Skip to main content

tv   Government Access Programming  SFGTV  May 20, 2019 10:00pm-11:01pm PDT

10:00 pm
fear our son will deal with these issues as he grows older. in addition to that, i want to say that mental health issues in our children are very real. my son, after experiencing a traumatic life event, was diagnosed with adjustment disorder. he woke up in the nights for months screaming, waking up from nightmares. the healing process was a long road. he has finally been able to heal and gain a sense of belonging, but i want to say that we need some investments in our school, invest in racially, culturally inclusive schools that are supportive and address mental health needs of children and families to give our students and families a chance to succeed. thank you. [cheers and applause]
10:01 pm
>> i'm emily and a union mojo leader and a senior at george washington high school. i'm here today because i deeply support our healing and hands campaign. i've seen too many friends struggle with mental health and struggle with reaching out for support because of the harmful stigma. my friends come to me about stress school, stress from family and other personal struggles. personally, i was struggling with my own mental health in the spring semester of any junior year and wanted to get help but every time i was in front of the wellness center, i kept making excuses and telling myself i would come back the next day. it was not until i found out a friend of mine received therapy at school that i got the courage to help myself. put so i made my appointment along with other followup appointments to go over the
10:02 pm
paperwork, receive parental consent and finally after a month, i started to see a therapist. put and whilwhile i was able toe help, i know there are other barriers to accesses mental health resources. that is why i support this so we can all help build a healthy school environment where we can nurture each other and also ourselves, a recommendation that i would like to highlight in this is peer-to-peer counseling. i believe in this recommendation because this will prove how youth had the leadership skills to create support and healing spaces. it is a chance for us to prove that we are worth more than our test scores, that we care about one another and enough to build a stronger community. now is the moment for us to join forces with other students,
10:03 pm
teachers, parents and all supporters in this room. the board of education commission education and superintendent vincent matthews, please stand with students of colour and others to work by these recommendation and show your public support by tweeting #ourhealinginourhands. thank you. [cheers and applause] >> my name is maritza gomez and i'm a parent of a second-grader. my son has mental health needs and just by experience from kindergarten until now, i know that the schools don't have that support that he needs. from being at the school supporting him all the time, i know that there are -- the schools need more wellness centres and they need time away from class where someone will understand what they need to
10:04 pm
help support them, someone they can trust, who they know. they won't get in trouble or get suspended. for things that they can't control. thank you. >> hello. i'm a mother of three boys and growing up in a unified school district, i was one of those kids that actually needed a wellness center and when i was growing up, it wasn't there. sometimes you need somebody to speak with you for five minutes and growing up and being a part of my kid's education, i see how important it is for wellness centers to be there for children that have mental health issues, that have behavioral issues, suspensions are very high and i stan here as stand here asking g
10:05 pm
that this bill does pass. it's very, very important for children to get that five minutes, that two minutes, that minute they need to speak. suicide is an epidemic out there and hopefully you can understand it's very important for the children to have somebody to hear them out and not blame them for what they don't know is wrong. thank you. [cheers and applause] (speaking foreign language).
10:06 pm
>> so hi, everyone. my name is angela, i have two children, both of whom have gone through the district and i have been very active in school affairs at the schools that my kids have gone through. i'm very happy to see everyone and am representing the workers at cpa today.
10:07 pm
(speaking foreign language).
10:08 pm
>> i really thing the young people who have put the proposal on the table today are brave to share with all of us what is in their hearts. i really want to also applaud the wellness centers for doing their best with the limited means that they do have right now. i actually have a daughter who has faced mental pressures from
10:09 pm
and through deep listening and also encouragement, we have walked out of there together. but what i learn there was that when someone has mental pressures, the most important thing is for someone to hear them out and so, we know that their peers are the closest allies that they have. so that's why at my proposal here, specific about the peer coaching programme, i really think this will help studentses to sharstudents toshare freely . students face a myriad of pressures, both from society and family and really hope the district can prioritize this issue so that young children can give out their lives and confidence. thank you. >> i'm from iraq, the arab and
10:10 pm
resourcing center and part of the al youth group and we're here in solidarity with cpa. i'm a sophomore at the high school and right now we experience high levels of bullying and islamaphobia. as an arab muslim woman, i see this and i experience this every since preschool. my friends have experienced this, too. this year, i did use our wellness resources, but for the longest time, i didn't know these existed. i personally have seen the benefits of having wellness staff and anything that strengthens this can support all our communities. i'm someone who tends to not stick with things but i get excited to be a part of this and i wouldn't have been a part of this youth programme without the wellness center at our school. we ask you today to vote in the favorite of strengthening our wellness services. thank you.
