is the american civil rights union as all mary lynn school guarantees students the freedom of speech with no punishment meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement to you saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for not taking part in patrick observances the school also encourage students to speak out marianna said she was inspired by an american football quarterback who you know during the national anthem before a game in twenty sixteen his silent protest things spread among other athletes to provoke fahri political debate all the way to the white house but you love to see one of these. when somebody disrespects. to say get that son over the field right now this guy that was not against our anthem or our flag that was actually kneeling is a reference position. ok let's discuss this a bit further shall we with joan william lloyd and he's a former republican member of the missouri senate and also rich goods they need a former adviser to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. john if i can start with the first stand on this story is he clinton making a valid p

that was actually kneeling is a reference position but responding to the girl's moves the american civil rights union urged all married in schools to guarantee students the freedom of speech without punishment meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement to saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior but marianna does say the teacher shouted at her and she had to leave the classroom in tears well earlier we discussed the issue with john madden from the former missouri republican and also richard goodstein a former advisor to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. football is about football schools about school and if you have a protest protest in a constructive way this girl can write letters to the editor she can arrange a little march but protesting in your classroom to irritate your classmate mates and virtue signal and that's what she's being taught mom's teaching her mom is so proud you're taking to the streets is that bothersome to people is that annoying to people when you get when you get arrested disproportionately when you get shot disproportionately

and she reportedly left the classroom in two is the american civil rights union has told maryland schools to guarantee students freedom of speech without punishment meanwhile the girl's school is issued a statement saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior. that mariano said she was inspired by an american football quarterback who know during the national anthem before a game and twenty sixteen his silent protest soon spread among other other athletes this provoked a fiery political debate reaching all the way to the white house would you love to see one of these n.f.l. owners when somebody disrespects our flag to say get that son of a up the field right now out of the sky that was not against our anthem or our flag that was actually kneeling is a reference position my colleague discuss the issue with. missouri republican and richard goodstein former advisor to the hillary clinton presidential campaign football's about football schools about school and if you have a protest protest in a constructive way this girl can write letters.

flag that was actually kneeling is a reference position responding to the girl's move the american civil rights union has urged old maryland schools to guarantee students freedom of speech without punishment meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior but mariano says a teacher shouted out her and she reportedly left the classroom is my colleague discuss the issue with a former missouri republican and richard goodstein a former adviser to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. football is about football schools about school and if you have a protest protest in a constructive way this girl can write letters to the editor she can arrange a little march but protesting in your classroom to irritate your classmate mates and virtue signal and that's what she's being taught mom's teaching her mom is so proud that her daughter is virtue signaling that she cares more than anybody else and i actually find that to make no sense when you get arrested disproportionately when you get shot disproportionately when you get put in jai

teacher shouted at her because of her behavior she reportedly left the classroom in tears the american civil rights union has owed all maryland schools to guarantee students freedom of speech without punishment meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior adding that it fully supported students' rights over mariano said she was inspired by an american football quarterback who knelt during the national anthem before a game and twenty sixteen his silent protest soon spread among other athletes and this provoked a fiery a political debate reaching all the way to the white house would you love to see one of these n.f.l. owners when somebody disrespects our flag to say get that son of a up the field right now. that was not against our anthem or our flag that was actually kneeling is a reference position. my colleague and your family discuss the issue with joan williams for my misery republican and richard goodstein a former advisor to the hillary clinton presidential campaign book football's about football schools about school and

flag that was actually leland is a reference position responding to the girls moved the american civil rights union urged all maryland schools to guarantee all students the freedom of speech without punishment meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior but marianna says her teachers shouted at her and she left the classroom in tears my colleague andrew farmer discussed the issue with john loudoun a former missouri republican and richard goodstein former advisor to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. football is about football schools about school and if you have a protest protest in a constructive way this girl can write letters to the editor she can arrange a little march but protesting in your classroom to irritate your classmate mates and virtue signal and that's what she's being taught mom's teaching her mom is so proud that her daughter is virtue signaling that she cares more than a body else and i actually find that to make no sense when you get arrested disproportionately when you get shot disproportiona

that was actually kneeling is a reference position but responding to the girl's move the american civil rights union urged all married in schools to guarantee students the freedom of speech without punishment meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior but mariana does say that her teacher shouted at her and that she left the classroom in say is earlier we discussed the issue with john loudon he's a former missouri republican and also richard goodstein he's a former adviser to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. football is about football schools about school and if you have a protest protest in a constructive way this girl can write letters to the editor she can arrange a little march put protesting in your classroom to irritate your classmate mates and virtue signal and that's what she's being taught mom's teaching her mom is so proud you're taking to the streets is that bothersome to people is that annoying to people when you get when you get arrested just reportedly when you get shot disproportionately when y

