>> second. commissioner johnson. >> i conhavcouldn't have said ir myself. >> very good, commissioners. >> a motion with modifications. (role call). >> the motions passes 5-0. >> thank you. it will place us on 2017-01239 drp at 275,823r 275,823rd street, discretionary review. >> good evening. i'm david winslow, the project is before you an initiate request for permit application 2017 09289889 to constructs a

two-story rear horizonal addition to a two-story one -- i'm sorry. groundhog day was my favourite movie. [ laughter ] >> bear with me.

this is to secret a one-story vertical audition and horizonal addition to an existing 1372 square foot, two story, two-family home at 2758 23r 2758 23rd strategy. 2758 23rd street. the dr requester, jennifer fe feeber, that the project will result in permanent displacement of both tenants of the off nut d the right most o removal of affe housing and this almost doubles the size and therefore diminishing the affordable

housing stock. to date, the department has received no letters of support, nor letters of opposition and our planning staff review, however, the extent of the addition will nearly double the size of the units which will presumably enable increasing the amount of rent that can be charged to returning tenants or new occupants. , unless its reasonable to assume a decrease. issues to existing tenants by the san francisco rent board and not under the planning department's purview it is incumbent on the project sponsor to provide a plan for the tenant's displacement and the extent will cause displacement is not known as no plan to house were otherwise accommodating has been provided to staff to data. subsequent to the dr request, the project was recommended some

cosmetic changes to the front of the building with the existing entry stoop and two doors be maintained and the brick base be lowered to a height that is quo lenequivalent to the sort of tht this was constructed as a part of. in addition, if you look at the stoop condition, it doesn't, to my mind, meet code in front door. so that it is a condition that would have to be reconciled before an approval because it would not tout b doubt be changa building not compliant with a building code, as far as i could see. this concludes my presentation. staff recommends to approve with the modifications approved. i'm happy to answer questions. >> thank you and we will now hear from the dr requester.

>> i think everything i need to say was in the original dr. thank you, mr. winslow, for taking it seriously and putting it into your recommendations. i have spoken to the new owner right after i filed and he seemed like a nice guy but clueless that tenants have rights in san francisco. there was no plan for where they were supposed to go during construction and i asked what about when it's done and can they move back in and he's, like, they're not coming back. that's not illegal. that's an eviction and since then been he has tragically filed evictions on the tenants. so they are here. one of the tenants has been in the mission for 50 years and i would just want to let them

speak for themselves and get out of the way. thanks. >> come on up. >> i'm here for cal fox of the tertenderloin housing clinic. i'm here for the tenants upstairs. spoon *they have been tenants f9 years and unlike the characterizizatiocharacterizatit seems like a nice guy, we had the opposite impression. they hathe showers were water w. this work being proposed would

reconfigure the units, not just expand, so there is no effort to keep the tenants in. whether or not there's been an implication of a notice of termination is not the point here. we're in the present. this is their long-term home. the work that's being done is purely elective and cosmetic and intended probably to quadruple the value of the property, not only by creating more size but by getting rid of the long-term tenants. this would eliminate the backyard which is part of the very, very limited open space. they have a dog that uses the backyard. there is very limited space in san francisco and throughout the mission district. it's so concrete and steel. this is one of the few places where they can go out and enjoy the sun and light and let me

just ask. (speaking foreign language). >> i'm the daughter of a deceased person who meant so much to me. that is my father. who is supposed to be the head of the household, right? and we hit rock bottom because we're just getting hit left and right with these new oppositions about new improvements to the house. yes, they are needed, but they're asking us to be displaced permanently and where will we go?

we haven't discussed where to move. how we're going to continue on while i'm still in school and employed. i'm looking for someone to work. it's very hard. but it was just a matter of time when they say it's time to go. >> so in a nutshell, they work will result in the displacement of people that are already in a crisis because of the premature deaths of the father, husband, and then it's like that carlos santana letter, where it says come home and what's their letter saying, get out of here. so we ask you to please deny this permit application and not issue a permit that's going to unnecessarily get rid of long-term tenants. >> thank you.

