>> very good. good afternoon welcome to the san francisco historic preservation commission, wednesday july 20, 2022. in person and remote require attention and our patience. if you are joining remote low and not speaking mute your fooik microphone. sfgovtv is broadcasting live. we will receive public comment on today's agenda. comment upon or opportunity to speak are available by calling 415-655-0001, code 24930398886.

we'll take public comment from persons present first and then open remote access. speak clearly and slowly and if you care to state your name for the record. each speaker allowed up to 3 minutes then you will hear a chime indicatingior time is up. when your time is reached i am take the next person. for those call nothing to submit testimony when you reach the item when you are interested press star 3 to be added to the queue. >> best practice call from a quiet location, speak clearly and slowly and mute the volume on your television or computer. attending in city hall i will ask that you come forward and line up on the screen side of the room. i would like to ask everyone to silence mobile device. at this time i like to take

role. president matsuda. >> here >> commissioner black. >> me. >> commissioner foley >> here. >> commissioner johns. here. commissioner write. >> here we expect nageswaran to be agendaful first is general public comment. members may address the commission on items of interest in the subject jurisdiction of the commission except agenda items. agenda items, your opportunity to comment when it is reached in the meeting. each member may address for up to 3 minutes if if you are in the chambers come forward. remote, press star 3. seeing no ask the from the public. general public comment is closed. now department matters. announcements. >> good afternoon. rich, department staff.

providing you a couple of updates on the work that the department has been doing. as part of our adapttation strategies we have been working on waterfront strategies part of our waterfront program. you know much of the port national historic district. our strategy has been addressing see level rice. storm water. and projected through 2100. planning has been working with us and we are starting to out reach with our community members and especially, we are asking and giving an update to commissioners on the work that has been happening. we are happy to provide additional work you will be seeing not guilty future at your hearing. information on resiliencey element. you will get a fuller picture. if you have questions on this work contact us and help to

connect you with the staff. relative to landmark's preservation designation work program, we only have one brief update. the -- turks and tailor coming the compton's site in august hearing. the st. james church initiation the first read yesterday tell move to the second hearing then the mir. that is when we have on this end. and left, i want to notify you about a great opportunity that we had nawas lead by staff. we are in rope of 40 thousand dollars grant from the office of historic preservation. for work this we scope a native american property documentation form. this is a really great opportunity and great achieve am. the grand proposal lead by

francis mc milan who was in the office but in the back. marcelle and susan parks as well as allison and melanie bishop who worked and responded comments. and awarded with success. we will be working closely with the native american community as well as with any other entered stake holders on the production of that document. i figure for once we share really great news that has will have a lot of impact for the future. that is all. >> very good news. thank you. >> thank you. commission matters item 2 president's report >> i don't have reports at this time. >> item 3. consideration of adoption draft minutes for the regular historic preservation kigz hearing and architect review meeting june

16th, 20 twoochl open up public comment. members, this is your opportunity to address the commission on the minutes. from june 16th. >> calling in remote press star 3. in the chambers come forward. no questions public comment is closed and the minutes are before you >> adopt the minutes. >> second. >> thank you. on that motion to adopt the minutes. commissioner wright. >> yes. >> commissioner black. >> yes >> commissioner foley. >> yes. >> commissioner johns. >> yes. >> commissioner so. >> matsuda. >> yes. >> that motion passes 6-0 and place this on item 4. commission comments and questions. commissioner wright do you want to disclose your we can get to the that.

yes. we can go on. >> there are no questions or comments. item 5 case 202-0099 remote hearings. we adopt had resolution every 30 days in the everyone 91 of you can appear in person to carry on city business. this is the opportunity to address the commission by pressing star 3 or if you near the chambers come forward. seeing no asks to speak, public comment is closed. this resolution is before you. >> motion to approve. >> second. >> thank you, commissioners on this motion then to adopt the resolution to allow remote hearings if in, commissioner wright >> yes yoochl commissioner black >> yes yoochl commissioner foamy. >> aye >> commissioner johns. >> yes. >> commissioner so. >> yea. >> and matsuda. >> yes yoochlt that passes

unanimously 6-0. placing us on consideration of items proposed for continuance. there are no items proposed to be continued. under the regular calendar. that would place us under for items 6a, b, c, d and e. for case 2022-006120. 2022-00618, 2022-006119, 2022-6116. and 2022-006122lbr the properties 525 lagunasm mission. 2555 irving, 63 ellis street, and 2200 oakdale avenue. these are all legacy business applications.

>> good oomph. commissioners, planning staff we have 5 legacy business applications. we will present the application and after youville an opportunity to speak during public comment. i will turn it overfor the first presentation. thank you. >> thank you. good upon afternoon, commissioners. [inaudible] department staff i will present 2 legacy business case today. the first legacy business application for [inaudible] in the west addison neighborhood a twine year old house which is a built with [inaudible] pubs popular in europe. strewn [inaudible] this year and managed by the [inaudible] and his wife maggie. known for simple german dining and upbeat [inaudible] with traditional beer halls. provides itself the first business hallucinogens help

provide the hayes valley in the 90's and also the founding member of the hayes valley small business association. the business provide jobs and food to the locals as and [inaudible] of the hayes valley neighborhood and history. the strain maintaining dining men use. chalk board menus and beer mugs which belong to beer hall in germany and other place in europe dating to the 1900's. staff support this is and recommend the resolution to add to the legacy business registry. the second legacy business application lacken [inaudible] a 32 year old [inaudible] in the mission neighborhood. it was founded by sylvia and [inaudible] in 1990. and it started as a clothing store that men, women and

children's clothing. they expanded the business under lacken bride [inaudible] that celebrate the latino culture. later in 2013 the founder renamed to lacken briden. the businessicaters to latino disc and sells formal ware for wedding and more. they are also the only accidents that sell accessories bridal coins and bouquets. they help customers with customization of clothes but support them by helping in event coordination and event planning latin bridal see multigentational of familiesship and provide jobs to locals. it is committed to maintaining their festive wear offerings, and planning excellent

workmanship and the department recommends the addition of latin bridal to the registry. i will now hand it over to ryan. thank you. >> thank you. good afternoon. commissioners ryan, department staff. the legacy business application is nomad cycle a local bicycle shop this served as a cycling sales and repair hub for the san francisco community for 53 years. the business is owned by roger cub employee of the shop who purchase in the 1997. no mad cycle has woj location on irving street. serving the outer sunset. new residents and tourists arc like. beyond traditional cycling service nomad provides a space to sorize and get advice on routes and site in the city.

