kids and 20 grandchildren so they are very proud people close ups of celebrities such as barack obama hillary clinton and uncle americal cemented chavez right now and. each owes the same big head style as he calls it for his series on survivors. the faces speak for themselves. show that took these photos in jerusalem the atmosphere at the shoot was relaxed. he completed the 75 portraits in just 10 days that's not much time but time enough for moving encounters and incredible stories the russians liberated the camp and i'm like mark. it may by any chance in this picture i had a photograph of me from a newspaper article and show the pictures famous picture of the children standing behind this wired friends and she's like oh yeah that's me and that's my sister motto wise herself the historian is concerned that the stories of survival not be forgotten especially in the face of resurgent anti semitism varian oriya works for yad vashem israel's holocaust remembrance center which co-sponsored the portrait project. when we try to get to fly then to symmetry zaman the denial of all of course we are doing in t

kids and 20 grandchildren so they're very proud people close ups of celebrities such as barack obama hillary clinton and uncle a magical cemented show that's renowned. he chose the same big head style as he calls it for his series on survivors. the faces speak for themselves. charlotte took these photos in jerusalem the atmosphere at the shoot was relaxed. he completed the 75 portraits in just 10 days that's not much time but time enough for moving encounters and incredible stories the russians liberated the camp and i'm like mark. i it may by any chance in this picture i had a photograph of me from a newspaper article and saw the pictures famous picture of the children standing behind this wired friends and she's like oh yeah that's me and that's my sister motto wise herself a historian is concerned that the stories of survival not be forgotten especially in the face of resurgent anti semitism vivian oriya works for you advice sham israel's holocaust remembrance center which co-sponsored the portrait project. when we try to get to fly there and the symmetry is in when the denial of all of course th

grandchildren 5 kids and 20 grams or so they're very proud people close ups of celebrities such as barack obama hillary clinton and uncle americal cemented shadows renowned. each owes the same big head style as he calls it for his series on survivors. the faces speak for themselves. charlotte took these photos in jerusalem the atmosphere at the shoot was relaxed. he completed the 75 portraits in just 10 days that's not much time but time enough for moving encounters and incredible stories the russians liberated the camp and i'm like mark. i may by any chance in this picture i had a photograph with me from a newspaper article and saw the pictures famous picture of the children standing behind this wired friends and she's like oh yeah that's me and that's my sister moto wise herself a historian is concerned that the stories of survival not before go. isn't especially in the face of resurgent anti semitism vivian oriya works for yad vashem israel's holocaust remembrance center which co-sponsored the portrait project. when we try to get to fly then to symmetries him in the denial fall of course we will doing it bu

with me, michael starr hopkins, a democratic strategist who worked on the campaigns of barack obama, hillary clinton and john kel lane any. this news coming days before the next big democratic debate. we know snoenator booker was no going to be on the debate stage. what do we know now? >> you're right about the timing of this. we're in iowa, a state where cory booker spent a lot of time campaigning as a candidate. the debate stage was going to be critical, especially with the impeachment trial looming, that would take the five senators, now four senators now in the race, out of iowa and put them in washington, d.c. for the trial. all of that factored in. craig, we often talk about the money that's needed, the lifeblood of these campaigns, your control room can pull up on the screen a piece of this message from cory booker where he says in a media post they've reached the point where they 23450ed more money to scale their campaign and they don't have it now, but that given not being on the debate stage tomorrow night and not being able to be out on the campaign trail during the impeachment trial, tha

that goes all the way back to al gore, and john kerry, barack obama, hillary clinton. obama exceeded in winning the white house. but it's very, very important, the first win here. we are following that and what's happening at the big old selloff. a lot entered david with impeachment or any of that but having to do with the coronavirus in the slowdown following up, american airlines, and united airlines and delta saying to avoid the area altogether. they are cutting back is not eliminating flights to the region and giving people a few days to get the stuff together. if they want to get out of the region. more on that in a minute. right now to the iowa caucuses. and what is the stake for the candidates and what's at stake for the state itself. let's get hilary vaughn into this, joining us also in des moines. >> joe biden is reminding voters that the biggest difference between himself and the current iowa front-runner bernie sanders is he is a democrat and sanders is not. that is plain into the iowa caucus night strategy reminding caucus goers that he wants moderates to u

