tv Dateline NBC NBC August 31, 2015 2:03am-3:02am EDT
2:03 am
2:04 am
2:05 am
>> luminess is stupendous. >> announcer: watch this redness disappear at the touch of a button. >> people have said to me, "you look amazing. what have you done?" >> people ask me if i've had a face-lift. >> people asked if i got botox. >> announcer: these women all switched to a new foundation. >> people come up to me and say, "your skin is beautiful." >> announcer: it's not a skin-care lotion or potion. it's not even plastic surgery. >> i will have people say, "what are you doing? you look younger." >> announcer: it's a huge leap forward in makeup technology. >> this is what i used to look like 10 years ago. >> announcer: and it can help you look 10 years younger instantly. >> i've had two people actually tell me it looks like i have porcelain skin. >> announcer: it's the airbrush beauty breakthrough -- luminess air, the most exciting new beauty product in years. it's the revolutionary new wayde to apply makeup that gets results liquids and powders can't match. >> i love it. i love the way i look. i looked in the mirror, and it was like, "who" it's a miracle makeup. it's the only makeup i will use. >> announcer: today, you'll see
2:06 am
dozens of women who have modernized the way they do makeup and transformed their faces instantly. they are ecstatic about their results. >> your skin almost glows. >> i have gotten my youth back. >> i look better than i've ever looked. >> luminess is a magical result. >> announcer: the makeup you're using can look dry and cakey. it exaggerates your pores and wrinkles, and it can make your skin look rough. keep watching. you'll learn how you can go from this to this. you'll see how you can erase your flaws and cover even the most difficult skin problems instantly. you'll learn all about how youno can have smoother-looking skin, eliminate the problems of traditional makeup, and look 10 years younger instantly. and you'll learn how luminess air has reinvented the airbrush to make it easier to use than ever before. airbrush makeup was born inar hollywood because it gets the very best look. oscar- and emmy award-winning makeup artists switched to using airbrush because it eliminates the heavy, unnatural look of
2:07 am
liquids and powders. airbrush makes everyone who wears it look younger. ve neill is an eight-time academy award-nominated makeup artist. she's worked on some of the biggest movies in history, including the "pirates of the caribbean" films and "the hunger games." she knows how beautiful airbrush makeup looks. >> it's a really flawless, very soft, velvety look, plush. it gives your skin a really plush look. >> announcer: john elliott is an oscar nominee and was the head makeup artist on "desperate housewives." >> airbrush makeup is so sheer, it's so natural-looking, that people just look and say, "god, you're glowing. i don't know why, but you look great." >> announcer: every woman knows that with fingers, sponges, and brushes, it's very hard to get a smooth, natural look. airbrush beautifully covers your flaws with the smoothest, most natural look available in any makeup anywhere. but until now you had to be a celebrity. not anymore. now airbrush is for everyone. luminess air has made this hollywood secret to beauty and looking younger foolproof.
2:08 am
the airbrush works by adding just a few drops of foundation to the stylus. then start the air source. air enters through t hose, and when you pull back on the button, the air and the foundation mix into an ultra-fine mist. tiny particles of makeup cover the skin completely, creating a beautiful, smooth, and natural appearance. it erases flaws and softens wrinkles. >> luminess air is the easiest, best, most natural-looking makeup i have ever used. they've made it so simple and so easy that you really can -- anybody can do it. i have a lot of brown spots on my face -- melasma. it's really hard to cover it up. they're incredibly dark. they're all along the sides of my face. before i'd started using luminess, i'd just given up. there wasn't anything that was gonna cover it, anyway, so i just stopped using anything. i'm ecstatic about luminess. i'm ecstatic about how easy it is, how fast and convenient and how much it covers. people have been complimenting me on my skin, which is something that never used to
2:09 am
happen. luminess air is amazing. >> announcer: the luminess air system was designed for regular women to use at home. it's so easy to use, it's practically foolproof. >> to my surprise, it was so easy. you just look in the mirror, and you just start putting it on over your skin, and you start to see, immediately, the results. >> announcer: ordinary makeup is way too heavy to get a natural look. it exaggerates skin problems and cakes up throughout the day. it makes you look older. luminess air is just the opposite. it's so light, it actually uses up to 10 times less makeup than ordinary liquids. >> my old foundation would sit in the pores, like spackle in a nail hole. it didn't look pretty. it didn't look smooth. it looked like something yucky. when i picked up the airbrush for the first time, i could see the difference. i thought, "this is the one. this is the one that's gonna work." >> announcer: our new and improved luminess airbrush with our new no mess tip now makes airbrushing even easier and more controllable.
