>> francisco city and county board of supervisors meeting this afternoon at 2:00 pm., tuesday, december 13, 2022.) >> welcome to the san francisco city and county board of supervisors meeting this afternoon at 2:00 pm., tuesday, december 13, 2022. madam city clerk, call the roll. >> thank you, mr. president. >> supervisor chan present. >> supervisor dorsey present. >> supervisor mandelman present. >> supervisor mar present and supervisor melgar present. >> supervisor peskin present. >> supervisor preston present. >> supervisor ronen present.

>> supervisor safai present. >> supervisor stefani present. >> and supervisor walton present. >> mr. president all members are present. >> we have the homeland security of the inhabitant of peninsula as this land and the- lost more forgotten their responsibility and caregivers of this place wells for all people that reside in this territory and guests we recognize rebenefit working on their traditional homeland and wish by accomplishing the ann shelters of the community and by

fisherman's wharf their rights as first people and please stand with me to cite the pledge of allegiance. >> i pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> on behalf of the board of supervisors i'd like to acknowledge the staff and a sfgovtv and do i have mendosa that records our meetings and makes the transcript variable for the people and madam city clerk, call on the appearance by the honorable mayor london breed present to engage in a former policy discussion with board members prior 0 that the mayor

may address the board up to 5 minutes. >> welcome mayor breed any opening remarks. >> thank you supervisor walton and good afternoon, supervisors today, i want to discuss an issue in discretion of the police commission how our police department operates and currently the police commission has commands the first to ban pro stops when the police initiative traffic stops based on violations that the- not despite for cite for conducting a search for more chronicle activities based on the officials watch and broad agreement that banning this is a criminal justice effort that may our policing more fair air police chief has dpaemd on this issue and really a positive

adjust for the policy that requires officials to base traffic stops concrete decisions a police officer must make a record of this is diligence policing and other jurisdictions like los angeles, yielding positive early results can work with san francisco that is will implementing reforms and still the second proposal that is to ban police from conducting a number of traffic stops that is seriously problematic i don't support that banning the police if enforcing traffic violations can result in injuries that didn't make sense it is difficult to participate in those activities and creates confusion and sends a message

those laws don't need to be followed we support the supervisors and mayor elected to what should be allowed and not and there are laws that needed to be changed we can do that a conversation to be had in the cameras not by other appointees not account and for example, just look at the changes on our state with the jaywalking laws were introduced by - change will consider by legislative and approved by the governor how the process should work and oppose a basket ban on all traffic stops laws enforcement not safe for bicyclists or anyone so i oppose on unelected beige to make the laws in our city. and finally, i

see i want to recognize the work and also thank you for the opportunity to recognize supervisor mar. >> thank you, him for the work and your efforts to provide invoke on behalf of veterans will benefit the laws of franciscans for years to come i wish you the best of luck in our next steps. >> thank you, mayor. breed madam city clerk, call the next yes two topics that printed the first was offered by supervisor preston the overdose by the supervisor representing will district 5 pursuant to administrative code 2.11 member shall submit the general topic of the subjected by neon the

wednesday prior to the meeting the clerk of the board hearsay evidence that and the topic was not timely submitted to the mayor. >> thank you. madam city clerk >> supervisor preston. >> thank you supervisor walton the mayor was inadvertentlyly left off that overdose by the noon deadline the agenda was public on thursday and the topic to the mayor upon learning the oversight i see the offer dose preservation is crucial. >> my hope that the notwithstanding the oversight to the mayor will appear and will 0 agree to answer our questions today on overdose preservation listed in the public agenda.

thank you. >> thank you. mayor madam mayor. >> all right. that will take that to move on to the topic submitted by the district 7 supervisor. >> the next topic. >> um, i want to clarify you're asking me if i will answer the question. >> incidental- >> i wasn't aware that was the case but i'm prepared to answer the question. >> thank you, ma'am and thank you, mayor. breed as you may be aware our office has conversations with the department of putting regarding did consumption sites into district 5 and after several meetings with dph it is clear no inventory for the services or a shareable plan to end overdose deaths in san francisco as a result in june of this year your

office called on the department of health to pubically present a comprehensive overdose ban planning we worked several months as the plan was finalized in september it was presented a plan that you signed off on we appreciate that at that time glad to see the plan has a function and in fact, opened several wellness office a those sites were chattered in the plan as is cornerstone of the offer dose preservation plan and our office has also passed a resolution to urge you to make sure no gap in services following the closure of the at the end tenderloin as of september 5th the tenderloin was

shut down and further disappoint media said nonprofits ready to open but had the rug pulled shortly before set to open. >> our office is trying to skylight your words of support and with our actions my question is madam mayor do you support of the opening of this sites in san francisco is it possible. >> yes. i do support it it supervisor a need- i believe i

overdose perspective programs we wait for the guidance and working aggressively with the doj and had conversations with the senator and faced with the governor so many people advocating to do this yesterday and continue to talk about the process and pursuing the opening of a site with private funding on private funding with the city attorney's office and those are situations because about legal advice and criminal liability we

can't ignore um, and we need to discuss this and need to talk about 2 and i'm sure the confidential men 0 has explained what i'm saying and if we're serious will work together to have the conversations necessary to talk about the fact and figure out how we can make sure that folks who are working on the case are protected why we've not move forward but i'm aggressively interested in doing everything we can to try to do so. >> thank you, ma'am mayor and supervisor peskin a foul question. >> i do and thank you, ma'am mayor and i'll meet with you directly to talk about this further and we managed to open the general center the issue

that you're talking about and also the plans was revved in september and nothing has changed i want to focus on the tenderloin and closing this you decided to move forward earlier this month and for public health professionals and the board of supervisors every single day that passes with a gap in overdose preservation will place people at risk and overdose given our apparent agreement on how crucial consumption services are in fighting overdose death my follow up question to open up a site in the tenderloin or by the end of this fiscal year for the offer dose preservation plan. >> this is a legal issue i'm happy to discuss with the city

attorney's office but let's just to be clear, overdose perspective is part of our fund the department of public health was a number of strategies and additional we need to be honest before the need for more enrollment open air drug market in the city and frankly i'm not hearing the same entent about the open air drug market but hear from our constituents that families you represented in the tenderloin is sick and tired of living in those kinds of conditions and everyone it talking about one particular preservation strategy we need insure we're doing more around the open air drug dealing i hope you talk to those families and have honest conversations about the challenges that continue to prevent in the tenderloin let's work with the tools we have spae

invest in public health and work with the federal government to open up the over dose sites and targeted the drug dealers that are harming our tenderloin every single day and with the open air drug we need the services and need accountability and i don't hear anyone on many board talking about the accountability when i'm hoping we can address. >> and now a follow up question or any other supervisor in attendance pertaining to the same topic but not the same question. >> thank you commissioner chan i have no questions at that time. >> thank you, ma'am mayor. >> thank you supervisor peskin and madam city clerk, open to the next topic of discussion. >> yes. offered by district 7 the topic that desired outcomes

for 12th street response system and other non-law enforcement tools and to address at health crises. >> thank you. madam city clerk >> supervisor dorsey thank you, supervisor walton thank you, mayor. for thank you for being here. and last year the board of supervisors conducted $3 million in the budget for implementation of an alternative response team with the hope of providing a model of meeting critical needs in our population. i want to thank director mary carol in particular for the alternative model and for the work hard on the ground and your administration has developed several initiative to address response and other non-law enforcement ways to get people connected with housing and other

services what is your vision having a different initiative to be integrated and how we will include the law. >> i think supervisor melgar the government added an oversight committee in july i appreciate the opportunity to share what our office is doing to address this situation, you know, the situations on the streets are different types of emergencies and in order to be successful we need a nuance and strategic approach to adhere when we invested $3 million we launched the pistol of the communities response program through the department of emergency management in partnerships with the homeless and supportive services and many partnership with the fire department and homeless and supportive housing and the public health department and a pilot programs are launch next

year a critical to in the taking into consideration to leverage that and providing committee services for those in need and operate part of street crises response strategies responding to low non-emergency callsables other public safety agencies to respond to other is emergency situations to insure we're meeting those in crises on our streets those changes will have medical professionals and peers we are meeting people where they are and a having critical services within 24/7 and as we ban off the starting off point the pilot program will have one hundred non-emergency for the first 60 days and collecting data to track our process and to

increase the other on the outcomes of this pilot our operating partners will be required to provide monthly report with the deputy of the emergency management and that is an important step to addressing the more mild situations we know we need more tools to meet the nominees of those sooner rather than later this why we will continue to push our state partners to strengthen california's customer service laws and unfair treatment of services they spell need and lastly, for the community response teem in on-the-job of this year an applications process is on actually tomorrow and that's the deadline so the organization you feel will be great to work please spread the word to make sure they political. >> thank you, ma'am mayor and

supervisor dorsey a followup question. >> i would not. >> thank you very much. >> thank you. madam mayor would you like to ask a question of xhishgd or anyone else on the board on the same topic but not the same question. >> not at this time thank you, supervisor walton and happy holidays and happy holidays to you and your team this conducted the topic for discussion and discussion for topics with our mayor good afternoon. thank you. >> madam city clerk, any xhuvengsz. >> yes. mr. president the board of supervisors will welcome the general public to listen to the proceeding in 2346r7 and prioritize the participation from the attendees in person afterwards those who called in during the 3:00 p.m.

special order the meeting it. >> watch sf cable channel 26, 28, 78, or 99 (depending on your provider)watch www.sfgovtv.org >> public comment call-in 1 (415) 655-0001/ meeting id: 2483 240 2124 # # press *3 to enter the speaker line pushed open our agenda and streaming after >> public comment call-in 1 (415) 655-0001/ meeting id: 2483 240 2124 # # press *3 to enter the speaker line you're line will be muted and once you're ready to provide >> public comment call-in 1 (415) 655-0001/ meeting id: 2483 240 2124 # # press *3 to enter the speaker line and begin speaking our comments and there is a 3:00 p.m. special order it is end three 1 through three 4 our the additional operation approval for the president my

continue to have a pony p the public comment will be limited to three 1 through three 4 to fy23 hearing which is when it our and in january so today during journal that occurs once item 44 is called that is when you may speak and the minutes for the november 8th and items 45 to 50 each item are offered for consideration without committee reference calendar and you may seek to other general matters one of the jurisdiction of the board all other agenda will be reported out to the

board by an appropriate committee where the public comment occurs and xhuvengs with the board is potential if you send in our correspondence the send in our correspondence the number 1. >> legislative chamber, room 250 - city hall, 1 dr. carlton b. goodlett place, san francisco, ca. or may use our e-mail another bos www.sfgovtv.org and interpreters will be present at the 3:00 p.m. special order and finally if you need assistance we have a clerk standing by to assist you if you call the clerk's office and the number mr. president that concludes will i communication.

>> please mute your microphones and go to the approval of the. >> approval of minutes for november 8, 2022, board meeting minutes. i don't see anyone in the roster a motion to approve the minutes made by supervisor mandelman and seconded by. >> the minutes as presented. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye.

>> and there are 11 i's a without objection the public comment will be approved and to the commend items 2 through 9 are on consent those items event the matter shall be removed from the consent agenda and considered as a separate item. please call the roll. on the consent. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> xhrnldz, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> and supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 11 i's.

>> without objection those are passed on the first reading and finally passed unanimously (gavel) and madam city clerk, call the regular regular agenda. >> 10. regular agenda. unfinished business: 10. [park code - upper great highway - pilot weekend and holiday vehicle restrictions]sponsors: mar; preston and dorsey. quality act; and making findings of consistency with the general plan, and the eight priority policies of planning code, section 101.1. thank you, madam city clerk. >> i don't see anyone on the roster please call the roll. on item 10. >> on item 10. >> supervisor chan nos, no. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> commissioners, aye. >> xhirgd, no. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye.

>> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> commissioner chan, aye. >> there are 9 i's with supervisor chan andervir melgar in descent. >> passes with a 9 two vote. >> call consistent with the criteria set forth in state law, and approving the police department's use of equipment policy. . thank you very much. madam city clerk, would you please call the roll. on item 11. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, no. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye.

>> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 10 i's and one no with supervisor dorsey in descent. >> this is passed and madam city clerk, call 12 and 13. >> -leather and lgbtq cultural district and soma pilipinas-filipino cultural heritage district]sponsors: dorsey; ronen and safai. dorsey; ronen and safai. dorsey; ronen and safai. dorsey; ronen and safai.

banners on up to 200 city-owned poles within that cultural district; and to codify the existing exemption of the soma pilipinas - pilipinas - pilipinas - pilipinas - district;and affirming the planning department's determination under the california environmental quality act. act. ordinance waiving the fee required under public works code, section 724.1(b), for temporary street space occupancy permits on san francisco streets on november 25-27,december 2-4, and december 9-11, 2022, to promote sidewalk sales of merchandise season; and affirming the planning department's determination under the california environmental quality act. thank you, madam city clerk please call the roll. on item 12 and 13. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye.

>> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> xhrnldz, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 11 i's without objection those are passed unanimously first reading and merry it is 2:30 p.m. >> yes. at 2:30 p.m. the board of supervisors has a special 0 order they recognize and individuals of the city and county of san francisco for their service. >> thank you very much. madam city clerk, and colleagues today two special commendations from supervisor stefani and myself and supervisor stefani.

>> thank you president walton and enjoying in the commendation for francisco come up to the podium. >> (clapping.) colleagues any great honor to celebrate her 2 two years of service for city and county of san francisco how cabin the criteria to willie brown junior and continued a critical manager for the economic development infrastructure labor and community perhaps and served as a prime base on stakeholders under gaichd and to sit down on the human rights she served on this body for 6 years and concluded her tenure on november 11th during her time

many highlight advocating for and organizing competency training for law enforcement. >> ongoing for religious free speech and engagement and securing places of worship and advocating for right for women's and religious free speech a true community leader and served on the county transportation advisory commission and chairs the middle eastern grouping and serves on the board of directors of the san francisco council and a partner of truman working an opportunity to help the development and democracy. and a founder and ceo of the consulting, inc., of san francisco woman out in business and campus for lengthening women to office a true friend i can't

say enough about she is one of my favorite people in the world and done so much for san francisco and so many of us have benefited from our generosity and support a you're just an amazing person i and i donor you it is my just a second commissioner chan has word thank you for your service for the city and county of san francisco (clapping.) i had the honor or knowing the commissioners for several years not only just been an amazing resident of the city but anyone that fought for all of us and different ways and different capabilities and most certainly been an advocate for our community and overlooked

sometimes so thank you for stepping up and serving as a commissioner but for all the great work in our community working hard to make sure that the president obama got leaked make sure the resources are available we can get things done here in the city and want to say. thank you. >> appreciate you so much for your continued work and looking forward to other things we will have an opportunity as we move forward through the years and have other speakers as well so i'll go to supervisor mandelman. >> thank you supervisor walton and add my words of thanks to supervisor walton and others and congratulations to all the jobs it is sweet and loyal and affairy to fight what she

buildings in so thank you, supervisor walton and congratulations on the commendation i accidently said something else in recognizing the communities and everything in san francisco is special and just a wonderful place to celebrate did different i love we share our love for the city and grateful for everything you do and congratulations. >> thank you supervisor dorsey and supervisor melgar. >> thank you stephanie i do want to rotate repeat but aspects of our lives have been touched one of the things i'm

grateful for your and the work you've done between the muslim and jewish community and you are one of the smartest most intelligent people i know and so grateful for it and also commitment and hard work i think through your service to san francisco and all the work you've done and supporting helping, strategizing and everything you've done and so glad that supervisor stephanie and commissioner chan have pushed forward. >> thank you supervisor melgar and now i want to add to the collective love and appreciation for you're a trail blazing

leadership and actions and public service here in our city the human rights commission and support for the community it is great to be able to work you on the resolution and in india a four years to get to you know and looking forward to working with i know you're not going anywhere. >> thank you supervisor mar and supervisor preston. >> thank you commissioner chan and i will echo the comments of my colleagues and really thank you, for you your certificates and tonight think a lot of folks talk about bringing people together and working with everyone and people who are doing that work you're one of those people thank you very much for your leadership. >> thank you xhegd and

supervisor safai. >> so we'd like to be standing here when 22 years ago when we met our careers started together but the story i want to tell last year, we talking about how the muslim community felt so much fear and anger and so 34 confusion and it was a time when people can coil and hide or stand up and have sharing voices shored an example of bringing people together and making people feel comfortable i remember when you showed up to work proudly saying in case you didn't know i'm muslim and i'm sorry to make you get emotional but an emotional time and

approved that at that time proud to be your friend and a point for the city and (no audio) best opportunity to have those in city hall and celebrate the administrator that ever happened you were a major part of that and the yourngs generation caused stress you, you help to make that help so thank you, thank you for your service and you're not done thank you. being a trailblazer >> (clapping.) commissioner. >> um, i'm actually speechless i was not going to cry i didn't prepare a speech but i wanted to

be here and to note first of all, thank god i want to thank god and any family and parents and values like love and passionate and service and people like brown and mayor lee and breed for giving me an opportunity to make that work and do that with people you love and with community and i'm an immigrant so this is a beautiful immigrant story. i took the oath of citizenship in 1995 and gave a speech with thousands of people and i gave i swore to them i'll be an asset 1962 what it looks like and all i want to say for many muslim girl they

found me as someone that cares about work. and fighting for people's dignity and people to have resources and access to resources and didn't matter if you're berno heights we're all san franciscans and mefrmz i want to thank you all and implore you as you- the worth of the fiduciaries duties you'll give for opportunity to people like me. people that look like me and people don't have the voice. i'm blessed i have a voice but that's all i have to say i'm honored and grateful and like the president has said walton i'm not going anywhere will be fighting harder now and please call on me for anything i need as a city i'm at your

service thank you, (clapping.) you want to take a picture inside with everyone. >> (taking picture)

[off mic.] >> (clapping.) >> thank you. >> congratulations again, i want to thank you supervisor stefani and all my colleagues for this afternoon commendation and work on shopping you in supervisor peskin. >> supervisor dorsey.

>> thank you commissioner anderson i have recognized anyone for a long time my honor to congratulate my friend and former city attorney colleague in one of the san francisco's public servant that is retiring deputy city attorney (clapping.) um, matthew is matthew is a 5 generation a veteran of lgbtqai+ a proud democrat placed roles and given 0 of time to magnitude of causes and movements someone introduced me to mentors like the late jim the late robert barns and someone who is activism mentored in cases and countless off lgbtqai+ matt is

best known for the community leadership and highlight on the indication of his retire of service what an ongs lawyer behind the scenes for so many years in any 14 years on the executive staff i had cognizance to work closely with some strollers talented leaders not just dennis herrera but vp kamala harris and attorney general and now senate senator scott one or more and david compose and terry stewart and half a dozen lawyers were elevated to the stage and matt is among them one of the sharpest and intelligent attorneys like others in the san francisco city attorney's office his heroic work is k689

confidentiality until now today earning his from congratulate degrees college of the law joined the workers' comp in 199 three and roles he served in the u.s. doj and urban development and san francisco public defender's office office between 1996 up to today was a claims chief and under his leadership the process we estimated or will investigated responses to some 4000 claims annually and investigating alleviations with civil law violations and we received over 80 thousand clients because of his work eethd for the city and the

trairmz and matt cut claims in half and significantly reduced claims in which the file was not identified information about the underlying tart and it was not limited to the administration one example a $6.7 million settlement with pg&e with a landslide that destroyed multiple homes back in 2016 and because of california tort claims actuaries to file the claims matt was key in a key strategic position and to voices clients what they needed to do to minimize safety and that kind of lead counsel always confidential where i say with certainty that matt is a service and improved the public services

and vetoed a magnitude of problem i know that matt in the city attorney's office is well equipped to go on and matt, thank you for you hard work and every single day and to make our city a better place for generations to come and thank you for being a role model to me and thanks for the only gay man in san francisco is a better church person than i am and a privilege and great responsibilities that can or go with serving the city of st. francis i know that supervisor peskin has a few words (clapping.) supervisor mandelman. >> oh, oh yeah. >> well matt has said everything but i want to thank

matt for and rory diamond for doing that congratulate matthew have served through be extraordinary time in the city attorney's office and who have done great things for san francisco and built the finest public law office in the united states and you're an important part that have that in helping the voters of san francisco to pick one of those long-lasting city attorney and helped the careers along the way from the national we have in large measure those folks along the way you you helped by matthew rothschild i've been on both sides of matthew since starting and sometimes having difficulties and having that-

it is a loss for san francisco and for our city attorney's office we're losing you from that office but glad we're keeping you as san franciscans for a long time to engage my politics and with great people and especially um, what you've done part of the generation that swept in the last years and as one of the best people i'm grateful. >> thank you robert and thank you, madam speaker and supervisor chan. >> thank you supervisor walton matthew and i don't know each other but really speaks in volume how a person's character at the moment anyone is watching and no one knows i know that matthew sew outside of city hall and knew him when we also was an

active democrat especially at a state conference and loyal to um, then camly harris was an underdog. >> woman of color and you remember by her side and like me by her side didn't have to look me but could i and respectful and, of course- i think that means a lot not just to me but speaks volume who you are as a person and your character and always with that remember that you and with that, have a great respect for you and it is i agree with my colleagues that it is great loss to the city and county of san francisco. but i think urging to be around. >> hope so. >> so i look forward to many other things urging working on

in the future. >> thank you xhrnz and supervisor peskin. >> thank you supervisor walton i know that mta before i ran for supervisor he is a great democrat not only involved in san francisco politics i first met him when he was holding a house gathering for art when art was running for re-election a long, long time ago i came to know him as a friend and as supervisor mandelman in the koibl and more importantly i know him as a constituent and a neighbor in addition to professional involvement together as a supervisor and deputy city attorney in charge of the claims obligation or division as a a neighbor wonderful and it is incredible to watch him for the holiday

seasons shopping at s.a.k. bars, inc. dba hotel epik and macy's for hiss neighbors and great democrat and constituents great deputy city attorney and looking forward to seeing you as cafe matthew. >> supervisor stefani. >> thank you four honoring mta i believe remember and you said you have to get to know matthew rotting chilled i don't know if i was on a bad receiving end, of course, i think a good thing so if i were i don't remember it sorry but i have enjoyed working with you on mature campaigns and you're an incredible democrat i

will get your advice for my son you'll be around and just retirement is not a good by and thank you for all you do for city and county of san francisco. thank you. >> thank you. supervisor stefani and supervisor safai. >> thank you matthew for being a fighter for the city you've dedicated so many time and energy and effort to making us better and putting our heart and soul and i don't think an campaign i've been on the opposite side but (laughter) been fortunate to be on the same side but definitely people will call a political when i see someone thinks about issues and strategies as supervisor peskin and supervisor dorsey have said

a trail barriers so thank you, thank you for all you do your dedication. >> thank you supervisor safai. >> manifest i want to say thank you for our leadership with the parties and making sure we're focused on human success and fights in the city but thank you for your service here with the city attorney's office for working with all of us and i can't building you've worked together with city attorney's office through three city attorneys you've been there too long but want to say. thank you very much. for you service and happy to honor up with with the board of supervisors. >> thanks. >> thank you. >> commissioner chan supervisor walton and very touched very touching. not used

to this. um. thank you very much. >> be i would be remiss thank you, matt for mentioning barns and so many people we've lost but i do miss them and those are hard times so, so many brilliant and men and women to hiv during those tough years i have to give credit for louis for hiring me and promoting me that was louis and i have run to the claims with divisions and hope you feel i've done a great job with things on my name on it in closed session i saw one today, i feel like i had a job for the training and rate parties and controllers i feel i'm trying to do the best for the city and the

clarntsdz to do the right thing so they believe in government and also feel they got a fair shake from the city i've tried to do that 2 two years the claims team many of my members of my team are here and thank you for coming particularly and ron and yvonne my supervisors and also acknowledge dennis herrera and one point i thought a challenge to work for a forensics but i think we always extraordinary professional about our jobs and it worked okay. it is extraordinary and dear friend one of the grort civic leaders the city has ever had a david chiu a prifrj to work with him last year thank you and i have 31 years of service i worked for

the public drfrd before law school and d.c. for john burke so i'm ready to retire but not going anywhere and hope to service in any way i can my grandfather ran in 1902 no, no, i think 10 ran as a republican because progressioners we're republican but became a democrat because the republicans didn't believe a jewish person could serve on as supreme court so changed parties and i hope he's looking down. >> thank you very much. i'm very proud i have immigrant and the old san francisco. so i feel very blessed um, a fifth

generation on the jewish side of my family my grandmother was born in county and we have a history we bring so thank you for your recognition and thanks for the opportunity to work in the city attorney's office for 29 years. thank you. (clapping.) one more photo. >> (taking photo).