10:11 pm
[cheers and applause] >> i feel like for many minorities, there's an automatic level of trust that comes when you talk with someone similar to you. this level of trust can help students be less hostile and more open. this will help councillors for the students' mental an emotional state and find the next steps to help the student. it is alsos remember to convey messages or events that cannot be easily translated into english. there are conversations or events in my life and in the lives of other minorities that would be hard to translate into english while still holding the same tone, mood or gravity.
10:12 pm
it suggests simply to say it in the native language. additionally, there are different societal norms, rules and traditions that only people of the same culture can fully understandings. that is why i believe that our students will have better mental an emotional space if they can talk to a councillor and peers they can relate with and that is why we are here, to support the resolution to fight for cultural support and resource for our communities, specifically for the asian pacific communities and other expects of colour. thank you. >> hello board of education, students, i'm the director of the san francisco youth commission. i'm here on behalf of our 17 youth commissioners who are appointed by the board of supervisors and the mayor to
10:13 pm
advice them on the unmet needs of people in san francisco. aon march 19, 2018, they presented to the youth commission and the commission voted to support our healing and our hands campaign. they want to enact implementationestimplementationt youth commissions. as someone in bureaucracy, it's not only about the resolution by implementation of it and we are excited to see that action move forward. thank you. thank you all for coming out. just stick around and you'll know the next step. this is section j.
10:14 pm
for first reading, our policy 3260, fees and charges, 3515.4, recovery for property loss and damage, 6.190, and 9.192, athletic competition and 430 employment and we just heard the last one about our healing and hand. may i hear a motion and second to the board policies? i'm referring the policies to the rule's committee, the resolution we were hearing public comment about will be budget and crim lu curriculum m. so that's where it will go and take a little while to get
10:15 pm
through the whole process but thank you again. you may want to take this opportunity to leave because there will be more boring stuff coming up and i know there's a lot of you here for this. thank you. so public comment on non-agenda items. we have a fair amount. when you hear your names, you'll have two minutes. (names called).
10:16 pm
if you hear your name, please come to the podium. ok, welcome. >> good evening.
10:17 pm
, board, community. i am here as one of many from the community of james lick middle school. [cheers and applause] because our community is concerned. we are concerned about the budget that was allocated to us for next year and what our administration chose to do with that. the middle school received funding as it did in the previous year. unfortunately, with the teacher's salary raise, it means that we have now the funding for three less full-time educators. our administrator without consulting, our ubc decided to take that budget and make those cuts to classroom teaching positions without any consultation without any governing body. the school site council was
10:18 pm
shown without told what it meant, without being told or giving imput about what positions would be cut and did so without a quorum. we as a staff, as a ubc, as a parent community have all said that we not want these cuts to come from the classroom. we are worried because it takes a village to educate our children. it takes a community and we are a community. we are here tonight because james lick, unfortunately, we are tired of that of the er classification and we're tired of coming at the top in suspensions. we want to do more for our students and continually asked do more with less. james lick is here tonight and you will hear from students, from parents and from staff that
10:19 pm
are saying that we need the school board, we need you all as part of our community to help us, one, rescind the budget that was already admitted by the administrator so we as a community can decide on our priorities and look at funding allocations that are designated as pitch schools or high potential schools, thank you. >> before you go on, i'm assuming that was mr. ariba and i foregoat to mens, please note public comment is an opportunity for the board to hear from the community on matters within the board's generation. jurisdiction. if you have a complaint about a district employee, submit to the district supervisor and as a reminder, board cools d rules ds to respond to questions during the comment time and if
10:20 pm
appropriate, they will ask the staff followup with speaks. as members of the board of education, you should be fundraising money for our students and schools. budget cuts are not the way to help our school. the spanish emerging helps many kids. it's not easy being a middle-school teacher. the budget for next year make my teacher's jobs harder. teachers deserve a budget that supports them. students need an education, full class sizes, updated des textbo. the ones we have are old without
10:21 pm
updated information. this budget cut will not make this possible but reduce the that materials. so this is why we're asking within the proposed budget to fully fund or gyms to help educate all our students of all colour and all income. [cheers and applause] >> good evening. i'm an attorney with the california supreme court. like the back of my t-shirt says, i'm also a proud parent of the that particular eighth grader that just spoke. she's more than that, plea played volleyball, soccer, debate team, and she spoke to you tonight and her grandmother and i and the three of us rushed over after playing a girl's got
10:22 pm
goal soccer game run by the after-school programme. when i told her it would be ok to miss this meeting, but mommy, it's important. these extr extraindeed spanish y we are spanish in the first place. we're determined to raise two spanish bilingual, bicultural children in this city. so with all sincerity that a proposed budget cut that forces cuts to spanish emersion, are why parents like me choose spanish education.
