just 5 minutes for leipsic to school sell some bits of poking home a team of them across was the bush cheney aloft a half an hour then applying the finishing touch this time was christopher to pile driver maybe 3 up to 35 minutes was and marcel house the bag slotted home soon after the formula was the 5th arrived just before half time you see how sad this time of the band fan of crap they 2nd soon after the restart was 6 nil to leipzig but they weren't on then nobody will care he's had to make it 7 after 15 minutes have before i defend save makes up gifted like seek and i have one final goal was the cop's biggest ever wimsey the oem here's a look at all of the results so far from best a 10 frankfurt preyed on bar big time 51 winning that when the berlin darby with the home side you know no way laver couldn't fail to go dog main down the wall spurred as he dissolved life molly whopped mites by 8 goals bravely shared the spoils of freiburg on friday night hoffenheim had a cakewalk victory against drug dealing pot a bone. here we see pavel cut a rabbit feeding the long ball the year get a look

i mean, for gosh sakes, this woman worked as a field -- in the field for bush/cheney running for president and then found her way into the foreign service from a clearly political beginning of her career, so any attempts to couch these witnesses and how powerful was that opening statement of lieutenant colonel when he said in russia, if i were in russia and speaking truth to power, even if i respectd a ed and did behind closed doors, it would be a problem, and frankly if i did it publicly like this, i would be killed. >> this is what colonel vindman testified to in his opening statement. in russia my act of expressing my concerns to the chain of command in an official and private channel would have severe personal and professional repercussions, and offering public testimony involving the president would surely cost me my life. i'm grateful for my father's brave act of hope 40 years ago and for the privilege of being an american citizen and public servant where i can live free of fear for mine and my family's safety. not the whole picture. there are news accounts in the wall street journal

correct prior to becoming a nonpartisan career official you worked as a field representative for the bush cheney campaign in 2004 and then you held a political appointment in the department of homeland security under secretary chertoff is that correct that's correct sir and now as a foreign service officer you have served 3 presidents 2 republicans and one democrat a variety of roles correct yes or and in your current position you're detailed from state to advise the vice president on foreign policy towards europe and russia correct that's right is williams on sunday the president personally targeted you in a tweet this is after he targeted ambassador you event of edge during her hearing testimony i'd like to show and read you the tweet it reads tell jennifer williams whoever that is to read both transcripts of the presidential calls and see the just released statement from ukraine then she should meet with the other never trump who i don't know and mostly never even heard of and work out a better presidential attack ms williams are you engaged in a presidential attack there is williams are you

cheney. --ice that bush is portrayed you can barely see him in his seat in comparison to cheney. there you are. one of the interesting things to me as i reach this in march 2007 is actually that on the inside, cheney's power is actually waiting a lot in the second term. public image has not caught up to reality yet. in this particular episode, it did not help. bush himself had to go out and publicly state that he thought the firings had not been handled well. that famous expression was uttered, mistakes were made. no one involved in this came out looking good. they did not go viral. >> the next step that happened ,fter that in the aftermath was there was somebody at the justice department interviewing new u.s. attorneys and saying, how much do you love your president, please tell me. there was a loyalty question added to the job interview that hit the washington post. there were rogue line prosecutors who saw an opening because they felt the justice department was on the rocks little bit. they indicted senator ted stevens, and that was the beginning of how the indictment got thro

cheney would dominate the conversation. happened.e opposite bush completely dominated the conversation and you had to work hard to actually get questions into cheney and get him to talk. afterwards, the democrats say, need i was cheney's plan all along. but -- by the way, people who knew bush knew it was not a surprise. this was in the spring of 2004. articulate and he has a characteristic decisive style. his style is entirely different from clinton, who also fills up the room conversationally. but clinton is full of wandering digressions and speculations and just burns the clock up on you when you are questioning him, which i did. bush is not like this at all. bush is incredibly direct, to the point, this, this comic key point, boom, boom, next. that was very much the pattern when we actually talked to him in 2004. here you are a few years later and you know why. michael: let me ask a question of all of you. there are certain presidents of whom the public perceptions forms that there must be somebody in their administration, or somebody in their w