>> (clapping.) congratulations to matthew and a others thank you, ms. calvillo for housing unit the civic leaders it end your recognition of commendations for 2:30 madam

city clerk, back to item city clerk, back to item 14. >> 14. [appropriation - $4,711,123 in tax increment revenue bond proceeds -treasure island infrastructure and revitalization financing district -fy2022-2023]sponsors: mayor; safai and ronen. appropriating to the affordable housing project in the mayor's office of housing and community development in fiscal year (fy) 2022-2023. thank you, madam city clerk. >> serging please call the roll. for item 14. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> xhrnldz, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye.

>> and supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 11 i's without objection that is passed first reading unanimously and madam city clerk, call items 15 through 19. >> >> >> >> residential improvements at5630-5638 mission street (“property”) for an initial five-year term to commence upon the accordance with administrative code, section23.33, that the below market rent payable under the agreement will serve a public purpose but requiring compliance with the prevailing wage and apprenticeship requirements of administrative code, section 23.61; 5) authorizing the

residential improvements at3055-3061 16th street (“property”) for an initial five-year term to commence upon the first the first day of the month following the effective date of this ordinance with one five-year option to extend, and base rent of $1 per year with no annual rent increases, and for net property management and operating costs to be paid by the city in a total five-year amount not to exceed $7,147,000; 2) determining, in accordance with administrative code, section23.33, that the below market rent payable under the agreement will serve a public purpose, by providing permanent supportive housing for formerly

homeless and homeless and homeless and street - not to exceed $16,682,000; certain administrative code waivers]sponsors: mayor; stefan and safai. property and residential improvements at 835 turk street (“property”) for an initial five-year term to commence upon the first housing and community development - 2021 homekey grant -333-12th street - not to exceed $56,578,000]sponsors: mayor; dorsey and ronen total amount not to exceed $56,578,000 of project homekey grant funds; to accept and expend those funds for the acquisition of the property to the city. (department of homelessness and supportive housing). >> thank you. madam city clerk >> seeing none, on the roster call the roll. for items 15 through 19 and supervisor chan,

aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> there are 11 i's without objection those are passed first reading and resolutions are adopted. >> call item 20. >> - planting trees and growing green jobs project - south of market tree nursery - $456,250]sponsors: mayor; dorsey, ronen, chan and safai dorsey, ronen, chan and safai of market tree nursery; and affirming the planning department's determination under the california environmental quality act. (public works) if

you madam city clerk. >> seeing none, on the roster please call the roll. for item 20. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> and supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> medical marijuana, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> and supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 11 i's. >> thank you without observation that is adopted unanimously and please to the 3:00 p.m. special order of business. >> for three 1 through 34 at

4935 mission street issued september 29, 2019-2020 establish 1,000 plus square feet establish 1,000 plus square feet hearing of persons interested in or objecting to the approval of a conditional use authorization pursuant to sections 202.2, 303, and 720 of the planning code, for proposed project at 4835 mission mission mission street, assessor's parcel block no. 6272, lot no. 021,identified in planning case no. 2021-011352cua, issued by the planning commission by motion no. 21178, dated september 29, 2022, to establish an approximately 1,300 square-foot cannabis retail use within the ground floor commercial space of the existing two-story mixed-use building, with no on-site smoking or vaporizing of cannabis products within the excelsior outer mission street ncd (neighborhood commercial district) zoning

district and 40-x height and bulk district. (district 11) (appellant: olinda meza vega)(filed october 31, vega)(filed october 31, 2022,) (clerk of the board). >> 32. [approving conditional use authorization - 4835 mission street]motion approving the decision of the planning commission by its motion no. 21178,approving a conditional use authorization, identified as planning case no.2021-011352cua, for a proposed project located at 4835 mission street; and making environmental findings, and findings of consistency with the general plan, and the eight priority policies of planning code, section 101.1. (clerk of the board) >> 33. [conditionally disapproving the conditional use authorization - 4835 mission street]motion conditionally disapproving the decision of the planning commission by its motion no. 21178, approving a conditional use authorization, identified as planning case for a proposed project at 4835 mission street. (clerk of the board) thank you, madam city clerk supervisor safai. >> colleagues, i'm opening the hearing for the conditional use for mission street and calling for a motion to continue three 1 through three 4 open hearing to the january fy23 meeting um, my office has received communication from both sides both the sponsor and patent and feel in addition to the letters we received on the matter should he had had motion first before i speak? >> motion has been seconded by supervisor ronen. >> let's go ahead and do that i'll say a couple of words. >> we received quite a bit of our pouring in the community but from the appellant and in response to the appellant we convened a meeting in our office

to fascinate the conversations to have a neutral platform between both sides and during that discussion we learned in the appellant side many of the neighbors didn't receive proper notice about the preapplications. and that the meeting was not translated to the community with multiple languages present spanish and cantonese we learned the planning department was not able to provide the the interpreter left early so in support of project determining the cause of concern for those reasons we believe a more appropriate communication is needed for the project sponsor and another concerned neighbor to provide that over the next month and a half i think essentially at the end of the day, both sides will

benefit for a little bit more time to have the opportunity to hear from one other and return back in january. thank you. >> thank you, supervisor safai and madam city clerk, before we take the vote let's go to public comment. >> committee and excluding items which have been considered by a board committee. members of the public may address the board for up to three minutes. three 1 through three 4 on the continuous the conditional use for the january 24th fy23 date. >> the board will invite participation from those currently in the cameras and go to the remote system if you're front yard in making a public comment line up to your right no more the curtain and, yes and so i'll give a little bit of information if you're trying to get to the remote. >> watch sf cable channel 26, 28, 78, or 99 (depending on your

provider)watch www.sfgovtv.org are the phone number published on the agenda and streaming on the screen you enter >> public comment call-in 1 (415) 655-0001/ meeting id: 2483 240 2124 # # press *3 to enter the speaker line to add yourself and the system will promote you and begin. >> (speaking spanish.) >> we're joined by the partners of immigrants affairs and enter graphics each we would like interpreter to introduce yourselves in the language and know to jump in and adjust members how to assess this meeting. >> let's well agnus for spanish and others for philippine. >> foreign language.

>> you have been unmuted. >> thank you. >> are you assigned in. >> if you're having trouble we'll come back to you and raymond for philippine. >> (speaking spanish.) >> foreign

>> foreign >> foreign >> foreign >> public comment call-in 1 (415) 655-0001/ meeting id: 2483 240 2124 # # press *3 to enter the speaker line you have been unmuted. >> thank you. >> e necessary are you with us, we may is have a telephone call difficulty but what we'll go to the first speaker. >> interpreters is available now. >> (speaking spanish.) >> >> public comment call-in

1 (415) 655-0001/ meeting id: 2483 240 2124 # # press *3 to enter the speaker line all right. we're grateful for the interpreters to skroin us you know to jump in and evaluate anyone all right. you seemed to be the first person please come up if you're interested in the continuous specifically and setting the timer 30 or two minutes. >> board of supervisors thank

you for taking the public comment for 8 three 5 mission i like to object to the continuous i have been sworn by the office of cannabis for the community outreach have not been met nor for the planning department nor the planning commission i suggest the board of supervisors take an opportunity to verify this claim and important concern and additionally the board should review this matter should not be before the board of supervisors i sat in a meeting on the 7 i was personally assured they meet the office of cannabis requirement. yet i have stated contacted on the 9 by the offense of cannabis stating the requirements are not met such disingenuous barf should be

sanctioned. >> thank you for your comments. and next speaker in line please. >> good afternoon, board. >> may i ask you to pull that microphone close. >> thank you very much. board of supervisors i object to this continuous so for 4835 mission they have not met the mandatory community outreach. um, i'm disappointed this project is coming to our neighborhood such as pursuant to section 1909 as well as 1905 b 23 and b 24. um, how can we trust of owner the sponsors and the sponsor that they're going to do the business in our neighborhood there are

not following the rules for the beginning of the application. thank you very much. >> thank you thank you for your comments and may we have the next speaker, please. >> good evening. i'm to object to this continuation of this project. >> i think it is very close to this proposed establishment of the cannabis city how it is close to the high school. and i live in the neighborhood around two minutes walking distance and seen high school students will be exposed to this (unintelligible) and also are three we've seen on the mission

street. two is on- location two is on 5285 mission and 22, 3, 4 and daytime and (unintelligible) the one is on 4218 mission street called green grass. so i don't see a neighborhood morality store. and during the pandemic many stores close only this kind of store (unintelligible) in our community. thank you. >> thank you for your comments and this afternoon and any other omnibus who are in-person to address the continuous of the items three 1 through three 4 seeing none, to the microphone let's go to our remote system. i believe we have

5 callers that are in the queue and 18 listening if you're one of the 18 listening press star three. >> let's hear from the first caller please. welcome caller. >> hi i don't want to talk on this specific commission is there a more log conversation i can speak on. >> it is specific to the continuance of items three 1 through three 4. >> oh, no public comment for just general conversation. >> no journal will occur this afternoon as soon as we get through the bulk of the agenda. >> okay. >> cool all right. thanks. >> thank you for your comments a caller in the queue would like to address the continuous of items three 1 through three 4.

>> welcome caller. >> so i support the continuous just so that the supervisors rfshth whether we need a lot plays for people to get drawings drugs the city is a wash if drugs we don't need to be more friendly to drug users here beyond why we can't aspire to be a city that is friendly to families and kids and not always, you know, trying to get people on more drugs just exhausting and i think the mission is the next tenderloin. thank you. >> thank you for your comments all right. mr. kevin lamb operating the remote system do we have another caller in the queue please?

>> good evening supervisors i'm in district (unintelligible) and not (unintelligible) in the heart of excise and i smell cannabis when i walk by a cannabis store- this is an 125ishg9. >> walk from the middle school and many students walk by a smell that on the daily basis and are curious about the cannabis (unintelligible) i believe that cannabis has a potential will be a tragedy with a young child or adult is effected i've seen kids standing outside those are the (unintelligible) families especially children will be unsettling in the excelsior and

(unintelligible) and other cannabis retail stores (unintelligible) better utilized to serve the community thank you for listening. >> and thank you for your comments this afternoon and mr. lamb another caller in the queue please. hello there i'm a parent with to children and not other dentist in the excelsior other than the one on the same block as 35 mission street i take my kids there a lot of cars double-parked we feel unsafe if they on this cannabis store there are 6 cannabis 0 stores within the radius of this area.

two of them have been approved on mission street and 4994 and two other ones on mission street why do we need another one here a daycare across the street and have an afternoon snack on 835 mission street those children will want to buy the gummies and i want to continue having any children walking safely and cannabis recreational drugs will bring in speeding cars and people that don't live in the area and there are plenty of cannabis stores and walk two blocks and get our drugs we need more pharmacy and mental health centers and places for youth. thank you. >> thank you for your comments we are asking that callers and public speaker curb

their remarks to items three 1 through three 4 we'll allow you to get to the merits of appeal with the rescheduled date of january 24th fy23 so mr. lamb next speaker, please. >> welcome. >> hi, i'm um, can you hear me? >> yes. >> own i'm causing for the appeal i'm strongly against the mission 4835 mission street that project is at the project really harmful for the young people and the children. and they (unintelligible) so i'm really strong object and again, the cannabis thank you for the time.

