owe other wholesale customers that have guarantees i think you know this is a question that we and bosca would like to be in conversation with them one possible answer from the commission palo alto is san francisco has done it's part by providing one and 84 our job and your job to make that work with the 12w40e8 customers i think that is one position to incentivize that decision and the minimum purchase agreement that might help the conversation. >> commissioners. >> i would be interested in hearing the public comments i know we have representatives from- >> we'll go to public comment and circle back to us first bryan perkins is here from congresswoman bureaus office good afternoon. >> good afternoon we appreciate this opportunity to speak on above the palo alto compensatory damages vaechd stretched in east palo alto we appreciate 24 the system pratsdz on behalf of the decision that benefit the user and san francisco public utilities commission has been the trust since the city the city of palo alto is in a tough position and growth and the city is unable to provide the basic needs for t