>> so we will take a public comment in support of the dr requester. >> my name is steven booth with the tenderloin housing clinic. this is maria and she's lived in this property for 38 years and raised a family there and she continues to be a part of the very fabric of this neighborhood. her doctor is three blocks away that she can walk to wherever she needs to. she shops on 24th street and

knows the neighbors there and is virtually a part of the fabric of this community. this project makes no provision for her. her story is quintessentially an american story. she umgreated from el salvador and in the mission district for 50 years, got married in san francisco, worked at the st. francis hotel for about 40 areas. she's supported this community and part of it for a long time. what you're asked to do is to authorize a permit which essentially allow for a dream of profit in the future by a real estate speculator and do we

support that dream or do we support the american dream which this is an example of the american dream. she came here, worked hard, is has been here all her life and will be excluded from the mission. also with her today is pedro rote, her son, who his formative years were spent in that home. the home is still the center of the -- she has three sons, an extended family, grandchildren and they come to visit her on holidays and this is really her pricplace and her community. i also want to say that the landlord's attitude to her has not been friendly or kind. in the very beginning, they tried to trick her by saying, we'll pay you a paltry amount if you leave and then told her she had to leave in six months.

three times they shut off the water and she wasn't able to bathe, clean dishes and they will build a taj mahal. >> any other public support in request oresponse to the dr req? >> i'm greg smith, the architect for this project.

the owner would like to add vertically up and down to each unit, creating from what is a two-room, plus a culture, a two-bedroom and the same footprint and not expanding up and down.

so what the owner is trying to do is make family use fit units preferable over one-perform units and that's what we're trying to do. you'll turn it over to the own owner. >> i'm neil aton, i'm the owner and so my wife and i live a few blocks from the property with our young family. we're not looking to profit from this development but live in this development. ed takewe've ended up with this confrontation with the tenant tenantsand the communication i've had has been clear that

there's no real room for negotiation. what i heard back was the only way that they would not file a dr request is if the tenant were never disturbed. bringing this up to standards is not possible. to respond to the character characterizations is evil landlords, turning off water, trying to trick elderly ladies into leaving their home is completely false and inaccurate. water was turned off during repairs and there were issues

getting it on. this happened over the weekend and we had to call the first available plumber to come on sunday morning. the other issues that miss miranda ref dens referenced aboe water being shut off, that's new to me. in terms of the issues mentioned by the downstairs tenants, any -- nobody communicates with me any issues. after we filed eviction notice, there was retaliation in terms of complaints of the building department which had been depth with or had been dealt with and as soon as we heard from them and so, unfortunately, we've ended up in this scenario and this is the only property that i own in anyplace. we've lived in the mixe missionr

five years and hopefully we'll live here for a long time to come and i'll leave it at that. thank you for your time. >> do we have any public comment in support of the project sponsor? with that, you have a two minute rebuttal? you get two more minutes. >> commissioner johnson. >> where do i begin? this is not the first time we've heard a case like this, in which there are tenants who are in danger of being rent evicted out

of a property. to all of the folks who cal camt and who had to go through the struggle of coming here and sharing your story, i say thank you. and you shouldn't have go through this. i think we as a commission have again and again and again stated that if a project comes to us, we are not comfortable with rent rent evictions and certainly a plan in place of how people will be moved and put back into the units is the bare minimum and then we have serious concerns and want to go through it with a fine tooth comb. so i'm a little disappointed that this is here. there is no way i could support this project at all.

so i would take dr and not approve and would love to hear what other commissioners have to say. >> i second that motion. >> commissioner moore? >> mr. winslow read into the description of this case and suddenly suggested indeed the applicant had not provided any kind of mediating suggestions of what to do with the tenants. the owner stands in front of us without acknowledging the problem is difficult and makes me feel very uncomfortable to hear this project. so the rules surrounding these particular cases in the city are very well published and well-known and i am actually quite speechless.

speechless to hear an applicant coming forward with as many tenants in the building and kind of, really, at least i'm sorry to say that seeming oblivious to the problem he's creating. i have to say that because we are very fair and patient, week in, week out, year in and year out, to see these cases piling up and to sit here with no acknowledgement of the problem is, frankly, shocking to me. and just as commissioner johnson very skillfully summarized her feelings, i would second your thoughts. >> commissioner richards. >> miss fever, please, what estrucevictions have been filed?

