adam tolley looked at a series of - tolley looked at a series of complaints in three departments whereen a cabinet minister and he upheld some of those allegations of bullying into departments, the ministry of justice and the foreign office. he did not uphold the complaints from when he was in the brexit department and didn't uphold complaints in other areas in other departments. the crucial word is bullying and adam tolley said that is not a legally defined term, so then he sets for the purposes of his report he would define it. the first areas if the behaviour is offensive, intimidating, malicious or insulting. the second area is if it is an abuse or misuse of power that undermines, humiliates or denigrates people. and adam tolley has said that in the areas where he found against dominic raab, some of that language applied to his behaviour. that is exactly the area dominic raab hit out at in his letter that you mentioned. what he said if that adam tolley set the threshold for bullying very low and he said if you set it that low then you encourage spurious complaints against ministers

so what is in adam tolley case 's abrasive. so what is in adam tolley casey's report? _ abrasive. is in adam tolley casey's report? the _ abrasive. so what is in adam tolley casey's report? the senior- abrasive. so what is in adam tolley casey's report? the senior lawyer l casey's report? the senior lawyer says dominic raab acted in way that was intimidating, in a sense of unreasonably and persistently aggressive conduct. it also involved in abuse or misuse of power in a way that undermines or humiliates. adding, he went further than was necessary or appropriate in delivering critical feedback, necessary or appropriate in delivering criticalfeedback, and delivering critical feedback, and was delivering criticalfeedback, and was insulting. mr tolley also says mr raab was abrasive and had described work done for him as utterly useless and woeful. a description reasonably understood as insulting personal criticism. isn't the blunt truth when you read all of this report, that a fair—minded person reading it would conclude that, you are a nightmare to be working for?— that, you are a n

the lawyer, adam tolley, upheld some but not all of the allegations, so at the former brexit departmente said that mr mr raab... but at brexit department he said that mr mr raab. .. but at the brexit department he said that mr mr raab... but at the foreign office he found he had acted in a way that was intimidating, and which also involved an abuse or misuse of power that in a way that undermines or humiliates. at the ministry of justice, he also found that the deputy prime minister acted in a manner that was intimidating. dominic raab described the work of some officials as utterly useless and awful and the some officials as utterly useless and the prime minister said there had been shortcomings in the complaints process which may have to be addressed in future, but it is very clear from be addressed in future, but it is very clearfrom dominic be addressed in future, but it is very clear from dominic raab�*s resignation letter to rishi sunak, that the now formerjustice secretary believes he was treated unjustly. he said the senior lawyer, adam tolley had dismissed all but two of the cl

what has been previously outlined, it wasn't adam tolley was my job has been previously outlined, itas to whether raab did bully anyone or did break the ministerial code butjust to set out the facts. ultimately the decision very much lies with rishi sunak and it's quite a difficult line to tread. to keep his party happy, to give the electorate happy, and to keep the promises he made when he was elected. figs and to keep the promises he made when he was elected.— when he was elected. as you have ointed when he was elected. as you have pointed out. _ when he was elected. as you have pointed out. it _ when he was elected. as you have pointed out, it is _ when he was elected. as you have pointed out, it is a _ when he was elected. as you have pointed out, it is a very _ when he was elected. as you have pointed out, it is a very difficult i pointed out, it is a very difficult decision for him to make. and especially to make it in a way that satisfies everyone. i mean, just in terms of the political repercussions, of his decision, do you think that is going to be quite important? because hi

i am sure ou eyes from adam tolley's report? i am sure you will — eyes from adam tolley's report?atter, welcome to a conclusion, it has not been resolved. he says, well i feel duty bound to accept the inquiry, dismissed all but two of the claims held against me, he also says, in setting the threshold for bullying solo committee inquiry has set a dangerous precedent, encouraging spurious complaints against ministers —— for bullying so low, the inquiry has set a dangerous precedent. the letter was posted to twitter. notjust an issue about me, he says, an issue about what happens with ministers and in government and with ministers and in government and with the british people.— with the british people. absolutely. and how we — with the british people. absolutely. and how we are _ with the british people. absolutely. and how we are governed, - with the british people. absolutely. and how we are governed, that - and how we are governed, that relationship that exists between appointed civil servants, if you like, the permanent machinery of government, employed to impartially carry out t

