supervisor avalos. >> supervisor avalos? avalos present. president breed?> here. >> breed present. >> campos present. supervisor cohen. >> present. >> cohen present. >> supervisor farrell not present. supervisor kim? kim present. supervisor mar. >> here. >> mar present, supervisor peskin present. >> tang present. supervisor wiener? wiener present. supervisor yee? yee present, madam president you have a quorum. >> thank you, ladies and gentlemen, please join us for the pledge of allegiance. i pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> thank you. madam clerk, are there any communications? >> yes, madam president. from supervisor farrell, dated march 8th, requesting that he be excused from today's meet colleagues, is there a motion to excuse supervisor faler? motion by supervisor avalos, seconded by supervisor cohen, colleagues can we take this without objection? without objection, supervisor farrell is excused. [ gavel ] >> all

supervisor avalos. >> supervisor avalos? avalos present. president breed? >> here. >> breed present. >> campos present. supervisor cohen. >> present. >> cohen present. >> supervisor farrell not present. supervisor kim? kim present. supervisor mar. >> here. >> mar present, supervisor peskin present. >> tang present. supervisor wiener? wiener present. supervisor yee? yee present, madam president you have a quorum. >> thank you, ladies and gentlemen, please join us for the pledge of allegiance. i pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> thank you. madam clerk, are there any communications? >> yes, madam president. from supervisor farrell, dated march 8th, requesting that he be excused from today's meet colleagues, is there a motion to excuse supervisor faler? motion by supervisor avalos, seconded by supervisor cohen, colleagues can we take this without objection? without objection, supervisor farrell is excused. [ gavel ] >> al

supervisor avalos. >> supervisor avalos? avalos present. president breed? >> here. >> breed present. >> campos present. supervisor cohen. >> present. >> cohen present. >> supervisor farrell not present. supervisor kim? kim present. supervisor mar. >> here. >> mar present, supervisor peskin present. >> tang present. supervisor wiener? wiener present. supervisor yee? yee present, madam president you have a quorum. >> thank you, ladies and gentlemen, please join us for the pledge of allegiance. i pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of america, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> thank you. madam clerk, are there any communications? >> yes, madam president. from supervisor farrell, dated march 8th, requesting that he be excused from today's meet colleagues, is there a motion to excuse supervisor faler? motion by supervisor avalos, seconded by supervisor cohen, colleagues can we take this without objection? without objection, supervisor farrell is excused. [ gavel ] >> al

er >> okay, this item was sponsored by supervisor avalos, so i would like to turn it over to him.r >> thank you, chair farrell and i want to appreciate the work of the budget committee to hear this item and also for all the previous work that the board of supervisors has done for the geneva car barn and the newest version or newbesting building that we're trying to restore in district 11 are the emergency hospital on onondaga and the home and health site on onondaga and elevate, these latitude buildings are two public buildings under the department of public health jurisdiction that had been empty, i believe it's been around 7 years that they've both been empty, they've been sources of blight fwl the neighborhood and just along the corner of alamani and onondaga, there have been homeless encampments there on the build, there's been people squatting inside the building as of last year, the corner building and it's also a part of the commercial corridor in district 11 that we're trying desperate toy to bring up to viability and economic viability, we've made some really good improve

supervisor avalos they'll be on march 22 agenda. peter thank you. colleagues, either any changes to the feathery 9th 2016 regular board meeting minutes? seeing none,, is their motion to approve those minutes? moved and seconded. collies can we take those meeting minutes without objection? without objection those minutes will pass after public comments. >>[gavel] >> madam clerk, please read the consent agenda >> items one through 7 are on consent is considered routine. whenever the object server and item that considered separately >> seen no names on the roster, adam clark please call the roll >> on items 1-7 supervisor avalos aye, breed aye, campos aye, cohen aye, farrell aye, the camp absent among mar aye, the peskin aye, tang aye, wiener aye, yee aye there are 10 aye >> these items are fat pass any adopted unanimously >>[gavel] >> madam clerk, please will to item number 8 >> item 8 resolution to approve the agreement doing business as san francisco auto return for towing storage and disposal of abandon and illegally parked vehicle