a long time fixture in the community the business serves as a community hub for residence dens and sponsored the frenlzy bicycle club and noticing wheels racing team. today, nomad made more than 10 be thousand dollars bicycle sale in 50,000 bike repairs. staff support this is and recommends a resolution to add nomad to the registry. with that i will psz it to g. g. to condition with staff presentation. thank you. >> thank you. ryan. good afternoon, commissioners g. g., planning staff. the fourth is for johns grill a sit down restaurant in district 3 union square owned by john senior. johns grill at 63 ellis for the entirety of the 114 year history. easily recognizable with classic

in often sign the menu is american with i stalian influence. food found in a stake house and seafood restaurant, stake, lamb chops, clam chowder. pasta, salad. comtailgates and more. serving tourists, business people and shoppers and hosting pat residence of political significant cans. robin williams. nancy pelosi. diane feinstein. wilbrown and other known politician, athletes and musicians joe montana and willie mc carpety. john's grill is known for association with the then 31st the multifalcon the character detective spade dice at the restaurant and eats chops, baked potato and sliced tomatoes dineers can still order today t. is known for election day

parties. those who vote may join in on free food. john's grill given back to the neighborhood. organizing street events during the pandemic and building food time and resources to organizations. staff is supportive of this application and a resolution recommending this be added to the business registry. the fifth and final application is for wilcox frozen foods. 76 year old distribution business in district 10. wilcox frozen foods opened by don in 1946 and owned and operated by the family since 2021. 200 oakdale in bayshore industrial in 1948, their distribution building is easily recognized with the name kill cox frozen in green and black text. wilcox was the first distributor

in san francisco and was one of the largest distributeors of frozen foods in the bay area. service grocery stores. restaurants and holings in san francisco. business can distribute large volumes used by large foodservice chains and businesses. wilcox has nonfrfrt customers. project open hand. valley senior services and self help for elder low. wilcox serves local entrepreneurs those in district steffen and committed to min taining low processes to remain affordable to all. wilcomfroze ebb foods gives back to the commune it service donating toed to local shelters, food bank and pant rows. wilcox used local union labor since first open nothing 1946. staff is supportive of this

application and recommend the business be added to the business rej stroll. this concludes presentations and we are available for questions. >> thank you. >> thank you. we have open up public comment. for members of the public who would like to speak to these industry applications come forward. and if you are call nothing, press star 3. i'm here to share words about nomad psyche. i'm retired from the cycling industry. sprent 40 years as a sales rep in the san francisco bay area. and in ha40 years i worked for major bicycle distributor and i got to have been most of the

store in san francisco and the bay area. and one thing about nomad they were here when i started my will career in 1984 and one of 4 stores that are still in business. the cycling industry seen lots of booms and busts from the early 1970ss, again in the 80s with the mountain bike and now carbon fiber technology. stores come and door. stores ride out the good time and had it is tough they close. roger from nomad, served the sunset district on irving for the entire 53 years the store hen in existence. i wanted to share my experience and why i think they deserve to be a legacy business. thank you.

>> hi. good afternoon. commissioner and supervisor mar and first i want to thank you for all of your important work in the historic preservation commission for so upon many important programs and -- ensure our city restains and preserves the rich history of culture and physical environment at a time when we are changing as a city. thank you. and the legacy business program is so important. thank you for your work and i'm here to speak in support of the application for nomad. i was proud to have nominated them about 6 months ago. i'm glad it is finally coming before the commission. nomad cycle is just a perfect example of what the legacy business program is intented

support. being in business. as a mall neighborhood bike shop for over 50 years. mostly at the current location or another location in the central sunset. i'm being an anchor small business and in our neighborhood and our community. not just in the sales and repairs and maintenance of bikes but really fostering community. among cyclists and families here in the sunset. so it is a wonderful business. these are challenging times for small bike shops with the corporate bikes sold at their outlets. upon even in san front and online sales. so. it is i time of opportunity had there is we see growing interests in biking among families with kids and promote nag in the sunset district. and creating safer streets to

ride. i think with the legacy business status. support nomad is well positioned to condition to be a kornldzful anchor business in the outer sunset for detectiveds and i want to thank roger cook the owner and face and -- presence of nomad. for 40 years. and his dedication to his business in our community. thank you. >> thank you supervisor mar for putting out to support this program and the legacy business in general and your support for all of our work for to maintain and sustain historical resources. >> good afternoon i'm raffle lane i'm a constituent of irving street. spent 60 years there. i bought my bikes at nomad and

kidd kid's bikes there. it is more then and there an anchor it is also a book end. it defines the end of this strip on irving. it is the western border and the ferfect ambassador for a residential community who wants use the commercial district and has a reason to go there for themselves and their kids. in addition, i want to say that roger has been riding up and down irving street for so many decades. and attends to all of the other businesses on that street. and become a person on that street that everybody looks for and wishing to use the helmet. i want to say hai want to give you color to it. because it is more than just the time he has been there. it is what he has done with the time. thank you.

i started [inaudible] and i want to thank the commission for as an immigrant to come to this country to have the opportunity to be so long and once and to continue also in the building itself, which is like since 1870 or so. and to continue to have the daoist place preserved. and the architecture. there are few places in the city which min tain the architect and the starkness of the intear interior. i loch hayes valley it became a home and want to express that and to serve the people there.

big honor and to be also part of san francisco for so long manage from munich. want to express my gratitude. >> thank you. we'll dp to remote callers. had you hear your line is unmuted that is the indication to begin speaking. >> hello can you hear me this is david from wilcox frozen foods. >> yes, we can hear you >> great. so a bit about the business, we were customers my mom and i customers of wilcox for 20 years. it hen a learning curve. understanding stepping in the

distribution business. but it was irrelevant important to us that this local independent, san francisco distributor stayed local. there was no other buyers the business was going to close or we were going to buy it. we bought it. saved jobs. we have been in san front our lives and i pledged my future and my family's future to the city with continuing this and you know i have been looking forward to keeping everything all the wonderful stuff we will have does in the community furthering those, everything we want to do. in district 10 and i made roads with local pantries and

[inaudible]. and i want to keep going. i love san francisco. the legacy business is a fantastic way to so lidifiy your place in the community. and i'm -- grateful. thank you. last call for public ment on any of the legacy business registry applications. >> no additional requests to peek for members of public. comment is closed the matters are before you. >> thank you, commissioners, commissioner johns? >> thank you. if is nice to seat legacy businesses today is a group of wholesale and retail businesses and so often the wholesalers

don't get recognized. but it is really great that they do. i'm going to focus on the one business where i have been going for i say 70 years. that is johns grill. i think the lamb chops are supush and martinis works of art if you have not done field researchful may i suggest you do promptly. thank you. >> thank you. commissioner so. >> today is a good day to see so many legacy business coming forward i love all of you and i wanted to give a shout out to the nomad cycle, finding a high, good quality, local bike shop in san francisco is dwindling. it is river.

