in person and remote hybrid hearing will require everyone's attention and most of all obligation. if you're joining us and are not speaking please mute your microphone. to enable public participation, sfgov tv is podcasting and

streaming this hearing lives and we will receive public comments for each item on today's agenda. comments are opportunities to speak are available by calling 415-655-0001. access code 2487 726 7831. we will take public comment from persons in person first and then open the remote hearing. please speak clearly and slowly and be prepared to state your name for the record. each speaker will be allowed up to 30 minutes and you'll hear a child indicating our timeis almost up . when your time is reached i will announce your time is up and take the next person. for those persons calling in to submit their testimony when we reach the item you are interested in please restá3 to be added to the queue. when you hear the line has been unloaded and is your indication to begin speaking.

best practices article from a quiet location, speak clearly and slowly and knew the volume of the television or computer. for those persons attending in person is line up on the screen and silence any mobile devices that may be lostduring the hearings. commissioner release . commissioner diamond. [rollcall] i'll pass it off to president tanner for everything. >> thank you all for being here. decent crowd today for this agenda and thank you for joining us remotely. i want to start off with outlander knowledge meant. the planning commission acknowledges we are on the unseeded ancestral homeland of the ramaytush ohlone . the original inhabitants of the

san francisco peninsula and as stewards and in accordance with traditions the ramaytush ohlone have neither neither seated nor lost their responsibility as caretakers of thisplace as well as for all people who reside in traditional territory . as guests we recognize and benefit from living and working on their homeland and we wish to pay our respects by acknowledgingancestors and others and relatives of the ramaytush ohlone community by affirming theirsovereign rights as first people. thank you . >> we move on to ourfirst item on the agenda . a consideration of items proposed for continuance . the commission will consider a request for continuance to a later date and the commission may choose to continue items as listed on the agenda. the items on the continuance calendar ir itemnumber one are 2760 divisadero street . december 2021 00 497 arp and item to work 3055 clement street or case number 2019

022830 eight hv proposed for definite continuance. at this time there are no other items on the agenda. listed to be processed. >> this time we will take public comments on the continuance calendar. anymember of the public that would like to speak on this item in person please line up on the screen side of the room . seeing none, we will also open up the public comments from the remote speakers. and we do not have any remote speakers. we willclose public comment . >> and a commissioners . commissioner koppel. >> motion to approve items one and two.

motion by commissioner koppel to continue itemsone and two listed on the agenda . we will take a rollcall. commissioner ruiz. >>. [roll call vote] and president tanner. that item passes 7to 0 and we will move on to consent calendar item be on the agenda . while matters of the city hearing are considered to be routine by the planning commission and maybe acted on by a single rollcall vote. they will be no separate discussion of items of these items unless a member of the public or commission or staff requests in which event the matter shall be moved to the consent calendar and considered as a separate item for a future

hearing. items on the consent calendar include item 341 70 south bend case number 2021 002045 ca. and item for 43931 allegheny boulevard case number 2021 013 00 three cua. requestfor conditional use authorization . does any member of the public wish to pull any of theseitems off the consent calendar . >> seeing none, we can entertain a motion. >> moved to approve. motion made by commissioner moore to approve theconsent calendar . second by commissioner imperia . let's take a rollcall vote commissioner ruiz .[roll call vote] the item passes 70.

moving on to commission matter item 5 , commission comments andquestions . >> any items commissioners. >> there was a distressing article on the front page of the chronicle today about portfolios remaining closed and i was wondering if the director might want torespond to that. there are obviously some concerns . >> happy to and we know through the pandemic it's critical to residents of the city and visitors who work there. so our take is that if the buildings are open the provost

should also be open so perhaps we can send a notice to all buildings that do have those and let them know if they do not open we can start enforcing actions but we can look into that because again our take is if the building is open the provost should be open as well. >>thank you. >> a follow-up question director ruiz . is there more of an active oversight in terms of checking it or it's more based on complaints? >> like most of our enforcement worktends to be complaints . >> vice president more. >> i wanted to ask director ellis question regarding transamerica permit. we understand there's a major change in ownership and refurbishing the building and other activities on the site.

however none of that has come in front of us and their speaking about provost at least for three or four weeks now. theentire block that is montgomery , clay turning onto sanford are border often includes the part that is one of the first and the city of san francisco downtown parts. it's completely closed off. that particular part for decades has served as an open space for the sro in chinatown. given that there is a high degree of people not having open-space in addition to using this particular open-space for community relief. can we get an update of what the plans are. why this particular part is closed off in that particular project has notcome in front of us . >> we will look into it. i think what's already been

approved is some renovations to the ground floor of the tower itself. i think the notion was to add some additional or to repurpose some of the space to retail. i think that'sapproved but to me that would necessarily necessitate closure of the park so we will look into that . >> the building, the tall building at the corner of play. it's all completely closed off. >> there's an application in for the office building on the northwest corner of sansom which will have to come to the commission as ibelieve it's a project allocation . but we will give you an update on the timing of all that as well as questions why the entire block is closed. >> thank you. >> anything else commissioners? thank you. >> i was just notified that we have a caller requesting to

speak so through the chair if we don't mind we will see what this remote callerhas to say if they want to speak on one of the items that we've already discussed . >> hello caller. you're welcome to provide your comments. do you want to speak on one of the itemsthat the commission has already discussed in terms of either the continuance calendar or consent calendar ? >> this is michael cross. it was on the consent calendar and i believe the commission already approved the item i was just going to voice my support for the allegheny project . the formula retail project. >> thank you color, i was going to say if you wanted to speak or for your support we would pull the item on the agenda and hear it on theregular calendar >> i had actually raised my hand whenyou asked for that to pull it off the calendar but it wasn't recognized at the time but that's fine .

>> you so much . >> commissioners we can move on to item 6 department matters. directors announcement. >> we will move on to item 7 review of past events at the board ofsupervisors courtof appeals and historic preservation commission . i can provide an update on all three ofthose. the hbc did not meet yesterday . they had cancel the hearing . relative to the court of appeals i was informed by the deputy zoning administrator that the court of appeals did not hear any items of future planningcommission and then finally for the board of supervisors , legislative affairs manager aaron starr provided to me before plex legislation was continued to the june 6 land use committee and the mission cultural center past landmark nominations past its first three of the board of supervisors . >> if i can add on before plex

legislation because we did get a question as to why wouldn't it come back . apparentlythe proposal that the board is considering is to limit those , limited to only property owners who own their property for five or more years to take advantage of the density increased to go from two units support. and although we didn't necessarily discuss that as a policy issue when it came to us it's limiting and we kind of dramatically limited the abilityfor lots to take advantage so that's why it didn't come back to the building commission . just to limit the number. it's more restrictive. >> we can move on to item e, general public comment. at this time members may address the commission items of interest to the public within the subject matter jurisdiction your opportunity to address th commission will be afforded when the item is reached . each member may address the

commission for up to three minutes. when the number of speakers exceeds the 15 minute limit the general public comment may be mute moved to the end of the agenda. if any members would like to provide their public comment please line up on the screen side of the room. seeing none, chair. we have one caller requesting public comment. chan, can youunmute . >> it's georgia. attachment for general public comment. >> there was a presentation, it was kind of brief but wasthere. there was a lot of material and

supporting documents i think it was 4d . about the pending legislation both local and state. and i thought that at some point the commission was going to request, was going to have an informational on legislation from the state. just thought i'd ask about that today because if anybody's curious i guess you could go look at the ddi provided to the members. it's like 4 to 6pages . local and the state. take care, have a nice day. >> i think that is all of our publiccolors in the queue . we can move on to the next item on our agenda. moving on to the regular calendar. item number 8 a and 8b or 350

ocean avenue case number 2017 01961 spt and record number 2017 001961 see you a request for conditional use authorization. just for the record on february 24, 2022 the hearing after closing public comments continued item to april 14, 2022 by a vote of 3to 2 . on april 14 the hearing was continued again to maine in 19 by a vote of 7 to 0. since this item hasbeen her we will be limiting public comment time to 2 minutes . >> good afternoon president

tanner, commissioners. the case before you is a request for conditional use authorization for incentives and waivers from development standards under the individually requested statement fonts project and request for adoption of shadow findings on the demolition of 2 existing one story commercial buildings and the construction of a five story over basement 55 foot six inches 36 dwelling unit residential building which will contain 15 occupancy parking spaces, 36 class i bicycle parking spaces, to bicycle parking spaces and is located within the neighborhood commercial transit zoning district and 40 5x height and bulk district. the proposal includes 19 2 bedroom units, 13 one-bedroom units and 4 studios which range in size from 415 to 1215 feet in space. under the individually requested statements the

project is seeking approximately 5.1 percent density bonus and waivers from the rear yard, usable open-space, exposure use requirements . see the commission was granted conditional use for the development of a lot size greater than 4000 square feet . pursuant to planning code section 121.1, 150 5r, 303 and 750 and the adoption of shadow findings pursuant to planning code to 95 and adoption of findings related to the requested waivers pursuant to planning code 206.6 and california government code section 6.515. on february 24, 2022 the commission heard and continue the project and requested the project sponsor evaluate various design changes including relocating the

transformer from within the building to within the public right-of-way . providing a dwelling unit with direct access to the proposed rearyard space as opposed to the buildings amenities. and redesigning the ground-floor fagades to minimize the number of students . aproposal for you is addressed both listed design changes and as a result has created one additional dwelling unit . since february 24 planning commission hearing the department has received concerns regarding traffic, parking, construction effects to recent properties. the project was considered individually valid under the elbow apart nation eir which consider the topics concerned. theapartment recommends approval with conditions and believes the project is desirable for the following reasons .the department finds the project is on balance consistent with theplan. the balboa park station area plan and meets all applicable requirements of the planning

code . the project will maximize the use of underutilized lot and construct a five base building within close proximity to public transportation, public open-space, commercialcorridors and jobs and project will increase the city accounting stock byproviding 36 swelling units , six of which will be designated as on-site rental dwelling units, 18 percent of the project's total units . the project will provide a land-use compatible with an nct one zoning district and a building that is responsive to compatible immediate nadir of its characteristics including size and building mass. this includes staff presentation and i'm available for any questions . >>how long was the project sponsor presentation ? >> three minutes. >> good afternoon, project sponsor. at the very first hearing the

commission provided several suggestions to make the projec better . we went back and listened to the tape again very carefully. and really tried to be responsive with certain revisions. the architecture will go over that in a moment but in your packet and the brief there's also a chart that lists all those comments and how we've responded one of the revisions is to move the transformer below grade under the sidewalk and we would appreciate your expressed support for that move. i want to talk a little bit about outreach. the project has had to notice neighborhood meetings early in april 2019 and another one in november 2020 there have been other discussions with neighbors throughout the process . on march 25 after the first hearing there wasanother meeting in person with several neighbors and supervisors sapphire is a. several revisions have been made .