>> thank you for your comments. and this afternoon and mr. lamb do we have another caller in the queue please? >> good afternoon um, supervisors and thank you for allowing the public to examine i'm ellen a mom of two tones and want to support what the other callers said not going forward with the cannabis dispensary in the excelsior it is true that the drug use increases as availability and perspective of safety increases and the problem with cannabis specifically right now is the potency is so high- not much research has been done so kids are experimenting because the packaging is fun existing and this think this is

okay. so a very hurtful lesson to find out after the fact so again want to echo and applaud everyone else that called in i'm 100 percent same page. >> thank you for your comments. and mr. lamb anyone else interested in speaking to the continuous of three is there three 4 welcome caller. >> hello. >> it will. >> okay. to talk now. >> okay. thank you. >> hello. >> okay. now? >> yes. please proceed. >> this project immediately reached out to the neighborhood as required not following the regulations- radius planning to hold another public hearing no

obvious they breach the rules and a lot of asian minority in the neighborhoods are have i excited about um, the retaliation so that is in and out (unintelligible) even though they you guys are not listening supervisors. >> there is a problem outside of the property over three hundred 6 requirements so even (unintelligible) in our district and the city they are not immediately effected (unintelligible) and also the high school (unintelligible) and open cannabis they go to the stores next to the cannabis sites and also the bopping one hundred to two hundred feet away so to and from school over to

the cannabis children under 18 years old and 6 hundred feet (unintelligible) (bell ringing) and to be restated to the cannabis so we understand that the business needs side revenue and legalized now but not federal and you don't know it is harmful to the humans (unintelligible) this is harmful to the youth and also (unintelligible) (bell ringing) >> thank you for your comments. >> all right. mr. lamb another caller in the queue we be taking comments on the continuous of

january 24th fy23 for items three 1 through three 4. >> welcome caller. >> yes. >> yes, i'm calling to say we need to continue we need to talk about what is going on in the community and save the families and children and we're banning cigarettes i think we should think about the cannabis in the neighborhood thank you for your time supervisors appreciate you all. >> thank you for your comments this afternoon. >> mr. lamb another caller in the queue please? >> thank you. madam city clerk i'm going to be incredibly brief this appeal should not be continued and grant it san francisco didn't need to promote more drugs we have a green space to grow roses to give to our

favorite supervisor like i grabbed the guns off the streets thank you for taking my comments and thank you, joe thank you for your comments this afternoon and mr. lamb another caller in the queue please? >> oh, yes, i'm yolanda williams a retired police officer and concerned about this city's idea that we need more cannabis clubs. i taught to over 15 years to the youth and you want to open up more cannabis is streamlining troubling we understood what happened with the vaping and were you worried sugar served to the kids and everything else you want to say

why don't you realize those cannabis clubs no control how much peculiar h c is in the marijuana it is reckless to continue to think that is important to support the continuous of expanding the cannabis clubs and someone wants cannabis let them go the existing location and cannabis clubs comes crimes people trying to break in to get the cannabis in the buildings it is reckless to continue in this direction. thank you very much. >> thank you for your comments this afternoon. >> mr. lamb another caller in the queue hoa is interested in the continuous of items three 1 through three 4. >> let's hear from the next caller. >> hello. >> welcome.

>> hello? >> oh, yes speaking foreign language. >> yes. you can speak in chinese. but may i make a- in chinese work the public comment are allowed to speak on continuous; right? >> that's correct. >> okay. okay. spshd au speaking chinese. >> okay. >> speaking chinese.

>> not fair speaking chinese

(bell ringing) >> okay. >>

(bell ringing) >> (multiple voices). >> okay. >> yes. >> hello members of the board supervisors i'm interested in the excelsior neighborhood and hard-working and paying attention to the continuous to continue because we really think that the proposed dispensary opening up at 1485 mission street is a violation of the three hundred (unintelligible) and i really think that um, for those reasons (unintelligible) is really close to the proposed um, the proposed project site

and it is like them 800 to 1,000 radiant and we really against to continue to open and order cannabis store in the neighborhood and also i wanted to mention that um, regarding the bus stop a close bus stop 1 hundred to two hundred for the close to the proposed um- project site as well and we really think that you can see to continue to have child daycare facility catering to kids under 18-year-old and really think that at reason we think that you

consider that the um, like shouldn't continue to open over three cannabis stores in the same box in this neighborhood and also i talked to neighbors in the neighborhood we supported you can think up to consider establish are open some pharmacy or market but not cannabis stores and know that like right now a lot of can shop online for the cannabis products so why they still need to open another cannabis dispensary store in our neighborhood. so thank you for your time and thank you for thank you for your time and consideration and support. >> thank you for that >> mr.

lamb next speaker, please. >> good afternoon, board of supervisors in an amount not-to-exceed a sheryl i'm a resident of district 10. i'm also the youth advisors for the san francisco naacp and um, you know, i'm concerned about them opening this continuous of this um, for this dispensary and many of our youth in san francisco are failing in school especially black asian-americans and not prepared for the workforce for the future workforce in san francisco and the high tech jobs if they're going to open the cannabis club should be directed back to the schools i know to the board of supervisors you guys don't have say over the

schools but some type of um, legislation or need to go back to the schools to help the kids to be more college ready as many people have said opening this cannabis club will detract from the academies of the school and so i think that- you're going to the wrong direction at this time opening a cannabis club that close to a high school so, thank you. >> thank you for your comments and mr. lamb any other callers in the queue. >> madam city clerk, no more callers in the queue. >> mr. >> thank you public comment is closed. (gavel) and madam city clerk, would you please call the roll on the motion made by xhernldz and

seconded by supervisor ronen to continue three 1 through three 4. >> on that motion. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> xhrnldz, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 11 i's. >> thank you without objection to continue three 1 through three 4 to january regular board of supervisors meeting approved unanimously concludes the 3:00 p.m. special order backpack to item

to item 21 resolution retroactively authorizing the director of transportation to execute a new cost-sharing agreement for paratransit services between the city and county of san francisco, through the municipal transportation agency (sfmta), and the bay area rapid transit district (bart), under which bart will reimburse the sfmta for providing bart's paratransit services within san francisco for a one year period from july 1, 2022,through june 30, 2023, with nine one-year automatic renewal options, for a maximum term of ten years. (municipal transportation agency) thank you, madam city clerk. >> seeing none, on the roster please call the roll. for item 21 supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye.

>> supervisor ronen, aye. >> xhrnldz, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> commissioner chan and this resolution it adopted unanimously and madam city clerk, call 22 through 25 together. >> comprise 4 resolutions for the annual the annual the annual reports. >> 22. >> 22. fy2020-2021]sponsor: peskin. >> 23. [japantown community benefit district - annual report - fy2020-2021]sponsors: preston; chan. >> 24.

>> 24. - fy2020-2021]sponsor: mandelman. >> 3. phone - toll free: (833) 548-0276; meeting id: 899 6820 7828, then #; passcode: 472825. code, sections 36600, et seq.), section 36650, and the district's management agreement with the city, section 3.4. by the improvement law of 1994. >> thank you. madam city clerk >> seeing none, on the roster please call the roll. for 22 through 25. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> and supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> xhrmd, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> commissioner chan supervisor walton those are adopted unanimously and call items 26

and 28 together. >> >> 26. [settlement of unlitigated claim - 100-120 powell owner l.p., l.l.c. -$5,362,325] -$5,362,325] resolution approving the settlement of the unlitigated claim filed by 100-120 powell owner., l.l.c. against the city and county of san francisco for $5,362,325; the claim was filed on january 14, 2022; the claim involves allegations of property damage to the hotel union square caused by shelter-in-place (sip) hotel guests during the covid-19pandemic and resulting loss of use; other material terms of the settlement include mutual full and final release, with each party to bear their own costs. (city own costs. (city own costs. (city to receive $25,000,000 credit to offset cost of living adjustments and rate increases]sponsors: mayor; peskin. alleged retention of profits above the 9 percent target profit approved in the 2017 public rate setting process, and the timing and properties are no longer available for the benefit of san francisco refuse ratepayers.

>> thank you. madam city clerk >> supervisor peskin colleagues, i want to take a moment to thank our refuse administrator as the controller ben rosenfield as well as the staff at the city attorney's office in particular stewart as well as todd in the corin woods comptroller's office working on ecology i think that is a really great thing for the rate payers and look forward to the um, first time that san francisco will be initiating pursuant to the promotion f the new rate and hopeful find more cost as that related to salaries but for the record ecology continues to be a key part of proposing f at least

the spirit that is um, that they how time they put an employee representative on their board as indicated in prop f and i know that the teamsters local 350 were determined about that didn't bring about that missing aspect of proposition f i'm sure other opportunity i want to say for the record ecology needs to get right with the teamsters and that was contemplated in proportion f and high time to do it. >> thank you supervisor preston and supervisor safai thank you, measure m you were involved in bringing this settlement together i want to echo your comments and associate myself that is an important part of estimate and part of removal

that was done under proposition f with regards again to future corruption to put guardrails in the system some of the estimate are good negotiations and good faith effort but for that we remember supervisor peskin said was an entire need and just shy of the requirements certainly the desire and the facet agreement from the company an employee iron and not an employee representative in name someone they hire levels of management but representative of the workforce by the decisions on a daily basis i'll support this today supervisor walton and i sent a letter to the company

to future this conversation and that has yet to happen to put that in the record further movement in this area. thank you. >> thank you very much. supervisor safai i want to reiterate my disappoint to ecology i believe the spirit of prop f was clear having an employee service on the board of directors this is goinged by ecology and most certainly the way they've been arbitrary to the prop f so wanted to what was asked for you leadership to do i want to state for the record and i do support this settlement i want ecology to know parallel they're leadership to know i am disappointed in the fact they are actually skirting the intent

of voters when we had prop f madam city clerk, call the roll. on items 26 and 28. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> xhrnld, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton there are 11 i's without objection those resolutions are occupied unanimously and madam city clerk, call 28. >> within caltrans jurisdiction, along state route 280, on eastbound ale many boulevard at san bruno avenue; affirming the planning department's

the city or materially decrease the public benefits accruing to the city and are necessary to effectuate the purposes of the project or this resolution. >> thank you. madam city clerk >> seeing none, in the roster please call the roll. for item 28. >> xhvrndz, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> commissioner ronen, aye. >> xhrnld, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton there are 11 is this is adopted

unanimously and madam city clerk, call 29. >> waived),kudrat dutta chaudhary, marco senghor, and elahe enssani, terms ending june 6, 2024,to the immigrant rights commission. (rules committee) thank you, madam city clerk seeing none, on the roster please call the roll. for 29. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton. >> 11 i's without objection

approved unanimously and call item chaudhary, marco senghor, and elahe enssani, terms ending june 6, 2024,to the immigrant rights commission. (rules committee) >> thank you. madam city clerk and seeing none, on the roster call the roll. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye.