2:10 am
this new tip eliminates overspray and gives you complete control. just watch how luminess air makes this age spot disappear. there's no traditional makeup in the world that can do this. only airbrush with luminess air. it really is this fast and easy. >> i'm gonna show you how easy it is to go from naked face to beautiful coverage using the luminess airbrush. i have some problem areas, like this big sun spot here that isn't going away, and it tends to get a little darker, especially in the summertime. i also have redness and rosacea on my cheeks and ny nose area, so i have a challenge trying to cover everything up, but yet have it not be too heavy so that it accentuates the wrinkles. i like to use about four drops. that gives me the coverage that i need. and then i'm gonna push the button. you can feel the soft air blowing on your skin. it feels really nice. and then i'm gonna pull that lever back as i'm doing the little circles, and i can feel the cool mist on my skin. it feels really nice, actually. so, you can see e redness on
2:11 am
my cheeks, so i'm gonna focus on that now. look at how that covers. i've got a spot on my chin i'm gonna focus on. now i'm over here working on that sun spot and the rosacea that's showing up there. it's not even going into my hair. it's not going into my eyes. i'm going right around my eye area. this tip is great for giving you wonderful precision, no mess around your hair line or onto your clothes or in your eyes. and you can feel exactly where it's goingén it's so easy to control. nothing to be afraid of. okay. so that's it. i'm done. wow. i love it. it looks so wonderfully even, and it covered up the sun damage, the rosacea, the redness of my nose. and look how even i am. that's amazing. i love it. >> announcer: take a look at this blemish. now you see it. now you don't.
2:12 am
>> it is amazing. >> announcer: do you see this age spot? don't blink. it's gone like magic. >> luminess is stupendous. >> announcer: watch this redness disappear at the touch of a button. airbrush makeup is the hollywood tocret to beauty. now airbrush is for everyone. you'll cover all your flaws and look years younger. >> it is the best coverage you'll ever have, and you will look stupendous. i promise you. >> announcer: luminess air uses up to 10 times less makeup than liquid foundations applied with your fingers. so instead of exaggerating wrinkles and pores, luminess gives your skin a soft, youthful, glowing look. you'll look dramatically younger when you wear luminess air. >> the wrinkles are not there. everything's covered. i see smoothness on my skin. >> i know one thing for sure. when i use the wrong makeup, i'll age 10 years on the spot. i'm 60 years old. luminess air is gonna make you look younger. >> announcer: now to celebrate our 20th anniversary,
2:13 am
introducing our new and improved luminess airbrush. this is our best airbrush system ever. this new system is 10 times quieter and half the size of our previous systems. it now features our new and improved no mess tip. the overspray is gone. this new tip gives you complete control over the makeup. that means there's never, ever a mess. >> i love that special pink tip that's on the end of the airbrush because there's no mess. the luminess air system is so fantastic. >> announcer: this is our best airbrush system ever, so if you've beewaiting for the right time to begin airbrushing, this is it. >> you need to look younger. you don't need to look older. everyone should buy this. you're crazy not to. >> you need to stop wasting your money and try luminess air 'cause you're gonna look amazing. >> announcer: and now our 20 years of beauty anniversary sale is on. luminess air is now more affordable than ever. call or go online right now. you can try everything you see here. it's the best of luminess for just $29.95. that's right -- only $29.95.
2:14 am
call now. you'll receive our newest generation airbrush complete with our brand-new no mess tip. you'll see how easy it is to get airbrush coverage at home. you'll receive the award-winning luminess air foundation matched to your skin te. and when you order now, we'll include four more free gifts. we'll include our luminess air blush, the skin-brightening luminess glow, our luminess air bronzer, and the luminess air moisturizing primer. it's an $80 value -- yours free when you order. and you'll get the luminess air mobile app free. the luminess app is like a personal makeup artist on demand. it's loaded with video tips on how to get the airbrush look at home. the luminess app is for apple and android devices. >> $29.95 for the whole unit to try it? how could you not do this? >> only $29.95? it's a no-brainer. >> announcer: the luminess air formula is a breakthrough inía cosmetics. it's made from natural mineral ingredients, it's hypoallergenic, 100% oil-free,
2:15 am
fragrance-free, water-based, is spf 15, and lasts 12 hours. and at luminess air, we never test on animals. hold on! now our 20 year anniversary special is on. when you try luminess air, you'll save 33%. that's right! you won't pay $29.95. now, for a limited time, you can try luminess air for just $19.95. this is our best offer ever, but it's only for a limited time. and we'll even include free shipping when you order right now. why wait? >> $19.95? this is a great deal. there isn't a better product out there. >> that is a ridiculous price to get this kind of result. >> it is infinitely better than anything else i have ever used in the past. >> announcer: call or go online for your luminess air right now. >> i have no foundation on right now. i am naked right here and here.
