>> lots of new things. >> i like to call this meeting to order. madam secretary, call the roll. vice president [inaudible]. >> here. >> commissioner maxwell. >> commissioner paulson. >> here. >> commissioner stacie. >> here. >> we have a quorum. do to the health recommendations by the san francisco department of public health and the emergency orders concerning social distancing and lifting restrictions on teleconchs this meeting is teleconference and televised by sfgovtv be aware well is a brief time lag. i would like to extend thanks to

sfgovtv staff and puc staff for assistance during this meeting. if you wish to comment dial 415-655-0001. meeting id access code: 2490 474 7569 ##. to raise your hand press star 3. know you must limit your comment to the topic discussed unless on the other hand general public comment. if you don't stay on topic the chair will ask. >> refrain from use of profanity. address remarks to the commission and not to individuals. silence your electronic device. before i go to the land acknowledge. i want to welcome commissioner stacie.

i would like to announce the puc acknowledges owns and stewards of the unseed lands in the historic territory of the troib and other descendants of the federal mission san jose band of alameda county. sfpuc recognizes every sides within the greater bay area has and continue to benefit from the use and occupation of the tribes lands. since before and after the sfpuc found nothing 1932, it is important that we not only recognize the history the tribal landos which we reside but also

the acknowledge and honor the fact the people have established work partnership with the sfpuc and are productive members within the greater san francisco bay area communities today. madam secretary. . next 3 election of officers discussion and possible action to lect a president and vice president of the commission each to serve a year per the san francisco sfpuc rules of order number 6. so, i want to announce for the processes of election, the following steps public comment. nomination for the commission president. nominee accepts or decline and motion and second.

>> madam second. do we are callers with hands raised? there are 2 callers in the queue. you have 2 minutes. thank you. this is peter i'm the policy director from the river trust. i would like to welcome commissioner stacie. i heard you are bright and look forward to seeing you serve.

and -- with a lot of changes at the sfpuc we have 2 new commissioners and about to have a new president i'm might be commissioner ajami and hoping with the changes the commission will be more active. there is a tendency to hear about issues but not prioritize action. an example is 7 workshops and information was shared. no changes made as a result of that information. and -- having meetings and workshops is very important to move us in a new direction and we need that at the sfpuc. so. take that in consideration that this is the year of action and making positive changes. thank you.

can provide public comment until you made a motion or opened nomination public comment on election of officers occurs when there are officers proposed in nomination. aside from that i would support commissioner ajami for president and either commissioner maxwell or paulson for vice president. i think it is important to have understanding of the commission and how it operates before become an officer. and given the seniority that's how i would go with this one. thanks for listening. >> thank you for comments. >> there are no more callers. why thank you issue public comment on election of the

president is closed. >> can i have a nomination for the president? i'd like to nominate commissioner ajami for president. i will second that. >> thank you. >> can we have a roll call i accept that and appreciate the nomination. have a roll call on this item. >> vice president ajami. >> do i vote on nile own. >> yes. >> commissioner maxwell. >> aye >> paulson. >> aye >> commissioner riera, >> aye. >> commissioner stacie >> aye >> motion passes. >> this is an honor. i say and now i have a gavel. and i want to say i'm looking

forward to what lies ahead this is we are dealing with a lot of different critical issues from impacts of climate change and dispute of light. nobody is red to deal with impacts we are experiencing. also the lots. staff retiring. figure out how we are replacing all the staff members and bringing now blood and fresh blood in this process. and how we grow has a utility and thinking about intersection of climate change. environmental health. and dealing with the community and making sure they have secure access it water. these are important issues and i look forward to working with over this. with that, i would like to actually ask for sorry -- public

comment again. public comment. >> members who wish to make 2 minutes of remote comment for item 3 the election of the violent police press story 3 to speak. do we have members present? provide upon comment on the election of the voiment. >> do you have callers with hands raised. >> there is one caller in the queue. >> hello caller you have 2 minutes. >> thank you this is peter drubbingmeyer. i like to congratulate president ajami. i think she doll a great job and think that commissioner maxwell would be a fabulous vice president, vice chair. hoe is trusted by everyone and i have a lot of respect for her and i was impressed last week.

he attended the land use and transportation commission meeting or committee meeting when they discussed the toxic algae bloom in the bay i thought it was grit to have her there representing the commission. hearing what was and engaging we need more theory with other commissions and the board of supervisors. thank you very much. >> thank you for your comments >> there are no more callers in the queue. >> thank you, public comment is closed. gi want to open nomination for the commissioner vice president i'm -- not sure what the adoptions we have i like to see if possible considering all the comments we got from the public

if -- commissioner maxwell would be willing to take this role but want to make sure we have other fist they have other comments or suggestions. we can put it to vote or are you asking commissioners to we in prior to the nomination? >> do have you a comment? opening now with the comment i'm interested in being the voice chair, also. >> mr. palson we have difficulty hear you go. >> there was a question asked about the vice president i would be interested in that, also. >> okay. i nominated commissioner maxwell i don't do you have are other

commissioners do you have comments reactions i think i think it is important to realize what options we have but i think personal low i think commissioner maxwell and her experience in this area would be great help for me. i would very much look forward to work with her as a partner in this process. may be we can donna, i don't know can we -- would this work for you commissioner maxwell? do you accept this if i put this to vote. >> i would accept it. >> if you made the motion and accepted we need to vote on that. >> i will not accept it yet and if there is further comment then if anybody. please speak in the microphone.

>> sorry. >> madam chair it is up to you how you like to proceed. >> i have a question does there need to be a second different a roll call. >> do you have comments or can someone second. first of all -- her name is up. i'm sorry. go ahead. president ajami i will second this nomination. >> thank you. may be we will have a roll call? roll call vote on the nomination or election of commissioner maxwell as vice president. president ajami. >> aye. >> commissioner maxwell. >> aye. >> commissioner paulson. >> no. >> commissioner rivera. >> aye. >> commissioner stacie. >> aye. >> 4 aye's.

>> okay. thank you. okay. so -- i guess madam secretary move to now that we have the election do we need another public comment on that. >> no. >> then let's read the next item. >> next is item 4 adopt fine beings under legislation to allow hybrid meetings and direct the commission secretary to agendize a similar resolution at a meeting in the next 30 days. >> comments? can i have a motion j. we need public comment. >> members of the public had wish to make public comment on item 4 press star 3 to speak.

do we have callers with hands raised? >> there are you no callers in the queue >> opinion comment on item 4 is closed. any further discussions? okay. can i have a motion and second, please. >> so moved. >> second. >> thank you. can we have a roll call >> president ajami. >> aye >> maxwell wrchl aye. >> paulson. >> aye >> rivera. >> aye. >> stacie. >> aye. >> next item, item 5 approval the minutes of september 27 of 22 and october 11 of 22. >> can i have a motion and second? >> public comment. do you have comments on the minutes? >> no. >> can we have public comment.

why members who wish to make 2 minutes of public comment on item 5 the minutes press story 3 to raise your hand to speak. seeing noneful upon do we have callers with hands raised? >> we have one caller wish to be recognized. >> thank you. >> your line is open have you 2 minutes. >> can you hear me now? >> i'm having trouble on the phone hearing the commission secretary. i think i'm getting all the commissioners but perhaps the audio from is not typing direct in the audio system. on the minutes thank you for continuing the last set in my opinion it is cal deferred correctly.

thank you very much. there are no more callers in the queue. >> public comment is item 5 is closed. >> can i have of further discussions. i want to highway light we had 2 minutes we carried on one from the september 27th which had incorrect date and october 11th. any further discussions or comments. can i have a motion and second, please. >> move to approve. >> second. >> call the roll. >> president ajami. >> aye. >> maxwell. >> aye. >> rivera. >> aye. >> commissioner stacie. >> ayech >> we have 5 aye's. >> item passes.

>> item 6 general public comment. members who wish it make 2 minutes of general public comment on matters in the commission's jurisdiction and not on today's agenda press star 3 to speak. there are 8 callers in the queue. your line is open you have 2 minutes. >> thank you. i'm peter and i live in potrero hill. i'm urging action to prevenn another algae bloom.

[inaudible] and [inaudible] and it was just so shocking to be in the water and to see the dead fish this they see the dirty water and the [inaudible] more about it. my understanding from the articles is it is worse than any city in terms of the way we manage the wastewater and volume going in. i imagine there will be more people living in the bay area i think is good but means urgency for us to change the way we deal with the water and prevent the water and you in trients going in the bay. i would ad 3 years we were on a trip and impressed to see a city people swimming in the water.

manage to keep the water clone and had is know area where san francisco can be a leader and doing a better job with the fresh water flow and help with other important efforts like salmon restoration and the fisheries. >> the last thing critical there be concrete action and in the voluntary agreements. various [inaudible] not related to [inaudible] reaction. >> thank you very much. >> thank you for your comments. of next caller, your line is open have you 2 minutes. >> welcome the newest member of the commission. on the board of supervisors

website under events there is a place by the puc revenue bond oversight committee for a site tour on november 4 of the ocean side treatment pasillity. tours have been on hold since precovid and expected to for future. i'm requested to be include. in tour. i submitted my request. >> thank you. >> next caller >> denise here member of the better for biological diversity. welcome to new puc decision makers. san front is a biodiversity hot spot blessed with native plants and wildlife many of which we

humans brought to the brink. san francisco name for st. inferenceis is our moral and ethical to sured our lands without sending species to00 autodelta is of significance for birds on the fly way. we have known that [inaudible] on the decline now there are barely enough to count. than i are an indicator species of the poor health of the ecosystem and the 7 are threatened. you have the power to act [inaudible] and ecosystem. san francisco cares as do scientists and pores like me. i have not told my 8 year old grandson about the lawsuits that block the state's plan to

increase fresh water flows to the bay he cry when is he heres trout is dying i want to tell him a positive store thedependsos whether you with draw. thank you. >> next caller? hi. i'm judi irving. i'm a documentary film make are probably known for the wild of telegraph hillism finished, cold refuge about swim nothing sudden front bay and how restorative it can be to swim in cold pure open water. but last summer i swam in the to beingic algae bloom it was

yucky. it had. as i walked the water the water was not greenish gray or grayish green the way it urthly is. i was not sure so a swam and i swallowed water it was in the a happy day swimming in the bay and i urge you to please recycle our wastewater to remove the nutrients that feed the algae. if you don't do this we will have to beingic algae blooms more approximate more often and they will be worse and worse. as a swimmer who has been swimming since 1984 i beg you, keep the bay clone and swimmable. thank you.

good upon afternoon and consideration commissioner stacie. i'm executive director of california out doors a professional river out first trade association and calling to talk about i call in the before about the xrifr your commission's workshops and the design drop that you adopted. we pointed out and i want to point out again our concern tht design drought harms the river at the system it adopts rational demand projection and i pointed out a few times i represented my clothes and constituency in reliancing and processes across

the state and and what i pointed out those entities pge and placer county were involved in those care about making sure we don't run out of water and reasonable projections that's what i ask you to do. welcome to the new commissioners and i look forward to working with you. next caller >> good afternoon i'm mary butterwic a san front reden for over 30 years the past couple years i attended commission meetings regarding flows on the river i'm here to show my concern and mainly -- i stated

previously last year salmon in the river was 186. it is heart break to realize this precious resource could disappear forever in my life time another alarm bell in the bay this summer with the to beingic blom that killed fish including endangered green sturgeon and others. i urge the commission to draw this lawsuit against the state water board's delta plan and work with the state to ensure flows are consistent with flow standards adopt in the 2018. we have lost 4 critical years of progress and stake sustainable flows. . water management relyos conservative 8.5 year design drought. commission should shorten the drought by a year. the date the commission has been

unresponsive to numerous requests from an interested and concerned opinion information on the design drought, water demand and alternative water supply. i watched the land use committee hearing last week and learned about the approximate terrible for recycling wastewater to reduce the load to the bay. this would contribute to an alternative water supply rusing relines on the river. >> bay area residents such as myself, care about the environment. we look to the commission to be responsible stewards of the river by increasing flows. thank you for your comments. next caller, 2 minutes. thank you. peter. a year ago commissioner herrington requested a regular update on eclogical issues

related to the river. somewhere to drought commission's update but when the state of the salmon and he was ignored and we kept raiseings the issue and in march staff said he is no longer on the commission. at that point commissioner maxwell said i would like to see this as well. and coming happened. so -- president ajami i hope you will add that to the calendar along with a date when the reports will start being issued. my colleague dare warn are produced that informing for you not this difficult. last week reported 423 fish on the river and zero on the river.

