. -- andover street. he no longer wishes to hold the permit. we can briefly here from the public if he wishes to speak. he is saying he does not. we can take public comment and then consider a motion. is there any public comment on item 5? seeing none, commissioner stacks president goh: -- commissioners? vice president garcia: -- president goh: seeing none, i will move to grant the appeal. >> call the roll, please. >> on that motion from president goh to grant this appeal and deny the permit -- commissioner fung: i vote no, -- i intended to vote no, but based on their request, i will vote yes. vice president garcia: yes. commissioner peterson: aye. >> the vote is 4-0. the appeal is granted. >> the second housekeeping item is in regards to item 10, appealed 10-144, to alter a building on 19th street. the parties have reached an agreement and asked to grant the appeal and condition the permit with the terms stated in their joint letter, dated february 9, 2011. i do not know -- they are here? both parties? great. if you have any comments, you can