2:16 am
i've got a lot of freckling. and i've got some lines around my eyes and forehead. it just kind of gets me down sometimes. i love the luminess air, so i'm gonna just take this, go lightly over everything, very lightly at first. look at that. the magic is, see this little freckle right here? watch. pretty cool. i love it. more to cover. little freckles. not at all messy. look, it's not even in my hair. that's the reason it works, that little, pink tip. more to cover. little freckles. and there. done. it looks awesome! look at that! i love it. and it even lightens my crow's feet, which i preciate. they've created this system that
2:17 am
just sprays the product onto your face, micro -- micro-spraying. and i look younger. [ chuckling ] and i love that. >> announcer: luminess air invaded a shopping mall and introduced the beauty of airbrush to women who wear ordinary makeup. for three days, hundreds of women got to try luminess air. they were photographed and videotaped and asked to compare luminess air to their regular makeup. some of the women were a little intimidated. >> are you scared? >> yes. [ laughs ] >> i'm nervous about this. >> i'm a little concerned. >> it's intimidating. >> i'm nervous. >> announcer: and then they tried it for the first time. >> you ready? >> oh. i guess so. >> just push it? >> yeah. >> a couple drops? >> two, three. >> i was kind of scared i wasn't gonna be able to do it. >> it feels really good. >> it's a lot simpler than i thought. >> it's so easy. >> announcer: when they finished luminessing, they looked at the results. >> wow. it looks amazing.
2:18 am
my skin looks flawless. there's a huge difference. it's so amazing. >> i don't like to spend a lot of time, and i like things very, very natural. i think it's great. this looks like i have flawless skin. >> i feel like i'm 10 years younger. i really do. i mean, this looks great. >> i have so much redness, and i don't see that anymore. it's very easy, and it's great. i like it a lot. >> i love it. >> i'm rea to take one home. >> i do look good.mu it looks incredible, yeah. thank you. >> announcer: the new and improved luminess airbrush with our new no mess tip makes covering difficult problems fast and simple. watch this video demonstration. take a look at the blemish on this woman's face. now watch the airbrush make it disappear. the blemish is gone without the need for heavy, streaky concealers. you just saw it happen. now watch this age spot disappear instantly. the age spot's gone without the look of heavy, cakey foundation. can your current makeup do this?
2:19 am
of course not. how about dark circles under the eyes? airbrush covers them like magic. here's redness and rosacea. now watch it vanish quickly, ealy, and flawlessly without any heavy buildup at all. this is luminess air. >> the coverage is amazing. the tiny, little, broken capillaries, the little red dots, the sun damage -- it covers all of that. >> announcer: if you have sensitive skin or struggle with breakouts, the way you're applying your makeup could be a big part of the problem. >> this brush is a potential cause of infection on the skin. >> announcer: dr. debra luftman is one of the world's leading dermatologists. she's the author of the book "the beauty prescription," and her beverly hills practice is filled with celebrities who need care for their skin. she has an important warning about using dirty fingers, sponges, and brushes on your skin. >> a brush is a porous material that can get contaminated very easily by touching skin, then touching makeup.
2:20 am
and if you use your dirty fingers to apply makeup, then that can even be worse. potentially, this could be the source of irritation and breakouts. touchless makeup with the luminess air means that there is nothing that is going to be contaminating the makeup and then contaminating your face and contaminating your skin and causing bacterial infections. luminess air is great because it's so gentle on your skin. it's made from natural ingredients. it's hypo-allergenic, non-commedogenic, and paraben-free. it's completely water-based, oil-free, and fragrance-free. so when you're wearing luminess air, not only do you look great because of the makeup, but you're actually protecting the future of your skin. >> announcer: luminess airbrush foundation is pure and water-based. watch what happens when we put a few drops into this beaker of water. it mixes completely. this is what truly water-based foundation should do when dropped into water. leading store-bought foundations claim to be water-based. here's an example. let's put it to the test. watch what happens when we drop it into water.
2:21 am
it should mix and dissolve, but instead, it falls to the bottom of the beaker like thick lumps of goo. it's shocking. most store-bought foundations that claim to be water-based are loaded with oils and emulsifiers, and that makes them thick and heavy on your skin. the difference between the purity of luminess air foundation and the heaviness of store-bought brands couldn't be more dramatic. now let's take a look at what this means when you actually apply the foundation to your skin. this woman has sun damage, age spots, and fine lines and wrinkles. this is what happens when she tries to cover these problems with store-bought liquid foundation. it covers, but it's so thick and heavy, it builds up in the fine lines and wrinkles around her eyes, actually making them look worse. this is luminess air. her skin looks baby smooth, her pigmentation problems are covered, and the fine lines and wrinkles around her eyes are practically gone. let's compare them side by side. on the left is no makeup. in the middle is old-fashioned heavy liquid foundation. on the right is luminess air.
