countries and they guarantee health care to all people person with all eyes on front runners biden julian castro went on the attack her. president barack obama's vision was not to leave 10000000 people on covered he wanted every single person in this country covered my plan would do that your plan would you do not have to buy you. do not have to buy you just said that you just said that 2 minutes ago you just said 2 minutes ago that they would have to buy your did you said they would have to write i had to buy it if i holler fire you for getting what you said just magically for a while i was doing what you said just 2 minutes ago i. should have to make that but i will leave change on this issue because i have seen what the corniche creates in communities like mine and in odessa i met the mother of a 15 year old girl who was shot by an a r 15 and that mother watched her bleed to death over the course of an hour because so many other people were shot by that an ar 15 in odessa in midan there weren't enough ambulances to get to them in time hell yes we're going to take your a r 15 your a k 47 to on

participarÁ elizabeth warren, joe biden, juliÁn castro, bernie sanders, kamala harris y beto o'rourkeda los pormenores de este debate esperado. adelante, fernando. fernando: aquÍ estÁ todo listo en la sala de prensas de la universidad de texas en houston, donde tendremos la oportunidad de analizar el desempeÑo de los 10 precandidatos demÓcratas en el debate. los partidarios de juliÁn castro y de beto o'rourke ya han alineado las calles cercanas al sitio el debate en houston, temprano. adentro, la realizaciÓn hispana mÁs antigua del paÍs y exigiÓ que los demÓcratas no traten a los latinos como piÑatas polÍticos. indicando que el camino a la casa blanca pasa por los barrios latinos del paÍs. pidiÓ arreglar muchos temas. >>finalmente las reformas de las armas, sabemos que una persona fue a el paso texas buscando para matar mexicanos y matÓ 22. fernando: mientras se afinado a los Últimos detalles, jÓvenes pedÍan compromiso para soluciones a una joven con daca y una condiciÓn mÉdica que podrÍa negarse la visa de residencia del gobierno piensa que es carga pÚblicas es que ya regresa a colom

or did joe biden kick julian castro's dog? to be suggesting that soe biden wasn't all there and had forgotten something he had said. >> stephen: right. and there were several attacks, not just that one. >> the one about like, "you want the credit for obama's good things but not his bad things." i mean, cory booker had done that at the last debate. he was just smilier about it, so maybe you didn't remember it. but the one about the age i tought was a-- look, he's-- castro's campaign is struggling, and he needs to-- he's really trying to make this generational argument. and there are other candidates-- congressman ryan from ohio who didn't make the debate stage-- who has also said that joe biden is not as sharp as he used to be, and not as eloquent as he used to be. but you saw the audience turned on castro when he said that. it was-- and, also, i think he was wrong. i think what biden thinks he had said he had actually said. >> stephen: right, that is actually-- i thinkings that the fact check, what he was accusing biden of sayi

that's what joe biden's campaign is calling julian castro's debate attack on the democratic front-runner. is biden pushing back hard enough tonight as some raveival question his ability to stand up to president trump. >>> parts of the bahamas are now being warned about a gathering storm. stand by for the new forecast that also has florida on alert. >>> and orange is the new bold. president trump offers a bizarre explanation for the color of his complexion. does he think americans will buy his claim that energy efficient light bulbs are the reason he often looks orange. >>> we want to welcome our viewers in the united states and around the world. wolf blitzer is off today. i'm brianna keilar. you're in "the situation room." >> announcer: this is cnn breaking news. >> we're following breaking news on the first high-profile sentencing in the college admissions scandal. actress felicity huffman now under orders to serve 14 days in prison, pay a $30,000 fine, and perform 250 hours of community service. the "desperate housewives" star admitted she gave the scam's mastermind $15,000 to boost he

and the other thing i want to say is that julian castro, sort of going after joe biden on his age, intentionally or not, is that going to end up being -- is that going to turn everybody off to julian castro but land a blow -- essentially a kamikaze mission to draw attention to biden's age? and does it hurt castro but help everybody else? that's something to pay attention to. >> or hurt both of them. biden and castro. nice to see you. zach wolf, bright and early this morning. >> we'll play you that entire exchange about the age in 30 minutes. >>> ahead, an early review shows a glaring mistake by the crew on that boat that caught fire off the coast of california, killing 34. when we started our business we were paying an arm and a leg for postage. i remember setting up shipstation. one or two clicks and everything was up and running. i was printing out labels and saving money. shipstation saves us so much time. it makes it really easy and seamless. pick an order, print everything you need, slap the label onto the box, and it's ready to go. our costs for shipping were cut in half. just like that. s