>> i'm not sure. you should ask the attorney. >> miss fox, do you know. >> will you please speak into the microphone. >> they have filed notices of templtermination and we intend o challenge that when the notices expire. >> ok, thank you. >> i mean, i echo my fellow commissioners. you already live in the mission and that's great. you're a part of the community. you bought a building that had people living in it who are also a part of the community. for you to continue to live in the mission, these other members of the community are going to be thrown out into the street. that's heartless. if i could put a notice of special restriction that you could never expand your building on your building because of what you're doing, i would, but i

can't. but i'll remember this address and i hope that it gets dred again. i can't support a project like this. there's a motion seconded to take dr and disapprove and i would recommend that you articulate findings for mr. winslow to add to the dr action memo. and i hope that it gets dred >> for discretionary reviews, you don't. >> we sat through a presentation

that took two years of staff work to come up with strategies on community stabilization, on preservation of housing, on all of the resources that the city is spending to make this happen and that surely can be a finding. so i am -- i think that prevention of homelessness, community stabilization, some stuff about map 2020, the preservation of housing, the tenants are folks who are older. they're also protected tenants under the rent-control law and there are things we could state as findings. commissioner richards? >> hardship due to loss of family members, extra stress of young persons still going to school and in the middle of loss of a father, you think that there are millions of arguments, particularly after we spend listeningy time, as you

mentioned on the community stablization act today. >> if i could property you to also include one of the issues brought forth was the expansion doubling the size, automatically increases the affordability, inaffordability of this. >> commissioners richards? >> so at my first confirmation hearing before the rule's committee, i mentioned hershey chocolate company because they bought joseph schmidt with the intent of not wanting him to compete with them, so they bought the business and shut it down. you bought a business, which is is housing provider business, using the ellis fact and you're shutting it down for your own gain. when we started this hearing, i

mentioned to some people, we have to go to the state and senator weiner and assemblyman chu and get them to do ellis act reform, there has to be a spectator tax on profit. this is what we're looking at right now and that's my last two cents. i'm flummoxed. >> thank you for those findings to disapprove, (role call). >> so moved, commissioners and that motion passed 5-0. >> we're now adjourned.

>> self-planning works to preserve and enhance the city what kind hispanic the environment in a variety of ways overhead plans to fwied other departments to open space and land use an urban design and a variety of other matters related to the physical urban environment planning projects include implementing code change or designing plaza or parks

projects can be broad as proipd on overhead neighborhood planning effort typically include public involvement depending on the subject a new lot or effect or be active in the final process lots of people are troubled by they're moving loss of they're of what we preserve to be they're moving mid block or rear yard open space. >> one way to be involved attend a meeting to go it gives us and the neighbors to learn and participate dribble in future improvements meetings often take the form of open houses or focus groups or other stinks that allows you or your neighbors to provide feedback and ask questions the best way to insure you'll be

alerted the community meetings sign up for the notification on the website by signing up using you'll receive the notifications of existing request the specific neighborhood or project type if you're language is a disability accomodation please call us 72 hours before the event over the events staff will receive the input and publish the results on the website the notifications bans feedback from the public for example, the feedback you provide may change how a street corridors looks at or the web policy the get started in planning for our neighborhood or learner more mr. the upcoming visit the plans and programs package of our we are talking about with our feedback and participation that is important to us not everyone

takes this so be proud of taking [roll call] we have a quorum. >> wonderful. before we begin, the general public comment, i wanted to welcome a new director to our board. a big welcome to you. you will be coming from a background of grout knowledge in-housing development and the foundation and he comes from --

he is an urban planning by training with lots of credentials and it will help us in our business of --[ off mic ] >> i'm excited to be on here and i'm very excited the growth of treasure island and hope to bring my background both in organizing, working in public-health as well as real estate development and urban planning and to the board. >> thank you, ruby. >> good. >> next item, please. >> general public comment. do not appear on the general agenda. it will be held during each item on the agenda.