10:23 pm
this has taught me many things and it requires skills and qualities that is not easy to come by. i speak from helping in the classroom saying they have many, many great teachers going beyond a call of duty in service of their students. many which are here today. the district is proposing a budget to force the school to make the difficult decision to cut three full-time teaching positions, two of which are in the spanish emersion programme. instead of a budget that requires teachers to shoulder a greater workload of a very diverse student body, we ask the student to re-evaluate the budget and recommit full and financial support and hard work.
10:24 pm
>> good evening. i'm proud to be here with the middle school. one of the best schools in the country. when i was in elementary school, i was in the ssc, the council for two terms and i am the councillor at the middle school. and as all of you know, raising every penny is hard but we don't give up. we're still trying. at the end of this year, last couple of weeks, we found out that we will be losing three teachers, because of this budget allocation. don't think that's a very smart decision. in fact, it's demoralizing.
10:25 pm
after working so hard this year and last year to try to raise additional resources, i know you agree with me that it is demoralizing. i probably know you don't want to do that. do the right thing, rescind the budget, give us an opportunity to resign the allocations in accordance with school priorities and we'll engage stakeholders and community. it's not that hard. so we hope you'll mang the right decision and we know that you have the right way of thinking about this, reinstate our tech funding, et cetera within an, ak we will have a better chance that way, thank you for your time. >> good evening. i'm mark deluki and i wasn't planning on speaking today, but speaking because fo of the yout.
10:26 pm
this has been very hard for parents at james lick. the budget is constantly being cut for us and we constantly have to be fighting for every little thing for our students and it's really, really hard. you know, your vision statement says you'll provide quality instruction and equitable support and that's all we're asking we're fob equity here. help us do our job and if you could help us rescind the budget to get everyone together to really propose a budget to help our students thrive. we need this.
10:27 pm
>> good evening. i'm a sixth grade spa spanish emersion teacher and i taught some of the parents in the audience receiving work. i love my students and community. i'm here for my families who can't be here because they're working their second shift and i'm here for our families in the southeast corner of the city that are underfinished in theirr school is a pitch school, one of 781 schools designated of not meeting needs of our most struggling students and end of measure is based on deficit mindedness and because our students see the beauty in our school. our students come back year after year after they graduate
10:28 pm
to support our emersion programme. they appeal to the board to support our most vulnerable students. mission education center is one of our feeder programmes. our new-comer students receive their support in language development, in sheltered instruction through the spanish emersion programme. we were cut by .6 for for a full-time position and cut .2 and what that means we have to delve into the pockets of our school site funding to replace those or cut them. what our administration chose to do without any consent from the community or consensus building with our staff and parents. we have more parents and more faculty here at this board meeting after our long workday, after their second shifts and we
10:29 pm
have children here, more than were a the pleasant quorum. we are asking you to look at the central funneling for our school. we are a pitch school. we are a school you keep measuring as failing but our kids keep coming back and saying we win. we need your help. [cheers and applause] >> my name is charnell russ and i'm a sixth grade science teacher. i was not able to get my card in on time but as an african-american woman i would like to be heard. >> that's fine, but can you keep it short. >> i got you. so i'm just here with the rest of mickles to talk about the two things we're asking from you. one is to rescind the budget and two, is to fully fund our school. we are cored. my first core, i have 21
10:30 pm
students and my second, 28 studentses. this is a big shift where i have a small amount of time to work with them and going to my 28 students where it's almost chaos because of the amount of opportunitieses i have in that class. we're talking about next year, this shift being 28 students for every class and that is kind of crazy and it's due to the budget and so i am personally asking for the budget to be rescinded and us to be fully funded. thank you so much.