and so he will looking at whether what adam tolley says is subjective oras what adam tolley says is subjectivet goes in there that really do interpret as bullying or are they so general that they could be interpreted by one person as bullying but by another being directed? i think rishi sunak will have a toughjob directed? i think rishi sunak will have a tough job here to make that decision, but it is over to him and he will bejudged decision, but it is over to him and he will be judged by many as to how he will be judged by many as to how he handles this. he he will be judged by many as to how he handles this.— he handles this. he will have the final sa . he handles this. he will have the final say- lout — he handles this. he will have the final say. but i _ he handles this. he will have the final say. but i wonder— he handles this. he will have the final say. but i wonder whether i he handles this. he will have the i final say. but i wonder whether you get the sense that no matter which way this goes, this inquiry, will it shed some light or maybe because some changes in how the government d

the lawyer, adam tolley, upheld some but not all of the allegations, so at the former brexit departmentid that mr mr raab... but at the foreign office he found he had acted in a way that was intimidating, and which also involved an abuse or misuse of power that in a way that undermines or humiliates. at the ministry ofjustice, he also found that the deputy prime minister acted in a manner that was intimidating. dominic raab described the work of some officials as utterly useless and the prime minister said there had been shortcomings in the complaints process which may have to be addressed in future, but it is very clear from dominic raab's resignation letter to rishi sunak, that the now former justice secretary believes he was treated unjustly. he said the senior lawyer, adam tolley had dismissed all but two of the claims levelled against him and then challenged those, claiming he had been exonerated about many allegations about his conduct. not once in four and a half years, he said, had his worn or shout at anyone, let alone thrown anything physically intimidating to anyone, and he i

we bought from adam tolley- be— minister. overnment— individual from outside government . cgrbb individual from outside government. individual from outside- government . adam tolley kc individual from outside— government . adam tolley kc was government. adam tolley kc was chosen to conduct the investigation , though it was investigation, though it was made clear from day one that his remit was solely to establish the facts of raabs conduct , not the facts of raabs conduct, not to decide whether he should face sanction. five months on the tolley report has now been handed over to downing street and to his allies. dominic raab is a committed politician who demands high standards from his staff to his detractors. he is a neurotic bully who gets a kick out of picking on junior civil servants . rishi rishi sunak out of picking on junior civil servants. rishi rishi sunak may have hoped that choosing a deputy as experienced and as loyal as dominic raab would make his own life that little bit eafien his own life that little bit easier.

look, if i inadvertently i mean, the adam tolley suggested that i had been unintentionally abrasive.meone had hurt feelings because of something i did, of course i want an empowered team. the vast majority of the civil servants who worked for me were brilliant, fantastic relished the energy, the challenge, the drive that i believe i brought. but of course, i don't want to upset anyone. and i and i made clear that i'm sorry for that, but that's not bullying. and we can't deliver for the british people if the bar is that low. what about your future in politics? will you fight the next election as a conservative here? well allow me to allow the dust to settle. i'm very confident that the prime minister will win the next election. i think he's done a fantasticjob as a result of that and the strong campaign we've got here, i think we're well set to win here. with you as the candidate? look, allow me to let the dust to settle a little bit, but of course, it's not ultimately my decision. it's for my local association. but i can tell you i've been overwhelmed with support from people, consti

it is reported that borisjohnson, who was interviewed by adam tolley, had previously warned raab aboutent? the last available review into bullying within the civil service was carried out in 2018. 73% over 13000 respondents said they had experienced some form of bullying and harassment during their civil service career. and nearly half said it was repeated behaviour. but many fail to report it. 90 per cent were concerned there would be reprecussions, if they blew the whistle. live now to our political correspondent, jonathan blake. he does not believe he broke the ministerial code thank you for being with me. let me just start with you. i'm wondering what you're hearing tonight the politics of this?— what you're hearing tonight the politics of this? there is a lot of weiathin politics of this? there is a lot of weighing in _ politics of this? there is a lot of weighing in on _ politics of this? there is a lot of weighing in on his— politics of this? there is a lot of weighing in on his mind. - politics of this? there is a lot of weighing in on his mind. he - politics of this? there is

