this sunday terror in paris. how were suspects known to french and american authorities allowed to commit these atrocities. >> the more innocents who are killed in the attacks the greatest the impa 'tis for others to carry out similar attacks. >> eric holder will join me from paris. inside the mind of a terrorist. i will talk to a journalist who interviewed one of the men who carried out the paris massacre. why home grown islamist terror has been less of a threat in the united states. >> the person who immigrated here 20 years ago, their grandson who is now mike. >> in 2016 mitt romney is considering a third run for the

white house. what is behind his change of heart? i'm chuck todd. joining me are david brooks, andrea mitchell helene cooper and rich lowery. welcome to sunday, it's "meet the press." good morning. france's leadership has declared that the country is at war with radical islam. after three days of horrific terror attacks which brought fear and despair to the city of paris. 17 civilians are dead, 12 at charlie hebdo, four shoppers at a shupupermarket and a police officer. an alleged female accomplice is on the run. she wasn't part of the attacks, contrary to some reports out there.

overnight a german newspaper, which printed cartoons from charlie hebdo, was targeted in an arson attack. no one was injured. two people have been arrested. this morning, a video has emerged appearing to show amedyhmed coulibaly. there's a massive rally today taking place in the french capital part what have the prime minister has called a "cry of freedom" with up to a million people attending along with dozens of world leaders. nbc's chief global correspondent bill joins me now. tell me about this atmosphere. >> reporter: good morning. from the very heart of the demonstration, after a week of horror that has seared itself

into the soul of france this is a day of defiance. hundreds of thousands gathering here showing flags of france i'llalgeria algeria, all coming together. they showed -- had a -- hoisted up a giant pencil, a symbol of free speech here. ready to march the leaders of britain germany and israel showing their solidarity. this could be the biggest rally in france since paris was liberated from the nazis at the end of world war ii. as the leaders march and as they meet, they have a challenge. how to confront the terrorism here without overreacting legally in terms of police measures and without alienating the population. remember, france has a muslim population of 5 million. that's about 9% of the population. any overreaction could alienate a lot of those people and would be a disaster. it's a challenge to hold the

populations together. france's president francois hollande has described this as a test. it is but it's a test not just for france but the whole of europe and the whole of the west. >> it is. lots of implications for this around the world and in french politics as well. thanks very much. want to talk to eric holder in a moment. the paris attackers were known to the authorities in france and here in the united states. the big question is how did this happen? our chief foreign correspondent richard engel has been looking at what went wrong and the challenges that face security services around the world to stop similar attacks. >> reporter: these were not lone wolves but trained and disciplined killers on a mission. their victims, executed with single, controlled shots. this is what home grown terrorists look like in the era of the islamic state. like soldiers. the kouachi brothers were known

militants. they had been under surveillance but not long. counter terrorist sources they were deemed to be a minor threat. there were too many targets for security services to follow. this is the paris tourists don't normally see, the slums where illegal immigrants rub shoulders with drug dealers and religious extremists. for islamic radicals, these neighborhoods have long been a source of recruits. this week's attacks in france were tragically foretold. were you surprised by this attack ina attack attack? >> no. france was attacking terrorist attacks. >> reporter: did you think there would be an attack on this scale? >> no. >> reporter: the reason it was so big at least one of the broubl brothered brothers trained with al qaeda. they are part of a growing number of lawless places where

radical islamists are free to train recruits from the western world give them a taste of real warfare and send them back to the west with money and a mission, to launch spectacular attacks on soft targets. this week in paris three radicals killed 17 people and brought a world capital to a standstill. others may try to repeat their success. the question is, can western governments find a way to stop them? richard engel, nbc news paris. >> we're joined by the attorney general, eric holder, who is in paris for a security summit today with intelligence and law enforcement officials from around the word. he announced that another international summit on preventing extremism will be held at the white house next month. mr. attorney general, welcome back to "meet the press." let me start with a first question here, the french prime minister declayred france is at war with radical islam.