in addition to planning questions one of the neighbors who spokeis on construction and excavationactivities . everything from construction noise to insurancecoverage , cal osha requirements . the project sponsor has been in the business for decades. has built many projects in san francisco. we have very specificbuilding code requirements in the city and review processes . those are all in addition to conditions of approval and mitigation members by planning so nothing short of full compliance with building code regulations and laws and review processes is planned here on permitting and construction. we want to ask we certainly understand nobody wants to live right next to the construction site however it is temporary and we have laws and regulations and processes and enforcementprocesses to make sure it's all done in a compliant and safe manner so i'll turn it over .

>> good afternoon commissioners. sorry, newmicrophone. good afternoon . verybriefly the changes we made , there's an extension of the light well on the right side of the building and we've demonstrated the nearest building in terms of exposure is about 60 feet away. i should mention our rear wall will align with the neighbor to our right. in thebasement we've relocated some of the bicycle parking and shown the transformer on the sidewalk . again transformer on the sidewalk with a new one-bedroom unit up front and now two bedroom units in the rear with open-space. second floor and not we eliminated property line windows and added our light well facing the neighbor . showing the roof we have increased the occupied roof deck and also shown unoccupied landscaping with railings all around. and updated the front with no residential stoops.

i'm available for any questions. thank you. this time the commission will take public comments on item number 8 a and 8b. if there's a number that would like to providepublic comment please line up on the screen side of the room or, to the dais . seeingnon-we have one remote caller . chan, can you unmute? hello caller. >> speaker: this is ernesto. owner of the 320 ocean avenue immediately adjacent to the project . we did meet with kevin in january and there were two other neighbors. we did make some headway with the privacy issues. we still have concerns and issues on sustainability, excavation on march 25 kevin

mcavoy said he would not provide mitigation to code 832 means heis supposed to make an effort and we're supposed to have conversations on that but he immediately said we would not . wehave in terms of the onset parking the dimensions of the cutout with the garage door opening , aren't really going to be conducive to havingcars coming up in and out . we will be hearing the noise of the car alarm system going on. more than anyone would like to hear. and finally, we talked to the neighbor and he has not had a positive issue and that's concerned. i do . >> thank you, if any other memberwould like to provide public comments to the commission , pleaseá3.

i do not see there's one more collar. can you unmute ? hello caller. hello. i think you need to silence your tv or your computer and speak into your might. we can't hear you. there we go. we got you now. >> are you readyfor me to speak? >> yes, feel free to provide your public comment . >> this is camille at 120 ocean avenue. i have a concern as obviously the parking is turning into the property and also leaving the property with the amount of pedestrians. we'velived here for a while. we've seen the amount of pedestrians on the street . and also we know that emergency

vehicles going down there's an abundance of them. in fact when we turn onto our property we can backup traffic so that's a big concern for me. thank you. >> thank you. i see no other members of the public. one more. canyou please unmute ?color, you'rewelcome to provide your public comment to the commission on 350 ocean avenue . >> hi. i would like to ask commission to consider delaying the project to get more time to the local communityand neighbors . many of which are elderly and were impacted by the pandemic. i would also import the commission to consider that. thank you. >> thank you.

last call for public comment on items eight a and 8b april 3, 1950 ocean avenue. if there's any member of the public that would like to provide public comments please feel free to step up to the dais. >> quite sometime since i've spoken with you. my name is scott kuipers, civil assistance planning task force. and i'm neutral on the project, just want to say the owners have treated us well. i have a gallery on the site and appreciate the time we've been there the neighbors have had concernsand i appreciate their in conversation . it's mostly just taking a moment to advocate for keeping spaces occupied until they are finally approved and demolished and i appreciate the owners been willing to work with us and will keep the building active and looked after and

make sure everything goes smoothly if neighbors have concerns on had to be on site and there are several sites languishing and i really like to advocate for programs that can allow nonprofits or nonprofitssponsored arts groups to keep these spots active. there's a church on market strikes, a church on. at sixth street. the old trophy shop across the street from our place . i moved in our business in 2019 after our block at 3/65 street was in increased and it's a giant lagoon so i want to hope projects areapproved once they're ready to go and all financing is in place that's really as far as the policy . we helped craft x which needs revisiting. it was formerly pdr space but it's still a big facility ther . we're hoping that maybe there can be revisiting that site because the arts community continues to be in crisis and has been kind with any performance arts.

so we're hoping there could be continued work to help make sitesespecially as they're in transition with the planning department and other agencies to keep them activeuntil larger economic interests move forward . the owners have been supportive to us, and help with rent during the worst parts of the pandemic and again i just appreciate the conversation they are taking place . >> i see no additionalpublic comment either remotely or in person . through the chair i think a couple of our commissioners have some disclosures . >> if there's disclosures you should make them work if you want to. >> computer diamond. >>. >> thank you. i just wanted to notify everyone including the public that they arrived late for the last hearing and therefore the city attorney was unable to vote.i want to assure everyone that i since then review the entire transcript

from the last hearing of course with all the materials today. >> thank you commissioner diamond. >> i just wanted to follow commissioner diamond and also say i was not present for the february hearing and ireceived the hearing and i'm prepared to move today. >> we will go back to you vice president . >> i wanted to acknowledge the fact that this is a great example of how the commission commenting thoughtfully and given some clear guidance to project sponsors can indeed make a big difference. i believe the concerns we had addressed together have all been considered and i have found that they have been satisfactorily resolved. i think we have a better building as we have a better place of large units on the ground floor, we see these

four-bedroom unitswhich have family oriented units with their own open-space. i am in support of the project . the only thing i would like to ask the architect is the use of the word unoccupied landscaping is somewhat unusual can we rephrase that to unoccupied roofers landscaping . i do want to avoid that the deck area spills over into the landscaping and while we have to resurface and there's provisions for specifically the pathway to service the green i do not want it to be confused with the roof decks. i would like to see it be amended to unoccupied with the landscaping if that's possible. otherwise i'm in support and appreciate theadjustments that have been made . >>. >> i did have a lesson for the

architect team, a request for the transformer to have support from the commission. if you could explain them preventing agency is it public works? who is it you need topersuade to allow you to have a transformer there and it is there a possibility they might say no . what would happen in that situation ?>> there is already a conditional tool that always says here is the preference from planning departments perspective as to where thetransformer should be located but we appreciate you as the commission could also say yousupport placing it onto the sidewalk. it would help us when we go to dpw to get approved the commission strongly supports the duplication on the sidewalk . that would be our presence . >> do you have concern they might not confer with that? >> we spoke with the civil engineerfor the project and he believed we can place it on the sidewalk but we're just trying to cover our bases . >> i wanted to makesure if we

were nervous about it or if we were confident we could get that to happen . >> president chan, in the past few years we had a number of high density projects on the street where that was a necessity in each case may ultimatelyrealized the transformer on the sidewalk . >> i don't see any other commissionershands. is there anybody who was interested ? >> i'm in general support of this. ido have a question in the nearby neighbor . in conversations it seems like the main issue still is that his driveway and the gate entry to the building are perhaps there's going to be some sort of a trafficor intersection. are there mitigation measures , are you guysthinking of in terms of how to avoid his driveway ? i understand that the curbside

has already been inplace . but what kind of discussion has been with him? >> specifically on that concern. i was just looking at the plan. it is about 30 feet away from his property line. that should be sufficient in maneuvering area. and i think generally speaking we don't want to make garage openings larger than they need to be . and in this case the garage is around as soon as the door is open and there's enough space to pull in. personally there's not enough cueing. we do think it is an appropriatelocation and a safe location . >> thank you. i don'tknow if other commissioners have comments . >> i certainly want to

appreciate the concerns the neighbors haveabout as far as turning into and out of the driveway . i don't know that much can be done about the noise but in regard to the system it's alerting people, it's so noisy i think that's the purpose of it which is to provide analert to pedestrians to avoid conflict. the solution to one thing can create another challenge and i think that's just part of expanding the trade-off . i'd rather have a little bit of noise then have someone get hit by a car. i want to thank the project sponsor and members of the community that participated and to provide her safai's office. is there a commissioner that would like to make a motion? >> i'm going to approve. >> second. >> we have a motion from commissioner moore to approve the items . item eight a and 8b and second

from commissioner imperial. we will take a roll call vote. [roll call vote] that item passes 72 zero. we will move on to our next item. the discretionary review calendar . and item numbernine 42230 washington street .case number 2021 004022 crp. request for discretionary review. >> good afternoonpresident tanner, vice president more . the item before you, well the dr requester william and project sponsor have come to an agreement they would like to have memorialized by having the

