i would hope reappointing andy moran, and both puc had andy moran and with a non-manager who lacks expertise. this rules committee could reject this nominee and seek to have the mayor appoint a qualified person to this seat. ms. stacy is certainly qualified for other appointments but not this one in my opinion. thank you for hearing my comments. >> are there any additional speakers on this item no. 1? >> >>clerk: that was our only caller on this matter. >> public comment is closed. when mr. -- becomes mayor, he can nominate whoever he chooses. but i find the qualifications that were created by this supervisor in proposition e whatever year it was 2007 or 8, i think i wrote the qualifications for the members of the puc commission and subject to all of them to ratification by the board of supervisors and the voters voted for that. i find that ms. stacy does indeed have experience in water systems. to that end, i will make the motion to amend the subject motion by removing in the title the word "rejecting" at line 3 and removing the word "rejects". on the motion, >> roll call, please. >>clerk:

moran is a rock of stability at the puc. whether he was an employee the general manager, a commissioner or the commission president. everybody has relied on andy's expertise. and knowledge and history and i don't think that there is anybody here at the puc who offers a wealth of knowledge as anldzy moran and i will say i had the opportunity ton andy in a couple of ways first as the city attorney. where we did not always agree. now in my 11 months as your general manager. and i can only say having fwhn this role mou. i have such an appreciation for his expertise and knowledge for his perspective on thaefrg falls under the per vow of this agency. and the universal respect that andy enjoys is something i don't think any other person affiliate with the puc has. the fact that you have our former control and former gm red to sit in public comment tells you all you need ton about the respect that folks have for andy moran. and i can tell you for me the best part of my 11 months here has been our phone calls we had either in preparation for these meetings or other meetings i found anldzy to be a great council counselor and a gentlemen. i can think of no

i would hope reappointing andy moran, and both puc had andy moran and with a non-manager who lacks expertiseules committee could reject this nominee and seek to have the mayor appoint a qualified person to this seat. ms. stacy is certainly qualified for other appointments but not this one in my opinion. thank you for hearing my comments. >> are there any additional speakers on this item no. 1? >> >>clerk: that was our only caller on this matter. >> public comment is closed. when mr. -- becomes mayor, he can nominate whoever he chooses. but i find the qualifications that were created by this supervisor in proposition e whatever year it was 2007 or 8, i think i wrote the qualifications for the members of the puc commission and subject to all of them to ratification by the board of supervisors and the voters voted for that. i find that ms. stacy does indeed have experience in water systems. to that end, i will make the motion to amend the subject motion by removing in the title the word "rejecting" at line 3 and removing the word "rejects". on the motion, >> roll call, please. >>clerk: [roll ca