that's using a lot of data, whether that's big data, it's a lot of data through the automated targeting system, which is part of the national targeting center that was set up by customs and border protection. and so now not only can we identify the small fragment of people that might pose a threat, and then to ask them some questions before we allow them into the united states, because if you're a foreign national, you have no right to enter the u.s. but in that small group of people, and by the way, it's hundreds per year, we deny entry, which means that they are put on an airplane and sent back. now, the other thing we're able to do now, and this has been since the underpants bomber as they called him in australia, since that time, we're actually able to do this intervention before they get on an aircraft at a foreign airport like heathrow and so forth. and cvp actually has teams of officers there to do the counterterrorism questioning of the people that we determine are potential terrorists, so they don't even get onboard the aircraft. if we believe -- if we assess them to be a secur

i guess my question is, if it is okay for you to sell big data with personal information, why can't the cfpb rely on anonymous data to protect consumers? >> look, that is a great question. a brilliant set up. it is true that we have carefully studied the 2008 and 2012 obama campaigns and while we are still behind them and gathering metadata and don't have quite the ties they haven't silicon valley and major intellectual centers comeau we were doing everything we can to be at least as good as using metadata. i appreciate your recognizing while we are 2nd, we are working hard to catch up. you put your finger on it. i cannot go to somebody and threatened to cut off bank loans, threatened put them in jail. peoplejail. people who happened to be on my list voluntarily signed up to get information. and they can voluntarily get off the list without having a bureaucrat: threaten. if you look at the power of the government and imagine random independent bureaucrats who aggregate to themselves the right to decide what my consumer choices should be, that is real power. we are just a private company

. >>> still to come on the show, big hopes for big data. peak to social media firm star count and how it's managed to get another big round. that's up next. much more here on worldwide exchange. find us on twitter @carolyncnbc or @louisaboyerson. the flu virus hits big. with aches, chills, and fever, there's no such thing as a little flu. and it needs a big solution: an antiviral. so when the flu hits, call your doctor right away and up the ante with antiviral tamiflu. prescription tamiflu is an antiviral that attacks the flu virus at its source and helps stop it from spreading in the body. tamiflu is fda approved to treat the flu in people two weeks of age and older whose flu symptoms started within the last two days. before taking tamiflu, tell your doctor if you're pregnant, nursing, have serious health conditions, or take other medicines. if you develop an allergic reaction, a severe rash, or signs of unusual behavior, stop taking tamiflu and call your doctor immediately. children and adolescents in particular may be at an increased risk

. >> this is the panel on privacy and big data that have all had issues. the report stated they fundamentally shift the way that we interact with our surroundings and the state can certainly be extended to include reflects of data as they are covering the differing views as to whether this is a good thing or a bad thing. nevertheless, there's an energy medicine medicine from health care, politics, government, content and virtually every business is deemed affected their. we have a great time to discuss these issues. i will introduce them alphabetically. sean is the chief economist and senior director of research at the consumer electronics association. he is the author of recently if typical of the digital destiny of a of the new age of data will transform the way that we work with and communicate. to his left is alex macgillivray has been at the white house a little less than a year in his portfolio is the focus on internet policy and intellectual policy and the intersection of big data technology and privacy and before joining the government served as th

have you seen big data analytics being used in this space? how can it be used to prevent these kinds of attacks? general hayden: it follows the path of what we would call disambiguation. the whole universe of data points being boiled down into very specific things. we've gotten fairly good at that. disambiguating identities so that we can target someone either for action are for collection. or so they don't get on an airplane. we need to perfect that and use it better. it's not a contrarian view of the complementary one. an awful lot of what now passes for analysis is disambiguation. going from the mass to the specific. that might be at the cost of broader strategic appreciation for what is going on. it was a mix of a policy problem and intel problem. we may have been so busy as an intelligence committee chopping down trees over here that we kind of missed the second growth forest. the data is good that we have to do that effective disambiguation. don't forget you need to tell your policymakers to keep reaching nuanced strategic appreciations

