artistic director of the new musical development foundation as well as former president of american greetings dot com thank you to both of you for just a little great to have you here with the structure it so you can call. these inequities stats that i was sharing in the rant a few minutes ago these are not the result of. you know wealthy people being evil people or that kind of thing that the result of a relatively small number of people reading this is really gaming the system we find from the statistics of sixty three percent this last poll sixty three percent of people who earn over a million dollars a year actually want their taxes to go up so. charlie let me put it first to you that there what do you say to people who think that things when tax rates were higher were like somehow worse in the fifty's sixty's seventy's and there's there's no evidence the polow tax environment the historically low tax environment under which we live now has not created any of the jobs that the high tax environment that the ninety's created so so should we i mean is there counter evidence well reducing taxes on milliona