commissioner avalos? >> i am appreciative of the work that they have done, and especially the work on the reliability and that is significant and that the thing that the public has really called about and is concerned about is the need to reliable and so the focus is really good and i am also wondering what the focus will be on capitol, and the facilities and structures that are put in place that will make the experience of the riders, and the transit users that are and we have a lot of situations in places like balboa park, station areas and other places that don't work for us. that area needs attention especially in parts of the san francisco that take up the great chunk of the capitol dollars. >> dually noted. we are as you are well aware, investing in those muni facilities and the mant nens facilities at the, and to bring it to a lesser extent at the moment across the street in the gene va yard but we certainly have a long way to go in that regard and looking across. the agency has just entered into a

supervisor avalos, do you want to join us?>>[applause] >> thank you for your hard work and congratulations. that was the last of our 2:30 pm commendations. colleagues, who were turned for regular agenda. beginning with item number 20 >> item 20 resolution to receive and approve an annual reports that broadway benefit district for fiscal year 2014-15. >> will call vote >> on item 20 supervisor yee aye, avalos aye, breed aye, avalos aye, cohen aye, farrell aye, kim aye, mar aye, peskin aye, tang aye, wiener aye. there are 11 aye >> the resolution is adopted unanimously >>[gavel] >> item 21 >> item 21 and ordinance 2 men the planning code to allow the existing bar on the ground floor the upper market street input commercial transit district expand to the 2nd floor under specified circumstances with a conditional use authorization tool from the claimed by ms. ceqa determination and make the other findings. >> colleagues, tickets item same house, same call be without the ordinance passes unanimously on the first reading >>[gavel] >

. >> item 1, roll call, commissioner avalos, present. commissioner breed, present. commissioner campos, present. commissioner cohen, present. commissioner farrell, absent. commissioner kim, absent. commissioner mar, absent. commissioner peskin, present. commissioner tang, absent. commissioner wiener, present. commissioner yee, present. we have quorum >> okay, i want to thank sfgtv for broadcasting todays meeting, leo [inaudible] and also colleagues supervisor farrell has asked to be excused in adivision supervisor kim is ill and unable to attend so can i have a motion to excuse commissioner farrell and commissioner kim? motion by commissioner cohen, seconded by commissioner compose and do wree need roll call on that or take that without objection. >> take without objection. item number 2 >> chairs report. this is a information item. >> colleagues we have two pieces of good news to share. first i like to congratulate cal trans and transportation authority with public and private sector partners for winning the california transportation award. we had the opening of th

supervisor avalos, do you want to join us?>>[applause] >> thank you for your hard work and congratulations. that was the last of our 2:30 pm commendations. colleagues, who were turned for regular agenda. beginning with item number 20 >> item 20 resolution to receive and approve an annual reports that broadway benefit district for fiscal year 2014-15. >> will call vote >> on item 20 supervisor yee aye, avalos aye, breed aye, avalos aye, cohen aye, farrell aye, kim aye, mar aye, peskin aye, tang aye, wiener aye. there are 11 aye >> the resolution is adopted unanimously >>[gavel] >> item 21 >> item 21 and ordinance 2 men the planning code to allow the existing bar on the ground floor the upper market street input commercial transit district expand to the 2nd floor under specified circumstances with a conditional use authorization tool from the claimed by ms. ceqa determination and make the other findings. >> colleagues, tickets item same house, same call be without the ordinance passes unanimously on the first reading >>[gavel] >

supervisor avalos they'll be on march 22 agenda. peter thank you. colleagues, either any changes to the feathery 9th 2016 regular board meeting minutes? seeing none,, is their motion to approve those minutes? moved and seconded. collies can we take those meeting minutes without objection? without objection those minutes will pass after public comments. >>[gavel] >> madam clerk, please read the consent agenda >> items one through 7 are on consent is considered routine. whenever the object server and item that considered separately >> seen no names on the roster,

supervisor avalos >> the general call for introductions supervisor avalos >> supervisor avalos? supervisors. >> submit content supervisors because >> cement submit. supervisor cohen >> cement >> supervisor farrell. i have one item. you continue to gun violence in san francisco and across our country. where the contributor doctors documented time and time again which was addressed in part by there were happy to cosponsor this year was regarding the safe storage of firearms. this issue continues to threaten public health in our city. recent study over 1.7 million children under the age of 18 were living in homes with loaded and unlocked firearms but another study 73% of children under the age of 10 living in homes with guns knowing the location of their parents firearms. such as children and youth who are at risk. about guns in homes are also susceptible to theft during home invasions which was part of the issue last year. according to data from the bureau of justice statistics program of the united states department of justice, closer 90,000 arms are sold stolen each year during