2:22 am
the results are dramatic. these are the kinds of results you'll see on your skin when you use luminess air. >> makeup is supposed to help smooth the lines, but it actually kind of fills into the lines and makes the linetrlook worse. luminess does this amazing thing. it makes your skin look flawless. i mean, it covers it in such a beautiful way. now when i use luminess, my skin automatically looks more beautiful, and i look young again. i love that. >> i have this problem, and this is rosacea. it gets so red, i look like rudolph. i'm not kidding. and it's horrible, and you cannot cover it up. and i have tried everything, and nothing works. i'm gonna show you exactly how i use the airbrush to cover this and get rid of this rosacea so you never see it, and the results will be amazing. get your stylus, put a few drops. i just use four. get it going. you'll feel the air coming out. here comes the makeup. you see? look how fast it's disappearing. it's just microscopic amounts of
2:23 am
makeup coming out right now. and look at that. the redness gone. lookit -- red spot there. watch this. gonna get rid of that. i'll concentrate on that a little bit. voilà. gone. got a little age spot there. come even it out over here. but the thing is, it's so easy. it just goes on so smooth and clean. i'm not using anything else anymore. and look, i look perfect. no rosacea, no age spots, no imperfections. just a smooth, natural complexion. i think it's amazing. >> announcer: let's take a closeup look at why luminess ll look so beautiful on your skin. we used a microscope on this model's face to show exactly what liquid foundation and luminess look like when applied to fine lines and wrinkles. just look at the heavy cakiness of liquid foundation and how it makes her crow's feet look worse when she smiles. now look how smooth and pretty her skin is with luminess air. the luminess coverage is
2:24 am
ultra-fine and doesn't cake on. now look at our model's skin side by side. you are seeing the reason why traditional makeup can actually make you look older and why luminess air will make your skin look baby smooth. >> there's not a big buildup in here. it just sort of finely feathers that away. underneath, the crepiness doesn't seem to be as rough or textured. >> when i was using my old makeup, i felt i was looking older than my age. it would kind of get into the creases of the lines and actually make the lines more prominent, and now using luminess just is incredible. it makes the wrinkles around my eyes have a flawless look, and it diminishes the look of the wrinkles. it's awesome. i look better than i've ever looked. i would not go back to my old makeup. >> announcer: take a look at this blemish. no qyou see it. now you don't. >> it is amazing. >> announcer: do you see this age spot? don't blink. it's gone like magic. >> luminess is stupendous.
2:25 am
>> announcer: watch this redness disappear at the touch of a button. >> people come up to me and say, "your skin is beautiful." >> i've had two people actually tell me it looks like i have porcelain skin. >> announcer: introducing the airbrush beauty breakthrough -- luminess air, the most exciting new beauty product in years. it's the revolutionary new way to apply makeup that gets results liquids and powders can't match. >> i love it. i love the way i look. i looked in the mirror, and it was like, "whoa." it's a miracle makeup. it's the only makeup i will use. >> announcer: airbrush makeup is the hollywood secret to beauty. it's the reason celebrities look so fabulous in magazines and when they walk the red carpet. now airbrush is for everyone. luminess air is the new and better way to get results like this. you'll look better than you've ever looked. you'll cover all your flaws and look years younger. airbrush foundation is unique in the beauty world because it completely coverflaws but
2:26 am
looks just like youthful, natural skin, not makeup. take a look at the blemish on this woman's face. now watch airbrush make it disappear. the blemish is gone without the need for heavy, streaky concealers. now watch this age spot disappear instantly. the age spot is gone without the look of heavy, cakey foundation. if redness is your problem, watch how it's covered. this is what luminess air can do for you. >> it is the best coverage you'll ever have, and you will look stupendous. i promise you. >> announcer: and we've made airbrushing easy. just a few drops of makeup in the airbrush, a touch of the button, and apply with a controlled mist of air. liquids build up and turn cakey, but look at luminess. it blurs and softens the fine lines for a smooth, natural, younger look. luminess air uses up to 10 times less makeup than liquid foundations applied with your fingers. so instead of exaggerating wrinkles and pores, luminess gives you skin a soft, youthful, glowing look. you'll look dramatically younger
2:27 am
when you wear luminess air. >> the wrinkles are not there. everything's covered. i see smoothness on my skin. >> i know one thing for sure. when i use the wrong makeup, i'll age 10 years on the spot. i'm 60 years old. luminess air is gonna make you look younger. >> announcer: airbrush eliminates that foundation mask with the best color match you've ever seen. >> it's a perfect match. >> i'm hispanic, and it's always been difficult to find a good match. with luminess, i'm able to match my color perfectly. >> i get the perfect color. it works. >> announcer: luminess air is a complete makeup system with a full range of shades, from the lightest porcelain to the richest ebony. and for difficult skin tones, you can even blend different shades of luminess foundations to achieve the most spot-on color match you've ever seen. >> i love that i can blend two different shades and get the perfect shade for my face. >> i've never seen my face look that flawless and clear. i've never had that in a
2:28 am