in january of 2008 it endorsed hillary clinton over barack obama. in 2016 hillary clinton won the vast majority of newspaper endorsements including several traditional conservative morning papers like "the dallas morning news" and "the arizona republic" which hadn't gone for a democrat in 126 years. "the times" endorsed hillary unsurprising but also ran an anti-endorsement titled why donald trump should not be president. all of this seems to have backfired alienating trump supporters and allowing trump to paint himself as the victim of media bias. so will a "times" endorsement move the needle or might it color the paper's view. go to my website smerconish.com. should newspapers make political endorsements? joining me now, an editor from a paper deciding not to endorse any candidates, david haines of "the milwaukee sentinel." >> thanks for having me. we decided in 2012 after a very contentious recall involving governor scott walker to take a look at our endorsements. at the time when we looked at it we just didn't feel like we were having impact. and

now, democratic debate coach, bob barnett, who worked on 10 debate campaigns including barack obama and hillary clintonat glad to have you with us. >> good evening. glad i'm not standing out in the snow like jeff. >> we put you in a nice warm studio. >> let's start with joe biden. i think he has to have another strong error-free performance, try to demonstrate as he's been trying to demonstrate he's man of deep experience for eight years in the white house, many years in the senate and with foreign policy coming to the forefront over the last week, it gives him, i think, a great advantage. i think bernie sanders is making a mistake. he has clearly decided he wants to go after joe biden on a vote from 20 years ago, and he wants to go after elizabeth warren, amazingly to me, by trying to say she's an elitist progressive. i went through the '16 election with hillary clinton and actually played bernie in all nine debates. i know him well. i feel if he doesn't get it we will have the same thing in '16, an absence of support and encouragement to his supporters which could be extremely harmful as i think it w

whether it's obsession for barack obama or hillary clinton or just being erratic because of the people he has around him as well. it's all self serving. and now we're not safer. we're less safe. >> i just want to ask you about a report in the "wall street journal" that they report trump, after the strike told associates he was under pressure to deal with soleimani from gop senators he views as important supporters in his upcoming impeachment trial in the senate. that's being reported for the "wall street journal." he was whipping votes for his impeachment trial, so he took out the number two in iran? >> that story was pretty shocking when i read it this morning. it's all about politics, about winning. he's been obsessed with impeachment for the last several weeks, frustrated by nancy pelosi. i think he's been told by allies he needs keep his republican flank in line because we already started to hear from susan collins and others they do want to hear from witnesses now. i think it shows how totally focussed he is on his own political survival. >> not reassuring at all. i'm sure it's ac

would want to sign it and said make it big and bold enough and take the time to do it barack obama and hillary clinton with a sharpie and they did it really quickly and didn't pay much attention because they were both ready to leave. he was becoming president i have more time on my hands. [laughter] so i filled it in and the grandchildren all ran their fingers over it. >> is what we have been telling them their entire life don't carve the furniture. [laughter] exactly what they're not allowed to do. >> then jackie said this feels great. >> but you tell the story waited for the grandchildren to be around and then dedicated the book is my mother. >> but so talk about that. >> you get more serious about your job and what you see i am rarely fearful or discouraged i can't help of the direction we go for four more years. i don't want my kids and grandkids to have to deal with that so that makes us more serious of our task at hand. i turn 67 yesterday. [applause] i just feel lucky to be relevant at the age i met. in this book grounded me more because i realized it made me more serious the gravitas of the jo

. >>> under the leadership of barack obama and hillary clinton the generals have been reduced to rubblee been reduced to a point where it's embarrassing for our country. >> i know more about isis than the generals do. believe me. >> they don't know much, because they're not winning, that i can tell you. >> welcome back to "hardball". that was donald trump talking about the top military leaders. in private his tirade against them went further once he won the presidency calling top generals losers to their faces. that was the word he used. that's according to an upcoming book by washington post reporters. it's called "a very stable genius". the book is out, i believe. a new excerpt released in the washington post describes the president lashing out during a pentagon meeting in the summer of 2017. quote, you're all losers, trump said. you don't know how to win anymore. he added i wouldn't go to war with you people and then referred to them as a bunch of dopes and babies. these are generals he's talking to. i'm joined by ted from california. a former active duty office who serves as a membe

hillary clinton would be a third term or barack obama , the power would continue. but donald trump vowed to drain the swamp. they do have a sibling one - - a malignant force. they did not want to be drained. power in washington is like crack cocaine. once you get on and have it you don't want to give it up and you will do anything to stop someone who will take her power away from you. so that is how the russia hoax began. that is the witchhunt because these people saw donald trump as a threat to themselves what they love of power and the end justifies the land - - any means even lawlessness. >> you wrote two books on this tragedy it doesn't end. >> i and the book. >> you better be taking good notes. >> i'm not inclined to write another book but the only cure for a lie is a truth the only remedy for lawlessness is justice. i end with that then say a reckoning awaits. so we wait. i follow very carefully i continue to write columns on the subject matter. so we will wait and see i am as curious as the american public to see whether or not people will be held accountabl