last year 6 thousand salmon under 600, what is difference? a big one is unimpaired flow. on average it is 40%. [inaudible] it is 21% sxf dry yeeshs lower. last year 9% and year before this 15% and 15%. it is not managed in an eclogical responsible way. i want to share the water committee invite need present to them on salmon this wednesday at 9 o'clock on line. if you like to tune in, you are welcome. it is a (egg i would love to give. why don't we have a workshop on the state of salmon. remarkable a group invited me to present. obviously -- thank you, your

time is expired. next caller. i'm john, i'm a farmer, commercial fisherman formy angler. former biologist. and i like to welcome the 2 new members to the commission i'm going to ask that the commission once again ask you drop the lawsuit. we had the 50th anniversary the drenal water act and fighting the clean water act. our voluntary agreement has been a failure and yet you want to do want to revamp the voluntary agreement and doing the same thing that does in the work is

madness. and the other thing as meter mentioned before and seeing the years i followed the report stone call reaching information this should be public and transparent. i hope you are able to distance yours from your former relationship with the utility commissioner you worked for and have an open mind and be able to make -- scientific decisions approximate and in the depends on the utility information. in the workshop looking at times and review on this. the utilities studies were not up to snuff.

thank you very much. welcome to 2 new member and hope as we go forward we -- don't say we continue about salmon where as you [inaudible]. thank you. thank you. next caller. good afternoon. i am the on the board of northern california council of [inaudible] and i'm interested in the sfpuc taking a good look at projections for water demand. there has been consistent over projection of water demand. and impacts the what you put in storage. and as your plan and i also encourage with sfpuc to adopt the bay delta plan. and make it workable.

and increase the flows on the river to the 40%. lastly with recycling there are examples original the world australia, san francisco's city of [inaudible] as california state first. and i think that it is a great opportunity for san front to take the lead in recycling. thank you. next caller. your line is open. daved againful 2 items on general public comment. last night i was watching the

news. i saw an item about anchor brewing company and their use of recycled water for processings purposes. included [inaudible] on tv talking about water resources and a bit of her at crystal springs this was nice. a bit about anchor brewing and paula. i have a question you might address. the last meeting the upper watershed approach old and not considered at the meeting there was a deadline of november 10th of this year to see what it

said. to submit to the water control board a proposal to substitute that for the flooding solution for the area. what was not clear from this slide is whether that requires action of this commission by november 10th or whether staff can submit that proposal to substitute prior to this commission acting and either way wondering if this would be back before this commission on november eighth or in the future. >> those are my 2 items for public comment. thank you. >> thank you. there are no more callers in the queue. >> thank you. yes or no public comment is closed. >> please read the next item.

item 7, communication. >> any comment or discussion on the items in the communication? i want to yes. go ahead. please. i should pay more attention i keep looking around. >> commissioner maxwell. >> thank you, i had a question on the green infrastructure grant program said we spent 10 million dollars, which is grit but commolested 2 project it is. my question is, why have we not i'm more on the completion of the 2 projects and when do we anticipate completing and is there a date for others? >> good afternoon.

wastewater enterprise the short around the upon grants, washed over time they were not issue in the a batch process. they are simple low at different levels of completion the first 2 the stats report was the first 2 have been done. and all of the other currently awarded contracts are in progress. i think impelementation time is witness we awarded they go in design and construction. i think you are looking at say, at least 1-3 year window to be generous from award to completion. remainder of the projects you should see them coming back in the next status reports. than i are all on track. and we opened our latest competitive round as this report notes and we are seeing really

strong interest in the program. why great. may be would be may be you should say more than to that point when you read it -- it is from 219-22 does in the say just to say the others are in progress we have 2 completed the others in progress or something to that. very good. absolutely and subsequent quarter low reports we'll add that to the table that has the status sum res. >> great. thank you very much. >> before you sit down i have a question for you, too. so -- on that item, i'm guessing you anticipate my question. but this is back to the discussion we had about 3 months ago. how are we tracking the performance of the system and are there -- are we -- how is that going? >> we have spoken about that with the staff and with sarah

and the leadership team. we have ideas for some technology based monitoring on the systems. and at the moment we don't have anything specific for each of the projects to my knowledge and i want to verify this with my team, we have done a set of post construction monitoring on most if not all of the early implementation projects you heard about. 8 projects that are built in the public right of way the last several years.

it anymoring questions. >> i have one more question, on the hold of i'm sorry. the river. we have a list of projects for restoration we are moving forward with. similar to that question i wonder what we have baseline data. i hope you will have a monitoring press to see if they are working or not that depends on the year when water year it is. i'm wondering where we are.

>> steve rich, this is pilot project. signed an mou with fish and wildlife service in 2021. to begin working on the projects in anticipation of the process. and this is a primary element to that is making sure we have a rigorous monitoring program to measure what is success and will what is not so then we can elaborate in terms of future restoration projects. so -- this case we have just begun work on this project i say we are still in the ceqa process. even in the san joaquin valley they take awhile going through the ceqa process we plan to implement in the not very distant future. >> vice president maxwell? >> thank you. i noticed that 2 projects that

were going to be going forward. looks like the bobcat will not be so become to the drawing board in looking for another project? >> we had several candidate projects and i don't have that list there were like 4-5 projects and so bobcat when we selected start out with. we were not able to agree with the river. >> what was problem there? >> well, i think there are -- i got a copy here. the -- i think this there are question of whether or not people think we should proceed with the projects like this buzz they are similar to the voluntary agreement. i think there are people not like theville taer agreement so we don't want to support a project like this.

we will talk with them and others about the need to go forward with the projects and try to convince them they are desirable projects to workllow. how long will we work on this project. >> that one in i don't have the date in hand. these projects have been around for a bit of time. >> 3-4 years? >> you know probable the concept was in existence 3-4 years. the actual work on that -- you know since we signed the mou a year and a half. >> it read this we were looking for another project. >> yes. med me feel this was off the drawing board and look for example another project. i wonder -- if this was going take as long. the projects that are looking at men they will be different or will not have had a long lead

time 3-4 years. jot challenges is in this breech of the river the owned by private parties. so -- they are a bit more challenge to work with to come to an agreement on how their land should be ewe likewised. it is on hold. i say that this time off the drawing board it is on hold. >> bobcat is on hold >> yea. we are not going to give occupy that. the time is in the right, right now. we will look at other projects to see if any one of those are red. >> thank you. >> i have another follow up on this. these are pilot projects and they will test them and go to larger implementation of one or two or more? >> may be more. >> what time line are we looking at? from that perspective.

anticipating to see more of these flyers, more heat. >> employees extreme events i'm trying to see do we need to try expedite this press. i way we can do this faster? i'm just when is the time line. >> unfortunately the time line for restoration projects is in the dissomewhere for water supply projects. there are a lot of hoops to jump through and careful design consideration and the once who implement on the grounds you can't get one or 2 years of data and say, we got the answer but you pointed out the very ability with one and 24 years can be great. we think if we are lucky get 10 projects on the grounds within 15 years and start to see results from them.

in this case the consult ans we have on boards have experience on lots of rivers.

getting an answer is something had is quick. we tell you what is going on with it. but -- in terms of report had is something on the order of twice annually they don't move -- i appreciated every report on the conversation they are useful.

madam second, public comment. >> members who wish to make 2 minutes of remote comment on item 7, communications press story 3 to speak. do we have members present who wish to provide public comment on item 7? do we have callers with hands raised. >> there are 3 in the queue. caller you have 2 minutes. >> can you hear mow. well is a technical problem with the audio. i could in the hear on the phone, the back and forth with steve and i had to listen to that on the computer. and because it is not time coincident, well is a delay and it is very distract to sort

through this. either now or following public comment if you could recess the meeting and get media service up there and straighten out the audio, it is you know -- it is fringe low a brown act and sunshine problem to condition with this meeting if the public cannot here when you are saying i have no problem hearing commissioners but you cannot here the audio from the lect urn, it is not the audio is not coming through on the phone. it is not typing through what it needs to pipe through. my other comment on item 7 is -- on 7e. david excellent report. the letterhead somehow has the address on the top right corner, twice. that's you will i have, thank you for listening. please attend to the audio.

>> thanks. >> thank you for your comments. >> next caller you have 2 minutes. >> coalition for sudden front neighborhoods. i am on the phone only on not on a pc. or looking at sfgovtv to amplify the comments i can heart commissioners fine. i cannot hear waters comments from which me this is know important issue. because on this agenda is item upon 15, this water supply assessment. again, i can hear may be when you speak a bit but then it trails off and i can't hear anything. so please, if that could get resolved. thank you. >> thank you.

next caller you have 2 minutes. i was having trouble with the audio. i wanted comment on 7-8 the happen at that time restoration project is i good project. river trust neighborhood a help at that time restoration project in this your a few years ago focusing on the side channels. and then the water agency approached us and are working on a program in river so the 2 are going to work well together and it is a great demonstration of collaboration. we have to remember that happen at that time restoration is important but flows are important, too much for example, rester a flood plain but no water they don't serve a purpose. another great example is the dos

rios ranch project. 2100 acres and -- a week ago there was a celebration there. with all of the parties involves the governor was there from the sfpuc. it was a great upon effect working together we accomplished so much creating flood plain happen at that time real storing the area for species. and the sfpuc did contribute 2 million dollars toward the purchase of this land we appreciate that. this is the beginning we have more work to do we need to restore had been at that time and neil adequate flows, thank you very much. >> thank you. there are no more callers in the queue. >> a way we can make sure that people can. >> i will ask i sfgovtv said

they hear the callers. they don't think what the issues is now. i think may be speakers use the other mic the ad a mic when you speak, please pull it toward your face and speak loud low approximate we have issues we will resays sez and -- see had the issue is. >> for now the plan is to use the microphone on your left. from the audience side and hope that one will work. and if that doesn't we will have an alternative plan. >> testing that in a moment to see if it is working in the room. >> even that one was work nothing the room i'm not sure what was going on with the audio. i want to say. i appreciate the comments about the collaborations. it is important to highlight that we are collaborating with

environmentsal groups it is not just all grim and gray. and so sometime its is shining and bright. important to highlight that. can we. other discussions, colleagues? you are good. >> okay. can we -- have the next item. >> next item is 8 the bay area conversation update. >> teleo commissioners congratulations on your presidency. commissioner maxwell, welcome commissioner stays and he rivera

and hello commissioner paulson i'm pleased to being her to provide you an introduction. i know commissioner rivera you and i have not met and to updateow a few things. the first thing is what is is? the bay area water supply conversation agency. a special district form in the 2003 to represent the interests of the 26 wholesalers. water supplyers in 3 counties. serve 1.8 million residence centses. 40,000 businesses they all rely upon your san front regional water system for majority of their supply. this is a map showing our member agencies. service area. in the 3 counties.

the board is 26 members strategy. comprised appointee from each the member agencies. and our goal is very simple. reliable supply of high quality water at a fair price. i have the benefit i don't operate a system like mr. ritchie. we are focussed on this reliability of a water supply and the connection to your water system. >> this is another slide i used out in the public i get, lot of questions. what is up with this rep with you and san francisco and why does it electric like this? and irrelevant you go become to the beginning of the system thought of. this water system was conceived, designed, built and pritted from the beginning to serve the entire region. that is a picture of the cover

of the report from 1912. this was i report to the mayor and the city attorney general. if you flip it open on the inside and i had a chance to see that the title page reads for the water supply of san francisco and the neighboring ecstasy. and in fact a number of my agencies then communities supported the congress in 1913. this water has been delivered to the region since construction. and the current relationship between san francisco and its customers. is governored by the water supply agreement. that defines our relationship with you. to give you a perspect you have how reliant the agencies are, on this system hi purchased 2 thirds of the water the system produces a year that represents tw thirds of the supply they use to deliver their customers and

meet needs. in addition to the water purchases from the san front system, my agency rely on groundwater. they have recycled water. their own local surface water. they import from other sources. state water project. valley water and in total the total supply for the rent year was 205 million gallons a day and in exchange for the purchase of this water they sends you 300 million dollars a year. and another thing that is different or interesting, the thing i like the most about this group is this they are diverse. and i mentioned they serve 1 penalty 8 million and the 3 counties. and the we have small agents. smallest is city of [inaudible] serving 4500 people. and there are learningest is alameda county that serves 3

ecstasy 358,000 people. and everything in between. we have a mix of cities. water districts. 2 private utilities. i mentioned there is diversity in the counties. over 90% of the water supply in san ma te'o from the water system and the water suppliers. san ma te'o is department upon your system. less in santa clara and 'll meada. quite diverse. and also how reline they are on the water system and so 65% of them are 90% or more relinocaine on the roej nal water system. this is a component of what they deliver to their customers. so this is a graph i showed to the commission not long ago.

