and then anne cook, i wanted to give her a particular shout out because anne was here with me along with carry killstrom on the first waterfront plan. i'm not the only one who knows about the first waterfront plan as well as this one and she has been just the sage adviser and will be wrapping up her second round here at the port helping us out at the end of january. so, i really wanted to recognize all that she has done both for the waterfront plans but also she has been key in bringing the equity lens through all of the goals and policies in this plan and then working with byron on the ordinance integration as well as where the resilience team so that the equity values that we heard through the planning process, are really integrated throughout all of our efforts and our trying to respond to the directives that wove gotten from you through the strategic plan as well. so it will be hard to move on after she retires in january. she's been extraordinary in her devotion to this waterfront and i wanted to thank her publicly. the plan is still a draft. it has to go through the environmental r

ann: this is bloomberg surveillance. let's get to your bloomberg business flash. apple ceo tim cookate tax system needs to be overhauled and he is hoping the debate can take place at the global level. he spoke in dublin today. apple is appealing a $14.4 billion bill for back taxes from the european commission. the u.s. is awash with natural gas and it is about to get worse. despite the glut and depressed prices, sale -- shale output continues grew to -- shale output keeps growing. prices fell below two dollars for the first time since 2016 and at that level, u.s. producers don't make any money. airbus is offering airlines a way to guard against falling ticket prices. clients of the airbus -- will trade futures and options on index that capture fair fluctuations and that is your bloomberg business flash. francine: thank you so much. minutes,st couple of -- look if there is any fallout from that rating cut later today. the interview of the week without a doubt is carrie lam, chief executive of hong kong. we will ask her about the future of hong kong and her place in it. we are delight