yes, alec kemp says 15 billion to 16.5 billion up to 2050. he goes on to say it will be up to 24 billion if you take a future resource in the reserve. this country of scotland with only 16.5 billion barrels of oil, up to 2050, worth one trillion pounds in wholesale value over that period. or to go low, 1.5 trillion. this come has a great curse of 15 billion barrels of oil. every other country in the world would give their eye teeth for such a substantial resource. why did labor party and the labor party's allies think it was a great curse on scotland. incidental, having 25% of the off shore energy renewable continent offshore for europe is not a disadvantage. >> order. >> the knighted country is not. it is a wonderful country that deserves not to have its intelligence insulted. >> order. >> it is not a debating point between me and the first minister. it is what a senior person in the oil industry is saying about the future of our country. so let's review the record over the last two years. the first minister said there was legal advice. that

yes, alec kemp says 15 billion to 16.5 billion up to 2050. he goes on to say it will be up to 24 billion if you take a future resource in the reserve. this country of scotland with only 16.5 billion barrels of oil, up to 2050, worth one trillion pounds in wholesale value over that period. or to go low, 1.5 trillion. this come has a great curse of 15 billion barrels of oil. every other country in the world would give their eye teeth for such a substantial resource. why did labor party and the labor party's allies think it was a great curse on scotland. incidental, having 25% of the off shore energy renewable continent offshore for europe is not a disadvantage. >> order. >> the knighted country is not. it is a wonderful country that deserves not to have its intelligence insulted. >> order. >> it is not a debating point between me and the first minister. it is what a senior person in the oil industry is saying about the future of our country. so let's review the record over the last two years. the first minister said there was legal advice. that

alec kemp is cited as the person for the forecast.e points out there are 125 dac -- which will be undeveloped by 2050, admit that it is a long term business that will be with us for generations to come? davidson will know that major figures in the westminster government have admitted they underestimated the significance of oil and gas. we underplayed the value of the resource. it was part of the normal .attern to question the values given the track record of westminster, is it not possible that our government are doing exactly the same thing? [applause] looking at the evidence over the last 40 years, most people in scotland would say, let's get to using natural resources for the benefit of the scottish people. [applause] >> how will the scottish government ensure the future of shipbuilding? >> tuesday, i met with the ferguson shop schools. tomorrow, i will speak with employees about the scottish government's commitment to the future. a multiagency task force has been convened by the cabinet of the secretary and is due to have its next