flag that was actually kneeling is a reference position responding to the girl's move the american civil rights union has always told maryland schools to guarantee students freedom of speech without punishment meanwhile the girl's school as you see the statement saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior but marianna says the teacher shouted out and then marianna reportedly left the classroom. discuss the issue with. missouri republican and richard goodstein advisor to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. football is about football schools about school and if you have a protest protest in a constructive way this girl can write letters to the editor she can arrange a little march but protesting in your classroom to irritate your classmate mates and virtue signal and that's what she's being taught mom's teaching her mom is so proud that her daughter is virtue signaling that she cares more than anybody else and i actually find that to make no sense when you get arrested disproportionately when you get shot disproportionately when you get put in jail just proportional

flag that was actually leila is a reference position responding to the girl's move the american civil rights union has urged all maryland schools to guarantee its students freedom of speech without punishment meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior but marianna says her teachers shouted at her and she reportedly left by classroom in tears. my colleague andrew farmer discussed the issue with john larkin a former former missouri republican and richard goodstein a former adviser to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. football is about football schools about school and if you have a protest protest in a constructive way this girl can write letters to the editor she can arrange a little march but protesting in your classroom to irritate your classmate mates and virtue signal and that's what she's being taught mom's teaching her mom is so proud that her daughter is virtue signaling that she cares more than a body else and i actually find that to make no sense when you get arrested disproportionately when you get

flag that was actually leland is a reference position responding to the goals move the american civil rights union urged all maryland schools to guarantee all students the freedom of speech without punishment meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior but marianna says her teachers shouted at her and she left the classroom in tears well my colleague andrew farmer discussed the issue with john loudon a former missouri republican and richard goodstein former adviser to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. football is about football schools about school and if you have a protest protest in a constructive way this girl can write letters to the editor she can arrange a little march but protesting in your classroom to irritate your classmate mates and virtue signal and that's what she's being taught mom's teaching her mom is so proud that her daughter is virtue signaling that she cares more than a body else and i actually find that to make no sense when you get arrested disproportionately when you get shot disproport

girl her teachers shouted at her over her behavior and she left the classroom in tears the american civil rights union has edged all married and school scare and guarantee students the freedom of speech with no punishment meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for not taking part in patriotic and. mariana said that she was inspired by an american football quarterback who melts during the national anthem before a game in two thousand and sixteen his silent protest soon spreads among other athletes this provokes this provokes fiery political debates all the way to the white house you love to see one of these in a phone. when somebody disrespects our flag to say get that son of a the field right out the star that was not against our anthem or our flag that was actually kneeling is a reference position my colleague andrew farmer discuss the issue with john william leighton a former republican member of the missile ri senate and richard goodstein former adviser to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. unless you have a goal and someth

responding to the goals me for the american civil rights union schools to guarantee students the freedom of speech without punishments meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior but marianna says had teachers shouted at her and she left the classroom and ten as well as we discuss the issue with john leighton format mystery republican and richard goodstein former advisor to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. football is about football schools about school and if you have a protest protest in a constructive way this girl can write letters to the editor she can arrange a little march but protesting in your classroom to irritate your classmate mates and virtue signal and that's what she's being taught mom's teaching her mom is so proud you're taking to the streets is that bothersome to people is that annoying to people when you get when you get arrested disproportionately when you get shot disproportionately when you get put in jail just proportionally that's not just annoying that's totally ruining you

flag that was actually kneeling is a reference position responding to the girl's move the american civil rights union has always told maryland schools to guarantee students freedom of speech without.

flag that was actually kneeling is a reference position responding to the girl's move the american civil rights union the old maryland schools to guarantee all students the freedom of speech without punishments meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior but marianna says her teachers shouted at her and she left to a classroom in tears well my colleague andrew farmer discussed the issue with john loudon a former missouri republican and richard goodstein former advisor to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. football is about football schools about school and if you have a protest protest in a constructive way this girl can write letters to the editor she can arrange a little march but protesting in your classroom to irritate your classmate mates and virtue signal and that's what she's being taught mom's teaching her mom is so proud that her daughter's virtue signaling that she cares more than anybody else and i actually find that to make no sense when you get arrested disproportionately when you get shot disproport

to the go head teacher shouts at her her behavior and she left the classroom in this the american civil rights union has edged all maryland schools guarantee students the freedom of speech with no punishment meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement saying it's not aware of any students being disciplined to not taking pause in patriotic observances the school also encourage students to speak out mariana said that she was inspired by an american football quarterback who now it's during the national anthem before a game in two thousand and sixteen his silent protest soon spreads among the athletes this provoked a fari political debate debate all the way to the white house would you love to see one of these in a phone. when somebody disrespects our flag to say get that son of a. right. to start that was not against our anthem or our flag that was actually kneeling is a reference position my colleague andre farmer discuss the issue with john williams the former republican member of the missile ri senate and richard goodstein former advisor to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. unless yo