i thought it was worth bringing back. it provides over all total water use and population. from 1975 to 76. that is our oldest reliable data. goes to fiscal 2021. actually available on the website. as the head line says uses 24% less water comper seed the peek use in 86/87 despite a population increase. this increase is the result of many things. actions at state and federal willful for efficiency guidelines and local agency investment and customer investment in water efficiency. exit site that, this is something when you go out people speak to. this level of efficiency is the result of extended droughts. our economic downturns and the pandemic. if you look at this graph the

droughts shown with the #lines and for each drought period water demand reduces in response there is flow rebound. if i had fiscal 21 and 22 data it would be harshed. this is an inside i shared last time approximate with board policy committee this month. i will say it again, as i looked at this it assessmented to me are we in the extended drought? is this drought [inaudible] opposed mull pull 2 of 3 year drought with light years in between. i of course it forces us to think where we are today if this is the case what does it mean for customer and ability to conserve more. i continuing is a way to think

about it. and the other piece that build in what is this meaning per person basis? this graph shows residential per capita use and gross per that use. same data set. and the drought years are shown in dotted lines over all since that peek use in 86 average residential use decreased by 37%. and average residential use down to 56 gallons per day. at the time they were below when anybody thought was normal. we were citing 50 gallons per day and it is rebounded it is low are than other presidents. so this is something we have to examine close low. as we consider when actions need to be taken. we have an issue product updates or projections i look forward to bringing that to the commission

i'm expecting the end of this year. so updated water use data, this data set relies upon information that my agency send to the state every among this is total use not purchases and the most reason data august of 22. we see is that for august of 22 savings compared to left year in august, we had a -- now i can't find, 6.5% les than last august. and -- while we continued to see a savings, the conserve is that we are not continuing to see this much savings as we need hit our targets. and this is concerning especially when we think about summer time of august, for example, is general low the greatest opportunity for savings.

so raises a question what are we going to do more in the event next year is potentially dry? so a couple things. this is a snapshot from our website. one of the big questions we get calls our name is bay area water people say i don't my water supply how i do find out to get information we use maps on the website to help people locate where they are this monopoly allows them to find rebates click on the service area and takes them to their water agency. we fiepdz is very helpful. wee start one for great water use and resource page with a fact sheet and a map that will agencies get gray water pages on their websites get populates

with that. what are we doing in we are focused with the aemgs in anticipation tell be dry next i don't remember we always have to plan for dry. that is hawill happen. we are committed our agencies are committed to meeting the call for water use reduction and your call. but having devils. where do we go from here? we have meetings with you and our agencies compiling information of when they are doing so we can look together to say what are their things, more actions we need to take and what are they is is there a stronger voice about this. don't have the answer but i wanted share that is the active conversation going on right now.

and look forward to reporting become to the commission on that and that concludes my remark bunkham pleaseed answer questions you may have. >> kidnap questions. thank you. 2 things. i cannot ask questions. one, you indicated people are calling to see where the water is coming from which i finds that very wonderful. majority of people don't know where it come from. making an effort to understand is a positive indication. and i'm ais more than before that is why you are putting effort in website and directing public. the second thing you mentioned we have every indication that next year well is the high chance will be dry and i say even if next year is in the dry there is no guarantee after that will not be dry. so it is important for us to be

mindsful of how much of this conversation or efficiency we see is implemented. would stay long to make sure we have we can save water for the fufrment right. every drop we are not using will be a drop that we can use or share with the environment t. is like an important indication for people to realize you mentioned it. we have been in the fast 20 years more dry critically dry and draught spells than wet years. there is in guarantee we will get out of this. we want to make sure we are using our water wisely regardless of had year we have ahead of us. thank you i appreciate that. >> thank you very much. can we have public comment. members who wish to make 2 minutes of comment on item 8,

press star 3 to speak. do we have callers with hands raised? >> there are 2 callers. >> you have 2 minutes. >> can you hear me now? loud and clear. okay. daved again i'm trying to be calm i'm going to read you california gentleman code section 54953 e 2b. in the events of disruption prevents the public agency from broadcasting to the public using the call in option or internet based service option or a disruption within it is local agency's control prevents the members from offering comment using the call in option or internet based service the body

recollect take no further action on items appearing on the meeting agenda until access to the meeting via the call in or internet based service opgsz is restored action taken during the disruption revenning the agency may be challenge pursuant to the code. furthermore the city attorney's memo of september 28 of 21 on page 6 question 8. made a policy continue to meet if challenges disrupt public comment. discusses it is recommended staff consult with the city attorney's office immediately to and recess the meeting to correct this. it is unfair to member of the public who are call nothing and participating as their right under the law to not be able to hear speakers this institutes a disruption to the meeting and i urge you to recess the meeting

fix the technical problems so we hear had you can hear in the meeting room. >> while you are on the call were you able to hear the other microphone? >> i can hear you i can hear the other microphones it is not as clear as it usually is i know you are in a different room but you gotta get media services and figure out which audio. i think it is a problem with the phone bridge. i'm not. >> i appreciate that comment. >> if you hear me for a second we changed the microphone for the speakers. and we are trying to figure out we did try to make an adjustment. while you are on the call, i'm wonder figure you were able tom hear mrs. can cola. you are saying you were not able to hear her again this time. we changed the microphone.

>> on the sfgovtv feed throughout commuter. not a problem hear everything broadcasting find it is over the phone i can hear you not as well as usual but i can hear you but we cannot hear anyone who is the public audio is not working. it is not routed correct low through the sound system to the phone. >> thank you. we will make an urge to fix this. thank you. >> are there other callers. >> yes. one more caller. your line is open you have 2 minutes >> peter, i want to commends boska on great strides toward water use efficiency.

it is inspiring and as a result of this and the water first policy the hetch hetchy system has 4 years worth of water in storage. the envy of water agencies. unfortunately, the water we comfortable rarely benefits the environment it gets stored behind dams when we have a good water year all that water people comfortabled is dump in the the river and have one good year at the expense of men poor years. when i talk to people about this and say your water conversation is in the providing environmental benefit they are outraged because the number one dry for people to comfortable water is to benefit the environment. look at this and may be ask your friends if you found out your conversation is not helping the environment what would you think? i think you will hear the same

results i have. again. congratulations on the wornful progress but let's make sure that benefits the environment as well as a very, very long draught plan 8.5 years. the long-term very well inability that is unlike to to ever occur. thank you. >> clear clear thank you for your comments. there are no more callers in the queue on this item >> public comment is clezed j. so we am take a recess to solve this technical issue. and -- hopefully will be quick. >> okay happy to be become we solved the techical issue. and moving to next item.

. we are on item 9 report of the general manager. >> thank you. item 9 aa drought condition update if steve ritchie. >> if i could have the slides this is steve ritchie. as noted, we are now in a now water year the slides will be a little different this time because the reports don't show much we have been in it for a week. residence wire storage is shown. again, hemp hetch hetchy is 75% full. water bank is dun the 44%, which is low are then and there normal this time of year that is our big concern on the storage level. >> the residence wire throughout the state not much is changing here. the shasta and orvil storage are

low. california drought monitor is unchanged at this point the state is all in drought. this is the beginning of the water year, for the new commissioners the block line is the median presip station. the top dotted line is 1983 or wettest year on record. blew is 1977 or drivewayest year on record. and the gold dotted line is last water year. in the corner is the red borrow that is this year. nothing's happened i will in the say this. we got.07 inches in the hetch hetchy system this does not go far. this is.00 it was from last week

that was yesterday's results i saw this morning. bay area again, no precipitation. fog, yes. role rain, no. and again snow peculiar you see there the red line is the snow pillow index. they are remote monitor stations the black line is the historic mode written had is a curve this shows 100% of snow pack april first and then tails off. the dotted line at the top is 2017 the wettest years on record approximate 2015 is that low figure out the color an orangish color this is one of our least snowy yers on record. and the purple is 2021. which was not a bad year.

but we are just starting on this year. >> water available to the city, under the act the irrigation districts have the entitlement to water about 2500 cubic feet per seconded that is the low are part of when we call the top half there upper per is 4,000. that is what the act says is the district's max entitlementtur look and modesto irrigation district. fully is below this line. it is their entitlement if above that it is our entitlement. this line is important. you see the blue squigel on the bottom this statute water in the river now there is not much run off coming down. >> the national precipitation forecast. whites not good no precipitation and the top box is last week.

and the low are box is the coming week and california is white. not much happening this is the slide of the deck that irrelevant is something this is important now when demand is. you see the orange line is 2015 demands that is aim of water we deliver throughout the year this the cal defer year moving left to right. poke is in the middle this is the summer the peek demand. at the top is calendar 2013 that is the highest before the last drought. and you see calendar 2020. and the green is calendar 2022. and what we have been talking to our customers about is trying to make that track can calendar year of 2015 that's where we

will like to be this year. we have in the quite knead there. the last several weeks we have been on top of that orange line the latest data this morning we are on top of that. so we are doing pretty good in terms of shaving off the summer peek. that green line is lower than calendar of 2020 and lower than 2013. it is not as low as we will get. we have been talking and we will talk with the wholesale customers about when we want to do next year. we'll focus on what specific measures we think the customers should take in terms of conversation practices that could make a difference going forward. rather then and there giving a percent. have not dhan and talking about practices but we need to fine tune had we request our customers do. with that, i'm happy to answer questions.

>> colleagues, question? >> commissioner maxwell. when you say we are going to tell them. why commissioner, are we say figure you use 2 gallons of water less you will save this amount. are we getting that specific and how you can save 2 gallons less. >> right now they are survague the customers to see what everyone has done and what is work and not working the best example now is we being say to the entire service area we recommend that off the customers organizations and the wholesale customers limit out door irgigz to 2 days per week and outside the hours of 10 in the morning to sick in the evening. and we can't tell them to do

that but we can say if you don't agree to that we will make the numbers mandatory and he making them mandatory sesomething that everybody wants to avoid it can get punitive quickly. and they would rather hear what can i do constructively. we will hear from the customer first what they have been doing and what is working and not working. >> thank you. >> one comment i have often people worked with the landscapers to do out door landscaping or setting up irrigation. i wonder if we can work with our team to you know identify landscapeers that come up with the best management practices or build this connection as onen row way to changing water use.

out door is driving a lot of water use during summertime. and i heard from people they don't know. they landscapeers come and -- set up irrigation. and get their bill. i think that is roorth entry point stake holer we can work with. make sure it looks good and they hear. if we make that the primary message. can look good and also look driveway. we near a draught and that's how it has to be for, while >> sure, >> thank you. >> other comments?

>> can we have public comment. thank you. >> public who wish to make 2 minutes of comment on item 9 apress star 3 to speak. okay there we go. commissioners i wanted let you know this we work in partnership with cal water efficiency partner help to offer that is qualify water efficient landscaper training. sent i text to my staff i don't have the answer when the next class is held this is manage we

do throughout the area exactly what you said. there is an on line class scheduled for december. qualifying your regular landscapers throughout the service area and makes that information available to the public. >> thank you. any member present. >> do we have speakers with hands raised >> there is one caller in the queue. >> hello you have 2 minutes. thank you for your 2 minutes i'm francisco decosta. and we have to focus on the [inaudible] act. >> focus that is number one. number 2, the conscientist webs

of san francisco were comfortabling water. you commissioners who have no sense that we have [inaudible] hetch hetchy 3-4 years. and we are not addressing the occurrence of the salmon and talking about all these you know training for -- things involving landscaping and all that bullshit. that's not what matters here. act number one, the conscientist webs of san francisco, number 2 and number 3, commissioners fit to do your job. and right now it does not seem you are fit to do your job. you are talking in circles.

mr. ritchie was my friend. i [inaudible] presentation that does not matter now. what matters now are the salmon. if we don't take it to the salmon we don't tailor to anything at all. the salmon were there before all of us. the indigenous people for 23,000 years and strangers [inaudible] 250 years and destroyed everything. thank you very much. thank you. no more callers. >> thank you item 9 is closed. >> 9b a drought public out reach summary. good afternoon i'm beth roads senior communication manager for water and external affairs i'm

sum rising the drought public out reach campaign this year. so, as you remember, in november of 2021 you declared a water shortage emergency. you asked our customers to reduce water use by 10%. that ask increaseed 11% when we went to a tier 2 water shortage emergency. staff koshed nayed with water conversation staff and started design of a comprehensive public out reach aimed at retail and wholesale customers. >> so research says the attention pan of a person is 8 seconds and in order to initiate behavior change you need to make your ask clear and consistent. reach people in a number of different way. we designed a campaign 14 calls to action each advertisement focus on one thing only we want customers to do to save water.