in theory he could have overruled adam tolley— theory he could have overruled adam tolley report but determination to move away from the boris _ his determination to move away from the borisjohnson error. three years a-o the borisjohnson error. three years ago we _ the borisjohnson error. three years ago we saw— the borisjohnson error. three years ago we saw similar report into priti patel— ago we saw similar report into priti patel in_ ago we saw similar report into priti patel in the — ago we saw similar report into priti patel in the home office and clear that he _ patel in the home office and clear that he wanted to put a bouquet of blue water— that he wanted to put a bouquet of blue water away from this. you and to the — blue water away from this. you and to the point _ blue water away from this. you and to the point that _ blue water away from this. wi, and to the point that these things were swirling around. that is the accusation levelled at the prime minister. that he had wind of this, but still in a sense loyalty and paying it back i suppose for being a supporter in his camp

of november, number 10 confirmed that the independent investigation would be led by the lawyer adam tolleys newsnight reported that he could face other claims. questions for the deputy prime minister, dominic raab, tonight over his conduct in office. newsnight has been told that several of mr robb's former private secretaries are preparing to submit formal bullying complaints against him. later in november we learnt that the investigation had been extended to a third complaint, whilst on the 14th of december, number 10 said that five more complaints about the justice secretary were being investigated. the guardian published this article on the 25th of january saying that at least 2a civil servants were involved in the complaints against dominic raab. during prime minister's questions on the 1st of february, the prime ministerfaced pressure over what he knew about the claims. this is what he told our political editor, chris mason. even informal ones raised with you about the conduct of dominic raab before you appointed him as your deputy? i've been very clear. i don't recognise the characte

adam tolley went beyond his man er— that adam tolley went beyond his man er te— that adam tolley wentremoved from a team when you were negotiating on gibraltar. do were negotiating on gibraltar. t>e yea— were negotiating on gibraltar. t>e yea te— were negotiating on gibraltar. tee yea te yea— were negotiating on gibraltar. do you do you regret removing tara— do you do you regret removing atra trera — do you do you regret removing him from that— do you do you regret removing him from that team, changing the eereeaaete — him from that team, changing the personnel? ne.— him from that team, changing the personnel? no, it— him from that team, changing the personnel? \vtitt c cticg personnel? no, it was absolutely essential . the personnel? no, it was absolutely essential. the individual concerned had breached the negotiating mandate , had allowed negotiating mandate, had allowed discuss actions in relation to gibraltar to with the spanish to involve of allowing law enforcement officials from spain to act in the territory of gibraltar. that would have undermined our sovereignty position on

that was what adam tolley used. i didn't think it was too low. he clearly dismissed some complaint.d serious issues in at least two cases as we know about what might be perceived as intimidation and overbearing behavior toward civil servants that undermine them in their work. my personal view is the decision is the right one, whether he did jump or was pushed is not the point. he needed to go in the light of this report. it's not just about the dictionary definition of bullying. it's about whether his behavior was appropriate for a sitting minister, who ought to be setting the highest standards. we shouldn't see this as some great constitutional issue. >> i was going to ask you. he makes allegations that speak to the criticism he makes about the civil service saying there was systematic leaking of fabricated claims in breach of the code, the coercive removal of a senior official who designated private secretaries from his ministry and then he says they are blocking the work of the government with passive aggressive tactics. no one knows the civil service better than you. he's not th

the report from adam tolley kc, concluded that the deputy prime minister's conduct had amounted to a of power" in a way that undermined or humiliated the staff who worked for him. and he "must have been aware of this effect" said tolley because he had been warned about his behaviour on three separate occasions by two permanent secretaries — though mr raab who was interviewed four times, denied those conversations had ever taken place. what we will do tonight, is pull out some of the key findings of the 48 page report alongside mr raab's response to them. lets start with his style of leadership which tolley says is the context for the interactions. of the report tolley says this. "the dpm's style is, in his own words, inquisitorial, direct, impatient and fastidious. in the course of his ministerial work, he often encounters what he genuinely sees as frustrations in respect of the quality of work done, its speed of production and the extent to which it implements his policy decisions. in his letter of resignation, raab is unrepentent. but there were extreme example of this said tolly w