what does the biden campaign make of this attack by julian castro? oe biden campaign is arguing this is going to backfire against julian castro. they're pointing to other moments previous debates and moment ins the campaign cycle where candidates have gone after joe biden and not benefitted frd it. pointing to two examples eric swalwell and gillibrand who went after him in debates and are not in the democratic primary race any longer. the campaign is painting this as a low blow. and a cheap shot. the candidate himself is trying not to engage in it. simply saying he thought the castro was wrong. as you mention he's acknowledging he has room for improvement had when it comes to debating. he didn't say which areas but knows he needs to do better going forward. castro was not the only one to raise concerns about biden. corey booker waited until he was off the stage and in an interview said there are concerns from people biden won't be able to cross the finish line without fumbling. booker tried to walk it back this morning. on our air. but what's interest

biden. julian castro tried and there's an idea where he went too far. that exchange saying joe biden didn't remember what he just said when, in fact, he was wrong in that exchange. i think that there's this idea if you're going to try to criticize biden you do it in a way that feels as though you're saying look, i respect you, i respect president obama, i respect everything you've done for the party, but we need to pull this forward. senator harris did that in a way that got her a bump in the polls but she's not been able to sustain that bump and take more support away from joe biden. when talking to the candidates, there's this idea that bernie sanders and elizabeth warren are pitted against each other but they're both looking at joe biden and saying we need to make sure that person's supporters understand what we have to offer and they choose us over biden. >> thank you both. >>> president trump has reached out to african-american voters in the past in a very unique way. perhaps you'll remember this moment from the 2016 campaign trail. >> we had a cas

but biden's campaign tonight is sieging on that moment. that clash he had with julian castro saying the former hud secretary's comments are a low blow and a cheap shot. tonight joe biden pushing back on rival julian castro. after some heated clashes at thursday night's debate. >> i'm fulfilling the legacy of barack obama and you're not. >> that will be a surprise to him. >> reporter: castro launching this attack on biden during an exchange on health care. >> they do not have to buy if. >> you just said that. you just said that two minutes ago. you just said two minutes ago they would have to buy in. are you for getting what you said two minutes ago. are you for getting already what you said just two minutes ago? i can't believe that you said two minutes ago that they had to buy in and now you're saying they don't have to -- you're forgetting that. >> reporter: biden responding a short time ago. >> think he got his facts wrong. >> reporter: in fact biden did say earlier in the debate some people would not be required to opt in. >> anyone who can't afford it gets automatically

interesting that in interviews afterwords he chose to side with julian castro and start questioning biden'sty. that will probably not fare well in the days to come. >> i heard a lot of people going after castro and questioning that tactic. the candidates say we have questions about the rhetoric from joe biden. talk quickly about guns. beto o'rourke has his position and impassioned about the shootings in texas and el paso. do we think the dynamic is changing on the campaign trail and capitol hill? >> democratic voters, especially older democratic voters will be decisive in the selection remember too well what happens when democrats take positions on gun control, it has backfired on them quite badly in the past. the clinton era saw a weapons been that was a political disaster, when beto o'rourke, he has always chosen to sound very angry, profane, upset, going to take the guns, that scratches a niche for an outspoken loud minority but it reinforces things for him, he's not electable. he can't take his message to a larger audience. >> got a couple more guests coming up. impeachment was not ment

president trump obviously a frequent target and at one point, an exchange between joe biden and julian castro turned into verbal jabs. >> yes, we're going to take your ak-47s. >> the candidates aren't the only ones who are debating what should be done with gun theount. you havemericans who say they back a mandatory buy back for assault weapons, 46% of americans oppose it. it pretty much evenly divided. >> president trump also chiming in saying he thinks former vp joe biden could end up being the nominee. >>> the bay area is rising to the challenge of combatting its housing crisis. new information shows san jose is increasing apartment construction nearly 300% this year. it will be building more than 6,000 new units. oakland is said to end 2,000 new units by the end of the year. san francisco is fourth. the numbers come from rent cafe which analyzed new apartment construction in about>> antonio playing this sunday for the new england patriots. he postedt from out in new england. he's planning on playing against the dolphins on saturday. he says he won't let the devil bring him down. his person

i was disappointed in joe biden last night and julian castro for attacking joe biden the way he did. other thing i wanted to say is all of the people -- i am trying to stay away from party. all of the americans who think we should not have any gun control because they are worried about their second amendment right, what about the right to live? said before you go, you beto was not your favorite candidate, between elizabeth buttigieg, who has the edge? caller: elizabeth warren. host: why? caller: i think she is vibrant, intelligent, she has the fire in her belly to fight and work for the things she is saying she has a plan for. if we can get together and put away the republican and democratic party fighting, maybe we could come together and find a common ground and solve some problems. tweak them where the democrats want it, tweak them where the root publicans -- where the republicans wanted so we find common ground. host: wisconsin, independent line, good morning. caller: good morning, thank you for taking my call. i was wondering, when obamacare was installed congress voted to opt o