the imminent threat that led barack obama and hillary clinton and others to say that we needed to topple the gadhafi regime had nothing do with america. it was an imminent threat of what we said was going to be an imminent genocide of libyan rebels by moammar gadhafi and we were not going to allow that genocide to happen on our watch. and nancy pelosi, who is opposing this and rightly so, where was she in 2011? there was no imminent threat. there is no consistent application of this congressional authority. it's a shame. there should be. the constitution put this in congress's hands for a reason. we're operating under a system of authorizations of use of military force written into law in 2001. we're drone striking people all over the planet and there's not really consistent congressional opposition to it and that's a damn shame. >> nikki haley last night i'm sure you saw this, former u.n. ambassador to the united nations in the trump administration. this is what she said last night about the fallout and criticism of the strike. >> you're not hearing any of the gulf members, you're not h

and it has lasted this long and thinking of the vitriol of barack obama and hillary clinton and it doeshe women voters 19 days before iowa. >> and the progressives that i am hearing from onndhe presiden coming as the impeachment trial is set to begin. stay with us. it's the next one. you always drive this slow? how did you make someone i love? that must be why you're always so late. i do not speed. and that's saving me cash with drivewise. my son, he did say that you were the safe option. and that's the nicest thing you ever said to me. so get allstate. stop bossing. where good drivers save 40% for avoiding mayhem, like me. this is my son's favorite color, you should try it. [mayhem] you always drive like an old lady? [tina] you're an old lady. things you can do with schwab: you can earn more when you invest your cash. ♪ you can get a satisfaction guarantee. ♪ you can also wonder why our competitors don't offer that. schwab, a modern approach to wealth management. >>> in our politics lead today, house managers, and the how much impeachment managers are moments away from the senate decid

michael worked on the campaigns of barack obama and hillary clinton and matt welch.s a saying in politics nothing is more valuable than the candidate's time. how critical do you think it is for those four senators not to be in iowa or new hampshire, at least largely not there? >> certainly not helpful. a lot of them are sending surrogates, but since there's such an undecided field in iowa, i don't think surrogates will help them. i think it will be a boone to joe biden and mayor pete in the ability to meet new voters, talk to new voters. at the end of the day, i don't think it makes a difference. >> do you agree, matt, there's an argument to be made with all of the country's attention on impeachment, maybe i am making an assumption that isn't actually so, but could this in fact maybe benefit those senators? >> cannot benefit amy klobuchar. she's from the midwest, i don't know if you heard this, she needs to get a good result in iowa. >> she also has been somebody who you hear voters in iowa say i wasn't thinking about her, but when i went to her event, when i met her

right now back in '08 hillary clinton was actually ahead of barack obama with black voters in much ofountry and folks had to get to know barack obama now and any poll after south carolina to this day hillary clinton would not be ahead of barack obama. >> right. >> so to the extent though that we are not just looking at the static number of how many people are for biden because maybe they believe he's best able to beat trump or maybe they believe that white folks more likely to vote for a biden and who motivates people to the polls, who will expand the base? who will reach young black people to turn out to the polls? it can't just be about the democrats getting 95% of the black vote. it is about how many black people turn out out of all of the folks that get to the 90% and not just the number of people but the percentage that show up to vote but expanding the base of people and right now looking at the biden rallies, the number of people that are making individual contributions to joe biden, he doesn't seem to have the type of enthusiasm and motivation. he is someone that we have had a

. >> this is just the way the barack obama observe and hillary clinton relationship got testy and theyad to be picked at the box office. i think that's what will happen here. >> they were going to be civilized and eventually they were going to have to distinguish their policies because they see eye to eye on so many different issues. but now we see this personality clash come out and iowa. >> don't worry, you're likable enough. >>> up next, evelyn yang's powerful me too story and why she's sharing it now. only pay for what you need. ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ ...take the personal assessment i love the new myww program, because it's tailored to you! and get matched with a proven weight loss plan. find out which customized plan can make losing weight easier for you! myww join for free and get two months free! that's why it's important to be prepared for anything life brings. at fidelity, we'll help you build a clear plan for retirement. one that covers health care costs, taxes, and any other uncertainties while still giving you the flexibility to make changes to your plan as

