[pledge of allegiance] combhrn walker. >> present. >> commissioner benedicto >> present. >> commissioner burn. >> here. >> commissioner yee >> here. >> over stone and alias are excused. >> go to item 1. this commission has important work and prepared use all options to accomplish this task. will preshth the arrive every person to voice opinion to make public comment no how hostile they may be but cannot tolerate

refusing to comply with rules. speaking out of turn and other conduct disrupts the police commission to do business the commission will order removal of the individuals engage nothing that behavioral. before take the step the commission will warn and afford them the opportunity to correct behavior. if there is disruption will not restore order the commission the order the room clear and continueful will allow news media to remain. importance removed may watch in the over flow room only if they don't intrefr worryings in the over flow room to watch. commission is asking cooperation and ensure the mote to run smooth wants to hear from everyone that can only occur if we maintain an orderly meeting. thank you. >> line item one. weekly recognition certificate. an officer above in the

performance of duties officer ryan gonzalez star 592 from tenderloin station. good afternoon upon members of the police commission. chief of staff and ms. hawkince. chief scott and sfpd and members of the community i'm lieutenant casper tenderloin station here to introduce officer ryan gonzalez from tenderloin station. police. officer ryan gonzalez a veteran assign toed the tenderloin station midnight watch. he is well regarded by peers and supervisors. he works as a patrol officer and with the tenderloin station plain clothes team and committed to addressing the neighborhood crime problem the residents famous he is a field training

officer entrusted by the police department to ensurety new officerers trained up to expectations set forth by our department. officer made numerous arrests with crimes as well as reported crimes. officer gonzalez the department's values of vigorous enforce am a deterrent to crime and amid the staffing crisis the officer volunteered to remain on duty past shift and come in on days off to serve the tenderloin community. services with integrity, respect and professionalism and deserved recognition as a member of the tenderloin station and san francisco police department. thank you. [applause] officer gonzalez star 592 tenderloin station the officer of the website. recognition of dedication and

professionalism demonstrated throughout the policing practices and inspiring greatness esq. etch fighting i deals police officers guardians of our community. an example is worthy of highest e steam by san francisco and the police department. presented to you on the 12 of july, 2023. from chief william scott. [applause] will officer, gonzalez want to say a few words. >> i like to thank everyone i'm honored. thank you, chief and thank you for lieutenant casper and sergeant chung i work under them at tenderloin station. without their valuable experience i would not be the officer i am today. i'm glad to work in the community of tenderloin i know i have been there for a long time and developed good relationships with people there. such as e mergence and people

that you know ask us for help daily. none the less i like to thank everyone the commission near everything tonight and thank you. [applause]. i believe chief scott you want a few words? >> thank you. thank you commissioner yee. i wanted say thank you to officer gonzalez. as said in this commission the tenderloin all the issues there it is a challenging accomplice to work. and we need officers like officer gonzalez to do what he does and the way he does temperature compassionate. characteristic engaging and about engaging and connecting with community and providing services that people neechld i thank him for his work. thank you. >> thank you. chief. >> okay. commissioner walker. >> officer begins want to thank you for your service i hear from

a lot of my friends who is work and live in the tenderloin a lot around issues and they are really speak highly of you and thank you for your service and wanted to pass that along. thank you for your out roach in the communities. you know that is the shift you have is the hardest. i think a lot of us have -- gone on along in the night and -- it is a challenge so i appreciate you being there. thank you. >> thank you. >> don't leave, yet. officer gonzalez. i want to thank you for your hard work. sometimes we don't say it enough. putting your life on the line and tenderloin is the toughest stations, i believe. my opinion. but so again, thank you for your hard work and continue the good service to the community and the city of san francisco. thank you very much. >> thank you.

[applause] okay. for member who is would like to comment on item 1 approach the podium. no. this is public comment for line item one the weekly officer recognition. there is no public comment. let's go to line item 2. general public comments.

okay. we are on. you know 113 people mostly children arrested on saturday nightful 113 arrests i will ask a request. anyone can answer, around quick. 113 arrested how many are innocent? 113. i was there until 2:30 in the morning with those children until the last was taken away on a bus and i did not see 113 innocent people. what i saw and many of you then and there term it is process is punishment.

i saw process is punishment i did not see innocent kids put on the bus i saw tort sxurd people presumed get. first and fourth amendment and in the constitution are not peanut butt and chocolate. the kids were treated poorly. now. in the 80s they had a study medical malpractice insurance people wanted ton your the claimants happening. they study 2 populations of doctors a mall population medical malpractice and some had a lot. the small medical malpractice had a lot of mistakes. what they did is approached the patient and said i'm sorry i screwed up. the doctors had a lot of medical malpractice claims denied. we were cut on the forehead. have kids shoot fireworks at us.

it was not our fault. those turn to medical malpractice claims. ure know there are a lot of people in the room about the events in delores park and wanted to note that it does not appear on the agenda today which yu are here for general basketball everpublic comment. which was last week. and the commission is limit in the when we can talk about not on the agenda tell be discussed in the chief's report but agendized specifically next week as well for a full are explanation from the department and response to a letter the commission received from the

board of supervisors and so for those that are here we want your comment we space to be for the community to be heard if you wonder yet commission will be limit whatted we are talking about because of of that the finalize anded a full discussion at next week's meeting as well. wanted note that for the members of the public. joy will call commissioner. >> public -- comments continue. >> good evening am i'm jeffrey the president of the harvey milk democratic club i'm here to express the outrage the concern that the queer community in san francisco feel about the incident at delores park. on sunday i was at church holy redeemer and fellow perish in came up to me who lived in the castro and the white night riots

recalls people in riot gear rushing in the gay bars of the castro. the scenes of certity were hundreds of police officers in will riot gear waiving batons. drawing guns. rushing unarmed civilians. youth. he never thought that would happen again in san francisco before living through that he wanted mow it share that with you. chief scott you mention the community engagement and the budget and the last 2 months we heard about that community engage am. if there is one group that deserves our police efforts in deescalation tactics in community policing it is our youth.

the police feature responsibility of priority iegz the tactecks and we want answers as franz san franciscans in a public park and week before pride we were garthing there with joy we want answers and respectfully ask the commission to open an inspect investigation. thank you. i'm richard beshg 42 year resident of mission with the answer coalition. and i like to say 3 words are on the minds of people in san francisco that what the hell! what the hell was going on that

night? what were all the police doing out there something that happens every year. who made the decision to do that? the chief? [applause] the mayor. mayor novelty running on platform of reelect mayor breed she is tough on kids is that what is going on? that the hell is going on in i mean i remember in 1991 when the sheriff declared state of marshall law and hundreds of people were arrested walking down the street and that only ended when a mass demonstration and this lead to his resignation. that is what has to happen now and should happen now. [applause]. it it is an out ridge to the community. an outrage to whoefrn believes in justice not just in the community but across the

country. people are watching what you are doing and watching what is happening here and asking is there going to be justice? for the young people what is the deal, anyway? that one police officer gives a small cut and 113 people all young people have to pay for it? [applause] you know really. therenieses to be action taken by this commission. if you are going to retain any shred of credibility. you have to take action. you have to take upon disciplinary action against the police department. i don't think you will do it, if you don't do it your credibility is gone. rhyme karen pleas manual homeowner and mom and concerned sides. we have a cultural program in

the police department. chief scott you are here because of the justice woods coascompligz because of the hunger strikers who had to go to strike for 21 days without eating that is why we were able to getef chiefs fire dmd outsider chief hired and the d. justice to make 472 recommendations a blue ribbon panel and all of that is collecting dust on a shelf. the culture problem is real and it is every level. we got a da who charged officers criminalally that is what we need to do to tone down the d. what happens billion arias and tech entrepreneurs fund a recall election and get brook jenkins special takes away the charges. city government allocates 40 million dollars to sfpd without account at for that. and who pace the process?

black come brown young people. don't forget the mission police department is the people who killed pair us lopez. and lewis pat. and alex. they have a problem with black and brown young people in san francisco and it is your responsibility, our collective responsibility to stop that before someone else gives the arm. i have been there. i worked in youth organization when is i young person come in after a brutal encounter with the police it ruince their life temperature is very, involve traumatic for the young people that is going with them for the rest of their lives. we all beirut responsibility for that and it has to stop. i live in the mission are is so

many things to criticize i will keep it specific am i want an end to the kettling practice. saturday night reports encourages unlawful arrests that violate the rights of san franciscans and humiliates policy. look what mission local pub labored how y'all treated the under age people no bedroom, snacks or calls or nothing. it is unjustifyd and gross. the policies have negative impacts and waste time and taxpayer dollars and fighting the lawsuit people are the right. there is a huge distrust for the police, look at the [inaudible]. and the practices deepen that wedge think about the people are going to feel about the police. when people say, f00 autopolice this is what they mean. there will not be trust for them growing up.

increasing the police budget is useless if we spends it on lawsuits. there is no point in giving you more money if you will be to defend yourself for policies that you decided had no negative consequence. ban the practice now. [applause] good evening a civil rights lawyer national civil right's organization and i'm long-term residents of the mission district. with -- a long history of -- litigating and working for police reforms and -- and -- frankly i have not seen anything exactly like this in san francisco since 1991 the incident dick becker was

referring to when we had to file a class action lawsuit costs to the city. upon since then i thought the san francisco police had gotten better about knowing when you are allowed to arrest member for a crime. and that you can't sweep people up off the street as if they are garbage to prevent a garthing of -- i talk to -- literally dozens of the families. i don't think i talked to one single youth or adult arestee who heard orders and had an opportunity to dispurse justifying an arrest for failure to. instead. the kids some of the00 autokids i talked to age 13.

were passing by or trying to skate board or watch the eventer passing through the area when they were trapped between police lines kettled. not giving an opportunity to leave and some of the kids they are good kids and saw police and walk up to the police and ask for instructions what do i do to leave the area. and the police direct them to turn around and go in the police kettle where they are blocked in and not an opportunity to leave. so not [inaudible]. hello i vehicle a police

brutellity activist for 15 years. i worked autouse force policy that is talking about deescalation. there was no attempt at understanding our caring for our youth. in fact this , was a planned ambush. where there was -- there was riot gear in the vans where the police were parked for hours to wait to attack our youth! it is is hard to be a kid now. they don't know if future is a thing anymore. they have a few hours where hay peel free and be themselves and show who they are and this is what we do to them? shiver in the cold or afraid. don't give them understanding of legal rights. they peed on themselves they did not have food and water. what is the matter here?

it is as an elder activist. mother and grand mother we're restarting our defunds the police campaign! [applause] i was up for 9 hours during black lives matter when 200 people call in the to this commission until 5 in the morning to say why they wanted to defunds the police. we don't want you in our neighborhoods or your guns we don't want you there. we want the money to go to housing, health care art programs for the kids and this is what will happen next year. skate boarders rule come to our car free eventses with our youth putting on a show breathtaking acts of courage and skill. a pollution free art form a form of transportation.

brilliant! [applause] my friend asked to go to his friends house. 18 minutes later he was detained. he was not at the events. he was traveling up 17th on his scooter with his 2 friends. they sought police they did not know what was going of the police told them go that way. so they d. when they went that way there was a row of riot cop and grabbed him and zip tide him he sat on the ground until one a.m. in the morning. they took his phone. he was not allowed call me i did not know where he was he never made it to his friends house. can you imagine what that is like.