i remember having my child finding a bike that fits her with a personal touch and also being economical temperature is challenging time for small businesses to be so niched. and i fully support your legacy business application. and likewise with the rest of the applications today. and thank you for supervisor mar to be here. i wanted to see our businesses thrive and continue to support our local community. i want to give a shout out to soup and kitchen. i butcher it. but i had a great time there. for over the past 20 years. it is every time my friend go there is it is a community & anchor for hayes valley and always a reference point for us to meet up after a long day. thank you for being here today

and thank you for being a good local businesses. example for each community. i appreciate your time. >> thank you. commissioner wright. >> yea. i want to add to the previous commissioner's comment and say that these businesses are the backbones of our community. and they help to stabilize and preserve the cultural identity of our neighborhoods. it is so wonderful to see you all here. and i thank you you a lot. >> i'm in full support. >> great. thank you. >> commissioner foley. >> thanks for your legacy businesses i agree with commissioner wright. you are the fabric. i want top do a shout out to soup and kitchen i have been eating there since you opened and drinking there since you opened. drinking more than eating there. but it is interesting watching the transformation of hayes

valley and you were there. i appreciate you and your team your team is awe some. food is consistent and beer is cold. it is critical. i say that beer is cold. johns grill. martinis are great. food is great and nomad you are an institution i owned 9 bike stores in the bay area they come and go and thank you for doing what you do and thank all legacy businesses for your work. >> commissioner black. joy will not go through all the restate when my fellow commissioners said >> i want to shout out to the community who came out in support of the local businesses not just the representatives. i think that is wonderful and that includes supervisor mar, i appreciate that. per of what makes san francisco a fabulous place. thank you, all. >> thank you. >> i also am very proud and supportive of the legacy

businesses before us today. i had a question about an i than i'm mispronouncing. because it is a legacy business of 29 years. may be someone i'm not sure if planning staff if one of you could answer this. i know this small businesses have been very challenged during covid and many approximate that i worked with have gone through a lot of land lord/tenant issues. and rent has been a key factor in weather a business stays arc live or guess away. i wonder, did we make that a part of the consideration to have this legacy business come before ausat 29 years versus 30. i'm sorry i did not see that in the application. it is in the that i'm opposed i wanted a bit more information.

>> >> 29 years old you know it is an exception for business fist they are between 20 and not yet 30 they can be added to the registry at risk of disaccomplicement and getting on the registry would help them remin in their location and remain in business. we did acthanking in their application and aware. yes. >> good. thank you i wanted to clarify and a shout out to latin bridal. i understand this you already have a succession plan in place and will be your daughter? i think this is wonderful it is

hard for many small businesses, family mall businesses, stay arc live and to continue that passion within the families. i and being appropriate to your community. >> i think we are ready to have a motion. >> motion to approve. >> thank you. commissioners. on that motion to adopt recommendations for approval of legacy applications commissioner wright >> yes >> black >> yes >> foley. >> aye >> johns. >> yes. >> so. >> yes. >> and president matsuda. >> yes. >> this motion passes unanimously. 6-zero >> congratulations to all of you.

item 7a and b 2020-6466, and 2014.0746u at 621 waller street. you will consider a request for certificate of appropriateness and adopt a resolution or consider a resolution recommending to the board of supervisors. or historic property conbeing tract. i would like to request i be recused employing both items. >> thank you. on that motion to recuse commissioner wright >> wright yoochl yes yoochlt commissioner black. >> yes >> commissioner dpoely >> commissioner so. >> yes. >> that motion passes.

commissioner wright we will ask you to leave and return when we get to item 8. >> good afternoon will michelle, department staff. there are 2 items before you the first is a request for certificate of propertiness for the property 621 waller street. located in debose park historic district under article 10 appendix m and the second item a resolution recommending nonrenewal of the property contract for 621 waller street. i will focus on the certificate of appropriateness. the commission asked to condition the item for 90 days

to allow the project sponsor an opportunity to add a scope item to their application. the project sponsor revised the plans and the application to include site improvements and regrading of the front walk way as requested. >> sick 21 waller street is 3 and a half single family resident built 1900 in queen ann style this wood frame building front facing gabe roof and porched with railings and clad in a mix of wood siding, shingles and panels the project would arc bait planning case number 2020-008528ens. the project cope includes legalization of work performed without permit including stairs and reconstruction of front railing. reroofing and 4 new sky lights.

initial unpermitted work includes alternate rigzs to the rear such as repair restoration of wood siding. removal of window opening. new window and door opening. new fencing and new roar platform. new work will include front window repair. repainting, regrading and drainage improve ams and sigh lights added without permits. much of the work cover instead certificate of appropriateness is with the historical contract record in the 2014 included rehab plan with specific scopes of work scheduled for completion between 2014 and 2020 some of the work performed much was done without per hit mitts the upon property owner partially

completed the following items without permits. waterproofing and residing at the rear elevation. repair of rot iron at front stairs and porch. replacement of rear windows and replacement of the roof. not aural work is complete and outstanding rehab scope items include repair of the front windows. repainting of front elevation. site grading and drainage work at the front and replacement of roar balcony covered under a separate permit. project before you today will both legalize unpermitted work performd and fulfill the commitments of the contract rehab plan. majority work done without permit staff found this this work of the appropriate with article 10 and complies with the standards for rehab.

where work did not meet the standards the sky lights the project experience agreed to remove and restore the officer appropriate low. staff determined the scope of work in the report is in conform ajs with the requirements of article 10 of the planning code and the secretary of interior standardses. staff has not received support or opposition on the project. we did receive a general inquiry about the scope from the du bows triangle neighborhood association. based on information presented today. staff recommends prove with conditions that addresses enforcement issues and the work under the mill's act. these conditions are. one, the end of the 30-day appeal period of the certificate of appropriateness the sponsor pursue per mist within 30 days.

2, upon permit issuance the project sponsor submit the job card with permit number and construction start and ends days to planning. 3, if construction lasts more than 30 days sponsor provide monthly updates with sdringz of work completed showing the progress of arc bait am. 4, upon completion of work as requested in the application number, and conformance with architect ral plans and labeled exhibit b. the project sponsor so photos to planning staff for review. once the planning department determined all work is compliceant and approves at this time sponsor move forward with obtaining a final sign off and sends a photo to planning staff.