members of the public may address the board for up to three months and 30 seconds remaining and prior to make your comments, state your name and the organization you are representing if any further record. >> treasure island museum. welcome director shiffrin. first of all, i'd like to invite you, particularly to the saturday's fleet weekend lecture in the big idea series. it's about panam and the clippers and their role in helping win world war ii and the pacific. i am really here -- peter can -- what i'm here for is to get you half as excited as i am about this project that i've been working on. you are probably familiar with the math head which was the naval station treasure island weekly newspaper from 1941 until

the station closed in 1997. it recorded the life of the island in ways big and small from chances an dances and spors to redevelop the entire island and put housing. this is from 1966, from the mast head and that year also the death of admiral nimith. week by week, they documented half a century of the life of naval station treasure island. so i'd like to introduce you to second class carolyn brown she worked on the staff of the mast head in 1944 and 1945 and when she stepped down, her colleagues gave her a couple of bound volumes of the the 17 month mast head she worked on. and the museum has -- they were given to the museum two years ago by her daughter.

the museum has digitized those issues of the masthead and -- let's see if this works. and you can go online, members of the public can go online to our website and page through issues the masthead and follow the life of treasure island. i'm working on putting a search function in this but it's just an amazing record of the history of the island and you can go online and browse it at your leisure. the old museum had an almost complete file of mastheads and they are now in the national archives down in san bruno and it's a dream of mine to get the resources to have someone go down there with a scanner and scan the whole half century plus of mastheads and put it up on our website. i've been through some of those issues and it's an amazing, amazing resource.

the things you find in there. at least we made a start on it? >> thank you for that report. please come up. >> members of the board, my name is travis lund i'm the executive director of the treasure island sailing. i intend to give a full report at the island meeting next month i wanted to address a couple of items with you. say in general our over all summer programs are up by 12%. we had a banner year this year. it's been precipitation that's . u.s. sailing was given a gift. i sent a communication about that and i'm sure y'all received it. i wanted to formally invite you in-person to that. it's a 3 million-dollar gift they gave u.s. saling to expand the sport of saling in terms of diversity and bridge the gap

between youth and older students. they put brand new boats and they have done that across the country. i have those formal invitations i'll leave with you and that's october 20th from 3:00 to 4:00 and the presentation is from 2:30 to 3:00. we love it if you could make it there. it would be wonderful if you can. the other invitation i would say is that we're continuing to do our stem and sailing program and it's been expanded to a fifth grade program which is a five-daylong program which facilitates 84 trips to treasure island sailing center throughout the year and that's running monday through friday now somewhere between 9:00 to 2:00 depending on the day and we'd love to invite you to come out and witness that if you wanted to step up for a half-hour. it's something we'd like to invite you to. send me an e-mail and we'll make sure everything is lined up appropriate for you and get on a boat and see it as well. thank you for participating in our program this summer as well.

that's it. thank you so much. >> thank you, travis. >> i'll leave these invitations. >> i know that you've had a great summer and the summer camps were very successful. we know quite a few families who took the summer camps and we're appreciative that you offer those classes. >> thank you so much. >> next, please. >> good afternoon, my name is jim hancock i'm the president of the san francisco sailing science center not to be confused with the treasure island sailing center. i'd just like to sailing science board meeting on sunday and approved and the first exhibit and that is going to go into progress this week.

when it's completed, it will be displayed at the treasure island sailing is the directors will be invited to that as well as other key stakeholders on the island. we hope you save your date december 12th on your calender. thank you. >> seeing no others, next item, peter. >> item number 3. report by treasure island director. >> good morning, directors. this week is plead week and staff have been doing a lot of work trying to complete we are

continuing to take our typical precautions with increased sfpd presence barricading off viewing locations and flaggers for potential traffic problems, signage as well as temporary rest rooms and waste reseptic als. this past month, treasure island, one treasure island completed their fourth construction training program and i'd like to invite sherry williams to come up and say a few words about it. >> good afternoon, commissioners. i'm sherry williams with one treasure island and welcome commissioner. we look forward to working with you. so we had our fifth graduation and just for a little background, i know that a lot of you are already familiar was that this construction training program was really for us to

provide people that -- with your support with the development support. this program grew out of a report we did two decades where we looked at what are called nuisance buildings but all the buildings on the island that it would be an opportunity for us to actually create a job training program for people who have various employment, low background in employment and so fourth to actually have hands on experience by taking down the buildings. and about two years ago now, we've joined forces with echo bay, with the support of you all and we have a six-week training