a general counsel at the american civil rights union. great to have both you've with us on this friday night. doug, let me start with you. essentially it sounds like what they're saying is dhs and this trump administration didn't put up a good enough argument. but it never had the constitutional authority behind president obama to start it, and so why can't this president unwind it? >> on the one hand, you can report somewhat fairly that this judge is giving a stinging rebuke of daca itself. but this was the judge who back, shannon, april 25th, gave the government 90 days, making it clear that if you articulate a solid reason for it, the court will listen to it. the judge said, once again, you failed to articulate it. the judge said, this court is not holding that dhs cannot terminate the program. they're saying, you didn't give us a sufficient reason. >> in the meantime, let me read a little bit of the judge's decision. the courts simply hold that if they wish to take any other action, it must give a rational explanation for its decisio

what do our legal eagles think, doug burns and general counsel of the american civil rights union, can see cal ski. good to have both of you with us this friday night as we iron out this decision. let me start with you. what they are saying is the trump administration didn't put up a good enough argument why this program should be disbanded but they said it never had constitutional authority behind president obama to start it and so why can't this president unwind it. >> a couple ways to digest this opinion. you can report that this judge is giving a stinging rebuke on the question of dac a itself, this was the judge on april 25th gave the government 90 days making it very clear if you articulate a solid reason for terminating at the board will listen carefully, they came forward after 90 days and the judge that you failed to articulate it but the last one is the key. this court is not holding that dhs can determine its program. you didn't give us the question. >> none of this will take until august 23rd, there will be a chance for appeal. let me read the judge's decision, the court ho

attorneys who proposed that a private civil rights group, the american civil liberties union, the acluharge of locating hundreds of deported parents who have been separated from their children in the wake of the government's family separation policies. now the judge is the same one who has been overseeing the return of those kids over the past few weeks. he calls the administration's proposal to let the aclu and other groups locate the parents unacceptable. he also added that the reality is for every parent who is not located, there will be a permanent orphan child and that is 100% the responsibility of the administration. joining us jeff merkley, who has visited some of the detention centers the kids have been kept. senator merkley, thanks for being with us. do you have any understanding as to why the government thought it was the aclu's responsibility to relow -- to find these parents, to essentially right these wrong in the first place? it wasn't the aclu that separated the kids from their parents. >> no, absolutely not, anderson. the situation is that the government has so botched

civilians, union and confederate, enslaved and free americans, who lived through the tumultuous and defining years of the american civil war. in the decades of reconstruction and civil rights struggles that followed. monuments are and always have been an important part of that commemoration and an important part of interpreting history and understanding the past. they provideds, focal points, tangible icons that help visitors understand that they are on hallowed ground , where americans of all sides struggled to deal with the wrenching issues that divided our nation and forged the country that we are in today. monuments tab for thousands of years expressed -- monuments have for thousands of years called to us to reflect. understanding, to draw meaning from the past for our own time, the shenandoah valley battlefields foundation considers monuments to be historic in their own right. to be important features on historic rural and urban landscapes and to be worthy of protection. accordingly, the shenandoah valley battlefields foundation makes the following statements of policy. we are opposed to the eradication or removal of plaques, statues, monuments, place names and other

the field right now these guys that was not against our anthem or our flag that was actually kneeling is a reference position responding to the girl's action the american civil liberties union urged all maryland schools to guarantee students freedom of speech without punishment meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement saying it is not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior we put the issue up for debate with former missouri state senator john loudon and richard goodstein and former advisor to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. football is about football schools about school and if you have a protest protest in a constructive way this girl can write letters to the editor she can arrange a little march put protesting in your classroom to irritate your classmate mates and virtue signal and that's what she's being taught mom's teaching her mom is so proud you're taking to the streets is that bothersome to people is that annoying to people when you get when you get arrested disproportionately when you get shot disproportionately when you get put in jail just proportionally that's not just annoying that's totally ruining your life so the fact

field right now out of the sky that was not against our anthem or our flag that was actually kneeling is a reference position while responding to the girl's action the american civil liberties union urged to all maryland schools to guarantee students freedom of speech without punishment meanwhile the girl's school has issued a statement saying it is not aware of any students being disciplined for such behavior who put the issue up for debate with former missouri state senator john loudon and richard goodstein former adviser to the hillary clinton presidential campaign. football is about football schools about school and if you have a protest protest in a constructive way this girl can write letters to the editor she can arrange a little march but protesting in your classroom to irritate your classmate mates and virtue signal and that's what she's being taught mom's teaching her mom is so proud you're taking to the streets is that bothersome to people is that annoying to people when you get when you get arrested disproportionately when you get shot disproportionately when you get put in jail just proportionally that's not just annoying that's totally ruining your life so the fact