5, rehab scope item 4 is related reconstruction of roar balcony and will be completed under building permit number 2033-12305216 by december first of 22. the property owner move forward with obtaining the final sign off and send a photo to planning staff. and now i like to move to the second item buffer can the resolution recommending nonrenewal of the historical property contract. the condition tract is a 10 year rolling contract. one year is acided automatically to the initial term of the contract at the anniversary date unless notice of nonrenewal is given whchl in nonrenewal the tax benefits provided wind down over the 10 year period until it

reaches zero if contract is in the renewed. scopes of work in the maintenance plans will still be completed according to the schedule in the plan. if the hearing on march 16, 2022 the commission expressed interest in limiting the condition transact for 621 walltory a term of 10 years better to achieve a balance with the mills act and cost to the city. therefore, the department recommends the commission adopt findings recommending to the board of supervisors nonrenewal of the historical property contract for 621 waller. per the terms of contract in local and state laws, only the property owner and board of supervisors can elect nonrenewal of the contract. therefore, if approved, the resolution would act as a recommendidation for the

consideration of the board of supervisors. if the board of supervisors decide to consider the recommendation, the item would be heard by the government oversight committee and review of the board of supervisors. this concludes my presentation. but i would like to note that we did receive a request this morning from the property owner to continue 7 b the nun renewal resolution until august 17th the property owner is on vacation and unable to attend today. and with that, i want to note that kelly wong and i. kelly is our senior enforce am planner, are available to answer questions. >> thank you. >> thank you. is there a representative of the

sponsor. >> thank you. >> good afternoon i'm arc lisa skags an architect with [inaudible] and has been assists with the enforcement issue. the upon property contributes to the du bows historic district and includes the familiaring and notable character defining features the form, scale and

proportion, including the double hung windows wood windows. materials and finance paint horizontal wood siding. architect details the bay windows, gabe roofs the cornices the shingles and spindzel work. >> they have done a bit of work on the home at the front facade the work includes the repair of the raw iron over the front porch. replacement in kinds of the iron metal work the top and bottom ris on stairs. replacement of the wood stairs in kind. work still includes repair of the existing windows which they surveyd and repaired according to sheet a902. this slide shoes the work that

was done at the metal work at the porch. it was in good condition and only required minor repairs preparation and paint. >> the decorative metal at the stair was not in good condition special replace in the kind and the lower bottom is how it looks today. >> this slide has a closeup of the stairs that will replace to match the original. >> there was other improvements including the concrete pad under stirs to store and hide. the trash and recycleingly bins. >> a roof was installed and sky lights, planning said that the 2 sky lights close to the street on the roof were too close to the street and a bit visible and

so they have agreed to remove the 2 sky lights which will mean making appropriate patching and repairs to the roof. >> repairs can replacement of wood at the rear. these were previously rerued and approved by planning. >> this slide shoes the rear facing facade west. here again aterations were reviewd and approved by planning. and this is a photo of the finished work at the rear. and this is from the drawing this was not presented at the last hearing but we were recommended to include and the paving the concrete paving area that is on the east side of the stair will be replaced. the existing drains away from the house and foundation so tell new will be similar to what is

there now and include a curb to prevent water and soil run off from the adjacent property that concludes my presentation. i think there has been a lot of great work done at this house and that complied with standards. and we are pleased have another property that is protected. thank you very much. we should open up for public comment. member this is is your tupt to address the commission by pressing star 3. if you are call manage and if you notoriety chambers come forward. no requests to speak from any member of the public. public comment is closed. and these matters are buffer, commissioners. why thank you. are there members who wish to make comment or have questions for staff?

commissioner foley. >> thank you president matsuda. i want to thank staff for the time they spent on this. i know it is a lot of work. i appreciate the work. just want to say worn thing tot project sponsor. the planning staff is spafkly the preservation staff worked hard. and it is unfair they have to do extra work when it is something like this. and i want to thank planning. that's my comment. >> thank you. >> commissioner black. >> i wanted to say, i think we should i'm going to recommend or make a motion to approve the project with conditions and all reserve my comments for later to the mills act for another hearing. assuming we agree to continue the mills act portion.

you know the next item. . see what my fellow commissioners think. >> thank you, commissioner johns. >> thank you. i wonder with b on this motion to continue the property owner is away on vacation. the interested in knowing when the property owner was notified of this hearing. >> and i would like to know when the property owner went on vacation? >> thank you. >> michelle, planning staff. the property owner was alerted to the nonrenewal last wednesday. i did inform them by e mail both property ordinance. it was also published in the public low available agenda on wednesday. we planning staff was alerted an among or so ago the property owner would not be in available

for this item today because they were on vacation. however we did feel it was appropriate to include the nonrenewal resolution with the certificate of appropriateness rather than to separate the 2. >> i'm sorry clarify. the property owner was notified last wchldz officially notified that had prior knowledge to that? no. and then we do have the property owner's architect here? who spoke to the project. >> that's right. and the property owner could have call in the to provide us information? that's right. i did -- i did inform the property owner last wednesday that they could call in or write a letter to the commission if they would like to and did not was not aware of them.ing to

respond. >> i see. >> when you talked to the property owner, did the property owner could have another representative here the property owner never has to appear in person. did this come up? >> no. commissioners. i'm just noticing now that the what the phone number provided me of the property owner is raising hand to speak they are online if you want to afford them the opportunity to speak now. >> sure. >> okay. >> again when you hear your line is unmuted that is your opportunity to speak. >> hello this is [inaudible]. the property owner. so i very much apologize not able to be there. this was the second portion of the [inaudible]. unfortunately we were literally

going to the mountain this is week. have been active i saw this. yesterday. and we love to have had the chance to write our recommendation in hopes we will be able to condition the mill's act contract. i would like to add that we believe that we recognize how we have not been able to comply with the mill's act in the early days and you in we are trying to do everything we can to comply and like to have that in addition my wife and i have been diligent with -- to ad to the preservation of the building. things not on the exterior. like non -- nonrequired foundation upgrades. structural upgrades throughout. repainting classical and historic [inaudible]. we feel we have done a lot to

sort of counteract that. we understand that perhaps the frustration with the commission with us but we will hope to have another chance to renew the contract. thank you. >> thank you. >> so. the having heard from the property owner, i take it it is no longer. we no longer have a motion to continue before us? does that --. conch census or not. there was a request from the property owner to continue a matter i did in the hear a member of the commission make a motion to continue. why i misspoke. i should not have said motion i should have said request. and as i see it that's -- no longer a question. and i think we can proceed. to consider these 2 matters.

and i'm satisfied that the staff has presented a completely adequate case for us adopting a recommendation of for approval with conditions. >> for each of them. >> thank you. >> that is my mowing. >> thank you. i'm going to ask -- commissioner so to provide her commentses and commissioner black spill think we will come become to you commissioner johns to see if there is a second on that motion. >> i think anybody should have an opportunity to talk not a way of foreclosing consideration a way of focusing the discussion. >> go ahead commissioner so. >> all right. i really appreciate michelle, going through all of this for no one how long you have been over

a year. and also alissa, thank you for i don't know if i misspoke, the architect. thank you for continuing to be here. i remember last time the presentation was -- very thorough and i appreciate today the package that you provided us. it is very clear that you had -- really addressed every comment we did. clearly. all the way down to the drainage to the sidewalk with the concrete grading. i justmented to -- say that i'm appreciating these effort. of our staff and also the one of the very best historic preservation architect in the city to really help the homeowner to make things right. thank you for being here. and i would like to also agree