i'm telling you i was -- frantic not knowing where he was. at 3:30 in the morning i got a call from the police to tell me i can get my son. that's how it went. he told me he was forced pee in a bucket and girls ped their pants. i'm just like that is what happened. nndz kids and kids that might have been looking at what was happening got arrested. that is unacceptable. upon this can never happen again! good evening i recents the fact i went to 2 rallies today about our police department. i began at 8:50 brian because of shawn moore who is murder at his home result in the dropped charges. many people spoke including the

retch rand brown to express outrage. here i am againful what happened last saturday was excessive and, bus and i have traumatic. is had when we are teaching our young people about civic engagement? it is difficult to know about what is happen width city budget develop the. how the police department is asking over and over and getting over and over again more huge amounts of money by the millions we are kuth the critical programs. upon even food banks. makes no sense and outrageous. i remember that rodney king riots of 91 lead to the demonstration in 92 when our chief did lose his job because of abuse of excessive huge numbers ever police going out and rounding upon people who are demonstrating are we going in that direction again.

please, get it right with true reform. good evening. i'm daved and i represent ukrainian community san francisco. so we are dealing now like we have our community consists of women with children. and many of them are like teens. and these children are dealing with war trauma. we have like who is -- she has 2 teenageers. like -- they drove on the ballot from [inaudible] this is like city and -- teachers of shared children were killed and everything. so and what happened in delores

park is contradicts everything what i telling my community. and i'm ashamed of it. i'm tell thanksgiving is a safe place this is like where you can recover and where you can deal with your trauma and start new life. as -- like from our community. actually like i was a participate of my ref lougz of dignity i don't know if you know how it started because it first started like this whole process we are going to europe. but when it turned in revolution, that resulted in flowing our president. am when riot police, abuse the our youth. and then like people mriek [inaudible].

good evening. i like to point out mr. becker mentioned credibility may be lost you never cared about credibility. may 28, i watched 16 officers let a woman get beat until stabd and then realized they should stop the beating. you feature communities you are supposed to protect. police and leadership discussing watch you do this to our city. on june 9 i was on 24th at9:.

07 get shot because others d. it it is terrible to know the guy shot in the head survived because the bullet went through someone else first. that guy [inaudible]. . disgusting the community is supposed to protect and i tell you anything and everything about the sfpd.

>> i'm a doctor from the do no harm coalition. chief scott i trained at ucsf and took care of the frisco 5. communities affected by sanctioned violence in struggle for health, dignity we are disgusted. what happened on saturday night is blatant sanctioned child abuse. right here? >> shooting rubber bullets at

children. i took careful upon patients hit by rubber bullets left severely disabled. one man half face was blown off and left unable to eat our talk. defunds the police. someone born in the city i'm devastate body how san francisco is becoming a police city and county. [applause] >> hi. good evening. i'm here to talk about my son who was murder august 14 i like to use the over head. to this day next month will be the anniversary of his murder. to this day the case is not solved. i was putting this off because

former mayor said, he said, he know that mayor newsome said i whon killed your son the da know the police know who killed your son. still to this day and if they whon killed my son and here they have the name was perpetrators that murdered my son that day. hahn balthomas. paris moveit. andrew badu. jason thomas. ashley hunt and marcus carter one is diseased today. i ask for here it is this article in october 2022. it says san francisco paid zero rewards to solve unsolved homicides and near low a decade. i have been asking, to find ways

to pay tipsters to pay to come forth. one wants to come forth because they are scared. some way you can protect them and pay them. to give some information. so that mothers like myself can heel i have been coming here every week, every week on wednesdays nonstop. no mother wants to be standing over their son. no nobody wants to do this. i live had every day. this is hat perpetrators left me watch a dead son on the gurney lifeless. help, please. [applause]. >> members that have information regarding the murder of audrey you can call the 24/upon 7 tip

line. >> i'm rebecca reduce with the mother of steley. was murder in the 2001 by sfpd during a mental health crisis we know it is violence of sfpd is not new. should be alive side and o'neil ask shawn moore should be alive today. we have a systemic intentional problem of the brutal clowns that apply to work at sfpd. sfpd was involved. >> they bring in more chp, national guard and the lion share of the budget to abusive police department. i read this the preteens were

zip tide so tight their wrists bled until 4:30 a.m. folks say these are good kids this should not happen to any kid. not anybody. anyone. i'm not here to ask for training because we know from the studies training does not work. we can only disinvest in the violent gang that is san francisco police department.

>> but few speakers earlier said a good world. deescalation and another phrase should be built in to your atype, make it safe and keep it safe this is not anything new. i have been to a bunch of and skate boarding since before most people born in this room. like this is not anything new. it is what it is. i'm not saying it is great or whatever i live right by delores park i was walk to work and saw an explosion where i was like, holy crepe i'm back in iraq. i'm not here advocating for

those people i'm advocating for the children. who were just skate boarding. and -- we need to figure it out and be able to meet our community halfway and able to figure out a way where we and say, hey. we are in san francisco this is what you want to do? we will make it safe. because at the end of the day upon you are our public servants. and these are people's children. . and least figure out a way to compromise. and if you can't, deescalate. don't take kids to jail until 4 in the morning. when i was walking home from work i met all of the parents who my chieldz was arrest third

degree saturday had a junior police sticker on his sweater and i was like, how does this happen. i look at your website and says. in order to protect life, we will provide service with understanding compassionate and law enforcement with vision. and i i don't know where that was this saturday. honestly. where was that? where was deescalation that everybody said. i don't know why my chieldz was arrested. if you are going to have this on your website live by it not put it up there. thank you.

i cord nit a bike program in the city offer support for bike curious folks that give bikes a g. more than that i think we offer a space for youth especially to feel like they have a place that is hostile to them. because of gentification and displacement and drugs and homelessness. unaffordable housing under funded school s and criminalization. this commission has lead on important changes to the relationship of vulnerable communities and law enforcement. such as the amendments to pretext stops exercise all options to investigate this abusive power to drop charges for youth subject to force by trained officers there is no excuse, defunds the police.

there is say senior investigator from dph outside if anyone wants to speak with dpa or file a complaint. you can also call us at 415-241-7711 or online on the website, https://sfgov.org/dpa. >> thank you. >> thank you for giving me minutes to to speak. i'm a skate board and partner in the skate board company in business in this city for over 33 years i believe in skate boarding and skate boarders and the youth and it can change the world for the better. i'm disappointed by what happened on delores the city's

response was excessive. and the city has a deep issue rich cultural history surrounding skate boarding diverse being beautiful, young culture that stands alone and special. i hope in the future the city recognizes and embraces that and works with the skate board community and youth and make a positive change for many. i hope that some review of police force toward minor in the situation is examined and hopeful low never happens again.

this was a kid who never in a situation like that observe. he was scared. he was cold. he was upset. i had my little daughter and niece and older daughter came over. with her partner. i left where i was with my kids and came out in the night at ger oro and 17th. i could not believe a neighbor unable to get in his apartment. a line of cops with shields and a big line of pady wagons and line of cars and i turned and said the police man is there did they process the other mops and i see 2-3 moms no they will not tell us anything. i brought waters none of the kids were allowed drink water. like my son said asking a cop to pull hoods up and that was

denied. they were freezing defense very cold they were on that cold ground. we waited for hours. with the understanding that each kids was begin to their parent to a responsible adult. when 2:30 came they let the kids out like nothing one after bart with no one there to help him. they did nothing to make sure the right kid was with the right adult. they would not answer our questions. a big brawl broke out in the elbow room a girl got beat downful moms were hammering on the glass help them. they were like we will call someone. i was not shocked i grew up see nothing earlier childhood days.

i am a residence upon devenlts baker house art transhome. funded by the mayor's office of house and community upon development. the following situation detail the police responses to my experiences there. on or about august fifth last year i move in the and since then i subject of continued and increaseingly #campaign of sexual abuse and intimidation. and in february i went to the

mission street station. by the handses of st. james staff [inaudible]. nothing was doneful no investigation done. i followed up with scu, nothing. on program third the mayor's office issued an order to say pause all actions against me. in response to 2 articles published about me in the bay area reporter. and upon blanche craig for those of you keepingly track at home. on may first precious to thebert rested for violation. accomplice pertaining to harassment i was forced out and beaten by their staff. . dog was kicked i was kicked.

forced mow back in no allowed them to do that and no charges pressed i wanted charges priszed nothing was done. nothing. not allowed become in. i stated my case june 28 to an open town hall. to thomas harvey. hello i'm lian d8 supervisor mandelman responded on social media to sfpd show of force against kids and young adults at delores park on saturday. many things to question about sfpd response and criticize

about the supervisor heart will kwip. this done because of safety occurrence. how is safety measured here. harm or trauma? we know physical injuries heel more than emotional were all skater kids pulld and asked if they were safer. force to pee in pants and muni bus and not allowed speak to parents safety? we need to know how our will government and definition of safety is for black and latin kids over police exclude girls and transkids. which bus were transkids put on? safety used by anyone a means of [inaudible]. natesys the nights of broken glass violence nazi mobs used against jewish communities. synagogues burned a horrible 48

hours. police arrested the victim. police round up jewish men for safety. of again i ask what is the definition of safety and the for who. you heard anyone can claim safety and we continue is bullshit. over 100 kids traumaticized for what? my brother was tackled by police guns drawn 20 years ago when he was 13 because he was playing skate boarding the day his childhood was shattered this was in mass saturday in san francisco! good lucking evening. on saturday kids from hang out celebrating life at delores park. the violent thugs of the sfpd

responded with brutal excessive force and kids pissd and shirt themselves and could not contract parents until 4 a.m. will is this protecting and serving? i continuing is bullshit or [inaudible] non[inaudible] way. who cares about graf feetee. children innocence were lost i call you pigs that is offensive to pigs. i will end this by reworking a classic song by new york band, sf police you know we hate you you know we hate you. you know we hate you london breed. luck you. >> brook jenkins, luck you, die. i yield my time! luck you! next speaker?

that's a tough act to follow! chief scott and commissioners. some of you may recognize me not as a skate boardingly member a pedestrian mission merchant association and skate boarder. i have been in the skate industry for 17 years. and locked up for skate boarding. had my board taken away for walking through embarcadero because skate boards were not allowed in the 90's. i notice things softened up with boarding i gallon out and sometimes skate to the library. does not matter if someone has a weapon in the open the first place the sheriffs go is me the skate boarder. i try to look at through nonbiassed perspective. i listen to the elders that don't understand skate boarding.