you know that key moment between vice president castro -- vice president biden and julian castro and whether their plans would enroll anyone. you support medicare for all who want it but you have not released a full detailed plan explaining it. would anyone be automatically enrolled under your proposal if they lost their insurance because they lost a job or any other reason. >> yes. and you'll see more on that in the forthcoming plan. we need to have a vision to make sure everybody is covered. my vision of medicare for all who want it versus the sanders/warren is i think we cannot order the public on the alternative. that medicare for all who want it is better than all of the private plans i just trust the american people to make that decision for themselves and vote with their feet rather than ordering them to switch plans when they don't want to. >> when are you going to release the medicare for all who want it plan? >> soon. >> soon? a week or month. >> i don't have a date for you. >> what do you make of the criticism of people like you or others who don't support embracing medica

administration. >> right before we introduced you we played the line from former hud secretary julian castro to joe biden saying i'm fulfilling the legacy of barack obama and you are not. is julian castro correct? >> i think they all have the ability to fulfill the legacy. being in the race, i'm thrilled by the -- >> that is very diplomatic of you. do you think that was a fair line? >> i think they can all say that and the question is the voters get to decide. i think the fact that he was a member of the administration and he has idea going forward, some of which are very consistent with what president obama tried to do and some of the other candidates in the field. again, i don't know that there's very much difference in terms of the core values of the candidates. all of them stand head and shoulders over the current occupant of the white house. the question is how do you convince the american people that you're going to turn your vision into a reality and that that is going to affect the quality of their lives. that's what i think voters are looking for. >> president obama has made it clear he's not go

at one point an ex change between joe biden and julian castro turned into serious sniping. >> you justd two minutes ago they would have to buy in. but you said two minutes ago that they had to buy in and now you're saying they don't have to buy in. you're forgetting that. the dates are becoming unwatchable. >> this reminds everybody of what they cannot stand about washinon >> many political pundits point out castro was probably wrong in his argument and keeping an eye on democrats on the 2020 election, mr. trump thinks joe biden will end up being the nominee. >>> here in the bay area, starting today and for the next ten days if you have friends from college to come in, and check out the sites, the san francisco cable cars will be out of service. crews will do repair work on the system's massive gear boxes are what move the cable cars along the san francisco steep hills. tourists were caught b surprise yesterday when we talked about the powell street turn around trying to get a ride in before the closure. >> these cars mean san francisco to me. >> for the many tourists, buses will run a

fallout after that heated exchange in last night's democratic debate joe biden coming under attack from former hud secretary julian castro who appeared to take a shot at biden's age. late today the former vp responding. peter alexander has more. >> reporter: tonight, joe biden brushing off that stunning swipe from julian castro at last night's debate. >> i don't view it as anything i think he has his facts wrong. >> reporter: biden had come under intense scrutiny for a string of misstatements and castro seemed to question his memory during this clash over whether biden' health care plan automatically enrolls the uninsured. >> no, they don't have to buy in they do not have to buy in. >> you just said that. you just said that two minutes ago. you just said two minutes ago that they would have to buy in. >> they don't have to buy in - >> are you forgetting what you said two minutes ago >> reporter: but was it a fair attack castro appeared to misrepresent what biden said, even though he correctl highlighted the common criticism of biden's plan. still, it was the apparent shot at the former vp's age that's come under fire. >>

carvana. >>> so one of the big moments from last night, former housing secretary julian castro directly questioning joe biden's discussion on health care. castro himself told us this morning it was not a personal attack. we heard from senator amy klobuchar. she thought it was personal. i want you to listen to what senator cory booker told cnn after last night's debate. >> i think we're at a tough point right now because there are a lot of people concerned about joe biden's ability to carry the ball all the way across the end line without fumbling. and i think that castro has some really legitimate concerns about, can he be someone in a long, grueling campaign, that can get the ball over the line? and he has every reason to call that out. >> joining us now is new jersey's democrat senator cory booker. thank you for being with us. i want to play you a moment from the debate itself last night. we just heard you after talking about joe biden and concerns you have about fumbling. this is what you said in the debate itself. >> this must be a moment where we as democrats can begin to show that we cannot only stake an

