reshetnikov maxim gennadievich our minister of economy our minister of finance of russia uh andrey mikhailovich makarov on the budget of the state duma and uh, without andrey mikhailovich breakfast uh and thank you very much for his active position always. e borisovich titov borisovich first of all he is a well-known businessman. and , of course, presidential commissioner for entrepreneurial rights uh hmm alexey mordashov. thank you very much, alexey , for being with us, as it were, key participants, but nonetheless. i invite everyone, uh, entrepreneurs and leaders of the regions. and uh, all participants for half an hour to participate in our discussion with you. well, uh, if i may, i'd like to show you some slides. with uh first effect we have today from sanctions, it is much softer than expected by all experts and experts. what is called on the other side of the world, which were undertaken e, against the russian economy and the russian expert - e ruble. eh, strengthened this has its own reasons. eh, of course . uh, including the strengthening of the ruble affected inflation and what we are seeing n

uh, i would like to ask andrei mikhailovich makarov a question regarding the image, uh, the economy of your vision. eh, after all, one way or another, we had a discussion between. if the difference between dreaming and planning and should it be and should it be dreamed of e great e, that is, dreaming of economists is a diversified economy, which, of course, gives another stability level. how do you see 2030? can i come back on the 22nd? you know, i was sitting here writing down, because in fact i learned a lot of interesting things. maxim says that finally business. he finally got everything cleared for business. true, he doesn’t know this yet, maybe he just knows that specific one with first names and surnames who was really allowed. they probably know, if the others find out, in principle, it will already be good, but i would like to return to the topic. e, which was marked. how to build a brain. i believe actually the answer to this question is long to say. this is an absolutely brilliant german man. i have always bowed before you. now i bow. that's absolutely. this is the first def

well, what are the back-tudes of the sas, he asked, comrade makarov is wonderful, but absolutely a person and a great specialist, andrey mikhailovich, as an amateur, yes, well, let's hear more say the solution to these problems, what does this mean again the question of an amateur fan beatles back to the something else no. yes, because obviously the economy of the soviet union was inefficient for a number of years, and it would be off topic, because it was closed. she was effective because it was uncompetitive. she was inefficient because she was the centralized section of it all. no, of course not in russia. well, another model, what should i say. what period in soviet history is she trying to tell about, so that it is more accurate, because , if necessary, it was inefficient, how she managed to defeat the most effective european of the thirties forties. i won't take it. it's good if you liked it. so these self-propelled guns of makarov or the beatles, i myself benchal this song on the guitar like that. here. ah, why we willingly use any historical experience of any country, except for the historical experience of our own property

shhh asked comrade makarov absolutely wonderful person and a great specialist deputy of the state duma committee andrey mikhailoviche an amateur, right? well , let's listen to another naftavaz offer. talk about solving these problems, what does it mean again a question of an amateur fan of the beatles or something else? that is, it is not here now. yes, because the apparent economy of the soviet union was inefficient throughout history. i would not be in the subject, because it was closed. it was efficient because it was not competitive. she was inefficient because she was the centralized section of it all. no, of course, russia no, well, another model, what should be said about such a period of soviet history. of course he tries to tell, so that it is more accurate, because if she was inefficient, as she managed to defeat the most efficient european thirties forties are at the beginning of the gigantic. it 's impossible. if you liked these words of makarov or beatles, i myself benchal on the guitar. i'm a child myself what makes this song so? here. ah, why do we willingly use any historical experience of any count