i didn't know about the skate event i heard about it few hours before and no idea it would turn in this situation. well is not a sanctioned place to skate. take a minute. response on twitter was disappointing he was happy to see kids arrested but no solutions to avoid this in the future. as a community and the city of san francisco, it important this we come to peaceful solutions

rather than aggression. thank you. i'm rocko i'm 15 and one kids arrested and detained on this night. i will explain what happened. i heard about a week before through a friend exit went to see it. and i got there when police were there at the bottom of the hill they closed everything down and have full like suitos and everything. and had rubber bullet guns out and they were trying to make everybody go back i went back down the street i came and blocking us in and making us go up the street we xham and forcing us to turn right. down delores. and you keep going straight or you go become to the train to go home obviously the events got shut down i'm going down to get back to the trin exit get

trespassed. and a bunch of police trap us and they never told us why we were being detained. they just told us to sit down and shut up. we were just on the ground forever not knowing what is happening. and we would go up and ask the cops and most would tell you to go and sit down and not tell us why. and said the bus of going to come. said this for sick hours and realized the police stakz is helpful a block down they have 60 guys out there in swat suits and stuff they could not march half a block down to the station. we were waiting forever and like one a.m.? they where i want tie us. so we are zip tide against the wall for another hour and like 2:30 a.m. they bring this bus to get the rest the left of us.

get bus down 2. . 30 a.m. and take us half a block to the station where they instead of like processing us they just put us in the outside cell for another like [inaudible]. next speaker, please. let the speaker speak and listen >> defunds sfpd. defunds sfpd! defund sfpd!

defund sfpd. defund sfpd. defund sfpd. i'm nancy. i'm with the party of socialism and liberation we are here today and absolutely we will be here next week and we'll be here until all of you are gone. of because i know what you will say what will happen to crime if police are gone you are the crime. you are the organizationed crime that we don't need you to keep us safe. we keep each other safe and know what keeps people safe food, house and jobs you should be ashamed of yourself. because we are not funding our programs that keep people safe we give the money to you. you are parasite to the society and you need to be gone you need to be out of our city you don't keep us safe. all i have seen you do is harass homeless people, black people

and people of color and hart ras people struggling now harass kids? that's what you want to be known for. you should all be ashamed of yourself! this is not to you. this is to everybody else in the room that we can organize we can come together and build a society that actually keeps us safe. this society is not working for anybody. we will be here next week all right! are we going to fight. win? win? come out with us, talk to somebody because together we will build a better society.

i'm kamila. i am here with the community out reach. ready to fight the city pushed monin a dead this targets working class. criminalize our youth and streets what city attacks kids and uses the police force and riot gear to prevent them from skating? did y'all not have a childhood and enjoy your youth the people of san francisco not enjoy things you don't house, feed or represent us. call you do is criminalize us. when people try to find joy you

take that away. you say the keep the streets safe i don't know about us i never felt save knowing what you are capable of doing with guns can you take them and use them when you want to. you better hold yourself accountable we pay your saul reese the reason why you have salaries because of tax money you don't live freely off our tax money to criminalize us. like everyone said we want you gone. and want a better system that keeps you goneful thank you. i was one of 87 children rested i showed up and did not see a city who was there to help the

community and protect the children i saw cops with riot gear and rifles pointed at us i was arrestd and kept there for 5 hours sat on the ground not told i didn't was arrested i was not read my right when is i was zip tied and against the wall and i marched half a block to the station and shove in the a room outside with a bunch of other kids none of us knew what was going of i sat there as we yelled at the cops held a 12 year old kid in the cold kept outside for 5 hours they did nothing. i watched people pissed on themselves. than i were kept there for 5 hours. and many talked about how they knew this event would help there were other things the community could have done. paramedics there. could have been ambulance if you were worried there would be people there to help not cops with rifles shooting at people i

know people that got shot with rubber bullets because they were there. they were just there. and you may say they were criminals they were not. you came there and were already to get on people for the act of skating you were not there to help people you were there to shoot at them and there to provoke them. the only time people were doing anything a peeve event until cops showed up with riot gear. nobody was doing anything to the cops until they pushed people away from an event that has been happening for years. it is dangerous but you made it more dangerous you put so many lives at risening. instead of being there and helping upon the community. hi.

i'm gwen. i'm a worn and raced in san pran and a member of the democratic socials of north america. the hill bomb and skating is a tradition it has been going on for scombroers will continue to no matter how many riot police you bring out. instead of this and misusing the city funds. ensurety 70 save. i know this skaters love the city and i don't know why the city can't love them back. video of a girl must be 6 unicorn helmet on a scooter with riot gear approachingly her. it is just so ridiculous and

outrage us in a city like san francisco for stars and city all people here if your elected officials have not said anything what wake up. it is not okay. communities safety or how we keep the community safe it is ridiculous to claim a bunch kids you heard 12, 13, 14 skating down a hill is crazy danger to our community when 2 weeks ago a dumb police officer recommended their cruise are car in a loved community business like who is endangering our community the 12 year old skaters or the police officers ramming cars in buildings and injuring citizens. mruz mrauz. >> good evening. i'm steven torres i'm a city commissioner and serve on a

board the castro lbgtq+ cultural district and entertainment commission i peek on behalf of neither i'm encouraged to hear this will be agendized but express concern and shock at the testimony of what is shared this evening. the organic events in san francisco are part of the fabric of the city. and safeties and mitigations for events dike march a couple weeks before do not involve excessive force. if we tell the youth of the community this is how we are going to react. we are not holding them as the future of the community we tell them they are not the future of the community. i request investigation occur and that something happen to

address everything this is being shared today. when i hear reports of mothers in regards to them not knowing where children are. it is pains my heart. my mother experienced this herself. when she knew she had 3 brown children out and that we often would get harassed by the police. next speaker? hel oi i'm a democratic board that fights women in the philippines and in sf. within 13 skaters were arrestd and youth kept from parents

denied rights. getting shot with rubber bullets. is this what our tax money is used for to terrorize our youth. a billion dollars tax dollars to protect our own greedy interests and not the people he is meant to serving. drop the charges and defunds the police. i'm maggie city college of san francisco. participating kids, teen and young adults police terrorize the kids 113 unlawful arrests made this weekend. this mayor in the budget increased sfpd making 1 billion dollars i can't imagine it in my pocket now. only weeks after we see the negative impacts the mayor

should expect third degree to happen directly hurting the youth and attacking our communities and increases the police budget and wastes tax dollars. breed allocated 10 mission the asia po cooperation. cell identity their own people for free trade deal this is shows where her priorities lie. cares about money in the city's pocket that will not help any of us. riot gear was useod youth with weapons when does a child hold wood and wheels allow police officers to hold weapon in their face.

[speaking fast]. next speaker, please. of i'm page lima. i'm a teach and a fourth generation local. it is dus gusting that this happened. as a teacher my number onion is safety. number one. supposedly that is supposed to be sfpd's job, too.

no child is deserving of treatment like this for any reason especially for culturally significant cleatic art's thaevent happens every year. where is community out reach you could have support third degree and made it safer and you show up and completely, i mean 113 kids arrested left on the street cold it is disgusting. i had a kindergartener excided about a present she was giving her little sister. it was a skate board. she said she was going to get one to teach her and support her in her learning. it made me shuttory think this is what she and her 3 year old sister have to look forward to. don't make this for what are it is this is child abuse. this is child abuse by sfpd.

sfpd are child abusers. defund the police. immediately. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> y'all. i'm not good at written speeches i will note a few. on your officer of the week. you mentioned he come in on the weekend specials stays late how much does he get in ot for that. how much does he get? how much ot do your officers do when they brutalized children in and for to you have the audacity to tell people call us let us know. you have body cam footage. check it. it will take time. yea. guess what you took the time to abuse kids. lucking do it yourself. and for the better part of the

last decade i worked with youth and never once put my handses on a kid. i had kids scream at mow and swing on me. i had kids kick me come never once have i needed to resort to physically hitting them or restraining them? you have guns. you have batons. what lucking threat do they pose to you? if you are too lucking scared to go in front of children? find a new lucking job i'm so serious. you. every cop here that has a badge and gun on. check your shirt if you can't handle it we don't want you. nobody wants you around.

kids do dumb things i d. i grew up in suburbs and like the worse thing happen cops come and tell us to get out and stlrp other ways to deal. holding children in the releasing them children urinating on themselves that -- i have been upset for nights thinking about what that will be

like for those kids. i was speak with supervisor mandelman who said that the need force and condition be out numbered about an event, there were children mall children, 12 year olds 14, kids. this is it is upset to thank you is a city where we think the pregnancy to skate boarding is overwhelming force and riot gear and holding kids 1 in the morning. what would make us safer am hay bails. if we are this technology and i garnt it is cheap are than the over time spent. thank you. >> hi. i'm a teeper here in san francisco with first graders when i looked the the picture it is that riot gear looks

expensive. i wish i could get money for chairs in my classroom i don't have enough. and and as teachers we there were we make the weather. i want to echo what youth said when you showed up in riot gear you made the weather you made all of those things happen. we oshg moez cops we are look and know cop stele is here in san francisco. in san francisco children are not allowed climb tree in parks not allowed to skate. schools under fund exclude my experience childcare is rabble for purchase the shut down of the [inaudible] is not free. this is class warfare. you are terrorists. we don't want you in our schools or in our streets we don't want you in our community. we are supporting the youth and

building the future they deserve you are not in it. as per usual in my work being here i'm inspired by the youth you are brilliant and brave and deserve better. listen to them! >> thank you very much. next speaker, please. hello. i apol yoiz for being late i was discussing this with supervisor mandelman he does not get it. i don't trust the board or the mayor who asks for moreover time to waste on beating children. i charge it with you this commission to rhythm this. hold people responsible. if the sfpd can't handle kids what are we doing here? i'm not afraid of kids i was there that night. i was afraid of the cop who is stopped my bus and ordered mow

around. pointed vault rifles at me and my wife. i'm not afraid of children if the cops are you can't dom this job get out of my city. i was on the 33 at 8 p.m. on saturday night. buses stoppedir had no idea and throughout front window i saw a cop dm riot gear and was scared. we get off the bus and children in i was surprised to see all of the force for the kids the children were not making the scared the cops were. this was a tollly unnecessary show of force i was heart fwriendz out they were detained. somewhere not participating in the events they were spectating. i echo, this is child abuse

dromotropic charges against the 113 youth and investigation in what occur exclude if possible a hope there is a way to support the event next year i like the idea of the hay bails. listen to the kids let it help safely. thank you. i'm gloria berry a member of the democratic party for identification purposes i'm a member of the san francisco reparation committee for identification purposes. this incident helped with the youth bringing mow back when my daughter was detain in the de facto arrest exclude held in tenderloin station for sick hours buzz they were trying top find machine that shot a gun. i were the being fremantlic waiting those hours tieing to figure out what is going on why

was he in jail? and her boyfriend and come to find out the next day they arrested everyone black at the bart station that said over the radio. they could not tell me anything it passed her 18th birthday. i'm confused why the youth's parents were not notified and moving along. i'm concerned the skate boarders near my house coming from school and mow come my grond son watch because it is a joy to seat youth doing their thing. of interested think burglar vehicles border and not because

team commander that night. the callings the shots from questioned without the presence of a lawyer. >> i'm chris martinez i own a skate board company in san (advocate of skate boardingly my son and partner on sixth street. you go after orbit kids. are you kidding me. wow. >> now we have this i was

witting for to you do your job you didn'tful let this sink in a bit i see it every day i do your job every day. am i -- i'm protecting the youth every day. the cops roll up dangerous it is amazing we have a huge problem. skate boarding is not a crime. tell be a crime. figure it out. all of you. the seriously. a shame. look at you you have nothing blank lookos your face a total shame. disapoints in the all this.