rent, own, indoor, out door, behavioral, turning off the faucet or shorter showers to replacing the toilets. we wanted them to be bright. be eye catch and wanted them to issue easily translate in the chinese and spanish to reach the audiences in san francisco. modia buying firm to place the advertisements and outletos your screen that includes social mode enthusiasm google adds. cards on the inside of muni bus in san francisco. we worked with our per ins to place electronic billboards at 14 locationos major highways. we had 3 separate subcampaigns on spanish speakers and one on [inaudible] speakers and one on cantonese speakers. it is important to note the

weight and the percentage of the buy is related the amount of water people use. a third focus on san francisco and 2 thirds focusing on wholesale customers. >> now paid advertising is an important tool but not the only tool. we deployed all this year. we know our customers love to hear from us in traditional ways they like the news letters. bill inserts e mail blasts. made sure they were on bills and made surety messages on the my account bill app portal if you pay online they would appear in front of ump to the right you see a screen shot of my ash count that green bar is the proximate amount of savings we are asking. in san francisco a customer log on and see daily and he hourly how their water use is core

sponlding to our ask of them. water conversation staff also ramped up concern projects and programs during this time. that includes like alerts where an automated meter detects 3 days of nonstop water use they indicate a like and let them know. and direct out reach to high water users. you are using too much water compared to peers and we are here. the way we help them is the water wiedz evaluation. in san francisco water technician will come to your house and evaluate in and out and identifies ways you may be waisting water and not know. they distribute free high efficient fixtures to the public as well. we worked with reporters and member of the press to reach our audiences with water messaging including a water wise evaluation in san francisco.

and includes water wise evaluation of a reporter's house and throughout this time close low coordinating with the state d. water resource save our water cam sxan coordinating with the bay area water agency. what you see is a photo from a press conference in august. to promote draught landscaping and encourage increase water use out door. >> you front mr. ritchie or tipical summer pattern has a peek. outside san francisco the weather is hot and the largest amount at the home is out door. the instructions from water earnprize this summer were clear. flatten the curve. in july we went to folks us on mess ammings of out door water use and fixing leaks. we placed advertising on spotify streaming app. we purchased space on bart

stations in the region and san francisco and now running adds in bart cars. and we are continuing with the tactic that has been successful throughout google search engine advertising. you pay to have your content connected to preprogrammed google search. if someone in hayward looks up water rebate program or ad come up. >> it is increased engagement this year and effective tool. we have tried a lot of strategic partnerships to extend our reach. working with the san francisco apartment association. the golden gate restaurant association. water conversation messaging in san francisco airports. by part largest partnership this summer with the san francisco giants.

advertising on the roduring games. tv drop in's if you watch in between batters break out in water conversation messaging. includes a lot of social modia digital ad. e mail blast for major league baseball. filmed public service, nounsment with the giant's mascot republican inside the park and social modia. if you were in the park you might have seen it on the main screen and all the way finding signs and the ribbon on the park as limp this including 6 in person activations we met fans at the gates with actuals if they answered a trivia question. got a rolly tile. i will say we had 3,000 high quality educational inneractions with fans it was irrelevant successful. so we set forth for ourselves 3

trackable metrics. the first was reduction of water use. 2, engagement with content this is electronic in the click and individuals to the pages on the website. and engagement with service are people taking us up on our offer of help. they are updated the campaign is on going. you will see 78 million impressions and when someone cease your contentful 155,000 clicks we got from dast from maker league baseball and giants and looks like 80 million impressions. website traffic increased. you see that we had an increase in asks for water conversation services and calls for water conversation bureau. the most person number is

reduction of water reduce that was 10.5 increase. we fell hor and appeared in then a bit overnight summer we have more work to do. that is next? we will take a break from advertise thanksgiving winlt. refresh and restrategize and wait from direction from water and where we want to go we be ready when you need us. i want to thank you for opportunity to speak and happy to take questions. thank you. any comments. go ahead. sure. that was wonderful you know there was the things called robo calls and like click get rid of social media that don't get that message and you get rid you sewn

it 100 times i have seen a lot of these by being a citizen of san francisco. and there is never anything intrusive. the message has been up there with this type of a word but it is -- seems like effective. it was effective on me. but that said, very good job. this was impressive. thanks. >> thank you. >> i have a question for you. it is wornful and i'm glad to see all this. this is fantastic. this might be a question you motive fot not have an answer. do we know how many are on autopay for their bill? i don't know that might be something tong b. people on autopay are not seeing your ad. on the payment's page.

one other comment i'm excited by water wise evaluation. and you mentioned that the advertise specials people search for water conversation. in some areas and just one quick thought on that is on the autopay and the specific thing, we want to make sure we reach people not searching for water conversation. well is an an -- world war ii at of the planes that were coming back they were everybodying was focusing. smg coming back safe. they were shot out. focusing on the yours that were shot at. and somebody realized this is a bad idea these people survived we need to look at the other parts of plane that makes the

plane fall. nile family is on autopay we don't see our water bill. so just 2 examples of focusing on people who motive not be interact with our system as much you are pausing and rethinking 2 ideas for you >> good point. the multiple term we

preprogrammed started with draught and water conversation. we started getting engage when we did water combil rebate programs we know people therein is a draught. this is information that can help us be more effective. other comments? >> okay. public comment. thank you. >> members who wish to make 2 machines of remote comment on 9b, press star 3 to speak. do we have anyone present? do we have callers with hands raised? there are 2 callers in the queue. hello your line is open you have 2 minutes. >> greatest will daved again.

so good work upon on the comprehensive war communication efforts. i wanted to relate the quick history i'm thinking that was 15 or 20 yearsing on there was a fair amount of out reach about the sewer system improve am program and a fairly provocative set of messages used. i think the best was your number 2 is our number 1 when tyrone was in charge of communications or sewer out reach. i'm not sure how edgy the campaign could be or should be buoy think when we get a little more edgy that gets more attention. i don't know how well this is receive in the other community or how well this translate in

other cull urs and languages but you know the more one can impress the idea of water conversation now and in the future the better. we should cell brit that we use less water per capita than others. again, great w on the communication efforts. thank you very much. next caller you have 2 minutes. peter tuolumne river trust.

congratulate mrs. roads on a high energy presentation i see why we are getting ruand wonderful if we put her on the salmon issue. i got the numbers for the river 541 counted so far. 541, 22 for tuolumne. that's a much big are difference than last year where it was 10 to one. thank you. no more calls 9c gentleman affairs update and meaghan scott will present. >> good afternoon meaghan scott the acting director of policy and gentleman affairs. we are a small and sponsive team that works with staff to veterans sfpuc legislative and

policy priorities. i want to start by recognizing my team. jenny reyes. rebecca peacock. scott and jeremy spitz. thank you for your hard work. commissioner in your meeting materials have you a written memo highlighting our activity from the year it has been a busy year. at the local level secured 35 legislative items before the board of supervisors and handled 100 consit web requests. worked to electronic over 300 bill this is year and enengage on high priority issues. ip proud of the w that our team has don advocate and secure state and federal funding. this had been a multiyear effort involving many stake holers working with our industry association. and to date provided over 20 million dollars for rate payor relief and additional help on the way with funding for power

early next year. we are excite body that. i want to an a thank you to our liaison in each enterprises. thank you for your partnership and hard work this year. i want to thank our state lobby i have had don gilbert. jason and bridgette they represent us in sacramento we appreciate it. at the federal level it has been an exciting year with the passage. 2 historic bills the infrastructure investment and job's act and inflation reduction act. my team has been working with staff across the agency to explore funding opportunity as they roll out and to advocate for agency's priors and projects. we organized a productive trip to washington for general manager herrera and flynn and it was time well spent in person with our congressional offices

and federal agencies talking about our priorities. as we look toward the next year my team's top priorities will be infrastructure and rate pear payor assistance they are critical leaderships of the broader affordability strategy. thank you and i'm happy to take questions. >> commissioner maxwell. thank you. >> thank you. it was good reading thank you i have done a lot of great work. on 1469 new bradford water rates. what will they get from decoupling the water sales from the revenue? >> i think tell help incent sunrise the conversation that we have been talking about perfect segue. selling water as a unit there is incentive to sell units to make prefer that decoupling allows them to incentivize conversation

in that way by not having rates tied to the units of water used. >> great. thank you. commissioner? >> we have a dedicated lookyist for all 3 of the different enterprises in different departments? is that this is most low for local and state and dc when needed >> we have one in sacramento represents us the 3 i named work for this firm in sacramento. reminds me of the firm is etsdzstein and smith. [inaudible]. and the federal level our contract previous lobbyist expired we are in the procure am process for new lobby service. anybody like on point in the city to do that, too. >> we work closely with the

mayor's office and the federal level. thank you. i want to say water is a front and center a lot of legislative processes and i think i mentioned it is important to be on the right side. sometimes may sounds doyle implement or handle you know different leaderships that goes into the bills. i think for it is good for us to make sure that the try to work to make them make them work for nus a broader community and on the right side of the issue i appreciate you focus on rate assistance it is an important issue. we i know there are challenges

in distributing that money from the federal level we have been trying to figure out local low this is an important issue when it come to environmental justice and access to water. so i'm happy to see you are trying to have been working on that with different legislative avenues especially since going through both state legislator and the federal level. so i appreciate to see this and want to say you are from my perspective important to be on the right side and. deal with the challenges. thank you. i like to really want to comp limit meaghan and alexander who did a fabulous job organizing our trip to wish wash she referred to in terms of both our

congressional delegation and the agencies we met with epa and at the army core. they did a fabulous job and it was clear that the federal agencies are impressed with where their money has been going and i want to compliment them for organizing a wornful trip in the entirety of the government affair's operation. did a great job. >> thank you very much. great i'm glad. one quick thought i have there is -- we have been a lead mera few areas everybody people agencies cannot [inaudible] buoy want to make sure we are leader help is rescue noised. because we are small we are small and mighty as a utility i want to make sure a lot of efforts we have is highlighted

and rebel indicated in other parts of the state and country. i appreciate you going there and i think your leadership is need in the this process as you work with different member of legislative body. thank you. >> thank you. public comment, please. thank you. >> members who wish it make 2 minutes of remote comment on 9c, press star 3 to speak. do we have callers with hands raised. where there are 2 callers. >> hello you have. >> commissioners. i have raised up my hand on 9 b but i will connected to 9c. what i want to say to you commissioner is -- you do know

that we have the infrastructure bill that has reached you all. and this is a golden opportunity for us to set time reaching up millions and millions of gallons of water into the previous present upper on 9b all over the place. you have to learn, commissioners, that we need to do a need's assessment in our backyard. [inaudible] pipes not upgraded and over 1, 205 miles in the city we also have the pipes [inaudible] [echo heard to

understand]. for the tenacity to address this major issue of millions of gallons of water [inaudible] 40 million of [inaudible]. it is's shame to talk about conversation. learn to do a good need's assess am. use now, appropriate for the infrastructure bill so this we can do real time reaching out millions of gallons of water in the [inaudible]. learn to stop telling the people what to do when you yourself cannot do a basic thing like hai stated. thank you very much. >> thank you for your comments. >> next caller, 2 machines y.

thank you for the policy and gentleman affair's update. good work i have one minor quibble on the letterhead for this report it still shoes former president moran. use current letterhead i asoul there would be a new letterhead tomorrow morning reflecting all 5 commissioners and the election of officers. i know there are various types used throughout the organization but it is important to affect the current leadership on the appropriate letterhead. thank you for listening. >> thank you for your comments. there are no more caller in the queue. public upon comment is closed. >> that concludes my report. >> excellent. thank you so much. i guess you are move to the next item.

read the next item >> 10, new commission business. >> new business? can we have public comment on this. do we need to have. >> no. >> okay. >> so read the next item. >> next is 11 issue consent calendar. any comments on the consent calendar? any questions? none. open for public comment, please. >> members who wish to make 2 minutes of comment on 11 the consent calendar press star 3 to speak. are there members present who wish to provide comment on item 11? mr. moderator do we have callers with hands. where there is one caller in the

queue. >> your line is open. 2 minutes. >> great. david again. i don't need any of the items pulled i have a couple of brief comments on item 11a. the verification line is missing the word, of. on 11b, i would clean up the fifth where as clause. i have no idea despite all my involvement with muni i don't know what pol and depolar support means. and usually muni trolley bus system troll harburg in general

modifications and close out, items it is helpful if the staff report and resolution makes clear if there are changes to money, scope and or time. and so for example if an increase. 100,000 i might add with no change in scope to be clear money, scope and time those other reasons why a modification is other then and there that i have no issues with consent. >> thank you. >> there are no more callers in the queue. >> thank you public comment on item 11 is closed. >> can i have a motion and second on this item >> move to approve. >> second. >> thank you. madam secretary, roll call. >> ajami. >> aye >> maxwell. >> aye >> paulson.

