these two adu eliminated 6 parking spaces. the second of three fold is the appellate claim the owner does not have the right to alter the parking to change the nature of a tenant parking space. my understanding is that the owner isn't restricted how parking spaces are located or designated. i redesigned parking as part of constructing adu at 1251, 8 avenue (inaudible) and 969 (inaudible) parking gets restructured. i summarized the codes on page 10 of the presentation. will you please show page 10? this is a list of the codes saying the restrictions and requirements for parking in san francisco. the thirds thrust of the appellate complaint is that or appeal is that the owner must design parking space to the appellate specification or comp sate the appellate accordingly. this might or might be true it isn't subject to the building or planning code as the purview of the bord of appeals. this is a matter for the rent stabilization board. appellateprinted to the san francisco planning commission in des correctionary veview a. print

upper left hand corner is a adu lower left corner is a rks u. upper right is adu. the lower left shows the tandem garage and building lobby. the red block is where we put in mechanical room for new water heaters for both hidronic heating system and new domestic heating for the building. the gray is the new garbage area. the colored zone in the back is the terraced area for providing hor zauntal exposure. the owner agreed-you see the tandem parking you see the private door to the garage for the appellate new parking spaces. the owner is also agreed to request sfmta to designate a red or white zone on the front curb in front of the building at completion of construction with the understanding that this is fully at the discretion of sfmta. this is shown in further detail on page 9 of the presentation. there you go. this is where the owner is more then happy to work with mta to put in a red or white zone such that appellate can park his car there for loading and unloading. we all understand mta has their own rules and not part of the building approval process. so, thus

the old ret row fill done is ing the way for the adu. there is also claim lying reducing tenants services. only one tenant had access to marking and that is (inaudible) father. and he had two parking spaces before they were (inaudible) he will have two parking spaces afterwards. so, the claim by them this is reduction in tenant services and that (inaudible) would comply with the planning code comply with building code. we are providing two parking spaces. the fact mr.verts vertz and his daughter do not like them is irrelevant as far as board of appeals. this has to do with rent stabilization board. i yield the balance of time to david alexander the owner representative. >> thank you all. i know i-can you hear me? >> yes, please go ahead. thank you. >> okay, thank you. there is limited time. i apologize i am on vacation with poor cell reception: there is no much to respond to on the call and apologize i wont get to all of it, but most would be something that would be heard by the rent board in regard to the parking spaces. mr. vertz is a

in our case adu's below us.he status of lifetime renter has grown in recent decades due to rising home prices. renters are in this community and renters are aware about demolition. this legislation would help mitigate this vulnerability. thanks. good afternoon commissioners. san francisco land use coalition. i would like to thank supervisor and her office for this change. working on the national media about san francisco, those of us who actually live here know better and this is an appeal process similarly to the south that is only open to property owners. in a city with great majority of residents are not homeowners. blocking tenants from participating in the appeal process speaks about their races and class reality that we are faced with. oftentimes new millionaires, and it's too costly to bring up to code to get the approval of a demolition of a building. there have been time this commission is -- this change will enable tenants to appeal their case to a democratically elected body and thanks to supervisor m

upper left hand corner is a adu lower left corner is a rks u. upper right is adu. the lower left shows the tandem garage and building lobby. the red block is where we put in mechanical room for new water heaters for both hidronic heating system and new domestic heating for the building. the gray is the new garbage area. the colored zone in the back is the terraced area for providing hor zauntal exposure. the owner agreed-you see the tandem parking you see the private door to the garage for the appellate new parking spaces. the owner is also agreed to request sfmta to designate a red or white zone on the front curb in front of the building at completion of construction with the understanding that this is fully at the discretion of sfmta. this is shown in further detail on page 9 of the presentation. there you go. this is where the owner is more then happy to work with mta to put in a red or white zone such that appellate can park his car there for loading and unloading. we all understand mta has their own rules and not part of the building approval process. so, thus

the cornerstone of the city's plan involves building as many as 225 adus, also known as granny units. >> adus are a way to add to the housing stock and create more affordable housing. >> reporter: the international city council says it's the best solution for a city that's run out of land to develop. but neighbors like cindy fox remain skeptical. >> if it's all adus, i don't think it's going to solve the issue. that's my opinion. we are desperate for affordable housing. teacher, service worker, diversity. >> reporter: the councilman says currently in the city there are just a four undeveloped plots of land where house cog be built. and even if you built on every single one, it still wouldn't be enough. don't be so quick to dismiss the value of a granny unit housing someone's adult children or aging parents. >> those people will be living in an affordable house, not taking up another house. and the housing stock has actually increased. >> reporter: in order to encourage more people to build adus, the city is cutting its building fee in half through december 1. housing advocates say it