get your priorities safe. hello i'm liam mcfadden and san fran native over 10 years now. >> talked about the out roach to the community after die in the 2020 i i believe mandelman at the time asking skate boarder to reach out to himmism roached out to him through twit exert e mail to contact him and have it help safer in the future. from my experience the time event goes bad when well is not

people from the community there who can police the event from the inside and keep it responsible. 2020 people died no one was there it was not the official event organized by the community. and i think for mow the frustrating thing you should have known. you did the same in 2017. a police response and broke a kid's femalure and sued. now 5 years later taking the tactics you learned from then and use them on teens. you kettled teens and came there it was a peeve event and showed up with riot gear and rubber bullets and insighted a riot the people getting riot charges other cops who showed up. the kids did nothing. it is disgusting.

i'm the copassport of san (latin x club born and race in the the mission it is fascinating. on juvenile diversion program we are speaking about the arrests and child abuse. we have a supervisor defending the actions no one died. zip tied for hours in the cold and soilingly themselves, i hate to see failure. wit we have with the police getting too high to count.

yourself. you see different communities coming together. skaters, mothers, teen and businesses the civil and constitutional rights violateod saturday skaters deserve accomplices to play and have fun. this city was an accomplice for everybody. next year the kill bomb commune sanctioned with the fourth of yell. needs to be ash countability from the commission on what happened. and an investigation in the mission police station on dehumanizing conscience. on the forth of july and hill bomb drop the charges of the youth. if you think the delores hill bomb was a riot you will see worse.

people of san francisco demands an investigation of every police officer in the actions at last saturday's delores hill bomb and how the police department colluded with the sfmta to organize and buses as pady withons to hold and trans port the children for book and the extent which the police department utilizes funds and machine power of city agencies to carry out premeditated acts of terror against children and others in san francisco. buses are not jails. than i must not be used to traumatize. mandelman orchestrating the violence especially in light.

on saturday. as you heard from everybody outraged you heard from people this is not new you have been over mroegs the mission for a long time the community has alternate solutions and ways on pend moncompetence give it to

the police and the first things we see you do after breed gives you more money is this. thank you so lucking much y'all. thank you so much for showing that community exactly why so many people in the room and community organizationers have been beg to take your money away. collect and joy to prove they can keep each other safe and in community. somebody said, yes, talk to somebody you don't know already. organize with each other. because this is not what keeps us safe this is when keeps all of us safe. next speaker, please.

>> hi. [laughter]. >> i want to read some of your use. force code of conduct policy it seems like you forgot when that means. in regards to vulnerable populations the use of force including children can under mine public trust come should be used as a last resort when all other means have been exhausted. you will defud yourself with let yous in 2018 more then and there a quarter million dollars was paid out to a skater kicked boy an officer at the event. what do you think the amount for

the lawsuits. mruz mrauz the community demands an religion in the events this helped at delores park hill bomb and we will be back with another soon are than you think. >> everyone i'm joe shrilledo skate negligent city for 30 yers and social work and with the sf state club after school program. i was at de lores street on saturday to see what the skween was like before settingum. and pop said explained what happened and for the record 4. . 30 an emt van. 21st street behind 3 blocks behind cops.

a lot of things were not in accomplice and i don't do public speaking like spoke in front of an snougz that harms you. what is in the honorable to use that authority to intimidate and bully taxics to the youth. this is as skaters we fall and break bones. we are not afraid of challenges. if the excuse was huto use force against people with fireworks using force across the whole place is only going to trigger people and make people freeze or trigger them to react in unexpected ways perform for safety that will not work with

skaters. next i don't remember among the institution and the police if you are talking about doing similar tactics what is honorable to speak up against that not engage this this violence. honorable to that were you are here to protect and serve us and communication is the key it is about proactive engagement with us and we are here keep notoriety streets all the time. talk you to and continue. thank you. next speaker, please. >> hello i'm nick skate boarder. previous years it is disgusting what you did and in the surprising that is sfpd m. o. do this and bullshit all the time. have you no regard for our communities and we are tired. i'm glad to hear many different folks coming out. it time we need to get together

and fight back. like what is happening? with the mayor. jenkins and them wanting to open the jail again with them fighting the closure of you've sethis a plan for to say why we can't close >>youy you arrested a bunch kids. this will help the numbers threshold to push open a new jail? the complex is work hard from the mayor avenue office to the board of supervisors and this room and the city need to get together and feks this. they are not going to do temperature they don't want to do it. the chronicle bs press release and it is chronicle prints them like gospel. you know it is lies.

we know you are lie to us and tired of it. and we am come for your money like the teacher said they need chairs they need to get paid. how do you go to the mayor and board and ask for any money and you get t. and put all of our for penys. this is the system in we have to destroy. that's all i gotta say. good evening i'm leslie i'm a secretary of united educators of san francisco. i represent 6500 educators in san francisco. and i just will start my 18th year as an educator and social worker here. and here is when i do know. i do know that as the last

couple days unfolded all of us are having to start creating heeling circle in class room when is we come back all the things we have to heel in terms of the harm inflicted upon our young peopleful deep expect profound in ways that is hard to explain. you heard from their families you heard it from their church and communities. this is profound in way us don't understand. every time manage like this happens it reverb rites. we have to pick update poses and so i have an invitation for you commissioners. invite to you a school and the impact it had on young people. i would love to connect you with

opportunity who is have been impacted. when i look at the videos those are my students. almost all of friends work in secondary these are young students. we have to pick update pieces of that. school start in a couple weeks. my information is available. i like to invite you commissioners to come out and hear us. i'm one of the parents kid got arrested i have 2 kids going for years and have taken them when they were little they were skating for many years and my 18 year old had left 10 minutes before. i was happy that skating like

what he started skating at middle school it was a change.

his wrists were almost bleeding and i don't know how they came up with the charges. conspiracy? my kid we come become from a giant's game and they decided to go where was the conspiracy. a riot? [applause]. really. like this is -- not even they are stupid to say the least. next next. hi. i was not plan to speak this evening. but my son was brave enough to get up here rocko the 15 year old wrongfully detain exclude arrested by all actions being

cuffed. fingerprint and mug shotted all of the above am our store sesimilar to a lot of the other parents. experience this evening it is not something i wish on any parent and not only affecting our child it it is affecting our whole family don't think i slept since saturday night over worries. of the it it is -- all of the chargers outrageous and unsubstantiated. you know when -- you have children and raise them and try to protect them from crib and it is being man and these things the last thing you want to think you have to warn them about the police now. because they are supposed to be your safe xhaven my son has had negative experience with police officers. and this is just put the nil in

the coffin, i guess. you know. for him to just feel like he has to step it that's the way it is. i don't thank you is right or anyone should thank you is okay. thank you. >> i wanted comment i hope the new established rep rigz funds enter minorities school rooms we will see. a bicyclist killed a year ago from traumatic brain injuries after a skate boarder slam instead cyclist the police recovered fire arms at the skate boarding events this year you heard young people were not permitted bathroom break and sit on hours in the cold. of course if this is the weirs

thing they experience in the life so for they are in for a rude surprise. it is in wonder -- if wonder the police force and the military ever now experiencing crisis in recruit am. benchers the trends are now competing against females and athletes. the very definition of punching down and chemical castration and transificationing to females in high school. on another subject entirely the dogma that you can't rest where you are way outer of poverty. and that -- drug arrest killed people dependsos mob logic the oxymoron in itself. you can't arrest the cycle poverty incarcerating repeat criminals. criminals and add roindicates and related policy makers have

been driving businesses out of business making workers jobless. and residents out of residents. in being home and commercial sore fronts the policy makers climbs of having out laud residential tenant evictions extended i pol of congress rock in the counselless households of thoughtless. next next. >> be careful. i am. i like to begin by saying i am a residents of the [inaudible] i could not let that whenever that was go. i have i degree in finance and living in the city of san francisco for 6 years. well is plenty in terms of particular rough mou and the goner capable in terms of whipping ching everthings like

the federal reserve with mayor london broed and they put our money in the buckets of money reporting to the bank bail out that could be used to provide safe hay bail and ambulancing for students, people and kids to be fed, safe come not abused by the city. disgusting. please. [applause]. good evening am commissioners i'm nina parks i sit on the justice for equity council that is a part of san francisco office racial equity. so it is my understanding the body focuses on policy in regards to pleasing. i want to read part of the community policing yes or no order.

a minds set through which officers build collaborative, trans parent and trusting rep with communities they serve through partnership and problem solving. it is built upon plots fee embodying i guard yen mind set officers are seen as part of the commune rather than separate. seemed like an on going issue around many city departments implementation of policy. an effective one as well as systems of acounterability to implement the policy well. in the order as well there health care shifts over past 7 to 9 years since creation. where the accountability bodies don't include any real communities organizations that are doing every day work to keep communities safe and teachers and other city diameters that

are over lapped. seems it is ins lawyer to the police department. so. well is a lack of design in implementation of your policies this is causing a huge issue in our community we need that fixed. thank you. okay. i want to thank the speakers for coming out glad to hear you are you the next speaker. >> okay. where you can go first. you continue. kirby have i trespass. you can do, lot with resource fist you know how to use them. you can do more. if you have them. you can do more if somebody put

them in affect before you come in the world. anybodiments to take a screen shot here is your action item list i will sends you the link. before the cop it is showed up this is had they did to the street i drive this route to work every day. i teach skate boarding at yams middle school my opportunity were at the events and caesar chavez elementary to 4 year olds and 7 years old 9, 10 issue lefrn, 12 and then year oldses and 14 i have a 12 year old i taught 200 people to skate. i'm a business owner. i make skate boards i teach with i'm the business that would succeed if you were proskate boarding city. i make skate boards for transportation. skate boarding is a part of your

yesterday pol everything you do for skate boarding in the city is antiskate boarding how much did this cost >> was there anything post third degree is sfmta the streets you have an active communities plan a bicycle plan you see the bicycle infrastructure in the back. this is the skate boarding infrastructure you head out to do harm before the kopts show up and that's what was waiting legal to skate and have protection under the law. you were going to hurt them before the cops showed up you were going to hurt up and down nobody thursday than i want to make it about the cops i go to rides with the stay stay and public work and add rocase. skate boarders can't come in buzz they are not allowed in the building.

is there more public comment? thank you, sir. >> thank you, sir. of shout out to the educators here. because there are, lot of people who love frisco kids. shout out to everyone watch and listening and on k psa talking about this issue. i'm burglar to advocate for young people and speaking at city hall since a teen trying to advocate for justice for young people. i see young people have been impacted by police presence. so, i foal like now that all of the nonprofit and organizations try to accommodate and come up with programs to help people to

feel a part of something and go outside when it is scary. to find places they can belong and be a part of something. give out bicycles and we donate bikes and help them to find people and there is value in that. there is machine in your budget sfpd has not spent. there is personnel program this is have not been spent. there is money that has not been used. at the other side of this there is the xr money spent on over time. the community workers here who work for the kid we don't get paid over time every officer getings 113 dollars for every hour of over time. that was i waste of 2 huh thousand dollars or more not counting the future lawsuits

that is our money 80%. 80% of the money that sfpd has is out of the general fund. this is almost all our money. i want no money to go to police association log i want no money allocated to sfpd officer to do any work. i'm keeping [inaudible].

thank you for coming and speaking today. we will continue our meeting. we agendize this item to the next meeting. so this will let everybody know. at this time i'm -- ask the chief want to say a few words? >> please. please be respectful. they have not been respectful to us. we sat through everybody's comments 2 minutes each.

