and that it's time to bury the tragic bush cheney era once and for all. rnal rest grant unto them, oh, lord. turning me now, joe kent, who just defeated congresswoman in washington, just like liz cheney, she was one of the ten house or republicans who voted to impeach donald trump. also joining the, charlie hurt, fox news contributor and opinion editor for "the washington times." joe, as i mentioned in my eulogy, this is a referendum on the g.o.p. establishment. the g.o.p., they -- you know, the g.o.p. has lost its way. i think it's found it in america first and we are about we going to hear from liz cheney in a matter of moments from her campaign headquarters. your reaction tonight? >> it's great, congratulations to the people wyoming for getting ready to rate of one of the biggest neocon establishment rhinos that we have. it's a great thing that they got rid of her in a very big way. like you said, this is a referendum on the failed establishment. that referendum began in 2016 with the election of donald trump, and establishment republicans did everythin

and back, even republicans even came to hate bush and cheney. ey were in office, they abused that office, horribly. they used that office to do lawless and irresponsible things at home and abroad. and did tremendous damage to the country. they were not public punished for that. they weren't held to account for that, via impeachment or any sort of real actions regards to congress. nor were they held to account for that by the republican party. they were how'd allowed -- the cheneys and the bushes -- were allowed to become almost their own statesman in the party. and then, as time went on, when the party moved further, and further right, even they got bit by it. but i think it's really important to understand that when donald trump was -- perhaps at his most dangerous in 2016, at this point where he could have been stopped, republicans like dick and liz cheney did not try to stop him. most republicans felt, got on board. in fact, they were in the culture of the party as it now exists, which is more interested in winning office and holding power tha

lut interestingly, those voters were incredibly loyal to t bush and incredibly loyal to cheney and of course, liz cheney. it'shehe just so remarkable. of course, you know, the only reason she has this job in the first place is because sheac rode her here daddy's coattails and his and her family name into this into this position.er and then for her to turno on voters who are trying to explain to her no, this is all wrong. you know, the trump agenda,t the america first agenda is what we believe in. and for her to react in thisly way, it really is . it's astonishing. and as remarkable as this is , if she does go down in flames the way she looks likewy she will in wyoming tonight, the larger proof thatro the america first agendaof is is is the future and that the trumpre agenda is winning is candidates like joe kent and all of these candidates across the country who are winning even maybe candidateses who weren't endorsed by trump but who are running on the america first trump agenda. that's the victory for conservatives fir and republica. hey, l joe . tonight on msnbc, adam kinzinger, wh

and so what he basically did was expel bush/cheney ideology from the republican party by denouncing them, and all this is, the reason dick and liz cheney hate donald trump, the bush family as well, because it's petty dynastic vengeance, angry that trump positioned himself as an adversary of their defining world view, dynasty and legacy, and won the republican primary by doing that. >> will: at one point the adversary of neoconservatism aligns themselves with the banners of neoconservatism in order to oppose donald trump because he was aopposed to neoconservatism. really, really principled. glenn greenwald, thank you for joining us tonight. >> to be with you. >> will: nancy pelosi's visit to taiwan has provoked a major response from china's government. it's not good news for the green energy crowd. that's straight ahead. hi, i'm denise. i lost over 22 pounds with golo. i've done the work. years and years of fighting and fighting and never getting the results. golo is the only thing that gave me this. it gave me back me. >> will: we told you earlier in the show about the inflation running

at the same time very early on what might focus was concerns over bush/cheney executive power theorieshe sampling of possible liberties. i always had an audience not just on the left but also libertarians well. the first event i ever did the second was at the cato institute read that gives you a flavor of always managed at these various in my audience. >> host: how do you do that as with the left in the right meat. >> i think there are more places were left andig right meat than either side likes to a admit. and that media conveys. i think what attracts standard media tensions in the left and right are fighting. and how many areas theyre have n common. have a lot more agreement than typically observed in the left and right definitely been a focal point from the beginning. >> host: for people tuning in and saying i know that u name, give us a sense of some of the issues you have worked on as a journalist over the years before getting to your book. >> i first started writing i did not go to work att the "new york times" i was a practicing lawyer focus on constitutional law. google that a