this complies with the planning code and the state adu program.epartment respectfully ask the board to deny the appeal and uphold the issuance of the permit. >> thank you. >> we have a question from president swig. >> yes, i feel awkward in this. i see your point. there is no expansion, correct? same building, same footprint. the only difference is the adu is being constructed on the ground floor. nothing physically is being done to adjust the building envelope. i will ask a question about those stairs in a second. what's confusing me here is the permit holder and the testimony didn't seem to understand what they were doing. the designer said, at least i heard her say, i haven't seen plans. i had a hard time hearing her and saying i don't have plans and i don't see the work being done with this property here. my concern is, does the permit holder know what they have? how do we know that the permit holder knows what they have and the owner of the building may or may not do something with the staircase, the issues with the firewall and these are all

the cornerstone of the city's plan involves building as many as 225 adus, also known as granny units, over the next eight years. >> adus are a way to add to the housing stock and a way to create more affordable housing. >> reporter: city councilman sean luthold said begany units are a best solution for a city that has run out of land to develop. >> if it's all adus i don't think it will solve the issue, honestly. that's my personal opinion. we are desperate for affordable housing, teachers, service workers, you know, diversity. >> reporter: councilman luthold says currently in the city there are four undeveloped plots of land where housing could be built and even if you build on every single one t still wouldn't be enough and he says don't be so quick to tis miss the value of a granny unit housing someone's adult children or aging parents. >> those people will be living in an affordable house, not taking up another house and the housing stock increased. >> in order to encourage more people to build adus, the city is you the canning its building fee in half through december 1st. housin

through this hearing i'm interested in streamlining of our adu program have been.nd the rest i submit. >> thank you, supervisor mar. supervisor milgaard. >> thank you, madam clerk, thank you mr. president and colleagues. as you know laguna honda hospital is in great crisis. while they're working feverishly to regain information, we have been pressured aggressively by the medicaid services team for not moving vulnerable frail patients transferred quickly enough. after last week's meeting, we learned about another death of transferred patient. now we've had four deaths of patients. i introduced the resolution last week, pleading with south ba sera who is a former congressman from southern california and attorney general to allow patients to stay until recertification is completed. we have an imperative item for you today to consider to urge government, governor newsom and state health officer to use their special powers under the california constitution to help hault patients transfers. ier urging to reverse the vision and save new lives through this relocation traum

through this hearing i'm interested in streamlining of our adu program have been.nd the rest i submit. >> thank you, supervisor mar. supervisor milgaard. >> thank you, madam clerk, thank you mr. president and colleagues. as you know laguna honda hospital is in great crisis. while they're working feverishly to regain information, we have been pressured aggressively by the medicaid services team for not moving vulnerable frail patients transferred quickly enough. after last week's meeting, we learned about another death of transferred patient. now we've had four deaths of patients. i introduced the resolution last week, pleading with south ba sera who is a former congressman from southern california and attorney general to allow patients to stay until recertification is completed. we have an imperative item for you today to consider to urge government, governor newsom and state health officer to use their special powers under the california constitution to help hault patients transfers. ier urging to reverse the vision and save new lives through this relocation traum

with me are aletha adu, who is a political correspondent at the daily mirror and john stevens, deputy let's take a look at some of tomorrow's front pages: the sun reports on a premier league international footballer being arrested on suspicion of rape. the metros front page focusses on the go slow protest across the country today which was over fuel prices. the mail reports that police of being urged to use the powers to stop the protest by being arrested. the eye for an page dedicated to borisjohnson, focusing on the cabinet sing the cabinet is so angry having to defend them again. the mirror also looks at political stories and reporting of the fact that boris johnson stories and reporting of the fact that borisjohnson was made aware of formal complaints about the behaviour of use ago and the guardian in the front page also including the story the bbc has admitted and received complaints against the former dj tim westwood. the telegraph from page has news on that by keir starmer a couple of hours ago of hours ago the parties knew brexit policy. right, let's start. that's a big politi