10:31 pm
>> they did not get this information and still do not have this information. in general, the best decisions are made when all of the shareholders -- stakeholders are at the table and it's clear that all of the stakeholders are not at the table. it really is important to revisit this issue, see if something better can be done for this school, this pitch school and make sure that information is shared with the union building committee, which is a contractual right, once again and with the school council. thank you. the next speakers are involving the mrk.
10:32 pm
would the first speaker please approach the podium.
10:33 pm
(speaking foreign language). >> good evening, board members. first, i would like to address a couple of points on the letter that i had received from mpd today. in response to the first point
10:34 pm
in the letter, information on the letter and the survey does not match. survey did not mention the number of chinese classes we provided during the school hours, nor did it become computer-based. the survey included three ons fooptions forparents to choose n the class is offered. therefore the response letter from mpd provided false information and it's a lie. another point to address is that the before-school option was not preferred by most parents. the parent's first option is
10:35 pm
chinese class during school day, previousably sixth period. the information on the letter is inconsistent with the response to parents during the meeting. >> my name is cindy. (speaking foreign language).
10:36 pm
>> good evening, boar members. my name is cindy and i'm here to demand the san francisco school district fulfill a six-year-old promise. i would ask for additional funding to hire chinese bilingual teacher. chinese bilingual programmes to start at mlk and uses the middle school and we're not asking a lot, we're asking for enough funnelinfunding to hire one chie teacher to teach six and seventh
10:37 pm
grade. the cost of one teacher is $100,000. this amount should not be a problem because parents were informed of this expansion six years ago and we believe that the district has had full time to prepare the necessary funds for the endeavor and that you are now prepared to fulfill the promise to the community years ago. theis the district planning to e to us another six years and continue to disappoint students and parents. we want the district to fulfill a long promise and please provide a chinese bilingual teacher for august of 2019 so our children can continue their bilingual education.
10:38 pm
(speaspeaking foreign language). >> good evening, board members. i'm a parent of er taylor and i'm here tonight to demand that san francisco unified school district to fulfill a six-year-old mp promise. i'm not asking for much. i'm asking for $100,000. the schoole school district wile to fulfill a project of
10:39 pm
$100,000. the district will also be able to regain the trust of studentses and parents with $100,000. please provide immediate funding to mlk to hire chinese bilingual teacher for august of 2019 so our children can continue their bilingual education in middle school as promised. perfor pai(speaking foreign language).
10:40 pm
>> good evening. i'm a parent of er taylor and we met on may 8th to discuss start of the bilingual programme this august. at this meeting, they stated this was possible with additional funding from the district to hire one chinese bilingual teacher so we are asking that district to provide immediate funding to mlk to make this possible. please do not use insufficient fund as an excuse. this amount should not be a problem for the district because the parents were informed of
10:41 pm
this expansion six years ago. so we believe that the district has able time to prepare for necessary funds. don't tell me that six years is not enough time to secure funding hired for one teacher.
10:42 pm
(speaking foreign language). (please stand by).
10:43 pm
10:44 pm
>> my name is ivy. during the may 8th meeting, we were informed by a representative from the district that our children can choose chinese as an electsive if they want to learn chinese in middle school. we met the principal immediately after the meeting to confirm that this is an option and is not in conflict with their bell schedule next school year. the principal of mlk is also in agreement with parents to start a chinese bilingual program and propose a follow-up meeting on may 15th regarding our
10:45 pm
request. pleas take immediate action and provide funding to mlk. we will continue to fight or our children, future, and take necessary actions to achieve our goals. >> good evening, everyone. [speaking foreign language] >> my name is lisa. i'm a parent. please fulfill your promise now and provide funding to mlk to start a chinese bilingual
10:46 pm
program in august of 2019. if our demands are not met, we're going to take further action. we will not stop in our demands are met. thank you. >> good afternoon. [speaking foreign language] >> my son is going to mlk after summer. according to the principal, the funding in order to open chinese classes, since they already planned six years ago, i don't see any excuse that they cannot open any time soon. also, i want my son to be like others. other schools are able to provide chinese classes. why mlk cannot provide? that's no excuse.