at this conference but early on when i began writing about politics my focus was concerns over bush cheney executive power theories and the trampling of civil liberties. i always had an audience not just on the left but also libertarians as well. the first event i ever did was the eight aclu and the second was the cato institute so that gives you flavor for how i've managed to have these prompts with my is audience. >> how do you do that, where the left and right meet? >> there are more places than the left and right meet the other side likes to admit and the media typically conveys. i think what attracts media attention is when the left and right are fighting and they gloss over how many areas they have in common. also the left and right and i think those areas of agreement i tried to build coalition and it's been a focal point from the beginning. >> for people tuning in and saying i know that name, give us a sense of some of the issues you workedon as a journalist over the years before we get your book . >> when i first started writing i didn't go to work at the new york times, i was a p

the same time very early on when i began writing about politics and my focus was concerns over bush cheney executive power theories and some of the trampling of civil liberties and the name of the war on terror. i always had an audience not just on the left, but also libertarians as well. my first book the first event i ever did was at the aclu in the second was at the cato institute, so that gives you a flavor for how managed to have these various problems to my audience. how do you do that? is it it's where the left and the right meat it seems there. i think there are more places where left and right knee then either side likes to admit and then the media typically conveys because i think what attracts standard media attention is when the left and right are fighting and that obscures how many areas they have in common. i think that you parties are have a lot more agreement than typically is observed and also the left and right and finding those areas of agreement and trying to build coalitions or foster them through my work is definitely been a focal point from the beginning well for peo

here's my question: haven't even trying to do this for the last two years and didn't the whole bush cheneyng back even further? how successful have they been? what has liz cheney's performance on the january 6th committee actually accomplished? isn't trump's influence in the g.o.p. stronger now than before this charade of the committee began? the fact is, liz cheney just didn't fail. she failed spectacularly. if cheney as a member of congress didn't hurt trump with her subpoena power, why would anyone believe she has a better chance of hurting him after she's out of congress? that's it for us tonight. remember, it's america now and forever. greg gutfeld is next. ♪ ♪ [scattered applause] ♪ ♪ >> greg: yeah! yeah! [laughs] wow. happy wednesday! my goodness. i guess we should talk about liz cheney. the lady who puts the y

and so what he basically did was expel bush ideology from the republican party by denouncing themm,. and all this is the reason, dick cheneyate donald trump and the bush family as well is because it's just petty, dynastic vengeance. itthey're angry that trump positions himself as an adversary, an opponent of their defining worldview and ideology and legacy. and heyn won the republican primary by doing that to the left. so wedded to principle. at one point, the adversary of neoconservatism aligns himself today with the originators of neo conservatismvati, the bannes of neo conservatism in order ton oppose donald trump because he was opposed to neo conservatism principled.ly glenn greenwald, thank you so much for joining us tonight. thanks, rob . good to be with you. y nancy, pelosi's visit taiwanas has just provoked a major response from china's government. it's not good news for the green energy crowd. straight ahead, hollywood actor alec baldwin, actor alec baldwin. authorities say that actor alec baldwin shot and killed a woman on the set of his upcoming film. russ. alec baldwin always seems to be in the spotlight for go

i worked in the bush-cheney white house. i find it shocking that democrats are all pro-cheney.ember when they were trying to throw dick cheney in the war crimes jail. it's stunning to me. >> congressman, let's go to alaska and this senate race. lisa murkowski, she's the only republican who voted to convict the former president after his impeachment in 2021. she's on the ballot. we know the record for those ten house republicans. seven will not be back. two have a shot at it, and of t. you think that senator murkowski has a better shot, a clearer path to coming back in 2023? >> i actually do think she has a very good chance of coming back. she will advance tonight in alaska with this ranked choice voting system. she will advance. she's not going to lose a primary. she will be on the ballot in the fall. now, we have to see, you know, who else breaks through here. just to handicap what night happen in the fall. but i think she is well positioned to win again. you may remember that she defeated a tea party favorite several years ago. she lost the primary to a guy, and then turned a