supervisor avalos they'll be on march 22 agenda. peter thank you. colleagues, either any changes to the feathery 9th 2016 regular board meeting minutes? seeing none,, is their motion to approve those minutes? moved and seconded. collies can we take those meeting minutes without objection? without objection those minutes will pass after public comments. >>[gavel] >> madam clerk, please read the consent agenda >> items one through 7 are on consent is considered routine. whenever

supervisor avalos >> the general call for introductions supervisor avalos >> supervisor avalos? supervisors. >> submit content supervisors because >> cement submit. supervisor cohen >> cement >> supervisor farrell. i have one item. you continue to gun violence in san francisco and across our country. where the contributor doctors documented time and time again which was addressed in part by there were happy to cosponsor this year was regarding the safe storage of firearms. this issue continues to threaten public health in our city. recent study over 1.7 million children under the age of 18 were living in homes with loaded and unlocked firearms but another study 73% of children under the age of 10 living in homes with guns knowing the location of their parents firearms. such as children and youth who are at risk. about guns in homes are also susceptible to theft during home invasions which was part of the issue last year. according to data from the bureau of justice statistics program of the united states department of justice, closer 90,000 arms are sold stolen each year during

supervisor avalos >> the general call for introductions supervisor avalos >> supervisor avalos? supervisors. >> submit content supervisors because >> cement submit. supervisor cohen >> cement >> supervisor farrell. i have one item. you continue to gun violence in san francisco and across our country. where the contributor doctors documented time and time again which was addressed in part by there were happy to cosponsor this year was regarding the safe storage of firearms. this issue continues to threaten public health in our city. recent study over 1.7 million children under the age of 18 were living in homes with loaded and unlocked firearms but another study 73% of children under the age of 10 living in homes with guns knowing the location of their parents firearms. such as children and youth who are at risk. about guns in homes are also susceptible to theft during home invasions which was part of the issue last year. according to data from the bureau of justice statistics program of the united states department of justice, closer 90,000 arms are sold stolen each year during

next speaker. >> hi supervisor avalos and jane kim. i leave that there should be eliminated for suspension of court debt. my occupation is driving and in order to get to work i need to drive and if i have a court fine i can't pay if i'm not working so i believe it should be eliminating for suspension of license for court debt. thank you. >> thank you. >> hello supervisor kim and avalos. scott nelson with the coalition on homelessness and here to speak about the quality of life citations. there is already a parcel amnesty program started by da halnen where people that get quality of life tickets in the city can get them dismissed through the coalition and the district attorney if they accept serves from the city of san francisco. the police give people ticket squz say here is the ticket for sleeping on the side walk and go to the coalition to get it dismissed. that works for a lut of tickets but doesn't work for muni tickets thmpt inspects and the muni tickets are $112 and nothing we can do because it isn't a police matter. we can omwor

supervisor avalos they'll be on march 22 agenda.colleagues, either any changes to the feathery 9th 2016 regular board meeting minutes? seeing none,, is their motion to approve those minutes? moved and seconded. collies can we take those meeting minutes without objection? without objection those minutes will pass after public comments. >>[gavel] >> madam clerk, please read the consent agenda >> items one through 7 are on consent is considered routine. whenever the object server and item that considered separately >> seen no names on the roster, adam clark please call the roll >> on items 1-7 supervisor avalos aye, breed aye, campos aye, cohen aye, farrell aye, the camp absent among mar aye, the peskin aye, tang aye, wiener aye, yee aye there are 10 aye >> these items are fat pass any adopted unanimously >>[gavel] >> madam clerk, please will to item number 8 >> item 8 resolution to approve the agreement doing business as san francisco auto return for towing storage and disposal of abandon and illegally parked vehicles burn amount not

commissioner avalos? >> i am appreciative of the work that they have done, and especially the work on the reliability and that is significant and that the thing that the public has really called about and is concerned about is the need to reliable and so the focus is really good and i am also wondering what the focus will be on capitol, and the facilities and structures that are put in place that will make the experience of the riders, and the transit users that are and we have a lot of situations in places like balboa park, station areas and other places that don't work for us. that area needs attention especially in parts of the san francisco that take up the great chunk of the capitol dollars. >> dually noted. we are as you are well aware, investing in those muni facilities and the mant nens facilities at the, and to bring it to a lesser extent at the moment across the street in the gene va yard but we certainly have a long way to go in that regard and looking across. the agency has just entered into a