>> so. i will ask chief scott to say a few word in regards to this matter >> thank you. commissioner. this. agendized for next week. next week i have a detailed report for the public and the commission includes cam are footage there is a lot of. everything i will present to you

is in taken from the video. body worn camera and videos we are seen. from the members of public. definitely we understands the frustration and understand the questions. and next week drop the charges! please let him finish. and next week we will release the videos and have a detailed account of everything that happened including the time line. all right. >> thank you. thank you. chief. we'll go to commissioner yanis. thank you. commissioner yee. i appreciate everyone's time. i appreciate everyone's energy.

and i really value the young people this shared their stories. i feel that. i have wed with wroung people for 30 years. i'm almost traumatic. there was a clear failure of deescalation here. there was well is a clear traumaticization of a whole community of young people on the day we will talk about prebooking and creating a program to not criminalize young people and i'm embarrassed for our city. i am embarrassed for the actions that this department took. to criminalize activity this are for young people and could have been contain exclude cell brit

exclude lead to men an annual event people recommended. so, i share your pain it is but one that can be supported. as opposed intfred with i hope we generate solutions from this. this was not agendized and will be next week but it is clear to me we need an internal affair's investigation. i demand we have an internal affair's investigation in this incident. i encourage each and every one of thank you experienced any level of disrespect during that day, to file a dp areport. and to make sure that you follow through to so we can hold the officers that did not add here to the policy for how they innerfits with young people so they are held, countable by this

body. i just -- requested i just requested an intern affair investigation the procedure we will embark on. we don't dot investigation. dpa the d. police accountability takes the reports. and internal affair division does an investigation. and then charges after the video or body cam and all the investigations are concluded they will bring hose to us and we would hold the officers that did not add here to juvenile policy accountable for anything that they did to traumaticize a child. so with that, so those other

questions. those other questions this i i'm surety chief will address. i also i also asking chief this you provide us with details about the deploy am, how many officers were requested. how much over time was invested. and how many officers cull monated in the event. and so with this i do thank you. and i do expect to see this room full again next week when we delve fourth in this conversation. and i appreciate your time. thank you.

the member of the community and acknowledge the community organizations this have mobilized the democratic club. do no hrm and the office of public defender. i echo what commissioner yan said we will have more discussion next week and look forward to seeing the communities and asking questions of department then. the out economist the event when we had is absolutely unacceptable and to me a failure of everything we -- that whf we

will represent as a city and department we work for. and often said the trust can tick a lifetime to be earnd and a minute to be lost it is disapointing to me someone who worked close low to see improve ams and see that takes a huge step become was disheartning. cordination not cohergz. i would loishg to quote them that's what we need we need out roach. we need the community. this is not made safer by law enforcement. not the way we will get to safer event and we need that. i echo what commissioner said about an investigation to see if policies if there are violation and discipline go throughout press and repeat what

commissioner said about the defense accountability. we have the chief of staff. it it is inspect of the police department and empowered investigate claims of misconduct and it is one of the moss for how accountability investigations are done. if you for the youth that are here. roach out to the d. police accountability that's how we will make things better exit want to thank everyone for being here and looking forward to this the first of many conversations with the communities. thank you. >> thank you. commissioner walker. yes. i will not repoe what has been said i think this the results of all of this are upset to everybody. i'm also i want to echo and reiterate that i think that

these events when they are done with community input. and done right are the best for our city. i agree with that and i would be help to inspect any way to make sure that safe evans like this are permitted easy and we can do these in a way that works. i think this is the goal. it is not the gospel anyone to stop these i believe that. we gotta do it right. we gotta -- reach out. i got it. what my upon point is this we gota do better. from here on in on these to make sure they are planned safely internal and externally. thank you for coming. >> okay. seeing no other like to move on to item 3. consent calendar.

>> line item 3. consent receive and file okay. report of disciplinary action second quarter of 23. among low reports and dpa1421 and month low report. receive and file. >> seconded. >> a motion and second. commissioner walker yoochl yes. >> commissioner benedicto. >> yes. >> commissioner yessir yessir. . >> and commissioner yo. >> let's remember members like to comment regarding item low the consent approach the podium >> that's when we are supposed to do.

none? no. real quick. i guess my comment is supreme court decision in gonzalez police forces don't protect people this is not part of their yen they are not expected to do so. gi don't give a luck, dude. >> comment on consent. >> commissioners no further public comment. item 4 adoption of minutes, action. move to approve. >> second. >> members who would like to comment regarding item 40 adoption of minutes approach the podium. there is no public comment. on the motion commissioner walker. >> yes. >> commissioner benedicto. >> yes. >> commissioner.

>> yes. why commissioner burn. >> yes. why commissioner yee. >> yes. >> 5 yes's. >> okay. >> take a 5 minute recess here. >> great. >> all right. be back at 7:44. >> line item 5 chief's report. crime trends. over view dihns in san francisco impact on public safety. commission discussion on activities will be limitedical dar for future meeting the chief will not discuss the delores park event this evening for line item 5 am public comment will not be taken on that incident for line item 5. of chief scott.

>> thank you. >> all right. i will start with the crime trends update. upon an over view of the property crime and violent crime. sick percent reduction in crime in the city this year. which is just under 1500 few are over all than this time left year. rilent crimes 2% increase a difference of 48 crimes higher than last year. property crimes down sick % a difference of -- 2300 crimes. from this time last year. firearms in homicides. in terms of homicides with firearms 19, 18 this time left year 6% increase. shooting victims 12%.

90 left year. 1 where are 1 this year and total gun violence 120 left year. 11% over all. year to dpaet homds up by 2. 28 compared to 26 an 8% increase from this time last year. weapons seize third degreeier 564. compared to 539 inside of 5%. ghost guns decrease the 11%. 86 ghost guns 2 homicides for this period. one was on the 800 block of jamestown on july fourth 10. . 30 p.m. victim saw his son, son republican the victim followed the son shot and killed him. victim taken to the hospital but

that investigation is on going. good leads but no arrested. another death homicide third and ethbert on july third the victim and husband a person walkedum and pushed the victim. victim lost balance sxhch struck her head and taken to the hospital and later sucupped yours that investigation is on going. good leads to identify the person responsible for purke the victim and more to follow. 2 nonfatal shootings this period. one on the 1800 block of sunnydale. this was on yell fourth. victim in the vehicle subject opened fire the victim taken. stable. no life threatening injuries and no rest and golden gate on july

8. 508 a.m. recommend in the street from gunshot wound no suspects and information at this time. victim was life threatening injuries no rested made. as far as narcotic was on june 26. search warranties for 2 identified evaluate in the safely narcotic in the tenderloin. on june 28 located near fair excel polk the cause develop the subjects accomplice in the custody without incident and search result in the seizure of 128 grams of fentanyl. cocaine. cocaine base and suspend meth. and thing opinion 7 grams of heroin and 9.8 grams of suspected oxy contin pills.

oak land located more narcotics and as well as large amount of currency. most of these folks were booked for charges including possession of methamphetamine, possession of controlled substance. kr significant event in thes northern district on july fifth. witnesses heard gunshots 2 vehicles traveling on broadway. both of the vehicles discharged weapons at each have gone. one unoccupied california and octavia. with casings inside. fire shell casings. damage found to uninvolved

vehicle. highway patrol stop eighth and stevenson and met the video of the driver leaving the vehicle of the scene of the shooting. we are searching for this person and have in the found him yet. few other things an update on the tenderloin over all. this past week. officers seized 3, 500 fentanyl. 72, 036 fentanyl in 27 weeks 3 times the amount from this time left year. increase of under 200%. narcotics seized is 110.5. am compared to last year 169. increase. as far as our enforce am on drug

dealers, there have been 463 arrests this year. that is almost double when they were this time left year. we ended the end of the year with 566 rests. with the focus in the line line on narcotics dealing and enforcement that is resulted in significant amount of increased rests. year to date. that is it for my report and -- we will report on the delores park incident next week. >> thank you very much. chief. is there questions? >> commissioner burns? thank you. chief. regard was the tenderloin has there been update on swing shift

increase presence in the tenderloin? >> yea. update i have now is we have adjusted the hours of the task force. that is working to work night hours. there will be further adjustments during the sign up happens in about an among and a half. and due to mou agreements that is the best way. we will increase that further. we added >> future recovery team to this and they are assigned to the tenderloin and. what did you say? also have a fugitive recovery team. >> yes. and their role there are outstanding warrants now in the tenderloin. they will be working those evening hours and they are working 4 days a week. in addition we do more when the

sign ups happen. in 6 weeks. sign up goes in assessment. but officers will sign up -- early august. in of the increase presence now is those 7 officers working swing shift? yes. and is there foot patrols daily through the tenderloin? >> combination the foot patrol officers they do still work of the narcotics cases and narcotics enforce am. we also have the visibility along eddie is more consistent. and hited, golden gate. are they foot patrols. not all the time. the foot patrol officers also work narcotics cases when they do they are in plain clothes.

i noticed police presence in cars. patrolling. but you don't i have not witnessed foot patrols. i was just i know not in the evening time during the day when i have driven i have not seen them. >> there is still foot patrol unit this is out there. and those officers there is a group that work full timol foot patrol. another group that work foot patrol and work our narcotic's cases they are not there all the time in foot patrol. oceanally. >> okay. thank you. commissioner? thank you. chief. with regards to the enforce am efforts, is there a time line for this effort.

to sunset to end. do we have a definition of when success will look like to get in that phase and how far are we from that stage? no time pliant now. one of the measure system -- the difference on the streets. there are a lot of folks out there for the youth end of the equation out there. what the public the people in the public met with a lot of people from the community. and they don't care about statistics i read them her they want difference in the streets. our arrests increased from last year and the year before, it is not having the impact with what we need on the street. in derms of list dealers and groups of dealers out there. this is one measure and we

measure performance all day long. we mode to see a difference on the street. the other end with the youth side. 2 thing system to have less people who are on the streets we have a lot of people with fentanyl who are passed out on the streets. we like to see less of that. not just he less and get people

off the streets. some of that is treatment. am some incarceration. thereupon is through d p h. and -- there is out roach going out on and i met

contin it we are dealing with people with serious addiction we'll continue to try. >> thank you. commissioner benedicto.

thank you. i talked about measures of success the last time we spoke none of tenderloin arrests had accepted treatment yet is this still the case >> yes. in we are over 100 people. but this is the case. >> is there -- i know we all agree we'll will like to see any of the individuals accept treatment. but wishing for that is not i plan. is there a plan. the plan with public health partners and the offs. some of the people are known to some of our treatment providers

and hopefully the relationships long-term. when the people that we engaged with that are under the influence. that fact ours in with refusal the time they are arrested. but there are some reps that exist. people revisit people after released we hope that will play diffident this is is the not police department have you to have reps to get at the issue. why do you know individuals accept the treatment after release.