would you say the united states is at war with radical islam? >> i would say that we are at war with terrorists who commit these heinous acts and who use islam. they use a corrupted version of islam to justify their actions. we are bound and determined to hold them accountable, to find them wherever they are. and then to try, as you indicated, to come up with ways in which we prevent young people who become attracted to this radical ideology from becoming members of these groups and perpetrating these heinous acts. >> now, it seems that according to various sources we have here that the united states warned france that these two brothers in particular had gotten training in yemen nearly five years ago. is this an intelligence breakdown that happened in france or a law enforcement resource issue? because they can't follow everybody. >> well i'm not sure at this point that it would be fair to comment in that way. we are still dealing with the

immediate impact of these terrible acts that occurred here in france. there will be time for an after-action analysis of exactly what might have been done better. as we have done in the united states, when we have had to deal with these incidents ourselves or where we have disrupted plots, you always look back and try to determine how you might do things better. i will say that the french have been among our best allies, our greatest friends in this fight against global terrorism. and we are here to express our solidarity with them. >> considering though that it looks like yemen -- al qaeda and yemen had some impact on this operation, in 2012, john brennan, when he was the counter erer terrorism aid, he said that there was -- you had made progress degrading al qaeda in yemen. and yet they are clearly still inspiring and possibly funding

attacks. what's the status? >> i done't think there's any question we have decimated core al qaeda. the threat is from affiliates. chief is on the arabian peninsula. we have had an impact on them. but they remain a very viable threat. they have the ability to inspire people around the world, unfortunately. they have explosives experts in al qaeda, in the arabian peninsula, in a capacity that is unmatched by any other terrorist organization. so they remain a very viable threat that we have devoted considerable attention to and will consider -- will continue to focus on. >> considering that these two brothers potentially were essentially lyly a sleeper cell for nearly five years, if their training took place in 2012 and here it is 2015, are you concerned that there are potentially people in the united states that maybe the intelligence community asked you or the fbi to start following

these folks you stopped following them because you thought they didn't present a threat do you have to reconsider some folks here in the united states that maybe you had thought weren't a threat that maybe they are, maybe they are sleeper cells? >> we are constantly evaluating where we stand with regard to those people who we have suspicions about. we have a universe of people who we focus on, using all legitimate means. and keep track of them. keep track of their movements. using appropriate mechanisms monitor them as best we can. we do this in conjunction with our state and local counselor counterparts. the american people should feel secure in what it is that we do. now, one has to understand that it is very difficult to maintain a good contact, to stay in touch with all the people who are potentially going to do these kinds of things. that's the thing that keeps me

up most at night, this concern about the lone wolf, who goes undetected. but we are doing, as i said, the best that we can, marshaling resources we have. >> a year ago we were having a debate about privacy in this country. western europe was very upset with some of the surveillance tactics that they thought the united states was using in order to deal with terrorism in order to track potential terrorists. there has been announcements made that reforms, some sort of rolling back of this aggressive surveillance. any second thoughts about rolling back the aggressive surveillance that the united states was doing over say the first eight ten years after 9/11? >> i think what we looked at was changing the way in which we conduct some of our electronic surveillance programs so that we are focusing on -- focusing that effort on the people we are most concerned about. we're not going to do anything that -- you would term a rollback that would endanger the american people. we have talked to people in the intelligence community.

we have talked to people in our congress. i think we have come up with a way in which we can enhance the privacy concerns that people have expressed while at the same time making sure that we keep the american people safe. >> i got to ask you one last question on another topic. david pa tray yas has been under investigation for possibly sharing classified secrets with his mistress. there was a leak that prosecutors have recommended that this go to trial and that you mr. attorney general, are the final arbiter the final decision maker. are you going to make this decision before you leave office? >> i don't want to comment on what is an ongoing matter. i think that anybody who shared information that led to that report did so inappropriately. the determination has yet to be

made. we will just see how things play out before any final decision is made. >> but you are going to make this decision? >> well, again, i don't want to comment on an ongoing investigation and say where we stand with regard to any matter. this will be something that will have to be decided by the appropriate people in the justice department. >> all right. i will see that as a bit of a duck there, mr. attorney general. thanks for coming on "meet the press." >> thanks. let's get reaction from the panel. david andrea, rich and helene. andrea, if this attack happened in the united states and there was evidence that the united states intelligence agency had identified these two brothers and all three as potential threats, had gotten training in yemen, we would call this an intelligence breakdown.