foundation ever. i love it. >> announcer: and now to celebrate our 20th anniversary, introducing our new and improved luminess airbrush. this is our best airbrush system ever. this new system is 10 times quieter and half the size of our previous systems. it's now so compact, it fits in the palm of your hand. and it now features our new and improved no mess tip. the overspray is gone. this n tip gives you complete control over the makeup and totally eliminates overspray. that means there's never, ever a mess. the luminess airbrush delivers ultra-high definition coverage. makeup doesn't get any better than this. >> i love that special pink tip that's on the end of theop airbrush because there's no mess. the luminess air system is so fantastic. >> announcer: this is our best airbrush system ever. so if you've been waiting for the right time to begin airbrushing, this is it. >> you need to look younger. you don't need to look older. everyone should buy this. you're crazy not to. >> you need to stop wasting your money and try luminess air
2:29 am
'cause you're gonna look amazing. >> announcer: and now our 20 years of beauty anniversary sale is on. luminess air is now more affordable than ever. call or go online right now. you can try everything you see here. it's the best of luminess for just $29.95. that's right -- only $29.95. call now. you'll receive our newest generation airbrush complete with our brand-new no mess tip. you'll see how easy it is to get airbrush coverage at home. you'll receive the award-winning luminess air foundation matched to your skin tone. use every last drop. you will love the way you look. and when you order now, we'll include four more free gifts. we'll include our luminess air blush, the skin-brightening luminess glow, our luminess air bronzer, and the luminess air moisturizing primer. it's an $80 value -- yours free when you order. and you'll get the luminess air mobile app free. the luminess app is like a personal makeup artist on demand. it's loaded with video tips on how to get the airbrush look at
2:30 am
home. the luminess app is for apple and android devices. >> $29.95 for the whole unit to try it? how could you not do this? >> only $29.95? it's a no-brainer. >> announcer: the luminess air formula is a breakthrough in cosmetics. it's made from natural mineral ingredients, it's hypoallergenic, 100% oil-free, fragrance-free, water-based, is spf 15, and lasts 12 hours. and at luminess air, we never test on animals. hold on! now our 20 year anniversary special is on. when you try luminess air, you'll save 33%. that's right! you won't pay $29.95. now, for a limited time, you can try luminess air for just $19.95. this is our best offer ever, but it's only for a limited time. and upgrades are always nice, so as part of this anniversary special, we'll even include free shipping when you order right now. why wait? >> $19.95? this is a great deal.
2:31 am
there isn't a better product out there. >> that is a ridiculous price to get this kind of result. >> once you try this product, i am telling you, you will never go back to using your department-store brand. it comes out perfect every time. >> it is infinitely better than anything else i have ever used in the past. >> announcer: call or go online for your luminess air right now. >> if you care about your skin and you want to look younger, you should try this product. >> you need to throw away what you're using and try this. because once you do, you will never go back. you will never go back. >> it's a miracle makeup, which sounds so silly, but it really -- that's the only way -- the only way i can describe it. it's the only makeup i will use from now on. >> i can honestly say you need to buy luminess air.
2:32 am
it's gonna help you out. it's gonna make you look younger. it's gonna make you feel better. it's the best thing ever. >> announcer: this is your last chance to get the flawless-looking skin you have always wanted. covering skin problems really is this fast and easy. now it's time to call and see the magical results of luminess air for yourself. the luminess air makeup system comes with everything you need to look younger instantly. luminess air is so easy to use, you will see the flawless results the very first time you use it. it takes just seconds. our 20 year anniversary special is on now. don't wait. there has never been a better time to try luminess air. call or go online right now. this has been a paid presentation for luminess air.
2:33 am
this has been a paid ...8 layers of wheat... ...and one that's sweet. to satisfy the adult.... ...and kid - in all of us. ♪ nutritious wheat for the adult you've grown into. and delicious sweet for the kid you'll never outgrow... feed your inner kidult... ...with frosted mini-wheats® and now you could win up to a hundred dollars when you buy any specially marked kellogg's cereal. it's from daddy. sfx: dad's voice i love you baby girl. duracell quantum lasts longer in 99% of devices so you can always be there.
2:34 am
♪ moisture so i can get into it ao enhance mbit quicker. ral and when i know she's into it, i get into it and... feel the difference with k-y ultragel. so whgetting better dental checkups than me, i decided to go pro... with crest pro-health advanced. my mouth is getting healthier. my teeth are getting stronger. this crest toothpaste is superior in five areas. great checkup.
2:35 am
what happened here in little owego, new york, in august 2007 was almost unbelievable. cal harris, convicted of killing his wife, michele, was about to be sent away for 25 to life and suddenly it all blew up right in d.a. jerry keane's face. >> i came into the courtroom thinking the defendant was going to be sentenced and it ended up more my being on trial. >> reporter: who on earth had the power to make this happen? he did, kevin tubbs. >> i know she was there, okay? i know she was. >> reporter: kevin tubbs, a
2:36 am
plain spoken rough hewn farm worker back then was hauling hay. why was he so important? because after six years during which tubbs swore he barely registered the fuss over the harris case, he picked up the paper and saw the story of cal's conviction and -- >> i seen that and, you know, i started like recalling, you know -- thinking like oh, my god. >> reporter: just like that, he suddenly knew, he said, that what he saw the morning after 9/11, the morning michele harris disappeared was important. it was between 5:30 and 6:00 in the morning, he said. he was hauling a load of hay. >> as i was going by the harris property, there was a blond woman out there and a young gentleman, you know, in his early 20s. >> reporter: standing by a pickup truck. >> my lights were right on them. >> reporter: and hardly more than ten feet away, he said, he looked straight at the young man.
