rulemaking is proceeding on september 22012 feels like just yesterday i referenced the wire and i said amanda scott to have -- and certainly each of you have lived up to that. going back to the wire and that's all in the game for people who know how the -- operates. turning to the item itself when we adopted the npr and i shared principles that but dyed my deliberations. in particular he said we should keep the auction as simple as possible and be as fair as possible to all officers and remained -- this item strays from each of these principles in both the reverse in the forward actions. the commission for civic simplicity for unnecessary complexity primarily for the purpose of manipulating the market. the rules that we adopt are not fair to many important constituencies. the taxpayer's public safety officials broadcasters rural americans in wireless carriers that were chosen to participate in past spectrum auctions. the commission a key juncture substitutes its own policy preferences for the direction given by congress the spectrum act. for all these reasons i respectfully dissent. let's start wit