cheney. a lot of respect for the bushes, for the cheneys and i remember liz cheney was here for a long time.competent she is. i have not forgotten that. but here i think she made some huge mistakes for a lot of reasons. it got very personal. >> harris: you and others with not need to do any of that behavior about, you know, not denying one side whatever so that you can keep in the middle, keep your job. maybe she felt the pressure of that because of her last name and if you saw her dad's ads. maybe what the rest of the family would feel politically. we don't know. i wonder if this is a topic. now liz cheney had this to say about a possible run for the white house. >> i'm not going to make any announcements here this morning but it is something i'm thinking about and i'll make a decision in the coming months. >> harris: we talked to voters about this. they are mixed. >> no, please, no, no, no, no, no, no. >> we need strong women with powerful decision making. >> i don't see her getting a lot of support for republicans. >> i have no use with people to quit the brand. >> harris: we put up a foc

gosh, grassroots republican voters think they're working to -- they've been working to bury this bush-cheneyup for years. howard: whether for principle or power, it'll be one debate on this program. i'm howard kurtz, and this is "mediabuzz." ♪ ♪ howard: the most heated media clash remains this one, the fbi's dramatic mar-a-lago search really necessary? >> remember how this was urgently needed to protect martial security? turns out attorney general merrick garland sat on his butt and waited weeks to approve the search warrant. >> they found what they were looking for. end of story, what i you did was wrong. there's the, well, i killed him, but i didn't. i stabbed him but i didn't shoot hill. >> when woke twitter and the new york times are your only sources of news, police state politics seems perfectly normal. trump is bad, find a reason to arrest him. that's how they think. howard: now, a judge has ruled he's inclined to release parts of the affidavit used to justify the mar-a-lago search warrant, and several news organizations urged in their filings, and giving the doj a week to redact can

not with bush cheney. >> this is what happens when you tell the truth now?t happens in the republican party. one of the things i think you heard her say there, and this is a challenge i think for democrats as well, is that if the democracy question and making sure that we ensure we have peaceful transfers of power in the future is going to require people who fundamentally disagree on issues, democrats and republicans, actually getting on the same page, actually protecting this. she is very critical of democrats are going after peter meijer, the republican congressman, basically saying, it's -- >> as she should, as she should have been. >> this is the kind of republican you too has the kelly guys want more of. it really is -- frustrations here. understandably, stop telling me you want more people like meyer and kinzinger and cheney. and then democrats throwing up blood money into their campaigns. if i'm a democratic donor i am appalled that you used my money to do that. but it might not work out. >> alice, you heard what liz cheney was talking about. can her

on one hand, back in 2000-2001, felt like the bush-cheney election derailed a lot of our movement.he fact that we witness the largest antiwar protests in history, you know. i was in new york city during 9/11. i remember the islamophobia, the critical separation of cops and first responders. keep in mind, this is right after in the wake of the cincinnati rebellion, able to thousand one come after the killing of timothy thomas. this was in the wake of the dia blo protest. both cases, unarmed lack men -- black men. cincinnati look like ferguson. it was like a precursor many ways. protesting bush era militarism. that militarism continued as collate despite the claims there is an end of the war. your last guest talked about the continuation of these wars. militarism continues to this day. sometimes it takes on the form of israeli occupation of palestine. it takes on the form of expansion of troops and africa. -- in africa. a lot of what we were fighting against then still exists. i think that is important. thinking about critical race theory. it is an interesting problem because the lat

and it's also been a long time rejection of everything that the bush cheney folks stood for, whetherhat's being a neo-con, the compassionate conservative, all that stuff is purposely and soundly rejected by the base. and she's a flawed messenger, as being part of that dynasty. but it will be interesting to see if she can marshall the resources of what's left of that pro-business republican party to do what, i don't know, but clearly she wants to be at the front of something. people got to be behind you. it's not clear that's happening. >> that's the million dollar question for what happens for liz cheney going forward. elliott williams, thanks for joining us. >>> and coming up, a hard fought victory, but can the climate care bill save them in november? visisit bathfitter.com to book your free consultation. men put their skin through a lot. day-in, day-out that's why dove men body wash has skin-strengthening nutrients and moistuzers that help rebud your skin. dove men+care. smoother, healthier skin with every shower. so we need something super distinctive... dad's work, meet daughter'