2:37 am
saw he was dark haired, muscular and visibly angry. >> he looks at me like this, like what do you want? >> reporter: and the woman? she was looking down. >> just by her face, looked like she was crying. she was either upset or wasted. >> reporter: the woman, he said, he was certain of it, was michele harris. >> i know it was her. >> reporter: was it true? if kevin tubbs really did see michele on the early morning hours of september 12th, then the prosecutor's case was in ruins. because cal harris couldn't have murdered her some seven hours before and an innocent man had just been convicted. and so the judge tossed out the verdict, called for another trial and sent cal home to his kids. many, including michele's family, thought tubbs story was bogus. >> everybody knew he was lying. it was the most bizarre story that you could have ever told. >> reporter: and of course, when
2:38 am
trial number two opened in 2009, the prosecution attacked tubbs' credibility. why did he wait six years to come forward? still for the defense, tubbs was pure gold, the man to create reasonable doubt. >> there simply isn't enough evidence to convict cal harris of murder. >> reporter: bill easton was one of cal's attorneys. >> there's not an eyewitness to it, not an ear witness to it. he didn't confess to it. none of this direct evidence is present in this case. >> reporter: the prosecution argued that cal showed how unfeeling he was by failing to join the search for michele. that was nonsense, said his aunt merry. cal was simply trying to keep it all together for his small children. >> there were dozens, maybe hundreds of experts scouring the area, looking for her. and there was one person taking care of these four kids. >> reporter: that alleged motive that cal was worried the dealerships would take a hit because of the divorce? not so said cal's side.
2:39 am
his lawyer told him michele couldn't touch the business. and that anyway, before she vanished, michele had decided to accept cal's settlement offer, $740,000. >> she had indicated to numerous people she was happy with the settlement. >> reporter: besides, said aunt merry -- >> there's plenty of money to go around and no amount of money would have made cal say a ha, you know, for $2 million, i'm just going to wipe her out. >> reporter: then there was the blood, the spatter in the kitchen alcove. could have been a cut finger, said the defense. anyway, nobody could tell when it was left there. as for the prosecution's claim that cal tried to wash away blood on the garage floor -- >> there's a small amount of diluted blood that was found days after the new york state police had walked through this particular area of the house while they were conducting the search. >> reporter: walking on it is not going to droi the blood cells.
2:40 am
>> it could dilute it if their boots were wet. >> reporter: finally the defense decided jurors needed to hear from cal harris as a caring father not as the menacing husband the state made him out to be. the defendant took the stand. >> it was nerve-racking at first. obviously my life is on the line and my kids are -- you know, their lives are on the line. >> reporter: he admitted to an affair, blamed himself for the end of the marriage. but denied threatening her or trying to control michele. if anything, he said, she had been living a wild life, staying out all hours just before she disappeared. >> she came and went as she pleased. she had money to spend. i wasn't tracking her down. the baby-sitters were here. the nannies were here. she was off doing whatever she was doing. i don't even know what she was doing. >> reporter: was it enough? the jury deliberated for almost two days. and it wasn't. guilty again. >> takes your breath away.
2:41 am
you know, it's like getting stabbed in the stomach. just -- i'm numb, you know. i had already been through it once. >> reporter: family and friends stepped in, took care of his small kids who began a weekly ritual visiting dad in prison. taylor, the eldest. >> you go and get to see him for two hours a week and you've got a bunch of other people talking and it's loud. and you can't really have a private conversation. that was definitely the hardest part for us. i mean, he held it together well but -- >> reporter: what was it like driving home? >> quiet. >> reporter: watching his kids walk away week after week, said cal, was unimaginably hard. >> that was the worst. i went back to my cell and just laid there for hours and hours and just closed my eyes and tried to block it out. >> reporter: three years rolled by. but then came a day in october, 2012, when cal harris found himself crying for joy in the
2:42 am
prison yard. coming up -- >> it's rare, though. i mean, this is really rare for that to happen. >> yeah. >> a new chance at freedom, new urgency from the kids. >> it's time for the truth. >> and a whole new theory of the case. >> it's all coming together. >> it's time to look elsewhere. >> trial number three, when "dateline" continues. get ready to show your roots with roots touch-up from nice'n easy. seamlessly blends with leading shades, even salon shades in just 10 minutes. no roots. no grays. just the most shade choices for natural looking color as real as you are. so go ahead, show the world your roots with america's #1 root touch-up.
2:43 am
2:45 am
it's built-in, back-up braid helps stop leaks by channeling them back into the core, protecting you in a way no other tampon does. tampax. power over periods. a new test with pwe rented this resort, hid smelly objects all over each villa and plugged in febreze. then real people were asked to stay for a long weekend. would they smell anything? the room itself was like [sniff] ahhh. feels like someone has pumped fresh oxygen into the room. on the last day we revealed everything. oooooohwoww. we were sitting right on it. febreze is stunningly effective. continuously eliminate odors for up to 45 days break out the febreze you plug in [inhale + exhale mnemonic] and breathe happy.