security policies and practices and procedures and i know that the data security is part of the regulatory issue and part a market issue. is it a big enough incentive to force the companies to invest in data security. so how do we end where is the approach to invest to ensure we have good data security because i don't think there is enough of it and i speak because it is in the position to try to deal with the downstream effects of it. it pollutes the database. are they not enough and we need more but the right role of the government regulation in creating the incentives to invest in the data security. >> we have very poor data is hard to answer that question but i'd like to see the ftc step forward in this area if they do the recent examples there is this dot target break in. there is these reported to have turned out not to be nearly as costly as we have reported in the initiative stories. they are constant for the companies but when they try to do the appropriate cost-benefit analysis they have the data about what the costs really look like. >> can i get a word in now on the consumer side of this essentially we are our own first

will come of this is the panel of privacy and big data, all very hot issues. a recent mckinsey report stated that internet has the potential to fundamentally shifted the way we interact with our surroundings and that cancer when extended to include the effects of big data. they had differing views as to whether this is a good thing or bad thing. nevertheless, virtually everything transportation, energy, medicine, healthcare, politics and government, content and virtually every business is being affected. we have a great panel to discuss these issues. i will introduce them alphabetically. shawn dubravac is the chief economist, senior editor of research for the consumer electronics association and the author recently of, digital destiny, how the new age of all transform, work and comedic a. to his left is alexander macgillivray, who has been the deputy chief technology officer at the white house for a little less than a year and his portfolio is the focus on internet policy and electrical property policy and the intersection of big data technology and privacy an

but there is so much change in the global world, the economies and technology world between the big data cloud, platform based business models, uber, airbnb, but when i was retiring four years ago, these were ideas and concepts but i personally believed they would have a massive impact on corporate structures. >> rose: bruce riedel and sam palmisano when we continue. >> rose: bruce riedel is here, director of the intelligence project at the brookings institution and a senior fellow. served in the c.i.a. 30 years and a national security advisor to four presidents in south asia and the middle east. new book is called "j.f.k.'s forgotten crisis: tibet, the c.i.a., and the sino-indian war." the financial times calls it a minor gem of eloquent history writing. pleased to have bruce riedel back at this table. welcome. >> pleasure to be here. >> rose: i assume you like the idea of "eloquent gem of historical writing" because you sat down and said to me, "this is the most fun i've had." what was it about the experience that so resonated with you? >> the kennedy administration. woe call it camelo

i guess my question is, if it is okay for you to sell big data with personal information, why can't the cfpb rely on anonymous data to protect consumers? >> look, that is a great question. a brilliant set up. it is true that we have carefully studied the 2008 and 2012 obama campaigns and while we are still behind them and gathering metadata and don't have quite the ties they haven't silicon valley and major intellectual centers comeau we were doing everything we can to be at least as good as using metadata. i appreciate your recognizing while we are 2nd, we are working hard to catch up. you put your finger on it. i cannot go to somebody and threatened to cut off bank loans, threatened put them in jail. peoplejail. people who happened to be on my list voluntarily signed up to get information. and they can voluntarily get off the list without having a bureaucrat: threaten. if you look at the power of the government and imagine random independent bureaucrats who aggregate to themselves the right to decide what my consumer choices should be, that is real power. we are just a private company

. >> if you look at high tech and big data will look at productivity as growth in what is central to it and whole range of the immigration that is like the industrial revolution and it changed the country and brought great population but also great -- brought great poverty. because of the union movement to hebetude decades of reform so i am optimistic about america. i know we have declining wages, family breakdown but i also know it brings change to make it possible to be successful. >> are we in the second to gilded age? >> for sure but also in that era led get the city with this minimum-wage, is sick days and a variety of reforms in california and connecticut's it and what is happening in business as whole, the catholic church as they address problems of poverty so let's also recognize there is the process of reform. >> what about the baby boom generation? >> that is the biggest days that i talked about in the book to have these two revolutions where it all comes together the growth of the millenials in the metropolitan areas at the expense even of the suburbs. it is said change of