so what is in adam tolley kc�*s report? or lawyer says dominic raab... adding he went.. mr tolley also says mr raab was abrasive and had described work done for him as "utterly useless and woeful". a description " reasonably understood "as insulting personal criticism". turning now to sudan. it appears another ceasefire, supposedly agreed so people can celebrate the muslim holiday of eid al—fitr, hasn't held. there are reports of more fighting between sudan's army led by abdel fattah al—burhan and the paramilitary rapid support forces, led by mohamed hamdan dagalo. this was the capital, khartoum, earlier friday — gunfire and explosions heard across the city. the un says more than 400 people have now been killed in the fighting. we go live now to kalkidan yibetal, who is monitoring the situation from the ethiopian capital, addis ababa. it's good to see you. the general has been speaking since the first time since the fighting began. what has he been saying?— fighting began. what has he been saying? yes, he gave a televised _

so what is in adam tolley kc�*s report?ays dominic raab "acted in way which was intimidating, in the sense of unreasonably and persistently aggressive conduct. it also involved an abuse or misuse of power in a way that undermines or humiliates." adding he went "further than was necessary or appropriate in delivering critical feedback," and was "insulting". mr tolley also says mr raab was abrasive and had described work done for him as "utterly useless and woeful". a description "reasonably understood as insulting personal criticism". isn't the blunt truth, when you read all of this report, that a fair—minded person reading it would conclude that, to be crude, that you're a nightmare to work for? actually, almost all of the complaints against me were dismissed. and what this doesn't give you, it's a handful of very senior officials, none of the junior complaints were upheld. and i got on and dealt with hundreds of civil servants, thousands of other people in the prison service and court service. what you've got is the risk h

remit was to only eetottten— adam tolley's remit was to only establish the— adam tolley's remit was . so the ball is going to be toot— . so the ball is going to be toot tn— . so the ball is going to be back in rishi— . so the ball is going to be back in rishi sunak court very tt-tt— back in rishi sunak court very tt-tt te— back in rishi sunak court very soon. it'll be really interesting- soon. it'll be really interesting to see what he soon. it'll be really— interesting to see what he does. some— interesting to see what he does. some tow— interesting to see what he does. some tory sources— interesting to see what he does. some tory sources are suggesting tnot— some tory sources are suggesting tnot oetwottv— some tory sources are suggesting that actually civil— some tory sources are suggesting that actually civil servants tnneotentng— that actually civil servants threatening to _ that actually civil servants threatening to quit if raab is tonne— threatening to quit if raab is townt to— threatening to quit if raab is townt to te— threatening to quit if raab is found to be rishi sunak

so what is in adam tolley casey's reports?ed in a way which was intimidating in the sense of unreasonably and persistently aggressive conduct. it also involved an abuse or misuse of power in a way that undermines or humiliates, adding... mr tolley also says... around the world and across the uk. this is bbc news. the first glimpse it's a typical training session for the academy kicks under eights. but these bromsgrove boys are wearing kit made completely from recycled materials. right at the start, there weren't any great solutions out there. but yes, actually now to get to the day where we can see these these [ads running around, it's just fantastic. and it's notjust the clothing. take the average kit bag and there's plastic everywhere. the water bottles, shin pads, the bibs are made of polyester, the cones. this wooden handle is because the plastic original one broke. even the bags themselves, they're made of plastic. birmingham county, fa have already won awards for their green initiatives on plastic. with 5200 clubs and 80

so what is in adam tolley kc�*s report?g, in the sense of unreasonably and persistently aggressive conduct. it also involved an abuse or misuse of power in a way that undermines or humiliates." adding he went "further than was necessary or appropriate in delivering critical feedback," and was "insulting". mr tolley also says mr raab was abrasive and had described work done for him as "utterly useless and woeful". a description " reasonably understood as insulting personal criticism". to germany now, where representatives from 50 countries have been meeting to discuss how they can give ukraine more support. the latest package includes ammunition for himars rocket systems, long—range artillery, and anti—armour weapons. earlier, i spoke to the us national security council spokesmanjohn kirby about the us position in ukraine. i want to start with an announcement we saw from the defence department saying that the abrams tanks that the us has promised to deliver to ukraine, that they will get to the battlefield this fall — that i