sort of heard gasp in the room and reaction throughout the day was not against joe biden, it was against how julian castro went after him. >> the immediate reaction was julian out kick his coverage, he went a little too far going after joe biden there. that's the risk when you attack a popular politician. he's by every poll of the most popular democrat running for president right now. if you are going after him, you need to do it carefully. it looks like if you are trying to score points or doing it in a way where somebody perceive it being mean spirit, it could hurt you. castro is not backing down. he's e-mailing his supporters today. i am going to fact-check and be aggressive and so will donald trump and i am ready to take him on. >> fact-checking and being aggressive, we just fact checked it. castro was wrong. >> right. loisvil absolutely. that's why this is a risky strategy for him. he qualified late in the game of the debate. his last couple months of the campaign has been like it. he gets a lot of attention and performs well or aggressively and inserts himself in the conversation. he has had a hard

julian castro was looking for that kind of an opening. was he questioning yoebd's ajoe age? was he questioning joe biden's mental ability? we 'do know this morning julian castro is defending his remarks, right? >> that's exactly right. we'll get to that in a moment. there was certainly that implication when you heard the crowd when he made the implication. julian castro was on "new day" this morning. here is what he said about last night. take a listen. >> i wouldn't do it differently. that was not a personal attack. this was about a disagreement over what the vice president said regarding health care policy. >> reporter: now, biden's deputy campaign manager was just on cnn as well. she categorized it as definitely a personal attack on vice president biden and then she went on to say, look, other candidates in the race have personally attacked biden and it hasn't gone well nor them, in their words. she highlighted kirsten gillibrand and eric swalwell. we did fact check that. castro was partially correct. here is the deal. he stands for medicare for all, which would automatically enroll all americans. biden's plan offers y

. >> so julian castro was the latest far trailing -- distant trailing candidate to take a shot at joe biden in a debate, a personal one, and it didn't go over well, did it? >> it didn't. you could hear the reaction in the crowd. listen to what julian castro said. this was about the debate during their health care plans. take a listen. >> the difference between what i support and what you support, vice president biden, is that you require them to opt in, and i would not require them to opt in. >> they do not have to buy in. they do not have to buy in. >> you just said that two minutes ago. you just said two minutes ago they would have to buy in. are you forgetting what you said two minutes ago? are you forgetting already what you said just two minutes ago? i mean, i can't believe that you said two minutes ago they had to buy in and now you're saying they don't have to buy in. you're forgetting that. >> so you can hear the reaction from the crowd when julian castro, seemed to plan to be pretty aggressive all night last night. when he made that comment, you could hear the crowd kind of sighing

. >> several of the candidates targeted front runner joe biden but many say julian castro's attempts to focus on joe biden's age back fired much the first time that all of the top candidates were on stage at the same time. we heard candidates pushing a plan to raise taxes on the rich and wealthy and beto o'rourke talked about gun control. >> yes we are going to take your ar-159, ak-47. >> those at the very top, the richest individuals and the biggest corporations are going to pay more. >> joe biden started strong in last night's debate and senator kamala harris focused on president trump in opening and closing statements. >>> well in san francisco about 100 people watched the third debate at a gathering spot in the mission district. the audience at maddy's listened to the debate dominated by healthcare early on. they were hoping to hear solutions to mass shootings. >> i thought kamala harris had good points, i feel like joe biden i want to root for him so badly because i know obama saw something in him, he really struggled this evening. >> in the end those viewers said they found the

tonight joe biden was definitely more forceful and energetic than he has been in any of the previous debates, but julian castro would not let voters forget how forgetful biden has been on the campaign trail. watch this moment, really by far the most heated of the debate were castro accuses biden of not remembering the details of his own health care plan. >> when you said just 2 minutes ago -- i can't believe that you said 2 minutes ago that they had to buy in and now you're saying they don't have to -- you're forgetting that! >> anybody whose grandmother has no money. your automatically enrolled. >> automatically enrolls people regardless of whether they choose to opt in or not. if you lose your job, for instance, his health care plan would not automatically enroll you, you would have to opt in. my health care plan would, that's a big difference. i'm fulfilling the legacy of barack obama and you are not buried >> that will be a surprise to him. >> in that exchange, biden was right and castro was wrong, but there was another exchange for bernie sanders seemed to get the best of biden and it was on an issue that

the showdown driving today's news, julian castro's suggestion that joe biden has time to remembering ws pressed castro on the subject last night. >> most people thought there was another aspect that you were suggesting that a man of 76 years had lost his ability to remember what he just said. >> not at all. >> you rubbed it in three or four times. you kept saying you don't remember? you don't remember what you just said? >> we had a disagreement whether

