tom gagon, and aloysius hogan are with me. i'll give you a chance to respond. i expect mr hogan was claiming that wages should go up with productivity. as unions disappeared in the 1970s, here is what happened. from 1979 to 2014, g.d.p. has gone up 150%. productivity has gone up an astonishing 75%. hourly wages have gone up 5%. 0.2" a year. total disconnect from productivity and since 2002 for 80%. the bottom 80% of the workforce, men and women, wages have dropped. so one of the reasons for bringing back a labour movement which i argued for, only one thing can save us is to connect up wage gains with productivity. the koch brothers are not in favour of the wage gains and higher productivity, because wages would be higher. >> crazy left-wing publications like the economist in london noted that the workers claimed less of a share of productivity than any other workers in the world. >> let's put to this way. the workers should be free to associate with who they want. people can join, if they like and one year they join one year they don't. unions you must join and