>> aye >> rivera. >> aye >> commissioner stacie. >> aye. >> 5 aye's. >> next item. >> item 12 authorize sfpuc partnership program and request the general manager seek authorization of the program from the board of supervisors by ordinance with the program parameter in attachment a, b, develop rules for the program to ensure the transparent and implementation and enforcement and c, staff the program to efficient low impelement the program. >> before staff presents there are a now herey. i'm proud of the work that

has been done to strengthen the social impact partnership program by the entirety of the staff. in ash linement with values of trans paraphernalias, accountability and good governors. puc a year ago i watched our staff under go a deep evaluation press to identify best practice in yours if improvement. and this opportunity to authorize the program is a long time coming. as you know soon after i joined an audit was conduct in the 2021 and made 7 recommendations we agreed to impelement the end of the year. we have completed 5 out of the 7. the remanipulating 2 are one, coming to you today and legislating the program at the board of sprierdzs and 2, developing rowels which we have done and informed by today's

conversations. >> this powerful program is worth the effort of our staff over of the last year. put in practice have yous to be a good neighbor to the commune impacts by the contracts being project and operations. call nothing our private contractors to dot same. last decade the program lead to social impact communities in san francisco and across the puc service territory and provided a model that partners have sought to replicate. it is with pleasure i introduce the presenters republicany and chelsea acting director of strategy, planning innovation. i rescue noise this program has

received, let of attention over the course of the last year and beyond exitment to compliment the entirety of our staff for commitment of trans paraphernalias in the community. a moment to recognize valerie. okaying social per inship manager and the work they have committed to. on this program. we are excited to present to you about the social impact partnership program. first everfirst i want to reground in the policies this commission unanimously passed which helps guide the peculiar

peculiar in how we do business and assist us toward the utility of the fufrment environmental justice is will do no harm toft environment nor toft communities affected boy our services. second, is our community benefit's policy. which is our good neighbor policy and our agency's ain't to positively impact communities. and lastly in 2020 our racial justice resolution that recommits the agency to veterans racial justice and equity throughout our agency including the contracting processes. make meaningful impacts. make commitments delivered during the term of their contract. the sip program in accomplice

for over a decade begin nothing 2011 and included in 90 contracts from professional services, construction and power procurement. the sip commitments delivered throughout the agency service territory the puc past projects, contract and prescriptions ranging from bayview to tuolumne st. john's and he east palo alto and the south bay. >> the sip program has 4 yours that firms decide to criminality commitments. education, environment and commune health, job exposure and small businesses. this next prosecute voids a snapshot of the impact the program had the past decade. important to say share this program impacts our service translator and all the rate payors can benefit. paid intern shps for young people in tuolumne and here

throughout the city of san francisco. education commitments allowed for teach are development and the expansion of literacy learn negligent public school system. these have a direct nexus to our agency. i am now furn it over to chelsea. >> other examples under the small business program area, there are programs like this in bivow want specialing food venders, contributing to economic development in the community by investing in technical assistance and bringing now food vendor businesses from the stages the business development to brick and mortar. and under environment and community health one of the pictures you see there is a program this is east palo alto serves by sfpuc water log high

school students environmental stewards, spent weeks learning about history of water. created a vo and present this vo to their community. so again these are the program of the last decade has been able to produce many, many meaningful out come and hopes that the stories give you a look in some of that. over the left year the puc done work thank you to general manager herrera to identify upon opportunity to strengthen the program. some of those improvements includes administrative improvements including upgrading data systems and verification of reporting from firms. imprufg internal recension policy and more. we lunched a public interactive barb board on the website

regarding all sip commitment and progress to date and beneficiaries that received any single volunteer hour through the programs. encourage folks to check that out on the website. we are excited. we built a registry for nonprofit organization or public school who is sign themselves up and serve as a to the for firm its ewe likewise that registry, identify potential beneficiaries in the program area and geography that they apply to. identify those potential per in and deteriorated rowels for the sip program. formalizing the governors, administration and requirements we have an initial deteriorate of this that is informed by feedback from the conversation and feedback from you as commissioners. and we will looking forward to finalizing that after we have

gone through this legislative process. >> could i interrupt here. so the last bullet point on the last slide about drafting rules and regulation system that with what -- herrera said. an eye toward the board of supervisors is this part of what this drafting of rowels is for? a preliminary idea of concepts what construct the program. >> sure. i will go to my next slide i think -- answers your question. >> thank you. we are here today to approve the per inship program the first step of authorization. the second would be go to the board of supervisors for formal authorization by the board. the rules and regulations there will be a great level of defy tail in those. this are not necessary low don't not appropriate for legislatedive press but will

come become to you at the commission for review. so, in terms of the authorization today. the intent is to further ensure the delivery of commitments to the community through enforcement and out loyaling program terse condition transacts and thresholds that sip, ploys to. legal remedies and key tools and processes to maximize transparency. with this i think we are help to answer questions and thank you for your time. >> thank you, both. any comments, colleagues? >> go ahead. why hello i wanted make a couple comments. as i was reading through presentation this is the most outstanding program i have seen for a government entity to reach

out and you know have this unbelievable social impact on our future and kids and neighborhoods you know. i just -- to me i was blown, way. i thank you is outstanding -- you guys are doing great work this is an unbelievable program that i wholehearted low support and i feel like i was just so moved by the affect it is happening. this it is affecting our kids. and our future. so i wanted to give this foal thanksgiving i had about this. i think you are doing very good work and i toll low appreciate it. and i look forward to this moving forward and completing as you know by the end of the year and approved by the board of supervisors. thank you. why thank you. great. >> commissioner stacie. >> thank you.

i really want to compliment staff. to allow none prefers and schools to participate in it. it is i really impressive effort. i had one other thought as i was looking at the dash board. i know the puc does not get involved. with the nonprofits or the school programs that happens inspect of the puc, another interesting peeves information men in the long-term for this dash board and the public it see is to get some feedback about the programs itself. themselves. i think may be a couple of the

program dos surveys that you -- there may be feed become out there. it would be great to see this if there is i way to do that without inserting the puc in this separate relationship with the firms that are work width nonprofits and the schools. would be great to hear how people see the effectiveness of some of the programs. i remmented compliment you on know amazing amount of information and emphasis on transparency and access. thank you. >> thank you. commissioner paulson. i'm impressed with the way this process has been going and moving forward toward both formal rules and the legislative piece. and i continue is embed in the things we have in the totally

seen at this presentation but i help this there is metrics who getsion and is it role trinning and in the a cycle of something people have done like 5% of what is needed to get the community and the nonprofits involved in our process to be true partner in this grit w we do with infrastructure. we are not jackson, mississippi we take care of ourselves not justice our water but our folks. we just opened 15-50.

i just want it thank you, this was it was so manage 95 cent and so wonderful when we saw people sitting there eat and that's when we envisioned. it is because of our interaction with the community. it is because the contractors gave more. because they were part of the project. again, i'm going to thank the puc and thank all the departments and all of us for really stepping up to the play. we within over and beyond that's what a utility of the future does. it does good not just no harm. thank you, everybody. >> you know i irrelevant appreciate this program. a couple of things. i think -- one thinga is important when you do impelement projects or program system for everybody to realize there is no slam dunk ump can't like go and start arogram and it does

great. it is i baby that is scomborn has to fall and twist and turn to figure out how to crawl and then walk. you guys took the fees feedback and made the program stronger. we are here, reflect, improve and every step here feedback is an opportunity for us to make a change. and i irrelevant do appreciate a lot of different steps you have taken not just because well is transparency external low it is for us internal low to use this to make us better. we can use this information and data to improve.

may be we should tweak this now and this now. that's okay on to good thing and stump knell fall and come become up and try again. i think i appreciate had. and i want to say, i wanted congratulate you for the program that you did. i thank you is important. and i appreciated your effort to go dp find that fellow help and apply and dot program and i would like to see more people to use those opportunity. we want to grow our team internally. congratulations and job well done. i'm looking forward to the

outcome of that effort. >> i appreciate that. i think thank you. public comment. member his wish to make 2 minutes of ment on item 12, press story 3 to speak. do we have anyone present to comment on item 12? do we have callers with hands raised. why there are 13 callers in the queue. thank you. >> thank you very much. good afternoon. i'm [inaudible] will i am a cofounder [inaudible] i like to thank the puc and the team for efforts to really restructure and responsive to the issues around the program. i called to support and stress

the importance of supporting this effort and others this really drive racial equity for the black community of san francisco. i say [inaudible] sfpuc and [inaudible] department in our [inaudible] we have [inaudible] [echo hard to understand]. we have great examples what happened when they center community and provide opportunity for black businesses to get a cut and be sustainable. there are examples where this has not happened. this program is person people acknowledge there has been [inaudible] and devastating impact on the quality of life. clear team to [inaudible] harm investing back in black businesses contracting and building a pipe line for

partnership and allows our communities top have agency and informed policy without how we show up. and buildings in the budget project and billions and dramatically improust quality of life. i think sfpuc and the [inaudible] is the beginning stage and how to build a mtsdz city to push toward equity and he make sure communities have reinvest in the. after being under develope

employing thank you for sharing your comments next speaker, please commissioners, when i want to say is -- the community social impact partnership. and we can see say a lot about your situation at hand. that misleads [inaudible]. which the harm done is so deep that the realistic [inaudible].

i in the community for 40 years. participated in each of the meetings. task force and the improvement project. 400 million dollars, 5% of sick billion dollars. 150 for out reach. [inaudible] and 150 million [inaudible] [echo and muffled]

we are in the year of 2022, we need a digital platform >> thank you for sharing your comments next speaker, please. i'm nicole [inaudible] a nonprofit organization in district 10. the sfpuc hen working with [inaudible] since 2012 know amazing support and partner for yaoing internship includes our college bound program city works. they were a cocreator of during the inception. this sip program was designed

increase equity competence access to opportunity for under represented minority youth. goal to accomplice young adults 17 to 22 in the work accomplice to gain skills necessary for academic and encourage system. it provided men with valuable real life work response than i not have access to. to give you an upon general vow of success of the program in total, to date we have over 100 students. we had threat gone on to be college graduate. 31 enrolled in 4 year institution and 18 are in the commune colleges. i say all this because 91 of it possible if not for all of the partners and the sfpuc in the sip program. their commitment to the program and the district 10 community is appreciated and look forward to

working with them. thank you very much. >> thank you for sharing your comments. your line is open you have 2 minutes. >> hello i'm [inaudible] i'm [inaudible] nonprofit community based organization around for 35 years. and during those years we [inaudible] community you know i love hearing all the conversations that are going on here and -- in terms of asking the commission to approve this program and we support that. and we are an organization that -- has sfpted community college, 4 year university. graduate school. school areships and provide leadership training in terms of

helping the college studentos their own narrative. and of course they are committed to serve their community and social justice issues. . who do we serve? 9 percent are lo income and first gent rig college students many daughters of immigrants. some are lgbtq. other dreamers. our impact has been critical as -- 95% who attend [inaudible] graduates compared to 70% state wide. this is about 95% graduate compared to 50% state wide. 88% graduate from commune college and state is 40%. and we you know in terms of our

profile the students we serve. the communities that -- sfpuc serves. and now the last here are partners have provided scholarships. thank you for sharing your comments time is expired next speaker, please.

the delta mount which are low income and many people of color suffer to beingic algae blooms regular low. we have the big one in the bay wrar this summer. it is worse admit delta. the cause is stagnant water. sunlight. we have the regular bloms there. these are humans like us. we mode to do what we can to protect their quality of life. ri2 recommendations. one is to invite restore the delta to give a present egg on the delta to beingic algae bloms. second, when a new tuolumne river agreement come, ask where you are staff how will this benefit the delta prevent the algae blooms. my guess is it will not.

and the bay delta water control plan is aimed restoring the bay delta. in the just the rivers. it is not okay to need ignorance we need to learn more about the blooms in the dale and the contributions the sfpuc contributes to that. thank you. thank you for sharing your comments. you have 2 minutes. i'm dave and i'm the executive correct for the mother load workforce development board. your residence woir is in our region. benefit benefity. we have had a great experience with your folk coming down here

and -- ruling out the sip program. mainly roll row and zelda have become really studental in helping bring multicraft core crim patrol the construction trade credits to this your. local college does not offer the classes and it is the only place where locals learn construction trades. we run 9 cohorts with over 100 graduateds and the vast majority have -- received jobs with local units or with local construction companies the impact this had is e menstrual. our rural community we are

supportive and hope you material out in our area and bring san front to the mountains. thank you. >> thank you.