bush administration and after working as a field representative on the 2004 bush cheney presidential campaign. she joined the foreign service the following year completing tours in jamaica beirut and lebanon prior to joining the office of the vice president she served at the us embassy in london as a public affairs officer in april 29th team ms williams was detailed to the office of the vice president mike pence where she serves as a special advisor on his foreign policy team covering europe and russia issues in that capacity she keeps the vice president to where foreign policy issues in europe and russia and prepares them for foreign policy engagements and meetings with foreign leaders to final points before witnesses are sworn 1st witness depositions as part of this inquiry were unclassified in nature and all open hearings will also be held at the unclassified level and the information that may touch on classified information will be addressed separately 2nd congress will not tolerate any reprisal threat of reprisal or attempt to retaliate against any u.s. government official for t

in fact, she worked on the bush/cheney campaign before joining the service for former dhs secretary under bush. in addition to that, she has served, just prior to coming to the white house, for trump's ambassador to the united kingdom. and she would not have gotten the job at the white house without his positive recommendation. it's important to bear in mind that jennifer, along with the other foreign service officers that are being brought up to capitol hill under subpoena are doing this as career officials, not as a partisan exercise. and it is incredibly damaging to the service for us to start labeling people with certain partisan agendas, because ultimately they have to carry that label when they go back out to the field, deal with foreign leaders. it's just damaging to our national security. >> she's already testified behind closed doors as you know, testify that she felt that the president's request of the ukrainians struck her as unusual, struck her as inappropriate as well. how significant do you think her public testimony is going to be? >> well, i think what you will see, both f

bush administration and after working as a field representative on the 2004 bush/cheney presidential campaign. she joined the foreign service the following year completing tours in jamaica, beirut and lebanon. prior to joining the office of the vice president, she served at the u.s. embassy in london as a public affairs officer. in april 2019, ms. williams was detailed to the office of the vice president, mike pence, where she serves as a special adviser on his foreign policy team covering europe and russia issues. in that capacity she keeps the vice president aware of foreign policies and prepares him for meetings with foreign leaders. two final points before witnesses are sworn. first witness depositions as part of this hearing were unclassified in nature and all hearings will be held at the unclassified level. any information touched on classified information will be addressed separately. second, congress will not tolerate reprisal, threat of reprisal before testifying before congress including you or any of your colleagues. if you would both please rise and raise your right hand,

bush administration and working on the bush/cheney presidential campaign. prior to joining the office of the vice president, she served at the u.s. embassy in london as a public affairs officer. in april 2019 miss williams was detailed to the office of the vice president, mike pence, where she serves as a special adviser on his foreign policy team covering europe and russia issues. in that capacity she keeps the vice president aware of foreign policies in europe and russia and prepares him for foreign policy engagements and meetings with foreign leaders. two final points before our witnesses are sworn. first witness depositions as part of this inquiry were unclassified in nature and all open hearings will also be held at the unclassified level. any information that may touch to classified information will be addressed separately. second, congress will not tolerate any reprisal, threat of reprisal or attempt to retaliate against any u.s. government official for testifying before congress, including you or any of your colleagues. if you would both please rise

and after working as a field representative on the 2004 bush/cheney presidential campaign.he joined the foreign servicet tos inamaica, joining the offic the vice president, she served at the u.s. embassy of london as a public affairs vice president mike pence where she serves as a special adviser on his foreign policy team covering europe and russia issues. in that capacity, she keeps the vice president aware of foreign policy issues in europe and russia and prepares him for foreign policy engagements and meade meetings with foreign leaders. two final points before witnesses are sworn. first witness depositions as part of this inquiry were unclassified in nature and all open hearings will also be held at the unclassified level. any information that may touch on classified information will be addressed separately. second, congress will not tolerate any reprisal, threat of reprisal, or attempt to retaliate against any official testifying before congress, oan colleagues. if you will both please rise i will begin by swearing you in. do you swear or affirm that the testimony you