hillary clinton. barack obama. same kind of conversation. since iraq is now back in the conversation, we are sort of seeing again some of this conversation about some aspects of having more, quote, purity in the democratic party. but it hasn't usually been in this generation or two of the democratic party the drive of the democratic party. but it's been much more the case with regards to the republican party. that was also the reading in terms of the blum article with regard to the tea party. how did the tea party operate in terms of an insurgent movement inside the republican party and how did it impact, in fact, how the republican party operates? anybody read that article and have an answer for me? what do you know about the tea party? we don't hear the term as much as we used to. >> during mcauliffe's election they supported only tea party candidates which caused the republican establishment to vote for the democratic candidate, and they considered it to be a success for the tea party because they were able to exert their influence. even

barack obama, john edwards, and hillary clinton. they were very close.e are going to watch some video of ultimately president obama, but then candidate obama claiming victory and hillary clinton's concession in iowa that your. >> thank you, iowa. they said this day would never come. they said our sites were set too high. they said this country was too divided. two disillusioned to ever come together around a common purpose. night atis january this defining moment in history, you have done what the senate said we couldn't do. this is a great night for democrats. we have seen an unprecedented turnout here in iowa and that is good news because today, we are sending a clear message that we are going to have change and that change will be a democratic president in the white house in 2009. host: david? what a campaign that was. first african-american with a serious chance of winning, first woman with a serious chance of winning. there a tough for democrats to sort out. figure johnrismatic edwards was involved in. big question, can a woman win? can an african-a

hillary clinton would have been a third term of barack obama, their power would continue, donald trump vowed to drain the swamp. they are the swamp, a malignant force, they didn't want to be drained. power in washington is like crack cocaine. once you get on it and have it you will do anything to stop someone who is going to take power away. that is how the russia hoax began, that is how it began the witchhunt, these people saw donald trump has a threat to themselves and what they loved, power, the end justified the means, even lawless means. >> host: this whole tragedy since 2016, you have to end your book. the whole idea is keep going. the journal every day - got to be taking good notes. >> guest: i'm not inclined to write another book. the only cure for a lie is the truth and the only remedy for lawlessness is justice. i end with that and say a reckoning awaits and so we wait. i follow it very carefully. i continue to write columns on the subject matter. we will wait and see. i am as curious as the american public is, whether people will be held accountable. nobody is below the law

barack obama is not president anymore. come on. we can say it together. barack obama is not -- president anymore. he's not the president anymore. hillary clinton was never the president. barack obama is not the president anymore. barack obama has been out of office for nearly three years. president trump owns this crisis. another one of his own making. but there are people wondering out loud about the timing of all of this. elizabeth warren telling jake tapper this. >> next week the president of the united states could be facing an impeachment trial in the senate. we know he's deeply upset about that. and i think people are reasonably asking, why this moment? why does he pick now to take this highly inflammatory, highly dangerous action that moves us closer to war? >> is it fair to question the motives of a commander in chief? like that. when it comes to life or death decisions that could lead to war. well, someone else once thought so, and that someone is donald j. trump. tweeting in 2011, quote, in order to get elected, barack obama will start a war with iran. and then this, this is 2012. don't let obama play the iran card in order to start

a devout liberal, too extreme for even the obama administration under eric holder, donated thousands of dollars to hillary clinton barackbama, and in june, whoon is she supporting for president? $1,000 to that socialist, yes $94 trillion green deal $52 trillion elizabeth warren. she once appeared on a podcast called versus trump where she trashed conservatives. her insane rage against all things trump is so extreme, she refuses to even walk on the sama side of the street, not making this up, as the trump hotel. we have thep, videotape, let's o to it. >> i came in from the airport yesterday and i got off the bus from dulles down at the plaza, i walked and as i was walking past what used to be the old building and is now the trump hotel, i had to cross the street of course. >>are you staying there? >> god no. never. >> another great witness imagine carrying around that much hate, that much resentment and anger every day of your life. pretty sad, pretty pathetic. not good for the country, and frankly house democrats they look really, really stupid. i didn't think you could outdo the schiff show, but they did. that psychoti

look at our last two nominees, hillary clinton and barack obama. but there is something at the core level that democrats have to make sure that they are being reflective of the mass diversity of the party, which, you know, what karine said and what you said was correct wasn't represented in the debate. >> tom steyer talked about 12 minutes, 26 seconds tonight. the most talk time was actually elizabeth warren who i would argue is the only person and correct me if i'm wrong if you agree with this our political scientist friend jason, elizabeth warren was the only person who said anything memorable. it was hard for us as producers, we have a list here of sound bites we want to play. it was hard to come up with anything else other than elizabeth warren making that remark other than the two women on the stage having won all their races in the last ten years. >> joy, so the person who spoke most elizabeth warren and tom steyer, they're the perfect contrast. tom steyer is essentially the guy who spent a lot of money at the concert to sit up front. he spen