you can set the parameters in the we won but to set that digital model is the big data sets with the much richer basis of data so anyone who has intelligence community access ended is unique to you by is unique to me. so if you deviate from that norm than a light goes off why is that? there is the crisis you were called in. may be your supervisor says i don't know. so that is the situation. and for a deviation those patterns versus someone trying to buy a carolyn or ecstasy but you can't be spoke those parameters that will have more clarity. and then to have a human but is trained to understand the technology to make human judgment were at the end of the day to have a due process. the only takes you so far down the road so plugged in end let her do her job. >> one of the success stories with those adjudication for those who never had a clearance before. unless there's an extensive overseas time so those that we would like to have the cultural understanding it is almost impossible to get them through. to be strung along via the process. >> the reason i am here before you today because

how is big data and all of this information affecting the way you look at the business? >> pandora is largely known as a specialized internet radio service. that's how we deliver music to listeners, the vast majority in the u.s.. we have been doing this for 10 years. our 10 year anniversary is next month. so, people think about us in the context of the music genome project. that is our cold start answer to how you categorize music and played music like other songs. the reality is, the true gold is, 50 billion times in the last four years, 120 million bedricans have found -- thum a song.wn that tells a lot about musical preferences. we combine that with democratic data -- age, gender, and location. data, age,hic gender, location. we can know something about your family situation. if you have a mother. shows how all these data points can be pulled together. we have been working on this big data company for years to create this amazing music service. when we talk about engagement with listeners, we talk about getting them to listen longer, understanding preferences, and pla

me, there are, for example, a whole company that does nothing but creates ways to search through big data. we are not using these capabilities. some of this is just inept tuesday. i can check out my granddaughter's new boyfriend but the department of homeland security cannot figure out it needs to track the jihadi websites? some of this is a failure to keep up with technology. some of this is bureaucratic inept tuesday. a great deal of this is an administration that does not understand the knowledge -- the urgency of the situation and the administration has not reached out to the private sector and said, we need help. >> the super pac mostly supporting you, it is now running an ad thatting theres you directly to margaret thatcher. >> margaret thatcher said she was not content to manage the decline of a great nation. neither am i. >> mrs. fiorina isn't that a little over-the-top? >> it is not my ad. it is a super pac ad. second the many people have compensated on the comparison. i am flattered by it. frankly. patchy fog was a great -- patchy fog was great leader for her nation at a pivotal

it will be in dry dock for a few months to fix what could be $70,000 worth of damage. >>> anher big data breach as heats up. the kids technology toymaker vtech said hackers stole the personal information of 5 million customers and their children. the hong kong based company said credit cards and social security numbers have not been compromised but the breach includes address, names, gender and birth dates of child users. >>> the numbers are still coming in from a very busy cyber monday. analysts say shoppers spent nearly $3 billion yesterday. that's a 12% increase in spending from last year, and it makes yesterday the biggest day ever for e-commerce. on average retailers marked items down 20% for their sales. >>> the higher customer traffic on target's website was apparently too much. look at this. the site was intermittently un unavailable for a time yesterday. target was actually plain spoken about it admitting the problems were caused by abnormally high customer traffic. >>> some good news. another drop in gas prices making it 24 the national average now $2.04. drivers in more states

response to big data and eavesdropping and privacy invasions and balancing security and liberty are almostconversations when you can just pick up all the technology and move it to a different country or offshore. >> and keep in mind -- >> and becoming -- i just want to, if i can, talk about what is going on, on the campaign trail because marco rubio was against these changes, and on friday he really hammered ted cruz over his support for the bill. let me just play that and get your reaction on the other side. >> yes, there are policy differences between me and ted cruz. he supported weakening the intelligence programs of this country. i do not. it's a legitimate issue to have a debate over. barack obama proposes even that we cut it. that's a legitimate policy difference. >> robert, i know you wanted to get in here. help us put this in political context. >> one other thing that's interesting, ted cruz has in a sense been carving some area on the political spectrum in sort of in the rand paul nexus, and he is very skeptical of some of these issues on metadata questions, and good for him. the

