because of the lack of supplies, let's fix it all that the doctor, alice ralph charles is a physician and a member of jewish voice for peace as health advisory council. she's the author of condition, critical life and death in israel and palestine. joining us from seattle, thanks for your time with us. on the 0. your someone who knows garza well, you were there. as recently as august the i mean the health care system was already strange. under 16 years, a state of siege on the number of fours. just tell us what your initial thoughts are right now on the situation that's unfolding. as well as a member of the health advisory council of jewish royce and peas. we've been cutting out an urgent update every $3.00 to $4.00 days documenting the realities on the ground from multiple sources. so this is a roofing catastrophe. a violation of international law, an appallingly immoral acts being committed over and over again. and so it's, it's a rolling catastrophe that we see basically live streaming. and this, the collapse of ship a hospital as well as 3 other hospitals. and guys of city was pre