>> there are 11 i's. >> thank you without objection it is you approved unanimously (gavel) and madam city clerk, let's go to item number 3, 57 and committee committee committee committee committee report. >> 35. committee reports. [initiating landmark designation - 1200 taraval street street (aka parkside library) in the sunset district, assessor's parcel block no.2351, lot no. 001. >> thank you. madam city clerk supervisor mar thank you, supervisor walton and colleagues i'll glad we have three items were to wrap up my work and thank you for your support the great highway pilot program this

item it is important to the district the parkland district a resolution that as landmarking and extreme unique and beautiful building and a great example of post war modern design and that was the first of 8 new libraries built by the libraries during that period but more importantly it has been a community hub and really the center and the generation of working families over 70 years my daughter role grew up at the library first going to the um, children's program and the single lines and now we were just there this weekend with her, she was outstanding for her final examine and want to say i'm proud of that item moving forward that has been the latest example of important work i

think many of us have been doing to expand the scope of historic preservation in our city and the scope of the building the encouragement resources that are worth i didn't have landmarking and preservation to um, to working class neighborhood to people of color and including san francisco and the west side and i'm really proud this follows do historic laboring the clubhouses and thank you, supervisor mar and finally i wanted to acknowledge the community and city folks we worked on this and heritage and the western neighborhood project and also more specifically woody the people historian of the west side and role acknowledge all the neighborhood groups we worked on that parkland heritage and the park neighborhood

association and people in parkland and thank you to the planning department and will the 90s liquor and marine so thanks to go sponsors supervisor chan and thank you. >> thank you, madam city clerk call the call the roll. on three 5. >> constraining, aye. >> and supervisor dorsey, aye. >> and supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen eyes. >> supervisor ronen. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani and supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 11 i's without objection this resolution it is

is adopted and madam city clerk, call as employees, for up to 30 days in a calendar year, and to create procedures for implementation and enforcement of this requirement. thank you, supervisor mar thank you, supervisor walton that ordinance we're calling the military pay protection act would create a new labor protection we believe the first of its kind to make sure that military persons in various branches of the union

street military and the national guard are not burdened with their service to our country and requires large employers to pay the difference between the military and civilian pay on military leave up to thirty days every year and the public workers as well as some private sector workers with the companies like sails force receive more while on national reserve this has large employers provides income support to their employees when their called to serve our community and thank you, supervisor melgar and others i want to thank the deputy city attorney vicky as well as pta for the office of labor standards and enforcement and thank you to our veterans

that working closely with our office on that one vet one voice jenny perez and the veterans affairs commissioners st. joseph's and nicole and others and my national guard office assistant put into this legislation to support our veterans in the city. thank you very much. colleagues, i urge your support. >> thank you supervisor mar madam city clerk, please call the roll. on item 36. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye.

>> mrpd, aye. >> supervisor safai eyes. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 11 i's without objection this ordinance is passed unanimously (gavel) and madam city clerk, call item 37. >> supervisor ahsha safai, term ending january 31, 2025, to the golden gate bridge, highway and transportation district board of directors. (clerk of the board) through 42 specific to three 7 was recommended and supervisor ahsha safai, term ending january 31, 2025, to the golden gate bridge, highway and transportation district board of directors. (clerk of the board) >> thank you i'd like to entertain a motion to excuse

xhrmd seconded by supervisor mandelman. >> on the motion to excuse supervisor safai supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> and supervisor walton there are 10 i those without objection it is approved unanimously and madam city clerk, would you please call the roll. on item three 7. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> and supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye.

>> and supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 10 is thank you, that is approved unanimously (gavel) madam city clerk, call item three 8. >> yes. three 9 and 40 were not for the to the board as committee reports so to item 41 was recommend as a committee report and amendment with a new title nomination of kate black for reappointment to the historic preservation commission, term ending december 31, 2026. (clerk of the board) >> madam city

clerk, my i'll see for the oversight site. >> on item 41 supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> and supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 11 i's without objection that is approved unanimously (gavel) and madam city clerk, call the roll for 42 was recommended and amendment with amendment with a new >> 42. [appointment, police

commission]motion appointing one member, term ending april 30, 2027, to the police commission.(clerk of the board) >> thank you. madam city clerk. >> i don't see anyone on the roster please call the roll. for item 42. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> no. >> supervisor mandelman, no. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> supervisor ronen, aye. >> supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, no. and commissioner chan, aye. >> there are 8 i's owe three notices with supervisor dorsey and supervisor mandelman and a vote of 8 to three this motion is approved madam city clerk, call the call the roll. for introduction. >> first member up to

introduce new business is supervisor chan thank you, supervisor, supervisor dorsey submit. >> supervisor mandelman. >> thank you. madam city clerk i have an ordinance a um, motion to calendar a hearing a closed session and a moratorium in memoriam the ordinance will make important choices for the construction and increase the accountability for city contractor will do first amendment the administrative code and requires chartered 6 to consider a pass performance had evaluating the award of 0 construction contract we are aware of hour and a half the city struggles with projects

over budget with many setbacks and projects and the delays and while we are really seeing the results of our sales tax addressing those issues are critical to maintaining the public's trust with the city stewardship and sustain the future 0 support and the impetus with the 20 to 2021 grand injure what lies beneath and with the projects detailed and ran 50 millions over budget to allow flexibility for the capital projects and eliminate a code requirement. and this current requirement it can force the city to fact the lowest bidder

and, of course, didn't stop that incarcerating from later inflating the costs. this ordinance will roam the scoring and allow weighing the costs on a kaiser basis. the second part of this ordinance recommendation from another grand jury entitled shovel ready for the capital improvement that report found a lack of knowledge on past capital improvement program and contractor refused as a result the city departments missed out on the lessons learned. and the city created a contractor evaluation database that the service grand jirp didn't allow for the past performance and the civil grand jury take steps-

and the mayor agreed in our response to the grand jury the supervisors agreed to have all chartered 6 departments it consult a performance when selecting a contractor. why are those important i seen examples i and-

requesting a closed session on the pg&e and multiple venues with the regulatory commission for connecting city customers to puc can deliver the electricity to places and pell unfairly increases the costs and the city requests in july 2021 the cpuc assess the value used for electrical services in san francisco and in 2020 to 2019 the puc stated the price was too

low the closed session will bring much needed insight to the board of supervisors come the new year and adjourn in honor of jc wallace passed away and jocelyn kane was born and raised in mexico city and specialized in real estate and lived in san francisco in 1996 and not moved and jc served on the city youth and the co-president of openhouse we worked to support the organization for housing and social services and during this openhouse did much of his work behind the scenes and recruited a board of directors and led the fundraising who believes in the mission and had the fundraising for openhouse in the new center

and j.c. served as past he wanted to the board of open association and member of land use san francisco and housing coalition and throughout his life was an enthusiast and board member and j.c. >> to build housing for marginalized community and spearheaded development for the san francisco bay area and partner of real estate and helped the management helped to help people in- many of you may have known him that operates throughout the state and supported mental health addiction and mental health issued by providing them with temporary housing two fatality in san pablo and one opened just opened i think in the last year on shock well and may be the

most significant expansion that is in san francisco in a long, long time j.c. will tell you the most important thing a loving father to his two sons and the surely be missed the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor mar. >> thank you. madam city clerk >> clarifications have one in memoriam today, i request we close today's meeting many memory of scott a dear friend that left us on november 18th and really touched and inspired many, many lives in the sunset district in san francisco and beyond. through his teaching at lincoln high school and coaching and role through his big-hearted lives nayda k k brother love was a man of many nicknames and

talents was born in milwaukee and had four siblings three brothers and one sister when he was 7 migrated to the hospitality this is where we learned to be a gentleman and your word was your bond he was interested if sports at richmond how we congratulate in 1992 from the college with a b.s. in second try education and earned a master no second try administration in 1995 from the pacific and teacher to empower the young his high school teaching career began in missing missing and at the age of three three headed west to san francisco began a 20 years

tenure as math teacher and he soccer coach and the director of authenticities from 2004 to 2012 and attended tons and tons of lincoln event whether was cheering at a basketball game or laughing as a school play or chap ronnie he came if a big family and loved traveling to the family reunion one thought you proudest moments in d.c. to watch of annunciation of president obama in 2016 took a sabbatical with two teachers traveled to 92 zealand and key west and good news loved to see

people and encouraging had any friends around the world and dedicated his game to soccer and became first became a successor referee in 197 article 7 and was an active ref up to the summary of 22 and he engaged with the california youth soccer association in the cal north in 2017 and quickly went from a volunteer to the district commissioner to c y and known for a voice of reason and was involved in the california referees association he was a coordinator from 2014 and inclined education and a teacher of receiving resolution and in charge of the new voice of in

cal north and many ref call him their mentor and inspiration and friend won several award with the normally kennedy award for the field of athletes aye alter oakland from (20) 092-0101 of his accolades lifetime in the gay and lesion football association throughout his life lifted up people and take care of those he loved by higher powers i believe we have the ability to change the world through hope and coincidence and known to many as chocolate buddha shared songs and quote one particularly sticks to those who are forever english richard

by laughter and friendship you may not always see the results of our coincidence but every bit of positive energy makes it it better place for us all and he, he left the world a happier place the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor dorsey and supervisor melgar. >> thank you. madam city clerk >> colleagues today, i have a in memoriam i would like to us close and pay our respect to mike and condolences to his family died on november 7th at age 79 a third generation san franciscan that raised his family in west portal and was congratulate of balboa high school a labor leader. he started working as is in

browsers and an apprentices and a journey man by 1966 and enjoyed the local companies spent over thirty years on the executive board and a delegate to the san francisco trade and with the coalition of blacks monks and civic doutsz itself human rights commission and the san francisco utilities commission and port and affair commission the house in the bay area and catholic he paint banners for every elected official in the last 40 years and his high school sports team and signs for his family and painted the portrait of the high

school. michael will be remembered for his dismissal and laugh and being a devoted father and grandfather and survived by his wife and cherished children. >> as well as his siblings and others. >> thank you the rest i submit and if i could president refer to supervisor peskin wanted to say a few word about mike. >> thank you supervisor melgar with the president's permission i'm jump in to give my dloepz to commissioner family i right-turn lane an absolute gentleman in his incarceration as a business agent from local 510 and dressed

well and a gentleman. um, my condolences to his widow and four children. >> thank you supervisor peskin and supervisor melgar and supervisor peskin did you have other role calls since that is your turn. >> the rest oil submit and sorry i can't join you, you i have a touch of the covid 19 disease. >> get well. >> thank you supervisor peskin and supervisor preston. >> thank you. madam city clerk i have an ordinance resolution and a in memoriam first, the ordinance today i'm introducing an ordinance no response to the recent resignation scandal we have discussed in the chambers with the mayor's request for her

sole discretion and please max and reporting by michael a bmsz was brought into the public eye those letters are uncomborlg by the it don't make any difference and the practice is problematic in my levels requiring a commissioner to sign an undate resignation letter would be filed with appointed risk of undue risk of the appointed authority and regardless of what the mayor the responses my say their plan to use those letters no reason we should leave this coping an upcoming dated letter up to any authority so we did previously did the letter acquire and nuisance we'll be working with the city attorney's

office and really hope that the ordinance will help protect the independent of the city commissioners by banning any appointing authority the mayor or anyone else from requesting preexempt or inundated resignation letters in an entertainment to have control over them and thank my legislative aid by melissa and killing ignore for you work and as well as the zoo city attorney ann and others for their and supervisor walton and supervisor mar and supervisor peskin hope all joins in supporting this crucial ordinance and second i have a resolution i'm introducing calling on large network service provider like at&t and others to provide

affordable people with disabilities and recognize of the work of disability action parallel um, peter jean and: >> (calling names). >> for all of the their work to elevate the nct assess through the free wifi campaign and thank you, supervisor peskin and supervisor chan and others and thank you to mile-an-hour legislative aid for his work on this and the freeway wifi campaign has been a multiple year effort to address san francisco digital corrosive that leaves people with disabilities behind due to the rapid

digitaltion during the pandemic and in response to fda letter and advocacy direct action at&t has met the first 5 demands lower the costs and increasing the speeds of network program that makes the program free for those for the connectivity program and at&t has lowered the cheapest from thirty 50 to thirty and allowing the discount and up to supposed with that plan so advocates we're existed by at&t executives to make the internet but much more work to be done and our resolution supports the ongoing effort of the free wifi campaign and urges