i have gone tr low income living you in a status of goodness. actually. and i want to say that because of sfpuc i have gone somewhere with myself rather than stuck in i low income your so thank you. >> thank you. your line is open you have 2 minutes. caller are you well in can you hear me? great. commissioners thank you for the opportunity i'm lisa beautifuler a senior principal with stantec consulting. az a furthermore stantec is committed to inclusion and diversity and committed to giving back to the communities we live and work in. we have been privileged to participate in the sip program. our voluntary effort my personal

voluntary effort the last senor focused on tuolumne count and he working with providing community benefits. having involved in the educational silence. this has been meaningful for me. i gradual up in the region as the previous call are noted it is a rural wrar and under served. being able to go become to my home town and participate has been wonderful for me. one thing we have been able to do is work with our sister firms and come together to participate in the engineer [inaudible] week. just this left march in i week we got 9 firms working together to visit 9 local schools bringing 24 voltories to go out and spend time in class rooms with opportunities and talk

about stem and their own careers. we did do surveying around that. received feedback from the teachers and vol torse and students. and the really has been meaningful and it is impactful we have been able to do it in one week. all involved have enjoy today. another fun thing is i have been able to work with [inaudible] thank you your time is expired. next caller. can you hear me. >> we can hear you.

why i'm jason wold a field representative for labor local 1130 in modesto. i robbery involved in the tuolumne program for 4 and a half years i seen men and women scold in changing lives with the help provide by the sip. i believe now we have about 15 aprentice labors that came out of the program that are working out of local 1130 five on the mountain tunnel project. this program has been a big benefit to the unions and community and cohorts. many of them lack skills to get good paying jobs and this teaches them construction skills, interview skills and how to interact with employ are one on one. the bay area sip helped remove

fees, tools provided helping -- prorided help with driver's license and crucial to the men and women. in getting back on their feet. without it none would be possible. thank you for your time. >> thank you. next caller. >> good afternoon i'm [inaudible] i'm the director of workforce [inaudible] our organization throughout san francisco focus on high [inaudible] in the mission and bay vow. [inaudible] [muffled] who

valuable the program is if the important to the community. often times may not exist.

we are committed and excited about the town to continue our work [inaudible] and support the program. thank you. >> thank you for your comments. your line is open you have 2 minutes. >> [inaudible] [echo and muffled] there is in work for

hetch hetchy. and here in san francisco adopted [inaudible] high school and prosecute voided everything from school administration to use. [inaudible] classrooms and hand's on experience. 2 blocks away from the school. [inaudible] show them that projects [inaudible] and impeculiaring the commune and

prevenning flood negligent future. community benefits work [inaudible] total low support the sfpuc is dog in the 40. thank you. clear clear thank you. your line is open you have 2 minutes. thank you. hello i'm michelle and i'm the executive director of mission hiring call. will thank you to the sfpuc for crediting this robust program to support a community and those in the community that need support the most. hiring [inaudible] san francisco job seekers with tw locations one in the soma and the mission district. mission hiring cord mary lou retton for city build and the home of the capita program the construction administration and professional services academy. both training programs

accomplice pip in careers in the construction trades or construction company anden relevel administrative capacity. sip support critical to both programs. contractors [inaudible] have supported the program with needed funds which filled funding deficits and training support to the upon participates of program itself. this support is inavailable and participatesern the strep with knowledge approximate training that leads it highway are retention rate and stability. we have participates who trains on previously projects with plans to accomplice more. proust sip program it helped us to continue connect residents with life changing opportunity. thank you so much.

>> thank you. there is one more caller in the queue. you have 2 machines >> can you hear me okay. loud and clear? 1 again david bill pillpel i take a different view of this. item i'm opposed thisseen with the parameters and rules. i think all aspects of this program are ripe for the kind of of abuse that lead to the -- fbi. investigating -- suspects of city gentleman and people [inaudible] and what not. i think that this program is in the needed. i think there are other ways to achieve the same or better commune and public benefits from

contractors. i would just include that work in the project scope. i think that this is some kind of an organized -- i don't want to characterize it i will use the wrong word and i don't want top do that. i don't like the way that this is structured. i think we should evaluate bids based on the -- cost and performance value that -- the public and rate payer get from the bids and to bid anything this is necessary on get the w done including w force training or anything else should be included in the project scope. so i'm opposed the social impact partnership program, period. thank you. thank you. there are no more caller in the queue.

>> opinion comment on item 12 is closed. >> any comments or discussions? can i get a motion and second. i will move it. second. can you call the roll wrchl president max ajami >> aye yoochl vice president maxwell. >> aye >> commissioner paulson. >> aye >> commissioner rivera. >> aye >> commissioner stacy >> aye. >> 5 aye's >> celebrity. item passes. next item please. next is item 13 approve modification 5 to contract ww628 increasing the amount by 58 million, 572,000, for a total amount of 548, 823, 816 approve

contract cost for total cost contingencey 6 million, 5ics approximate, 359 and future modifications to the colonel tract amount of to 555 million, 385, 175 with no xhafrj in alignment approved budget. senior project manager. the item in front of you is to approve modifications of 5 increase the contract amount and decrease the construction cost for ww628. southeast water control plant. i have a brief presentation to provide objectives of the on going kruck. status of the scopes and provide

progress on left scope number 3 >> want to acknowledge our construction manager in the audience. his team has been keeping the kayedence of our construction progress. the name suggests head works is the first step where wastewater and storm water collected and collection system arrives at the treatment plan. preliminary treatment the debrises and learning volumeers removed. for a treatment plant to function better it is important they are up front. southeast operation manager told me we had a storm on september 19th. we received 9099ed pounds of

grit over night. the current is upon 7% efficiency this means 90,000 grit head washings and went to the down stream. the grit is southeast not unheard of and quite common in the sue are system. ure new will remove 90% of the grit up front. doubling the removal efficiency. the commission has established level of service to maximum control of orders, noise and defense line and improust visual aesthetics of projects. i missed say that the other major object is seismic reliability and prescriptional flexibility and making sure we are able to comply with our 250 million gol gallons per day

capacity. in slide looks at scope of work. and many commissioners visited and familiar with the project settings. we welcome construction throughout if you want to come become approximate revisit us. also as a first, time commissioners we are welcome to welcome you for the visit. head works is located at evans and republicankin as is on the slide. 3 scopes scope one to demo of the oldest head works. to make room for construction of a new head works. we also install 100 million gallons merday pipe on evans. scope one has been completed. and scope 2 the 150 million per day pump station.

scope 3, conistses 3 major scopes one is new screening and grit removal. odor control and station rehab. we arast 77% completed on scope 3. monthly our drushth provides construction update on 3 major southeast projects head works is one to provide regular update to this commission. the head works budget approved is 679 million dollars. for scope 3 as listed we have completed 80% of our trade packages and few small packages left to be paid out. of the concern on going construction work includes civil electrical. fire protection and various equipment installation. photo you see is of screening

handling belling wall, 40 feet high and our iron workers are doing a great job installing the work that will be later poured concrete on it. the next 4 months fork susto cut a large pipes ranging from size 84 inch to 36 inch. and remove existing structure area and activate the new structure. our project completion assessment of 23 about this time next year and final compolice in february of 24. in conclusion the request today is to approve modification number 5 that would decrease contingances in the budget and the contract capacity. that will allow to remain lead packages being finish construction and accomplice new head w boy 23. modification

reflects the latest bisd the remaining peculiarage estimates and concern market conditions. i'm happy to take questions you may have. >> thank you. any questions. >> thank you. so let's call public comment please. members of the public when wish to have 2 minutes of public comment on item 13 raise your hand to speak. are there members present who wish to comment on item then? do we have callers with hands raised. >> there are 2 callers in the queue >> your sloin open you have 2 minutes to comment. >> commissioners first and foremost, i would like to commend the leadership linked to

the head works. i have been following this project for a long time. and it is one of the few projects that in spite of hurdles put in its way, has min tained standards. the bayview needs a new treatment plant so that -- upon the smell contamination in previous years a long time ago stewing the gas is eliminated so that quality of life issues can

be enjoyed by the constituents. [inaudible] the project has shown throughout community this itments to serve them. so -- the manager needs to be commended. we also have to include the precautionary principle. applied to the other projects. because zee contamination from this area. not so much the engineering -- but the cites and locations. thank you for your comments.

>> caller your sloin open have you 2 minutes. >> daved again. so on this item i'm very supportive. i could in the tell however from the resolution and the staff report if there are changes in scope? or if this is simple low adding more machine tow an existing project because of the economic s. there was ulc in reference in the staff report or resolution to the environmental document. i believe in previous items like this that there would be an environmental review box and reference but -- the project was already cleared. since there were no change in sdoep does not require environmental review and possibly where as clause saying that thing.

i don't know this it is requires an amendment but this would be best practice going forward. might help if you could clarify on the record that there are no change in scope and improved approved ceqa document. to sum rise grit w boy staff with a constrained space and lots of challenges at the plant and other projects it cord nit with and the mta decided to implement quick build project and remove traffic on evans making traffic more challenge right through the project area in the middle of constructing this important new head works facility. anyway. great work by staff. thank you very much.

thank you. there are no callers in the queue. >> thank you public comment is closed. i want to follow up with you on that left question. becausive had a bit of -- that was unclear in the documents. so -- e will be rit more. >> all the changes and all of the modifications were done year and a half ago there is no additional scope this requires additional ceqa. all scopes have been properly gone through ceqa clearance. >> we had this money you are to an actual usage. >> exactly. wanted to make sure this is clear >> thank you very much >> thank you. clothes more discussion? am can i have a motion and second? >> move to approve.

>> second. >> call the roll. >> president ajami >> aye >> vice president maxwell y. aye >> commissioner paulson. >> aye >> rivera. >> stacy >> 5 aye's. >> thank you very much >> read the next item >> next is item 14 approve 2022 integrated resource plan compliance filing and operate general manager toit some the plan filing to the california sfpuc by the november first of 22 deadline. >> good autobiography i'm cheryl taylor operations for example for cleanpowersf i'm here to make the final presentation and seek approval and adoption of frefr everpreferred confirming

portfolio we presented on john 14th. a status report on september 14. and presents findings on october 11. before starting i would like to recognize the creative and thoughtful work performed by our communication's team. manager peter and his team member dondz donald, jack and he kathy had a stake holer program one of a kind. as a reminder a resource plan is energy planning tool used to support achieving policy goal and meeting requirements. a planning process is focused on identifying a port knoll i don't of electric resources to meet our customer demand at the lowest cost and meeting policy goals and state requirements. we are required to submit this to the california puc next

thursday. will have electric resources to meet electric demands through 2035. sorry. integrate of plan portfolio allows electricity provider performing portfolios required use input and assumptions prosecute voided by the cpu c. alternative portfolios provide flex ability to use cleanpowersf. and today we request that the commission approve and adopt a confarming portfolio as cleanpowersf preferred portfolio required by the cpu c but use both the preferred and alternative portfolios to inform power supply procurement means.

we have 4 scenario, 2 each conforming and alternative. the first 2 are base case meets the city's 2025 renew appable energy ghee. the second emphasizing matching renewable energy prowsed with customer usage in 95 percent of all hours by 2030. cleanpowersf staff analysis identified the power supply resources that would be required serve no less than 90% of all the hours with renewable energy by 2030. we have 2 alternatives that include a climate action plan or the mayor electric vehicle interesting electrificationcasion that supplies the increase in load through 2040 resulting from san francisco e mission free passenger vehicle trips and decarbonization targets and a local resource procure am case

supplying half of clone clean forecasted electricity use with local resources by 2030. speaking of local resources we rescue noise this it is an important goal for the program. our project team required all portfolios to include 285 megawatts of capacity we listed here. the local investment represents about 6-1000 million commitment in local projectless. so on to the resultless. in the 3 pie charts we illustrate the total resource capacity in 2035 for each portfolio to supply 100% renewable energy by 2025. base case includes 2500 megawatts in 2035. the 95% time portfolio on the lower left calls for about 3,

250 megawatts of total exclusive by 2035 about 40% more. the 9% time portfolio on the lower right proviced a mid case including 2500 megawaltz of resource capacity by 2035 and that includes the most energy storage and geo thermal capacity. you see the new resource capacity for each is above each of the pies. night % time case provides happy median 922 megawaltz of new resources by 2035. okay. the portfolios is diverse energy mix 95% time case includes the most wind, on and off shore the 90% time case includes the most joeo thermal generation in 2035. on to the cost. this slide shows the portfolio costs overnight 2023-2035

planning horizon. the base case costs are the lowest of the conforming. the 95% is the most cost low. this is due to energy supply. 90% is about 4% higher in cost than the base the 95% is 30% higher than the base case. we invite to you visitor website. and -- this packet we have the ultimate modelings results i went over on october 11.