supervisor avalos, do you want to join us? >>[applause] >> thank you for your hard work and congratulations. that was the last of our 2:30 pm commendations. colleagues, who were turned for regular agenda. beginning with item number 20 >> item 20 resolution to receive and approve an annual reports that broadway benefit district for fiscal year 2014-15. >> will call vote >> on item 20 supervisor yee aye, avalos aye, breed aye, avalos aye, cohen aye, farrell aye, kim aye, mar aye, peskin aye, tang aye, wiener aye. there are 11 aye >> the resolution is adopted unanimously >>[gavel] >> item 21 >> item 21 and ordinance 2 men the planning code to allow the existing bar on the ground floor the upper market street input commercial transit district expand to the 2nd floor under specified circumstances with a conditional use authorization tool from the claimed by ms. ceqa determination and make the other findings. >> colleagues, tickets item same house, same call be without the ordinance passes unanimously on the first reading >>[gavel]

. >> supervisor campos is the author and joined us supervisor avalos well, thank you. >> thank you very much madam chair and colleagues thank you for hearing this item today the legislation before you is about helping families and school workers in san francisco remain in their homes during the academic year i want to begin by thanking the co-sponsoring supervisor kim and supervisor avalos and supervisor mar that builds on prevention that supervisor mar spearheaded in 2009 that legislation allows landlords to evacuate families owner move-in the families have children under the age of 18 the scald system and prohibits the eviction during the school year the current legislation expands the existing legislation to include all no fault evictions so that families with children in our system can not be evicted during the school year for evictions related to condominium conversion and substantial rehabilitation the second thing it includes educator and we define educators as people that work in san francisco continentals directing with students and home daycare's both public and private this n

supervisor avalos they'll be on march 22 agenda. peter thank you. colleagues, either any changes to the feathery 9th 2016 regular board meeting minutes? seeing none,, is their motion to approve those minutes? moved and seconded. collies can we take those meeting minutes without objection? without objection those minutes will pass after public comments. >>[gavel] >> madam clerk, please read the consent agenda >> items one through 7 are on consent is considered routine. whenever the object server and item that considered separately >> seen no names on the roster, adam clark please call the roll >> on items 1-7 supervisor avalos aye, breed aye, campos aye, cohen aye, farrell aye, the camp absent among mar aye, the peskin aye, tang aye, wiener aye, yee aye there are 10 aye >> these items are fat pass any adopted unanimously >>[gavel] >> madam clerk, please will to item number 8 >> item 8 resolution to approve the agreement doing business as san francisco auto return for towing storage and disposal of abandon and illegally parked vehicle

commissioner avalos? >> i am appreciative of the work that they have done, and especially the work on the reliability and that is significant and that the thing that the public has really called about and is concerned about is the need to reliable and so the focus is really good and i am also wondering what the focus will be on capitol, and the facilities and structures that are put in place that will make the experience of the riders, and the transit users that are and we have a lot of situations in places like balboa park, station areas and other places that don't work for us. that area needs attention especially in parts of the san francisco that take up the great chunk of the capitol dollars. >> dually noted. we are as you are well aware, investing in those muni facilities and the mant nens facilities at the, and to bring it to a lesser extent at the moment across the street in the gene va yard but we certainly have a long way to go in that regard and looking across. the agency has just entered into a

supervisor avalos, do you want to join us?>>[applause] >> thank you for your hard work and congratulations. that was the last of our 2:30 pm commendations. colleagues, who were turned for regular agenda. beginning with item number 20 >> item 20 resolution to receive and approve an annual reports that broadway benefit district for fiscal year 2014-15. >> will call vote >> on item 20 supervisor yee aye, avalos aye, breed aye, avalos aye, cohen aye, farrell aye, kim aye, mar aye, peskin aye, tang aye, wiener aye. there are 11 aye >> the resolution is adopted unanimously >>[gavel] >> item 21 >> item 21 and ordinance 2 men the planning code to allow the existing bar on the ground floor the upper market street input commercial transit district expand to the 2nd floor under specified circumstances with a conditional use authorization tool from the claimed by ms. ceqa determination and make the other findings. >> colleagues, tickets item same house, same call be without the ordinance passes unanimously on the first reading >>[gavel] >