with my fellow commissioner johns, i am in line with his motion which is approving the recommendations to move forward and approve this. >> thank you, commissioner black. >> i'm sorry were you done. why i'm done >> commissioner black? >> i'm torn. i have absolutely no problem approving the application with conditions. so they can move on. you know i always like to preserve an applicant's right to be heard. he did have a right to be heard and call in the. but we -- did not i mean -- i'm torn on the second item. i don't know that will significant canly affect my opinions on this, which i think we are fairly clear last time. but i -- i'm torn. i will do what the rest of the

commission thinks is right to do. i will say that. >> thank you. >> commissioner foley. >> i'm actually the recipient of a mill's act and we have been compliant around it. and we actually had to deal with many city departments besides planning and dbi to be in compliant. and for that, compliance and for all the work we did, we have a benefit. and -- my problem is if you get a benefit you have to live by the rules. and as much as i appreciate them doing upgrades to the build together it is good for them to upgrade the building themselves anyway. i personally think that we should follow staff's recommendations. approve with conditions. 7a and believe we should adopt a resolution recommending a nonrenewal. >> thank you. >> commissioner black, did you

want to make an additional comment. >> [inaudible] [no microphone]. ipment to make a couple comments about the mill's act. will and i had a couple questions for mrs. taylor. can you talk a bit about the difference between the mill's act and nonrenewal and had a cancellation would mean. >> sure i will be happy to. so, in the contract by state law is a 10 year contract. that renews annual in perpetuity date. any point they can put it in nonrenewal. that means that the contract would be limited to just 10

years. cancellation is a punitive approach. if there is noncompliance with the mill's act contract, then the city may opt to cancel the contract immediately. with a 12 and a half % penalty fee on the assessed value. upon given -- under nonrenewal. the contract expires is it an on going tax benefit. >> >> the contract in nonrenewal it is winding down. am the benefit based on a tax

a -- association provided by the state can determine that calculation for the benefit. it does line down to zero >> thank you. i appreciate that. so, it seems the applicants have already had because they did not really start applying for the permits until 2020? >> i believe the first permit we have on record is 20 there was one in 2013 that is incomplete and after there was a permit file in the 2017. >> they did record the contract in december of 2014. than i had an active contract since that point. >> but the -- the city's action to remediate, enforcement action, that was file in the 2020. >> that's right yoochlt not

action; is that correct. >> that's right. >> there was the work that had been filed in 20 upon 17 was the permit that was filed gone ahead and performed the work. that is when we opened >> without permit >> thank you. >> so begin there has been 6-7 years of -- benefit in the reduction of tax through the property ordinance without them fully complying on their ends of the contractual obligations. i have to say i express concern. city's mill's act programs is a privilege. and it most these don't upon offer it. and i'm sorry we have been placed in position in favor to the mill's act applicants and others who work hard to comply with the program terse of the

program, and in sfarns to san francisco taxpayers in general who don't have historic properties had don't have an opportunity like this, i do think that the begin this is the direction of the commission today, this we had make a recommendation to the board of supervisors for nonrenewal of mill's act application. >> thank you. commissioner foley? >> i think i like to make one more comment itch did in the know the punitive damages and i think tht property owner should be thrilled that the planning staff is not recommending punitive and that the property owners will receive benefits. for a bit of time. property owner is the win merthis. a bit frust ritting butt property upon owner should be happy with haplanning staff is recommending. >> thank you. commissioner so. >> i have a quick question.

i'm sure michelle, you had already reassessed and evaluate the options but is there a way to stop it now instead of not renew for 2 years? >> i'm sorry. repeat. not to the renew as of 2024 >> 2022. >> wherever the board of supervisors hears the item and approves nonrenewal it would go in affect. i believe 30 days after. >> immediately as possible. >> right. it is the hearing is schedule would be a big discussion at the board of supervisors. >> thank you for clarification. >> thank you, i think that when this matter came before us i expressed strong concern this this property owner had enter in the a contract in 2014 and had

clear knowledge of what was expected of him. and created the scope of work with the help of planning staff. it was not imposed upon him it was done cooperateively and clearly had knowledge and was informed of what the process required in terms of gheting a permit and moving forward within a time line and did not do that and proceeded do work without a permit. i'm happy the work has been done and it is done on what planning staff believes is adequate. but i don't think we should reward people who do not keep their promises and understood the terms of the contract from the beginning. i am supportive of what commissioner johns had suggested in his motion and i believe we have a second. on that motion. >> i didn't hear a second. >> thank you i heard a lot of support but not a second. >> i'm sorry.

[laughter]. there is a motion and seconded to approve a certificated of appropriateness with conditions and adopt a recommendation of nonrenewal for the mill's okay on that motion commissioner black. >> yes. >> commissioner foley >> aye >> commissioner johns >> yes >> commissioner so >> yes. >> and president matsuda. >> yes. >> is that motion passes 5-0. >> i will call commissioner wright. >> commissioners that it is place us on item 8. before i do, commissioner wright, i'm sure are familiar with 10 days to file.

your notice of recusal with ethic's commission. >> you have 10 days to file your recusal form. i don't hear you. >> sorry. every time you recuse yourself you file a form with ethices and have 10 days you are familiar just to friend low reminder. >> that will place us on item 8. 1015 guerrero street this . is a request to adopt a resolution in support to the national register of historic places. >> good afternoon planning staff. the item before you is an initial register nomination the tim 3 flewinger house at 1015 guerrero in mission. prepared by robert churny proif he wassor at san francisco state

university. as a certified local government the city is begin the opportunity rerue and comment on nominations to historic places prior to action by the state resource commission. any comment bunkham this commission will issue forwarded to the historic preservation august fifth state historical hearing the tim 3 flewinger house nomination will be considered. >> the house located on the east side of guerrero eldoverado and 22n't. italianate house single family dwelling. converted to 2 flats in the 80s. queen ann detail in the 19 huh human. wood frame facade is wood lopsiding the first floor and code wood at the second. recessed porch is accessed by

back speak fast] located to the left or noeth side of the building. 3 side bay on the second floor and false front with decorative brackets along the building and lights at first and became levels. the house is locally significant can under b in area of architect for association with architective merit. according to the nomination. guerrero street was purchased 1902 arthur fluinger had a tailor shop. the architect worked as a drafts man and hired bite firm of james rupervert and george [inaudible] in 1912 first solo commission.

lady of the way side a small church in portola valley. he worked with j r miller after the dissolution of the partnership in 1913 and following his military service during world war i. high profile project and got an act license in 1920 made partner in the firm. designed residential and commercial families. single family homes. sky scrapers. throughout california the nomination notes his projects and profiles best known designs the telegraph building 450 suand

