the next speakers are brett palmer and ip maine. on deck are congresswoman sanchez and colin o'mara. >> good morning. my name is brett palmer. i am senior vice president for government relations at peabody energy. using coal for electricity enables more people to live longer and look better and it drives the lowest u.s. electricity costs for any major fuel. peabody profoundly disagrees with epa's approach on carbon under the clean air act. we are opposed to this proposal that would punish electricity consumers at no material benefit under climate. and this indeed outside the bounds of the law and the clean air act. this proposal -- >> could you get just a bit closer? >> yeah, i'm sorry. peabody has profound disagreement with the carbon on the clean air act. we are opposed to this proposal is that punishes electricity consumers, has no material benefit under climate theory and is outside the bounds of the clean air act itself. this proposal must be withdrawn. access to clean affordable energy is essential at a time when a record 115