stay with us let's hear what the chairman of the independent police complaints council anthony neo had decided about the outcome. you have seen from the protests which originally were police or. generated into violent protests using weapons of all kinds in fact against police and others property was destroyed and this was a situation that a police force was. in their face when situation of course they have to enforce law and they have to protect the girls. and that is the situation that we have in hong kong the words of anthony neo there the chairman of the independent police complaints council cherry you saw the protests with your own eyes do these words and more broadly the findings match your experience. well. i actually. situation i have seen protests at spring break through i have seen them throwing has broken arms i have seen i think. prophecies and i think shots or infrastructure on the street that i have also seen in many cases the police very few saying false indiscriminately on the public where i have seen them and you think that the spray lawmakers who are trying to conduct