commissioner borden arrest commissioner hillis. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you on public comment there are no speaker cards >> is there any general public comment seeing none, public comment is closed. meeting >> good morning, everyone and welcome to the san francisco board of supervisors budget and finance committee meeting for wednesday, may 14th, 2014, my name is mark farrell and i will be sharing this committee and i am joined by supervisor john avalos and breed and, we will be joined by eric mar and scott weiner and i want to thank the members of sfgtv as well as the clerk of the committee, linda wo ng. >> silence all cell phones and electronic devices and complete the speaker cards and all of the documents to be included as part of the file should be submitted items will appear on the may 20 agenda. >> a few procedural items we have a long agenda, we will take a break from 12:30 to 1:20 wherever we are at that point in time, and

commissioner borden arrest commissioner hillis. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you on public comment there are no speaker cards >> is there any general public comment seeing none, public comment is closed. meeting >> the renovation of balboa park, the oldest in the city of san francisco, and now it is the newest part in the city of san francisco. through our partnership, and because of public investment from the two thousand eight fund, we are celebrating a renewal and an awakening of this park. we have it safer, happier, more joyous. >> 3, 2, 1, [laughter] =--[applause] >> it is a great resource for families, to have fun in the city, recreation. >> this is an amazing park. we have not revitalized it without public and private investment. the critical piece of the process of this renovation was that it was all about the community. we reached out to everyone in this community. we love this park dearly and they all had thoughts and ideas an

commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. and commissioner antonini will be joining us shortly first, it the consideration for continuance item one case at 1010 bush stre 1010 bush street conditional use authorization is for case numbers d d and d and case 2010 at the 2820th century lake street conditional use are proposed for june 20th, 2014, i have no other items proposed for conditions i have one speaker card >> karen jones. >> other mike please. this is item one a-1010 bushy own the building next door i'm new to the process but this is the second continuance i'm trying to plan my summer vacation is there a limit to how much time something can be continued i want to be sure and there's no before and after but mr. magaziney. >> the project planner. >> okay. great. >> is there any public comment on items proposed for continuance seeing none, public comment is closed. commissioner moore >> move to continue as noted. >> second. >> commissioners, on that motion as proposed. commissioner antonini. commissioner borden. commission

no >> commissioner borden. >> no. that commissioner hillis. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong >> no. president fong. no >> that motion fails 2 to 5 is there an alternative motion there is no alternative motion it will be approved in its current form. >> thank you, commissioners shall we move on to the next item it is item 15 for the next case at the 1423 ocean avenue a mandatory discretionary review on may 1st time f first, the commission continued the matter to this date by a vote of 5 to zero and commissioner antonini upper recused and commissioner antonini i recommend you request that recall again and president fong in order for you to participate in today's hearing you have to acknowledge you've reviewed the materials. >> yes. i was planning to participate pending a communication with the city attorney but there is still a little bit cloudy i'm no longer the owner of any dental practice, however, 0 over $100 to the practice an outside contractor so this is a gray area in my mind and until we get complete clarification i'm going to have to ask for a rue re

commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore per and commissioner sugaya and commissioners, first on your calendar is the items for continuance item one application information on anti description housing policies a considers of a proposed ordinance is to be turned to june 12, 2014, from a reof supervisor campos office and item 2 at the 722 south van ness avenue is proposed to june 12, '47. i have no other items proposed for continuance and no speaker card >> any public comment seeing none, public comment is closed. >> not yet ma'am, we'll call you under general public comment. >> commissioner sugaya. i move to continue those to the dates >> commissioners, on that motion to june 12th. commissioner antonini pr commissioner borden. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes amazing 7 to zero and places you under our consent calendar and routine commission. there will be no separate discussion of these items unless a member

>> commissioners on that motion to approve, with conditions, commissioner antonini. >> aye. >> borden. >> aye. >> hillis. >> aye. >> moore. >> aye. >> sugaya. >> aye. >> and commissioner fong. >> aye. >> the motion passes, 6-0 and places you on 19 b. >> thanks very much commissioners, case number 2014.0160 c, 2055 b, union street and request for conditional use authorization. >> good evening, again, vice president fong and members of the commission, planning department staff and the item for you is the question for a conditional use for 2055 b union street and the proposal is to allow a limited restaurant doing business as espressamente, illy located on the east end of the building, the proposed establishment will occupy, 1500 square feet, the operation will consist of 6 full time employees and operate 7 days a week from 7:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. currently, there are ten locations nationwide, two are the locations are in san francisco, on battery street and market street, at this time the project does not qualify as formula retail and no changes to the building envelope are proposed. the

commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you under our discretionary review calendar. item 14 for the case d at the 1110 ashburg after may first, they continued the matter by a vote of 6 to zero commissioner fong upper absent at this item and for you to participate you'll have to say you've reviewed the materials and that's correct i watched it on sfgovtv and am ready. >> if we can say add consulted the secretary on how to consultation the hearing this is the third hearing we just decided to allow for the staff for 3 minutes from the dr requester and open this up for public comment. >> okay. >> good afternoon. commissioner president wu and members this case is a discretionary review for 1110 ashbury street to allow the property owner project sponsor to work on the design and incorporate feedback. as a reminder the dr was filed by the resident directly from the adjacent property to the north. the dr re

commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero. commissioner fong >> i was absences at the leasing last hearing and had the ability to look at it on line and prepared to take action. >> i believe there's a request to make a statement. >> good afternoon, commissioners we were just informed today that the public health department has made a question on the developer and granted a permit through the change of ownership we request that item 15 the discretionary review on ocean avenue be continued to the commission can include and consider supervisor yee's legislation on the developer clustering the supervisor is not against the applicant but we're incentive to the clustering of the cannabis dispensaries on motioning mission avenue. >> commissioner sugaya i wish the city attorney were here i have a procedural question maybe staff know the answer. since this is pending as has been pending for awhile even if supervisor yee's legislation going

commissioner borden is expected to run late this is items for continuance the first at the tennessee bush street for for the next case and 2014 d at the 3305 broadway restrict street are for may 14 and the next case golden gate avenue conditional use authorization and the next at 23 turk boulevard is for indefinite continuance and further on your regular calendar for the next case bona fide eating place we've received a request from the supervisors office asking for a continuance >> i have no speaker cards. >> are there that any comments on the items proposed for continuance? >> good afternoon, commissioners i'm mrs. mcauthor i live on bush street across from tennessee bush street this was brought brought to my attention i said have opposed it i want you to know we have a lot of elderly people on bush street and their concerned about the - ma'am, on this time we're only taking comments on the matters of continued. >> this is continued. >> this is to support the conditions to that continue for a different date for example. >> i'd like to continue and i'll be back on the 22nd i apologi

commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong. commissioner president wu so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero >> the commission will take a 20 minute break. >> thursday, may 22, 2014. i'd like to remind please silence all electronic devices. that may sound off and and when speaking before the commission, if you care to, do state your name for the record. commissioners we left off under your regular calendar on item 11. the mission alcohol beverage special use ordinance amending the alcohol beverage special use district. diego sanchez i'll be talking about the special use district alcohol beverages, however, i'm i'm to provide supervisor campos office with time to present on the motivator >> good afternoon, commissioners the amendment to 9 special district is pretty small a narrow exception allowing the miniature golf course to serve alcohol beverages and bowling alleys enjoy this similar section and approached by a company and the business was conceived the people have been in the ne

. >> commissioner borden commissioner hillis. commissioner moore commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you on item 12 a and braxton building inspection commission on bush street a request for kufks and we're consider requires for variances. >> good afternoon commissioner president wu and members of the board. i'm with the staff. the project is located at 1430 bush street and a conditional use authorization to construct a hundred and 15 at all mixed use construction and with the rent a car at the current location. you may recall it was heard by planning commission on september 9th of 2013 and just to bring to our memory the project that was shown at that time, in september. one hundred and 15 foot tall building with 32 unit facing a alley and at that time, there was a few members of public that spoke in opposition and if the commission continued to further work on the design. and there were concerns about a central courtyard in which the unit that faced the courtyard

commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you under commission matters item four for the draft minutes for may 8 >> is there any public comment on the draft minutes seeing none, public comment is closed. commissioner sugaya >> i mows move to a adapt the minutes. >> commissioner antonini pr commissioner borden. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore pursue commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu. commissioners, on that motion that passes so moved, commissioners, that motion passes and places you on commissions questions or comments and commissioner antonini >> i'm not sure this issue falls under the jurisdiction of mta or the city through planning or is state of california but i had it pointed out to me from a visitor out of town that almost all signs are packaging prohibited and under every sign is a pan herald so if it's the cities job or the states job it says civic job

if not, commissioner borden? >> i don't necessarily want to know, nor is it germane to our discussion, the battle that is going on, but it disappointing that people are fighting each other about medical care that people need. i don't know enough to take anyone's side in this, but for our consideration, we just look at the facts of the case and in general, i mean, if the health department doesn't have a problem with the applicant, and we're not currently talking about clustering, because that is not just really what our determination is related to i don't see its a zero-sum game. i don't know what is going to happen in the future, but i don't see its a zero-sum game that you have to knock one business out in order for another one to be located somewhere. i just don't think that is the case. i understand that there is a concern that this is indeed true and we have that in other conditional use cases where a bar purchases another bar or things like that, but i always think those kind of anti-competitive sort of beha