> prior to becoming a nonpartisan career official, you worked as a field representative for the bush cheney foundation in 2004. you have served three presidents. >> yes, sir. >> and in your current position, you're advise the vice preside policy towards russia, that's correct? >> that's correct. >> sunday the president personally targeted in a tweet after he targeted ambassador yovanovitch during her hearing testimony. i would like to read you and show you the tweet. tell jennifer williams, whoever that is, to read both transcripts of the presidential call and see the just released statement from ukraine. then she thud meet with the other never-trumpers who i never heard of and work out a better presidential attack. miss williams, are you involved in aid presidential attack? >> no, sir. >> are you a never-trumper? >> i don't know the official definition of a never-trumper -- >> are you? >> no. >> did that make an impact on you when you read it? >> it surprised me. i didn't expect to be called out by name. >> it surprised me, too. it looked like witness tampering in an effect to get you to,

. >> part to being becoming a non-partisan field official you worked for the bush cheney chain in 2004 and held a political appointment in the department of homeland security under secretary cherdoff is that correct. >> that's correct. >> now as a foreign service officer you served three presidents one republican two democrats in a variety of roles. >> that's correct. >> you advised presidents on forms forwards europe and russia is that correct. >> that's correct. >> ms. williams on president personal targeted you in a twet after he targeted ambassador yovanovitch during her hearing testimony. i'd i'd like to read you the tweet reading tell jennifer williams whoever that is to read both transcripts of the presidential calls and see the just released statement from ukraine and meet with the other never trumpers who i don't know and mostly never heard of and work out a better presidential attack. ms. yms are you engaged in a presidential attack. >> no, sir. >> are you a never trumper. >> i'm not sure i know of a an official definition of a never trumper. >> would you describe yourself th

bush administration and after working as a field representative on the 2004 bush/cheney presidential campaign. she joined the foreign service the following year completing tours in jamaica, beirut and lebanon. prior to joining the office of the vice president she served at the u.s. embassy in london as a public affairs officer. in april 2019 ms. williams was detailed to the office of the vice president, mike pence, where she served as a special advisor on his foreign policy team covering europe and russia issues. in that capacity she keeps the vice president aware of foreign policy issues in europe and russia and prepares him for foreign policy engagements and meeting with foreign leaders. two final points before witnesses are sworn. first witness depositions as part of this inquiry were unclassified in nature and all open hearings will also be held at the unclassified level. any information that may touch on classified information will be addressed separately. second, congress will not tolerate any reprisal, threat of reprisal or attempt to retaliate against a government official te

bush administration after working as a field representative on the bush cheney presidential campaign she joined foreign service the following year beirut lebanon and jamaica. prior to joining the office of the vice president she served as the public affairs officer at april 2019 was detailed to the office of the vice president where she serves as a special advisor on foreign policy team covering europe and russia issues she keeps the vice president aware of issues and prepares them for foreign-policy engagements worker two final points, the first witness deposition were unclassified the principal advisor the national security adviser on ukraine and other countries in my portfolio the role the nsc is to develop and coordinate and implement the lands and policies with a full range of diplomatic military and economic national security issues for my core function is to corn a policy with the department and agencies. the committee has heard from many colleagues of the strategic importance working against russian aggression. is important to know our policyg ukrainian sovereignty and prospe

liz cheney was in the george w. bus bush/dick cheney state department and likely intercepted with ambassador yovanovitch. i don't know that, but liz cheney was a senior state department official and marie yovanovitch had hardship postings in the kinds of countries where a lot of foreign policy as it rises to the highest level of the white house reaches. it's likely that liz cheney knows her. i'm interested in your thoughts about that, claire. >> she's not afraid of trump. i think she thinks that her pedigree and her standing in her state is strong enough that she could withstand a trump-backed primary. and so that's all the calculation that's going on on the hill for most of these republicans. they'll tell me, you know, we know it's awful, we know what's going on is terrible, but we've got to be here to block his worst instincts and we need to hold onto power so you guys get stuff done. >> i've had people in my life i've disagreed with ideologically but i have complete trust in their integrity. the late charles krauthammer w