drive off on its own power but it will be in dry what could be $70,000 worth of damage. >>> another big data breach as the holiday shopping season heats up. the kids' toymaker vtech said hackers stole the personal information of 5 million customers and their children. the hong kong based company said credit cards and social security numbers have not been compromised but the breach includes names, addresses and genders and birth dates of kids. >>> $3 billion yesterday, 12% increase in spending from last year. and it makes yesterday the biggest day ever for e -commerce. retailers marked items down 20% for their sales. >>> the higher customer traffic on target's website was apparently too much. it was intermittently un unavailable and target said they admitted to caused by high >>> a drop in gas prices, 24 consecutive days of declines. the national average $2.04. drivers in more states are now seeing prices at 1.50 and below. a twitter user in lafayette posting this picture, take a look showing prices for $1.43. >> you can get a fountain drink for 89 cents. all right. when we come back pulled o

ashley madison still faces lawsuits after members from last summer's big data breech, the company maye benefiting from the bad publicity. the one site now says on its own page that it has seen a rise in membership and an additional 4 million people have signed up. >> nothing will stand in our way. >> star wars the force awakens has become the fastest movie to reach $1 billion. it took 12 days. one day fewer than jurassic world, when that movie opened in june. star wars took in more than $153 million. daddy's home, joy, sisters, and alvin and the chipmonks rounded out the top five. now for a look at what's ahead, jeff is in for scott tonight. >> no charges in cleveland for the officers involved in the fatal shooting of tamir rice. plus, from floods to heavy snow, a brutal storm system slowly moves across the country. dozens died and more bad weather is on the way. those stories and more tonight on the cbs evening news. ,,,,,,,,,, ♪ life. you never really know what's coming. life just... happens. just when you think you know where it's going sfx: (ambulance sirens) it takes you someplac

as we've learned by watching silicon valley rise, big data sets are the gold, they are holy grail of monetization. and clearly, this is an effort to get government assistance, to get access to content that would allow you to collect the metadata around that content. if you're the tv one network, you negotiated effectively with charter or comcast for carriage. you've negotiated for what channel you sit on, what tier you'll be on. you had a negotiation around tezzing, what -- advertising, what the splits will be. you may have any number of other digital rights. if i give that deal to you and then that can be sucked out the back door through a box and put into google's box, right? who doesn't negotiate with tv one for access to the content but is merely taking it, and then you're free to strip out all that stuff he negotiated for, you're allowing one set of commercial interests to monetize valuable property that they didn't negotiate for and enjoy all the repneumonia rahtive benefits of doing so without having to share that with the content owner. if you ask me, that's just blatantly un

big, you know? if i want to add up a trillion numbers, mathematically that's no more different or profound or interesting than adding up two numbers. same operation, just on a larger scale. what's interesting, the data we have now from social networks, internet usage, the nsa has it from god knows where, we've got a lot of stuff. it's not just that it's big, it's that it's structured. it has all kinds of structures embedded in it, networks of people, geographic structures, time structures. mathematicians are -- i would go so far as to say having to invent a new kind of statistics as we go. the old methods are just not suitable, they were designed for controlled trial that is we did one at a time. now we've got the fire hose trained on it, and we're trying to figure out how to deal with it. it's an incredibly exciting time when there's so many new problems just trying to figure out how do you make sense of a spread sheet that's a trillion by a trillion, right? the human brain cannot do that. that's not what it's built to do. we have to figure out how to interpret those numbers, and we don't know yet. it's not magic, right? so i think a lot of people will have an interest in making it sound like we re

how works this is the world 's first cloud-based big data platform for fertility that layers predictivelytics on top of real-time data streams and we can source medical history and information. and then we can get clinical information, things like hormone levels currently from the electronic record system. what we are able to do is integrate this information into a report that the physician can use to more simply explain to a couple what their chances personally, not just in a 35-year-old couple are to maximize chances of getting pregnant. next year we will be launching the first genetic test for fertility potential. a physician can take into account with someone dna says about their potential as part of their overall treatment recommendation. emily: tell me about this test a little bit more. is it really possible, such a thing as a fertility gene? >> it is very similar. you mentioned it earlier i believe. it is very similar to brca testing for breast cancer risk. we are looking for genetic factors that encode fertility potential. we all have a friend who really struggled to get pregnan