this is not a lone wolf. four days ago we were talking lone wolf. this is bigger. >> it is bigger. it's an intelligence failure. u.s. officials are privately saying that it was a french intelligence failure. look at the boston marathon. there was tracking and there were gaps. boston and america came together and we didn't go through a whole who messed up in boston. i think france similarly has to learn lessons from this because clearly they are not equipped. the lesson here is also that they don't have the manpower, the intelligence services. very view countries do to keep track of all of these individuals especially in europe where they can go back and forth from syria, from the civil war, back to the continent. >> is this a bigger problem for france than the united states? >> i think absolutely it is because they are far more -- they have a far bigger muslim population in france than the united states. that population hasn't been

assimilated. france has had problems with how immigrants to france have sort of conducted -- have been treated as part of french society. the whole -- this immigrant population that rings paris in the suburbs. they are not really part of french culture. you have the laws that have been passed in france restricting wearing inging bu rrkas. the united states, we are a melting pot. there is -- my family moved to the u.s., you know, 20 years ago and there's a reason why we chose to come to the united states instead of moving to europe. one reason, we thought we would be treated better. >> david brooks, 17 people are dead in paris, 2,000 nigerias in the name of islamic radicalism were killed this week. boko haram in nigeria. it's a worldwide -- what is this? >> failed states. say you are in college or want to give money, we give money to

clean water, all that anti-poverty stuff. the central program is law and order. you can't get rich if you are afraid of getting shot in the back of the head at night. if you are giving as an individual, if you are thinking as a state, giving to law and order groups, that is the basis to get an anti-poverty program. bono is doing great stuff with diseases, law and order comes first. >> this is -- rich louer erlowery what should the policy be? >> it highlights the importance of surveillance. these guys fell through the cracks in france because there are too many targets to follow in france. but this is a reason we have things like the nsa program. there's also this attack highlights the domestic security consequences of having the greater middle east in flapmes. you have extremists with space to occupy and train people. there's the radicalizing affect

of this mayhem and sectarian warfare. >> if we're not there it radicalizes people. there is this catch 22. >> the fact is that we have as a global society basically ignored the fact that syria has been in civil war, hundreds of thousands of people dieing for four years. this is radicalizeing the conflict between israel and the palestinians, but bring back our girls. the construction in the nigerian military was so dismaying that the u.s. government pulled back from its coverage and help to try to find the girls. boko haram is marauding undeterred. >> the most violent of these islamic radical-based groups. we will put a pause here. we will talk more on this topic. a journalist who five years ago was working on a story about the under wear bomber when he met and interviewed said kouachi.

daughter: do you and mom still have money with that broker? dad: yeah, 20 something years now. thinking about what you want to do with your money? daughter: looking at options. what do you guys pay in fees? dad: i don't know exactly. daughter: if you're not happy do they have to pay you back? dad: it doesn't really work that way. daughter: you sure? vo: are you asking enough questions about the way your wealth is managed? wealth management at charles schwab. sunday dinners at my house... it's a full day for me, and i love it. but when i started having back pain my sister had to come help. i don't like asking for help. i took tylenol but i had to take six pills to get through the day. so my daughter brought over some aleve. it's just two pills, all day! and now, i'm back! aleve. two pills. all day strong, all day long. and now introducing aleve pm for a better am.

pictures of the millions strong rally in paris. we have learned said and cherif kouachi spent time in yemen. a journalist met said kouachi in the capital of yemen in january

of 2010 while working on an article about the underwear bomber. earlier this morning i spoke to him via skype from yemen and he talked about finding said kouachi during his investigation of life for the underwear bomber in yemen. >> while we were walking on the street trying to get to the residents where he used to live, we found a guy, a foreigner guy playing football with s on the street. and we approached him trying to talk to him, because we knew that he was a student. and we expected that he might

know something about. i make sure after i looked at the pictures and found out that the picture that was released by the french police was for said the one that i recognize. so he talked to us. he was very polite. we asked him if he was studying at that school, and he said he was studying at that school and he was doing arabic grammar course. then we started asking him questions and he said he lived in the same residence. >> when you saw and when you talked with said kouachi, did you get the sense then this was a terrorist in training? >> he was very very normal and he talked to us normally.

