gadhafi secret police critics say that's the kind of information the bill is designed to suppress so begg who was held and here alleges tortured in background and guantanamo has a special interest in making sure there are no more secrets theory i remember the discussions that were taking place at the time it was very all the former guantanamo prisoners on one side sixteen of us and a whole bunch of government officials on the other side having a discussion negotiating a settlement we would have been able to do that basically we would have been able to certainly try to take the government to court but we would have to do it with our hands tied behind their back even the government admits that black and asian muslim men will be disproportionately affected as if they were most often involved in cases where sensitive information is being considered and still the bill rolls on the plans for so-called secret justice are proven so deeply controversial that they've been delayed but like a bad penny they keep turning up and every time they do it gives human rights groups another opportunity to rai