with me are aletha adu, who is a political correspondent at the daily mirror and john stevens, deputyolitical editor from the daily mail. let's take a look at tomorrow's front pages: the sun reports on a premier league international footballer being arrested on suspicion of rape. the times reports that the police have been told to "get tough" on petrol protestors. the mail takes a similar line on the same story and reports that police are being urged to use their powers to stop the go slow protests. the front page of the daily express features a story on the possibility of tax cuts for 30 million people to help with the cost of living crisis. the mirror also concentrates on a political story but they're reporting on the fact borisjohnson was made aware of a formal complaint about chris pincher�*s behaviour. the guardian also leads on pincher but the front page includes the story that the bbc has admitted it received complaints against the former radio 1 dj tim westwood. and the telegraph's front page has the labour leader unveiling the party's new brexit policy. so, let's begin. shall

. >> if it's all adus, i don't think it's going to solve the issue honestly.sonal opinion. we are desperate for affordable housing, teachers, service workers, you know, diversity. >> a spokesperson for the city says the town has a track record of success. the town is just one of a handful of cities that met their housing goals last time. gianna? >> thank you, justin. >>> what does it take to get a ceo of a major company to respond to your complaint in less than 24 hours? well, probably helps to be a kardashian and have a combined 600 million followers on that ceo's social media platform. yesterday the ceo of instagram released a two-minute video prompted by complaints over the app. andria borba has the story. >> reporter: two separate but identical instagram stories from kim kardashian and kiley jenner asking to "make instagram instagram again" elicited this response from instagram ceo adam moseri less than 24 hours after their post. >> i want to be clear, we're going to continue to support photos, part of our heritage. i love photos. a lot of you love photos

in the future there have been ordinances like adu and rent control effective date 1 but there may be instances and can data why there should be a grace period and this charter amendment incorporates that language. i think we should give it a whirl. we have heard the controller's analysis. there is no economic impact analysis report, and i commend to you colleagues and would like the board of supervisors to have the chance to put it on the ballot and prepare to make a motion to snd this to the full board as a committee report where it will sit tomorrow and can be voted on the following week july 26. any members of the public who would like to testify on this item? >> yes, members of the public who wish to speak and joining in person line up to speak at this time. those listening call 415-655-0001. meeting id is 24834359050 press pound and pound again. press star 3 to enter speaker line. wait until the system indicates you are unmuted. we have 3 callers in line to speak at this time. >> first speaker, please. >> fan cisco acosta again. first and foremost we need to do data assess ment

dropping dead left and right and using that as justification to impose a mass mandate againmpos on adus as well as children just before school starts and using a foundation of lies,s, she's been convincing people, people to believe her, believe the fear and say, okay, yes, fine, i'll mask myself and my kid because people are dropping dead and thenropp you have this is ni just usc medical center. this is where i useds tose work as a volunteer. this is los angeles county usc medical center. this is their own county hospital. it's a public hospital thates cares for the poorest and sickest people int the entire county. there and so if there w were to be people dying, guess what they would have been dying at ad this hospital. and if they're not and iff their own chief medical officero ,if their own head of infectious disease, if their own chief epidemiologist are all coming out in the pressc conference and saying we're actually sorry internallyeut telling their own staff without knowing that people a on the outside are going tore be watching us and we did. we uncovered it. guess what? wth th

is permitted under the state adu program, the board voted 3 to 0 to deny the appeal. similarly, they heard a case for a building permit at 706 vermont street and that was to construct a one-story vertical addition and new green roof at the top. and associated stairs. the appellant filed a discretionary review on the permit if 2020 siting the new third story addition with the green roof on top of the third story addition would have light and air and privacy impacts and the dr was heard by the commission in february of 2021 and the planning voted 7 to 0 to take discretionary review and it's set five feet. at the appeal hearing last night, the appellant said the guardrails and stairs at the roof be removed or setback an additional five feet. the board determined that the approved green roof and five foot setback for the guardrails were adequate for privacy issues and voted three to zero to deny the appeal, thank you very much. >> thank you. >> there are no questions commissioners, we can move on to general public comment. at this time, members of the public may address t

scholarship doesn't mean that does not reduce injuries or death but there is little available research in aduon can be traced to lack of federal investment in the inability of researchers to access essential data resulting in a lack of understanding and discussions that devolve into partisan talking points rather than a meaningful discussion of the facts. between 1997 and 2019 federal funding on gun filings had nothing and then it has put policy far behind all other complex issues that we have access to quality data trace data has also been stymied and acting new gun laws between public safety in individual rights access to firearms trace stated is the essential tool to understand how guns into the hands of criminals including mass shooters they have repeatedly called prosecuting fellas trained by illegal guns one outut of three mass shooters is committed by an individual that is prohibited from buying a a firearm but we as researchers are unable tofi use trace data to study patterns and trends to help inform the supply-side approach to include criminals on the other side of the border thereb