. >>> another big data breach to tell you as the holiday shopping seen heats up, v-tech announces hackers have stolen the personal information of 5 million customers and their children. the hong kong-based company says credit cards and social security numbers have not been compromised but the breach includes addresses, names, gender, and birth dates of child users. i guess this might qualify as perhaps the cutest picture to emerge from the holayay season so far. it happened at a mall in indiana. >> let's an look at there little guy right there. he fell asleep waiting for his turn to have a picture taken with santa. so santa made the best of it and acted like he was taking a nap, too. he probably could have used the rest. >> the little guy's name is zeke. his dad was taking the pictures. since he posted them online, they've gotten nearly half a million likes. it's very, very cute. picture was taken at a mall in evansville, indiana. and so. >> making a nice comfortable cushion for him. >> exactly. who knew that santa's belly made a nice pillow. it does. an dad can't believe how adorable our

to do things with big data.ion. >> maria job safe not a robot that looks like maria talks like maria. >> i hope not. >> you and i we are out -- >> what does research say about -- >> replacement? >> got you. maria: kidding you made important point now the skills the onus on the individual to have right skills, we don't have that goes to education who is responsibility is it is it government is it businesses? that are actually going to come up with the right skills, to is actually arm us with right information to get the jobs that are available? >> yeah great question, not to be clichÉ does take a village, so education has to do better, i am onboard of a higher ed institution, constantly innovateing to figure out how to deliver good education that is broad enough to make people think, but narrower enough to prepare for workforce organizational psychologists high demand a correlation, companies need to make the talent they have better, because recruitment is not always the answer, so those orlgs psychologists k dep

big data is a very big thing. data crunching, they are hot on that, but you also have a lot of other startups. "thehave led -- read startup nation" book. whether it's the military, whether it's the culture, whether it's the risk-taking attitude or saying they like to think out of the box and not follow orders -- even the army, they are shown to take initial initiative -- an initiative. as things have developed, you've also got vc culture. instead of kids wanting their doctors -- their kids to be doctors or lawyers, they want them to be startup founders. emily: you recently talked to start a fire. elliott: they've got big-name clients such as kraft, and what they are trying to do is to help brands who might, for example, recommend third-party content. it could be from a newspaper. it could be from bloomberg.com. they want those brands to not lose those viewers but see them on their facebook or twitter page when they send them to look at something else. when i spoke with the founder morning, he explained how it works

and then we harness big data. that is what generated the level of insight over the last 15 years. from the seniormost policymakers to the tactical commanders and operation level come to rely on from nsa. we have got to maintain that legacy. i'm very confident in our ability to do it, given the men and women that i have the honor of serving with everyday. i would be the first to admit, it is not without challenges. >> a lightning round. we are getting the hook. we got a lot of questions on isis. some of these nonstate actors as you can imagine. thatpen to have something you apparently said, it is what keeps me up at night. michael: i have no problem sleeping. >> this has nothing to do with your bedroom have it. -- habits. what happens when a nonstate actor who has no interest in a status quo take isis for example, his vision is opposed to ours, start viewing the web is not just a vehicle to that -- theynue, instead view it as a weapons system. michael: what do we do? we look at -- >> you have social media and all of these challenges now. the good old days seem better. to use: how d

