i wasn't planning to speak today but i felt compelled to express my gratitude to commissioner carter ober stone for being a leader with such principle and integrity. i think that we have been lucky to have someone with his expertise who has been willing to lend that to us to serve this city. he's been a pillar for civil rights and the community and i think it's very telling how many people have come out today to speak on behalf of the commissioner. i think that he's been an excellent advocate for the community and i'm grateful for the opportunity to stand with him. i sincerely hope that this board stands with him as well and i urge you to vote no on this motion. >> thank you. thank you for your comments. welcome. >> hello i'm from quadruple a another of ac's army of associates always hyphenated american. has there been some overstatements here? yes i. i can't see how this voting to sustain this would not be a step towards losing chief scott you've got to figure he's on a pretty thin rope as it is and you know i actually think maybe you know i've been watching the news a little bit and i a

i wish there had been a max ober stone carter for her. >> yeah. if you do this it will set a precedent. >> he what else is lori going to do if he wins this one? >> then you're sending him a message that it's he can do whatever he wants because this is really, really, really bad. >> i just i can't believe that any of you any of you especially some of you that are being recalled would even consider would even consider voting yes on this do the right thing. >> have some done us have some go on this. do the right thing. thank you. >> thank you. any porter. >> speaker welcome. good afternoon. hi everybody. >> i as president of the police commission sorry marie ravioli. i am an eighth generation san franciscan married to an immigrant so since we're all sharing that information i thought i'd let you know as president of the commission max carter over stone went far beyond the very laudable goal of police reform and accountability and overstepped with a very clearly clear and strong anti-police agenda that has impacted public safety for the last several y

i wish there had been a max ober stone carter for her. >> yeah. if you do this it will set a precedent. >> he what else is lori going to do if he wins this one? >> then you're sending him a message that it's he can do whatever he wants because this is really, really, really bad. >> i just i can't believe that any of you any of you especially some of you that are being recalled would even consider would even consider voting yes on this do the right thing. >> have some done us have some go on this. do the right thing. thank you. >> thank you. any porter. >> speaker welcome. good afternoon. hi everybody. >> i as president of the police commission sorry marie ravioli. i am an eighth generation san franciscan married to an immigrant so since we're all sharing that information i thought i'd let you know as president of the commission max carter over stone went far beyond the very laudable goal of police reform and accountability and overstepped with a very clearly clear and strong anti-police agenda that has impacted public safety for the last several y

vice president carter ober stone yes. vice president carter roberson is yes and president elias yes. present elias is yes. you have six yeses line item three adoption of minutes action for the meeting of january 15th 2025 so move if any member of the public would like to make public comment regarding the line item three adoption of minutes please approach the podium. there is no public comment on the motion. commissioner clay how do you vote yes commissioner clay is yes. commissioner benedicto commissioner benedicto as yes commissioner jonas yes. commissioner jonas is yes commissioner ye yes commissioner yes. yes. and vice president carter stone yes i was present carter always jonas yes. and president elias? yes. present licenses? yes. you have six yeses lean on him for chief support discussion weekly crime trends and public safety concerns provide an overview of offenses, incidents or events occurring in san francisco having an impact on the public safety commission discussion of unplanned events and activities the chief

president commissioner benedicto president commissioner janez commissioner years enroute vice president carter ober stone is also enroute

president commissioner benedicto president commissioner janez commissioner years enroute vice president carter ober stone is also enroute present i ask you have a quorum also with us tonight we have chief scott from the san francisco police department and executive director paul henderson from the department of police accountability. >> thank you. welcome everyone. happy wednesday. welcome to our february 12th meeting. sergeant please call the first matter line item one weekly officer recognition certificate presentation of an officer who has gone above and beyond in the performance of their duties officer shere khan star number 2278 from the airport bureau. >> hello. welcome to carlos gutierrez. >> i'm a captain with the san francisco police department air force patrol division. thank you for giving me this opportunity to present officer shere khan who was selected by his patrol commanders to receive this recognition officer khan is an 18 year veteran of the police department, has worked at the san francisco international airport for the last ten years through his years at the airport. he has deve

vice president carter ober stone yes. vice president carter is yes and president elias yes. present minuses. yes. you have six yeses line item for adoption of minutes action for the meeting of december 4th 2020 for i had a motion so moved i can if any member of the public would like to make public comment regarding line item for adoption of minutes please approach the podium and there is no public comment on the motion. commissioner clay how do you vote yes mr. clay is yes. commissioner benedicto yes. yes sure benedicto is yes. commissioner young yes. yes. commission yes is yes commissioner ag yes. commissioner. yes. yes. vice president carter ober stone yes i suppose and carter watson is yes and prison wise yes. >> yes. yes. you have six yeses i got him five chiefs report weekly crime trends and public safety concerns provide an overview of offenses, incidents or events occurring in san francisco have an impact on public safety commission discussion on planned events and activities that chief describes will be limited to determining whether the calendar for a future meeting

president commissioner benedicto president commissioner janez commissioner years enroute vice president carter ober stone is also enroute