biden's competitors going after his memory? >> well, what you failed to mention there was that julian castro then said he believes joe biden actuallya good candidate, and he wasn't personally attacking him. that's not what he meant. he wanted to have this agreement on health care, and their plans. contrasting their plans when it comes to providing more health care to the american people. so i think all in all julian castro said, "you know what? i believe he's a good candidate. i did not mean to personally attack him. but i do disagree with him." i think that's fair game when you're talking about people's records. and when you're talking about -- especially when it comes to health care, reply and now that differs from someone else's plan. >> harris: i didn't failed to mention anything, this is not on me. cory booker bent double down and defended julian castro on the point of viability of one's memory. again, is that helpful in this discussion that you would even make it part of it? with her today on second blush it gets a different read is one thing. last night, the country got to see him call member into question of joe biden. >> t

joe biden and bernie sanders. >> to me, berpnie seems like articulating. >> everyone was disappointed in julian castron's memory. she met him a few weeks ago and advised him against those attacks. >> we liked it when they were talking about issues and elevating the conversation. >> reporter: do you think he wasn't listening to you during this debate? >> kind of and it made me sad. >> reporter: do you know who you are going to support? you are tempted. >> who are your going to support? >> i'm going to caucus for elizabeth warren. >> reporter: no longer an undecided voter. among this group, the debates have been very good to elizabeth warren. gary tuchman, cnn, iowa city, iowa. >>> the 2020 democrats took turns attacking president trump's trade war. we traveled to one rust belt town that's been struggling for years. have president trump's policies helped them? t add up the years. but what i do count on... is boost® delicious boost® high protein nutritional drink has 20 grams of protein, along with 26 essential vitamins and minerals. boost® high protein. be up for life. at verizon, we're building the mos

one attack on biden in particular from former hud secretary julian castro about whether biden had forgotten something he said two minutes before received boos from the audience and tutting from the pundits. moments ago bride ebb brushed it off when asked how he viewed the attack. >> i don't think there was anything. i think he got his facts wrong. >> but the questions about biden's sharpness and vigor hangs like the sort -- above the democratic party. is the candidate who has ridden so far on the mantle of electability win. and the best of the three so far for the former vice president, other progressive commentators are saying that a rambling answer he gave about the legacy of slavery was disqualifying. jeff zeleny kicks off our coverage. >> are you for getting what you said two minutes ago? are you for getting already what you said just two minutes ago in. >> reporter: former vice president joe biden brushing aside another round of attacks on the democratic debate stage. this time from julian castro. a housing secretary under president obama. biden campaign calling it a cheap shot and low

former housing secretary, julian castro, questioning the memory of former vice president joe biden. and joining me now is former secretary julian castro. mr. secretary, thank you so much for being with us. good morning. >> good morning. good to be with you. >> so, paul begala, political adviser from your home state of texas just called that moment disgraceful. we heard from an iowa voter earlier this morning who was watching who said he wished you had laid off the personal attacks. you have had a night to reflect on this. how would you do it differently? >> i wouldn't do it differently. that was not a personal attack. this was about a disagreement over what the vice president said regarding health care policy. i'm glad, actually, that a lot of journalists overnight did the work of actually looking at the transcript. the vice president had said that he -- he didn't say the words "buy in" when he talked about his health care plan. he had, in fact said those words, but then he denied saying them. and i pointed out that he had just said that. and now he was denying it. this is important,

biden's response elicited another swipe from julian castro who also served in the obama administration as u.s. secretary of housing and urban development. >> my problem with vice president biden and corey pointed this out last time, is every time something good about barack obama comes up, he says i was there, i was there, i was there, that's me, too and then every time somebody questions part of the administration that we were both part of, he says well, that was the president. i mean he wants to take credit for obama's work, but not have to answer to any questions. >> following last night's debate, the associated press fact checked biden's claim of not using cages during the obama administration and found the chain link enclosures inside border facilities were built and used by the obama administration. in fact, the obama administration also separated migrant children from families under certain limited circumstances. >> and in one of the more poignant moeb moments of the night, bet yes o'rourke took a bold stance on the con fission case of assault weapons. >> if it was a weapon desi

the most talked about moment of the debate, julian castro slamming joe biden over his memory. >> it isare you forgetting what you said two minutes ago? heather: will that attack help or hurt castro? we debate it next. now and forever more. inside these buildings in jerusalem and throughout israel there are many elderly jews who are suffering daily and they need our help now. as christians and jews we know that we have a scriptural mandate to feed the hungry. and here there are thousands in desparate need. 17 years ago, edna was in a horrible terrorist attack. she is still in excruciating pain and she can't even afford her medicine. "i've lost my will to live." "all the time i suffer alone with sickness and pain." your help is urgently needed. please call right now and make a gift of $25 that will rush food and essential aid to an elderly jewish person struggling to survive. every gift helps keep them alive and shows your love to god's people. for over 35 years the international fellowship of christians and jews has been bringing christian and jewish communities together. and it's only