there is a big data set for a group or individual. we will be able to have a much .icher basis of a decision we will also be able to set up individual norms. intelligence community access. your norm is different from my norm. you leave at a certain time. your travel, expenditures and behavior is unique to you. mine is unique to meet. deviation,re is a and are suddenly showing up 2:00 a.m. on a sunday morning, and you never have before, a light goes off. maybe there was a crisis in your area and you got called in and maybe yourct the ok supervisor says i don't know why, he is never done that before there is no good reason. issue, you can build adjudication into the algorithm, as long as someone is behaving within the norm. when there is deviation from the established understood pattern. there may be certain websites. that should go off for everybody , not just a particular individual. this will give more clarity to an individual behavior. at the end of the day, when the little red lights go off or alarm bell rings, you want a human in

the fallen energy production is already showing up in the data big time.industrial production was really disappointing today. just up 0.2% because of this lower energy production as you can see. let's have a look at some of the oil majors. still, national oil companies in many sense, in terms of the weight they carry on the market. you see, rexle down. bp down over 5%. trading below $42 a barrel. there was a follow-through at the beginning of the session, from the upbeat comments we had here in new york, saying he was still dovish. and of course the huge 373 point rally in the dow, which as we were cutting the losses from earlier in the week on the disappointment. as you see, biggest loser today, electra lux. ge is canceling the deal they had with this swedish operator to buy their appliance business. as a result of the doj opposition. the department of justice fighting electrolux and ultimately ge pulling the plug on this. in france, today the head of the far right party that did so well in the first round of those regional elections held a news conferenc

cruz by big data. targeting being pulled together by panel analytics. they tell the cruz worker walking up to the door how to speak. >> they actually subdivide supporters into four subgroups and based on if there's, i forget the exact words but if there's a bit of a paranoia streak in them then they say talk guns and talk about overreaching a federal government. if they're stoic, they say talk about obamacare. a guy whose nervous about the federal government getting too much information about individuals are a campaign based on being as intrusive. it's humanly possible to gather big data and make up profiles of the people whose doors they knock on. >> i think it's phenomenal the way the campaigns target voters. every time you swipe a credit card, accepted a tweet we're creating a new data point. cruz's voters look most like the people we expect do show up at places like the iowa caucuses. the question remains is donald trump reshaping the republican primary elector to bring in a new group of people that wouldn't look like primary voters. they're frustra

they have gradually gotten better over time, now we are applying the internet, deep learning, big data, there is sort of an uptick. i've been dealing with since 1991, none are very believable. both siri and quintana are productivity tools. the designers of siri was to get something done. you ask a question i do get something done. gel gel ice is designed as a companion. 20,000,000 registered users, users, 10 million use it intensively, multiple conversations per day. 25% of gel ice users have set i love you too gel ice, 5050% have said thank you. it was even creeping up the microsoft designers. then i have this interesting conversation with a woman who is the former ibm researcher, she is chinese, she said you know when we come to your country it feels quiet. in china, interactions are so densely, people in contacts all the time. her her view is gel ice is private space. they call it toilet time. they go to the bathroom and have long conversations with gel ice. this is real. this is the world of her, were stepping into her. >> it sounds like her, does. as we get into this, there's anot

francine: this is big data.to ceos, to the chief investment officer's, to prime minister's. they want to understand better as they prepare for next year. simon: absolutely. the rise of the robots talks about the challenges people will face as we become an increasingly automated world -- francine: automated! simon: jobs that were once privy for humans have turned into robots. anchors? and news tom: it's a fabulous list. simon, congratulations. you see so many booklets and you ask if any of these are about them. a smar tlist. my book of the year is "hubris." simon, what i love about this book is the first 100 pages. he gives you and me a clinic on economic history. in his primal scream for humility after the blowup that we see. i thought -- it is a little it,, but the beginning of not that you would ever be at a cocktail party, that you are at a cocktail party and someone goes, how did this happen? and he nails that in the first 100 pages. simon: it's certainly the theme of the financial crisis. last year the book