but first i want to sum raise how we engage community members and sought feedback. if you recall in our june 14th visit to you, we presented a 2 phased community out reach plan. phase one discovery and input which we presentlied the planning process. released the community survey and held workshops. in between we hunk erred down with add sunrisor and during the second phase occurred mid-september through october 14th sought feedback on modelling results. feed basks express immediate across a broad spectrum rates and electric system reliability, interest admit role this distributed energy resource can play in local reliability and a support for the 90% time portfolio with interests in achieving a higher rate in the

future. on to our portfolio evidence to appropriate a staff recommendation for the intgritted resource plan we evaluated each of the conforming portfolios using metrics tieed goals adopted by the mayor, have had board and this commission. and those are identified here on this slide. so on to the rankings. staff weighed the results of our analysis against that and with respect to affordability 90% is mid second lowest behind the base case and second most reliable and diverse behind the sig 95% time coincidence fortfoal i don't they all yielded comp republic results for clone are energy and local investment. and the base case and 90% case

provide long-term rate and financial stability contrast the 95% time coincident case as you clone clean to sell a deal of excess electricity to the wholesale market that mean that cleanpowersf would take a speck welltive position it would be able to recover the cost of resources from wholesale marketless. this business model increases risk to rate payers when bear responsible for the costs through generation rates 90% time case ranked the best. costs are comp republic to the cleanpowersf 10 year financial plan the commission approved earlier this year. this exceeds california tarrant county, texas for cleanpowersf reliability moving san francisco close to providing real time renewable energy. 90% time case keeps us on track

to achief 1 huh human % renewable goals this also will yield local investments the other portfolio analyze and finally the 90% provides long-term rates without over building electricity generating resources and causing unreasonable market riskless. staff recommends the commission approve the 90% time portfolio for submation mission as cleanpowersf preferred to the california puc. this concludes my presentation and staff and i are happy to answer questions. >> thank you. comments or questions? i have been following the work

and foal this is a significant vote we are ready to take. its a big bench mark vote. probably not verse in the the details you were sorting through and ideas the last you know period of time but i think i'm willing to support them vote and thank you for such a througho presentation. you want to give know preservation for what commissioner paulon said this was know incredible amount of information for someone now to the commission it was useful to go through the packet and learn so much with your agenda packet. thank you. >> you are welcome. >> commissioner paulson do you have another comment. >> no.

>> i also appreciated. i want to reemphasize what i brought up and commissioner maxwell broughtum last time on the you bruit up youshz to make sure we deponent over build for the demand thap might not be there. doing a demand level analysis it see how what are the potentials for people to install renewables on their own and how that impact our baseline would be an important exercise. plaintiff's exhibit who is wish to provide comment on item 14. press story 3 to speak. do we have members present who wish to comment on item 47.

>> do we have callers with hands raised? there are 2 callers in the queue. you have 2 minutes. >> david pillpel great work, thank you all very much. locality. file this irp. thanks. thank you. i want to commends the greys greater work on the irp and community engagement has been robust and appreciate all the time that the staff made to work with myself and the other commissioners on a number of

questions. i submitted a written comment and i will touch upon the recommendation on recommending the 90% portfolio. one highlight staff did the challenges of the 95% time coincident america and hit thanksgiving shows the no audio.ing shows the no audio.ng shows the no audio.ing shows the no audio.ing shows the no audio.ing shows the no audio.ing shows the no audio.thing shows the no audio.ing shows the no audio.ing shows the no audio.ing shows the no audio.ting shows the no audio. are you having trouble with your line sf >> hello >> we will set the time are back a bit. sorry about that. >> thanks. i think i got cut off. i wanted say that the challenges of this 95% per foal i don't show this hitting the winner peek demand we have is a challenge we look at outside of just building up solar.

it is in the winter and also really appreciate the althoughive the irp and especially the -- the building decarbonization and electric vehicle program. that feel like this is the target we need to set on reaching to meet the city's climate controls and -- i'm about out of time. hope you look at others. thank you for your comments. >> there are no more callers in the queue >> thank you, public comment on item 14 is closed. i guess then we i need a motion and second. i make a motion. >> commissioner. so moved.

second. why call the roll. president ajami >> aye >> vice president maxwell y. aye >> paulson >> aye >> commissioner rivera. >> aye >> commissioner stacy. >> aye. >> this item is passed. congratulations. and can we move to the next item. >> next is item 15 approve the water supply assessment for 3251, 20th avenue water code section 1010910 california environmental e quality act and ceqa guide lines 15155. steve ritchie general manager for water.

water supply assessment is something the commission has to routinely prep for projects that are development include more than 500 dwelling units stones town project qualifies for this. and the whole idea of the water supply assess am to assess the water supplies to serve the proposed prktsd and coupe welltive demand of other projects. there are very strict guide lines how to prepare water supply assessments when we follow. it is basically concludes that under existing continues, we can -- meet the demands. that if the voluntary agreement were reached, because of the complications of the litigation is a volunteer agreement we meet the demand and if the water quality control plan were to take place wield have a system

issue we have to deal with this project would not contribute to any problem with achieving the demands consistent with the other agencies out there. again this is rivered by state law. it is not approval of the project. it is just approval of the assess am of the water supply which we convey to planning for their use in the environmental review process. happy to answer questions about this. >> clothes, questions? >> i have a question. i do have technical exert here to support me for details. why you have your a team with you y. you got it. >> [laughter]. first, does this fall under our 100,000 square not and highwayer or only if stacked on top of each other? >> stacked the over all

development. and i believe it is anywhere in san francisco so -- yea. >> yea. >> i don't think i saw it there but may be i missed it. i apologize if it is there. okay. and second thing i wanted ask is i wonder if thyself opportunity are giving i chance the new developments giving i chance to explore the net zero water development more slowly and get them to do more than that like i don't know using water for shower to toilet flushing. ien if this is something we need to do to the process or something we encourage developers to do? this is a big development approximate an opportunity for the city and us to encourage a different thinking here on

waterism wonder are we taking advantage of this? >> i think we would think of this as a regulatory policy or separate policy this is a preparation of a technical document for the use of planning and the ceqa process will be an accomplice where that could be considered but i think that really would be in the realm of the board of supervisors. and the commission to encourage it but we don't do it part of the technical analysis. >> got it, thank you. any other comments or questions. >> thank you. can we have public comment. please. >> members who wish to make comment on item 15 press story 3 to speak. do we have members present to provide comment? do we have callers with hands raised? >> there are 4 callers in the queue. hello i opened where you are

line you have 2 minutes to comment on item 15. >> eileen coalition for san francisco neighborhoods speaking on my behalf urging the commission to continue to provide the opportunity for a robust analysis. even though the project site is close to ocean beach there is no mention of the desalination in this report. it should be note thered is now off shore desal which requires no on shore footprint. there is off shore desal using wave power rather than electricity. in this report scene one no propose the vol they're agreement. this is the puc's preferred alternative. 2 is impelementation of voluntary agreement. third and final is number 3

impelementation of the bay delta plan amendment. number 3 seems to be the puc's over my dead body alternative. report also states and i quote, another way the project already accounted for in the sfpuc's water supply planning. and in other words, sufficient water for the project, sufficient water for possibly making san hose and he santa clara permanent customers and insufficient water for the salmon. thank you. >> thank you for sharing your comments. next speaker, please. 2 minutes. >> david. briefly just to reenforce this does in the indicate project approval just availability of water to serve it. not indicating the source not indicating the use just that

there is sufficient water available to serve the project as described under the state water code. to that ends i'm in support of this resolution. >> thank you very much. >> thank you for your comments. >> i opened your line you have 2 minutes. >> commissioners, you have to look at this project with the housing element in mind. and right where this project is supposed to be built some over 3,000 units, 1,000 units are vacant. much like 61,000 homes in san francisco are vacant. now, this is a preliminary

assessment. and even in the preliminary assessment the sfpuc should be mindful this we should not be using clean drinking water to flush our toilets. and that's the [inaudible] indicated this use agenda item. >> we must stop in this left lane of the ohlone stop high rise building and the large projects 3,000 housing units. over 1 thbld are vacant. think about that. i want to be a commissioner. but commissioner will walk and rubber stamp are [inaudible]

that's when y'all are doing. you have a general manager not an engineer. he was a city attorney. he was the put there to investigate of and investigated a lot the general manager now in the general manager's chair. what type of a comedy is this? making 500,000. >> thank you for your comments. i opened your line you have 2 minutes. >> thank you. peter, tuolumne river trust. a few yeeshs ago after the bay delta plan update was adopted making luit has not been implemented yet rust lawsuits and other, there are a number of these water supply assessments

this came become to the commission. i participated in those meetings and made comments at one point they were sent become to staff to address issues. i attended the planning commission meeting sxsz there a disconnect with the 2 commissions and i pointed this out in both commissions agreed it would be help to have a join session to talk about the water supply assessments. sfpuc disagreed and nothing happens there were 2 sfpuc commissioners that voted no. they were being ignored. i was appropriateed appeal one of the projectless. i had my appeal letter ready and a check in hand i gave the major's office a courtesy notice. and they said whoa, let's talk what can we do. and in exchange for not pelling

they gave me 10 minutes on the planning commission agenda exit present exclude people agreed. this was a big are issue we can't address now. they also created the major's water supply task force we had conversations of the stake holders. and present and staff could present it took away he said she said. we welcome that. it is not right that the sfpuc will always make water available for development even if it is a good or bad project but never for the environment. we could grow and put more water in the river. we -- thank you for your comments. your time expired. >> there are no more callers in the queue. >> thank you. public comment on item 15 is closed.

>> any follow up comments or questions. >> can i have a motion and second. move to approve the water supply assessment. >> second j. thank you. call the roll. >> president ajami >> air >> vice president maxwell. >> aye >> commissioner paulson. >> aye >> commissioner rivera. >> aye >> commissioner stacy. >> aye >> one quick comment before we move on i want to say we do need to think more about the land use water use connection and have it better strategy around that. hopeful low we will goat have it more in depth conversation. may be in the coming year. next item >> item 16 rill prove terms and condition the approval of 5 year agreement including 4, 5 year

extensions options. to the sfpuc 345 square feet of space and existing rotower at 322 coral hallow road in tracie, cal cat installation and maintenance and replace am of radio equip for the sfpuc water earnprice radio replace am project and month low use fee of 2500 with 3% increases and execute the agreement upon approval from the board and mayor. this action [inaudible] the purposes of ceqa pursuant to 314h. planning determined this action is exempt from ceqa. if, proved they will make a decision.

this is at an accomplice calls coral hallow. you might notice the sign if you go south on 580 for coral hallow road. it is southwest of tracie. it is -- i say the middle of nowhere this is where tesla is. it is out there. this is a good thing for a roproject this is a key place where we sign an agreement with somebody who has an existing tower and we have no land ownership in the area. also for a long-term agreement for the 5 year term with 4 football five year extensions to dheep for a long time temperature is critical for the straight shot it gets and to our local facilities. we recommend prove of this lease

agreement. thshg. colleagues, any questions. public comment. >> members when wish it comment on item 16 press story 3 to raise your hand to speak. do we have callers with hands raised. >> there is one call are wish to be recognized. caller, are you there? >> there are no more caller in the queue. >> thank you, public comment on item 16 is closed. >> clothes if there are no other questions can i have a motion

and second, please. >> move to approve. >> second. >> thank you. call the roll >> president ajami. >> aye >> vice president maxwell >> aye >> commissioner paulson. why aye >> commissioner rivera. >> aye >> commissioner stacy >> aye >> item passes. read the next item >> item 17 approve the general manager finding that on guard and mile stone security system products are soul source for sources necessary to match products used in the sfpuc facility and authorize of the general manager to designate the security system and a source public w contract specifications for project procurement and conformance with code 6.73 e 1 and 3400 c.