[inaudible]. the nomination highlighted innovation and embrace of modern approaches that incorporated elements from chinese, [inaudible] meso american and other artistic traditions the nomination details support of fine arts throughout his career. collaboration with artists and futures on infer yors and exeter yors of buildings. the building remained his home until his death in 1946. significance encompasses the date he designed his first building through his date of death. as stated in the absence of a constitute i don't or office the house associated with his productive life reflecting the time he achieved significant cans seen through alternateerations since construction and retains integrity. the department agrees with the property locally [inaudible]. the nomination provide said an

over view of career and buildings he designed throughout california. nomination focusos his career and details with 1015 guerrero and residents there from childhood through his death. the absence of studio or office associated with the architect. architects are represented on a national rejster under c by work. their hopes and studios eligible for consideration under b these other properties they are associated. staff requests you review and provide comments meets the significance. the commission may recommend the nomination, not recommend the nomination or recommend it revised. comments may be added to the resolution in packetses. tell be forwarded to the office of historic preservation. this concludes my presentation. i will turn it over to robert

churny who will present remote with the review of the nomination. jooshg good afternoon. commissioners. i think you can hear me now. thank you france and is thank you for helping and organizing this. commissioners it is a pleasure to be with you virtual tow talk about timothy and his house. he was one of the most creative architects to lived and worked in san francisco. some would rank him the most creative. he entered the profession when dominated by class simple but had a modern approach. sometimes incorporated influences from chinese, persian and ethnoamerican and other artistic traditions.

in addition, he was a strong supporter of fine arts and collaborated in his architect ral designs with known painters. can you click up my slides, francis. you are familiar with his best known works. in this, his first major downtown commission. challenged the prevailing notion of a tall building being like a classical column with base, shaft and capitol and uses tercota siding to suggest the grantite. second major contribution to the downtown skyline. here he embraced the art deco style with a twist. grew up on meso american design and patterns it create what the

architect ral historian christopher [inaudible] has labeled may an deco. designed with step route typical of mayan architecture. with roosevelt school. broke from existing styles. christopher describes it one of san francisco's most idiosyncratic buildings german dutch expressionist. the only in san francisco and the united states known to be design in the this a van guard style. >> the 20's and 30s motion picture theatres remember flamboyant and extravagant. he designed 9 theaters begin

width castro in twoochl paramount theatre in oak land is the most spectacular. carolyn picks prepared the nomination for the building describes it, the 2 great art deco movie palace in north america the other being radio city music hall in new york. of the unique facade. 50 feet wide come with mosaic of 2 giant figures male and female puppeteers. the entrance open in a long narrow and spectacular art deco lobby. >> in the 1930's when the great depression e eliminates commercialing destruction he designs schools and other public structures. allow his productive life. parents brought him there in 1902 when he was 10 years old and lived there until his death

in 1946 when at the height of his career. the period significance is 1912 to 1946 the time of his death. of this is the only known photo of the building from the time he lived there. you see that there is an oftening over the large first floor window. and you come see that his father's tailor shop is advertised on the oftening. when he grew up there his father had a tailor shop on the first floor. the photo from 19 seventy-four shoes the changes. the oftening is gone. and the large plate glass window on the first floor that was installed give august tailor

shop the most possible sunlight was replaced by 3 long narrow windows which was an alteration designed by him himself in 1945. next slide. from 1927 until his death he maintained his office and studio on the top floor of 580 market. his successors remain thered until 1980. they are no longer connection with him examine this location. in the absense of studio or office this house is the best example as a property associated with his entire productive life. and therefore fulfills the requirement under b that properties be associated with a person's productive life. reflecting the time when he or she achieved significant kajs. so e i'm happy to take questions

you may have. and i think this joe the owner is also available if you have questions for him. i think he was going to try to call in. we should take public comments. if you near chambers come forward if call nothing, press star 3. public comment is closed the item is before you commissioners. commissioner black. to me this is a no brainer all you do is look at the long list of his spectacular properties all over the city and beyond. the statement of significance note the most of his buildings

repurpose third degree is obviously instead of demolished this is a sign of architectal value. work spans more than 25 years. i love the variety and he did them all really limp i love the upon term mian deco that is fabulous. you see why it is got that term. he was supportive of artists a collaborator. and while the guerrero street residents in itself is a fairly not an example of his work other than windsos did not suffer much from the earlier alterations and -- conversion from single family to 2 family. and the martin house is important for us to celebrate

residents of people who were really important in san francisco and did important work. to the city no matter how long [inaudible] i strong low support resolution in support of the registry nomination >> commissioner foley. i don't know hay can say i support everything she said and thank you for being appropriate. >> commissioner so. >> i am in supportive of the nomination. thank you for all the work, francis and team. and i have to say that i have been in the paramount theatre recently and it is still a gem.

i had to w on restoration of several of his be projects and his works and can arc test to just how great they are. the level of craftsmanship and artist real that go in them and the level of thought i'm in full support of this. >> thank you. >> i think there was a motion and was commissioner johns. did you have a >> me, too. [laughter]. okay. >> second. >> okay.

>> thank you, commissioners if there is nothing further a motion that has been seconded to adopt resolution in support on this motion commissioner wright yoochl yes >> black. >> yes >> foley. >> aye >> jaunls. >> yes. >> so. >> yes and matsuda. >> yes. >> that passes. place us on your final item today number 9. mission dolores neighborhood historic context statement and survey - adopt, modify or disapprove. good afternoon, department upon staff. before you my present egg i will turn it over to the project sponse to provide an

introduction on the project. hello commissioners. president matsuda. i would like to the letter of support that in your package i added a bit to it. i will read had i have here. of so. over the last upon 17 years the mission dolores neighborhood association worked hard to protect our historic and important neighborhood. in doing so we raised the funds, hired consultant and worked closely with planning staff to complete a context statement and survey. we have also saved many important resources and worked to preserve the integrity of our neighborhood. on behalf, i would like to offer

our support for the adoption of the newly resunrised mission dolores statement and survey. i will clarify my our reasoning below. while the newly formed historic projection commission doomentd our mission dolores survey and statement on march 17, 2010. and unanimously reaffirmed that adoption on january 19, 2011. the planning department never recorded those documents. even though they were asked to by h pc. now under new leadership, and support of supervisor mandelman planning has revised our survey and contact statement to include

2 new historic district and it is 5 districts in the intermission north survey that are within the upon bound easier of the mission/dolores neighborhood giving us 7 historic districts. we would have preferred a few large historic districts that included the mission/dolores median, mission dolores park and extended period of significant this hp crib and mdma recommend in the 2010 and 11. we like to support the new proposal from planning so we can move on with our lives it has been 17 years and a lot of work. we hope you agree with this compromise. refer to h pc resolutions 0056 and 0097. if you have questions i will be happy to answer them.

