down three out of four provisions in the arizona controversial anti immigration laws justice antonin scalia had his samuel chase moment he went in and publicly ripped president obama for not enforcing immigration laws the way scalia thought they should be just a few days after the president had announced that the nation would no longer deport young undocumented immigrants who were brought here as children and are now in school or the military or working in keeping their nose clean scully has to say as the court does that arizona contradicts federal law enforcing applications of the immigration act that the president declines to enforce bottles of wine is secured territory in this fashion is not within the power of arizona we should cease referring to it as a sovereign state and no i'm not exaggerating his tone that much actually so eight hundred three samuel chase criticized the president for trying to expand voter rights and got impeached in two thousand and twelve antonin scalia criticized the president for trying to save young undocumented immigrants from deportation pretty unlikely with

. >> supreme court justice antonin scalia goes off the rails criticizing the president. >> the big panel on the fox and friends justice next. >>> darryl issa lets the truth slip about his fast and furious witch hunt. >> do you have any evidence that white house officials were involved in these decisions, that they knowingly misled congress and are involved in a cover-up? >> no, we don't. >>> and find out why republicans are breaking with michele bachmann on health care. >> obama care as we know is the crown jewel of socialism. it's socialized medicine. >> former insurance executive wendell potter joins me for that story later. >> this is it for freedom. >>> stilto come, justice antonin scalia rails against president obama in his dissent on arizona's immigration law. katherine cryer, michael medved, and joan walsh will weigh in on the fox and friends justice and much more. >>> and later, as we await the supreme court ruling on the health care law, surprising poll numbers show even republicans are in favor of what they call obama care. except when the president's name is attached to it. we

phillips'. >>> justice antonin scalia once said, a good, hard-hitting dissent keeps you honest.ing on the arizona immigration law not to offer a challenge, but to take political cheap shots. as one reporter for "mother jones" put it, if you put scalia on "fox and friends," you'd have to squint to notice the difference. good one. in his dissent, he complains about the lack of law enforcement by feds, by the feds even though the obama administration has cracked down on illegal immigration. scalia writes, arizona bears the brunt of the country's illegal immigration problem. its citizens feel themselves under siege by large numbers of illegal immigrants who invade their property, strain their social services and even place their lives in jeopardy. scalia also used the ruling to rail against president obama's decision to halt deportations of thousands of young people brought here illegally as children. a policy that has nothing to do with the arizona case. the president said at a news conference that the new program is the right thing to do in light of congress' failure to pass the a

antonin scalia... and... ccarence pere's... our question of the dayy 3 do youuagree with the supreme court's ruling on the health care laa? go to fox- baltimore dot com .../ tell us what you think./. soond off thrr facebook../. send us a tweet./ or text your answer to 45-- 203../ enter fox45a for yes../ fox45b for in today's ruling... the majority of 3 &p conservatives... are clearly... -pd with... he nntion's highest court.../. but... many... vow... to conttnue... their fight.../. melinda roeder ... here... those groups --/ americans for prosperity is a group born out of fruutration pnd hope.stemmmng back to 2009 - hen taxpayers whh opposed the so-called "obamacare" - began protesting at congressional town hall meetings in maryland - and across the nation. they said they didn't want the government o come between them and their doctors. they increases. ironicalll, they say - the supreme court oday p cemented those fears.... essennially marrying thee issues of socialized medicine and taxes.the court ruled that congress ad the ri

said a precise salvage ob would be the more cooservative way to go - versus a áquoteá "wrecking antonin scaliaounded doubtfullthat could be possible.scalia says: "have we ever - most of our severability cases, you know, involve one little asppct of the act. the queetioo is ever really struck ddwn what was the main purpose of the act, and left the rest in effectt" regardless of tte outcomee- both the law's supporters and opponnnns havv been preparing for the fallout. senior white house advisor david plouffe - &pwhile maantininggthe law's that contingency plans have been mapped out. capitol hill democrats say they're strategizing as well.becerra says::"one way or the other, i think, on the democratic side we're prrpared to build onnthe landmark health reform to make sure more and more we ave affordable, uality care for warned republicans not to - - ááuoteá "spike the ball" should the court's opinion go in their favor. - and if it doesnnt?boohner says: down the entire laa, the hhuse - will move to repeal whaa's lefttof it. obama are is driving up the cost of health care and making it harddr for s