position approve building permit number 2021 c0329 7048. with the followingmodifications as incorporated into the revised drawing. to the proposed project i sent you earlier this morning . these include providing a 7 and a half foot site set back to the east starting 10 feet nine inches from the dr requester's rear building wall.and maintaining money as an unoccupied roof with a current higher than four or six inches. number two reducing the extent of the third floor rear wall b six feet . number three, providing a five foot side setback on the west side . to the third floor deck. and number for lowering the ceiling height of the proposed addition from 10 feet to nine feet .number five removal of the stair pan handles to be replaced by a four foot five inch high sliding skylight and parapet along the west side. will a maximum of seven feet

high with a parapet. number six finally a reduction on the roof deck with setbacks of three feet from the rear, five feet from the west and sorry, 7 and a halffeet from the east.this concludes my presentation and i'm happy to answer questions . >> through the chair it sounds like the dr requester has come to agreement. do the dr requester's want to speak at all or public comment ? we will limit yourtime to 2 minutes .>> thank you commissioner scott, i'd be happy to bring our requesters. i'd like to thank mister whitfield for his efforts at getting this to an agreement and mark graham the project architect for being flexible to try to address some of the concerns. >> just for thesake we will take public comment on this

item . if any member of the public would would like to provide publiccomment on item number nine please come up to the dais . and seeing none we also have no remote colors in our queue. so commissioners. >> questions, comments, motions. >> is your winslow did they inform us of the changesagreed to by the dr staff ? >> yes. >> thank you very much. >> commissioner imperial. >> just a question in terms of the residential policy. as i see on the first ground floor, as defined in the residential policy in terms of occupying. he, i guess i'm trying to educate myself here. as i see it as more of a full

occupying story and the full flat from the transfer down to the ground floor but there is a garage in there. so how is that? >> the residential flats policy was intended to preserve that type of housing with double exposure as a type that's not beingreadily replaced in the city . the commission left the details in that policy relatively vague but there were some specific intent and that is the idea that our flat is a flat.it's defined assomething that has double exposure typically . in the application of the residential policy in this case you could see the aperture or the exposure on the street fronting side is pretty much limited to a width of seven feet partially due to the accommodation of the parking in the front as well at that

level. we've determined as an internal interpretation to the department to some extent that for it to have exposure, to mean something it has to be a minimum width of the room and a minimum width of the room the building code is seven feet per bedroom. in this case that's what they have provided in that long looking always room configuration where seven feet is wide enough for a mission inhabitants. the other in this particular case the other mitigating circumstance is looking at the original flat ontop of the third floor flat. it was somewhat compromised by the stairs that access it . to a degree that yes, it had double exposure but one might say it had less than full exposure on the rear wall side. that's essentially our flat. the plaque removal policy in our application with that.

>> thank you for that clarification. yes, in terms of the exposure and i think these are kind of like an interpretation of how the practice is at the planning department. so yes, that's all for me. >> thank you. i believe commissioner moore. >> i see your name before me. >> i had already been called o . >> i just wanted a few questions ontransportation policy . the double back says a king size bed is 84 incheswide. this is seven feet by 42 feet . and i question that to be a viable bedroom for a plaque. and i believe that's the interpretation that the department uses.

while it's labeled as a hallway that's fine but a substandard bedroom because you can't out of bed on the other side. i question that perhaps this commission should revisit what minimal room sizes are when you are indeed exchanging a fully viable flat that occupies the full width is now being squeezed down for more than 290 square feet to a width of seven feet by 42 feet long. i question that. those are my comments. >> i'd have staff recommendation for doctor. >> commissioner koppel. >> motion to approve with the recommendation as agreeable . >> second.

>> so we have a motion on the floor to take the r and approve with modifications as recommended by staff by commissioner koppel and seconded by commissioner dimond. commissioner ruiz. [roll call vote] >> that motion passes 6 to 1. commissioners i've been informed by mister winslow that item number 10 or 46 homestead street case number 2017 013615 erp has beenwithdrawn . so this concludesour agenda for today . >> is this record for shortest meeting ever? that was prettyshort.

thank you members of the public and thank you commissioners, this meeting is adjourned . >>

>> we have private and public gardens throughout the garden tour. all of the gardens are volunteers. the only requirement is you're willing to show your garden for a day. so we have gardens that vary from all stages of development

and all gardens, family gardens, private gardens, some of them as small as postage stamps and others pretty expansive. it's a variety -- all of the world is represented in our gardens here in the portola. >> i have been coming to the portola garden tour for the past seven or eight years ever since i learned about it because it is the most important event of the neighborhood, and the reason it is so important is because it links this neighborhood back to its history. in the early 1800s the portola was farmland. the region's flowers were grown in this neighborhood. if you wanted flowers anywhere future bay area, you would come to this area to get them. in the past decade, the area has

tried to reclaim its roots as the garden district. one of the ways it has done that is through the portola garden tour, where neighbors open their gardens open their gardens to people of san francisco so they can share that history. >> when i started meeting with the neighbors and seeing their gardens, i came up with this idea that it would be a great idea to fundraise. we started doing this as a fund-raiser. since we established it, we awarded 23 scholarships and six work projects for the students. >> the scholarship programs that we have developed in association with the portola is just a win-win-win situation all around. >> the scholarship program is important because it helps

people to be able to tin in their situation and afford to take classes. >> i was not sure how i would stay in san francisco. it is so expensive here. i prayed so i would receive enough so i could stay in san francisco and finish my school, which is fantastic, because i don't know where else i would have gone to finish. >> the scholarships make the difference between students being able to stay here in the city and take classes and having to go somewhere else. [♪♪♪] [♪♪♪] >> you come into someone's home and it's they're private and personal space. it's all about them and really their garden and in the city and urban environment, the garden is the extension of their indoor environment, their outdoor living room. >> why are you here at this garden core?

it's amazing and i volunteer here every year. this is fantastic. it's a beautiful day. you walk around and look at gardens. you meet people that love gardens. it's fantastic. >> the portola garden tour is the last saturday in september every year. mark your calendars every year. you can see us on the website

valencia has been a constantly evolving roadway. the first bike lanes were striped in 1999, and today is the major north and south bike route from the mission neighborhood extending from market to mission street. >> it is difficult to navigate lindsay on a daily basis, and more specifically, during the morning and evening commute hours. >> from 2012 to 2016, there were 260 collisions on valencia and 46 of those were between vehicles and bikes. the mayor shows great leadership and she knew of the long history of collisions and the real

necessity for safety improvements on the streets, so she actually directed m.t.a. to put a pilot of protected bike lanes from market to 15th on valencia street within four months time. [♪♪♪] >> valencia is one of the most used north south bike routes in san francisco. it has over 2100 cyclists on an average weekday. we promote bicycles for everyday transportation of the coalition. valencia is our mission -- fits our mission perfectly. our members fall 20 years ago to get the first bike lane stripes. whether you are going there for restaurants, nightlife, you know , people are commuting up and down every single day. >> i have been biking down the valencia street corridor for about a decade. during that time, i have seen the emergence of ridesharing companies.

>> we have people on bikes, we have people on bike share, scooters, we have people delivering food and we have uber taking folks to concerts at night. one of the main goals of the project was to improve the overall safety of the corridor, will also looking for opportunities to upgrade the bikeway. >> the most common collision that happens on valencia is actually due to double parking in the bike lane, specifically during, which is where a driver opens the door unexpectedly. >> we kept all the passengers -- the passenger levels out, which is the white crib that we see, we double the amount of commercial curbs that you see out here. >> most people aren't actually perking on valencia, they just need to get dropped off or pick something up. >> half of the commercial loading zones are actually after 6:00 p.m., so could be used for five-minute loading later into the evening to provide more

opportunities or passenger and commercial loading. >> the five minute loading zone may help in this situation, but they are not along the corridor where we need them to be. >> one of the most unique aspects of the valencia pilot is on the block between 14th street. >> we worked with a pretty big mix of people on valencia. >> on this lot, there are a few schools. all these different groups had concerns about the safety of students crossing the protected bikeway whether they are being dropped off or picked up in the morning or afternoon. to address those concerns, we installed concrete loading islands with railings -- railings that channel -- channeled a designated crossing plane. >> we had a lot of conversations around how do you load and unload kids in the mornings and the afternoons? >> i do like the visibility of some of the design, the safety aspects of the boarding pilot for the school.

>> we have painted continental crosswalks, as well as a yield piece which indicates a cyclist to give the right-of-way so they can cross the roadway. this is probably one of the most unique features. >> during the planning phase, the m.t.a. came out with three alternatives for the long term project. one is parking protected, which we see with the pilot, they also imagined a valencia street where we have two bike lanes next to one another against one side of the street. a two-way bikeway. the third option is a center running two-way bikeway, c. would have the two bike lanes running down the center with protection on either side. >> earlier, there weren't any enter lane designs in san francisco, but i think it will be a great opportunity for san francisco to take the lead on that do so the innovative and different, something that doesn't exist already.