>> good afternoon. ron flynn department general manager i'm here to talk about 2 security products. important to the safety of our employees and the sfpuc. of the first is on guard and a panelling susare all familiar with it. when you come to the pu c building you put your budget on and this allows you in. this is an a system by software the building -- and use it in our other facilities. now we have almost a fully intgritted badging system you go through the our agencies as a puc employee and work the other is a software that runs our video technology for security

system. both of these systems are managed by emergency planning and security systems. the reason we are here is to for safety of employees and facilities the reason is a practical reason. for you to continue to match our system as we grow and build out and replace. we enough use the magic worried in our procure am say we want to use on guard and use the mile stone. that calls for finding by general manager herary and consultation with security department he made that is before you today to allow you to put those in the procurements so when it guess out to bid everybody knows we are going to use this badging system and please use that when you put your bid together. with that i'm happy to take questions and i have experts support as well if there are

technical questions. >> commissioner maxwell. >> thank you. welcome back. >> thank you. >> so are we then them is a sole source contract >> yes. to match our concern systems throughout. our system. >> so often it seems that those sole source contracts to match the systems at some point after 5 to 8 year they become a problem. >> i'm wondering, is that going to be a problem for us having a system that only one is a sole source system so they something happens to them and they did g out of business then what? >> this is a very aconstitute and fine thing that we must do as public agencies. we must try to be strategic in making sure we have uniformities throughout that we can reper se

systems and prit them. and done from a central accomplice and keep our eye on the fact that something will go out of business and is it the top of the game. that's why periodically the security team under takes evidence and see if they are there and steady buzz if we find out they are not we under take a bid study what is our badging system? how we will do new things. this is why it come back periodally to look that was done to say there is volleyball and top tier. and they are working fiulc and we want to continue to match temperature is different than saying we want competition like we put out to market who will install this for us. who will put it, if is a small portion of i learning are contract we need ton mindful that is why we go through this

rehave you and come back. gi understand this i want to make sure that we are not caught up in when we have been caught up with the city out date and costing a fortune to update and be able to community. so -- that's yet question is how often do we dot evaluations? >> i know in 2018 and 19 they were locked at and again now with this approval here. and usually the systems go in contracts that last are building the building it is a long product. this badging system will be in this building i imagine mag we will match that in the life of a current and we will so in a few years 5 years we will look and start saying should we be planning for a future about a new system in changing over? there is time lags because of

the process of building new things and matching when we have. >> is there a way to hold the contractors accountable so if they go out if somethings happens we can be made whole? these are not contractors i hear hall are say. this is products specified. in this system. and yes, through contractual purchases and warranties. but where we getoir protections is hawhen -- if they go out of business it is a bankruptcy we have no evidence over nothing showing, the companies we are in a world of hurt no matter what. we include protection and get insurance through the contracts we are procure and protect ourselves. >> thank you.

commissioner paulson. mr. flynn i'm of as a public servant i'm aware of the fiscal responsibilities getting the best bank. but the same time i know that you know something works that is what you want to have. and with the diligence you explains to supervisor maxwell, i can see you are doing that stuff because you know just the idea of bidding to bid because of the first thing i mentioned does in the money you will get the product and the service you need. and i'm q.ed we are not getting caught up with that or i'm going to vote, yes, so i will

telegraph that now and thanks for the diligence if it works let's make sure it continues to work in the future which is what you are presenting today with a recommendation. thank you. >> thank you. and i will pass the thanks to people behind me who everwho are doing that diligence. >> excellent. and other comments? >> can we have public comment on this item? >> member when is wish to make 2 minutes of public comment on item 17 press star 3 to speak. wroo do we have callers with hands raised. >> there are no callers in the queue. >> thank you. public comment is closed. callers there are in more questions can i have a motion and second. >> move to approve.

>> second. >> call the roll >> with the ajami. >> aye >> vice president maxwell y. aye >> commissioner paulson. why aye >> commissioner rivera. >> aye >> commissioner stacy. >> aye >> item passes. next item, please. >> next is item 18 aprufr the plans and specifications award a contract in 165, 2 schiene. 195 days to the responsible and responsive bid are pc all construction and consulting service [reading fast]. to design and construct new treasure island wastewater treatment plant. >> project manager for infrastructure division. i will be very brief it hen a language day for you i will be

as brief as i can. >> the design build contract is provide waste scombaur recycle treatment requirements to support the treasure island development. commissioner approves tell be responsible to design construct and commission the new prescription boy 2026. within the awarded process. the other few personal objectives to mechanic myself the others at the fence line produce the title 22 compliant water for use the new development. and most important low provide flexibility and future regulations we have to potentially meet. we are constructing this pleasant for the future full build out to the phase 4, the

developer and the sdpien flow averages 1 penalty 3mgd and the big water will be 3 opinion 9 million gallons per day. able to fulfill the development demands for title 2 recycle water up to the peek of 1 million gallons per day. project will provide cleaning update sludge and that small volume taken to the ocean side plant. we are living a footprint for future handling at the island when necessary phase 4 happens. the time line i'm not going back to 2020 but i was here in august of 2020 to ask approval to negotiate with the bidder and approve the general manager's commission of sole bidder. once the commission approved that bid project meticulous and thorough negotiation press and today i like to share the steps

we took. so negotiation approach was done in 2 fasz in the first phase of the infrastructure engineers and west water subject matter experts come through sole proposer to ensure the validity with the rfp and documents we had. approximately 1200 compliance items validated with the rfp and the proposal. once we confirmed thevillidity we challenges both our own staff and the proposal design builder to find way toes bridge the difference weapon fixed budget and base proposal. left 2 months our contract facility 3 workshops face-to-face meeting with the proposed design buildtory finds the ways to the budget and the

proposal. we had multiple calls specific topics electrical, control and et cetera, we explored over 40 positions to bringing this become to the budget. with about negotiations we bridge 46% of the gap. this is start of sum row for the staff's good work. basically we were addressed the 3 categories the first is treatment process scope of work. this includes items equalization and consideration. and that reduced the cost boy 1.3 million dollars. again, as i said before this does not impact design performance nor the level service of the pleasant. second category listed here includes

compressing the site liout. that way we use the cases and that way we reduce the cost am the category for fencing that will require design review approval. the total reduction was 4 million dollars in that category. left we had included enhancements part of the strategy for evaluating principles. this included warranty and maintenance contracts and botch and beyond when we put in our contracts this was additional low what our standard warranty period. collaboration and feigns maintenance staff we delivered amenable to not include the portions of enhancements. saving up a quarter million dollars. staff's negotiation efforts resulted savings of 5.6 million dollars. the starch recommends award of

contract db132 new treasure i larndz waste water treatment plant to responsive bid are pc l construction. at the fixed budget limit of 165, thousand dollars and duration of 1, 0 knife consecutive days. >> chair maxwell. >> thank you. good w. i wondered in the look at the w we do is there anything in this project hai believe the problem happens with secondary treatment. is there anything in this -- new project that will help have less you in triens? >> happy to heart answer. this project includes bilbgtal nutrient removal. we are ahead of the curve when

the project is done. this project does include nutrient removal >> thank you very much. grit to hear. thank you. >> i have a question. you might have answer third degree left time i can't remember. wet left lane in the front is that construction that we have putting in place and the idea is for to do another set of processing after the putting the [inaudible] through this process? >> that is accurate. it is polishes wet land y. guess through the wet land and the out fall. during the events that we ran out you know -- i know we are looking at all this different capacity creating space for -- extreme events in case we have something out of norm and not uncommon to have all of the extreme events happening. would the -- secondary or

[inaudible] go can it be directed. would be this able to do anything in case we have over flow or no? the wet land? >> yes. >> has a storage volume and dot treatment the additional storage. you noted we also have design treatment plant for 3 times capacity. it is not approximate it is almost 4 million gallon normal is 1.3. with the collections we don't expect much intrusion to the collection system. so we are confidence that capacity we have at the treatment plant will be able to handle the bad weather and wet left-hand side can store some. >> in case we have big are than when we have designed for. >> correct >> which it is every year you see something new in this weather patterns. good to know we have a secondary

stop gentleman hacan help us in case. thank you. clothes any other comments or questions? >> can we have public comment. yea. >> okay. >> public comment, please. member of the public wish to make 2 minutes of comment on item 18 press star 3 to speak. do we have callers with hands raised? >> there are no callers in the queue. >> thank you, public comment is closed. there is no more further discussion can we have a motion and second, please? >> move to approve. >> second. >> okay. >> police, call the roll >> with the ajami

>> aye >> vice president maxwell >> aye >> commissioner paulson >> aye >> commissioner rivera. >> aye >> commissioner stacy. >> aye. >> you have 5 aye's. >> item passes. thank you. thank you. okay is there any other items? >> that concludes business for you day >> excellent, with that we adjourn this meeting.

>> today's special guest michelle ginsberg. >> i'm chris and you are watching san francisco riegz the show that focused on reguilding and reimagining our city our guest is the general manager of the san francisco rec and parks, with us to talk about new parks, music and other developments. mr. ginsberg, welcome. >> thank you a pleasure to be here >> nice to see you again. >> last time was during the pandemic and virtual. so it is good to be back here. >> indeed. before we get in specifics,

let's start with a broad question, how can will park's system play a part in the economic recovery? >> well, our parks system playing an important role throughout the pandemic. parks were here when people in san francisco needed them the most. a place where people could gather and could care for mentality health and fizz cat health and have a sense of community and a sense of place during a really weird time. and now that things are reopening and figure out how to recover, parks are going to continue to play a significant role >> people are out and having a good time. there are special events happening in parks. concerts and the weather is good. the best way parks play a role in our economic recovery is to motivate -- people to come to our city from other places and

to motivate our residents to get out and enjoy themselves >> exciting to her we opened a new park and there is another. what is special about the 2 new projects? >> sure. san francisco is going through, i think, a park renaissance. we opened the francisco park, which is just magnificent property that sits on top of an old reservoir dating back to the gold rush and has tremendous views of the golden gate bridge and bay and a place where you can bring kids. a cool play ground to bring dogs an amazing dog park. a meadow to watch the fireworks. fog willing. fleet week, community gardens, it is just such an incredible unique space. we are proud of it. >> and then right down the road

in a few years, we will be pleased to welcome everybody to india basin in the bay view in the southeast part along the southern water front. 1.7 miles of waterfront that until recently has been under utilized and under fulfill in the a community this needs it the most. india basin is really a feel moment for the bay view and southeastern part of san francisco. it is going to be san francisco's next great and one of the most important parks >> that's fantastic. now, we have a great history of having conference in parks. can you touch on the year's highlights? >> upcoming and on going. this is something i'm particularly excited about. i don't think there is ever have been more music in san francisco parks than there is right now >> so, let's go around the city

and talk about music. stern grove, is in the 85th concert season. back after the pandemic. in this just fabulously treasured meadow. free concerts all summer long. in golden gate park, at the man shell not guilty music concourse free concerts 4 days a week. wednesday, friday, saturday and sundays. we have sing are song writer wednesday. jazz and seoul on friday. communities performances on saturdays of different kindses and sundays reggae it is extraordinary. and of course, later this summer we are pleased to welcome back outside lands for an exciting 3 days and 3 nights of incredible concerts and food and community. as we go across the city, we got wonderful performances in the

jerry theatre in mc clarnin park a special jerry day coming back to the theatre. on june 21st we had make music day appearing all over the city in park in civic center. on the marina green. again in golden gate park. it has been a great time for music and ties into the recovery and the tremendous energy where we are feeling and -- you know anybody who says san francisco is struggling needs to hang out in the park system. where well is joy and beaut and he inspiration every day. >> so, the san francisco board of supervisors passed legislation to make jfk drive in will golden gate park car free. how have residents responds. >> the san francisco residents responds positive. families.

bicyclists, joggers, people with dogs and people from every corner of san francisco have discovered that jfk promenade is a treasure. it enhances the parks so much. imagine a beautiful day in the park and weather on foot or on bike you are strolling down jfk, you pass sixth avenue and head to the music concourse for a concert or the museum; it is joyous and made golden gate park sproord. i have been hering about disk golf and pickle ball. can you tell us about and where people can practice and play. >> i knew you were going. pickle ball the fastest growing sports. you know across between 10 and is ping pong and may be with a whiffle ball. ping pong on a life sized course

it is easy to learn about skill based people who are good are irrelevant good and it is easy to play. it is fun and accessible. we are trying to accommodate sport. we have over 55 courts around san francisco. 11 dedicated just for pickle balt others per pickle ball and tennis. we have 5 or 10 space you can play pickle ball indoors and keeping up with the tremendous popularity of the sport. disk golf has a loyal following it is also going to continue to growch we opened our first disk golf course in golden gate park in 2005. and you know, whether you are an expert at disk golf or beginner, the idea of chucking a frisbee through the beautiful park and.

it does not matter what you score t. is just a good excuse to be outside and enjoy a beautiful day in nature. >> exactly. well, thank you. i really appreciate you coming on the show, thank you for the time you have given us tuesday. >> thank you, i hope everybody enjoys summer. get out and play in san francisco's parks. >> thanks again. that's it for this episode we will back with another shortly you have been watching san francisco rising i'm chris manners, thanks forrrrrr

[music] good morning. i'm san francisco mayor london breed and i'm joined today with our police chief bill scott. our sdreshth tournament jenkins and our member of district 6 board of supervisors matt dorsey. today we are here to talk about hahas been really frustrating for all of us. especially the people who