2:46 am
had cal harris won the lottery, it could hardly be as surprising as the news he heard in the prison yard in 2012. >> reporter: this is rare, though. i mean this is really rare for that to happen. >> yeah. >> reporter: what happened? new york's court of appeals overturned his second murder conviction, citing errors made by the judge and ordered trial number three. while everyone waited for that, cal once again went home to the house on empire lake and his four growing children. tanner, the youngest, was in eighth grade then. the rest were in high school. >> that was great. >> reporter: what a change, huh? >> back to normal. it was easy. >> reporter: yeah? >> yeah. >> reporter: didn't take long to adjust? >> he had to adjust to what our plans were. >> reporter: well, you'd been coping on your own for so long. >> yeah.
2:47 am
>> reporter: this time, this third chance, the kids were determined this would be different. >> we want you to know our dad will not be taken away from us again for a crime we know he did not commit. >> reporter: it was a very public coming out. cayla addressed the cameras. the rest of the kids and their teary-eyed dad stood by. >> we cannot sit here in silence and watch another travesty of justice take place. >> reporter: this was march 2014. the family was helping launch a tip line, asking the public to help find out what really happened to michele. >> it's time for the truth. it's time for a real investigation that will get us answers. i think that it was a good thing for us to finally come out and talk about it. >> reporter: how did it feel to do it? >> good. >> it was shaky, but -- >> reporter: nervous before, great after? >> yeah. kind of relieved after. >> reporter: you have the floor, sir. >> we all knew this was our time to come out and give our side
2:48 am
everything else as they searched through every square inch of cal's life and property. according to lead defense attorney, bruce barket. >> they pursued this man for 14 years with scant evidence. evidence that really no prosecutor should bring a case on. and they pursued him relentlessly. >> reporter: without bothering to seriously consider any other suspects, said barket. so the defense scoured the police files for clues and a picture 'merge -- emerged, said the attorney, a disturbing picture of michele's last day. >> perhaps she was trusting and perhaps she shouldn't have been. >> reporter: they went back to witnesses the police had interviewed years before. talked to them and the others that led them to. and that's when they heard a whole new story of michele's last hours on earth. there was also a partial record from earlier trials, they said, which showed the mother of four had been hanging around with an unsavory crowd, co-workers and
2:49 am
customers from her waitressing job. >> people there that were dealing drugs, making sexual advances. >> reporter: and on the night she vanished after she left her boyfriend's place, they now knew, they said, that michele did not go home because one of those witnesses reported seeing her later that night with another man, a local steelworker. attorney donna aldea. >> on that night at a bar, in a dance club, he actually said. he was there but left the two of them alone and went home. >> reporter: the steelworker was a regular at her restaurant, said the defense, who had told friends he had a sexual relationship with michele. who was this man? according to the defense, he was the very same angry stranger kevin tubbs saw with michele in the early hours of september 12th. >> as i was going by the harris property, there was a blond woman out there and a young gentleman, you know, in his early 20s.
2:50 am
>> reporter: tubbs identified that man from a photograph. >> his physical appearance, his facial hair, his height, his age and the type of vehicle he drove. >> reporter: tubbs said the man he saw was standing beside a black truck. the steelworker owned a black truck, same kind. >> and it's a new model and it's a chevy. you look everything up and it's all coming together. >> reporter: also, they said, the steelworker gave conflicting accounts of where he was the night michele disappeared and how well he knew her. >> it went from the beginning knowing michele and having gone out with her at one point to not even knowing her name, knowing nothing about her. >> reporter: the defense attorneys were convinced that man played some role in the disappearance of michele harris. now they decided a jury needed to hear it. only it wouldn't be in owego. early on, the team scored a big victory when a judge agreed the third trial should be moved to another county to make sure cal had an impartial jury. >> it was huge.
2:51 am
it's a difficult motion to win. they're very uncommonly granted. >> reporter: the new trial would be held in tiny schohairie, away from tioga county, where, said the defense, almost everybody knew about cal harris. >> you had a relatively small county where, based on the data that we gathered, the polling showed that something like 97% of the people in tioga county knew cal harris' name, which is more people than know the names of the president of the united states. >> reporter: finally this past february, it began. this time jenna, one of cal's daughters would testify for the family. and this time the defense came on strong, relentlessly chipping away at the prosecution. the blood evidence, for example. this time the state wasn't allowed to suggest, as it had before, that the blood was spilled around the time michele disappeared. >> to have forensic scientists get up and speculate and guess at how old blood was based on
2:52 am
the color from a photograph is an outrageously unsupported proposition. >> reporter: also out? hearsay testimony from prosecution witnesses who said michele told them that cal threatened her life. >> we don't think they belong in evidence. it's part of the reason the case was unfair the first time, the second time. >> reporter: but then? then the defense attempted to present its evidence about that alternate suspect, the steelworker. and the judge shut them down. the jury would only be allowed to hear the following fact. the man's name, that michele knew him, that kevin tubbs i.d.'d him and that he owned a black truck at the time. no more. why? because it was cal harris on trial. wrong man, his attorneys insisted. >> cal did not deserve to be on trial. and frankly, michele and her family deserve better. we all want to know what happened to her. it's time to look elsewhere. >> reporter: there was a new prosecutor this time around.