>> with all three concepts for valencia's long-term improvement , there's a number of trade-offs ranging from parking, or what needs to be done at the intersection for signal infrastructure. when he think about extending this pilot or this still -- this design, there's a lot of different design challenges, as well as challenges when it comes to doing outreach and making sure that you are reaching out to everyone in the community. >> the pilot is great. it is a no-brainer. it is also a teaser for us. once a pilot ends, we have thrown back into the chaos of valencia street. >> what we're trying to do is incremental improvement along the corridor door. the pilot project is one of our first major improvements. we will do an initial valuation in the spring just to get a glimpse of what is happening out here on the roadway, and to make any adjustments to the pilot as needed. this fall, we will do a more robust evaluation. by spring of 2020, we will have recommendations about long-term improvements. >> i appreciate the pilot and how quickly it went in and was built, especially with the

community workshops associated with it, i really appreciated that opportunity to give input. >> we want to see valencia become a really welcoming and comfortable neighborhood street for everyone, all ages and abilities. there's a lot of benefits to protected bike lanes on valencia , it is not just for cyclists. we will see way more people biking, more people walking, we are just going to create a really friendly neighborhood street. [♪♪♪]

they are participating in the as if they were present. public comment available for each item on the agenda for

members who wish to make comment. our members use is 415-655-0001. the code is 24877131992. pound and pound again. when your item is called dial star 3 to speak. ure may address per item up to 2 minutes. item one. call to order. >> tsen. >> here. >> dunlap. >> here. why richardson absent. >> doctor breston. >> here. >> supervisor haney. absent. we have a quorum. thank you i help that richardson will join us shortly. i'm glad to see you here today i wanted to note that the mayor's office and the board of

supervisors have reappointed myself, richardson, breston to another term on the board and i like to say it is really is my pleasure to continue to work with linda on the commission. i know that you share my goals to have a treasure island that is sustainable. [inaudible] i think that you

shared with the rest of the board correspond over those who did not have back up power. and how we account reach out in the system. and with your appointment, we upon heap you will assist tidea to resolve the issues. thank you. >> can i. >> yes. why can you hear me. >> yes. you joined us. >> i'm trying to workup 2 things here. can you hear and see me. >> yes. >> go ahead.

>> okay. hi. julia. julia. >> yes. >> hi. >> yes. go ahead, linda. >> so again, thank you jowlia, i tried leave a message for you. i guess yesterday. but i want to echo what commissioner, it is great you know working with you. we are part of the city family. we are excited. and just like you said, we'll look to help us out with the sfpuc. you know the issues and concerns are. and again we also [inaudible] for you it it is approaching together. you will be missed burr you are just ape stone 3, way. you should be proud of your colleagues here and we will be

you know don't be surprised when we log on and share you on. on your commission. . now the puc you know is commissioned and [inaudible] for decades worked on the initial funding for the puc capitol improvement. and -- most of the colleagues [inaudible] we know each other. we are excited for you. julia. and god bless. i want to take this opportunity to congratulate a new supervisor mark dorsey who will be our colleague. great things happening in the city. god bless. julia. >> thank you. >> thank you. >> congratulations. julia. i look forward to seeing what you do on the board.

>> thank you. we can go on to the next item, please. item 2, general public comment. the item to allow the opinion to address the treasure island board on matters in the jurisdiction of the authority board and this do not appear on today's agenda. in addition, public comment will issue held during each item on the agenda. >> okay. are there people who would like to address the board? >> seeing none. >> okay. next item. >> item 3, resolution making findings teleconference meetings under code section 54953e. >> okay. so moved. >> second. am you have to take a role call

vote. >> yes. director tsen. >> aye. >> dunlop. >> aye. >> richardson. >> aye. >> souder. >> aye. >> breston. >> aye. >> next item, please. >> item 4 report by treasure island director. >> thank you. simple my camera off again. >> no it is on. >> okay. okay. getting strange messages from my laptop. thank you. and i wanted to echo everyone thanks for director souder support in participation on the board and begin our -- certainty that our paths will cross. in your new role with the puc and acknowledge -- the

appointment of matt dorsey for district 6. and i will be reaching out to his office to provide him with information on -- the treasure island program offered to the i lands. >> i wanted to acknowledge that -- derrick core doea the department -- upon general manager with the county transportation authority for capitol projects and managing the ramps projects here on treasure island is retiring from the authority. he will be continuing in the consulting role. we will have the opportunity for his continued support of the work out here while of the transportation authority looks for a new capitol deputy.

um. i like to -- ask shanti to update the programs of the ymca. >> soundses good. hello. everyone. we are actually doing well over here. at the facility. so, since the surges have calmed down we have been averaging about anywhere between 45 and 55 members in the building a day. that is good because different pandemic we had 90 to 100 guests a day. this has been the last couple weeks the highest since the pandemic hit. when we sign up on the average of 3 board members a day. of people familiar and updating our service. we have actually purchased new equipment comprehend the older

equipment we had will upon slowly getting out and new equipment in more accessible to the older age group as well as updated equipment. it has been time. . -- we are in the process and looks like starting in -- july we will go ahead and open on saturdays as limp upon since the pandemic we have been monday through friday and we search staff and a staffing plan that will allow us to support having the community the building open on saturdays for the communities. which is cool as well as just we want to start implementing in the process. we think we have -- group instructor willing to come out on saturday for yoga. is that is part of the plan of us reopening and getting back to programming we have precovid. that is what is on the facility

side. the youth side is busy. kids keep us on our feet. we started enrolling fur summer promise. now based on staffing we are planning take 60 kids and we are 42 enrolled. we are in the process of putting our names out and let the families know what we have to offer temperature is exciting this statute first time we'll go on field trips. we know the bus we are taking and take them off site. once a week for field trips like the jungle or the zoo. and we are able to start our school lessons again. one day a week for 10 weeks summer they will get swim lessons and partner with street soaker usa to get sports skill building. that is what we are doing and other things we have been involved with.

supported the parent council with their easter event. we were able to give out a bunch of eggs and candy to the community. we supportd that. we were not able to be there. we were able to join the upon spring fling and we had a table and one of the y board members would -- one of the board members -- used to work at athletic gap. and when she transitioned she was able to get donations like 10 box of clothing from yoga pants to jackets and t-shirts. we set up a tain and was able to get rid of all 10 box of coats and jackets and shirts. that was cool and we also the last thing we partnered with vouchers for veggies. they work with the store and you use the vouchers well and other

locations off site. when we started the mr. foreman january we were getting 50 vouchers. every 3 months a new cycle and went freshman 50 to 120 we have 25 vouchers left to give out t. is for the communities and going to the community. it is cool, one of the. actual recipients wrote us and told us their limp droll to get french fruit from the farmer avenue market. because we provided vouchers they were able will to get it. it was cool and we are here trying to figure out how to be a resource and showing up. >> thank you for that report. >> i will ask to give an update on activities of one treasure island. >> thank you, bob. good afternoon. before i start, i wanted to

extend a thank you and congratulations to julia and thank you for service on the board. and your support. while we were getting the backup battery thing done. i appreciate temperature thank you for that. >> my report in your packet there are a few things i would like to highlight. first is that we are recruiting for the 12th cohort. of the construction training program. beginning on june 6 through july 29th. and so, if you know anybody interested in getting in the construction field. send them our way. >> our -- tax site wrapped up in april and completed 295 tax returns for the year. we are happy. with that. the shipshape community center opened as of april first. folks are able tom come in and

access services and meet with standpoint. and we are excited about continuing to be open up for more eventses and services. let's see. the supplemental transportation work group that we are working on on meeting 3 of 6. we have 10 participates and moving along working with sf to come up with recommendations for rum elemental transportation options for treasure island. the spring fling. it was a huge success. we partnered with the parent council others y, job core. life learning academy. sailing center. united service. john stewart company. we had over twitch vendors there. island market donated approximate prizes:council held a youth photo contest.

they were able to announce the winners. the [inaudible] they were able to seat 30 residents and provide screening and dental care. free vegetables were given away. and sfpd was out well and the fire department and the san francisco book mobile provide free book. it was a great day. we were excited that parents got the art's commission attended through the parent council for summer art programming coming up this summer and face painting was a bit windy. out there but everybody stuck it out and it was a great event. >> i like to mention that our oral history project will debut on june 23rd in building one. more to come.

look for invitations. we will host an in person emergency preempt workshop on june 4, 10-4 p.m. at the shipshape community center. >> it was jill who came inside of paris. thank you. >> and that's my report. >> thank you so much. lots of things happening. great employs >> thank you. continuing with my report. we don't have a time line for resumption of in person meet pregnants. anticipate the june board meeting will be virtual. we had a significant mile stone the wiek before last. the bristol achieved the

certificate of occupancy. which is the first step toward residents moving inform we discussed, weave have 5 upon households in the process. the mercy catholic charity's building. financing was approved this past mont. and we are working to sign closing documents perhaps as soon as tomorrow. and anticipate that project breaking grounds before the end of the month. this is 138 unit building that will relocate all of the

existing catholic charity households o. island and nonincome restricted units the first transition units for what we referred to as legacy households of the villages. and on may fifth, we held a process with the support freshman mayor's office of housing and community development. to determine order in which our 164 legacy households would be offered transition units. so -- the 23 transition units represent 15% of our total number of legacy households could transition in that building. we. continue to work last mont, we had a presentation on the

preliminary statement for the first death issuance under the infrastructure revitalization and financing district. we work with the office of public finance to -- first issue the official statement and move toward that debt issuance. that work is on going. the -- nurses clinic is open -- and fullef functional in building 201, which is in the space adjacent to the island cove market. they are open 2 to 6 on tuesday. and -- also -- public works courthouse from their street repair and paint shop started a sweep of pothole repairs on treasure island as well as refreshing the crosswalks and

red zones in the residential neighborhood. late program spur had a group of people come out for an event to ride the ferry out to the island expect walk up to yearna bane an to give an over view of the status of construction and the new dog park completed. 2 hours on may second on yerba buena island from a branch going on power lines. we will review whether we should

do street pruning to protect those. but we are getting close to most of the over headlines on yerba buena island becoming redundzant as we theoryingize the under ground facilities.ant as we theoryingize the under ground facilities.dant as we theoryingize the under ground uant as we theoryingize the under ground facilities.nant as we theoryingize the under ground facilities.dant as we theoryingize the under ground facilities. upon it is a -- one of the things we have been working toward with installation of -- lane closures and other equipment to ensure that outageers limited to the area of impact and don't result in the island white outages. and that concludes my report.rst

and don't result in the island white outages and that concludes my report.ou impact and don't result in the island white outages and that concludes my report.li and don't result in the island white outages and that concludes my report. i am open it up to the board. >> mike? >> i wanted to thank you for your continuing work on the electric and power issues. i know you are working hard on it. i think that slowly showing up. thank you. and -- secondly, i wanted to talk about the lottery. i have been getting a ton of calls about the lottery and people really upset about it. you know them is not the time to discuss temperature i hope may be we could put it on the agenda next month. >> yes, we can put it on the future agenda. yes. we can do that. >> thank you. >> okay. >> julia. i see your hand up.