i you noticed a difference in the tenderloin in talking to folks i appreciate the out reach there. i do irrelevant also appreciate the cordinating with other diameters. i know we have a friend from department of health in the issues dealt with by the d. health and partners in the community. i little this before the time spent waiting for that the hot team or cart team to come and transport somebody interested in doing manage different is an issue. i feel like the conversations with other diameters and our per

ins nun profiters important to help credit the alternative freshth. this will get in the agenda item on youthful diversion program its important we have an infrastructure of case management to make sure the people are getting the treatment they need. as an alternative. because i don't think there is a

lot of us in agreement here that incarceration is not the a. even with some folk who is have a history this might say this. i money if around addiction an understanding of a different path. so. i know the city is trying to help create that and want to reiterate support and anything i can do to help. why thank you. >> chief employmented to thank you and your team for wing on the tenderloin. district. i you heard from the commissioners. temperature is got uponen better. and the upon captain well for his heard work. wondering if the amount of over dose has it declined in since there has been more fentanyl

moved off the streets. i'm curious. may be next time you can report back on temperature whether or not we take the drugs off the street or dropped the over dose we are having. for me, myself, the week i was not here i was in new york visiting my daughter. what i wanted to visit was called a place on point. in new york city. called safe injection site. but the person in charge was busy i did not want to bother him. i see new york as way of something we can city that we tried in 2018 i know the federal law is against temperature i don't know if the city can do it it probably has to come out of

nonprofit. they have taken reduce our 900 people in a year's time. 900 people say their life is with us. i wanted to know if we can look at that and see if we can work with partnership and nonprofits. see if we move this out to i guess the community that is most needed and that is the tenderloin. also i want to talk about the amount of gun violence. in the bay rue. i see it is a rise in the homeless and you have it in the tenderloin. worning on the amount of ghost guns this has been seized year to date. if you have it.

it is lower than it was the number is 86. 86 this year come 99 last year. the bayview gun violence is down and i want to make sure mr. looking at it correct low temperature down in the bayview. 32 shooting this is time last year 24 this year. line sloin down a bill 16 this time last year. 14 had year. the gun violence downful the homeless rate is up. i'm look cam parables homicide rate is up by 3.

the tenderloin by 3 as limp okay. that's all i have. public comment. why members like to commencement regarding item 5 the chief's report approach the podium. success condition the getting measured sailing the arrests as a way to see that things improved or less people on the streets things improved is false. and the amount of people that will keep getting intermitt instead programs poresed deal drugs to surviv in america that's when is helping and will keep happening in ports of entry where the dealers come through. it is facilitated boy the state, anyway.

there will not be a decrease in the violence that you. . because the people are not getting the food, housing and the state they need first. next speaker, please. i like to stress how disis there is no report on the delores incident. child abuse tonight. and i feel it is to collude on reports later and not misspeak because of lawsuits. and then as far as the report on arrests, and the affect it has over doses, and cleaning update

tenderloin so it looks better to people who drive through and think it feels nicer for you and comfortable for you. i think you need to let the d athan the arrests of people that use is not guilty working. because according to cbs news fentanyl over dose is the highest point. because you don't see someone shooting in the arm during the love low day does not 19is not happening. i like to point that police the 1s to push folks to get happen is moronic. and -- i wanted to say i don't have faith in this body in doing resolve to what is happening in the city. i don't have faith with the sfpd.

i reached out to cho scott i wanted mote with you about rep rigz and push reform i never called because i don't see a solution. the rep rigz committee did not see a solution on what we could do and hopefully this body could think about reparations because the only way we can repair. next next. >> this is i heard chief's report give statistics on arrests. last year and i think bias is toward seeing the events.

but i did it question in public comment. is of the report include. comparing number of the rests to the number of contickets with pleas this don't flult rest and compare number of rests to convictions of people for selling drugs in i think it is know important fees of data to comper it is important to reduce contacts with the police across the board for reasons and if they are having more rest and convictions they increased condition tacts by aim of percent this is bad. data shows the increase contacts result in violence and trauma from the community. is this data presented to the commission or only get numbers of arrests in i'm commenting if

you can answer that. >> all right. yea. other speakers? you missed a lot when you sit in a car. it expense testify have a car and submit it and miss things. i was almost run over by police the other night wearing a helmet and the cops almost republican me over in the bike lane when i skate on the mission i see cars parked with lights on. and i stop boy and anybodying on the window and a can we help you. yea. when are you doing. this increased public safety. that's expensive to sit in a car

and miss xha what going on and i know i'm at my anxiety riest in a car. i get stuck in traffic i know you don't have laws that aplay to you when you get road ridge you can do when you want. or hit things. 39,000 people die every year. hit by cars. may be you should come out in the streets with us if you want it know us. instead of speeding by and expecting to make a difference. they have no troen trust you. go to next item.

6. dpa director's report accysts. commission discussion limited to determine whether to calendar for future meetings. chief of staff. >> good evening commissioners and members of the public. the main highway lights are trends from dp, is the increases [inaudible] currently. at this time last year we had opened 354 case. this year 390 this is 36 more case. we have 57 more cases pending now then and there we did this time last year. it is relevant to bring will up now. which will the board can understand from tonight complicated cases for you to investigate all angles there is a resource issue i know the city is foalingly i'm not saying anything people don't expect to

say we are having resource issue in investigative capacity. we'll fulfill our mandate and investigate everything thoroughly, but we are at a point i'm concerned about investigator case loads and the resourcing of complicated case such as this. i am proud to that were of the cases passed the 270 day marker we have 19 which is less then and there this time last year and shows despite the occurrence we are still keeping up with the mandate and deliver above and beyond. coverage case penning with the police commission are thick with the cho at the hearing or appeal level there are 84. in terms of trends. we received 39 new cases in the past 3 weeks and the highest amount was allegation officers

behave or spoke inappropriate low and complaints officers drove inappropriately or failed to take required action. in terms of audits last week we sent the draft of full misconduct audit to the controller's office for review of the report find nothing evidence when it is cleared we will snift to spoed speed fer their response the full audit you heard the mall innerim report and the conconclusion of that plus one new section. i mention third degree senior investigator steve intaul here to help this evening. and we have comment for other items i will save for when this is appropriate. >> is that end the report >> yes. >> okay. >> public comment.

i have one question. okay. commissioner. >> is the staff issue because of vacancies and recruitment challenges? or is it just you are fully staffd and there are many mattering you are dealing with. this is a good question. we lost 4 investigators the past 6 mont and because of budget concerns weigh may or may not be able to back fill the positions. we are still within the mandated amount of ratios we have one investigator per 150 officers we are at that bear minimum and so we are working with the budget office to see what is possible in the budget passed. >> thank you. public comment. >> members withhold like to comment regarding item sick the dp adirectory report.

approach. >> thank you. appreciate you taking the time to speak with me during the break want to report on what i understand the delores will be later and organization will be responsible for the investigation this is internal investigation and does not involve communal stake holders. i understands the same time a group that will make policy recommendations and that is not reloinlt the policy making session does not wait until the end of the investigation the investigation will take as long as it takes. not the upon end of the investigation the policy conversation star can start now. jonnel is the person who will work on policy. so. knowing well it is hard to get in the building with a skate board i urge all skate boarders to get involve federal you. to be involved in policy regards to the police department involvement with skate boarders.

the policy discussion does not wait until the investigation is over and can get involved now. we are invited. i begin them my phone number and expect to receive i call i will be out of town next week but will follow up if i don't receive a call. >> next speaker, please. >> i would like to skw that the department of police accountable make it more clear of how the youth that were harmed by the department can contact via phone number, e mail or address of offices anyway that people who are not used to this process. which is a very difficult press to file a complaint with your department. and also that there will be a

support protocol because it is so many youth involved. and what i remember is a lot of times the youth the person who was affected write their report in their words that's not easy. to do so that there be very youth friendly staff that assists the young people. and we should be seeing high number on your report were next week on unlawful arrests or searches. i yield my time. >> thank you. >> no other speaker. ton to item 7. commission report. why commission reports discussion and possible action a brief description. discussion limited to determine

whether to calendar raised for future meetings. [speaking fast]. commissioner kevin benedicto. >> thank you. i'm not couple of thing in my report tomorrow the working group for 10.11 body cameras regular a final meeting there are improvements it has been a collaborative working group and thank the staff who helped with this process. and will -- steve the manager of the special projects. additional low, we commissioner walk and i marched with joint pride parade that was a great turn out.

and another update the commission reported a number of months ago we reopened the job posting for our prints pel policy analyst position. we received applicants for this and close that posting. and voip carty over stone and walk and myself will be able to have a policy analyst and position vacant for a time that concludes my report. >> commissioner? >> thank you. president yee. quick social media investigative social media update. i want to thank jonnel doing the heavy lifting on this. taken the lead on meeting with the experts from the aclu. i believe this there was a contact also with berkeley university. i met with the public defender's

office and center for criminal justice cj. we are making practice. thank you for posting it. think the draft was posted on the first we have -- the remainder of this month to give feedback. i know there is progress in this process. i was asked to speak at latino task force to speak about the prebook diversion program we hopefully launch soonful so those are my reports. thank you very much. my report to say that left month

i was in new york. try to get to see on point in new york. the safe injection site. to being a look at their releaseos there in the vos. they are doing great work out there. providing i think -- safe needle change and providing services and a list of other items that they are doing for the community. it is a nonprofit. it is not run by the city but they near per inship with them to keep the people safe and you know -- have a place for if they do injection that is they have member looking out for them. may be the city with take a look in that direction. there are 2 in new york.

i went by the on point on 125 and harlem. may be when i go backil make arrangement to meet with the director sam walton i believe. that ends my report. >> let's move on -- public comment. members of public when would like to comment on item 7 approach the podium. >> go tom item 8. >> item 8. presentation and discussion regarding the update on juvenile diversion program the request of the commission. discussion. yea.

good evening. acting president yee, commissioners and hawkins and chief scott i'm kara lacy here to give you an update on the work the department has done. of our efforts to move toward a prearrest diversion program for you. spoed speed members active low engage with our community and spends time proactively working with youth throughout the year. through our community ren gage am division. we issue proud of a lot of different programs. in include operation genesis. we have summer programs for youth. we take youth out to the camp and have a wild areness program and give, ways. all in an effort to work with

our partners to positivism engage with youth. one thing we are working on and continued to work on since our last commission meeting on the topic is moving from a post arrest or post citation diversion model we currently have. to prearrest diversion model. goal to reduce the decrease the chance that youth will enter in the juvenile justice system. decrease in transportation of youth to clark. decrease in cuffing and decrease the nature of the interaction and moving toward a model where on scene we are able to contact parents, talk about the diversion programful get youth to agree to in a minute that program. let them go and later on they will attends clark and figure out their plan that is the goal.