10:47 pm
also, they cannot find anymore money to mlk to open chinese classes in mlk, we come in here more often. >> good evening, board members. my name is anna. i'm a chinese bilingual student from er taylor elementary school. i've been learning chinese for six years. i want to keep on learning chinese. i'm taking a test to go to a chinese bilingual school and pass. i was very disappointed and sad when i did not get into a chinese bilingual middle school. chinese is important to me because my family speaks chinese. i really hope that the middle school i'm going to can have a chinese class where me and my friends can continue to learn chinese. please start a chinese bilingual
10:48 pm
class at martin luther king middle school in august 2019. thank you. >> good evening, board members. i'm a chinese bilingual student in elementary school. i've worked hard to learn chinese. i don't want to give up because i have come such a long way and worked so hard. i'm a fifth grade student and will be going to middle school in august 2019. i really want to be able to continue to learn chinese because it's very important to me and my family. i want to learn chinese so i can communicate with my family. please start a chinese bilingual program at er taylor martin luther king middle school in 2019. thank you. >> good evening, board members. i'm a chinese bilingual student. i have been learning chinese for many years, and i want to keep learning chinese.
10:49 pm
i have tried hard to make it in a chinese middle school but ended up in a middle school that doesn't teach chinese. i want a chance to attend a school with a chinese bilingual program so i can continue to learn chinese. it's important to me because my parents only speak chinese. please start a chinese bilingual program at martin luther king middle school in august 2019. thank you. >> good evening, board members. my name is ivana. i am a chinese bilingual fifth grade student. i have worked really hard to learn chinese and would like to continue to learn chinese in middle school. i am ready sad that i cannot learn chinese in middle school. help me make my wish come true. please start a change he's bilingual program at martin luther king in august 2019. thank you. >> we've two more speakers on
10:50 pm
different items. sandra and julie. >> evening commissioners, superintendent. so two board resolutions are being discussed and circulated right now that directly impact art education? our district. before we have an opportunity to look at the arts education master plan refresh, come on, san francisco unified school district, you, the board of education, approved a community input process to create the refresh of the arts education master plan. so why create resolutions on arts education without the benefit of the refresh? the resolution and the one being developed around arts and equity both want to make systemic change in our schools. while i agree change is needed, i urge you to have public discussion on the arts education move ther plan refresh before making any policy and funding
10:51 pm
changes. hundreds of stakeholders and the arts community and school community came together in good faith and they attended meetings and they give input on what's working and what's not working with regards to arts education in the district. the district paid for an outside group to hold input meetings and then take these conversations and weave them into a document to inform arts education in our district over the next several years. as students devote access equity, they also deserve good policy-making processes. our school district loses credibility nationally and locally when it spends time and resources on a community engagement process to develop policy that gets preempted by board members before it sees the light of day. in our community and beyond, we are pitting ourselves against each other when we send competing messages. that this has implications for funding, enrollment, school
10:52 pm
bonds and community trust. just taking things apart is not enough. you're getting a bad wrap of taking things apart without a plan. arts education has been lauded nationally. let's have the refresh master plan and work together for the future for our students. thank you. >> hello. my name is julie roberts. i'm here as a parent from redding elementary. i wanted to come and thank you today because a couple weeks ago, redding parents made an effort to come out and ask that you keep our ost after school program open. we got the news that it will remain open through the last day of school 2020. i want to thank you very much. it's a huge relief for all of our families. we want to thank everyone who supported us, parents, teachers, elaine and betty, board members,
10:53 pm
administrators, it's been a huge relief. we really like the outcome, what we want to thank folks for, district staff is for making steps to partner with families to go from doing -- we appreciate deputy superintendent's partnership and leadership in getting a whole team to work with us. they came out and met with families and heard our needs and concerns. we want to thank you for listening and giving us time to ask questions and changing the outcome for or school. we look forward to being partners in problem solving over the next year. i want to leave with questions about what we can do to make partnering with parents the district default and not just happens when families push back. i'm curious about whether the program will stay open and whether or not they got the kind of partnership and meetings that redding got. i also want to really convey how deeply destabilizing it is for