>> thank you. and i want to thank you for the update and thank you for working with all of and you appreciate all the work you have been doing. also.ed ask about there was an article about -- oil being dropped on the island. bob do you know more about this? >> yes. i apologize i intended include that when i edited it it slipped my minds. this incident occurred i believe more than 2 years ago at this point. >> a contractor doing work in the city. brought soil -- not oil but soil. to the island. and -- just dumped it.

>> on the island. we were in the process of evaluating a couple of piles that had been dumped when a trucker showed up with another load. to dump in addition to the material that had been dumped. we were able to identify the. haller in question. and they identified the contractor they were working for. who instructed them to bring material here and we are thankful for the city attorney -- because there is environmental clean up on the island and subject to state oversight and with the d. toxic

substance control, we were. needed to test that material to be sure it was not contaminated. it was not moved elsewhere were clean up is on going. and upon even based on the conversations with the haller identified that -- came from off island we had to character it. we had costs to store the material. we put it in upon containers and stored off site while we waited for laboratory results to come back. so -- we did incure 2 huh human thousand dollars in costs. now they are seeking recovery of

those funds. >> good. thank you very much for that update. that was great and appreciate the work you are doing to help with the power lines and the challenges that are happening and look forward to working more with you. >> thank you. >> i see you have a hand snup go ahead. >> what date does the [inaudible] do you know, when -- what was the time? i can confirm the exact date i believe more than 2 years ago at this point. it was dumped near building 99, which is am close to fifth street between m & h. and -- okay. kind of -- it is the area where we have a lot of vacant

buildings. i'm curious if this happened before. how do we check in th we have enough going on. >> yea. illegal dumping is -- a problem throughout san francisco. and -- we you see it sometimes, it is on a smaller scale. last week i saw a dozen garbage bags dropped behind the fire

training academy. when that occurs, you know, we. --. . work with the property managers and we dispose of that material. oceanally we are able to find identifying information includes the household garbage they are dumping. this is the first time we had something on your scale. 3 truck loads were dumped part of this situation. we are already working with on the island seeps like we need to put more extra that this would happen 3 truck loads and come while there were people on site.

to do it again that is bold. i wanted to go back to the lottery. you said the ranking on may fifth. and the listed the 43 number that is a third of the eligible. >> we have in total 164 -- legacy households. and -- in transition. >> that are entitled to transition units. and building c3.1 will have 23 units. which is -- enough for 15% of those 164 households. >> so -- is that 15% total or is this just because the way the lot row is set up is available upon to -- this property first.

so, is that just villages. 23? and then the rest is everyone else? i'm trying to understand. >> so were, again. right now we are speaking about the eligibility for villages households who were here prior to 2011. to receive of a transition rental unit on the island. these are nonincome restricted newly constructed united. building 33.1 will have 23 units. we conducted a ranking to determine which would be the first offered those transition units. there are in addition 43 -- income restricted units in the

building that will be available to any -- qualified afford willable housing residents. photocopy someone lives in the villages, and meets the income requirements, they will enter in the mayor's office of housing and community development lot row for those 43 units and they would receive priority over any other residents that don't live on the island. they would have first opportunity at the 43 units. >> and has that been offered? have the 43 units been offered, were they have offered in the lot reel or the up something sfwhon >> that lottery will not happen approximately until latest 2023. at this point. we -- again. that building is only just

getting ready to break ground this mont t. is 2 years away from occupancy. the processes of units or the lot real come closer to the completion of construction. >> okay. and then mire last question upon this will lot row will they be the people when enter in the once eligible the 43, will they entered in a lot row with the rest of san francisco? or is it a lottery [inaudible]. >> the 43 units in the building will be offered brud low in a single lottery. anyone who is a resident as a treasure island preference number will mean when the lottery is conducted, they will be moved to the top.

kidnap resident who registers will receive an offer before anybody living elsewhere in san francisco. >> okay. >> i guess i agree with mark it would be good to put this from the things can be discussed. thank you, i appreciate you take the time. >> sure. >> see. who -- linda? linda. and then mark. >> yea. >> thank you. just to log in i'm using 2 device here. >> a quick question for you. with regards to the dumping do we have cameras in the your and how is someone able tom dump 3 loads of sand and before the

disposal [inaudible]. that is number one. then i have question -- regarding the lotto. you can -- respond for me. this was a mile stone. the first lot row we had and the applicants approximate will go through the under writing process to qualify ump win a lotto in the process if then they am [inaudible] the material

was tested. do we know? >> we don't, tida does not have cameras on the island. the only place where we have cameras are within will facilities where we are monitoring for po serb break in's and so forth. various commercial tenants do have cam ares and have been instances where pd and tida have been able to obtain information from the cameras that commercial tenants have. yes. they come through the bay bridge. the truck load is bold and criminal. admissible when we say here is

to trying to be aware and trying to make sure this does not happen again if it does we have measures in place we can go over and prosecute. that's what i'm trying to get in here. to get to the island there are cameras. you know whoever is managing -- anyone. that is just that and prevention we can talk more. but quickly on the lotto we can move on the agenda y. and to clarify. there is lot reese like the dolly lottery for bristol. and the lottery held for the bristol -- is -- the households that were successful in that lottery then we need to go through the process of -- you

know -- having the [inaudible] approved for the purchase of the units. and we have 5 households that are involved in that. i want to be clear the legacy ranking is nots the same type of lottery. we wanted to rank -- the upon 164 households so that in the future as transition units become available we valid a list that we can go through to determine who would first be offered a transition unit based on their the size available. and the replacement unit entitlement of the ranked households we don't consider it a lottery. and try not to use that word because it creates confusion. with the mohcd lottery process.

but it was a randomized ranking of the 164 households to determine in order. >> for me. >> yea. >> good ahead. >> yes, and i than we have a housing on the agenda. yes and as long as this is well explained to the residents. thank you, bob and we have a housing, i know we cannot spur the question yet we need that on the agenda. thank you. >> mark. jot last question. what was it think we could do it had they i know they think the island was a dump or what? i'm just curious about that. >> yea. i am prior i worked with the d.

public works. and their operations burroughs. and including the d. public works bureau and um -- the people who engage in this activity look for places where they believe can do something observes. where oorm00 there is not arc left activity. and so -- that probably made them assume they could get away with it. i have seenin other locations throughout the city. even had someone dump a load of construction debris up at the top of twin peeks. when i was with public works.

so, even though -- know -- the cost appropriately disposing of materials. is not a lot there are people who will kooek seek opportunity to cut corners. >> specialing that they can get a criminal charge against? if caught, yea. that's why they need cameras. there are types of materials that i think lends themselves more torcriminal charges. hazardous materials. and i believe there are also -- thresholds from cost that could lead to criminal charges. that it is not my area of

expertise. prohibited. >> we need to move on to the agenda. so -- if i don't see any other hands. we will go with public comment on this agenda item? >> there is no public upon comment. >> okay. >> let's move on to the next item. >> item 5 communications by tida. are there comments by board members on the communications? >> okay. >> seeing 91. public comment? no public comment. >> next item. >> item 6 on going business by the board of director it is. why du want to pinpoint other than what is on our log? if not, next item >> next 7 consent agenda of 7a

approving the minutes of the april 13th 2022 meeting. >> moved. >> second. >> >> no public comment. director tsen. aye. >> dunlop. >> aye. >> richardson. >> aye. >> souder. >> aye. >> breston. >> aye. >> there are 5 aye's. >> thank you. next item. >> item 8. placing recommendations for treasure island parks. >> i think roland from cmg will present on this matter. >> go ahead. >> okay. great. i will pull up my screen here. and while we are doing that. let neil say i got to bail bond she has been [inaudible] tours of the new bioretention garden.

we have on treasure island. [inaudible] they are now up and planted. and it is wonderful to see. that infrastructure can also be a nice walking path, bicycling path it is part of the public parks and realm that we have. thank you, lauren and i will turn it over to you. >> thank you. >> good afternoon. thank you for having me. i'm lauren stall i'm with cmg aushth. the lead aushths on treasure island. and i'm here today to present proposals for the first phase of parks in major phase combon to hear your thoughts on them. these were developed with tida staff. there is a group of people involved in developing the names

i'm lucky here to present them to you. other schedule. the construction. first treasure lieshg andz parks began early 30 year. we broke ground a mont ago and last knowledge not i took the main frameless to the tida cap and reviewed those with that group. and today i'm here torpresent to you all. and then we hope to come back and take the feedback from you and the feedback from the cab and go back and make revisions necessary and come back later this year for approval. and then in the first half of next year the first parks will welcome [inaudible]. we have gone through 2 other exercises now on treasure lieshgs land the first for the streets and that was they're inspired by the golden gate

expedition. there were people like antonio and johnson as well as a lot of the place named throughout the expedition honored part of the street naming. >> here is a diagram of the proposed treasure island names. there are different themes the names on the core the history of the san francisco avenue first airport. there are a few references within that core. and the other names are more reflective of the character or defining features the others vary a bit. when will we presented these.

