to the extent my experience as the akai for this -- arc h.i.v. ist. there are about 4,000. the files are rich and dense. they were consolidated for the reports for this process. you know, this has a rich history within the city and these types of requests don't come up for us very often. the extent it is more significant than the other works, yes. do i have data to present? no. i did receive a note that the online petition has over 1,000 signatures. to that extent, yes. >> thank you. >> i would like to hear from the planning department. three minutes please. >> thank you. just briefly. just to clarify there is a bigger issue regarding whether or not the city should choose to remove the sculpture or not. the only issue under consideration tonight is whether or not the historic preservation commission acted appropriately in granting the certificate required for that. there are a number of legal questions raised. i am not an attorney but the city attorney's office was involved with this project every step of the way. the certificate and found no legal conflict with city, state