here is one tweet that says the bush-cheney choice should be a lesson to us and our military: don't do stuff like that. another says what same leader would evacuate the military forces and then evacuate civilians? biden will be the worst evacuation in history. how many did biden leave behind? there were needless deaths. decisions have consequences. another says the agreement with the taliban was made by trump and he ignore the afghan people. a lot of the people did not want to leave when they had a chance. a lot of the equipment was disabled or blown up. truth matters, america. another says afghanistan did not fight back when the taliban advanced. they collaborated with them in the way that they were doing all along while we were spending millions. you can't help people who won't help themselves. and one final tweet, in light of the inflation we are dealing with, it would be worse if we had stayed and wasted billions more. it was good that we left. there will always be casualties in war. that is why we should avoid war at all costs. so the story in the business insider was a group that

it is dick cheney, the list of, who knows, maybe he'll be doing a master class on human rights international lawsuit. >> look, i'm all for standing up to trump but you don't need to invoke bush your evening. >> thank you. >> good evening to you at home and welcome to ayman. coming up tonight, trump's senate rejects bad polls, major gaps, the growing signs, the candidates might tank in the midterms. pushing back on china's threats, we'll be joined by democratic congressman don beyer who just returned from a delegation to taiwan days after speaker pelosi's visit. an american support investigating donald trump new polling shows that voters along the former president held to account. i'm ayman moye had been. let's get started. tonight, we begin with a status check. the midterms are just 11 weeks away. so the question tonight is, where to both sides stand. if you ask mitch mcconnell, he doesn't sound very confident about republicans prospects for winning the senate. there's probably a greater likelihood that the house flip

haven't you had tried to do this with the whole bush/cheney team going back even further? sful have they been? c what has liz cheney's performance on the january 6 committee actually accomplished? isn't trump g.o.p. stronger now than the charade before the committee began? the fact is liz cheney just didn't pao, she failed spectacularly. and if cheney is a member of congress didn't hurt trump with subpoena power, why would anyone believe shean has a better chane of hurting him after she's out of congress? that is it for us tonight. remember, it is america now and forever, greg gutfeld is next. ♪ ♪ >> todd: a fox news alert, all eyes on a judge expected to rule today. another judge with an affidavit with a raid on president trump's home. a big day in the sunshine state. you are watching "fox & friends first" on a thursday morning, i'm todd piro. >> carley: carley shimkus, the media outlet to see the documents the original search warrant and the justice department with operation that sent shock waves across the nation. but some say there is a reason biden officials want to ke

strong donald trump's hold is on the base of the gop and with her losing, it was symbolic of the bush cheneyarview mirror. no elected office is worth sacrificing the principles we fought for and were sworn to protect and serve but at the same time, she doesn't have a constituency. who is in her corner now? i commend her for what she did. she's been an ally for the january 6th committee and a willing topic for the beltway media and a willing antagonist. >> and the whole republican party. >> call me crazy, i don't call that as a constituency. >> clearly, she should be commended for standing up for demo democracy. we're analyzing her path. this is not a criticism of liz cheney to say she was ousted by the very party that her family helped to create is i think that's a legit -- >> listen -- >> -- analysis. >> the world changed tremendously. 2012 democrats told us that mitt romney was a literal monster, a sexist dog killing monster. now mitt romney is a hero -- >> democrats are saying if he ran, i might vote for him. >> which is insane. you would not. you'd vilify him again but this is what happe

i would also speculate, i know liz cheney, i worked with liz cheney in the 2004 bush-cheney campaign. she is a person who stands on principles and doesn't lose sight of those. she will not do anything that will help elect donald trump president of the united states. so if she considers an independent and be she does the research and finds out that her entrance as an independent would help donald trump and hurt joe biden, she will not do that. so i think her sort of north star right now is how to remove the republicans that are election deniers from this and defeat a possible donald trump candidacy. but she's only got about 20% republicans behind her. >> beyond cheney the other marquee name on the ballot last night was sarah palin. ali, you said this could take a while to sort out. so where are we this morning? >> doing exactly that. it's going to take a little bit of time to sort out if sarah palin is the person who's going to be heading to congress most imminently, though again, we have to remind people, chris, this is the race that comes back around in november to serve out an all f