we got a few comments one about quick are mraz as, they are on the list today and there is concern it may cause confusion. a comment the names were too literal. and then also a debate over the proper mother common an s or not. -- we will take that as well as other comments we receive and revise these as necessary before we come back to you. looked through each one individually for you. the first is treasure island landing. on each you see a proposed name and the name that we have in used for the places throughout the process. treasure island landing is proposed name for the waterfront plaza where the ferry terminal is on the western side of the

island. and are this name the landing is a reference to the aeronautical path. landing would be merry time term. as the lands here and the first place passengers will come on to the island it is the gateway. we felt that name was upon pro for this space. across the street is the building one plaza for that we proposed transpacific plaza. this again is a name that represents the past and future of the space. pan amthe airline made the first flight in 1935 and built the terminal and air control tower at that time for that airport. >> final mrazal include sculptors from the golden gate

expedition. the name is both a reference to the first historic flights and a nod to the cultures. >> behind building one clipper [inaudible] plaza. in the past it was the marina plaza. this space organisms up and steps down from the back of the building toward the cove and the marina. and so the marina is just behind off camera. and this place will have great views in the connection of the cove. name was appropriate here. >> the next space is in front of the left side of building 2 and the pan am grove. would approximatem building 2 it is former hanger.

it was the hall of air transportation during the golden gate exhi bigz. a grove of olive trolls that date become to the time of the expedition was transplanted and planted in the grove here that will form the frame the event row in the building. am you see a bit in the upon rendzerring it has a sculptor the spirit transportation. the name pan am grove the path with the hanger and future of the space as a grove. between buildingers 2 and 3, we proposed lean thanksgiving space the hanger yard this . is a mixed use basech it is designeded to hold farmer's markets here and are can be used daily as a parking lot and this is more u till tearian thanes

other spots. we thought it has an industrial -- more characters. you know we felt like hang are yard was promote. this sell clipper cove promenade. the features are the linear path way per pedestrians and bikes and elements along as well as people can stop and enjoy the cove. we felt like because of this you see the cove and the. useace the way it moves up and down we felt like clipper cove suited the space.

>> and moving north, site of the chap and he will for this one chapel green. if the chap cell a world war ii chapel retain exclude repurposed for function. the chapel will be organism and trees and it will sit in a park like setting. chapel green was a fit. >> on the western side. we decided over proposing we would maintain the name. city side park. some of the features of the park is that it in the western side. it is the first phase of it will be 2 blocks. it will issue half a mile long park on the western span of of

the island. at night the lights will be dpra update there and you can have a dramatic climate and winds. we felt the name was descriptive of the location and the exposure of the park. next is the common the official name will be just the common. and this space is a 6 block long park. each has a different use. spaces for picnic. garden space. play ground and dog park tell include the first 3 blocks of this park. >> park between several residential buildings. it is ment to be a shared space

for the residence debtses a place where is they can enjoy the different space. we felt like the common was appropriate for all of them to enjoy. finally is pier one park. this is the triangular space at the land side of pier one. and this space is right adjacent to pier one built by the navy in the 80s and will be intgreated open to the public part of the open space system. we anticipate once that pier is open tell be a major attraction. tell be the reason why people upon go there. we felt it was the main draw for that space. and major phase twhonl peeves park that will be built next to the pier includes picnic space. open lawns and then you see

great views of yerba buena i lan. this because adjacent to the pier we proposed pier 1 park. >> those other names in the first phase of the parks. i will leave this up and open up to comments and questions. >> thank you. i'm glad you are moving on and it will see that these parks are coming in to frusxigz when you name them becomes places. and i can see also that in the future there may be mainly opportunity [inaudible] places to raise money for the operations and make them guard pens. thank you very much for that and i will open it to the board exit see someone would like to speak. >> thank you. >> lauren for the update.

and i than -- are you aware again i want to raise the issue for the port of chicago. you know -- of the were recent findings and while we are talking and i want to make sure we have an idea where we are going to make that naming the recognition for that. are you aware? of the recent finding? >> i didn't hear about findings but we are i than hud sdpien landscape architect is designing the infinity point. will working with the museum to develop signs about the port chicago. [inaudible] i know, i don't think there are updates but that process is on going. >> yes, please. i want to make sure everything all of the parks are on the same page of yes. it is a high priority and now

every time we talk about -- the were conventions and location i would like to the point out that to [inaudible]. thank you. thank you. are there other are board member. >> yes. >> yes. >> mark. go ahead. >> i would like to endorse our director richardson's comment about port chicago. may be like the pier one which is a bland name could be port chicago and appreciate you are going to be -- in the future mentioning that and again. also the -- and mentioning african-american heros.

remembered in streets or -- whatever. thank you. >> thank you. >> any other board members? >> yes. >> i wanted to echo the same sentiments i did not realize it would be an electron to the 1930s through 40s. it seems like. where i can appreciate the historic value. yes. the names are bland and -- i don't think anybody living here on the island would really connect with anything that was presented like as far as beyond the treasure i lands landing.

nooim agreement that was no mention of port chicago. and that there will be an honorary mention is absurd why would we not the pier. makes sense to me. so i would like to see -- of some different were inventive names and more to the may be. the concern residents and you know. atmosphere is dictating we see more of that. >> and -- i think that the next time you present -- review walter hood's design for the top of yerba buena. and i believe there is going to be a tribute to port chicago and

information and education. for that port. so -- perhaps we can have a reminder of that and had has not been forgotten. it is incorporated in the very hive park on yerba buena. that's my understanding. >> g. other comments? so. hearing none we have have there public upon comment combrchlt no public comment. scombro okay. >> thank you very much, lauren for the presentation. >> and -- look forward to the

parks being developed and compriested. that is open to the public. >> and it is really important aspect. over all plan. treasure island. thank you very much. >> we gallon to the next item. >> item 9. resolution approving authorizing it is execution of the third amendment to professional services agreement with tida and associated right-of-way services of california corporation provide consulting and services and implementing the transification housing roles and for the development project. to extend the term. and increase the contract amount. question about your

presentation. there are 2 figures here. you need to reconcile what the amount is. we have 21 is like 2575. where is that posted? >> could you address that. >> we had 2120 now 2575. am i looking at the same agenda. >> had should 2120. why we >> go ahead. i'm trying to pull update agenda to see if -- i think00 oop the agenda was not edited to match the final if -- >> that is the. [inaudible] amendment the next item the amount for that.

>> 2120. >> item 9 which is the contract with the rws. 2 million 120,000. item 10 is lange and engineering for 2 million, 750,000. >> okay. >> go ahead. people seeing my screen yet. >> not yet. we -- the original agreement for 5 years. we are now coming to the end of that 5 years. >> you said with langeon. we are talking about the

[inaudible]. >> i'm sorry. we are talking about arws. our agreement with arws was originally for 5 years and we are coming on the end of that 5 years. we have had 2 prior amendments to adjust the budget. today we are seeking an amendment to extend it for an additional 6 months. and to which increase the budget. had been our infengz to put out a request for qualifications. for continuation of this type of service. due to a number of, we, that issuance of that was delayed. -- were arws is the second firm we had support being tida in this area. we had prior agreement with pair

gone support in 2011 and 2017. and then we issued the rfp that we have award to arws. the role that arws has been performing again is specific to the transition benefits that were adopted for residents of the villages on treasure island the market rate housing. and includes the describing and explaining the applicable eligibility >> reporter:s and the specific transition benefits that are available to those households. and advising households in evaluating their current housing needs and future housing options. and assisting in completing

applications for transition benefits including a transition unit. pursuit affordable unit or the payment benefit option. upon kwoens are high. and end you. requiring a let of repair w. to correct the approximate understanding. we have throughout the life of

the condition tract w in rerowelling and resunrising materials to make sure they are clear. also, when we had in person events. we thought to provide ample staffing. designing the events to be interactive with multiple tables on topics and adequate staff for residentses to provide ready access to residents for questions and conversations. and were toy schedule follow up sessions. and also accounting for language needs. this shows the left contract. the amount invoice monthly with some of the activities that

have -- related to higher levels of work. and billing. in the 2017 and 18 time frame. the period where we -- we -- attempted to reach every individual household. within the villages to -- verify their current occupancy and notice them of their potential eligibility that included setting up an on island office so people can drop in for sessions. and a level period with less are activity and we upon in 2019, we made the early in lieu available to residents and that if stimulated a level for a federal of time. and in december of 2019, we

modified the transition housing rules and regulations to provide priority for post households -- to be prioritized for new affordable housing on the i lands and did a period of time out reach about that -- in 2020 it we it set up the online portal. where -- residents have access to the communications that have been sent to their house. whether dover hangers or e mails or direct mail. all of those communications are summarized on the portal. and then -- we had 2 prior amendments to address the budget in between december of 2020 and february of 20 upon 21.

