name is bill i'm a third generation native san franciscan and i'm here to support the nomination of bob hirsho the police commission i serve professionally as a contract administrator for the northern california carpenter union master agreement 46 county the northern california and in the last 10 years i've served with bob on our arrebitration - he treats people with compassionate and you've got a good person and highly recommend him for the police commission thank you. >> thank you. next speaker. >> thank you my name is jay i'm not a native san franciscan i've moved her 40 years ago and lived in district 4 for the last 20 question live a few mr. cook's away from each other i don't know him from the neighborhood but now job i worked with the u carpenters local 22 and bob is the arresting translator we use when we have differences with our folks bob hears complex disputes between workers and lawyers and listens carefully asked thoughtful questions and rules with judgment the skill set bob brings will be an asset in exactly what the police commission in san francisco needs i urge you to move fo

name is bill i'm a third generation native san franciscan and i'm here to support the nomination of bob hirsho the police commission i serve professionally as a contract administrator for the northern california carpenter union master agreement 46 county the northern california and in the last 10 years i've served with bob on our arrebitration - he treats people with compassionate and you've got a good person and highly recommend him for the police commission thank you. >> thank you. next speaker. >> thank you my name is jay i'm not a native san franciscan i've moved her 40 years ago and lived in district 4 for the last 20 question live a few mr. cook's away from each other i don't know him from the neighborhood but now job i worked with the u carpenters local 22 and bob is the arresting translator we use when we have differences with our folks bob hears complex disputes between workers and lawyers and listens carefully asked thoughtful questions and rules with judgment the skill set bob brings will be an asset in exactly what the police commission in san francisco needs i urge you to move fo