after melanie is done. thank you very much. >> >> thank you. peter. today i'm presenting with i recommendation for adoption the mission/dolores neighborhood context statement and survey. the historic contact statement addresses the development of the mission system in san francisco. and focus on identifying properties associated with early residential development and post earthquake construction in the neighborhood. sponsored as you heard boy the mission-dloeshs neighborhood association in 2007 with the most recent draft finalized this

year. the do you mean will be used to inform the survey effort and ensure that future property evaluations are consistent with loam issue state and federal standards. >> to provide context i'd like to sum rise the project's history. since the founding of the mission/dolores neighborhood association in 05 received guarantees from the projection funds committee and san francisco vicktory yen alliance. the current draft finalized studies by [inaudible]. and [inaudible] and associates. and updates the document to incorporate new department documents and concern projection standards. the project was submitted the department updated the mission dolores neighborhood statement

and survey to incorporate the following documents and city actions. the inner mission history irk statement and survey adopt in the 2011ful latin x context statement. establishment of the american indian district. in progress american inldzian context statement. and ethnographic information by the ramaytush ohlone. the document incorporated the san francisco planning commission and historic projection commission resolutions centering the department's work on racial and social equity. completed and reviewed by department staff who meet the qualification standardses for historic projection. the survey area covers the western portion seen out line in the black of a larger area identified by ndn a mission

dolores neighborhood. the eastern area surhave aed the north survey in 2011 and contains 5 historic districts. seen and out lined in gray. 6 article 10 landmark in red are went mission dolores neighborhood. the mission dloer neighborhood statement and suri have provides framework for identifying properties as eligible for listing the california register under upon a1 eventses and c3 architecture. properties identified individually eligible are eligible in a district found to be so for associations of early development between 1864 and 1906 and reconstruction period following the 1906 quake and

fires. they are residential in character. using the framework that mission dolores statements. the department made the following determinations and recommendationings. 18 individual properties eligible for listing on the california register out line in grown on the map. 3 potential landmark cyn nikolas church, st. matthews and congregation [inaudible]. 2 on the california register shade in the blue and pink on the map. and we recommended further ajs of the dolores median, mission dolores park and the. mission dolores archaeological association and in consultation of the ramaytush ohlone.

>> staff and neighborhood association conducted out reach on january 27 a meeting hosted via zoom to update all property owners within the survey area and interested parties and organizations. department staff coordinated trial not sxifkz review with jonathan cordero with executive director of the ramaytush ohlone. maild and e mailed 20 day notice to all property ordinance in the area. and other interested parties. committee member and property ordinance were interested in the project and self expressed support. as mentioned the mission dolores neighborhood association submit aid letter of support them is in your pack and he no public opposition has been yet recorded. >> in conclusion, the department recommends adoption of the mission dolores neighborhood context statement and survey.

i'm happy to answer questions. thank you. >> thank you. we should open up public comment. members who this is your opportunity to address the commission. if you are in the which i am bers come forward if calling press star 3. when you hear your line is unmuted, begin speak. >> good afternoon, commissioners [inaudible]. can you more me >> we can hear you fine. >> this is kathrine, architect history yen i had the privilege to work on this project. in 2014 michael corpet and shane watson and i were engage in the the mission dolores neighborhood association to update the statement and findings we were asked to verify wlr all 500

parcels were contributing or not as historic resources and found the survey area, which contains [inaudible] will in total of that number 383 were determined to be contributing and 125 noncontributing. on page 10 of the version of the historic statement now before you stated the information recorded for each property included the address and current and updated status. contributor status analyzed and updated status quotes were arc signed the stats quotes assigned at the city's request and city requested we provide a framework to justify our funding. although if is common for survey finding maps to show contributing and noncontributing resources, it is map that is part of the presentation does

not have that as far as i w can see. my questions are which properties are contributes and noncontributes. where does this information show and up how will the property status be conveyed to the public? it may be obvious peter [inaudible] i continuing is fortunate to reiterate this hen a communal based survey of work and funded work thanks to mission dolores neighborhood. represents decades of effort. dpoument historic resources and i hope the results that this commission adopts today will be as robust as they can be. thank you. >> can you hear me? >> yes. >> thank you. i'm ted olson the third generation of my family to live in our house [inaudible] fourth

and fifth generation around the corner in the survey area. all 4 of my grand parents liveod this one block [inaudible] after the 1906 catastrophe and we [inaudible] city land morning 267. [inaudible]. i'm an original member of the [inaudible] of the market/octavia project and former chair of the trans bay joint powerhouse authority cac. i want to grant peter lewis for almost 20 years of effort in crediting ndna and increase adoption of the survey documenting our cultural heritage documents this in the neighborhood. i'm interested 5 the 18 properties noted historical are on sharon street. i'm grateful it includes to be

original and historic contributions of our native american people and i look forward to the suri have's valuable contribution to the city wide survey. i also wish to commends staff member melanie for her helpful efforts supporting the successful conclusion. thank you. i'm available for questions >> last call for public comment. >> upon seeing no requestings. commissioners public comment is closed this merit is before you. >> thank you. mr. [inaudible]. hi. commissioners rich department staff. i wanted follow up a bit on melanie's presentation and peter's comments. and just express our gratitude to peter lewis for his tireless commitment toward the project. he has been a long partner with

us in trying to get the sorry have a done and -- while i don't want to go in the nitty grit of what happened and upon the past, our condominium was to guest this done start in 2019. a global pandemic rerailed our original schedule and thankful we had a good fartd part in with peter, of the supervisor's office and melanie to bring this to fruition. since taking over in 20 many these other projects we like to bring forward we want to make sure they nit well in the department's projection program and help when we can come up with an outcome that works for everyone the end of the day and a piece of san francisco's history documentd and organized for everyone's use. gratitude to them on all their

work. >> thank you. commissioner foley? >> i would like to say to peter lieu and is mdna, thank you for your folk sdpus diligence for 17 years. really great. public system or the government does not work well sometimes but we carry it through and to mr. [inaudible] and your team great work it is a delight you took over projection to melanie i appreciate it and i'm supportive. >> thank you, commissioner johns. >> thank you. i think this is was of well put by commissioner foley. i think this is just a remarkablely wonderful statement. and mr. president [inaudible] said this this would be available for everyone's use. i think this is grit and hope everyone does use it because if people read it, it will dispel a

great many fantasies, myths, untruths. and other misconceptions about the history of the mission. and if they do read it and those misconceptions are dispelled i think effortses to preserve the mission will be vastly -- strengthened. thank you. why thank you. commissioner wright. >> yes, thank you. i also. to thank the mission dolores neighborhood association. and city staff for all of your work on this. to fruition. i would like to also say that given how long it has taken on get to the points where we are now. i would like to encourage completion and updates the

mission dolores meet meadia, park and archaeological districts. thank you. why commissioner so. >> this is a good day to hear this we are making it forward. we will make this happen. thank you for the leg work, melanie. not a small feat to bring it to the finish line. i live in the mission for over 15 years. this is arc maze to see that we create something that all of us in the neighborhood can make reference to. and set a standard for hopefully next time the next neighborhood does not take that long to do. it is hard to be the first. so i motion to adopt the

historic contact statement. and survey today. thank you for being here. >> thank you. commissioner black? >> it is is really a colossal pressure involving many hands over many years. it is hard to which manage something like that i'm appreciative of the neighborhood association and mr. lewis and the supervisor, it takes a lot of moving parts to make this happen. this was done with so many quality professionals including city staff. it it is a fantastic document spent the weekend going through it, going over and over parts it of. i had a lifely time going down and familiarizing myself. i don't live this for away from sharon and streets i have not been on recently.

you know it is just so nicely done. it is must do reading for all of san francisco. i would love to see history teachers require high school students to engage in part television. it is interesting. san francisco history. and also i would love to see a mention in the press if the press pays attention to our hearings. just a little something in the newspaper about this project. and this document. and a link so people can read it. it is visible to the public but they know about it. i will not go on anymore about the document but i appreciate all of the work that everybody did and i strongly would second commissioner so's motion if there is in the a second.

