actually gaining from this new democracy so that's the black middle class now is shrinking again besley is not good news for south africa and it is actually showing that although of course the racial segregation is longer here you still have whether your own humble economic apartheid state still black south africans are the poor part of the populations that africa and white south africans are still the daily so yeah moving forwards a south african definitely needs to work in making sure that that black male calls will grow again and that we have more consumers and in that markets have how how what more can the government do to improve the situation. yeah i know it's a debt that's really the needs to be a long term vision the problem is that the unemployment the youth unemployment here is staggering and the problem mainly is that there are jobs look for skilled workers but most of the young south africans are unskilled and a lot has to do with education public schools they don't give sufficient education to to set africans so we see kids leaving primary school and it a const sufficiently