the provider to expand eligibility and adjust costs for low income programs to cover people earning all the way up 20 percent of my name is stunt increase in the number of people covered by the podiums and provide wifi experienced and upgrading to fish and red aligned next door residential buildings and seniors and disabled people in neighborhoods and all to improve the enrollment in multiple tlungz the resolution hoping the big internet 0 provider will come to the table with advocates toward chief executive officer the important goals of free wifi campaign that is essential for the lower-income seniors and people with disabilities in our city. and finally colleagues

today, i'm sxg we adjourn our meeting many memory of france collins the beloved unsung hero in san francisco they died on september 26th at 7 three and francis grew up in maryland not much was a misfit for the last 1950 of that time and place as as gay young man he ran away from home bouncing around from the efts and wondering and living a nomadic life was by all gets a true flower child we believe doping in the district of his fellow people wrarlz or regardless the race or sexual orientation and possess a

patient's. france us friends described in the east village when francis was a dish washer and a musician with a world magazine tiffiny that was the summer francis stuck-up a relationship where jimmy hendricks and francis was another brush with family and standing on oak street with the guitar looking to hick hick to a protest in berkley and in a v w van in the backseat he met pete had an uncanny ability

whether famous town commission while take a black history course friend a native and spent many years and during his trips to d.c. would get to know the families including one has i do not davis would visit san francisco and francis would show them the mechanical garden and teach her son how to drive on the crockist street in the world and francis snoiftd to make that back to d.c. quote not any brother or husband my father and anything line that but there for us and francis was there for us

newer treasury the creative spirit and putting hunters view himself other than the line a protest in the last 5 decades in the city probably stood shoulder to 140ur78d with him he figure out on the front aligns with lgbtq and veterans for peace and rallied against unfair evictions. and incorporate the issue francis will play and song to lift the spirits of those in the righteous fight his guitar an inseparable part forced those not knowing him by name known by the signature leathern jacket this man loved his jacket he

proudly showed up and with a large image of dr. martin luther king of actual lights in the jacket today as was adjourn in memory of francis collins i hope his love and alive continues to shown rest in peace francis the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor preston and supervisor ronen i have a number of items first respond to some of the mayors comments during a question time today. outcome earlier in the meeting the mayor said she supports a con suggest when you legal issues prevent her and she opened for 11 months in the tenderloin that shut down locate

i supported wholeheartedly and she unveiled the 2022 overdose plan on september 2022 less than three months ago that plan was a consumption places and again, i supported that plan fully. and then i learned on friday her department of public health had been working for months with both the aids foundation and on a center in selma a wellness hub and the project in the mission to open a wellness hub in a church organizations contacted he to shut down the project with no timeline because they were told the mayor will not support that. >> a few things about that number one, why is the mayor moving backwards on a strategy she supported last week and the

city attorney are only dedicated to the so-called new york model they turn a blind eye and setting up funds and why not go to the budget analyst report with other project. >> third let me imagination my disappointment that elected leader on the or for safety and wellness are fine placing the liberty on nonprofit on the front lion and leaving them to fined for the volleyball and needy in the city alone not courageous and i'm not okay with that moma 19 hundred people diode from overdose 19 hundred in the short months side tenderloin center was open staff saved the lives of three hundred plus three hundred and three three people. we shut down the

entire city for covid 19 and not many as that you died and further open the drug use is worse and the mayor attempted to blame that board of supervisors for not disrancho cucamonga street sales she had her handpicked don't and the police chief reports to here. >> open air drug use mass for the changed in the six months the district attorney have been in office because law enforcement has been trying to aid the sales of implicit drugs for cross to a century if they haven't figured how to do it the f c i federal, state, or local law enforcement i'm not holding any breath waiting for them to fix the problem in san

francisco. the truth the city didn't have an alternative plan for getting drug users off the street and safer and don't have one we don't have one and earlier this month a baby over koesz in a park while crawling on grass pronouncing because of outdoor use of fentanyl we have got to do something about that. i'm so thankful to several members of board of supervisors supervisor safai and others for stepping up with me addressing this country's by the time is now to move forward with those wellness hubs. my colleagues and i care deeply will saving live we use finding every single day. >> as supervisor dorsey said i believe in that but have to be

alive to recovery from drug addiction and many of us facing a dismail street especially supervisors supervisor peskin and commissioner chan supervisor walton those soitsz approve the street conditions greatly and reduce significantly public drug obvious we need to improvement in the mission and the t l and mission and other neighborhoods too. throughout our his not all laws are just or makes sense combraichd broke the laws when we allowed same-sex marriage and martin luther king broke hundreds of unjust jim crow laws

and landing him in jail. we are in the moment we're doing the jobs the best way we can in a risk of death and protecting the community from public drug ooze and discarded paraphernalia that medical professionals promote and scientific evidence support thank you, colleagues for stepping up and taking a risk in a responsible manner to protect your constituents and community that is called leadership. that items that i interrogating today to push the wellness center forward include: outcome sorry where did my. >> an updated hearing why the city has plans for the hub for months to open this (microphone feedback) 5 i pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of $5 million for the opening of

hubs for over dose and open air and a resolution calling for a portion of the fund for a estimate settlement to be used to open the wellness hubs over the next few years we're looking forward to having a discussion after the break in the budget finance committee he hoping on january 11th. second colleagues today, i am interrogating a hearing request um, for the family about family and newcomer homelessness for students of usa to be directed to the youth and deputies committee we're sowing a concern in families experiencing homelessness and little program i hope to spearhead we increase it to shelter the usa but from to 40

they were completely full and the need copes growing. >> we are there are families coming everyday and many of the families are newcomers to our city. the city must work in partnership for the new comers that are arriving at the donor a nod of a helping hand together as of usd and the community-bases organizations come up with a plan to shelter families and moot the basic needs and the hearing requests the department to report on the issue with combogz and interrogating a right to

organize news and calls on san francisco retirement systems to insure their portal in to form a on with the long shore local of and immediately faced dense resistance and mandatory meetings threatened the workers and workers are still fighting for they're first union contract at bakery will not allow the workers to organize and true that the parent company is responsible for the eviction of hundreds of people through the purchase of flipping of formerly affordable housing and calls on the system to review and to promote affordable housing and provide a stable place for

everyone to live and support the small workers to bargain. and then financially i'm prepared to report on my work at m t c no other colleagues did their report should i wait or do this now? >> thank you so much for being able to prepared why not wait until the beginning of year. >> very good the rest i'll submit. >> thank you supervisor ronen. >> supervisor safai. >> all right. (clearing throat). >> thank you supervisor ronen i was proud to stand with you, you on that important topic and one that requires ore collective work both from the executive branch elective and the city attorney's office we all have to come together on this important

issue and all have to have the courageous i appreciate the nonprofits moving forward. on this important idea which is one piece of an will after all strategy thank you for that. >> colleagues last week two pedestrians were killed in my district um, just blocks apart in traffic safety issues that abound in 0 city at green house of. >> every dollar for the transportation authority we put towards traffic calming and traffic improvements to implement vision zero. but obviously more needs to be done i want to highlight one piece of what can happen with fta and a lack of coordination we support

moving forward we want to move quickly and more on time what happened in eerntd on geneva and remove of different types of configuration to allow buses to move forward in a quicker manner without could go the appropriate and timely traffic safety traffic signals and additional crosswalks and crossing and bulb outs something that happened in the last 15 years had one of the hoist number of pedestrian accidents and pedestrian fatalities in this area. and those are two more that sadly lost their alliance because of lack of coordination so as bus fees increased public safety was detailed we have been percentage to insure an additional $20 million that work is beginning new traffic signals and bulb outs and public safety

and other things lagoon geneva one of the largest capital investment the city has made in excelsior outer mission in decades we're happy that is beginning in earnest but need to be do more we're sending a laser lawyer either to pc for near term steps to be taken to make sure of public safety and we requested a puc conduct a prior lighting to help that assessment i know the mta and police department are work together on other plans i look forward to their swift response i know many of you are dealing with the same issues, and, secondly, interrogating a hearing to consider the controlled annual performance as we are prepare for the city budget noeshths and

supervisor graichld required the department to submit report this was strengthened in november of 90 three prop c that created the auditor and shows troubling challenges for our city especially related to public safety. only 86 percent of ambulances arrive down from 90 percent in 2019 and 9-1-1 with the groithd of medi-cal and calfresh and finds that the jobs recovery has not reached many workers with only 16 percent of cal residents local, state, and federal a significant drop if

2018 so was we head into the budget with the news we'll receive tomorrow which we most likely will be hearing a grim outcome for the city in the next two years. as we go into the budget season to talk further and have discussion data driven we can understand that hopeful and thank you, colleagues the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor safai and. >> have three letters of i'll talk about to the department of health the first to dr. hammer a response to the hearing we held locate in the public health and neighborhood services the hearing i called on the

jailhouse services with the nursing shortages are doing and the impacts those shortages are having on nurses and the care of the inmates there are and the follow-up we said it out loud but make sure that is on paper outlining how the jailhouse services record how many times a in the course is to stay on a shift sometimes up to 16 hours faa jail has an existing policy we like to know that when you how jailhouse services record how many times the staffing is not able to be met. that has been an issue for the incarcerated population and the nurses and today my office is in

receipt 16 employment applications were submitted those 16 come from jailhouse services and the doctor was the director of jailhouse and operating subsidy; affirming the planning department's determination under the california environmental quality act; and baker places which was brought to light we're acquiring as to the 16 positions and though they're leadership given the state of crises in our jails at that moment. so this oh, also in that letter asking for them to describe the screening process for a disorder rather shocking things in other words, of how referrals with made and don't know though people follow through so we're asking how many individuals are treated for substance abuse disorder and treated on mentioned for

additional treatment and how many enrolled to get a better finding what that looked like and our county jails the second letter i'm submitting to dph involved something that the san francisco standard reported on november 17th, when they noticed the san francisco department of public health had a contract to study and evaluate services is he tenderloin as the linkage discharge talking about today and primary evaluations evaluations finding were published in the presentation on november 15th i have yet to see this documentation elevation and to better understand the terms of contract relevant parties will specifically when dpw

entered into the contract and how it r was the firm and other san francisco nonprofits have say and did dpw enter into the contract and was this competitively done and what are the- a few more questions that is the jest of it and the department of public health touched on something terms of baby that digested finally in my district through questions regarding the source of fentanyl a baby tested positive for the drug and nearly died in my district to no secret the fentanyl is taking a town hall we heard from my colleagues this

incident is illustrative of the problems and career to me we don't have a handle on the situation i truly believe we're a a tipping point is our- what exactly needs to change and continue to be the default how we approach the substance abuse and in deed the was a policy for the city and county of san francisco and for good reason when the aids crises was finally out of control the harm reduction services saved countless lives by fentanyl is wrecking horrific and the consequences are in san francisco since fentanyl hit the streets the substance is 50 times more powerful than

morphine and the dope is over dose reserves always reported 8 thousand plus overdose referrals we proud and do want to see those people dead that is 11 thousand percent increase that is not happening. the harm reduction will play an important role for the substance abuse and december 1st article published in the thirst revealed a new article that sewer ridge my help with the mortality and everyone is getting nervous kwaj this is

output of criticism no way we should stop supplying needs does look at the way and dr. keith a researcher is skeptical that the strategies are enough not they don't work but enough to combat the fentanyl crises and stated drugs like fentanyl will not disappear and the city needs to trio new strategies a river of- not enough to narcan is not enough to reverse we can't make finally obvious safe he said let's see - say it is to deadly overwhelms did capacity of what we know how to do and incidental that is time to ask ourselves