. >> you have been through a few primaries, and 2008 between hillary clinton and barack obama it went through june of last year, same in 2016. how long do you think the democratic primary will go? senator cardin: it is difficult to predict. first of all, we have many viable candidates in a way that different primaries and caucuses -- and the way different primaries and caucuses distribute delegates, it is unlikely one candidate will have an overwhelming lead on the delegate count early in the primary season. and then you have the uncertainty of democrats -- uncertainty of candidates that may not be on the early ballots, such as mayor bloomberg. nt may be able to be competitive in some later primaries -- and he may be able to be competitive in some of the later primaries that may be rich in delegates. so it is too early to predict how this nomination process will be concluded. we also have a different structure regarding superdelegates. that could also have an impact on the nominating process. that is a long answer to tell you that i have no idea when this will be determined. historica

hillary clinton did? >> it is important to remember you have to to ask people to vote for you. you cannot take it for granted. certainly in 2008 and 2012 we saw barack obama in wisconsin within 24 hours from when the polls closed. i think hillary clinton, a great candidate, was advised by her team that the metrics demonstrated that she did not need to come there and i think that that may have contributed as well. and you don't get votes for free. you have to spend money and convince people that your program is going to benefit them. in addition to that, we can't negate the impact of the russian influence campaign that targeted african-americans in particular. >> in wisconsin? >> in wisconsin, targeted them to suppress the vote. i personally received robocalls with a clear russian accent stating that if hillary clinton were to win, she would start world war iii. so i think the influence campaign was a factor as well. >> what are democrats doing in the state to prevent this from happening in 2020, whether it's voter suppression, et cetera, what is happening? voter turnout? >> we are fighting again with very well heeled operations that involve the judiciary,

especially when the candidate is not top candidate as it happens to barack obama when he won iowa in 2008 overtaking hillary clinton ok and we'll know more than 3 weeks when when we have those caucuses always under thanks so much from washington. well staying in the u.s. after 18 months of bruising economic conflict the u.s. and china are set to sign what they're calling phase one of a trade agreement that calls for the u.s. to ease some sanctions on china the u.s. has agreed to stop labeling china as a currency manipulator ahead of that signing said to take place in washington for its part beijing will step up its purchases of u.s. foreign products manufactured goods like aircraft and some services analysts are calling the deal modest but there are hopes it will prevent further escalation in the conflict that has slowed global economic growth and hurt american and chinese exports. all european union is pledging to dedicate a quarter of its budget to tackling climate change the europe investment plan will channel one trillion us trillion euros into climate protection over the next decade the aim is to reach carbon

sometimes it is the truth and sometimes not, but they did pick hillary clinton and barack obama so theyave a good track record. in terms of any surprises that the caucus might generate, what might we be expecting their? >> any outcome is going to be a surprise, because the race is so fluid right now. the top candidates are so close in the opinion polls, one minute is bernie sanders, the next it is elizabeth warren. the next, it is joe biden. the next, it is pete buttigieg, who was once the mayor of a small city. , or minnesotae senator amy klobuchar is trailing behind them. anyone of them could be the winner of the caucus. it is very unusual in that it is not a foregone conclusion. couple -- paul: a couple of left-wing candidates, when it comes to track record, where does iowa choosingterms of candidates away from the center? i would democrats tend to be a little more liberal than the rest of the country so that does bode well for bernie sanders and elizabeth warren. is a sense that bernie sanders and elizabeth warren might be what democrats want in their hearts but in their heads, they

." >> the leadership of barack obama and hillary clinton the generals reduced to rubble.it's embarrassing for our country. >> the president in 2016, less than a year later, he was reportedly calling some of his top generals, "dopes" and "babies." we'll bring in admiral james defreetis ahead on "morning joe." eetis ahead on "morning joe." robinhood believes now is the time to do money. without the commission fees and account minimums. so, you can start investing wherever you are - even on the bus. download now and get your first stock on us. robinhood. and aren't necessarily great for your teeth. the acid can actually wear away at the enamel which over time can cause sensitivity and a lot of people start to see their teeth turn yellow. i like to recommend pronamel to my patients to help them protect their teeth and keep the enamel strong. proof i can fight moderate to severe rheumatoid arthritis. proof i can fight psoriatic arthritis... ...with humira. proof of less joint pain... ...and clearer skin in psa. humira targets and blocks a source of inflammation that contribute