2:53 am
tioga county's kirk martin. he made the same arguments as the previous d.a. saying the evidence pointed to cal harris killing his wife. the trial went on for three months. at the end of april, it finally went to the jury. and four kids and their father suddenly had nothing left to do but wait. >> we said what we want to do when it's all said and done and over with and the good end turns up. >> reporter: wlant to talk about that at all? >> vacation. >> yeah. >> somewhere cool. >> reporter: maybe. maybe not. coming up -- >> i know we're tough enough that we'll get through it. >> you have to be as positive as possible. >> what would happen this time? >> breaking news out of the east schoharie courthouse.
2:55 am
2:57 am
it was deja vu all over again for cal harris. wait by the courthouse every minute like an hour as 12 men and women weighed the evidence. and one man waited to be told his own fate. freedom or a possible sentence of 25 to life? you know, you have been confident before when you've gone on trial because you have said, i didn't do it and there's no evidence that i did it. so i should be acquitted. and yet you weren't. so how does that impact your thinking now? >> just by what bruce and his team have done in the investigation. it's -- it's really significant. now whether it will be enough, that remains to be seen. but it's got to create some doubt. it has to create some doubt. we didn't have that before. >> his life is on the line. >> reporter: defense attorney
2:58 am
aida. >> you pray for the best and i hope that the best happens in this case. >> reporter: uncertainty is a way of life for the harris children. never knowing if their father would be convicted again. >> so i think, you know, if things don't go our way, it will definitely, you know, turn all our worlds upside down, but i think we're -- i know we're tough enough that we'll get through it. you definitely don't like to think about that kind of thing. >> reporter: well, this -- you know, it's a daunting thought. and clearly you've had to think about it. if he's found guilty again. >> mm-hmm. >> reporter: how do you deal with it? >> we just spend a lot of time together. that's what we did when he was in jail last time. we'll see him every weekend. we'll have phone calls. we'll have each other. and you just have to try to be as positive as possible. >> not only for us but for him, too, with the whole thing, you know. >> reporter: but of course,
2:59 am
another family waited by the courthouse, too. michele's family, wanting a very different verdict. nothing they'd heard at trial number three changed the way they felt after trial number two. is there a corner of your brain that thinks, god, maybe it was somebody else? >> not at all. not at all. >> reporter: before two juries had returned their verdicts within hours. four hours the first trial, nine the second. but this time, the hours stretched into days. >> you want a hot dog, right? >> reporter: the defendant and his family did what they could to pass the time. lunching at the hot dog stand outside the courthouse, enjoying what could be their last moments as a family on the outside. four days in, jurors told the judge they were deadlocked. he sent them back to try again. eight days in, still deadlocked. again, they were instructed to keep trying.
3:00 am
finally, two weeks in, the jurors made it clear they simply could not reach a verdict. >> breaking news out of the schoharie county courthouse, the third cal harris murder trial has been ruled a mistrial by the judge. >> reporter: a mistrial. it was the outcome nobody wanted. >> we got closer to justice, but we're not there yet. we will continue to fight and continue to pursue the truth about what happened to michele. >> reporter: but her family believes they knew the truth, that cal murdered michele. they left the courthouse without comment. >> not right now. >> reporter: tioga county prosecutor kirk martin did address reporters. >> my obligation as a district attorney is to seek justice. >> reporter: he promised a fourth trial. >> there have been two guilty verdicts in this case and i eagerly await the earliest possible trial date that fits with the court's schedule. >> reporter: and so for now, a mystery almost 14 years old endures about a woman who
3:01 am
vanished on a warm september night while the rest of the world was looking the other way. that's all for now. i'm lester holt. this sunday, the trump effect. when donald trump talks -- >> make america great again. >> -- the rest of the republican field listens. >> with your help, we can make this country great again. >> how donald trump is setting the agenda for the gop campaign. also, hillary fights back. >> i'm not running for my husband's third term and i'm not running for president obama's third term. i'm running for my first term. >> hillary clinton letting joe biden know just how tough it will be for the vice president to jump in. >> the latest polls out of iowa. where things stand this morning will surprise you. where have you gone, scott walker? expected to be a front-runner at this point. he's been lagging in the polls. can he make a comeback?
136 Views
IN COLLECTIONS
WCAU (NBC) Television Archive Television Archive News Search ServiceUploaded by TV Archive on