antonin scalia... and.... clarence thomas. response ... prom... capitol hill... was quick.../, kathleen cairns... spent the day... in d.c..../ where ... she... poke ith members... of... maryllnn's del. delegation. at the us cap in wash dc a busyyday of debaae over otter issues seemed overshadowed by the sup cts decision involving health care. -standup--harris- opinions.-harris--dutch-so f - whats next???-dutch--harris- the debate now moves back to the olitical arena. in wash edition. 45 news late - &p conservative groups ... react... to... the ruling..../ and... vow... to fight... to epeal...//. group... stemming... back to 2009. // many... members... attended ccngressional... town hall meetings... to protest .../ they... also fight... against tax increaaes... in... several states..../ ironically,... the supreme court... ruled... congress ...could impose ...mandatory health coverage power... tt átaxá the publicc < "the court of public opinion and large, hate ttis thing. don't like when the federal ey - government comes in and tells them what to do nd what not to

. >> supreme court justice antonin scalia goes off the rails criticizing the president. >> the big panelx and friends justice next. >> darryl issa lets the truth slip about his fast and furious witch hunt. >> do you have any evidence that white house officials were involved in these decisions, that they knowingly misled congress and are involved in a cover-up? >> no, we don't. >> and find out why republicans are breaking with michele bachmann on health care. >> obama care as we know is the crown jewel of socialism. it's socialized medicine. >> former insurance executive wendell potter joins me for that story later. >> this is it for freedom. [ morgan ] right now when you use your visa card, you're entered for a chance to win a trip to the olympic games for life. to cheer the summer athletes to new heights, starting in 2016... as you experience every moment, every emotion, every four years... for the rest of your life. visa. supporting athletes and the olympic games for 25 years. people everywhere go with visa. visa. supporting athletes and the olympic games for 25 years. ♪ with the hundr

people everywhere go with visa. >>> still to come, justice antonin scalia rails against president obamassent on arizona's immigration law. we will weigh in on the fox and friends justice and much more. >>> and later, as we await the supreme court ruling on the health care law, surprising poll numbers show even republicans are in favor of hot they call obama care. except when the president's name is attached to it. wendell potter will join me for that. stay with us. lots more coming up. [ creaking ] [ male announcer ] trophies and awards lift you up. but they can also hold you back. unless you ask, what's next? [ zapping ] [ clang ] this is the next level of performance. the next level of innovation. the next rx. the all-new f sport. this is the pursuit of perfection. throughout our entire lives. ♪ one a day men's 50+ is a complete multi-vitamin designed for men's health concerns as we age. ♪ it has more of seven antioxidants to support cell health. that's one a day men's 50+ healthy advantage. but thanks to hotwire, this year we got to take an extra trip. because they get us ridiculousl

antonin scalia, a reliably conservative vote released a new book this weekend in which he writes thate has "little use for central precedent the boom administration is using in its case. joining me now is noam scheiber, senior editor of the new reasonable and author of "the escape artists: how obama's team fumbled the recovery." he joins us from washington. thanks for being here. >> as we see ourselves here with 8.2% employment. if you read my book, it's mostly critical from the left. mitt romney is critical, but i think there were missed opportunities. the stimulus could have been far bigger. there was more fuss on deficit reduction and not economy. and there was emphasis on bipartisanship with republicans the same republicans trying to elect mitt romney. i hope the president is able to recover and kind of learn lessons from the last three and a half years. had he learned them a little sooner we might not be in this situation today. >> john: i applaud you for taking on the tough questions. i'm sure your democratic friends are not going to be giving you a christmas present this year.

justices antonin scalia, anthony kennedy, clarence thomas, and samuel alito issued an unusual joint dissent, united in opposition. they said the law should be invalidated in its entirety under any constitutional provision. in a 65-page dissent, they repeatedly said the law "exceeds federal power" and accused the courts of "vast judicial over- reaching" to uphold the mandate as a tax and contrary to the specific words in the health care law. "to say that the individual mandate merely imposes a tax is not to interpret the statute but to rewrite it." now, justice kennedy read aloud parts of that dissent from the bench, and, scott, going into this decision today, many people thought if the court were going to uphold most of this law, it would be justice kennedy providing that key, decisive vote. but today, justice kennedy was the conservative, and it was john roberts giving that fifth vote with the liberals to uphold the president's signature achievement. >> pelley: a day for the history books, jan. thanks very much. the president and the chief justice have a somewhat rocky history. in 2005, th