program where after the six weeks, they actually graduate and become members of the either local 67 or local 2261. 261. they move from graduation to employment and many of them are put into positions on the island taking down these buildings. we anticipate many of them will move to other positions on the island as we go vertical on the ilan. island. we're really building a workforce of folks who have had few options really in gaining access to good-paying construction, union-wage jobs and we're creating that workforce so that we can make the job set aside that we set aside for the island many decades ago now. we can make it a real achievable goal. and i am happy to say of the 19

people that graduated, we have 17 have already started and had already members of the union and it was an incredible day because the other component here is almost anticipated positive is that we are really part of the restorative justice movement in the sensement of the folks that are entering our program are reentry. we have the public defender be our keynote speakers at this graduation and he is very -- wells patrick ryan who is the owner, the co owner of the echo-based services who has been our key construction training partner in the private sector. i just wanted to share this is something that we can collectively feel very proud of. we are going to troy to ramp it up so as things go vertical

there's a lot more demand for workers so we're hoping to have more rounds of training. it's our model and so we just want to be really intentional that we're ready for that when it happens. that is going into 2020, we're really hoping to have one of these cycles every quarter. so san francisco gets a share of those jobs that will be created and so train people who feed the skills are so important and you know, there's such a lack of skilled labor right now in the construction labor force in san

francisco. and in the bay area. so training programs that prepare people. >> if i can, mayor london breed just recently opened the office of equity, the first in the history of san francisco. let it be known, the treasure one treasure island with the help of treasure island development authority, we are the ones that are now implementing equity. i can attest this workforce training is one of the best. it's the must see. i see our jobs here and if you look at those remotely, we have the expertise to develop treasure island from a new

commissioners from everybody here we have the technical expertise. it's opportunities and making sure that the development of treasure island is shared by everyone from the low income, from the disadvantaged and it's the highlight of everything we do here. this program, we must not only put our efforts in that, we need to keep going. there's a shortage in construction. why are we not having this three or four or five times. the governor on down everybody needs to come into see what a wonderful program we're doing here made available but you all. you all need to be extremely very proud and sherry, for you and your staff, you are doing the work right here. we thank you for your efforts. thank you.

>> i just wanted to add to that too. the mayor's office does have a very similar job training program and twice a year and it stated in the past that they are looking to expand that program into a third cycle and perhaps for some synergies to be had there and in the future of one treasure island looking at expanding the program as well. i believe they're looking for places to actually train as well not just expand the program but looking for appropriate locations for the training which i believe we have a lot of availability on the island. thank you. >> thank you, sharon. i think oewd, you are correct, it's already in the process of outreach to director, you are right. so that collaboration could be a key. it's something very important. >> thank you. we turn to you. >> thank you. just on the subject of the training program, i did want to

highlight that one aspect of the training program that has made it particularly successful are the contributions that one treasure island brings to the program. with financial literacy and other life skill programs they incorporate into the curriculum along with 267 and the contractor. it's a very well rounded program that focuses on barrier removal and prepares the participants for success he in the workplace. returning to my regular report, we had a couple of events. on the great lawn there was a wedding in september and a music event this past saturday, october 5th.

and kaiser permanente. on the 28th of this month, cal trans is planning to have a ceremony to dedicate the pier e2 project that we've discussed in the past utilizing the foundation of the old bay bridge to create a public access amenity on the eastern shore of the island. they're supposed to issue their invitations for that event today. all of the board members should be receiving that but we'll make sure to pass it along to all of you as well. the treasure fest was the last weekend in september and we have events in the end of october and november. the treasure fest is reviewing

with staff the schedule and feasibility of continuing in 2020 or perhaps taking a year off. there are some construction activities, including the construction of the new sanitary sewer force main and the gas line improvements that will effect portions of the area, traditionally used by the treasury next year. they're seeing whether it makes sense to schedule around that or perhaps look for an alternative location for that year and plan to return to the island in the future. we had this past weekend, on friday, the muni25 reopened. bus stops at the intersection of clipper cove and avenue of the palms so we have a stop now with

immediate access to building one, the marina, as well as the clipper cove beach area. we had some utility issue this past month. on last weekend, we had two separate utility issues. one was a power outage that effected just one building in the residential area and that was reported at 5:00 a.m. on sunday with service being restored at 10:45:00 a.m. an unrelated, there was a water main break saturday at 10:11:00 p.m. behind the ship shape and cdda was able to respond and complete all repairs by 4:00 in the morning. two relatively small issues with the rapid response times from

the puc. peter summerville are also participating in the city wide preparation efforts around the pg&e public safety power shutoffs. planning around that for the city this time the city is not expected to be impacted by the current around the outage but if the city or in particular as it relates to at this da, oakland e able to put the island onto the generators that we have on the island if they need today interrupt the transmission of power to the island we would still keep the lights on for residents.