julian castro. you mentioned joe biden. did anything about betos a performance either meet or exceed expectations for him as someone who sort of is thought to have found his voice in el paso and odessa after those mass shootings? >> i have to say that practically every single candidate when they wanted to talk about el paso or they want to talk about gun reform, they tipped their hat to the leadership of beto. and beto owned it, and he did it gracefully. he talked what most candidates have been afraid up to this point to really talk about. he named racism as one of the things that is tearing this country apart and named that it falls at the foot of the white house. and that is refreshing, because if you can't say it out loud, you can't address it. >> maria teresa kumar, greetings from everybody here. you know everybody here. >> you guys are having so much fun. texas is having a great time. thanks for having me on. >> you'll be here next time. thanks for joining us. >> it's your punishment. >> from houston. and now i underst

minutes ago. >> the difference in these two men's plans here, but julian castro can say after the fact he wasn't going after joe biden's age or memory, but come on now, he clearly was, who did that hurt more, julian castro or joe biden. at the end of the day castro was wrong, biden didn't forget what he said. >> there was a backlash to secretary castro and not in a good way. he got to that debate by going after congressman beto o'rourke in june and then he tangled with vice president biden in july. he got that attention that way. this is a very different situation. the field is smaller on this stage, there is less engagement. they didn't do this in a way where it was a outliar in tone. we're all in this together and we must defeat trump. >> was that the right way to go after biden, to his point, castro get separate by getting aggressive but this was a different tone. >> yeah, and it didn't really sit real in the debate hall. a lot of the voters don't want mean, they want policy, they want to go after people in ways that are fair. however at the same time what julian was trying to demonstrate is that he is ready for thi

julian castro from the edge of the stage took a shot at joe biden's memory. care policy. in a moment i'll be joined by julian castro who defiantly says he wasn't going after biden personally. still cas

i've heard fromoc other dtic questions, the question is if the biden campaign is complaining about julian castro, how will he handle the heat 'll get from donald trump? anne: i think there's that old about if you shoot at the king, you best notiss. biden is not a king b in this case if you shoot at the frontrunner, youetter have your facts straight. robert: what's the political cost for secretary castro? anne: i: thinkre t definitely political cost for him. he looked factually incorrect and like he wasin m an ad hominem attack on biden's memory and fitness when, in fact, biden had not made a mistake. therere plenty of things you can point at when you're talking about joe biden -- he rambles, right. he does occasionally say stufftu that's just completely whacka doodle, as he did in the debate when he stakied t about venezuela when the question was on reparations. but in this case he'd been spot-on and clear in his original answer andigin castro s mistaken. carl: i heard from biden allies during the debate. they saidhis was b for castro. you heard the word disqualifying. i wan to make bigger point

joe biden promising to release his medical records before the first primary. former hud secretary julian castron's memory during a heated exchange about health care. castro denied taking a swipe at biden's age. voters gather for the iowa caucuses in february. meanwhile fans are mourning the death of singer eddie money. money had a string of hits in the late 1970's and 1980's including "baby hold on," last month money announced he was battling stage four esophageal cancer. he was forced to cancel tour dates. i'm jackie ibanez. >> sean: for more reaction on it tonighta breaking news, inspector general horowitz has submitted his fisa report for reviews. former congressman trey gowdy, the idea that now mccabe -- they passed on any special treatment but it was a while ago that report identified the inspector general report identified him as a liar and a leaker and you said it's a celebration of our justice system. now we have the second minor report. that was comey lacking candor. but that didn't result in -- well, it didn't result in a referral but it doesn't seem like they're moving forward. why i