actually, we didn't -- i got shocked when i saw his photo on the press saying that this guy was the one that attacked the french newspaper. >> up next, what makes the us different? why we think home grown islamic terrorism seems to be less of a threat here at home. push your enterprise and you can move the world. ♪ ♪ but to get from the old way to the new you'll need the right it infrastructure. from a partner who knows how to make your enterprise more agile, borderless and secure. hp helps business move on all the possibilities of today. and stay ready for everything that is still to come. so ally bank really has no hidden fees on savings accounts? that's right. it's just that i'm worried about you know "hidden things..."

ok, why's that? no hidden fees from the bank where no branches equals great rates. . . . . these ally bank ira cds really do sound like a sure thing but i'm a bit skeptical of sure things. why's that? look what daddy's got... ahhhhhhhhhh!!!!! growth you can count on from the bank where no branches equals great rates.

♪ as we have been discussing, france is still reeling from this week's atrocities. attacks carried out by those born and raised in france. why is there less of a problem in the american muslim community? muslims make up a third of the

population in dearborn michigan. >> reporter: men who are young, disadvantaged are ripe for exploitation by militant recruiters and radicals. do similar conditions exist here in the u.s.? >> an extremist in paris, we don't accept it. >> reporter: no say some of america's muslim leaders and activists. >> i think america is generally a more accepting country of newer immigrants. that's what this country was built on. >> reporter: we travelled to dearborn, michigan, where must immigrants are arriving. >> some of them don't speak english yet. so they come to the mosque.

if we can't give the service that they need, we have contacts to make those services available to them. >> reporter: 65% of the muslims in europe say they identify with their faith before the national identity. in the u.s., it's considerably less at about 45%. >> we believe that you can be fully american and fully muslim and practice your faith freely without restriction. >> reporter: this man say lawyer and activist in the local muslim community. >> the person who emigrated here 20 years ago named mohammed their grandson is now mike. i see an asimulation on a lot of different levels. >> reporter: for some radicalization and attacks against the u.s. stems from anger at american foreign policies and wars in the middle east. while the overwhelming majority of muslims have successfully lyly assimilated into u.s. society, the challenge is to find some on the fringes of the communities

and are alienated. >> we will be able to inoculate them. whether it's the internet or television, the phobia that has been going on for the last several years has been -- has hurt. it has really hurt. >> reporter: that's because with every attack carried out around the world, it's the muslim community that feels the blow. for "meet the press." >> i'm joined by a professor at uc riverside. senior editor of the "islamic monthly." should we be looking at this as we heard the french prime minister say they are at war with radical islam. does the muslim community need to -- are we at war with a strain of islam, or is this a

perversion that we pretend doesn't exist? >> there's no question that there has been a kind of virus that has spread throughout the muslim world, a virus of ultra orthodox puritanism. but there's no question about what the source of this virus is, whether we're talking about boko haram or isis or al qaeda or the taliban, all of these have as their source a single sect. the state religious of saudi arabia. as most people know, saudi arabia spent approximately $100 billion over the last 20, 30 years spreading this ideology throughout the world. so we do have a problem within the muslim community but that problem tends to be very much localized within a particular ideology that must be confronted first and foremost by muslims themselves. >> i was going to say, we have had this conversation previously on this show not long ago. i want to get you to react to

something you were going to be appearing with ali but i want to read a part of her op ed thursday. she was a former muslim. she writes this. what would you say to her? >> i would is a that she's being too reduckive in her reasoning. it's important to keep in mind when you are dealing with second largest religion in the world with 1.7 billion people, there's no minority demographic group in western society that is placed with more guilt than muss lip slimmuslims. it's important we don't have a double standard in terms of

calling out terrorism. terrorism today has been co-opted to only apply when brown muslim men commits acts of mass murder and when white christian people kill 77 teenagers and try to bomb the prime minister of norway's office, we didn't ask the christian leaders to come out and condemn this. i think it's reduckive. >> you said there needs to be -- the muslim community needs to stand up. who are these folks? who is going to do it? >> every single organization major organization muslim organization throughout the world and in the united states every prominent individual, be it political or religious leaders everyone has condemned not just this attack but every attack that occurs in the name of islam. anyone who keeps saying that we need to hear the moderate voice of islam, why aren't muslims denouncing these violent attacks

doesn't own google. but that said i do think that we do need to do a better job of providing a counter narrative. what really i think puts an obstacle in the way is opinions like ayaan's and so many others in the political and media mainstream who continue to say that 1.7 billion people are responsible for the actions of these extremists. that doesn't help the fight against radicalism. the answer to islamic violence is islamic peace. the answer to islamic bigotry is islamic icic icic icic pluralism. i recognize the work is being done, the voice of condemnation is deafening. if you don't hear it you are not listening. sgli >> i want to bring in the rest of the panel. many americans don't hear the difference. >> i think it's easy to make.