seeing none public comrnt is closed. >> on the consent calendar, avalos, aye. commissioner cohen, aye. commissioner farrell, absent. commissioner peskin, aye. commissioner tang aye. the consent calendar passes. >> recommend appointment of 2 members to the citizen advisory committee. this is a action item, we have mike [inaudible] >> the transportation authority advisory committee has 11 members suving a 2 year term. the plans and programs committee the board appoint to fill any vacancy. the transs portation thoert staff or caa make recommendation ons the appointment and applicants must be san francisco residence and appear before the committee once. attachment one shows information about currents committee member jz the list of applicants for vacant positions is attachment 2. detailed application materials can be found in the enclosure. the vac aenss are a result of resignation of wells witney and mr. lar son. mr. lar son is seeking reappoint: there are 26 applicant you can consider and with that i can take any questions. >> thank you, i don't see any questions

consideration or would have an impact on the order of 3, 3 and a half million dollars supervisor avalos spoke to the sentiment behind this and one we do support and that i recommend you approve the rest of the information is really for your background this is responsive for things you've asked us to provide in terms of information on the expenditure side i expanded the list to include all the things that the divisions of the agency has suggested as well as on slide 25 a list of - i'm sorry on slide 26 a list of potential uses of one time part of funds balance to, of course, stay above the minimum but this is based the priorities when we met in january so things there are there for your consideration on the capital does the only thing to make reprehensive on slide 29 we were previously showing somewhat of a decrease within the encourage proposals it is flat was we're now as shown on slide thirty we're incorporating a assumption we'll have the revenues recommended by the mayors task force specifically the state of california increase and a restoration of the vehicle licenses up to 2 perce

. >> item 1, roll call, commissioner avalos, present. commissioner breed, present. commissioner campos, present. commissioner cohen, present. commissioner farrell, absent. commissioner kim, absent. commissioner mar, absent. commissioner peskin, present. commissioner tang, absent. commissioner wiener, present. commissioner yee, present. we have quorum >> okay, i want to thank sfgtv for broadcasting todays meeting, leo [inaudible] and also colleagues supervisor farrell has asked to be excused in adivision supervisor kim is ill and unable to attend so can i have a motion to excuse commissioner farrell and commissioner kim? motion by commissioner cohen, seconded by commissioner compose and do wree need roll call on that or take that without objection. >> take without objection. item number 2 >> chairs report. this is a information item. >> colleagues we have two pieces of good news to share. first i like to congratulate cal trans and transportation authority with public and private sector partners for winning the california transportation award. we had the opening of th

supervisor avalos. >> thank you. ms. scott it's been ten years since i have known you and worked with you. you were part of helping to draft violence prevention set aside that we passed at the board of supervisors 2006, before i was on the board. actually i think it was the only set aside that supervisor peskin supported was that one. so that wasn't easy to get his moment no. >> but i think the exampleful of the bleeding that has been going on in our communitis and in yours in particular. in '95 we had scores of homicides in the western edition and '96 again and really showed that we needed to do something. the answer wasn't -- we wanted to have effective law enforcement, but the answer wasn't more police officers, but really trying to get at the root causes. part of it, as well as the mental health services and mutual support that helps familis to bear the heavy burden of losing loved ones to violence. and that is what you brought together and i just want to thank you for giving your heart the way you have. because

>> no. >> yee no. >> supervisor avalos. >> aye. >> avalos aye. >> there are seven ayes and three nos with supervisors tang, wiener and yee in the dissent. >> so this item needs eight votes to pass. >> rescind the vote. >> unfortunately it fails. [ gavel ] >> supervisor kim? >> madam clerk, is it possible you said there is an opportunity to rescind the vote and send it to committee? >> >> once the vote is rescinded a number of things can happen to the item. >> i will make a motion to rescind the vote. >> supervisor kim has made what she famously does a motion to rescind the vote and it was seconded by supervisor cohen. colleagues can we take that out objection? without objection the vote has been rescinded >> supervisor kim. >> i am going to make the motion to send this to committee >> it goes to committee, let's move to item 26 madam president at this point we would need a second and majority. >> seconded by supervisor campos. colleagues can we take that out objection? without objection this item will go to committee. item 26, please. >> item 26 is a resolution to urge the california