10:54 pm
our schools to fight back against these cuts even when they're reversed. my hearts goes out to james school expressing similar concerns. other schools i'm hearing about having classes consolidated, library hours cut, and more. so i want to ask us, what does it mean to be a pitch school. on one hand, we're adding resources. on the other hand, we're continuing to make cuts. i'm curious if there are opportunities to freeze cuts and create real partnership with pitch stakeholders at sites to best decide how to use resources. thank you all again. >> thank you for all the public comment. item 7, advisory committee reports and a appointments to advisory committees by board members. commissioner lopez and commissioner lam. >> i'm appointing karina wong,
10:55 pm
bilingual teacher to the sf usc charter overtigh oversight commd erika chavez to the living wage for educators oversight committee. >> i'm appointing emily to the parcel tax oversight committee. >> any others? seeing none, consent calendar. we need a motion and a second on the ca consent calendar. >> so moved. >> second. >> all right. public comment on consent items, i don't see any items withdrawn or corrected by the superintendent. >> yes. i call justin steel to read that item. >> thank you. there's one item withdrawn. it's item 46, 195-14w14 from the consent calendar. >> thank you.
10:56 pm
>> any items removed for first reading by the board? sure. mr. collins. >> i had a question on number 19. >> you want to sever that for discussion? >> yes. is that possible. >> do you have that? any items severed by the board or superintendent for discussion and a vote tonight? that's what that is. right? okay. and you don't have any? all right. so what's the item that we're going to discuss? so consent calendar absent that one item. roll call. >> thank you. [ roll call ] >> commissioner collins. >> yes. i had a question about number 19. it lists classroom library sets
10:57 pm
of books being bought for pitch schools. i just wanted to understand they're culturally competent book sets for 6th and seventh grade it said. i just wanted to know -- oh, i'll bring it up. i just wanted to understand -- my girls are at a middle school, and it's not a pitch school. as it was mentioned before, a lot of the books are outdated. some classrooms have culturally relevant collections, and some don't. i was just wondering how this fits into -- but my daughters don't go to a pitch school. >> got it. how this fits into -- >> and also what about eighth grade as well? >> so each pitch school came up with a pitch plan on their root cause and so what these -- the books that have been purchased are in alignment with whatever their pitch plan was. so i'm assuming that the schools
10:58 pm
that are getting these, part of their plan was that they would -- they needed to increase literacy rates and make sure there was culturally competent materials. that's why these schools purchased these books. >> i'm happy to do this. what about all the other schools having culturally relevant books? like my daughter's eighth grade class is amazing. the teacher has been building out libraries. it's amazing. but i know that's in partnership with ethnic studies as a team. she's been doing special projects. i'm just wanting to make sure that -- but in seventh grade they only had white white autho. that's in the same school. i want to make sure across the district, southeast side, north side, they're getting culturally relevant in middle school. we focus $on high school, but middle school is not at that point. >> i just wanted to add that in their effort to increase diversity in curriculum, the
10:59 pm
team has planned a rollout of clr materials, classroom libraries, with the starting point being middle school starting with pitch, but the idea is that it will start with the pitch schools and be submitted to other schools in the district, time line to be determined. >> thank you. you answered my question. all right. thank you. >> okay many roll call on item 19. >> thank you. that translates to commissioner 19514b10 [ roll call ] >> section e, proposal for action tonight are 10 policies which have been moved and seconded at prior meetings and gone through committee. we'll have one vote on all of them. these were all at rules, the
11:00 pm
best committee, of course. 5131.2, bullying and 2 is bp5123, promotion, ac acceleration, retention. three is 0420, school site councils, 4 is board policy 5125.1 release of directly information. five is board rule and procedure 9323.1, order of business. six is board policy 3100, budget and board policy 0460 local control accountability plan. number seven is board rule and procedure 9322. these were heard at the rules committee and all received a positive recommendation with the exception of 5132 bullying which is before us as