>> we see a lot of things data toto using discover things that, i am not sure are a big data problem.ug will work for what disease? it would be nice to think that you could analyze a set of data and figure it out. to me, it goes away from basic biology and assumes it is all computational. >> we have talked about this. it is a huge problem that no one knows how to fix. patches to thef problem and not a solution. what needs to happen for us to actually have a solution integrated in the hospital and people truly communicating with their doctors in an on-demand the wholeughout country? >> there is a lot that needs to happen. the first is building the pipes. you have to have places for data flow and have it he ubiquitous. it cannot be interpreted. it is still in silos. the government is doing that and they are saying that every hospital and practitioner has to have electronic medical records. get the data out there. it is then ubiquitous and we have access to it on our phones and computers. the analytics are up in the clouds and that is where we will see the changes. we are seeing hundreds

. >> we want to capitalize on big data.understand the patents of prescription of veterinary products and when the patient is not using that products, doesn't come back for a refill. the whole idea with vet street is we'll make sure there's better compliance with the prescriptions issued that are so important. >> people spare no amount on pets. they're forgetful? >> they forget to renew their prescription, they forget to renew the pills. all of this stuff results in low compliance on many of the prescriptions that are issued by veterinarians. >> sounds like everybody should have that. i mean, we go to a reminder for the dentist. that's a good idea. >> right. in the vet space we have about half the veterinarians using our practice management software. you take our software with vet street's data information and we have the ability to help the pet owner with better compliance. >> all right. some questions on the conference call about the consolidation, the acquisition. you seem to think that it will be okay, won't hurt your di

can big data be one solution to this global pollution problem?ly: global climate talks in paris had been set to end today, but it looks like we will have to wait another day for the idle agreement. fromve all the details paris. carolyn: after two sleepless nights at the climate change summit, it seems negotiators are lining themselves up for a third because the overall announcement on a global agreement to help limit climate change emissions has been pushed back, pushed back by 15 hours because of some key stumbling blocks. primarily ambition. how will we see the global communities agree on how to keep on ratcheting up the pledges they have made? more than 180 countries have made pledges as to how much they will curb global omissions, but they have to keep on of -- .mproving them they have to keep on agreeing to monitoring, to verifying their pledges, and improving them. .keley, it is cold hard cash how will we see developed two $20transfer of billion to the developing nations, and who will contribute? to help take on the worst effects of global

productizehat we can big data delivery -- i have seen it. it is very impressive. think it is a lot of long-term potential. but it will take a while to get it looking as good as they needed to look and do the things they need it to do and to get companies to pony up the large dollars for it. betty: what about walmart? dr. eggers: this is been one of those years where walmart has been underperforming. there has been to -- there hasn't been one incident -- betty: their stock has gone down almost as much as chipotle. dr. eggers: walmart has been on a long the client throughout 2015. they have been investing lesson e-commerce and in their -- than in the physical retail. but this is where walmart has an actual advantage. i think investors are still valuing the company for a while as if there would be a chance if they would be the next amazon and compete in that space. i think we are realizing that is not going to happen. too busy working on large-scale brick-and-mortar delivery. it will still be very successful and there is a lot of money to be made. it is not sexy. it

example, there's a whole company that does nothing but derive and creatal go riches to search through big data. we're not using their capabilities. for heaven's sake, some of this is just ineptitude. i good go to social media, check out my granddaughter's new boyfriend, but the homeland security can't figure out they need to be tracking they jihadi web sites? some of this is bureaucratic ineptitude and a great deal is an administration that doesn't understand the urgency of the situation, and therefore this administration has not reached out actively to the private sector and said we need help. >>> the main super-pac separate, is now running an ad which linking you pretty directly to margaret thatcher. here's a clip. >> margaret thatcher once said she was not content to manage the decline of a great nation. neither am i. >> ms. fiorina, respectfully, isn't that a little over the top? >> first of all, it's not my ad. >> i understand. >> secondly, many people have commented on the comparison. i'm flattered by it, frankly. margaret thatcher was a great leader for her nation at a pivotal and a per