. >> item 1, roll call, commissioner avalos, present. commissioner breed, present. commissioner campos, present. commissioner cohen, present. commissioner farrell, absent. commissioner kim, absent. commissioner mar, absent. commissioner peskin, present. commissioner tang, absent. commissioner wiener, present. commissioner yee, present. we have quorum >> okay, i want to thank sfgtv for broadcasting todays meeting, leo [inaudible] and also colleagues supervisor farrell has asked to be excused in adivision supervisor kim is ill and unable to attend so can i have a motion to excuse commissioner farrell and commissioner kim? motion by commissioner cohen, seconded by commissioner compose and do wree need roll call on that or take that without objection. >> take without objection. item number 2 >> chairs report. this is a information item. >> colleagues we have two pieces of good news to share. first i like to congratulate cal trans and transportation authority with public and private sector partners for winning the california transportation award. we had the opening of th

supervisor avalos, to have a continuance >> thank you.supervisor kim >> supervisor peskin made this point for me but i want to reiterate it's not a question about charging our drivers more were charging on the unique writers more. it's not an either. designer transit first policy either. it's really a question about what is the appropriate and fair way to generate revenue to pay for government services like muni. is it progressive taxation we pick is a flat progressive healthy in exorbitant penalty which disproportionately impacts poor and working-class families who have to make a decision again between paying for rent them a pain for food, and getting the car they need and depend on out of the tow-away law. i would even surmise that those that have higher incomes are more likely to star their cars in parking lots and garages and therefore may not be as impacted by tow-away signs on our streets as well. so, if we want to look at making up for the revenue loss, i support that. in fact, 6 members of this board said we want our developers to

supervisor avalos, do you want to join us?r your hard work and congratulations. that was the last of our 2:30 pm commendations. colleagues, who were turned for regular agenda. beginning with item number 20 >> item 20 resolution to receive and approve an annual reports that broadway benefit district for fiscal year 2014-15. >> will call vote >> on item 20 supervisor yee aye, avalos aye, breed aye, avalos aye, cohen aye, farrell aye, kim aye, mar aye, peskin aye, tang aye, wiener aye. there are 11 aye >> the resolution is adopted unanimously >>[gavel] >> item 21 >> item 21 and ordinance 2 men the planning code to allow the existing bar on the ground floor the upper market street input commercial transit district expand to the 2nd floor under specified circumstances with a conditional use authorization tool from the claimed by ms. ceqa determination and make the other findings. >> colleagues, tickets item same house, same call be without the ordinance passes unanimously on the first reading >>[gavel] >> next item >> item 22 one o

commissioner avalos. >> thank you, just a question on the daly city stop for the 14 r. areioaware of what the actual -what people are paying to take muni to daly city bart and take daly city bart downtown? is there a discount because they come on muni for that? >> i'm not sure how that workwise the transfer. >> just trying to remember what the deal was on that, so that's okay. just the extension of the 14 to daly city bart helped a lot of residents in my district t is the quickest route to get downtown so i support the project. >> great. thank you very much. seeing no other questions or comments we'll open up item 7 to public comment. any members? seeing none public comment is closed. if we can have a motion on that. >> motion to approve. >> thank you motion by commissioner avlease and seconded by commissioner cohen and take that without objection. item aithd, please >> item 8 rail capacity strategy update. this is information item >> we have graham from sfmta. >> good morning commissioner, graham [inaudible] thank you to tuque tauc about the work we are doing here. it

i want to thank supervisor avalos and of course community members. i know his staff has worked with us for so long. i do have hesitations about supporting this item today not because i do not support the project. i want to be very clear i do, but i do not like it in the form of a supplemental. as i've said on many other issues before us as well, when it come before us in this form. before i became a supervisor, stopping my predecessor predecessor on the committee i've seen funding for the geneva car born. we've always supported it our office could all continue to do to is a member of the budget committee as well but again in the form of a supplemental is something that i do not feel appropriate at this time. again, i have not seen from art even our mayor's budget office in unwillingness to fund this particular proposal. i would say that there have been many arguments made about lack of attention to certain districts. i can make that same argument for the outer sunset did in fact, >> i would agree with you >> thank you. i spent years tried to secure j