in all our brave new world bodies like alan greenspan and paul ryan but frankly to paraphrase antonin scalia today if the founders had heard such a proposal it would have run for the exits that's the big picture for tonight for more information on the stories we covered visit our web sites at thom hartmann dot com free speech dot org and r t dot com also check out our two you tube channels there are links at tom hartman dot com also tom hartman i concho all the different ways you can send us your feedback and don't forget democracy is not a spectator sport it requires your participation it begins when you get out there and show up tag your it occupies the seat of. wealthy british style. markets why not come to. find out what's really happening to the global economy with max cause or for a no holds barred look at the global financial headlines tune into kinds a report on our. download the official location to i phone on pod touch from the i choose ops to. life on the go. video on demand ati's minefield costs and says feeds now in the palm of your. question on the dot com.

justice antonin scalia rejected that idea writing in a scornful ascent -- arizona has the inherent power to exclude people from its territory. and our david wright is in arizona where the law will have real-life impact. >> reporter: as of today, anyone in arizona who gets pulled over by the authorities will have to convince the officer they're here legally. >> this whole illegal immigration problem that's facing our nation. something has to be done with it. >> reporter: for the gutierrez family, a huge worry. vladimir gutierrez is not a citizen, but his kids are. he now carries a document in his glove compartment so if he's arrested and deported, his kids won't end up in foster care. this person is designated as guardians of the minor child. >> yes. >> reporter: and there's one for each of them? >> uh-huh. >> reporter: what of the tens of thousands of hispanics who are in arizona legally? people like attorney ezekiel hernandez worries. they'll now be suspect in their own state. >> i have a tie on today. i'm probably the last hispanic you're going to stop in arizona and i have a truck. if

who pretty much knew their original intent when they started this country so-called originalist antonin scalia is determined to do his best to blow up anything that comes from a democratic president and the odds over it in trade right now around seventy eight percent that scalia will prevail and that the individual mandate will be knocked down on thursday so here's the good news if scalia does this president obama the democrats should take the concept that we're all in this together which after all is the core concept of obamacare and the mandate they should take that a step further this country already has a really good single payer health care system which has worked marvelously for several generations it's called medicare and it's so be loved by its users that they'll show up at tea party rallies with sighs and say keep government out of my medicare you damn socialists medicare is already in place already working already tied into social security numbers citizens only ready to go for the rest of us who are not over sixty five so real simple the president should propose a new health care bil

were in the majority opinion along with roberts while justices samuel alito, anthony kennedy antonin scalia 0 and clarence thomas objected. >> we continue our live team coverage from georgetown with reactions of those who will feel the effects the most. >> ever since president obama's health-care plan was passed, voters and business leaders were divided on whether the mandate would be a good thing or a bad thing for the health-care system and for the economy. today's reaction to the ruling shows the nation remains divided. linda and cheryl -- for cheryl, the ruling alleviates one reason she wakes up at night. >> worrying about whether my husband will have treatment or not and would have to watch him die because he is not getting a comprehensive cancer treatment he needed. >> there are a lot of cheers it that went up. a number of patients felt relieved that they had a safety net under them. >> many business owners worry the cost of doing business could be prohibitive. >> it could be one more thing have to follow. is a concern. >> it has not helped us at all. i have seen no instance where it

of the united states it began with the most conservative member of the supreme court justice antonin scalia we used his dissent to launch into a brazen political attack against the president school is set on monday to say is the record that arizona contradicts federal law but foreseen applications of the immigration act that the president declines to enforce bottles of wine if security is territory in this parish is not within the power of arizona we should cease referring to it as a sovereign state. scully is referring to the president's recent decision to stop deporting young undocumented immigrants were brought to this country is children that are now working have joined the military or are in school and school is basically saying that since the president refuses to enforce immigration law and it's up to the states to do so later he suggested that had the states known they couldn't enforce federal immigration laws on their own and that the president would selectively enforce them and the states would have signed the constitution that's just making stuff up a whole lot of stuff that was c

