bill donohue is taking a lot of heat this morning. he is back as is joe saying no they were not asking for it. bill your position was there was no excuse for what happened, but you have to be careful. >> it's a tragic thing that happened. the muslims are the ones to blame. this guy who was killed he was a stupid man. because what you can't do is this i'm making an explanation not a justification. you cannot be virginal and say it's okay to continuely insult muslims with the most graphic anal things imaginable and pretend they are going to come after me. had he put restraint on himself he wouldn't have been shot. okay? that doesn't justify it, just making an observation. >> what do you think, bill? >> i think bill needs to go to confession. you need a smack on your knuckles with a nun's ruler. you are marginalizing freedom of speech. >> weapons of mass destruction? watergate? >> no. no. >> that's what he's saying. >> he's saying, i don't disagree with bill donohue. he's done great things for the catholic community. i am a die hard god f

god forbid you make fun of -- neil: bill donohue said he certainly condone the violence. he said there's such a thing as discretion. i'm paraphrasing. don't go too far when you parody or satire someone. you start policing yourself for fear. he said we hustlerrized it. this newspaper in france went too far. >> you should be able to to do what you want. it's a free society. neil: it's satire. >> even in the koran muhammad never said blasphemy. these are misguided thugs really. it has nothing to do with ideology. that's what's upsetting. neil: what about the bill maher types that think this is something that tens of millions agree with it, that they might not vocally say go, go, go, but they agree with this. they think it's blasphemy. >> i can't imagine that. you talked to gabriel as well. you see on the network. and robert spencer you had on. and we have him on our show as well. jihad watch. i can't imagine that. i think these are totally misguided thugs. the question is: how do you stop it. you should be able to say what you want. on snl, we were able to do anything. when

steven says i think that bill donohue is confusing moral censorship area and there must be a line of respect. another individual says that he does not speak for catholics or american. it was not up to him to draw the line. and then charlene says i absolutely understand bill donohue's point expressed on your show and i agree with him. and then there's kevin who says that you cannot keep poking the tiger with a stick and then be surprised when it attacks you. michael of south carolina said that we should have the right to say and think and go anywhere and do anything we want without this. and then putting all this in perspective, caputo says just because we all have the right to speak our minds doesn't mean that you do when you sound like a kid going through puberty when you do. shut up and stay home, see a doctor, the sound of you gets on my nerves, which is why i came in today. because i know about this. and if you can't talk go get well because your voice is annoying. and rob in new mexico says what is the deal with you not getting well. and stay home and get well, please. and come

. >> there's plenty of racist publications, there's people like bill donohue who are incredibly offensiveey exist. you don't have these kinds of violence around them, right? obviously, that creates different kinds of conversations. and one of these is pragmatism. do you want to get involved in this? >> and the fear, i think, harry, is the point that you end up with the sort of race at the bottom. harry sheer, imam fisel and matthew atkins, thank you very much. that is "all in" for this evening. good evening, rachel. >> thanks to you at home for joining us this hour.

. >> there's plenty of racist publications, there's people like bill donohue who are incredibly offensiveobviously, that creates different kinds of conversations. and one of these is pragmatism. do you want to get involved in this? >> and the fear, i think, harry, is the point that you end up with the sort of race at the bottom. harry sheer, imam fisel and matthew atkins, thank you very much. that is "all in" for this evening. good evening, rachel. >> thanks to you at home for joining us this hour. the newspaper office is now known as the scene of this terrorist attack. but, before, it became a place where 11 people were murdered. before that, it was just an office. it was easy to find. if you typed in charlie hebdo in paris, it pops right up. a simple google search. first hit. anybody with a computer or a smartphone can find exactly where they are, can use the street view feature to scope out