chief strategist, the 2004 bush cheney presidential campaign, good to see you both. katie, i'll start with you. we have covered this reconciliation process now throughout the biden presidency. what is the significance of senate dems getting this done? >> alicia, this is major news coming in just a few hours ago. this is a big deal. as biden said before now we've been more so that all 50 democrats got on board. we heard biden last week saying that this was about compromise. a lot of parts of the bill that we're aiming at very high power authorities among progressives, especially like sanders, did not make it into the final package, but there is so much that was included. this is a big deal going into an uphill battle for the midterms. but especially really underscoring how this bill will benefit working class families. that is going to be the main question as we head into the house. there's going to be pushed back that is expected from progressives, they're gonna push back on the fact that so many parts of the bill that they were angling for for the past year to have

on this primary season culminating crushing defeat of liz cheney shows that that bush-cheney, romney-mccainat didn't really care about illegal immigration, that spent trillions on wars that were not in the strategic national interest of the country. not american workers that never took the media on and never took on woke left politics on. that's over. and this is good for the republican party heading into 2022 and 2024. they are a big tent party multi racial, working class. it's good news for the republican party. as for what is going on with this mar-a-lago raid and the justice department working so hard to keep secrets the underlying affidavit, hear a lot of people in d.c. shouldn't we wait and hear what the fbi has to say? the era of that is over also. we went through six years of them spending months if not years dripping out leaks and claiming that they had the goods on trump regarding russia. at the end of the day, they had nothing other than their own lies about affidavits, their own, you know, derogatory leaks, corrupt officials in their department. they don't have any -- there is n

with her losing, it was symbolic of the bush cheney, romney wing of the gop is in the rearview mirror her for what she did, i commend her for saying, no elected office is worth sacrificing the principles that we fought for and we were sworn to protect and serve. but at the same time, she doesn't have a constituency. who is in her corner right now? look, again i commander for what she did, right now, she has been an ally for democrats in the january six committee, she has been a willing topic for the beltway media. and she has been a willing antagonist against donald trump in the election deniers. >> and the whole republican party, really. >> so call me crazy, i don't see that as it can as a constituency for someone going for the presidency. >> clearly, she should be commended for standing up for democracy. but what we're doing now is just analyzing her path. this is not a criticism of liz cheney to say that she was ousted by the very party that her family helped create. i think that's a legit -- analysis. >> listen, the world has changed tremendously. 2012, democrats told us that mitt

and ceo of whole women's health and political analyst matthew dowd, the chief strategist for the bush-cheney campaign. i have to go to you first, erin. look, i mean angry women make history. you talk about whether it's abolitionists or whether it is the sufferage and the black women that fought to get in the game on the anger of women has moved amendments to the floor. what do you make of the anger that you're seeing out there, you're out there as a journalist covering these campaigns? you are seeing the level of anger that you think could change history? >> joy, what an apt framing for the conversation on the eve of equipment's equality day where we celebrate the ratification of the 19th amendment for which my organization is named. women have been on the front lines of democracy and been on the main people that are pushing for the expanded rights not just for women but for everybody. in our democracy and society. i'm somebody, i hate to say i told you so, but i said women will be the deciders of the election. honestly, can you say that every year. women are more than half of the electorate

i quickly add the bush/cheney white house the chief speechwriter for the president for more than half the administration was a senior policy advisor. and so, he had real standing on the white house staff. that was a good influence because he's very good at what he did. >> another point is why people care about something a member trying to pass healthcare print that was important because he spoke on it a lot. we really had to persuade people including members of congress to not only approve this law but to sign up. and we ended up going through all of the letters present obama received thousands of letters read ten everyday including from people who were saying this is what i'm dealing with, this is what i've been to this is what's really important. there why this medicine who's really going to make a difference. >> also my good friend just basically put together much eloquent version of the question i had. [laughter] sorry about that. >> a middle bit of scramble right now. i think of us to shift the perspective a little bit on how speechwriters have an influence and think something th