give more latitude to the states new questions are being raised about justices getting political antonin scalia now accused of being a quote politician in a robe but other states with similar laws are now assessing how this ruling will affect their own enforcement when we expect to hear the u.s. supreme court decision on the health. decision on their most arizona's immigration laws was too big to ignore and yet mitt romney tried as any day they're not talking about the economy they believe is a bad day for their campaign but are as you're what is that any day they're not talking about the economy is a bad day for the campaign guess what i think a lot of voters might agree but here's where the problem is and where the media misses time and time again just because the candidates are talking about the economy doesn't mean what they're saying is true and most often doesn't mean it's relevant to the majority of americans. i've had a real job in the real and the real economy i want to bring those skills to america the debate in this election is about how we grow fast and how we create more jobs and h

antonin scalia... and... clarence thomas. the... house.... controlled...by republicann.../ scheduled... a vooe... to árepealá... the... health ccre.. law..../ the... house ...will votee.. july 11th.../...but... theemove... will almost... certainly end.. there.../ since... democrats control the senate. the... decision... seemm to fuel... battle--lines.../. now... maryland lawwakers... are... lookiig at ... what... phis... means... in tte coming monnhs. (dutcc) "ttis is the law, its forward" (harrii) "in two weees were gonna come back aad file a bill to repeallbill in its enni" opposing sides... are... aa odd's... over... how... ...from small busineeses ... to... the... presidential election. the... rulingg.. came ...as a disappoinnment ... to... conservatives ... who... protested... "obaaacare"... all... along.../ melinda... roeder... tells us whyy.. "americans for prosperity."says... the law... áwillá be repealed pepealed :32 "it'' disappointing. we state director offamericans for prosperity...a group born out of frustration and hope.... stemming back to 2

well n writing his opinion on arizona's immigration law, his dissenting opinion, justice antonin scaliat directly after president obama, mentioning his recent decision to refuse to deport some 1.4 young illegal immigrants. that was not argued or mentioned in the context of this case, but justice scalia's got an issue with it, and he asked who will protect the borders of the sovereign states if the federal government refuses to enforce our immigration laws? that fiery debate is three minutes away. >>> and debby is just a tropical storm right now, so why are some forecasters worried that this thing could produce millions in damage and threaten any number of lives? janice dean has answers. >>> and breaking news just ahead on a letter from the house oversight committee to the white house saying president obama overstepped the guidelines on extending executive privilege to attorney general eric holder. we've got the breaking news. >> i'm going to ask you first of all today, have you and your attorneys produced internally the materials responsive to the subpoenas? >> we believe that we have r

justice antonin scalia sounded doubtful it could be possible. >> when have we really struck down whats the main purpose of the act and left the rest in effect? >> reporter: regardless of the outcome, supporters and opponents are preparing for the fall-out. david plouffe maintaining the law's constitutionality acknowledging that contingency plans have been mapped out. capitol hill democrats say they are strategizing as well. >> one way or the other, on the democratic side, we are prepared to build on the landmark health reform to make sure more and more we have affordable quality healthcare for all americans. >> reporter: speaker john boehner warned republican not fight the ball. should the court's decision go in their favor. if it doesn't? >> if the court does not strike down the entire law the house will move to repeal what is left of it. obamacare is driving up the cost of healthcare and making it harder for small businesses to hire new workers. our focus has been and will continue to be the economy. >> reporter: they must also resolve a medicaid claim brought by 26 states who argue

justice, he issued the rule and justice kennedy for the minority which included clarence thomas, antonin scaliacally blasted this whole notion saying it's not constitutional because if you don't get health insurance you're penalized with a tax which congress can do. congress can levy taxes. well, these justices led by justice kennedy said that's ridiculous and you're basically rewriting the law because congress never said to anybody we're going to tax you if you don't buy health insurance. so that play there was interesting and justice ruth bader-ginsburg rendered an opinion saying she thought everything of the affordable care act should be constitutional. only three spoke and everyone else was sitting there. they started right at 10:00. >> i'm curious what was the scene like inside the courtroom. we know people lined up overnight to try to get a good seat. >> it was the general public. it was hushed. relatives of the justices were in there. utah senator orrin hatch was in there and michele bachmann later on a megaphone outside blasting the court. she was inside and the retired justice john pau

does anyone wonder like i do what this skourlt, the one personified by antonin scalia and clarence thomasd have done in the landmark decisions of the post world war ii era. i doubt this pack of conservatives that includes john robards, sam alito, and justice kennedy would have removed organized prayer from public schools in the 1960s. that decision that ignited the moral majority. i doubt this court would have recognized a woman's right to decide on an abortion in the 1970s. let me proffer a tougher judgment, would they have upheld the 1964 civil rights bill, the statute that called it illegal to ban someone because of race. would they have approved the decision or joined in the dissent. maybe kennedy would have. we have the most conservative court since the '30s. these justices believe in original intent. they want the judge the case the way the founding fathers would. they wrote slavery into the constitution. it took a civil war and the 13th amendment to get it out. that's "hardball" for now.