and what coinsides with our work moving toward this model is being resunrised and we are near the end of this revision process. next step will be public comment and i hope that will happen soon. some of the work we have done since the commission last met on this topic we formed an internal working group we have sworn and professional staff working to figure out how to prayingalize this type of program for the department. and so we had a number of internal and external meetings to gain more information from the other count thes enengage in the programs. and we roached out and ponent to lapd and their programs. and also oak land and their program both of which you heard

from at the commission. what we are done is continued it work with our yesterday partners can trying to figure out what the program will look like. we continued to meet with the da office and had a very productive meeting with clark last week and plan on going back next week to understand the process and the programs this are in place now. it is a restorative justice model in accomplice nouchl we are trying to have i better sense of of the w being done. some of the data the successes this they see as we try to build out what the program will look like. as part of building this out we will have liaison in the department who'll be assigned to work with the justice partners. identified who that personal be and that person will w out of our community engage am division. we are happy to report on that

and we have continued to work on resunrising and making edits to dlaesz mou we hope to soon pass to our justice partners for review. lastly to follow up on the next steps. that we will dom we victim collaborative meetings with the justice partner and individuals a part of the program that is lead by mayor's office. mayor's office clark the da office and the public defender in communication with regards to build thanksgiving program out that collaboration will continue. we also are in the process of trying to figure out. what accountability looks like for individuals that might choose or unable to engage in the program what that follow through will look like and what role the police department will play in that. we are as part of that having

conversations with the da office about their role and how we can come to the table on that. we like i said need to finish the mo sxushgs require internal and external review of that and lastly, we have continued to work on the documents that will be associated with the program. the last thing we are waiting on we have made requests for data prosecutor justice partners and waiting on more information. we have a better sense of how we will operationalize this program and waiting on in of that. that's my quick update. happy to answer questions you might have. commissioner, walker. >> thank you for this presentation. i than we reported the concept

of thank you very much output umly the numbers on that we have seen youon the success of diverting prebook are positive. and it is something we are interested in. look at this, i it would be great to get detail friday the other oakland and the los angeles programs. to see how they are work to look at that would be helpful. there is -- the issue of -- making sure that we have enough case management to acomtate this that is -- at this times going to require case manage. it is you know it is a different approach.

and may have the thread of authority but it will be important that we have enough follow up case management we have a lot of good idea and programs and sometimes the case management and followingum on it and having enough personnel exit know everybody is hurting. to hire people. so -- i just i think this i would assume clark is those partners. not organizations part of that group? >> correct. they raised the need they will have to hire more. that funding something we get out of and, wear of now. not only impelement it and make it sustainable to continue to offer services.

>> and infrastructure including logistics. it is likely to be a different. when you do prebooking it is like the authority does in the have hand in the thing yet. intentionally. i will keep bring update issue programs that we had at the department of dbi nonprofits go out and solve problems before there was an official write up which starts the clock and make the connection in our system. if there is i way of solving the issues before. but it does require intense data management and over site sometimes is not there. so having a description what that looks like if it is not us. i thank you will be important. one things i want to put on the record here is that of upon this

prerest diversion program is also manage this we are looking at around addiction and mental health. so as we look at this. we can include that. its irrelevant important that we have an alternative response that is not incarceration and police that is effective as getting people -- inserted in an assistance and help. everybody involved can think about that, too. agreed. commissioner? thank you. i do want topup hold commissioner walker's statement. treatment and care management and support is essential to addressing the needs of young people that will be eligible for programs. my understanding tell be for

first condition tact offenders. divert them from the involvement of the system which is from the data los angeles presented has been impactful inrousing recidivism and young people out of system. i know the chief is invest in the this. the chief did make a connection with [inaudible] the mou the blueprint. we have to modify thing in san francisco we had the communal assessment referral center for 20 years. i'm glad there is move am in the right direction. one of the questions i have for you kara is believe i heard you say we are moving from a post arrest to a prearrest model. would you clarify that my understanding we are expanding our existing diversion model in san francisco including probation department and the da

office. and that the department the way l.a. does creating mou with the community part merto do prebooking not necessarily you know [inaudible]. would you clarify the statement you made does not seem like they are 2 separate programs. >> so. currently, all misdemeanor case are diverted. they are diverted after that citation is issued the goal to take all of those cases. move them toward a prearrest diversion model. 21s is fully built out. all misdemeanor case will be go throughout funnel of the prearrest diversion. if this makes sense. >> and does this then mean that

the current model gives young people 3 opportunity to comply and complete the promise once charges have been filed and the book has been made and clark. my understanding of the way l.a. does it is the prebook program give it is them 3 opportunity, same here. if they were to not complete their program, then they get referred to the normal part program and gives them additional opportunity because there is the wait of the probation officer involved in that process. are we saying the same thing >> yets l.a. model is youth are begin on 3 separate charges 3 separate arrests. they go through the prerest diversion program. where there were still be

potentially the traditional model of diversion or may be informal diversion through the probation department we talk about the potential back end accountability if somebody fails during. in that sense the options is what we are trying to work out.

nais something we have not worked out. how many sign to the mou. that is a concern discussion. i believe the america ou that exists between jpd and

hubbingelberry or clark might include things beyond the diversion than i may want to rewrite an mou or cope that that has not been discussed. what that model the look like. certainly tell be the police department and clark or hubbingelberry house that sign on. there definitely is i chance that other partners to sign as well. >> my understanding for the sake of clarity is the department based on what this body decides and encourages or requires can contract with the community partner. create a prebooking program without the da or probation department involved in that process.

the city attorney may be chime in. >>. s we valid to look i can't answer that now depends what the model may look like and who is affected. it is too early to say and give advice. please. chief. what i was going to say. >> i will say the goal is to really create the program that works for the city and it may end up looking different low than what the templet from los angeles locked like. i could not say it any better. i think everything is on the table oui are not locked it. i'm theme hear we are moving past the stage of conceptual wragz and design.

right. it look took a who i to get here. along the same lines do we have a time line for the draft alcohol was completed and i know there was an exception requested i'm not sure a time line or time frame? >> the next step to feet for public feedback and we will take that back to the group see what in the commissioner assigned you. would see what if any benedicto. between the 2 of you commissioners. see what if anything in included in the policy from the public feedback and then a [inaudible]. are we close to posting? >> yes. >> can we get a date. trying to get a date today i don't think we have it. >> i'm going to ask again next week. >> thank you. last question.

treatment. i know that one of the recommendations it is executive director was that because this is a first, contact effort you know oftentimes we atomb the first time this person in in contact with the system they are just going to need a baptist coaching and counciling. but what happens is this is the tip of the iceberg and the people will need wrap around treatment support. are those conversation happening with the probation department. i know there are resource imbedded in the probation system.

be able to fill the gabs we know exist and that is something we are talking about now. >> great. i am in contact with the probation department commission staff. on identifying the resource if and when we fwoet that point where we need either pilot with start up funds so there will be that additional support of to fill the needs i know that treatment is e terrible element of the program. those are my questions thank you.

public comment for line item 8 yoochl math. at the school i teach will 72% of low income and 4% homeless of the 200 people i taught to skate board 144 low income and 8 are homeless. billion dollars police budget. reactive responsive work. i'm looking for the preventative medicine. you take 500 dollars puff it in i benching ash count for every 55,000 students in the school district every month. and problem in home life paying people to raise american in the city.

500 a month pay the 55,000 public school students every month and do it thrive times over. invest in the children before than i are in trouble this is a matter of intention and recommend will the commission recommend than i give away some of the money or give it back.

go on to item 9. presentation findings and recommendations discussion.

[no audio] or move forward if

you are comfortable without seeing the power point. i think we can move forward. good evening acting president yee. chief scott. and sarah hawkins. sailor and i will present the review booshd fourth quarter 2022. the board convened on march 30 of this year. we'll talk about trends and recommendations that we saw. as relating to policy fail sxurs

training failures. trends by i ad staffed members department issue firearm failure to investigate. failure to appear for a dpa interview and failure to submit a response form to dpa. so on the dp aside the trends we identified were failure to receive a private person's arrest am failure body camera. detaining without suspicion and failure to super vise. i will take this packet apart. tell be easier for us. in the fourth quarter had one policy failure identified by i ad. investigator who took custody of a cell phone, which they were going to dump the search warrant

and during the course of maintaining the chain of can have the the investigator took it home. they the board recognized that as a policy failure. you will see it later in the recommendation and update of 6.15 property processing. in the fourth quarter had one policy failure finding. and the issue was individual was brought to a station for book and placed in a holding cell. kept there for 21 hours. and the upon the person kept upon in the holding kelly for 21 hours and this aim of due to sheriff department policy about accepting that personal the recommendation is to update the unit order in terms of economist to do in the situation.

the fourth quarter identified one training failure. we had a complaintant respond to a district station deaf in need of asl accommodations the telecommunication device was not hooked and up not able to provide the service we normally dom the recommendation under that is each station has a language access liaison officer. recommendations remember training was to happen. for the language access officer that all equip audited to make sure it was in connected appropriate low and to review update the department general order relating it language access. dpa one training failure case

involved whether or not somebody could be cat searchs and so there is we have identified in different situations training means and clarity arnold force everfourth ma'am situations this is an area there needs to are clarification and training. include language this prohibits investigator from taking evidence home. the second recommendation relates to book and detention what sailor was peek of for holding cell policy due to exceptional circumstances. recommendation number 3 all district stations equip auditd and ensure compliance with 5.23 interaction with deaf and hard

of hearing individuals. . prosecute request for sign language interpretation and provide train to district station personnel on this equip. fourth was improve training on pat search of mental health case 5150 evaluations. recommendation number 5 in relation to department bulletin report writing ps aclarify what reports they can be taken. them is set to expire on june of 2023. recommendation 6, social mode why acounters monitor exclude controlled by the media unit or credit a training for authorizationed users. recommendation 7 relates to addinggand for cri69. 2. calls for a task a committee with the rerue of internal

develop to ensure paraphernalias to ensure no bias in application of develop. during the fourth quarter review chief scott brought up 2 points one was what will is the definition of i trends in and how do we ensure we fair low apply equity tow all of those? in discussions with sarah hawkins as to had is trending when i said. tonight the argueigate trend for a member issued firearm taken we had 2 cases. that was brought we felt it was manage to be remedied through discussion. does not make it i trends if we have like nest glekt of duty one and like what makes it a trends in and so sarah can talk about this more she sit in with the board.

the i ad creating a unit order to aline with equity and inclusion to take a look how discipline is, plyd and have policy to support that. to stay in aline woman it. why sure one things with trends you gotta go become to the developary review and the purpose to credit a quicker way identifying issue we saw. i think one sthing potentially creating categories. like a difference to be significant versus this is an that were does not mean an over welming number we see it enough there needs to be quick and swift action in training or corrective before it becomes a significant trend. being be an area of evolving loss where we are like seeing impacts of the new law not being

trained to or whatever. i think we need to be more now they have been in existence and i think we have done really great work in the new format. i think more thought about how we are classifying upon trends and labeling them helpful internal low and reports to the commission and the public. i thank you is manage we'll work through over the next quarter. and hopeful low have more definitions and labels to direct what we are talking about in terms of trends. in concludes your presentation. and any questions. sorry. commissioner. upon page 11 with regards to recommendation 6 around the social media accountses. thank you for the recommendation we are working on the social

media rerigz and wanted get an update there was an exception requested for the working group but i don't i have not seen move. . but continue to see issues with social media come up i wanted get a sense from the department of how soon we are to activating the working groups to move the social media policy. i know we did w to advance the investigative social media process but have not started the working group for social bloo kaefd do we have an update on that chief or anyone else. y don't have the time line. of am and again you believe this recommendation speaks to the social media driven by the media relation unit that is important that in that entity well is training of users who are participating in that. if not trained you can't offer

consistency on how we utilize the platform >> does this fall within the social mode why revision process. false within the one you refer to. >> correct. >> we will of have this recommend. thank you. >> correct >> thank you. okay. public comments on? members like to make comment on item 9 approach podium. seeing none go to item 10. presentation of quarter low activity and data report fourth quarter of 22, discussion.