. >> consequential that very question in 2008, barack obama saw an opportunity with hillary clinton'sira war vote. i want to ask you, with the candidates versus donald trump, really their focus down the line, is foreign policy and national security an opportunity for them or a weakness? >> it is hard to say. look, i mean, if you ask me that question about the donald trump pre killing soleimani, i would say it is maybe a jump ball because his whole mo was to be noninterventionalist. but this action he took changed the ball game. and a lot of people who say that they supported him back in 2016 even especially among republican primary voters they said they did it because they were done with foreign wars, particularly in the middle east. now bernie sanders, who always felt that way, can take up that mantle in a way that others maybe can't. joe biden is saying, again in his op-ed, do it smartly, but he's not saying don't do it. he's saying have a strategy. >> understood. dana bash, good to have you. >> good to see you guys. >> talking about this debate and this race more than once in a cou

p9 bill clinton, barack obama, even hillary had a little bit of something not a lot but a little bit.and none of these people have sparked. jesse: they do not have the charisma. speaking about how is your dad doing? looks like he was out there hosting the lsu team and he was in great spirits. he was cracking jokes, they loved him out there. he took them to the oval office to take pictures. >> i have never been so proud of him when he walked in that stadium yet a hundred 20000 people chanting usa. that's what this country is about that will sum it up in a nutshell. jesse: the media won't show us that the show was a smattering of blue boos at a small baseball game. >> people love america, they love this country, they are proud we are back at military. they are proud that we are back in the economic world, 401ks have literally doubled in the entire world. we are the envy of the world people people envy that in that's exciting to see. jesse: and trump is getting a new haircut everybody, the ladies are going crazy. remember this. >> this is a very sad time for our country. this is no joy i

lou: well, and hillary clinton and barack obama, and the list goes on. well, david brock has been all over the place, so he's not even worth sitting here having a conversation. lou: why do you always say that when i'm having a perfectly lovely conversation with david bossie? >> i think he more than took care of it. [laughter] he's made his great contribution with the citizens, which is probably as important a decision as the court's ever made. so so give him the credit, we'll basically -- lou: as we should. >> as we should. lou: and your thoughts about this impeachment. >> it's the longest, most tedious day. i thought i was in, you know, at a graduate course and boring mathematics or something. the idea that these four members of the senate have to sit will there for 8, 10 hours of the day with only milk and water, that's all they can have on their desk -- lou: do you really believe that? >> the old senate i came in -- [laughter] lou: the old milk and water senate. [laughter] >> but i think the key thing here is the democrats say they have all the we've

expecting record turnout north of what barack obama and hillary clinton brought out in 2008.going to have huge impact. two, everyone says jump ball between the four candidates. no one surprised by any of the four winning. now, amy klobuchar, cory booker, andrew yang, people asking for all of the fall of 2019. would any of those candidates have a chance to have a late surge in iowa in january? if you believe the des moines register numbers and pretty much everybody believes this is the gold standard out here, it looks whoic because you got to have 15% of caucus attendees and every individual caucus has to make the qualification threshold before the second round where actual winners and loserser determined, looks like amy klobuchar at 6%, andrew yang at 5% none will clear the 16% threshold. could in a few individual caucus sites. after that first round of voting, klobuchar, booker, yang voters, free to align with some other candidate. what does that say? it says, first of all, everyone here takes bernie sanders really seriously. everyone theirs the sanders organization here ope

time a closed-door deposition, create add select committee like benghazi to go after barack obama and hillary clintonthis is the mantra that talked about. the american people's right to know the facts and truth about what their government is doing and now somehow are on the opposite side arguing the american people shouldn't know what's going on. it's okay to ignore documents. >> that's right. katty? >> an important point there that it was the ukrainian whose were actually flags this. an extraordinary situation where americans going around ukraine have transparency, no corruption and it's the ukrainian authorities who come back to giuliani and his cohorts and say, you mean you want us to have transparency and rule of law a bit like what you're doing to us right now? which is asking for a corrupt scheme? the irony was not lost on the ukrainians. zelensky pushed and pushed not to make that announcement. he resisted the pressure, even under the theft of russia invasion. he resisted because he knew it wasn't right. he said, has this gone through the right channels of the justice department? >> let's clos