>> dana: somebody was eventually going to raise this question of has joe biden lost a step and julian castroed it was going to be him. the thing is he went after joe biden and the audience felt like it was a low blow. it wasn't even correct. that isn't what biden actually said and it looked mean. and that's not what the democrats seem to want this time around. >> brian: theory? can i share it with you. >> dana: i love a theory, yes.de >> brian: i don't have much time buoy do you think people in the obama camp think biden lost his fast ball and gave him a wink and nod go for it and prove it. >> i think that was one of those things i'm thinking of running for president. you don't have to do that okay. we wish you the best kind of thing. and that they probably realize that there is not a lot they can do to try to help them. i don't think that the obamas will endorse before the convention. t this could go all the way to a contested convention next summer which would be really fun. t i asked bret human what's it like to cover a contested convention he said never done it. it could be history makin

senator amy klobuchar, cory booker, kamala harris, elizabeth warren, joe biden, and julian castro among others will grace the stage. plenty of attention on joe biden as he and elizabeth warren face off for the very first time on the same stage. biden's advisers pushed back on the idea the debate would be a show down between the former vp and the senator saying he is more likely to face direct attacks from others on the stage. biden's camp also says he is eager to make a broader contrast with his more progressive rivals and that he will be ready to push back against suggestions that he is pursuing middle of the road solutions. meanwhile, yang is apparently preparing something big for the debate. a senior official tells msnbc news he will do something unprecedented on stage but would not elaborate. yang showed a clip from the daily show, with the recent campaign vanes adding we've got something big in store. >> 29%, senator bernie sanders leads the 020 democratic field in new hampshire by eight points according to a new franklin pierce university boston herald poll. former vice president

bernie sanders and joe biden disagree on just about everything. when julian castro attacked joe biden, bernie sanders came over. this happened a couple times during the debate. bernie sanders came over. friends from the senate, the club. bernie sanders and joe biden disagree on just about everything, but that told me a lot about this race right there once you see it play out. they are friends. they're going to fight it out, but they are friends, and that can matter. >>> up next, that fierce debate over health care. when joe biden says he's still with barack, other candidates can't resist the opportunity to make a joke. >> let's be clear, joe. >> i would just say, joe, instead of saying, no, we can't, let's say yes, we can. since you're heading off to dad... i just got a zerowater. but we've always used brita. it's two stage-filter... doesn't compare to zerowater's 5-stage. this meter shows how much stuff, or dissolved solids, gets left behind. our tap water is 220. brita? 110... seriously? but zerowater- let me guess. zero? yup, that's how i know it is the purest-ta

hearing you're switching to the castro camp and not endorsing former vice president biden was not because of that exchange at the debate, even though many criticized juliansaying he was disrespectful. that's not the reason, though? >> no, not at all. everybody has their own style on the debate stage. i think the delivery, as i said, could have been different. but for the most part, i think they're all good, qualified democrats that care for this country that need to come together and figure out who our guy is that can take us across the finish line. at this point, after three debates and, you know, a year of campaigning, almost, i think it's pretty clear that the person who has shown the statesmanship that can take us past the finish line is the steady ship of joe biden. >> all right, joining me right now to discuss, washington bureau chief for the chicago sun times, lynn swede, and senior writer for rolling stone, jamil smith. good to see you both. >> good to see you. >> he said the attack on joe biden was not what moved the needle for him, but he's also saying joe biden is the most winningest. do you buy that? >> i have to ask, what do democrats think

instead the conflict was between biden and julian castro, a fellow veteran of the obama administration who critics say was too eager to draw blood or so eager to draw blood in fact that he got his facts what wrong while trying to imply that biden's age is a problem. >> the difference between what i support and what you support is whether people have to buy in. >> they do not have to buy in. >> you said two minutes ago that they have to buy in. are you forgetting what you said two minutes ago? are you forgetting already what you said just two minutes ago? i'm fulfilling the legacy of barack obama and you're not. >> that will be a surprise to him. >> in fact our fact checkers say that he was wrong, biden has called that a cheap shot. joining me, nbc's garrett haake in houston, kimberly atkins, political analyst mike murphy, and msnbc national political correspondent who does not sleep, steve kornacki. steve, what a night. let's talk about, first of all, the biden/castro matchup. castro getting criticized pretty soundly for being too tough and for not getting his facts straight and for se

los expertos dicen que lo hizo biden ya que dicen que soporto muy bien los embates de juliÁn castro cuandotir que usted y el presidente obama cometieron un error? por quÉ deberÍan confiar en usted de los latinos? >> por otra parte nosotros nos separaba mÁs a las familias. en segundo lugar, este es un presidente que llegÓ con el programa daca. Él paso una legislaciÓn diciendo que habÍa encontrado un camino para que los 11.000.000 de indocumentados y amÉrica pudieran seguir adelante. me satisface y me siento orgulloso de haber servido bajo obama. jorge: usted no respondiÓ a mi pregunta. usted comete un error a esas deportaciones? biden: el presidente hizo lo mejor que se podÍan ese momento. carolina: un excelente enfrentamiento y satcha pretto en diego nos tiene mucho mÁs. satcha: estoy con el vocero de una organizaciÓn para hablar sobre este debate y darles un anÁlisis completo. hablemos de este intercambio entre jorge ramos y joe biden con respecto a inmigraciÓn. el nunca dijo en cÁmaras y se sentÍa mal. >> el vicepresidente se vio en la defensa porque cuando tenÍan un control completo no