good evening. members of the commission and direct. chief scott. members of partial i'm catherine the executive manager of strategic management bureau. jason hour program manager in the professional standard's unit is going to present the state wide data compared to san francisco and look at our kwshg 42022 and q12021 data as present in the our reports. i will hand it over to jason. thank you executive director mc

guire. good evening president yee. chief scott. chief hawkins and members of commission. i'm jason cunningham a program manager in the strategic manager bureau of the police department manage business analysis team a group of 7 charged with creation of our routine data and reports to release public low this evening i will review 2 reports the first is the racial oyst profiling board. annual report from 2023. offered at the state level and the second is a sneak peek at the first quarter 2023 san francisco police department quarter low activity and data report. together these reports and annexes equal 800 page of informationil do my best to boil the obligation of information down to a few key points i present in the next 10 minutes.

of note neither present third degree evening a the question of why. put another way this focuses on the what, where, when and whom but not time on why. additionally, the presentation is a mirror of one given in february of left year. slide 2. . first off the ripa annual report of release in the january of this year covers data gather in the 2021 by 58 largest law enforcement agency in california and 3 smaller that opted in early. the california highway patrol captures the most data w. 55% of all recordsful staffs conducted by the california highway patrol. ful this simple 1.7 million out of 3.1 stops conducted in 2021. data collection is governed by

offering legislation and any actions taken by california department of justice often upon at the recommendation of the ripa board. all a remind are demographic data collected under the ripa stops reports officer perception. starting at the top level with number of stops by agency. you note the ped speed total number from 20 to 21 declined with reduction role numbers 11, 162. and percentage of 29% yearly this is consistent with other jurisdictions over the same time period. who is stop in the 21, the same 3 are stopped with the most frequency. those white, black come hispanic/latin x.

however the in order which stopped differs with per received hispanic individuals stopped with the most state wide where as in san francisco per received white individuals the largest portion stop. per received black the third largest stopped at the state level 15% of stops. in san francisco per received black individuals make up the second largest group stops 24.7% of stops. spined a minute on this table. when we have is a table showing search rate and discovery rate by demographic group compared to the per received white demographic of group in 2021 for state as a whole and the sfpd. startszoth left side of the

table we see search rates compared to perceived white individuals. at the state level if you are per received black or hispanic you have a higher likelihood of being searched than white vsed the true per received asian or the other groupful with the sfpd in 2021 you were less likely to be searched than a per received white if asian or per received the other groups. per received hispanic individuals have no affect on the likelihood of searched compared to white individual. perceived black vsed stop 3% more likely to be searched. all result are significant the zero. now the middle of the are chart special talk about the discovery rate analysis. . discovery rate the rate in which

officers discover evidence when searching an individual. this is 2 types. discretionary and administrative. ! which an officer requests consent and administrative are indent to arrest and a search warrant or conducting a vehicle inventory there are others out that are conducted however those were not considered by state in this analysis. considering discretionary searchs you see in 21 at the state level all 4 per received groups are less likely to have evidence discovered. as compared to per received white individuals. this is significant for the per received black and hispanic group it is and not significance for asian and other demographic ams. compered the sfpd in 2021 asian, black and hispanic individuals

are more likely to be discovered with evidence or contraband and les likely for the other group. 91 of those are significance. consider administrative searches state asian, hispanic last and i know other groups less likely to have evidence discovered compared to white individuals. per received black individuals slightly more likely to have ~est discovered but in the significance. sfpd in 2021 asian, black and hispanic demographic groups were likely to have evidence than per received white. individuals in the other demographic group are less like low to have discovered and 91 of the findings in 21 for the sfpd. next slide. this will be our last look at

statistics. the ripa report conjunctived an aggression analysis use of force and the receive made the stop. time of day and location, et cetera . to contract impact of the stopped individuals race or ethnicity on weather force was used. compared to white individuals the odds of officers using force during a stop 1. 24 times higher for black and hispanic individuals. at the state level. asian and other individuals officers stopped lower odds of having force used against them. relative to the odds for individual officers per received white. this holds true with findings when the chp stops are excluded.

all at state level are significant. looking at the left side of the slide compared to the sfpd use of force rate in 21, the sfpd had lower rate in all categories as compared to the state. of these are not manslaughter significant. next slide. now the first quarter quarter leave activity for 2023. this is instead of 2022 fourth quarter this is a sneak peek this should be out in the next week or so. of report considers data at first of sdwron march and captures use of force data late q42022. due to the change in use of force standard. next slide?

high level look this is stops over time on the left side of the chart when we see annualized number of stops broken out by race and ethnicity and year. what we see to the right is a per capita number of stops annual fre2018 through 2022. 2 key take a ways the decrease in stop count 2019 and 2020 and on going reduction in per capita in stops over time of that said, those do continue to persist. next. to the left of the slide is the last 6 quarters by percentage. of individuals being stopped by the sfpd race and ethnicity. no marriage changes over the last 6 quarters. afternoon additionalnants this reportom who we're stopping and

what type of stop was conducted. that is was the stop initialled by an officer or dispatched the analysis is simple but consider ru, counts. look that the state did with searches. a look at annualized searches per cap at that time last 5 years. mid 2018 you see the disparity between the number of per received black individuals searched and black individuals in san francisco residential population come down over time. that said again, the disparities

persist. when i referred to them in the following slide says note i will reference race or ethnicity to the same representation in the san francisco residential population. next slide.

new use of force standards in 2022 lowered in thresholds. which increase said the number our then increase use of force significantly. moving from 328 urn the old standards in 20 between the -- moving from around 328 under the old use standard to 2200 and 2300 in the third quarter. the kwourth quarter data is partially the entire quarter. in the fourth quarter we

transitioned to the current use of force standard. when we 47? yea when we consider use of force per capita over time reduction for black individuals and hispanic individuals. that said both fwroup and black individuals continue to have a use of force disparity. the data only considered 2016 through 21 had a consistent use of force standardful report breaks out each in more detail per capita. next. this is just the total number of rests by the sfpd over time since the beginning of 2019. kwshg 123 had the same number as we did at the beginning of the pan demmics in 2020.

>> this is the look at that same data this time broken out race and ethnicity a decline by percentage of black individuals arrested and incline of hispanic/latin x individuals. foiblely a look at arrested per that over time. you know the black individuals come down over time the trend line. this has occurred to a lesser extent for hispanic/latin x individuals. thank you for your takening i hundred it become to executive director mc guire. jason happy to take questions.

any questions? all right. thank you very much. move on to public upon comment. on that in members that will like to comment regarding item 10. prop the podium. the fact that skate boarding is not completely rill legal there are laws that set people up to be not for skate boarding you cannot skate board in the city after dark or before sunrise. you can visit if 2003.

>> okay. no other speaker. let's go to item next item. >> 11 employees discussion and action to approve general order information regarding registered sex offenders meaghan law to use in meeting with the bargaining units required by law discussion and possible action. >> hello. good evening. commissioners acting president yee.

chief of staff and chief scott. i'm deputy chief investigations which houses the svu i have captain shawn i will introduce. that unit does have ray 290 portion subunit in the sv sxushgs 290 refers to the registration of sex offenderers. dg oshg 7.0 low is when we hope to adopt. and it is straightforward i will turn it over to captain. this was done in my office and dp arecommendations were adopted iffure have questions i can answer them.

any questions. commissioner burns. so. as i understands the dgo and you are following penal code section 290 and 290.45. and upon adopting it to the police department who you need to talk to and following the penal code sections. that's correct. it does track the penal code and statute. within the prosecute visions the agency adopted procedures on how to disclose the information the upon extent that is made to possible third parties including people that the rej stranlt may be around and at risk. yea. so. yea. basically it is yes. it is just your interpretation of penal codes.

>> correct with assistance dliniate who had within the hierarchy supervisors made aware by an officer and after that the ultimate determination whether or not disclosure is made by a lieutenant after that is done a form is paired in the police department is documented. with the the listed -- lengthy. on page 5 sick off the information require have had to go in the police department and all of that update in the prime data warehouse for further rerue later on. >> one more thing. 290.46. governs the doj's when they put in the data base. >> commissioner, benedicto. >> acting president yo a couple of questions. anything dbamented to note.

i would echo all recommendations were accepted and that we think this will make is easy for officers to get help and to avoid adverse incidents. >> applaud for this it is clearer than the former one. anyone in the working group i'm trying to make it shorter. and -- this seems clear for the officers. it is also one of our 1990dgo, o's. i move to approve this for use with meeting with the units and consistent with the commission's labor relation resolution 23-30.

>> second. members that would like to comment on item 11 approach the podium. roll call wrchl no public commentful on the motion commissioner walker >> yes. >> commissioner benedicto >> yes >> commissioner. >> yes. >> commissioner burn >> yes. and commissioner yee. >> yes. >> next item. why 12, discussion and possible action to adopt department general order 11.33 recommended referrals to behavioral science unit discussion and possible action. >> good evening we spoke about this pol on multiple occasions i'm here to answer questions that may arisen since the left time i was here. if you have any.

american benedicto. i don't have kwis continualing it is a great general order and service offered to members as well as to professional staff and as well i'm glad the commission pass today and went through the labor negotiation process quickly i thank the bargaining units. 3 or more. a large number [inaudible] and others and thank the units moving this through. i know there are a lot we are moving through and grateful to the units for working through this and labor relation director. mrs. preston. i will move to adopt general order 11.13. >> second. >> of members of the public like to comment regarding item 12 prop.

there is no public comment. commissioner walker. >> yes >> commissioner benedicto >> yes >> commissioner >> yes. >> commissioner burn >> yes. >> commissioner yee. >> yes. you have 5. >> okay moving along line item 11 public comment pertaining to closed session including on item 14 vote to hold 15 in closed session. if you would like to comment approach the podium. i motion to -- wait. >> >> sorry. >> well is in public comment >> 14. vote on weather to hold 15 in closed session. action. i motion now. second. >> on the motion commissioner walker. >> yes. >> commissioner benedicto.

>> yes. why commissioner. >> yes. >> commissioner burn. why yes. >> commissioner yee >> yes. >> you have 5. >> we'll go in closed session. we are back in open session. >> motion not to disclose. >> second. >> public comment regarding item 16. approach there is no comment. commissioner walker >> aye yoochl commissioner benedicto >> yes >> commissioner >> yes >> commissioner burn. why yes. >> commissioner yo >> yes. >> you have 5 yes's.

>> 17, adjournment. clear clear