i know that supervisor avalos requested april april 4th. >> right. >> i've not spoken and today i don't know if this is a possibility to do that on april 11th instead of april 4th. >> i don't know the answer to that question madam clerk. >> i'll suggest to the call of the chair. >> we will continue to the call of the chair and check with supervisor avalos is there a motion for that to continue to the call of the chair motion carries madam clerk, is there any additional business to come before this body? >> no madam clerk, any other business before this committee? mshz /* /-. >> no. >> thank you very much this meeting is n francisco historic preservation commission regular hearing for wednesday march 16, 2016. i would like to remind members of the public that the commission does not tolerate disruption or out birches of any kind. please silence all cell phones that may go off and when speaking to the commission please state your name for the record. i will take roll. commission president president. >> here. >> commissioner high land. >> yes. >> commissioner hasz. >> yes. >> commissioner

on roll call commissioner avalos commissioners, any questions or comments? commissioner crews commissioner mar mr. chair we have quorum madam clerk. >> approval the pins from the december 11th with the publicity safety and neighborhood committee and colleagues, any questions or comments any member of the public want to comment seeing none, public comment is closed. and if we have a motion to approve the minutes motion doesn't chair mar and second is he commissioner campos we'll take that without objection. >> election of the chairperson and vice chair person for 2016. >> okay. well, let's role the today is i'm open to being continuing as chair and but willing to support other people as well i'll make a motion to nominate start with the chair position and kc vice chair i'll like to support xhukz to continue but i think we're open for a chair right now so. >> mr. chair i'd like to nominee commissioner avalos so once again serve as chair and my intention to then substantially renominate commissioner crews. >> second. >> okay. thank you and i really appreciate m

i want to thank supervisor avalos and of course community members. i know his staff has worked with us for so long. i do have hesitations about supporting this item today not because i do not support the project. i want to be very clear i do, but i do not like it in the form of a supplemental. as i've said on many other issues before us as well, when it come before us in this form. before i became a supervisor, stopping my predecessor predecessor on the committee i've seen funding for the geneva car born. we've always supported it our office could all continue to do to is a member of the budget committee as well but again in the form of a supplemental is something that i do not feel appropriate at this time. again, i have not seen from art even our mayor's budget office in unwillingness to fund this particular proposal. i would say that there have been many arguments made about lack of attention to certain districts. i can make that same argument for the outer sunset did in fact, >> i would agree with you >> thank you. i spent years tried to secure j

dick supervisor avalos >> i want to recognize the budget committee further work on this measure.since the budget committee liberated we also had a hearing that was looking at fees and court fees and how they were impacting the working people. through that, we heard a lot about the towing fee and how much difficult it is for our people who are low income were struggling economically to be able to pay for the fee. how the inability to pay for the fee could be 2 people losing their vehicles can not having the ability to get to work, which often is beyond public transportation, and putting them in i cycle with area are actually not able to escape poverty poor economic distress. so, idea makes a lot of sense that we look at paring back these fees. to actually make it easier for everyone to survive in san francisco during our economic crisis. in 2009-2010, the board of supervisors had all the fees of the city before street i recall in budget committee that those years having pages and pages of these that were ramped up in both years. i don't think we have actually is a city recovered a

commissioner avalos? >> i am appreciative of the work that they have done, and especially the work on the reliability and that is significant and that the thing that the public has really called about and is concerned about is the need to reliable and so the focus is really good and i am also wondering what the focus will be on capitol, and the facilities and structures that are put in place that will make the experience of the riders, and the transit users that are and we have a lot of situations in places like balboa park, station areas and other places that don't work for us. that area needs attention especially in parts of the san francisco that take up the great chunk of the capitol dollars. >> dually noted. we are as you are well aware, investing in those muni facilities and the mant nens facilities at the, and to bring it to a lesser extent at the moment across the street in the gene va yard but we certainly have a long way to go in that regard and looking across. the agency has just entered into a

er >> okay, this item was sponsored by supervisor avalos, so i would like to turn it over to him. er >> thank you, chair farrell and i want to appreciate the work of the budget committee to hear this item and also for all the previous work that the board of supervisors has done for the geneva car barn and the newest version or newbesting building that we're trying to restore in district 11 are the emergency hospital on onondaga and the home and health site on onondaga and elevate, these latitude buildings are two public buildings under the department of public health jurisdiction that had been empty, i believe it's been around 7 years that they've both been empty, they've been sources of blight fwl the neighborhood and just along the corner of alamani and onondaga, there have been homeless encampments there on the build, there's been people squatting inside the building as of last year, the corner building and it's also a part of the commercial corridor in district 11 that we're trying desperate toy to bring up to viability and economic viability, we've made some really good impro