on may fifth weed had a bit of a ramp up in the level of contract activity. appropriating if that are sxevent responding to questions following the event. in terms of population of what we referred to legacy households. that are eligible for units includes the 164 households. 97 upon households and 67 [inaudible] mixed households. we have 146 post. households. . that again are priorityized for potential future affordable. housing units. >> and -- the -- residents of

each type that -- could qualify for inclusionary units. supports tida. and in our out reach activities these other highlights of activities from this year including the will upon ranking and00 autoprogram development and out reach that went enemy that. and now that is concluded, engaging with the households that are more the top to discuss it is future housing options. and -- then we move in 2023, that's there will be this point we will have this will be beyond the current term of the concern

contract. but the rfq we are preparing, i wanted have you a sense of what will be coming up in 2023 and beyond. so there will be efforts to maintain communications with villages households. butt real activity here sorry to ramp up community engage am around the construction of the of new catholic charityy mersef bodiesing and transition units that are available in that building. we will first have a window where peopleing to move from the villages. inform this building or the opportunity to volunteer and we will utilize the. household ranking to -- offer any remaining units to households based on their rank

order. during the same time, i will have a couple minutes there will be a number of market rate households with inclusionary affordable units that are constructed. and opportunity for people to volunteer for pursue through the lot realty inclusionary rental and condo for sale units. just a word about the housing relocation opportunities. we will develop 20 separate sites with authority affordable units and in the process, we will developing inclusionary units. the parse elf will have some inclusionary and the next building we have inclusionary units will not be completed

until the 2026 time frame. there are the first 23 to deal with then a gab ofave couple years before transition units will issue available. this shoes all of the development that is happening on the island in the next 2-3 years. and there will is the of the 23 am transition units within the and we mentioned the 43 general affordable in the building. the these 23 will be for -- um -- residents. villages here prior to 2011. where as the 43 units will be any income qualifying of the villages regardless of whf they

move to the island would be prioritized. . we have cond osi including the 14 that are in the bristol. 5 households are going throughout process purchasing. as additional coloneledose become available we hope to see a greater percentage pursued by current residents. and went market rate affordable rental buildings. there will being an additional 39 affordable rentals that will be available toef residents regardless of the move in date. just a -- begin a highlight on spotlight on -- the mersef

catholic charity's building the 23 units you seat mix. bedroom sizes available inspect that building. each household this will be a very unique and personal decision. . inclusionary for sale households making 80-125% of ami inclusionary 60% and affordable units like the 43 within the catholic charity's building range 40 to 80% of ami.

and00 oop final affordability will be dictated by funding and operating requirements of each building. to give you a sense of what we understand about our 164 legacy households from a household/income perspective. we do approximate our understanding that -- 17% of them -- gnaw the 80-120% ami. and -- area -- where they -- could be eligible for -- inclusionary for sali nit and a quarter of them fall under 80% fall under to rental affordable.

and another upon 19% are section 8 voucher hold ands we vessel a quarter that did not provide household information. the household is unchanged since 20 level in terms of size and no. member vice president. they will be eligible the same sides as existing and reasoned will be tied to the current rent with adjustments for utilities and factors. if they are required pay directly in their new unit --

where their rent includes utilities the rent new unit decreased to recognized the would not be responsible for the utility bills. and if -- the number of household members decreased it is household offered a transition unit with 1 bathroom per eligible member. the affordable -- housing unist weather inclusionary or within an authority building like the catholic charities building the rent and total housing cost is based on the household income. and bedroom count based on the

number of members in the household. its in the necessarily people be comparris decisions of differents unit sizes and rents and -- it is not necessary low a straightforward choice. to pursue one option or the other. >> and choogs an affordable i mentioned. the number of bedrooms could differ the upon rent could differ. and then we have the fact this we have --ure know, many households out here are roommate situations. or -- multigenerational situations. have additional issues to consider in their transition

options. the replacement housing will be different. generally, the new units will not be small are than navy units and will not have the same amenities. in unit laundry -- guaranteed parking. et cetera . we are responsible for provides services to impelement the transition regulationless. and -- we have relied upon consultants in fulfilling the

obligations. advising residents of rights and the marketing opportunity. and guiding residents let you upon inclusionary housing process and the upon low market rate for sale. mohcd assists in implementation of the unit development. and the affordable how doing place ams. including free development and construction financing. and administration of the marketing plan. lotteries and the housing priorities and preference. and -- then on going -- monitoring and asset management for the completed buildings. the individual developers work

with residents after upon mo completed the lottery process. the complete income certification and leases. and they will work withful mayor's office of housing and tida as they vacancies are available in the future. the amendment we have before you today. is extend the tefrment agreement by 6 months. and increase the contract authority by 120 thousand dollars for those remaining 7 months. and again. approximate as i mentioned, staff are working to finalize the scope of qualifications or the scope for request

qualifications. . as soon as possible so we can advertise that. and select a candidate -- at the earliest date with the intention that process completed and any there be a period of time if necessary for transfer of knowledge and experience between arws and a new selected candidate. with that i am happy to take questions that you may have on the amendment. >> okay. >> thank you. >> bob. i know it it is upon a -- [inaudible]. yes. let me say that this is complex because the housing choices are complex and communication and information to the house holdses about the rights is very important. important to guest that

information correctly. and so i do believe that [inaudible] this is to support the tida staff is important. you know the affordable housing will take the time to develop. we now got 1 that is really were aimed at the mersef housing is coming on board. the others will be down the line and, lot of that is department on local state and federal subcylinderis for affordable housing. so tell take time for all of the housing to be built. and people have to take that in consideration. am some would decide to leave and take the payment and some decide they will stay until all of the housing is made available. but it is a complex choice.

i would like to say for one, i believe that we. do need to have the service. communication to the residents is important. and we need to support that ability to get information out there. i support it. only with the idea that -- in 6 mont's time. that is the end of the 5 year contract. we will have an rfp out and arwa may be a candidate there may be other firms that will propose on the services to be offered. but that we will do. at the end of sick month months. this is purely an amendment to continuance for another 6 months. and the amount is 120,000 that is what is borrow us today.

now i will take comments. i will let mark start he had his hand up and then linda. thank you. >> thank you. i really appreciate your explanations, bob and the hard work you put out agree that this needs to be passed. it did raise a couple questions, which i think will be discussing next month when we talk about the of lottery. but i had my understanding is lottery if you your number -- this makes it simple. if your number come up, you have to take the unit available or take the cash and go. sell that correct? >> the transition housing rules as written do say that when item

makes a transition unit available that at this pin in time, the household does need elect to take that unit or take the payment. and move out of their existing unit. i understand there have been a number of questions from residents about that. but the under loyaling premise is that the opportunity to continue to be on the island in a new unit is the promise that was made. in the thr and r. and when we make that unit available to people, they have have the opportunity to elect to take that or not. the inlieu payment is the alternative. that is the way the transition

housing rules are written. >> nobody can pass. on it and get another opportunity later on? >> it is a point in time decision as written. >> okay. thank you, bob. >> yea. >> linda, i see you got your hand up? >> thank you very much, break beck and for people may be not logging on and hear thanksgiving this should be a [inaudible] that this process started in 2011. and so -- from the tida standpoint i know we have not only met the obligationless and exceeding them by continuing to make sure that this matters stay on the radar >> because we are obligated to

make sure it does happen. a similar question for someone -- we have a lot of documentations. i like to just help us to break thicks down at some point may be not at this i prefer a lot of times i suggested that may be we have an upon spreadsheet and all the supporting materials are great. i can inform how that should be presented. so at any point if someone asked us from the city family or residents, we look at this spreadsheet and say, you know, this is the universe. household and add-on all this other categories. why am i saying this? so at any time we have a stamp of where we are. so -- work with you the rest of

that to propose that. it is right and it is true by mail all the households are identified. since 2011. if someone were to ask that question the answer will be, yes. right? >> i think that we have conducted the first mile stone for the legacy of ranking and that is to report that you presented. . we did. and we know we have a window 2074 when some of the units will come. my. question in your presentation has to do with income qualification. you mentioned people self reported. at what point do we get concrete data where you look at it and the specific household and you

have data because -- it is moving along now. society [inaudible] reported is close to the actual for their certification. . i think that will be important. i will go with this extension so we can move -- this matter forward. because of our commitment. and i'm glad that we brought in this -- i will talk about that a lot of times they have expertise in the administration and marketing and administration was lotteries. housing, priorities and they manage all preferences that are more complicated. than the preference we have on treasure island. what we are doing the end of the day that san francisco, has done for public housing, [inaudible] am and there are a lot of

[inaudible] on what is already the -- in the report. i think arc legalities of the issues and questions we can discuss habut again, i would be glad to endorse we keep a progress. going instead mrachls so. suggestion. thank you. >> thank you, lindza. other directors sns i don't see you all. if you do. hearing no other questions. by directorses we open up to public comment. >> i'm sorry. i'm having trouble with my computer. i did have a question. i was looking over the out reach it went to january but did not

seat out reach for 2021. so, i would like to just will we westbound aware how will out reach is going? i'm not sure who will do the contract with. this some when we are talk about. . of how the out reach will be conducted or will it be up to the whoever they consult with. as a resident and looking how the out reach was done amongst some of, during the lottery. and in different eventses that has been my thing with the i know land. points of contact and efforts and how we want to do it. what we want to see after. it is going the way it it is

exposed to. this is a really complex situation. we want to make it clear and easy. and to be clear, all of the out reach efforts are guided and -- and -- authorized by tida staff. you know. the advisors are there -- every day to take phone calls and respond to e mails inquiries. and hold one on one sessions. but any time that there is any form of mass communication going

out. and any time we hold an in person or virtual out reach event. tida staff are closely involved in shaping those eventses and the communication materials that are used in association with the events. so, yea.communication materialse used in association with the events. so, yea. attempt through our updates to -- advise the board of upcoming events. et cetera this is per of the director's report section of the month low agenda, does reflect only the concern calendar year. but we were doing that as well

in 2021. but -- perhaps we could do that on a rolling 12 month base i rather than the current calendar year vment >> yea. >> also i think good to utilize and i'm not sure i will not i don't know if this is the upon promote time. it would be good on utilize the groups i know we use a lot of -- it is agencies, focus groups. good to use groups that are close to -- the situation. as to close to redevelopment situations that are close to mixed communities situations and mixed houseings situations. often we come across you know and i -- have not had the opportunity, i don't live with villages i have not had an opportunity to work with add viseors. living on the island and the focus group from the tell to the

fer and he everything else, is nice to have someone am familiar to speak to you. il keep this in minds as we navigate this. you know we want the community to feel included in things that are going of might be good to have a familiar face and a familiar store whoa is getting the information out to people and seek information. . thank you. thank you. anybody else. so -- i make a motion. okay. we have a motion. excuse me before we do that. public comment. please. are there public comments? there is no public comment. >> okay. >> we'll have a motion and second, please. >> motion moved. second. and we have a second? >> second. >> okay.