one is financial assistance for home owners who want to add units for multigenerational living add adu and density and expand the lives space. it will also support tenant wanting to acquire their own units when their properties are placed on the market and it will also provide funding down payment assistance and rehab financing for family child care providers who are purchase their homes and intending to set up a child care in their homes. so, i'm excited about the possibilities and the investment in these programs that havet noexisted at the mayor office of housing and go hand in hand with some of the work we have been doing in adding-allowing single family owner to add density to their property and some of the work supervisor mar has done around providing technical assistance of home owners to add adu to the property, so thank you so much to my colleagues on the land use come ity for working out the kinks and making sure this goes forward and is successful. >> thank you supervisor melgar. madam clerk, please call the roll on item 46. >> on item 46. [roll call] there are 11 ayes. >> t

one is financial assistance for home owners who want to add units for multigenerational living add adu and density and expand the lives space. it will also support tenant wanting to acquire their own units when their properties are placed on the market and it will also provide funding down payment assistance and rehab financing for family child care providers who are purchase their homes and intending to set up a child care in their homes. so, i'm excited about the possibilities and the investment in these programs that havet noexisted at the mayor office of housing and go hand in hand with some of the work we have been doing in adding-allowing single family owner to add density to their property and some of the work supervisor mar has done around providing technical assistance of home owners to add adu to the property, so thank you so much to my colleagues on the land use come ity for working out the kinks and making sure this goes forward and is successful. >> thank you supervisor melgar. madam clerk, please call the roll on item 46. >> on item 46. [roll call] there are 11 ayes. >> t

treatment facility those are longer term residential treatment facilities as opposed to the short-term adus. and very small numbers, 1% go to psychiatric skilled nursing, transitional housing and residential care for the elderly. and sadly, the very last bar there, we only get about 1 patient a year into the state hospital. >> actually, can i ask a question on this one too. >> sure, chair mar. >> do you know how much -- ~>> i assume you're speaking the facilities, i don't have numbers on that. i think we could get that data for you. thank you very much, happy to answer any questions. >> that was it? i'm asking, if that was the presentation. >> yes. >> and then dr. cunnings is going to speak. i have things to ask but maybe we should have dr. cunnings and then have you come whack. --back. >> okay, thank you. >> good morning, supervisors thank you for inviting us to talk about this important topic. and i'll just wait a moment for the slides to come up again. just one note at the to many that i'll make. we're working collaboratively with dr. leaery to strengthen in whatever ways we can both the

tomorrow's affordable rents and indeed that is what this board and previous boards have done in the case of adus and multiplexes. what they hate is rent control. they hate rent control and that is why they're posing a bill that increases density in san francisco. so, let's be real about it. it is a positive step in the right direction. i'd say that is a supervisor who represents the densest district in san francisco. but it has remained stable and those communities have been viable because of rent control. i rest my case. >> president walton: thank you, supervisor peskin. supervisor dorsey. >> supervisor dorsey: thank you, colleagues. i will be voting against this legislation, but not before commending supervisor mandelman and supervisor melgar for their leadership on the original proposal. as someone who is coming into this process late, i think in good conscience i should give credit to others who worked on this, including those who offered amendments which i disagree. but i think this legislation could have made important progress for our city to meet its housing obligations over the course o

tomorrow's affordable rents and indeed that is what this board and previous boards have done in the case of adusy hate is rent control. they hate rent control and that is why they're posing a bill that increases density in san francisco. so, let's be real about it. it is a positive step in the right direction. i'd say that is a supervisor who represents the densest district in san francisco. but it has remained stable and those communities have been viable because of rent control. i rest my case. >> president walton: thank you, supervisor peskin. supervisor dorsey. >> supervisor dorsey: thank you, colleagues. i will be voting against this legislation, but not before commending supervisor mandelman and supervisor melgar for their leadership on the original proposal. as someone who is coming into this process late, i think in good conscience i should give credit to others who worked on this, including those who offered amendments which i disagree. but i think this legislation could have made important progress for our city to meet its housing obligations over the course of the next decade. philoso