let's bring in our legal guys, avery freeman joining us from cleveland, and richard herman, a new yorkriminal defense attorney and law professor. good to see you as well. this is an extraordinary case. wondering if this is kind of precedence setting. avery, you first, we're talking about christmas 2007 this sdent takes place. linda and ray and denise and george are all in a vehicle teeth. they were rear ended. no one is disputing the fact there. they all died either immediately or over time. he pled guilty to speeding, the dui, got 12 years in prison, now he's suing the estate for pain and suffering. is this precedence setting? avery? >> i don't -- i don't think it is. it's a disturbing case, obviously, fredricka. but it involved a felon convicted of certain crimes who is now bringing a civil action. and he's introducing his case with a reconstruction, accident reconstruction expert, trying to say that it was the victim's fault. let me tell you something, he has been on the stand, we heard from him yesterday. and the truth is that his credibility has crumbled all over the place. he's n