political analyst matthew dowd founder of country of a party, served as chief strategist in the 2004 bush cheney presidential campaign. friends, good to see you all. luke, i will start with. you talk us through your reporting about the potential threat from these mar-a-lago records. why is the cia so concerned? >> so, congressional committees on both the senate side and the house side have asked for there to be this damage assessment, conducted by the top as telegenic officials in the united states government. this is the first signal that the intelligence committee is concerned about what was going on at mar-a-lago. my understanding is the fbi in the justice department will be investigating the part of the matter about who had access to these documents and what the intelligence officials will be investigating. it's going through the mauve and determining which sources or methods can be identified and could have been compromised by the release. i think it's very important to note that we are talking in some cases here about human sources. real human beings who possibly could have been identified

he's an msnbc political contributor and former chief strategist for the bush cheney 2004 presidentialign. charles blow. he's a columnist for the new york times, and he's also an msnbc political analyst. gentlemen, which have both of you with us. charles, i start with you. a former president making money off of really having the image of saudi arabia. what message does that send to midterm voters? >> well, i don't think it sends a strong enough message. you know, i undermine, ayman, that we keep saying that things threaten our democracy, may damage our democracy, that that january 6th threatened our democracy. i think a large portion of our country, and a large portion of the republican party has the ideal of representing democracy, in its fullest embrace. so, they don't care about it. they really want to see the world post-democracy. they want to see america post democracy, in a space where a minority of people control the majority of the population. and that is the objective here. and so, if trump, you know, is a drifter, they accept that, or they deal with that, because he is the la

let's talk about op-ed that you wrote, actually really good death of the cheney bush dynasties you pointed talks about how what also happened with george p. bush lost attorney general primary runoff against ken paxton in texas, roughly 35, 36 we went liz cheney, roughly by 37 points catastrophic defeats to the names of bush and cheney, so to me the broader picture if you look at two races in particular that american people in republican primary voters in particular really want to finely once and for all turn page on excesses the destructive policies bush-cheney era no going back to pre2016 pre-trump status quo, no going back to effete make night with lirlz republicanism swash bug liner neoconservatism around the world no going back the only question 2024 when trump comes back or we continue with policies that trump put into place under a different banner liz cheney like you said made a huge gamble i think sanctimonioustude hollier than thoutude rubbed a lot of voters wrong way good for them. >> in with wyoming seems the case was case she lost that primary but at the same time you have ra

the same time very early on when i began writing about politics and my focus was concerns over bush cheney executive power theories and some of the trampling of civil liberties and the name of the war on terror. i always had an audience not ju o

i will quickly add in the bush cheney white house, mike carson, the chief speech writer for the president more than half the administration, was a senior policy adviser. and so, he was, you know, he had real standing on the white house staff and that was a good inference because he was very good at what it. >> it [inaudible] was in the circle of people didn't care about something, i remember when i was a, when they tried to pass health care, and so that was important because he spoke on offered a lot, he had to persuade people including members of congress and people in the different states to not only approve this law, but to sign up. and we ended up doing through all the letters. president obama received thousands of letters and read ten every night, including for people who are saying, you know, these are the issues i am dealing with, i've been through, this is why this is really important. and so we will tell a lot of the stories as a way to help people understand why this writers. and [inaudible] make a difference for. yeah. >> this is a bit short. and also, my good friend just basic

at the same time very early on when i began writing about politics my focus was concerns over bush and cheney executive power theories and civil liberties and the war on terror. i always had an audience not just on the left but also libertarians the first i ever did was at the cato institute so that gives you a flavor for how i've managed to have these problems in the audience. >> how do you do that? it's where the left and the right meats. >> there is they on either side likes to admit and the media typicallyti conveys because the standard media attention is when the left and rights are fighting and that is how many they have in common with more agreement than the left and right. it's findingo those areas of agreement and building coalitions and fostering them through the work has been a focal point from the beginning. >> for people tuning in and saying i like that name give us a sense of some of the issues you worked on as a journalist over the years before we get to the book. >> i was a practicing lawyer focusing on constitutional law and one day hit create a blog on one of the free blog s