. >> prior to becoming a nonpartisan career official, you worked for the bush/cheney campaign in 2004 and held a position in homeland security? >> correct. >> you have served three presidents, two republicans and one democratic in a variety of roles, correct in. >> yes, sir. >> your detailed to state to advise foreign policy in russia. >> that's correct. >> personally targeted you in a tweet. this is after he targeted ambassador yovanovitch during her hearing testimony. i'd like to show and read you the tweet. tell jennifer williams to read both transcripts of the presidential calls and see the just-released statement from ukraine and she should meet with the other never trumpers and work out a better presidential attack. ms. williams, are you engaged in a presidential attack? >> no, sir. >> ms. williams, are you a never trumper? >> i'm not sure i know an official never trumper. >> would you describe yourself that way? >> no. >> did that make an impression on you? >> it certainly surprised me. >> it surprised me, too. it looked like witness intimidation and tacherring in an effort to

president trump and previous presidents, even president that's aggressive on executive power like the bush and cheney. it was really as a matter of principle. you may not agree wit or may think they're crazy and had unrealistic interpretation but they really agreed it. that was overtly part of cheney's agenda. what's happening trump administration putting forward these theories, that's not where they are coming with this idea in mind of this long-term idea. the idea is they want to right now prevent information coming out and if there is long-term consequences creating risks for this institutions, they'll accept that. >> charlie, these are important things for you to consider. i appreciate you continue to write it, charlie savage with "the new york times." he's the author of "power wars," the relentless rise. it is an important read. several reports painting a picture of what happens if the world does not act fast. you are watching "velshi & ruhle" live on msnbc. lshi & ruhle" live on msnbc what's for dinner? (fake gagging noises) ♪ it's the easiest because it's the cheesiest. kraft. for the win win.

. >> prior to being that you worked as a field representative for the bush cheney campaign and then held a political appointment and the department of homeland security undersecretary? is that correct. >> that is correct. >> as a foreign service officer you have served three presidents to republican and one democrat is correct? >> correct. >> from state to advise of vice president of foreign policy toward europe and russia cracked? >> that is right. >> on sunday the president targeted you in asioio tweet, ts after he targeted humana marie yovanovitch, it reads told jennifer williams, whoever that is to revoke transcript of the presidential call and see the just-released statement from ukraine and then she should meet with the other nevere trumper's who i don't know and mostly have never heard of and work out a better presidential attack. are you engaged in a presidential attack? >> no, sir. >> are you a never trumper? >> i'm not sure i note an official definition. >> would you describe yourself that waste? >> i wouldld not, no. >> does that tweet make an impression on you when you read i

so great to be here with bush and cheney, because they won't be seen again the trial., and i wish i had done that [ bleep ] joke. i can't tell you how excited i am to be here tonight. now, i realize many of you may not share that excitement given you have no idea who i am. >> that's a very odd night, because i've done it a couple times. you know, that's kind of a tough room. >> even though his poll numbers are at an historic low, the speaker is writing another book. once again, he's taking a $1 advance. not voluntarily. that's the most he could get. >> they're as uptight as a group can be. you could do whatever you want to open a sphincter, all right, and it's not going to happen. >> in washington, there are people who live to be offended. comedians don't live to be offended. they live to offend. >> hosting the white house correspondents' dinner was the most scared i've ever been as a performer with the exception of my first appearance on the letterman show. >> mr. president, you remember when the country rallied around you in hopes of a better tomorrow? that was hilar

