wound up in the hands of the unbelievable secretary of war benjamin and not much more efficient at this kind of thing superior jefferson davis. and without going into the merits of the case from those people's perspective, there are two points i want to make for you. number one, that mute any was more broadly based than is generally known, number one. number two, it seems to be a beautiful illustration of his complete lack of standing before the valley campaign. number one, it is well-known that william w.loring, of no particular talent. he was imbedded tolliver who owed by the same denomination for his net merits. i've always b hindsight after the war when jackson had become absolutely legendary. he had been his sworn enemy wrote a whole chapter hemming jackson's glory. the reflective glow of the hero now to whom he had been so opposed during the war. in addition to them, everybody knows about loring and tolliver. in addition to them the original document sent off had the signatures of if not every, virtually every field officer of all the regimens under them. the very first one on that list, if it matters, the first one ph