it is all there in the plain words of bush and cheney and rumsfeld.ed to take the war not to al qaeda, but to the caliban and saddam hussein and iraq. they did not want to kill bin laden, they did not want for the war to end quickly. we don't want the war to end too quickly. this war will go on in time and place throughout the middle east. here we are 20 years later, 10 trillion spent, 2 million dead, including 7000 americans, 30,000 american soldier suicides and absolutely nothing to show for it whatsoever. they say that is why we have to pour all of these arms in ukraine so we can redeem ourselves for 20 years of failure in the middle east. unbelievable. >> absolutely unacceptable. love to talk about it. thank you. >> coming up. remember when doctor fatty claimed he is science wait until you hear what he said about truth. my memo is next. ♪ all just looking for the hottest stocks? (fisher investments) nope. we use diversified strategies to position our client's portfolios for their long-term goals. (other money manager) but you still sell investment

here is one tweet that says the bush, cheney, rumsfeld choice should be left to our military.nother tweet that said what sane leader would evacuate the military forces and then try to evacuate civilians? biden's legacy will be the worse evacuation in history. like vietnam, it was "planned." how many did biden leave behind? another tweet says the agreement was made by trump and they ignored the afghan people. a lot of people there did not want to leave when they have the chance a lot of the equipment was disabled or blown up. another tweet says afghanistan did not fight back when the taliban advanced. they collaborated with them, the way they did all along when we spent billions. it was a lost cause from the beginning feed you cannot help people who will not help themselves. and one final tweet -- in light of the inflation we are dealing with, it would be worse had we stayed and wasted billions more. it was good that we left. there will always be casualties in war. that is why we should avoid wars at all cost. there is a story in the business insider with a group that evacuate

into some of the mistakes the secret service made that day regarding president bush but with regard to vice president cheney, who would have been the president if bush was killed that day, cheney was in his office. he didn't usually go to his oval office meeting but that they did. he was meeting with a close ally who was a top budget official in the omb and he was watching the television when the second jet hit the second tower. the secret service, the person in charge of making sure that liaison with the faa about any threats to the white house because keep in mind the white house had been attacked by a car twice before. not by a huge commercial jet but it had been attacked twice before. twice planes and either almost crashed there or crashed into the lawn so it's not like that it's not impossible to envision that a plane could be used as a weapon. but the agent in charge of liaison with the faa gets a very urgent message from the second plane hitting the second tower. that is about 9:0 3 am that morning and it is we are still missing 2 jets. not communicate with us and heading towards you. there 20 minute

dick cheney, 14 years since he left the white house. it is no longer the george w. bushsee that in the primaries and we see that, i suspect, in the wyoming primary next week. >> was it cheney? i thought the first biden re-election ad. >> anti-trump forces and the republican party got closer. you know? one of these things. you look at arizona and these places. trump won but it was harder but he still is winning. sort of -- i don't know what the anti-trump forces do. >> i agree with you. when you look at it he is not at strong, right is in the tail is not in the same place that it was two, four years ago. but to your point, those are the people that are still on the ballot in the midterms and he is not going anywhere. looking at cpac. >> i think the big question for the senate candidates do you accept a trump invitation? the democrats have already decided they don't want biden any way around. >> i think that depends. >> we shall see. all we have for today. thank you for watching. i'm sorry to see juan soto go. i was hoping he would stay last week. go padres? we will be bac

trump ran in many ways as a repudiation of the bush-cheney administration.ort and then decide that the other 61 -- they are the ones who are wrong. they are the ones who are sick. i think that liz as heir gaited to herself the standard of being the more judge of millions of americans around 37 or 75 million americans who voted for trump because they are sick. they voted for trump because they deeply dislike the establishment. and no matter what you think about trump, they dislike the establishment even more. so it's amazing to me that nobody who is in the anti-trump faction has stopped to say what is it we are doing that repels so many americans that, again, wyoming is a great example the cheney name is a one-time magic. now it just doesn't get beat it's humiliated. 29%. take away the democrats switched party to vote for her. she got probably one in every four republicans, it's amazing. i don't take what she says very seriously. >> steve: she has kind of hinted she might run for president. let's see what she does next. >> bring it on. >> steve: newt, thank y