>> well, i think first off bill donohue is a great friend and defender of religious freedom. be respectful toward all religions. however, i do think that we have to protect the freedom to speak, even if it's in poor taste or bad form, and bill has the right to say what he wants to say and say freely. and while i disagree with what these media so-called journalist did in france, they have right to do. so but i think the bigger problem here lies with the government and how the government's been dealing with islam in their own country. >> back to these drawings you. raise a good point, and lauren, what the issue was with bill was that there is never ever a reason to kill anyone for something you don't like. however blasphemous or incentive or pornographic you find the images that incited these attacks, but that journalists in general have a responsibility to know the impact of their satire. what do you think of that? >> journalists have the ability and the backing to say whatever they want whenever they want. that's what this countries is about. that's what free speech is about.

after the murderous attack on this satire magazine yesterday, bill donohue blames the publisher, stephaneier is to blame for his own murder. >> it is too bad that he didn't understand the role played in his tragic death. bill, good to see you tonight. >> thank you. >> i saw you rolling your eyes when we talked about the courage of the satirists. i know you agree with their message. you said they were equal opportunity offenders. they didn't hit just islam, they hit catholicism judaism, you named it. i understand you didn't like the message. do you think they were not courageous in the face of death threats to be publishing what they did? >> no. i think first of all they're pornographers described as satires. we're not talking about mel brooks, we're talking about larry flynt going to -- >> larry flynt himself his embodiment of the first amendment himself was specifically recognized by the u.s. supreme court. >> that's exactly right. and i will make the point that i made my whole life, i'll make it again tonight. people have a legal right to insult my relijgion or somebody else's, they don

of the super majority of catholics of the court, for instance the bombastic bill donohue said, barely a peep was made. and the fact that for the first time in american history, no single protestantset among their constituents of one of the three branches of american government. hardly anyone seemed to notice that all. in making today is this __ among the many transformations that happened in the age of obama, and despite the rhetoric coming from the right, tthis team has come to be one of the most casual ways in which the country has come to accept it. this is great. it will be combat time. evidence for this is __ is everywhere. religious discrimination down in the united states, even though it has r sharply in other parts of the worl __ risen sharply in other parts of the world. in addition and of equal importance, i think, a large percentage of the claims are found to lack merit. would suggest that there is more fear than there is abuse. and perhaps the most compelling piece of evidence for the lack of interface in our days comes from the fact that the loudest claims of religious di

remarks on the state of american business and the economy thomas donohue called on congress to pass cyber security and immigration bills. and as part of the event, he took questions from readers. -- from reporters. >> thank you very much for your patience and for coming today. as you know, i'm tom donohue, president of the chamber. and in just a few minutes ago i delivered our annual look at the economy and business and what we might expect from others and what you could expect from us this year. if you missed it, there's a copy of the speech they're giving you, as is always the question the case, but not last year. because he was in the hospital scared the hell out of us. bruce josten who is our executive vice president of all things we do with government and related matters. a number of our senior advisors are here that handle many of these subjects and so they're over there and they're over there. you can catch them all at the end of your questions and pursue some of your issues in more depth. as i said in the speech, the chamber believes the state of american business is improving. and that the economy is gaining m

a cybersecurity information sharing bill, without delay as he says and a measure giving president obama more authority to negotiate free trade negotiations. donohueiticized the length of the approving the xl pipeline, calling the lent of the process as a political joke. david. david: rich edson, thanks very much in d.c. liz. >> look at lower part of your screen to see stocks tumbled again today. here is what the dow did, plunged two days in a row of double, triple-digit losses following weak december retail sales. could today's disappointing number trigger a market correction beyond one or go% per day we've seen already? let's bring in the panel. mark newton, gray wolf partners. neil hennessey, portfolio manager and cio and along with our own tracy byrnes. mark newton, to the charts with the emotion strained out of this, sift aid was, what happens here? are we starting to see a major correction on the horizon more than 5%? on the day what are you expecting out here. >> you can't really make that case just yet, liz. we haven't seen sufficient deterioration that the markets need to pull back more from here. it pulled back 1% from the lows. so it fe