do of adam tolley's report itself. i>e wea— of adam tolley's report itself. i>e wen nei— of adam tolley'sari— tom, i've not yet had a chance re reai ine— tom, i've not yet had a chance to read the full— tom, i've not yet had a chance to read the full report, as i'm wea— to read the full report, as i'm sure you can imagine. but i know inan— sure you can imagine. but i know that there are references to intimidating behaviour, aggressive behaviour, persistently aggressive behaviour, humiliate civil servants. i wouldn't expect that kind of behaviour in any workplace , much less from workplace, much less from a minister of government or indeed a member of parliament and that's why i think dominic raab needs to step down and let the people of esher and walton elect an mp who will serve with integrity and serve their members of staff with respect. they're fed up with being taken for one of the for granted. one of the complaints— for granted. one of the complaints that- 3: one of the complaints that was upheld eaiiei— complaints that was upheld eaiiei ine— complaints that was upheld called the ev

the report by the senior lawyer adam tolley kc found mr raab acted in a way in which was intimidatingd described work done for him as utterly useless and woeful. a description reasonably understood as insulting personal criticism. you have the risk of a very small minority of very active civil servants with a passive—aggressive culture of the civil service who don't like some of the reforms, whether it is brexit or human rights reform, effectively trying to block government. it is not on, that is not democratic.- is not on, that is not democratic. ~ , democratic. the prime minister said he accepted _ democratic. the prime minister said he accepted the _ said he accepted the resignation with sadness but there was no sign of rishi sunak in public yesterday as labour accused him of weakness. the big question for the prime minister is why he was so weak to appoint him in the first place. the second question is why didn't he sack him? and now it is left to dominic raab to resign. it is left to dominic raab to resin. , w it is left to dominic raab to resin. , . resign. replacing dominic raa

having read adam tolley's report is dominic raab a bully? do you think ? i certainly— was very ill, we all remember and i certainly remember it very oott— and i certainly remember it very wottlstoopot— and i certainly remember it very well,.stepped-the- and i certainly remember it very well, stepped the plate well, he stepped up to the plate ttot.— well, he stepped up to the plate ttot. to-s— well, he stepped up to the plate then. he's also— well, he stepped up to the plate then. he's also a— well, he stepped up to the plate then. he's also a man of his wort.— then. he's also a man of his uoto. att— then. he's also a man of his uoto. out to— then. he's also a man of his word. and he said that if there wosovotsolt— word. and he said that if there was adverse finding against was an adverse finding against him:— was an adverse finding against ttot-rostgt- was an adverse finding against ttot-rostgt .- was an adverse finding against him,-resign . and. was an adverse finding against him, resign . and that's him, he would resign. and that's oxootty— him, he would

the report undertaken by adam tolley casey, a very senior lawyer made clear that the people we came forwardr civil servants's courage in coming forward. ——kc. it is a further reason why dominc raab had to resign. fit. reason why dominc raab had to resin. �* ., , ., resign. a lot will be made in the cominu resign. a lot will be made in the coming days _ resign. a lot will be made in the coming days of— resign. a lot will be made in the coming days of dominc- resign. a lot will be made in the coming days of dominc raab's i coming days of dominc raab's assertion but this isjust coming days of dominc raab's assertion but this is just the business of politics, it is not very friendly, it is not touchy—feely and if weight needs to get done, and if wogan needs to be criticised, it is done so. is that a fair argument? is that how politics should or could work? i that how politics should or could work? ~ , that how politics should or could work? ~' , ., , ., work? i think there is a bit of nervousness _ work? i think there is a bit of nervousness in _ work? i think there is a bit of nervousness in do