>> so we will do this by roll call. director tsen. >> aye. >> director dunlop. >> aye. why director richardson. >> aye. why director souder. >> aye. >> director breston. >> aye. >> there are 5 aye's. >> thank you. we will go to the next item. >> item 10 resolution authorizing the treasure island director to execute an amendment agreement with tida and lan lon for environmental oversight of the navy remediation for the development project. increasing the agreement to 2 million 575 thousand dollars. >> go ahead. >> thank you. >> i don't have a presentation for this item i had a slide i was going to put up.

and of background for the discussion. >> the current term of the agreement is upon through also the end of this calendar year. and we -- this last year, our -- costs have exceeded our anticipated expenditures in part due to additional responsibilities that come with the transfer of land. but also in part due to expansion of the navy's scope of the navy's -- investigations on the island. as i mentioned in prior ft. meetings navy has begun process

of investigating -- for a class of chemicals -- called t foss. this is a type that is used in a number of industrial applications from teflon to scotch guard fabric coatings. related to the island is a chemical used in the foams that are used in firefighting applications. . so a chemical used at the site of the old fire training academy. all robin's egg blue 6. this is where the fire training used to be located prior to the construction of the current academy. but it is also a chemical that was stored in a number of

locations. adjacent to hanger 3. and has been having month low meetings to -- evaluate and look for the presence of that class of chemicals. we have a number of -- land use controls. in site 27, the part of the remedy was the construction of an armored rock bottom on the went cove.

every 5 years we need to reinspect that. there are monitoring well in site 21 and 24 that need to be protected and -- side. looking for an increase in budget for the remain happening 7 months of this contract. this cop tract was originally awarded in 2013. so we are coming up on almost 10 years of services upon at the time it was awarded anticipated

the navy would be completing the work the this time example preparing to winds down their program. unfortunately, the navy has not stuck to that schedule. and -- so we are -- in a position we node to think about a continuation of vipiral services beyond the current contract. i would like to have i future conversation with the board putting this contract out for proposals. because of the knowledge and familiarity with the navy programs that has been developed over the past decade. whether we might want to consider a sole source request through the civil service commission and the monitoring

division. that will be a future conversation but today we are looking for authorization budget authorization for the remaining 7 months. >> thank you. >> i think that -- they really have no choice. but to extend this contract because they. monitoring in terms of we need that independent monitoring. >> we need that specialized expertise. in reviewing the plan and forwarded by the navy. and as well as we need to have

an on going need for environmental services related to the lands use controls that we are required to monitor over time. >> yes. >> so. i am in support. i will open up for the board for questions. go ahead. >> thank you. the question i want to lanlan was the old and it is one of few engineering companies and environmental companies. they do have proven expertise dp integrity. the question i wanted support this. i think we don't have a choice. number two. because of the we spending more now because if we were to compare you mentioned the deliver. the time lines we had before is

may be a bit off. clean up is this then adding to the cost of providing the work -- how do you see that. certainly -- as the navy has been pursuing their remediation efforts. they wing with the d. toxic substances control and the california department of public health. they have initiated studies and reports and documents all of which. -- require -- of you know our review and comment -- which has been instrumental in providing comment to. and just -- you know the program

has -- has a. there are mnth low. we have 3 separate monthly meetings with the navy and regulators. one on the program at large. one specific to the navy's radio logical clean up and one to the investigation. well is staff time and cost incured in the process of -- -- supporting the all of the on

going dialogue. and -- the individual -- reports this are issued. >> okay. so. yes. basically -- for tida obligation the er and the clean up is on us. having an expert in place. we are meeting that obligation. that's what is this is about and that's comforting. you know when we are asked how we are going about this clone up. we have our consultant that [inaudible] we have the state regulators that are working along with this. and we are fulfilling the obligation continuing to retain our expertise that we are being guided by. before -- [inaudible] and think this is what it is. and i believe that [inaudible] is again one of the foremost

engineering companies anywhere and familiar with base of clean up in san francisco. in all the region. with that, i would support this. >> amendment. >> thank you. linda. are there other questions? comments by director? >> okay. i see no other comments we open up for public comment. there are public comments? no public comment. >> okay. could i have motion and he could? i will move it. >> okay. mark. second? >> second. >> we will have a roll call on the vote. director tsen. >> aye. >> director dunlop. >> yes. >> director richardson. >> aye. >> director souder.

>> yes. >> director breston. >> yes. >> there are 5 aye's. >> thank you very much. on this item and we go to the next. item 11 review of issues log and discussion of future items by directors. >> okay. directors, do you have any issues that you wanted to bring up at this point in time? no issues for me. when is the next it c meeting? >> the n it c meeting will be next tuesday. the the 17th. and i did note that there were discussions today of an update on the hill to which park and you want on the legacy ranking we will work those in the future agenda says. >> yes. >> thank you. >> mark? >> no. thank you.

>> i wanted bring up may be we had if you this dumping on future agendas to address that you know we got safe guard novembers accomplice to make sure this does in the happen again that is a hefty bill. we will provide an update on that may be -- yea. i will -- i will -- sum rise the event and look at doing an update at a future meeting. >> yes. >> thank you. >> and then anybody else? any public comment? there is in public comment. >> i think we can adjourn and bid farewell to julia. thank you for your time. >> i'm sure we will meet.

take care. >> thank you. >> goodbye, julia. good working with you. >> thank you. >> with safe. >> thank you all. >> bye. adjourned. >> shop & dine in the 49 promotes local businesses and challenges residents to do their shop & dine in the 49 with within the 49 square miles of san francisco by supporting local services within the neighborhood we help san francisco remain unique

successful and vibrant so where will you shop & dine in the 49 my name is jim woods i'm the founder of woods beer company and the proprietor of woods copy k open 2 henry adams what makes us unique is that we're reintegrated brooeg the beer and serving that cross the table people are sitting next to the xurpz drinking alongside we're having a lot of ingredient that get there's a lot to do the district of retail shop having that really close connection with the consumer allows us to do exciting things we decided to come to treasure island because we saw it as an amazing opportunity can't be beat the views and real estate that great county starting to develop on treasure island like minded business owners with last week products and want to get on

the ground floor a no-brainer for us when you you, you buying local goods made locally our supporting small business those are not created an, an sprinkle scale with all the machines and one person procreating them people are making them by hand as a result more interesting and can't get that of minor or anywhere else and san francisco a hot bed for local manufacturing in support that is what keeps your city vibrant we'll make a compelling place to live and visit i think that local business is the lifeblood of san francisco and a vibrant community [♪♪]

fisherman's wharf, this is a working wharf and it's part of the beauty of the san francisco area. >> before the restaurant, before the t-shirt shops. >> at first the fishermen would go out and do the harvesting. they process the crab. >> it really is industrial. it is fish processors. >> it's a working, living, breathing place. and it's a great place to visit and there's a lot of history. >> i'm a third generation italian fisherman. we're one of the oldest fishing families at fishermen's wharf. my family's been working here since 1908. my boat's called the lovely martha. sport fishing means when you come out and catch your own fish on the boat.

commercial fishermen come out, catch fish, it gets processed and they sell it to a store. they're selling crab off the boat. there's nothing more fresh than a crab. our crab are sweeter and better tasting. the meat is firmer. >> more crab. >> we love crab. we love the people out on the boats. they're awesome. >> what a good meal tonight. >> we just barely got down here in time. we would have come earlier if we knew how much fun it was. >> this is the place to get crab if you're looking for it. >> some of these boats have salmon permits. so every boat kind of does a different thing. you can come down here and have wild caught salmon that was just caught that morning or the night before and there's nothing fresher than that. >> that's the whole thing of coming out on a party boat. you can catch your own crab, lock cod, halibut, salmon, you can't get that kind of fish. >> now the consumer can just buy here if they want to and

take it home which is great. or they can buy it here and take it to one of the restaurants and they can have a glass of wine and enjoy the crab we just brought in for them. >> come on over. it's great. nice and beautiful here in san francisco and the port. definitely come. >> our fishermen are super excited. it's great to have the public come down here and interact. >> it's a whole experience for the family, where they bring the kids and interact and say wow, the crab's alive. it's going to claw me and everything. >> they really get excited they're coming down here and posting their recipes or pictures of the food. or their kids picking up the crab. they're making a whole experience out of it. >> it is going to give the locals a part of san francisco that was taken away from them. >> now i have a reason to come back. >> i had a guy the other day come and say he hasn't been down to fisherman's wharf in 10

years. he said i'm going to come down here every weekend. i forgot sustainability mission, even though the bikes are very minimal energy use. it still matters where the energy comes from and also part of the mission in sustainability is how we run everything, run our business. so having the lights come on with clean energy is important to us as well. we heard about cleanpowersf and learned they had commercial rates and signed up for that. it was super easy to sign up. our bookkeeper signed up online, it was like 15 minutes. nothing has changed, except now we have cleaner energy. it's an easy way to align your environmental proclivities and goals around climate change and

it's so easy that it's hard to not want to do it, and it doesn't really add anything to the bill. >> chair melgar: good afternoon. welcome to the may 16, 2022 regular meeting of land use and transportation committee of the san francisco board of supervisors. i am supervisor melgar, chair of the committee joined by vice chair supervisor preston and supervisor peskin. the committee clerk is erica major. i would like to acknowledge sfgovtv for staffing this meeting. any announcements? >> clerk: they are now convening