> prior to becoming a nonpartisan career official, you worked as a field representative for the bush cheney foundation in 2004. you have served three presidents. >> yes, sir. >> and in your current position, you're advise the vice preside policy towards russia, that's correct? >> that's correct. >> sunday the president personally targeted in a tweet after he targeted ambassador yovanovitch during her hearing testimony. i would like to read you and show you the tweet. tell jennifer williams, whoever that is, to read both transcripts of the presidential call and see the just released statement from ukraine. then she thud meet with the other never-trumpers who i never heard of and work out a better presidential attack. miss williams, are you involved in aid presidential attack? >> no, sir. >> are you a never-trumper? >> i don't know the official definition of a never-trumper -- >> are you? >> no. >> did that make an impact on you when you read it? >> it surprised me. i didn't expect to be called out by name. >> it surprised me, too. it looked like witness tampering in an effect to get you to,

> prior to becoming a flon partisan career official you worked as afield representative for the bush cheney and department of security under secretary che secretary. is that correct? >> that's correct. >> now as a foreign service officer served two presidents in a variety of rolls? >> correct. >> you are to advise the vice president on details of russia. >> that's correct. >> on sunday the president personally targeted you in a tweet. this is after he targeted ambassador yovanovitch during her hearing testimony. i'd like to show and read you the tweet. it reads, tell jennifer williams, whoever that is, to read both transcripts of the presidential calls and see the just released statement from ukraine. then she should meet with the other never trumpers who i don't know and mostly never even heard of and work out a better presidential attack. miss williams, are you engaged in a presidential attack? >> no, sir. >> ms. williams, are you a never trumper? >> i'm not sure i know an official definition of a never trumper. >> would you describe your self that way? >> i would not, no. >> did that mak

. >> prior to becoming a nonpartisan field representative, you worked for the bush/cheney group and then held a position under secretary chertoff, is that correct? >> that's correct. >> and now as a foreign service officer you have served three presidents, two republicans and one democrat in a variety of roles, correct? >> yes, sir. >> and you're detailed from state to advise the vice president on foreign policy towards europe and russia, right? >> that's right. >> ms. williams, on sunday the president personally targeted you in a tweet. this is after he targeted ambassador yovanovitch during her hearing testimony. i'd like to show and read you the tweet. it reads tell jennifer williams, whoever that is, to read both transcripts of the presidential calls and see the just-released statement from ukraine. then she should meet with the other never trumpers who i don't know and mostly never even heard of and work out a better presidential attack. ms. williams, are you engaged in a presidential attack? >> no, sir. >> ms. williams, have you a never trumper? >> i'm not sure what i know an offic

bush administration and after working as a field representative on the 2004 bush/cheney presidentialvice the following year completing tours in jamaica, beirut and lebanon. prior to joining the office of the vice president, she served at the u.s. embassy in london as a public affairs officer. in april 2019, ms. williams was detailed to the office of the vice president mike pence where she serves as a special adviser on his foreign policy team covering europe and russia issues. in that capacity, she keeps the vice president aware of foreign policy issues in europe and russia and prepares him for foreign policy engagements and meetings with foreign leaders. two final points. first witness depositions were unclassified in nature and all open hearings will also be held at the unclassified level. any information that may touch on classified information will be addressed separately. second, congress will not tolerate any reprisal, threat of reprisal or attempt to retal yent against any u.s. government official for testifying before congress. including you or any of your colleagues. if you