now, this has been a five—month investigation and it was led by senior lawyer adam tolley casey, who and he denies all the allegations of ms doing. dozens of people have given evidence for this inquiry, which as i said, began in november. we are still waiting for that and will of course be reynet extensively on bbc news for audiences, both in the uk and internationally. and i think we can just show our live page very briefly. there we go, if you want any more information on this story, right now you can go to our live page. bbc.co.uk/news.. it has all the latest evidence and information on this story from the ground. stay with us on bbc, plenty more to come. goodbye for now. hello there. most parts of the country will stay dry and sunny through the rest of the day. it is a chilly wind blowing once again with high pressure to the north of the uk, the winds coming in off the north sea, even a bit of haar flirting with the east coast of scotland. down those coasts it will feel chilly, temperature is perhaps no better than 11 degrees, highest temperatures in sheltered western areas could

the investigation by adam tolley, kc , a investigation by adam tolley, kc , o teottne— investigationng critical feedback and being insulting about work done by being insulting about work done to ntntstw— being insulting about work done to ntntstew ot— being insulting about work done by ministry of justice officials. _ by ministry of justice officials. tolley believed that wntte— officials. tolley believed that wntte toot— officials. tolley believed that white raab did— officials. tolley believed that while raab did not intend to upset— while raab did not intend to upset oe— while raab did not intend to upset or humiliate officials, tnew— upset or humiliate officials, tnew townt— upset or humiliate officials, they found him _ upset or humiliate officials, they found him unreasonably tttttowtt— they found him unreasonably difficult to _ they found him unreasonably difficult to deal— they found him unreasonably difficult to deal with as he was oetes— difficult to deal with as he was sometimes abrasive. dominic raab has sometimes abrasive. dominic raab nos ntt— sometimes abrasive. domini

, kc, who's— a very large report from adam tolley , kc, who's been tolley, kc, who's been investigatingak, which is what got him sacked by liz truss baring— what got him sacked by liz truss iaring ber— what got him sacked by liz truss during her brief— what got him sacked by liz truss during her brief premiership . so during her brief premiership. so the during her brief premiership. so be basi— during her brief premiership. so be as bing— during her brief premiership. so the last thing, the— during her brief premiership. so the last thing, the last thing ieisbi— the last thing, the last thing bisbi sanab— the last thing, the last thing rishi sunak wants to do is, is bese— rishi sunak wants to do is, is lose dominic— rishi sunak wants to do is, is lose dominic raab. however aebenaing— lose dominic raab. however depending what's in the report, he depending what's in the report, be nav— depending what's in the report, be nav nave— depending what's in the report, be nav bave ne— depending what's in the report, he may have no choice. he's raibei— he may have no choice. he's talked about— he

the prime minister appointed adam tolley to look into the matter. very first answer. himself. that is your very first answer- l _ himself. that is your very first answer. i was _ himself. that is your very first answer. i was trying _ himself. that is your very first answer. i was trying to i himself. that is your very first answer. i was trying to get i himself. that is your very first | answer. i was trying to get you himself. that is your very first i answer. i was trying to get you to address a different question, about those individuals. dominic raab knows the names of the people who have made allegations against him. you say it is business as usual in government, he is imposed. he could be dealing with those people today. do you think it is fair to those individuals who have made those complaints?— individuals who have made those comlaints? ., , . ., complaints? people will have made comlaints complaints? people will have made complaints and _ complaints? people will have made complaints and of— complaints? people will have made complaints and

adam tolley does present the ehthre— adam tolley does present the ehthre repert— adam tolley does presentt to be investigated thoroughly and thet-e— investigated thoroughly and that's exactly— investigated thoroughly and that's exactly what he wanted to see that's exactly what he wanted to hh— that's exactly what he wanted to he the — that's exactly what he wanted to see in the case— that's exactly what he wanted to see in the case of— that's exactly what he wanted to see in the case of dominic raab. so see in the case of dominic raab. se wett— see in the case of dominic raab. se we-hh hewe— see in the case of dominic raab. so we'll have to— see in the case of dominic raab. so we'll have to wait and see. wee. — so we'll have to wait and see. wee. ht— so we'll have to wait and see. yes. if dominic— so we'll have to wait and see. yes. if dominic raab decides thet— yes. if dominic raab decides thet he— yes. if dominic raab decides thet he he— yes. if dominic raab decides that he is no— yes. if dominic raab decides that he is no longer able to retehh— that he is no longer able to retehh the—