>> thank you. final comments thank you mr. lewis working with community and the associations ain't easy. have you done it for 17 years. you really deserve credit. and i -- i'm sorry for the delay. i'm sorry for hahappen in the the past but thank you for being big about it andment to move forward and looking at this as a big are project not with with any ill feel and making sure we document the store and he document it rightism agree with you this does provide a more inclusive story than we have seen in previous documents when we talk about the mission dolores and i'm glad that i'm not sure if that who included the information from the housing element. because that does highlight haour priorities are in social and racial equity. thank you very much. and i believe we have a motion

and a second. >> indeed, we do. on that motion has been seconded to adopt the historic context statement. commissioner wright >> yes yoochl black >> yes >> commissioner foley >> aye >> commissioner johns >> yes. >> commissioner so >> yes >> president matsuda. >> yes. my apologies. motion passes 6-0 and concludes your hearing today. >> thank you. learned and expan

it across the city. [♪♪] the tenderloin is home to families, immigrants, seniors, merchants, workers, and the housed and unhoused who all deserve a thriving neighborhood to call home. the tenderloin emergency initiative was launched to improve safety, reduce crime, connect people to services, and increase investments in the neighborhood. >> the department of homelessness and supportive

housing is responsible for providing resources to people living on the streets. we can do assessments on the streets to see what people are eligible for as far as permanent housing. we also link people with shelter that's available. it could be congregate shelter, the navigation center, the homeless outreach team links those people with those resources and the tenderloin needs that more than anywhere else in the city. >> they're staffing a variety of our street teams, our street crisis response team, our street overdose response team, and our newly launched wellness response team. we have received feedback from community members, from residents, community organizations that we need an extra level and an extra level of impact and more impactful care to serve this community's needs and that's what the fire department and the community's paramedics are bringing today to this issue. >> the staff at san francisco community health center has really taken up the initiative of providing a community-based

outreach for the neighborhood. so we're out there at this point monday through saturday letting residents know this is a service they can access really just describing the service, you know, the shower, the laundry, the food, all the different resources and referrals that can be made and really just providing the neighborhood with a face, this is something that we've seen work and something you can trust. >> together, city and community-based teams work daily to connect people to services, >> one more statement. we are the one. that is our first single that we made. that is our opinion. >> i can't argue with you. >> you are responsible please do not know his exact. [♪♪♪]

[♪♪♪] [♪♪♪] >> i had a break when i was on a major label for my musical career. i took a seven year break. and then i came back. i worked in the library for a long time. when i started working the san francisco history centre, i noticed they had the hippie collection. i thought, if they have a hippie collection, they really need to have a punk collection as well. so i talked to the city archivist who is my boss. she was very interested. one of the things that i wanted to get to the library was the

avengers collection. this is definitely a valuable poster. because it is petty bone. it has that weird look because it was framed. it had something acid on it and something not acid framing it. we had to bring all of this stuff that had been piling up in my life here and make sure that the important parts of it got archived. it wasn't a big stretch for them to start collecting in the area of punk. we have a lot of great photos and flyers from that area and that. that i could donate myself. from they're, i decided, you know, why not pursue other people and other bands and get them to donate as well? the historic moments in san francisco, punk history, is the sex pistols concert which was at winterland. [♪♪♪] it brought all of the punks on the web -- west coast to san francisco to see this show. the sex pistols played the east coast and then they play texas

and a few places in the south and then they came directly to san francisco. they skipped l.a. and they skipped most of the media centres. san francisco was really the biggest show for them pick it was their biggest show ever. their tour manager was interested in managing the adventures, my band. we were asked to open to support the pistols way to that show. and the nuns were also asked to open the show. it was certainly the biggest crowd that we had ever played to. it was kind of terrifying but it did bring people all the way from vancouver, tee seattle, portland, san diego, all up and down the coast, and l.a., obviously. to san francisco to see this show. there are a lot of people who say that after they saw this show they thought they would start their own band. it was a great jumping off point for a lot of west coast punk. it was also, the pistols' last show. in a way, it was the end of one era of punk and the beginning of

a new one. the city of san francisco didn't necessarily support punk rock. [♪♪♪] >> last, but certainly not least is a jell-o be opera. they are the punk rock candidate of the lead singer called the dead kennedys. >> if we are blaming anybody in san francisco, we will just blame the dead kennedys. >> there you go. >> we had situations where concerts were cancelled due to flyers, obscene flyers that the city was thought -- that he thought was obscene that had been put up. the city of san francisco has come around to embrace it's musicians. when they have the centennial for city hall, they brought in all kinds of local musicians and i got to perform at that. that was, at -- in a way, and appreciation from the city of san francisco for the musical

legends. i feel like a lot of people in san francisco don't realize what resources there are at the library. we had a film series, the s.f. punk film series that i put together. it was nearly sold out every single night. people were so appreciative that someone was bringing this for them. it is free. everything in the library is free. >> it it is also a film producer who has a film coming out. maybe in 2018 about crime. what is the title of it? >> it is called san francisco first and only rock 'n' roll movie. crime, 1978. [laughter] >> when i first went to the art institute before the adventures were formed in 77, i was going to be a painter. i did not know i would turn into a punk singer. i got back into painting and i mostly do portraiture and figurative painting. one of the things about this job here is i discovered some great resources for images for my

painting. i was looking through these mug shot books that we have here that are from the 1920s. i did a whole series of a mug shot paintings from those books. they are in the san francisco history centre's s.f. police department records. there are so many different things that the library provides for san franciscans that i feel like a lot of people are like, oh, i don't have a library card. i've never been there. they need to come down and check it out and find out what we have. the people who are hiding stuff in their sellers and wondering what to do with these old photos or old junk, whether it is hippie stuff or punk stuff, or stuff from their grandparents, if they bring it here to us, we can preserve it and archive it and make it available to the public in the future.

we will start with announcements. all right, this meeting is held in hybrid format in city hall room 416. broadcast live on sf. gov tv and you can listen to it by calling 1-669-900-6883. using id 23155123. all individuals present that all health and safety protocols must be adhered to. we appreciate your cooperation.