>> no. >> yee no. >> supervisor avalos. >> aye. >> avalos aye. >> there are seven ayes and three nos with supervisors tang, wiener and yee in the dissent. >> so this item needs eight votes to pass. >> rescind the vote. >> unfortunately it fails. [ gavel ] >> supervisor kim? >> madam clerk, is it possible you said there is an opportunity to rescind the vote and send it to committee? >> >> once the vote is rescinded a number of things can happen to the item. >> i will make a motion to rescind the vote. >> supervisor kim has made what she famously does a motion to rescind the vote and it was seconded by supervisor cohen. colleagues can we take that out objection? without objection the vote has been rescinded >> supervisor kim. >> i am going to make the motion to send this to committee >> it goes to committee, let's move to item 26 madam president at this point we would need a second and majority. >> seconded by supervisor campos. colleagues can we take that out objection? without objection this item will go to committee. item 26, please. >> item 26 is a resolution to urge the california

i want to thank supervisor avalos and of course community members. i know his staff has worked with us for so long. i do have hesitations about supporting this item today not because i do not support the project. i want to be very clear i do, but i do not like it in the form of a supplemental. as i've said on many other issues before us as well, when it come before us in this form. before i became a supervisor, stopping my predecessor predecessor on the committee i've seen funding for the geneva car born. we've always supported it our office could all continue to do to is a member of the budget committee as well but again in the form of a supplemental is something that i do not feel appropriate at this time. again, i have not seen from art even our mayor's budget office in unwillingness to fund this particular proposal. i would say that there have been many arguments made about lack of attention to certain districts. i can make that same argument for the outer sunset did in fact, >> i would agree with you >> thank you. i spent years tried to secure j

seeing none public comrnt is closed. >> on the consent calendar, avalos, aye.missioner cohen, aye. commissioner farrell, absent. commissioner peskin, aye. commissioner tang aye. the consent calendar passes. >> recommend appointment of 2 members to the citizen advisory committee. this is a action item, we have mike [inaudible] >> the transportation authority advisory committee has 11 members suving a 2 year term. the plans and programs committee the board appoint to fill any vacancy. the transs portation thoert staff or caa make recommendation ons the appointment and applicants must be san francisco residence and appear before the committee once. attachment one shows information about currents committee member jz the list of applicants for vacant positions is attachment 2. detailed application materials can be found in the enclosure. the vac aenss are a result of resignation of wells witney and mr. lar son. mr. lar son is seeking reappoint: there are 26 applicant you can consider and with that i can take any questions. >> thank you, i don't see any questions her

. >> next on the agenda was the second duplicated file for supervisor avalos ordinance which requires the conditional use authorization for the removal of any unit the city, supervisor avalos and i'm sorry in was continued to the call of the chair supervisor avalos and supervisor wiener will be working on amendments that require back to the planning commission for our review and recommendation also on monday supported by supervisor wiener own student housing several educational institution presented usf and sf state over the several months the supervisor has been working with the institutions on the need and plans for providing student housing the departments presentation staff discussed the need for student housing currently colleges provide on 9 thousand beds for the 80 thousand students the city and staff provided the historical that is two significant piece of legislation one in 2010 and one in 2012 both encourage the student housing and the protection of existing housing from conversion to student housing. >> staff provided an overview of eastern housing since 2010 and staffs clu

it moved to another job and shannon ferguson they made a difference i'd like to thank supervisor avalossupervisor avalos for their staff and the history center your waving aware from an earlier preservatintatio i'll hit on the points i think that we'll use the 3 minutes effective and the question when does the alamany integer hospital will represent and to recognize historically and the 80 steps there was an obligation to provide heathlth d safety with a significant design times by a persistent with getting adequate fund that never stopped the emergency hospital or the public health building a relationship with the community if you were raised in town ever itself knew where the emergency hospital were tuyou were taken there i got there 3 times the grattan elementary school change the model for providing the health care services whether the effort in 1978 to represent the possibility of closing the integer hospital the communities of outer mission the ex-wife's at the history stiffer and i kn that - the enterimergency hospis still closed some communicated services on site the last i was