also, on the power discussions, on october 16th, the public utilities commission will be performing some testing on the submarine cable that connects treasure island so they'll put it on to generators during that testing period and there will be two short outages effecting ybi only as power is transferred onto the generator and then later in the evening transferred off of the generator. last month, on the 21st, the new art temporary art sculpture was dedicated at the avenue of the palms in ninth street adjacent to the dog park. this is a sculpture that utilizes steel from the bay

bridge and the artist was one of those selected by cal trans to utilize that steel. director richardson attended and spoke at the event. also on the 21st, the treasure island community garden held an equalwanox. from residents that were interested in becoming involved in the community garden they're planning a workday this saturday at the greenhouse adjacent to the ship shape. the surcharge north of california in several areas is complete and the contractor is now in the process of moving that soil to other areas so avenue of the palms in front of building one is now under

surcharge and they'll also shortly begin moving soil from the catholic charities housing site where sur chargeses are complete to the adjacent parcel which will be developed to a mercy housing so that site will be placed under surcharge for construction in 2020. the improvement of soil conditions, particularly cement deep soil mixing under the causeway is nearing it's conclusion and they will reconstruct the causeway up to with the target of moving traffic from eastside of the causeway to the west side of the causeway in march. the contract will repeat that

process to excavate and improve the eastside of the causeway. work continues on the new water shortage reservoirs and also in november, the country transportation authority anticipates putting out to bid the new eastbound off ramp from i-80 and the south gate hill crest interchange. they will be at our i.t. c. meeting next week to provide an update on the scope of that project as well as the via ducts on the west side of the islands. the area has been under surcharge and geo technical work

is being completed. the ccdc is also working on finalizing their loan agreement closing with the expectation of mobilizing to begin construction in early 2020, february-march timeframe for that coordination conditioning with ticd on construction stages and access and temporary power and other issues. we condition to work with the navy on the transfer of site 24. just finalizing the deed descriptions and other documents with the expectation that that property will transfer to title of i.d. at the end of the month and that concludes my report. >> thank you, bob. are there any questions from -- yes. >> bob, just a quick question about the interruptions for the

power when we it kicks into the generator and when it rolls off, how long is the interruption. we put out notices and we expect we always publicize it will be an hour but typical is more on the order of 15 to 20 minutes. >> can it be further reduced for planned outages or is that just the amount of time it takes for the generator to transfer over? >> it's just the amount of time it takes. we don't have a automatic transfer switches and things need to be transferred manually and it's a function of the process of manually isolating circuits and reenergizing them on the generator. >> thank you. >> thank you for that

presentation. you should see on your desk, i brought some magnets and they are from the signal art dedication from treasure island and i had the privilege to attend this fantastic art piece. even though that signal is not a part of the over all art program that is going to be towards treasure island because we're still in the process of causing that. none the less, these are to work by mr. tom lavalin. 22 tons of fabricated steel. never seen anything where they took scraps from the bay bridge and what is very striking with this art is the public interaction. you saw the kids, a lot of

children, having great fun. to me, that is indicating what a group is. it creates a career city. when you look around that, you ask all these questions but the thing is it is also even though it's temporary it's only for five years and the public reception of this piece of art and when you get a chance to go to these and you yourself would see what a fantastic piece of art work this is. you have your pen there, use it. >> thank you, very much. >> no other comments. next item, please. >> >> item number 4, communication 0 and received by tida. >> i think this is a new packet.

are there any questions about it? >> yes,. >> my again, sorry. just a quick question about the translated notices from puc. i am noticing that and perhaps this is always in the case but i'm just for some reason noticing it, it seems that the template informs itself is translated however the actual content of the notification details such as the date and what the interruption is is still in english and is it possible for the content, the stuff that is actually important to be also translated? >> yeah, we'll view that. yes, this is the salient details that should be transferred. >> great. >> next item, please. >> item number 5, on going business by board of directors. >> does the board have any items they would like to bring up? nearing none,