obviously, not all muslims, not even a majority of muslims in any way justify this kind of radical radicalism. but the radicals so cite text to support their actiies that back up their interpretations. you go to saudi arabia you go to iran and you say negative things about mohammed, very bad things are going to happen to you. you can insult in the west catholics, baptists quakers, no one is going to show up at your door with an automatic weapon. that's not true -- >> you are providing a transition that i want to get to. that is this idea of what should -- how should the media handle this? is mohammed up not the same satirical treatment as jesus christ is, as the pope, all of those things? david you wrote something that i can tell you more people e-mailed me about your column on friday than i get usually. the journalists at charlie hebdo

are being celebrated as martyrs. >> the reaction should be for us domestically, is let's get offended more. let's tolerate a little offensiveness. microaggression, it's a minor offense against people. you have to learn to tolerate that. we have to do two things. we have to uphold standards of civility and decency. but we have to let the clowns say what the clowns do. you never do that with law. you never do it with speech. you don't disinvite speakers. you allow them to talk. you have distinctions. some people like we are at the adult table. some people like ann coulter, charlie hebdo, the kid table.

>> it's interesting. when it comes to satirizing mohammed, the only american organization that i have seen that has done it is "south park." i will play a clip. >> i can't be responsible for people getting hurt. especially me. >> yes. people can get hurt. that's how terrorism works. but if you give in to that you are allowing terrorism to work. do the right thing here. >> we laugh about it. what is the right thing? does the muslim community in general need to learn more tolerance of being satirized? or is this also isolated? >> i think it's a generalization to say that muslims don't tolerate being satirized. there is such a thing as privileged communities. it's okay and nobody really bothers you if you make fun of the christianity because 70% of the americans are christian. it's the same issue that we have with regard to black/white relations and what is and what

is not proper speech when referring to various stereotypes of either group. look the fact of the matter is that even in the most free democracies there are limitations about what you can and cannot say. in france there are limitations about what you can and cannot say about the holocaust. in india about religious minorities. we have to stand up as individuals and make sure that we are being counted. with regard to your question, if we're talking about what muslims can do what they can look to i think the best person to look to is the police officer killed by the men for defending the right to do this. >> thank you both for joining the panel. we have a lot of domestic politics we're going to do. up next, states of play. wait until you see this. the states where you can smoke pot, pack heat and marry your

same-sex partner all in the same state. and some of the states where you can't do any of them. as we go to break more scenes from the massive unity rally in paris. as you can see, world leaders, i believe up front there is prime minister -- israeli prime minister netanyahu. [ male announcer ] ours was the first modern airliner, revolutionary by every standard. and that became our passion. to always build something better airplanes that fly cleaner and farther on less fuel. that redefine comfort and connect the world like never before. after all, you can't turn dreams into airpl unless your passion for innovation is nonstop. ♪ ♪

shopping online is as easy as it gets. wouldn't it be great if hiring plumbers, carpenters and even piano tuners were just as simple? thanks to angie's list now it is. we've . mane from a handyman to a dog walker as simple as a few clicks. buy their services directly at angieslist.com no more calling around. no more hassles. start shopping from a list of top-rated providers today. angie's list is revolutionizing local service again. visit angieslist.com today. alka-seltzer plus presents

the cold truth. i have a cold, with terrible chest congestion. better take something. i'll catch up later. awww... truth is, theraflu severe cold doesn't treat chest congestion. really? new alka-seltzer plus day powder rushes relief to your worst cold symptoms plus chest congestion. oh, what a relief it is. here we go! woooo! woooo! and now, alka-seltzer plus has a complete line of powders to treat your worst cold symptoms. nerdscreen time. this is a fun one. you will enjoy it.