the report by the senior lawyer adam tolley kc found mr raab: mr tolley also said mr raab was abrasivebed work done for him as: what you've got is the risk here of a very small minority of very activist civil servants with a passive—aggressive culture of the civil service who don't like some of the reforms, whether it's brexit, whether it's parole reform, whether it's human rights reform, effectively trying to block government. that's not on, that's not democratic. the prime minister said he accepted dominic raab�*s resignation with sadness, but there was no sign of rishi sunak in public yesterday as labour accused him of weakness. the big question for the prime minister is why he was so weak to appoint him in the first place. the second question for the prime minister is why didn't he sack him? and now it's left to dominic raab to resign. replacing dominic raab as justice secretary is this man — alex chalk, and oliver dowden steps into the role of deputy prime minister, as his predecessor's departure sparks a debate about how things get done in government. dominic raab is the third ca

adam tolley is a very distinguished kc in in employment and sphere and his findings were balanced .rs with what ne-s— minister no favours with what ne-s-i— minister no favours with what ne-s-i inink— minister no favours with what he's-i think he's- minister no favours with what he's i think he's done him minister no favours with what htload i think he's done him minister no favours with what htload of i think he's done him minister no favours with what htload of favours; he's done him minister no favours with what htload of favours because ie him minister no favours with what htload of favours because the im a load of favours because the nine— a load of favours because the prime minister— a load of favours because the prime minister is— a load of favours because the prime minister is now not had to sack— prime minister is now not had to sakas—- prime minister is now not had to sakas— ine- prime minister is now not had to. sack—as the prime sack him and seeing as the prime minister— sack him and seeing as the prime iiinisrerlner— sack him and seeing as the prime minister-not elected—

adam tolley is a very distinguished kc in in employment and sphere and his findings were balanced .e minister no— friend his friend the prime minister no favours with what ne-s— minister no favours with what ne-s-i— minister no favours with what ne-s-i inink— minister no favours with what he's-i think he's- minister no favours with what he's i think he's done him minister no favours with what htload i think he's done him minister no favours with what htload of i think he's done him minister no favours with what htload of favours; he's done him minister no favours with what htload of favours because ie him minister no favours with what htload of favours because the im a load of favours because the nine— a load of favours because the prime minister— a load of favours because the prime minister is— a load of favours because the prime minister is now not had to sack— prime minister is now not had to sakas—- prime minister is now not had to sakas— ine- prime minister is now not had to. sack—as the prime sack him and seeing as the prime minister— sack him and seeing as the prime iiinisrer

two of the more by adam tolley, who carried out the investigation.t rishi sunak 'ust doesn't have their hacks?— that rishi sunak 'ust doesn't have their backs? ., ,, . , ., their backs? no. i think he has done a treat their backs? no. i think he has done a great job- — their backs? no. i think he has done a great job- i'm _ their backs? no. i think he has done a great job. i'm not— their backs? no. i think he has done a great job. i'm not entirely - their backs? no. i think he has done a great job. i'm not entirely sure - their backs? no. i think he has done a great job. i'm not entirely sure i i a greatjob. i'm not entirely sure i agree with the premise of the question, to be honest. the, agree with the premise of the question, to be honest. a group of mps went to _ question, to be honest. a group of mps went to chequers, _ question, to be honest. a group of mps went to chequers, to - question, to be honest. a group of mps went to chequers, to the - question, to be honest. a group of. mps went to chequers, to the prime minister's retreat, to talk to