commissioner borden? >> i would support commission er wu's interpretation. >> >> commissioner antonini? >> i will make a motion to continue to may 22. >> before we vote on it, stilled feel there is greement from the commission and i don't want both partis to come back on the 22nd and we end up at the same endpoint. >> we see two plans, one kind of outlining some of the things that commission moore and commissioner sugaya have suggested and one with what has been stated by other commissioners and then we can see what look better. i don't have any other solution there. >> commissioner moore. >> i don't have any particular plan or solution. i'm not here to design the building, but i would like to suggest that the building with interpretation from the zoning administrator help to address some of the common open space obligations that these projects need to fulfill? how that is done, is something that the residential design team could greatly help with. if your interpretation before was very kind of delineated

commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis. commissioner moore and commissioner sugaya and you commissioner president wu. so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero. that places you on items 17 a and b for the next case at the 456, 7th street mandatory discretionary reviews. >> good evening commissioner president wu and members of the planning commission i'm presenting a you mandatory discretionary review for a don't guess of a single-family dwelling a proposed new 3 story 2 family the address is 4 hundred and 5627 street. the current building is owner accompanied and contains 9 hundred quiet with one bedroom and one bath no off-street parking and the two family dwelling with one unit on the ground floor about 9 hundred and 23 square feet and the second unit occupies the second and third floors with 2 thousand 2 hundred and 61 square feet e square feet with 2 off-street parking spaces. the proposed building has been reviewed by your design team and the rtd said it's consistent with the residential design

> i'm will have interested in hearing that i wasn't sure how it came about. >> take commissioner borden's opinion that it was from 20 feet but the inspires are looking to narrow the case so whatever the case it tilts e it's woerthd hearing about. >> commissioner moore. >> i support we bring this back to the commission. >> moving on that places you on directors announcements. >> good afternoon john ram there's a hearing on the land use committee an is street width in the hunters point shipyard plan the fire department has asked for wireder streets for fire access reasons we'll be laborer the issues to find a way to accommodate their desire with not making the streets too wide and discourage racing on the streets so we're working with the other agencies right now and well, certainly be happy to schedule a hearing when the calendar permits. >> so we'll schedule the hearing and let the public know about it. >> the hearing on monday is that land use committee at the board of supervisors at the 1:30. secondly, i want to reinforce for the purposes of the commission and public there's a ocean ave

. >> commissioner borden. >> i want to echo the other commissioners comments i'm thrilled this is moving forward. when the redevelopment went away we were concerned i want to compliment you talking about the parks and groceries i recognize this is different there wasn't a developer set up but ate a great guide for future projects. thanks >> commissioner sugaya. >> yes. one last question ms. flores can you repeat this the grocery store aspect is in phase one or mr. rich whatever i think there's a provision in there there's a length of time that's been set forth in which they're going to get a grocery store into the space and emily can help me confronting the grocery store must be included in phase one and the key kick in when the project sponsor comes in for phase two and it can't be granted until phase one has received the t co and pulled ti permits to make sure the groceries is happening. but in recognition i'll tell you we've been working with the project sponsor this is not an easy location for a grocery store it takes work to get an operator there a because not a lot of housing and t

commissioner borden >> commissioner hillis.

amount to the front but acknowledge the adjacent neighbors this has not done that >> commissioner borden. >> i'm primarily voting for this if with we have a better way we could debate this 65 times over i'm happyly entertain another motion if there's a think a alternative idea but no one wants to take a position that's the issue i'm having here. commissioner moore >> i want to add one comment that applies to all of us ada is a human right and something that expresses itself in code and you can't avoid that this is a technical knowledge and i mentioned three-quarters of an inch i happened to consultant with someone that's an ada person skyline architect and just excuse me. ly speaking could this be done there was a clear answer to, yes this is a very large home and has a lot of spaces to do something we're not talking about the minimal dimensions to meet the code required for ada and access availability. it's not here as a group knowing the fact it was the triggers for the r a that's basically why their pulling back that leaves us with the other responsibility of thinking about the neighb

