he made a statement to never again be another operation in baluchistan. he was sending with i guess the chief minister, but what was interesting to me about that he was at the migration of a government technological institute. the last time he was there i think he was and not doing a marble corn plant. i think this question that moeed raises is, you know, as clinical scientist we would all like the civilian government in charge of the debugger. but is the army right now the best institution within pakistan to be doing some of these things, be helping with marble development or education or the frontier. is a which is the most effective organization? my second question presidents i met with a senior politician. i was surprised just her opinion was in the united states is not complete civilian control of the caa. there's the cia running amok in pakistan and the u.s. did have complete control which i didn't think was to but is that a perception that is very prominent in pakistan or not? >> thank you. spoke -- [inaudible] bruce riedel has written a column in

provincial subject which means it is ultimately inspector general of police in a province, punjab or baluchistan. he's not responsible to the frontier in the center. the chief of police of a province responds to the chief executive, elected chief executive of a province, so that is one. the second is in between police and, on the other side, armed forces. in between the paramilitary forces, frontier rangers. here, yes, they respond according to the constitution directly, they respond and are responsible and accountable to ministry of interior. but, in effect, they are led by senior serving army officers, major generals. though they technically, legally respond to the minister for interior or to respective chief executives in certain circumstances, but the in terms of the job requirements, in terms of their carriers prospects, in terms of their decorum, in terms of the rules of enagement they respond in many ways to the army chief or the military leadership because, after all, their postings as score commanders are dependent on the military chief. so this is paramilitary force which is somewhere