. i think whatever you can do as a commission to keep this measure off the ballot would be greatly appreciated and in the best interest of our community. thank you. >> thank you very much. >> thank you. >> next speaker, please. >> good evening, commissioners. i am a legislative aide to supervisor cohen here on behalf of the office of supervisor cohen. there is a very important item that i will be discussing today and i look forward to relaying that information back to the supervisor and the board of supervisors and supervisor cohen. >> thank you so much. thank you for coming. >> miss brown? good evening, miss brown.

. >> and i am here -- good evening, everyone. i am a little tired today. but i am here to talk about my son who was murdered august 14, 2006. his birthday is in a couple of days. april 6, and i'm not feeling all that great, you know, because, again, here is another birthday coming up and nothing has been done about my son's case. my son existed. i have his demr diploma from st dominick's catholic school and dominick's catholic school and graduated. i have no qualms of being the that, yes, i was, with him. i still say that before when i

come and talk and say that they know who murdered my son. i bring these names all the time. thomas hannibal, paris mof fit, jason thomas, afney carter, and marcus caal,r -- and ma, ty te are the names of the people that were there that murdered my son on that daythat 3:00. ty te are in my son's case folder. you say they know who killed my son. we have nowhere to put these homicide posters. i keep asking for a venue every year, every month, for thiol as i won't have to climb up on a pole and darn near break my neck to keep pe caae from tearing thm down. i am just asking that if anybody is watching this out there and sfgovon a levision and know

anybody that murdered my son, please help give me some closure. and i am as nowg for support frm the supervisors here. thank you. >> thank you, miss brown. iifow the number in front of -- i don't have the number in front of me, buturess brown co3 k offen a weekly basis to talk about the murder of her son aubrey arkansas and we are loo nowg for theor smber for th police type line and for those in the community that have the courage and conviction to come forward to identify the suspects, that would be greatly appreciated. she is an incredible mom and comes with her grand daughter this evening and co3 k here every wedon't to talk about the death of her son. it's incredible. the police tipher ne is area coe 415-575-44 of he. please do not hesitate to call. you see a mo-44 of he. please do not hesitate to call. you see a mom who is in anguish and wh41s not going tonowveear and will be here every week. we want her here every wedon't , afil this calk is solved. there is no statute of limitation for murder.

next public speaker. >> he png none, public comment is now closed. next line item. >>her ne 7, public comment on al matters pertaining to 9 below closed session including public comment on vote whether to hold itemhere i inek.osed lsion. >> ladies and gentlemen, in the public here, we are about to head intoek.noned session mattes to deal with matters that are protected under the california conpptution and through california supreme court case law. and so we have to go intoek.nond lsion. it cannot be disclosed. any public comment regarding our lk iatters intoek.noned lsion? he ping none, public comment is now closed. >> line eight, vote on whakerer to holdher ne itemhere i inek.n session and including vote on whether to assert attoon'ey-client privilege with iteard to items 9d, e, and g, san francisco administrative code section 67.1

pe >> do i have a ther ion? >> i move to go >> sergeant, would you please call line item number ten. >> commissioner, we're back in open session and we still have a quorum chl line ten, vote to disclose any or all discussion held in closed session, san francisco administrative code section 6712(a) action. >> i move not to disclose. >> second. >> president turman: all in favor? thank you. please call item number 11. >> line number 11, adjournment,

action item. >> move to adjourn. >> second. >> president turman: thank you. the meeting is adjourned.

sfgovtv.org. >> neighborhoods and san francisco as exists and fascist as the people that i think inhabitable habit them the bay area continues to change for the better as new start up businesses with local restaurants and nonprofit as the collaborative spaces the community appeal is growing too. >> what anchors me to the community i serve is a terminal connection

this is the main artery of the southeast neighborhood that goes around visitacion valley and straight down past the ball park and into the south of market this corridor the hub of all activity happening in san francisco. >> i'm barbara garcia of the wines in the bayview before opening the speculation we were part of bayview and doing the opera house every thursday i met local people putting their wares out into the community barbara is an work of a symbol how the neighborhood it changing in a a positive way literally homemade wine that is sold in the community and organized businesses both old and new

businesses coming together to revitalizes this is a yoga studio i actually think be able a part of community going on in the bayview i wanted to have a business on third street and to be actually doing that with the support of community. >> how everybody reasons together to move each other forward a wonderful run for everybody out here. >> they're hiring locally and selling locally. >> it feels like a community effort. >> i was i think the weather is beautiful that is what we can capture the real vibe of san francisco i love it i can go ongoing and on and on about the life in the.

>> shop and dine the 49 promotes loophole businesses and changes residents to do thirds shopping and diane within the 49 square miles of san francisco by supporting local services we help san francisco remain unique and successful where will you shop and dine shop and dine the 49. >> my name is neil the general manager for the book shop here on west portal avenue if san francisco this is a neighborhood bookstore and it is a wonderful neighborhood but it is an interesting community because the residents the neighborhood muni loves the neighborhood it is community and we as a book sincerely we see the same people here the

shop all the time and you know to a certain degree this is part of their this is created the neighborhood a place where people come and subcontract it is in recent years we see a drop off of a lot of bookstores both national chains and neighborhoods by the neighborhood stores where coming you don't want to - one of the great things of san francisco it is neighborhood neighborhood have dentist corrosive are coffeehouses but 2, 3, 4 coffeehouses in month neighborhoods that are on their own- that's

>> good morning, ladies and gentlemen. i'd like to call this meeting to order. >> all right. thank you, sfgovtv, and ladies and gentlemen, want to welcome you back to another exciting meeting of the budget and finance sub committee. my name is malia cohen. i'm the chairman of this committee, and to my right is supervisor sandy fewer. joining us shortly in this meeting will be supervisor safai. i want to thank jessie and michael for assisting us with today's broadcast. our clerk, of course is the lo