one tense exchange happened between biden and julian castro. >> the difference between what i support and i would not require them to opt in. they would automatically be enrolled. they wouldn't have to buy in. >> they do not have to buy in. they do not have to buy in. >> you just said that two minutes ago. you just said two minutes ago that they would have to buy in. you said they would have to buy in. are you forgetting what you said two minutes ago? are you forgetting already what you said just two minutes ago? i can't believe that you said two minutes ago they had to buy in and now you're saying they don't have to buy in. >> a very loud groan on the floor. we asked castro about that comment. he said he was not criticizing biden's memory or age. just his health care plan. we also spoke to young democrats at drake university in the battleground state of iowa about the candidates who stood out to them. >> i love pete buttigieg. i think that he brings the intelligence and the youth to democracy that we haven't seen in forever. >> imagine what would be possible right now with ideas that

but the arguably the most indelible moment was when former housing secretary julian castro challenged biden'semocratic presidential hopefuls prepare to debate stage in tonight, the focus for many continues to be electability. recent polls show former vice president joe biden continuing to lead the field, with senator warren close --reporter -democratic voters, the question continues to be, who can (grant) this was the third debate... and the first one since the field has been widdled down... from 20 candidates to 10.20 candidates down... from 20 candidates to 10. (pam) now back to our continuing coverage of the 2020 democratic debates tonight.(ken) we are now joined on the phone by david mccuan a political analyst and chair of the political science department at sonoma state university who is in houston right now for the debate. (ken) stay with us for full coverage of for full stay with us (ken) coverage of the debate. watch tonight at 8:30 as "inside bay area politics" host catherine area politics" as "inside bay tonight at 8:30 as "inside bay area politics" host catherine heenan will be joi

biden say they will release their medical records. age has been a hot topic this week after julian castro took a jab at biden's age.den is not the oldest candidate, nor is he the only one in his 70s, bernie sanders is 78 and warren is 70. together they have been dominating the field of their younger democratic rivals. despite the polls, warren appears to be making headway, it is different for joe biden. we spoesht to people in iowa. >> eight democrats all undecided about who to vote. we watched all three sets of debates with them, the consensus winner the first two times elizabeth warren, this time? >> warren and booker. >> warren and booker. >> warren and booker. >> booker and warren. >> in that order? >> i thought they tied. >> buttigieg at warren. >> how many said warren as your first choice? >> how many said booker as their first choice. >> a tie. >> two. so it seems like corey booker was second. >> everyone in the group tell u.s us they like warren's fight. >> she has done this and a lot in the past successfully. she wants to be in the fight and she is ready to go. >> she is clear, articulate, has plans, and g

biden was the most tweeted about. and the most tweeted about moment was when julian castro pointed out that biden forgot summon he'd said a minute before. >> and castro was wrong. >> when you drag somebody, you must have accuracy on your side. >> you must. >>> coming up next. the late night test that may keep people up. >>> a south bay >>> all right. let's take a look at what's going on. that's last week's forecast. the chiefs will be in town to take on the raiders and the temperatures will be mainly in the low 70s, dropping during the game. that's going to be a refreshing game. if you're going to the marlins and giants game tonight at oracle, the sun will set at 7:20. the temperature's going to jump rapidly during the evening hours. 67 as we head under the star-filled skies into the evening. >>> happening tonight, the royal transit will start doing more safety track testing during larkspur and san rafael. at 11:00 p.m. they're going to be checking warning systems. testing will continue saturday and if all goes well, service could begin in the next couple of months. >> happening today, a huge cypress is going to be comi

it was julian castro going after julian castro and afterword cory booker went after him again. >> a lot of people are concerned about joe biden'slity to carry the ball across the end line. castro has legitimate concerns. a number of us were looking onstage when he tends to go on, talking about record players, definitely moment you listen to joe biden and wonder. >> reporter: is there a danger of those attack damaging biden? >> people watch biden with baited breath especially democrats because the gaffes do occur and will continue to occur but as long as they stay minor i don't think it will hurt him too much. people still believe he has the best chance to take on donald trump. he has a good lead in most of the major polls. i don't think castro's attacks will hurt biden is much of that hurt him because it looks like a low blow. i still think biden basically is unscathed for right now. mike: generational attacks made the ladies on the view quite uneasy. >> don't do that. that was not what we needed last night. you have an issue with older folks that is your problem. >> this old thing has got to stop. 25% of the electorate is over