this week, florida became the latest state to the allow gay couples to marry and i say has to, because it was ordered many this case. this is what it does to bring the total number of states recognizing same-sex marriage to 36 including the district of columbia in blue and now 7 of 10 americans live in a state where same-sex marriage is allowed, and this got us thinking about how your individual rights depend on where you live. a take a look. this is some states ha that allow some use of marijuana. 19 states where medical marijuana is legal, and these four that allow recreational plus d.c. that allow recreational marijuana and allow same sex couples to marry and all of these states except for montana and arizona voted for president obama twice. and now looking at gun rights. look at this map. the states the in red, and almost all of them have the most lenient gun laws and the more position here in this case and the opposite of

the past two maps, and 8/10ths voted for president obama, and so which ones are more conservative ideologically? in is the ones more liberal to smoke marijuana and marry whoever you want and have a retirement age lower than the federal average and most of these states voted for president obama this in 2008 and 2012. and the other side of the pendulum, these are states with more conservative states of guns and abortion and not a surprise that these states went red in the past two presidential elections, and finally, the states that straddle the divide and in other words, the libertarian utopia and marry anybody you want and smoke weed and carry a weapon wherever you

want and guess where? think small and sparse, vermont, new mexico and alaska. libertarians, you should be moving there. and in a few minutes the real reason that mitt romney is talking about a possible third run at the white house. can move the world. ♪ ♪ but to get from the old way to the new you'll need the right it infrastructure. from a partner who knows how to make your enterprise more agile, borderless and secure. hp helps business move on all the possibilities of today. and stay ready for everything that is still to come.

. it was 13 years ago today that the united states government decided to open a prison on the island of cuba. six years ago, almost to the day, president obama tried to make good on this campaign promise. >> we provide process whereby kwan ta na mow will be closed no

later than one year from now. >> that's not the case. congress made it virtually impossible to move any detainees to prisons on american soil. the detainees that are there include some of the worst there were 242 men in prison there. now 127 remain. including 59 who have been approved for train inging. clifford sloan and carol rosenberg who has covered this extensively perhaps the most extensive of any journalist in the world, welcome to all of you. given what we are seeing and what unfolded in paris, clifford, i want to start with you. one of the three now dead

terrorists was somebody who got radicalized in prison. this was a regular prison, a regular jail. the big fear, obviously that is used to slow down or prevent figuring how to empty out guantanamo is this fear that they are going to return to the fight. what do you say to this? >> one point that is very important, chuck, is that there was a very intensive review of every person at kwan ta na mow. when you say approved for transfer, it's very important for people to understand what this means. it relates to your question. it was a year-long process. for somebody to be approved for transfer, it meant that six departments and agencies had to agree that the person can be transferred -- >> this is -- we're talking national -- >> the joint chiefs of staff, the department of justice, homeland security, state department. what that means is that you had

military, intelligence, law enforcement, homeland security foreign policy perspectives all six had to ooh none mausunanimously agree. that has stood the test of time. it was an intensive review. they looked at everything about the person and the risks. the percentage of those who have subsequently engaged in wrongdoing is small. it's 6.8%. everybody wants that number to be zero. that's too much. but that means that well over 90% of those who have been transferred in this administration after going through that process not only confirmed to have engaged in wrongdoing, they're not suspected. it's a very thurorough process. >> there's a return to terrorism problem. there's a vast number about which we know very little. you mentioned the paris attack. one of the terrorist that killed people in paris had been in yemen. what did the intell gens

services say? we know he went to yemen. there's a hole for the two years after that. i think there's a big hole for a lot of the people that left kwan guantanamo. if you are not willing to take people into custody, then you have to kill them. that means that you don't know anything about any of these terrorist organizations out there. that's the position we're in right now. >> i want to return this back to the issue of guantanamo. yemen is important here because of a majority of the folks left in guantanamo in this prison are yemeni. there's a concern yemen is not stable enough to return them. >> i think the blowback from the events in france from the past week is that nobody is going back to yemen. they will -- anybody who -- fine out one of the brothers in france trained in yemen. >> correct. and there's been a reluctance to sen the send the people who are cleared to find new homes to yemen. the threshold just got higher.

>> this was your job, you were trying to find these folks homes. here is something the president said very recently at the end of last year. >> a certain number that are going to be hard cases. we know they have done something wrong and they are still dangerous, but it's difficult to mount the evidence in a traditional court. >> you can't deal with them in the court and you can't return them. where are these people going to go? >> chuck, first of all there are a lot who have been approved for transfer who don't present that problem. the first priority is move those who are -- who have been approved for transfer now. first step in closing guantanamo is transfer those who can be approve approved. then you are left with a small core. the case for doing so it will be overwhelming. >> do you believe that guantanamo is a recruiting tool for terrorism?