. >> prior to become a nonpartisan career official you worked as a field representative for the bush/cheney in 2004 and held a political >> and now as a service officer, you are giving advice on foreign policy in ukraine and russia, correct? >> that's right. >> the president personally targeted you in a tweet. this is after he targeted ambassador yovanovitch during her hearing testimony. i would like to show and read you the tweet. it says, tell jennifer williams, whoever that is, to read both transcripts of the presidential calls and see the just-released statement from ukraine, then she should meet with the other never trumpers who i don't know who mostly never even heard of and work out a better presidential attack. ms. williams, are you engaged in a presidential attack? >> no, sir. >> ms. williams, are you a never trumper? >> i'm not sure i know an official definition of a never trumper. >> would you describe yourself that way? >> i wouldn't, no. >> did that tweet make an impression on you when you read it? >> it certainly surprised me. i was not expecting to be called out by name. >> i

for those who claim this is all politics, you served under former defense secretary dick cheney during the bush an outlier. you are a cabinet member when you were the head of nasa under george w. bush. >> yes. at no point do i ever recall on any disciplinary matter either the president or the secretary of defense issuing an instruction on what the directed outcome needed to be before the process ever began. that was not -- that was the furthest thing from their minds. >> in the case, one of those cases, the three cases, lieutenant golstyn had not even come to trial yet. thank you very much, good to see you again. >>> coming up, kavanaugh called out. how the supreme justice came to the president's attention. plus where his accuser's father stands on kavanaugh. you're watching "andrea mitchell reports" on msnbc. ndrea mitchell reports" on msnbc. e holidays.♪ ♪'cause no matter how far away you roam.♪ ♪when you pine for the sunshine of a friendly gaze.♪ ♪for the holidays you can't beat home sweet home.♪ the united states postal service goes the extra mile to bring your holidays home. we chose elean

bush. the higher the human. and you say we can. that. cheney. is going to want to head off i've always been and it needs. to with a mind though if that's true. and i'm certain they acquit in that little thing i'll say it offended because you know it just in that area the heat them on us and you will call her a bit difficult to swallow monkey can defend my nickel is worth all mine a lot of them mishmosh i didn't and all. i want to give the name of you here. with out on the. net and on the whole. take a leaf 11. and a half with that many in the. bottle. my own with my own. leave that here a. lot of mystery he saw fairly well with a lot of us i mean alignment exception of a sort of best answer. for the lot of gays old i over so if i can measure the height that he has a man was silent for a case about the if is war most out of. the muddle of any fallin with. 1000000 or would learn about in all my clean war home a lot of. squash were nada that was squash valerie and. good thing it been. able to run on them at a similar levels but they did in the level of a lot. of us had the tools. for the lord. to keep. with

bush for most of it was this high of the layman. when you say began and. that. cheney. is going to want to head off i've always been and it needs. to with a mind though if that's cruel. to animals can they acquit and then a little thing out at the front of a computer just in that area but feed them on your head of considerable use while monkey can defend my nickel is worth all mine a lot of them mishmosh i didn't and all. i want to give the name of you here. with out on. the monitor one. we should. take a leaf 11. and a half with that many in the. bottle. my own with my own. leave that here are. a lot of mysteries he saw fairly well with a lot of us i mean alignment exception of a sort of best answer. for the lot of gays old i over so if i can measure the height that he has a man was silent for case about the if is war most out of. the muddle of any fallin with. 1000000 or would learn about in all my clean one home a lot of. squash were nada that was squash valerie and. good then good then. able to run on them at a similar levels but it did in the level of a lot. of us

cheney on the campaign. cheney.er to dick he's a pretty cool customer. phone h w bush the and i made the mistake of asking, who was he talking to? said, "i think he was putting $50,000 on gore." this was a another pardon in the elevator moment. that was not funny. that was really unfunny. this is a man seeing his life pass before his eyes. jeb bush had been celebrating a victory and had two or three cocktails. he's very sober at this point. is going to lose the election for his brother. that gives you a tour of history in a still photograph. i know everything i know from ken burns. let's move ahead. that inan't always do one image. here is secretary clinton at the beginning of the journey. what is going on here? clinton, who was a 26-year-old lawyer on the impeachment committee. is nixon impeachment becoming a real thing. i've been there for two, i figure i will be there for number three. i may partial observer. if it was going to happen i will be there. we are going to see the evolution of hillary rodham clinton. this is hillary before she married bill clinton. a litt