. >> the supreme court justice antonin scalia's dissent in the sb1070 also criticized a policy that was before the court -- president of his recent announcement his administration would not deport many undocumented immigrants who came to the u.s. as children. scalia wrote -- , could youincapiÉ respond to that statement by justice scalia? >> unfortunately, his dissenting opinion highlights how ideology really is what is at play. that issue was not before the supreme court. the fact he felt he needed to speak to that and once again question the obama administration's authority on immigration at the same time the court had just issued a majority opinion, talking about the importance of the federal government's authority under the supremacy clause of the united states, again, just reminds us of the biases at play. it is not surprising that is coming from justice scalia. however, i think the important thing is both the majority decision actually gives more power to the administration and those of us that have been pushing the administration, like the dreamers, that have taken a courageous ac

a dissent read from the bench also in the arizona case by justice antonin scalia that was again not just furious but went after the president himself on immigration changes. so it's an amazing thing to see a court that is, a, says it wants to be out of the spotlight, and b, suffering from the lowest poll ratings this court has seen in a long, long time. doing things that seem to deliberately promote the idea that the partisan rift at the court is worse than it's ever been. >> on the issue of the campaign finance stuff, i realize citizens united has been famous since it was decided. it's getting more and more famous with each passing day in american politics as we see its impact. it's interesting to see the montana attorney general put out a statement in response to this ruling. montana law, their state law is getting overthrown by virtue of this decision. he seemed to signal he does not think this fight is over yet. he said, despite this disappointing decision the last word has not been spoken on the issue of how we preserve a viable democracy in which everyday people have a meaningful v

justice antonin scalia claimed the obama administration opposed the law because it, quote, desperately wants to avoid upsetting foreign powers. i guess he means mexico -- and that the majority ofpinion boggles the mind. this from a guy who thinks jesus liked the death penalty. as for jan brewer, she told a local white house, the white house opposition was part of a plot to get illegal immigrants to cross into this country to vote to help reelect the president. >> they want chaos. they want a larger voting base as far as i am concerned and they want the illegal immigration to continue so the illegals can all do whatever they want and register to vote. it's illegal but they are not enforcing the law. so what's going to happen to them? he is looking for votes. >> january bhch -- jan brewer is cubist art, three of the provisions, while keeping the one that allows police to use reasonable suspicion to check immigration status if they think they might be undocumented which concerned raul grajalva. >> i think it opens the door for increased violation of civil rights and discrimination. >> the

. >> 76-year-old justice antonin scalia has spent a third of his life on the united states supreme courtis apparently starting to get to him. he confessed today in writing, in a strange, even-for-him opinion that his mind is, and this is his word, "boggled." the most peculiar thing about justice scalia's dissent today is that he reached far beyond the record of the case, far beyond the arizona statute, and cited material that was never considered in the case. it seemscalia is very upset with president obama recent announcement restricting deportations of people under 30 who may be in this country illegally. scalia alone, among the justices, snuck that little bit into his thinking about the case. the president said at a news conference that the new program is the right thing to do in light of congress' failure to pass the administration's proposed revision of the immigration act. perhaps it is, though arizona may not think so. but to say, as the court does, that arizona contradicts federal law by enforcing applications of the immigration act that the president declines to enforce boggles

he was approving the law and i saw antonin scalia, sitting immediately to his right, who is the senior associate justice now and he looked distraught because he had lost this case. anthony kennedy who we thought was the swing vote, he later wrote a scathing, angry bitter dissent. where he said he would have invalidated the entire law. so that's how close this was. but the result was quite clear. >> sanjay, you heard governor romney a few moments ago say on day one he would act to repeal it. if you go to his website, it gives a pretty detailed view of his positions on health care what we don't from him is a sequencing. if on day one, i'm going to try to repeal it, you take the stems you can, you ask the congress to do things. you've talked to his policy advisers about this. how do they do the sequencing? the governor says, he would keep the pre-existing condition thing, keep the other more popular things. but how would they do it? >> well, you know, it's funny because i've asked that same question, john. there's not good answers on that particular issue. even with regard to some of the