>> absolutely not. you tell me if what happened in paris was because of gaunuantanamo or because of the occupation of jerusalem. there are always excuseds. >> before the president leaves office a minimum down to 60 prisoners. >> i believe it's going to be closed by the time the president leaves office. >> do you really? >> i do. nobody should -- >> the republican congress? >> nobody should under estimate president obama's xhiltcommitment of the issue. >> you watched a version of justice down there. >> the problem is, there's 127 men down there and only ten are before that version of justice. so the rest of them are captives in this thing we call the war for which there is nobody on the other side to surrender for that war to end for a mechanism for them to leave. the question becomes what are

they -- when does that war end and how long do you keep people as captives of that in. >> has the united states government given the detainees due process of any form that is defensible? >> well, the united states government position, it defends the legality of everybody who is there in court. my own personal view is that holding men for 12 13 years without charges, many of whom have been approved for transfer for almost half of the time of their imprisonment, is deeply inconsistent with the kind of country we want to be. >> appreciate it. we will have more of this conversation online. when it copmes to gitmo, there's more to say.

as parents we hold our kids' hands when crossing the street so think of the internet as the world's busiest street. teach your kids to surf and post responsibly. they'll be safer with a dedicated crossing guard... the more you know. it was a busy week in the world of politics. 2016 took a backseat to the events around the world. let's look at three headlines this week that made news in 2016 front. jeb bush, launching his political action committee.

he released a statement and it looked like his brother's 1999 and 2000 definition of compassionate conservatism. the iowa republican party voted to preserve andrea mitchell's favorite event, the straw poll. the august winnowing affect it has had over the years. probably the most important headline of the week came from courtesy of mitt romney. mitt romney says he is considering a third run for the white house. rich lowery romney versus bush. we had stopped saying mitt romney's name the minute jeb bush said he was interested. what's this about? >> well it may be that romney looks at the field, thinks they are flawed and thinks i have different flaws so why not? he can say i ran a credible campaign and maybe against someone who doesn't have advantages it will turn out different. i think it has to be a turn the page election for republicans. who has been making the most

noise? jeb bush, mike huckabee and mitt romney. these are not fresh faces. >> we just did -- observed a focus group in colorado. it was a lot of people sounding like rich, turn the page. no more clintons no more bushes. one guy wanted a congressional resolution that said clinton and bush couldn't run. >> the desire for something new may advantage rand paul. mitt romney's motivation -- people think in the end he won't do it. that all this talk is really antagonism against watching jeb bush getting so far out front that this is kind of -- if jeb can do this i can do it. in the end he will realize that there will be a reality check that third time is not a charm. >> part of this is personal. we have to remember politics is more importantalpersonal than we think. jeb never liked his decision to

flip. >> the world is governed by 4-year-olds. >> i thought the -- i thought we were at the adult table. >> the adults look at the kids on the playground. tell what kind of conservative you are by what year you want to go back to. i don't think romney is old enough. going back to peter heart, as bush steps out, as romney and clinton steps out, the country is recoiling. that focus group is part of the recoil. if ever there was a super highway for elizabeth warren and something like that, that is wide open. >> and rand paul. >> we have fun with 2016 with you. you think it's so early. but it's interesting going to this clinton/bush thing, around the world there's a rise of pop ooh lymph. when you have a rise it's not just here in america it's in france britain, it's taking place in western europe it means it's a revolt against the establishment ever taking place. that's what's going on. >> that's the case.

what's funny is i was talking to a french friend of mine who is -- about what romney -- >> name dropper. >> about the romney not really an announcement announcement. are you sure you don't have a monarchy in the united states? you are telling me we're looking at an election with clinton, bush and romney? there's something about that that strikes people everywhere as just completely offbeat. >> i think that this -- the terror incidents and the real concerns about what might happen here will change the dialogue. you are not going to have the republican field and the end ldzless primary show. this will be a more serious election. >> speaking of 4-year-olds and not serious, but presidential politics, very important to you helene, football season is