so i think it's a good project >> commissioner borden. >> i also any very supportive the project it's a great job when we had the draft eir concerns the partnering has begun a long way in fixing the blank wall and kind of the different ways of the facade and structure you have the breaking up of it and the surroundings area is effective and the incorporation of the historic facade i guess we can't say historic building it's great to see those being incorporated i'm not a fan of the facade being close to the gas station it didn't go as well with the building. so that's my thing i also think it's great you're doing the one site affordable i recognize the members that feel their concerns are not addressed but i know the testament of the 3 associations being supportive and the neighbor across the street, you know, not unsupportive i also support the project and i will wait to make a motion - and >> oh, there are a number the commissioners so i'll wait for other people to speak. >> commissioner hillis. >> i'm also supportive the scale is okay. i think it works well. and i like the design i

commissioner borden. no. commissioner hillis. commissioner moore. if you could for the record if europe following the procedures >> commissioner moore. >> no. >> commissioner sugaya. commissioner fong and commissioner president wu >> that motion passes 5 to 2 with the commissioners commissioner borden and commissioner moore voting against. xhirgz commissioners that places on item is 13 for a conditional use authorization >> good afternoon president chiu and planning staff this is for a at&t making could facility the project site is a 41 foot tall church the site was developed as the george washington ma sonic area and the site is surrounded by single-family residences with the expectation of the park as well as the mixed use building to the south the dell tin and the residents above will feature panel on the roof or sectors that will be set back and rise 6 feet above the roof and it will mimic penthouse elements the facility features a cage roof access ladder in the northeast corner of the building as well as a rear yard equipment area in the area c

serious and stand with the three of us or the 4 of us extending hours on this matter >> commissioner borden. >> i've been here since 2002 i think we've been through the process and there's been problems and times when the academy is moving he slowly but we've set a process in place and the zoning administer has set a deadline we know what that is and we can rightfully look at the individual projects and not lump everything to together we have a process and you don't think i don't see any harm until waiting until that occurs and having the meeting and prescribed time probably december figured out it depends on if it comes earlier or later and following through with the process and begin when everything is eir is final we can begin with the process. it's unfortunate it had to come to this were it not for the insistence of the city each one of the standards would be completed but we've asked it be a complete eir including a traffic study this is manage that takes a lot of time and we're asking them to comply and if they client we don't have to spend time on another meeting to schedule the meet

. >> commissioner borden. >> i guess i'm a little more optimistic. i think the change of the way manufacturing happens today, so much of it happens via design through computer and the like. so there can be a mix and i think it's incumbent upon us to figure out that mix and looking at the cohen-campos legislation that created the mix for pdr is something that we should use as a guide and i think that staff should look at in this period, while we're waiting to consider the central corridor plans, my understanding this is actually in the corridor area. if we actually can -- maybe we come up with a policy or do something, because i think it is sort of like what is the point of a zoning process if everybody changes zoning before you finish that process? so maybe we should think about some sort of policy regarding especially the sli or the areas of the district that are much more uncertain in terms of zoning? and what is that policy? maybe it's something that the commission agrees as a policy that we want to adopt. maybe we want to do always hybrid. you kn

. >> commissioner borden? >> '? >> instructor: a. commissioner hillis? >> aye. >> commissioner moore? >> aye. >> commissioner sugaya? >> aye. >> commission president wu? >> aye. >> so moved, commissioners that motion passes unanimously 6-0. >> do we need to keep this material? >> i would imagine you are going to be receiving revised plans. >> >> okay. commissioners, that will place you on your last agendized item, no. 17, for case no. 2013.340d, at 1423 [ao-fb/] avenue a request for a mandatory discretionary review. >> commissioner antonini. >> i am going to have to recuse myself from this. i am waiting for interpretation. i have project sponsor is a dental patient of mine. we're not entirely sure whether his services at this point and renumeration and once i have a clear understanding for project probings it may have a similar circumstance, but in this case we'll just have to ask for recusal today. >> move to recuse. >> second. >> good evening. >> sorry, one second. on the recusal of commissioner antonini commissioner antonini? >> aye. >> commissioner b

motion and second to continue to may 22nd on that motion, commissioner borden? >> aye. >> commissioner hillis? >> aye. >> commissioner moore? >> aye. >> commissioner sugaya? >> aye. >> commission president wu. >> aye. >> so moved commissioners and that motion passes unanimously 5-0. >> to staff, to work with the neighborhood groups to see if they wouldn't come up with a position in the next 2-3 weeks. maybe it's asking too much, but they have known about this information. >> i can reach out to the community groups and ask them what their position is supporting it or neutral? >> thank you, tell them we're asking them. >> i will do that. >> commissioners, if there is nothing further on this matter, that will place you on public comment and i have no speaker cards. >> any general parkway public comment? >> seeing none, general public comment is closed. meeting adjourned. yes. hello? >> so we're going to start i want to thank you all for coming i'm randy shaw the director of the town tenderloin it's been 5 years that we've worked to make the tenderloin museum a real