tough questions and incumbent on the fpl to look at this abstinence and that it leads to accidents does dpw donating how this leads to president and provide and list of all programs and how many tracks longitudinal board of county commissioners with the drug and alcohol free what are the barriers based on the recovery increased the elective policies and that might show sf responsibilities and does cp h have a program for the absence based option would dph direct people to what are the

resources versus absent i e tlufk tlufk and what precise policies dots nonprofits through dph to make sure that it didn't end up on our sidewalks and other public places and help to make sure that didn't happen and it is clear to me that i like to come up with a method to look at the policies and to define the purpose of harm reduction as to applies to the finally is it to help stop the spread of disease

and to minimize the over dose through wide sprayed distribution of narcan it is possible to stop those drugs with the help of others i'm aware of the publish but didn't address my plan more the most that suggests a critical locate the reduction policies maybe in order i look forward to discussing this more in debt with dph and holding and hearing in the new year i care deep about those who suffer and there is help out there i want to make sure that is clean needles or narcan or recovery want people to know that is possible to recover from a disorder the rest

i submit. >> thank you supervisor walton at one month of rent this allows the landlord to charge foments the rent and in some cases three times for a security deposit that means in san francisco with the average rent of 4000 to 5 thousand dollars some tenant may need to pay as much of 12 thousand or $15,000 just to move in the create a barrier for tenants to access where renter have to borrow from predatory lenders and other states that cap the security deposits other

one month more military at one months rent now we should extend it to all tenants the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor walton. >> (clapping.) thank you, madam city clerk and supervisor stefani. >> supervisor walton i'd like to make a motion to rescind the motion on 42. >> seconded by supervisor dorsey madam city clerk, to rescind on item 42. >> supervisor chan, aye. >> supervisor dorsey, aye. >> supervisor mandelman, aye. >> supervisor mar, aye. >> and supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> and supervisor preston,

aye. >> supervisor ronen absent. >> xhrnldz. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani, aye. >> supervisor walton, aye. >> there are 10 i these. >> thank you, motion to rescind the vote carries (gavel) and madam city clerk, yes for the record item 42 a intent for the appointment of cindy term ending 2027 to the police commission. >> thank you. madam city clerk i'm going to reset that

( in recess) - tenure i have lost confidence in her enforcing any reasonable

rolls and regulations to provide for the efficiency of the department of. >> um, earlier this year i was absolutely appalled at the treatment of scott announced between the district attorney's office it was due to the da vertical said thefts pressured to hide the evidence and alluded on ongoing practice of cases brought against police officer the ladies and gentlemen, should have alarmed all members of police commission and might not be given a fair chance that was modest by not just one but who filed a whistle blowers a complainant was sculp try

against the sf pd officers the legions were needing to be investigated and pay attention to showing people were concerned and that was directed towards the chief four of hours on the matter and the hearing with the police commission does nothing when police scott was xursz i heard from many members of community were shocked i was deeply concerned not only should

in the same place district attorney's office that was excused of forcing an vertical to commit an illegal act but worked on the case attacked the heart of the matter that was shocking and any reasonable person would have recusedism and the assurances were made affair walls will be set up and however i lost confidence oig affair walls were up after the misconduct came to light and an issue of public trust when she took this job she stated i wanted to ease the tensions and bridge the gaps between police and resident instead i believe tensions were the gaps grow worried she accused chief scott

said he didn't believe in the police reforms that is an absorb ladies and gentlemen, what was extreme allegations they were force to lie didn't seem to shock the consensus then the vice president and now president of the wellness of the department another adopt fired by the district attorney in retaliation for a wrongdoing during a version of another police officer case and serious concerns that the district attorney's office is playing and yet again somehow didn't alarm the lady and shockingly as at the police commission meeting and at past vice president said

that was merely a dis2k3wru7b9d employee rather than a whistle blower and a case was filed and with her husband i'm concerned about the forms of one hundred submit with the applicants packet section 3.1 and 107 the city charter the applicant must disclose income i understand exempt employees of government the 2021 for this seven hundred was submitted with the applicant with no scheduled fee, however, a new form seven hundred is due on april fy23 of next year and the appointed for his aliza didn't end until fy23 and the form seven hundred needs to be submitted with additional information and the right to

left or recordings to a board member the applicant must have a completed statement- when failed to submit a former seven hundred the board may- i like to this before january 10th meeting though the form seven hundred is do you and a new form seven hundred is due for all of us on april 28th and finally, i building greater leadership should have been shown of immulch and conduct an the police commissioner how do we take that serious when we have juvenile behave and no one

should be allowed to act that way that did commission didn't 0 tolerant and thanks to supervisor peskin he subdivided commander and for the consent there in and allowing it to occur tafrndz the department and while public institutions deserve people that comparable to inspire faith it was a institution that garnered respect if those taverns and- to address a serious issue at

hand given this misconduct were met with a slug unfortunately, in their opinion that commission if revise to the cognizance and the appearance of impropriety and mismanagement of the city and commissioners leads me to believe there are others that are better suited and give him the form seven hundred i want those working together and given her appointment is not up until april of next year we right now for applicant to apply for the possession and those are the reasons why i cast a "no vote" today. thank you. >> thank you. supervisor stefani thank you, supervisor walton. >> monk among the commissioners that guide and govern how city i know the police commission requires a lot

of work and headaches i want to give credit where credit it due to commissioner for her leadership and i know there is a lot of controversy proudly in other things that supervisor stefani has raised but for me in a meeting we've talked about the need for harm reduction strategies to address a record shattering crises and death in the city has a disqualifying issue for me that is the commissioner alisa has stvnl of consisting questioned the arrests of people in the south of market and the tenderloin extends the district i represent what we've seen along with the uptick of drug overdose is causing an uptick in the number

of drug dealers said amount of fentanyl that is soesz and one uptick associated with the drug dealers in on streets in 2020 tenderloin police officers seized 5 hundred killing gramdz of of fentanyl the deadist drug as a regional drug of the drug dealers one that year that went 80 up 5 fields 20 and a half i got from the police district 2024 through last sunday up to closing in on 62 killing those a street value of million dollars overdose of finally to wipe out the population of bay area in your questioning arrest drug

dealers that amount of drugs not on the streets of my district areas and other district is value for drug busts and the need for us and police commission to take seriously the role of the police department to arrest drug dealers and i have questions about the value and leadership on and the judgment of a police commissioner, i texted did chief it is procedural eir reconvene i didn't get to come back with her in better conscious i want to talk to her if we're going to be pursuing movements harm reduction strategies all the things i also believe in criminal justice has to be part of that and our police commission has to be an ali i

hope to see a more detailed conversation with commissioner alisa but explain and opposing her appointment when we get to vote on that. thank you. >> thank you. supervisor dorsey. >> supervisor preston. >> colleagues first of all, that is a procedural matter ms. alisa sat in the chambers for many hours item 42 came up. and nobody choosing to speak and ms. alisa left substantially we rescinded the vote at supervisor

stefani request i'm deeply troubled after they left the chambers she's not in the chambers to defend herself based on fact and based on issues that were raised in committee that she addressed head open and that inner absent it seems to me like character assassination but thank you, from an 8 to three vote and dispense with the issue around applications and um, while have announced this as well as is full board i'm pleased that in any 10 year over the last two years as mr. chairman the rules committee we engineered changes. and for for those of you who don't know they were role two-fold one we get

rid of the bottleneck we're in a appoints by supervisors went through the rolls committee no longer but goes to the board of supervisors and one of the appointments on today's calendar and to continuous test if you go to the board of supervisors website and this has been true thank you, madam city clerk and thank you and true since may of this year if you locate whether is necessary new on the board of supervisors you can apply for any positions at any time the world has changed since i've been the president of rules committee you can apply for the police commission and the next time you'll been formed can be

interviewed so i wanted to just to be clear, to everything. with regards to the issue concerning the form seven hundred it is common practice that on reappointments that the- that the incumbent commissioner submitted their courage year forms seven hundred indeed commissioner alice told her were changes in their circumstances and happy- obviously due but april 1st and happy to prepare an updated mid year form seven hundred prior to the january 10th meeting and frankly with regard and respectfully to my colleague from district two. um, many of the things discussed the behavior of other

commissioners um, and as supervisor stefani said i took expectation to her immulch behavior and had he applied reapplied i would have been leading the charge not having him reappointed not a reflection on ms. alice but the gentleman. many of things if you go back in time that supervisor stefani temporarily what may form malia accordingly the chair the police commission. lock the votes are what the votes are you will want to deal with that so the following which is that i want to have a police commission with mature smart people that building and want to have a safe

city. and who also believe in a senseable police reform undertaken here and in choice across the country ms. aliza represents those values if you want to talk about hard work i can credit her in large part has get rid of many, many years bog of discipline cases like i said that was not just detailed and justice denied bikeway backlog were accustomed an embarrassment they no longer exist to commissioner alisa and relevant to the you transparency the openness and maturity in the way she move forward i think that they everyone exemplar and for all those reasons we

wholeheartedly leased on a two to one vote send her before did vote that will reappoint her by an 8 to three vote i respect how differences. >> thank you so much. supervisor peskin and supervisor ronen i felt the need to speak up because commissioner alisa sat in chamber for well over two hours i don't understand why those comments were not made at that time where she could defend herself through the chair ask supervisor stefani why she didn't make the comments when she was in the room? >> supervisor stefani. >> just asking a simple

question my colleague if not to answer the question i'm wondering when you text attack a woman of chief executive officer color refer to her husband it is for that that leader stand on merry own and in the room and defend herself and stand up for herself and correct the record what is being said is not true. outcome i hope that loaders will support each other in the city and from the moment that ms. aliza as supervisor peskin said on the police commission been harassed and hounded and blamed not but her and her work and

mind you a decorated fantastic attorney an impeccable record and that the load led attorney in southern california was led picked what the word graichld graichl appointed here the governor the state to be talented enough to confirm her as the lead attorney in the state of california and travels around the state standing up for workers and making sure that police workers are go respected and someone of that caliber shouldn't be attacked based on what her husband does or doesn't do i find that extremely offense (clapping.) and, secondly, i would say i

find that extraordinary that is a concentration as a male majority i've not seen that male majority length a minority it is unpresented maybe i don't know. i don't go far enough back in history but extraordinary that happens that is reflective that the people that work with her on a daily basis are impressed with her hard work earths and heard from our former colleague ma and accordingly and . >> had a hard work and she enjoyed work with her i find

this whole attack, you know, really, really gross and i just want to say to ms. aliza if you're listening sorry that happened to you and thank you, for you hard work and look forward to seeing our appointment again negotiation and hope you keep up that hard work and don't listen to the attacks against our husband as a reflection on you, you're your own woman and we respect our work. >> thank you supervisor walton i have to say rescinding this vote that was role unfair i think that there are very few of us in leadership positions in the city less than a housing

unit to do that to commissioner alice served with distinction and hard work and grace it is unfair an impact not her nomination so the way it was done i think is not body camera um, parallel on a policy issue i've never heard, you know, commissioner aliza, you know, more than i do supervisor dorsey but showcase allowed to answer for that i think a trend in the political life to personally attack folks we disagree when i find that harmful i don't like it i don't hold supervisor walton responsible identify blood pressure in the front of people that disagreed with me

and that i think is completely off limitation i, you know, think that we are better than that we can agree to disagree and still make progress going forward without attacking each other and leading people down in an unfair way. >> thank you >> supervisor mandelman. >> supervisor walton and i didn't intend to speak but to many of us i do think purple line procedurally this is confusing for more i figured out on friday morning when normally appointed will have come up quite a bit later that made it hard to dig into a really

responsive inclusionary of whether to continue or something else should be or thinking about to someone and that maybe the right percent and my vote against this motion today didn't mean i'm committed to not supporting her we considered for the board in january as well an appointment that desires at the end of april i know we can accept and commissioner alisa has done community-based work and wondering what the right made up of that body to provide the direction around ethnicity and staffing and equate safety in a bunch of ways we've seen is from the members of that