and the report's been sam by adam tolley, been done.. it's a fine kins.— really fascinating. it's a finei kins—is line, isn't it, between what is just feedback to just robust feedback to a colleague or a junior in the workplace and what is a bullying, what's the best outcome for rishi sunak? well, he wants to keep him - f ?it“ , well, he wants to keep him because f 35“ , well, he wants to keep him because he isesp-i— he wants to keep him because he isesp-i wani— he wants to keep him because he doesn't want to _ he wants to keep him because he doesn't want to do _ he wants to keep him because he doesn't want to do a— he wants to keep him because he doesn't want to do a reshuffle. so doesn't want to do a reshuffle. ss iiie— doesn't want to do a reshuffle. so the conclusion— doesn't want to do a reshuffle. so the conclusion being that the iepsii— so the conclusion being that the report concludes, _ so the conclusion being that the report concludes, it— so the conclusion being that the report concludes, it wasn't, in my— report concludes, i

i mean, last week we had adam tolley's report about— week we had adam tolley's report about dominic—ly on this government— particularly badly on this government in the sense that it's government in the sense that tt-s heotet— government in the sense that tt-s heotet hy— government in the sense that it's headed by rishi sunak no ts— it's headed by rishi sunak no ts going— it's headed by rishi sunak no ts going to— it's headed by rishi sunak no one is going to accuse him of any— one is going to accuse him of thy tht— one is going to accuse him of any the ot— one is going to accuse him of any kind of impropriety. one is going to accuse him of any kind of impropriety . what it any kind of impropriety. what it perhaps— any kind of impropriety. what it perhaps hey— any kind of impropriety. what it perhaps may to— any kind of impropriety. what it perhaps may to t— any kind of impropriety. what it perhaps may do i mean , we'll perhaps may do i mean, we'll wett— perhaps may do i mean, we'll wott tor— perhaps may do i mean, we'll wait for that— perhaps may do i mean, we'll wait for that report

interesting poia result of this report by)pens as a result of this report by the kc adam tolley , primew— reduced to tears. and now, you knew .— reduced to tears. and now, you knew . eh— reduced to tears. and now, you know , some of them saying they know, some of them saying they eeere— know, some of them saying they eeere eeh— know, some of them saying they eeere eeh-h— know, some of them saying they could quit-if he— know, some of them saying they could quit if he stays , could quit if he if he stays, rhe— could quit if he if he stays, rhre hee— could quit if he if he stays, this kind of— could quit if he if he stays, this kind of talk— could quit if he if he stays, this kind of talk of bullying re— this kind of talk of bullying seems to be _ this kind of talk of bullying seems to be there way of getting here— seems to be there way of getting here wew— seems to be there way of getting their way essentially, you know, is their way essentially, you know, he ereehw— their way essentially, you know, he ereehw e— their way essentially, you know, is clearly a minister that they eeh-r— is cl

according to alum adam tolley , and to alum adam tolley, and therefore he had to go.mber of staff— the secretary of state to make a member of staff feel that ttey-we — member of staff feel that they've been— member of staff feel that they've been bullied . ' “r2 they've been bullied. and, you trow— they've been bullied. and, you know, whether they've been dismissed or not. actually, dominic raab needs to reflect on his own management style, perhaps because if people perceive that they've been bullied , there's clearly an bullied, there's clearly an issue there. and some of the complaints of bullying have been upheld, some but upheld, some haven't. but nevertheless, a period of reflection on dominic raab's part is probably what is better than doubling down on people who are victims or perceived themselves to be victims of his behaviour. yeah, well, that's tmbetesbtmd— behaviour. yeah, well, that's interesting though,- 2 yeah, well, that's interesting though, isn't it? teteebbtom— interesting though, isn't it? perception of— interesting though, isn't it? perception of b

adam tolley an or misuse well, that's a good point. fferent. g different. so if i was talking if like this to me, if my boss went like this to me, i would not. i would not find that is that. no. is that is that is that. no. is that is that is that. no. is that for me to be sort of that enough for me to be sort of an example of my bullying, if that's the best example you can give you've got give of bullying, you've got to admit the bar is pretty low. well i wouldn't say that. but he's example. he's he's given an example. he's giving that as an example. and you're he the you're so remember, he used the phrase of misuse of phrase an abuse of misuse of power the hand the face power and the hand in the face claim is not necessarily as claim is not necessarily seen as the example. there are the strongest example. there are lots others. the strongest example. there are lots .others. and _ the strongest example. there are lots-others. and he— the strongest example. there are lots .others. and he .the l lots of others. and he uses the wt,— lots