remember miss ohio, audrey bolte?ery next night. >> i have no doubt that this is what set her off, and she knew that she was losing him and that would be final. >> reporter: 24 hours later, ryan is dead. >> a highland heights woman allegedly shot and killed her boyfriend. >> shayna hubers allegedly fired those fatal shots. >> this is somebody who wanted him dead. >> it was like i was at -- it was out-of-body experience. >> reporter: and shayna is in the interrogation room, utterly ignoring her right to remain silent. >> i gave him his nose job he wanted. >> when i first saw the interrogation tapes of shayna hubers, i immediately thought of jodi arias. >> reporter: jodi arias, the arizona woman who shot her boyfriend then stood on her head during a police interrogation. if you thought that tape was off the charts, wait till you see this. ♪ how sweet the sound >> reporter: we'll be right back. ♪ that saved a wretch (vo) if you have type 2 diabetes, you may know what it's like to deal with high... and low blood sugar. ja

. >> reporter: the story begins here at a bar called the milford inn. 24-year-old audrey bolte is waiting, any minute now, a man is supposed to arrive. were you excited to meet him? >> yes, of course. i was very much looking forward to it. >> reporter: audrey isn't just your average beautiful blonde on a blind date. >> audrey bolte, you are miss ohio! >> reporter: she's miss ohio 2012! >> only three women left. >> reporter: one of the final three at the miss usa pageant. >> and the second runner up is ohio! >> reporter: but tonight miss ohio is hoping to meet mr. right. >> i had ended a serious relationship about a month prior so it was kind of like me getting back out to, in the social world. >> reporter: they had met on facebook through mutual friends. they talked about possibly meeting at ryan's condo but decide to rendezvous at the bar. one small change in the plans changes the course of the entire night. >> who wouldn't be looking forward to meet a lawyer from cincinnati who's attractive and funny and witty? i mean who wouldn't be excited to? >> reporter: it was going to be a night o