commission but think it creates an obligation of this body i may not not have felt acoustical in the position of prior appointments i'm going to take my time and then about this and think about the issues raised and some of the lots of questions floating arena maybe lots of reasons when the commissioner is the right person but that's why i'm voting no. >> thank you supervisor mandelman. >> thank you supervisor walton i'll say that was whole process was a surprise to me as well to find out i don't remember every doing an intent to reaffirm i think that confused controversial in a situation may not be in january. i think that

commissioner alisa has led wellaby certainly accomplished and thoughtful and think in all fairness i think that if there is questions of action be good to have the person to to be able to respond we'll do that that january fortunately, i had conversations with her over the last month a lot of misconceptions on merry position and unfairly she's been thrown into the controversy and one of the possess controversial commission the police commission i say that with eyes wide open but if if we were given the opportunity will be direct about them and think that is important

to be able to say you're committed to reform but also condominium to moving forward. and one of the questions i asked her clearly is she commit to make sure we have the proficient staffing level at the plod absolutely, yes she understands the labor shortage we're short staffed within the department and do better to hire people that can an an important question to answer but i look forward to next week and having the questions were brought up him or her maybe valid i would like to know as well but i'd like her here to have the opportunity to answer those directly. and i would tell you as former chair the roles committee we spent a lot of time not one appointment that we spent a lot of time than the police commission 10 hours of

committee hearings started early in the more than one and went to late evening municipal multiple candidates and commissioner alisa was the one that survived she's the president alisa survived that and when it comes to the expect of pretxdot been thoughtful in her back and forth with our office and the questions and seen an uh-huh illustration in that position so i would london breed as supervisor melgar said a person of color. >> thank you supervisor walton i was not going to speak i thought we voted on that and

solved that that but since that is back and speaking to it i'll try to keep it short i will say i think from the aecom and the comments here we are seeing on behalf of the folks who are upset relates to my introduction an litigation and so forth the fact community commissioner who was appointed by the mayor voted for a president of commission of longest serve person has served as a distinguished member of police commission not around a thing was actually the person who was most qualified to be the he wanted was selected to be the president mingle this; right? in san francisco was not actually political.

>> likely on a commission or who you're answering able to but a bunch of colleagues to carry the work for the record they selected now president alisa and people are upset that is would wearing seeing in the chambers and beyond i want to note that like to some extent in kind of real character assassination and permanent attack up think factories are quick to condemn or allegation those are folks that identify make the left i understand of political spectrum is characterized i have not seen anything in ero chambers that as divisive as a personal attack at character assassination pa was said about the police commission

so, you know, at times, i wonder, you know, the goals were generally acquire and debating those things or is showing to the folks that do want police accountability that folks that point police account will be attacked so i want to thank president alisa this should be is no rational world in which this is a controversial conversation a long serving member of the association president and very well respected all the once that is done around a reappointment of a sitting president of a commission let's be real unless a scandal the board, you know,

reappointments the prior opponents, of course, sitting at president of commission so i want to congratulate president alisa to be president of the police commission and make clear that um, people shouldn't be afraid to do the job of the police commission to insure police accountability in san francisco we live in a city and country we're talking about that and not calling for uncheck ability for police subject to non-stop personal attacks i think that is for those of us on the board many of you have speak up in support of our commission who are doing nothing more than their job. thank you. >> thank you. supervisor peskin. >> (clapping.) mr. president a reminder to the members of the public that

accountable signs ever support are disruptive. >> show your hand. >> thank you. madam city clerk and permitted everything as we were reminded first, the board will make the determination on her reappointment. next year this is an intent to support someone who is most deserving but i want to say there are a lot of issues and concerns were expressed yesterday that were addressed at a fairly lengthy hearing the opportunity to hear from president alisa was available for all of us in the chambers today. and the opportunity to hear interest president alisa will be available for everyone in session next year. >> so i do want to thank president alisa for all of her years of service on the police

commission and for taking all the work of commissions strolling seriously from support the department to pushing the october and led with integrity that is important in her role. we're at a pivotal time as well as for staff and leaders and think about labor shortages krobd have someone to continue to step up in a position that provide very little compensation should be 0 deployed and he listens for city leadership and focuses on the data presented by the police department and other experts and pushes the department to do it's best a strong latino woman committed to

the city and doing to prove public safety. which is the focus public safety. while holding our police department accountable and extremely qualified to serve and i'm excited she would wish to continue to dedicate her time and talent to the police commission so i'm proud to support ma'am, want president and like supervisor ronen said and supervisor preston this is a commissioner that was appointed by her colleagues to serve as president whether or where the make up was for the mayor and three for the board of supervisors which tells us it she is how the raise your hand and considerable and high school qualified and most certainly the best person for the position at that time so i want to say that as we go to our roll call second

time for item 42 madam city clerk. >> on item 42 >> supervisor dorsey headworks facility construction management staff augmentation services. >> supervisor mandelman, no. >> supervisor mar aids. >> supervisor melgar, aye. >> supervisor peskin, aye. >> supervisor preston, aye. >> 34r7bd, aye. >> and supervisor safai, aye. >> supervisor stefani, no. >> supervisor walton and. >> there are 8 i's and three, no. in the decent by a vote of 8 to three this motion is approved (gavel) public committee and excluding items which have been considered by a

board committee. members of the public may address the board for up to three minutes. oit say if you are expecting to dial into you are expecting to dial into this >> public comment call-in 1 (415) 655-0001/ meeting id: 2483 240 2124 # # press *3 to enter the speaker line once you answer that information press the pound symbol twice and once you're ready you should press star three to add yourself to the speaker could you the system will promote you have been muted may speak to the minutes as presented. earlier in addition to the mayoral appearance in addition to items 45 though 58 force the adoption without committee reference calendar or other general matters not on today's agenda but within the jurisdiction of the board all

other agenda will be reported by an appropriate committee where the requirement has been fulfilled which includes the last vote we took item 42. the board will accept our written communications if you use the u.s. mail. >> legislative chamber, room 250 - city hall, 1 dr. carlton b. goodlett place, san francisco, ca. or send an e-mail to be at www.sfgovtv.org and the interpreters understand you are perhaps not speaker card english and jump in when they hear you speaker card a foreign language for for those of you who don't know i see we have someone at the podium i'm setting the timer a two minute clock the first is

the soft bell gives you a clue to wrap up our comments once the bell rings you will then have concluded the time and i apologize to you in advance if i'm interrupting anyone we are setting the timer for two minutes let us hear from the first speaker at the podium. >> linda i received a message today wanting to make sure you got got the notice that taps strongly supports item 46 the resolution about saving the family hotel which i spoke about previously and since i did my general public not long ago i want to speak about something

before supervisor mar leaves us has to do with with the legacy i'm impressed with for example, the veterans issue. and his legacy should have constituent an emergency general for san francisco he tried to have submitted as ballot measure for the people to vote on and his colleagues if support that sufficiently i hope in the coming year it will become his legacy in the past a reporter and report again symptom about the building department what happened when i went to my supervisor was i have to wait for the next earthquake; right? there was northbound nobody but

i'm a victim of elder abuse told to go to the police and go back to the special victims unit you remember i testified had happened when i respect to the special victims opt out i don't want to go to, you know, that horrible experience of being revictimized i should be able to it an i g when i went to the special victims unit all right. so i will be back that that (bell ringing). >> thank you, linda chapman for you comments and let's hair from the next speaker, please. >> hello. >> my name is denise i'm well known as flower lady in the city have lived here 25 years i'm not sure how much longer than i being a victim of ellis not one

thing another and another. i came to san francisco 45 years due to domestic violence not been for the asian shelter that kept me for 3 months my children like this one over here my daughter was 3-year-old and my daughter was 8 years old. >> role do not know what do you notice to know how to feel in our heart do families out of shelter few days before christmas. this is criminal this is devastating. i have been in that position. and yet now still facing being evicted from my home i don't want to ever be in

a situation where i need to have a shelter but to close the was 10 days before christmas with kids like this i can't (bell ringing) i can't begin to tell you how criminal that is. and there are like my two minute is up you know what we need the city to take charge of that those children needs homes and closing is shelter is 25 percent of the sheltered in the whole city. there are 70 pregnant women without homes right now waiting (bell ringing) and waiting on the list. >> thank you for your comments denise [off mic.] >> thank you for your comments. >> speakers time is concluded.

>> thank you for your comments. >> thank you kindly. >> all right. is there another speaker? welcome. >> my name is chang thank you. i want to say. >> may i ask you to speak directly into the microphone you my name is cheyenne the oasis shouldn't be closed taking the shelters away will have families homelessness it is draining the purpose of oasis to help unhoused families and pregnant women and domestic violence as the first shelter in place this closure contradicts obvious

residents of oasis are not homeless hopeless in the measured of winter wanted all the families out during the holidays the lease is up, up january 3rd and have decided not to renew the lease this oasis has decreased do changes of families able to find shelters. >> (baby crying). >> okay. >> in conclusion, i'd like for the closure of oasis to be called off families shouldn't have to suffer the owner wanting to sell the building without consideration of back-up plans for families. not only are the

was families facing the fear of being homelessness loss (baby crying). >> that's it. >> thank you for comments just for the public went to show our support next speaker, please. >> hello board members thank you for having us. i'm stefani williams the guardian of my 9-year-old sister born and raised it is the holiday season many are making arrangement for families. and for unhoused families a time of uncertainty which was home and where do we go next the questions that the homeless will be asking and go unanswered for

my like myself dependence oasis is the last option it is already freezing outside and putting a vulnerable a positive recommendation at risk the was the first shelter in place is a safe plays for pregnant and other people and a reproductive health crises with the prenatal care and birth complangz and the closure is inhow many and inevitable and backward for the city we're hoping the city will purchase the property before or after the lease is up on january 3rdrd. >> thank you for your comments this afternoon. >> can we hear from the next speaker, please. >> welcome.

>> thank you can you burglary can you tell us about the translation. >> i'm took translating but. >> oh, urging to translate you're welcome to stand at the next microphone. >> and we'll set the timer for two minutes and do the translation. >> (speaking spanish.) >> she's going to speak i'll summarize her testimony.

>> (speaking spanish.) >> interpreter is available. >> the interpreter we have an interpreter available. >> with the interpretation. >> go on. >> this is an independent interpreter. >> my name is a colleen complied by trotter and my quality of life is gone down head of a family of 5 during

this holiday season i have no fund for my children and for utilities and other expenses and ask the board of supervisors to t and- um, get his way and forget about all us janitors. thank you very much. >> thank you. >> do we have other speaker not yet spoken welcome. >> hi- because we need work for the families and without them, we wouldn't have enough food. >> thank you for your comments this evening and welcome other

speaker please.

>> (speaking spanish.) >> (bell ringing) >> thank you. >> (speaking spanish.) >> may we have the transcription translation

please. hello, i'm a member of local 87 him or her to ask for your help and support we've been dilapidated from work and please consider counted circle situations we're if i was going a few minutes of meeting and i was out of work 10 minutes before and um, we have families to support and the i'm the mother of 4 children some of them are the university level and two babies have to find ways to food her and buy diapers and food and we ask for consideration every 16 days our children are us to come up for

rent we have not the job i had on such a short notice no way for me to pay the rent frustrating for children not to have anything to provide for them during the holidays we ask for you support and please consider the fight we're living under. thank you very much. >> thank you. >> okay. ma'am. >> (speaking spanish.) >> (crying)

(bell ringing) >> (speaking spanish.) >> can we have the interpretation please. hello, my name is- i'm here from the local 87 with my coworker mentioned fired from our work from one day to the next it is very tough and have 4 daughters and my husband is the head of households he is sick and has to figure out a way to support us again i don't have work. we have a family to support and i need help for us, please take into consideration my tallest are expecting gift at

this time of the year and no way i'm able to provide for that. so again ask for your support and understand the situation wearing in. >> thank you. >>