supervisor campos? campos aye. there are five ayes and 6 no's. >> amendment fails. [gavel] >> colleagues, with that, any further discussion? okay, at this time, madam clerk, could you please call the roll for whether this ordinance shall be finally passed. >> on item 9, supervisor chiu? chiu aye. supervisor cohen? cohen aye. supervisor farrell? farrell aye. supervisor kim? kim aye. supervisor mar? mar no. supervisor tang? tang aye. supervisor wiener? wiener aye. supervisor yee? yee no. supervisor avalos? >> n-o. >> avalos no. supervisor breed? breed aye. supervisor campos? campos no. there are 7 ayes and 4 no'ses. >> this ordinance is finally passed. [gavel] [cheering and applauding] >> thank you, colleagues. with that, why don't we proceed to item 10. >> item 10 is an ordinance to amend the business and tax regulations code by revising and clarifying common administrative provisions for the business registration for the payroll expense and gross receipts tax and deleting obsolete provisions. >> roll call vote. >> on item 10, supervisor chiu? chiu aye. supervisor co

use profanity we have two incredible supervisors who have done a lot for san francisco supervisor campos and supervisor chiu the candidates will answer questions and also questions by the legacy of women's voters they have agreed to ask their supporters to be respect fell and maintain quiet if you have your phones just turn the ringer off please not to interfere with the miff and tonight's forum will view a chance to hear from your candidates this really nice the candidates get 30 seconds to a minute 0 they're to get 22 half a minutes especially on tv our stories are 25 seconds to they're going get to stand ladies and gentlemen, welcome give a warm welcome to david chiu and david campos (clapping). >> stack hands and come out fighting verbally, of course. >> all right. okay so we have a total time i was wrong total time of 2 and a half minutes between the both of i i mislead you sorry if you haven't been a legacy of voter women we have a timekeepers ladies raise our cards so what was when necessary hold the yellow card you have 15 seconds to finish when the red that means stop so show th

supervisor campos? campos aye. there are 7 aye and 4 no's. [cheering and applauding] >> the ordinance is passed on the first reading. [gavel] >> and with that, colleagues, we have a 3:30 special item. and recognition of restaurant appreciation month which we do every year during this month, to each acknowledge a restaurant in our district that are doing special things. serving up special food. so, with that as my staff i believe has told some of your staff, what i'd like to do today is go in reverse numerical order starting with supervisor avalos at district 11 then going down to 10 all the way to district 1. so, with that i'd like to acknowledge supervisor avalos. >> thank you, president chiu. i appreciate going in reverse numerical order. and, so, district 11's first time. i welcome peter [speaker not understood] of rocksy market to the podium. and you want to come to the microphone. you'll need it for a couple minutes. if folks are aware of rocksy market on the corner of san jose avenue and san juan, it is a great place to pick up a sandwi

supervisor campos. >> thank you. i want to again look forward to working with my colleagues with the comments. i do support the idea, you know, i think this gives us an opportunity to make a statement, move something forward but at the same time make sure we have a process for these other bodies to look at this. thank you. >> stanchion. >> sure. i just wanted to clarify i do stand by my original, i guess amended motion to send it to the full committee on november 25th. ~ supervisor tang i think dividing the file defeats the purpose of exactly what i was trying to state earlier which is the whole process with all the various departments, thank you very much. and, so, i just wanted to say that i would like to reiterate, i know that [speaker not understood] the city attorney dividing the file takes precedence as well? >> madam clerk? >> mr. chair, it is a single supervisor's privilege to duplicate the file. >> thank you. and, so, i don't know how that would work, but i would still like to make that motion that we contin

. >> supervisor campos commissioner chiu. >> no supervisor cowen 90 no supervisor farrell no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor yee supervisor avalos supervisor breed no there are 5 i's and 6 months. >> the amendment fails the next amendment. >>was proposed by supervisor wiener this one is a technical one that has to do with the timing for feeds do we need a roll call on this one >> madam clerk since the last one had a different vote do we need to redo this. >> supervisor campos supervisor chiu supervisor cohen supervisor farrell supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee supervisor avalos supervisor breed pr there are 11 i's great that motion is adapted this men and women second one from supervisor wiener has to do with the automatic notifications to the cc&rs and hookz and in rh1 district and zones having is there a need for roll call workman's compensation this amendment has been adapted arrest next amendment was proposed by sorry the next one that doesn't require a referral back to committee supervisor

my name is david campos and i'm the chair of the neighborhood services and safety committee of the board of supervisors of the city and county of san francisco. it is our regular meeting of october 23, 2014. we are joined today by supervisor mar and scott wiener. the clerk of the committee is derek evans and we'd like to thank the following members of sfgtv staff who are covering this meeting today, jessie larson and joshua alex sander, district clerk, do you have any announcements. >> please make sure to silence all electronic devices. [inaudible] be on the november 4, 2014 board of supervisors agenda unless otherwise stated. >> thank you very much. if you can call item 1. item 1 is amending the police code to appeal the position [inaudible] to prohibit individuals from falling from the entrance of the facility, to prohibit impeding access to the door. >> thank you very much. today is a very special day for the neighborhood services and safety committee and on a personal level we're -- it's a very important day for me because we're dealing with two of the most important issues that my o

supervisor campos? campos aye. there are five ayes and 6 no's. >> amendment fails. [gavel] >> colleagues, with that, any further discussion? okay, at this time, madam clerk, could you please call the roll for whether this ordinance shall be finally passed.

with the transit occupies this need to be received back to planning roll call. >> supervisor campos supervisor chiu no supervisor cohen no supervisor farrell no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor yee supervisor avalos supervisor breed no there are 5 i's and of nos this amendment has failed correction. >> just making sure you're all paying attention (laughter) the next one is supervisor campos prsht are short-term rentals that rental that are significant to ellis act evictions. >> supervisor campos supervisor chiu no supervisor cohen. >> just so i'm clear. >> this is the amendment to prohibit short-term rentals that were subject to ellis act within years. >> supervisor cohen i supervisor farrell marry no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener supervisor yee supervisor avalos supervisor breed there are 8 i's and 3 nos this amendment passes and supervisor breed had an amendment and this has to do with also i believe a private right of action and ammunition with the ellis act evictions. >> supervisor campos superv

i want to thank david campos for his sterling leadership on this issue. thank you very much. next speaker. >> high, my name's heidi, i'm the we're a national organization, but here in san francisco. i'm also a mom in the mission. i'm here

with the transit occupies this need to be received back to planning roll call. >> supervisor campos supervisor chiu no pe

seeing none, public comment is closed. >> tome 6 supervisor avalos supervisor breed supervisor campos absent supervisor chiu supervisor cohen supervisor farrell absent supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang supervisor wiener supervisor yee that item passes. >> great next item. >> item 7 award a 12 month contract for the treasure island mobility management program and authorize the executive director negotiate the director terms an action item. >> very good seeing no comments from the board going on gone to public comment. >> i'm sure you're aware of in san francisco chinatown there are two chinese bunch of roadside i go every day monday and tuesday and wednesday, i go to both stockton and wells fargo is bargaining of course i know the best banker i'm sure you're aware of the union bargaining, however, the chinatown's for me is a good place to go to meet the - i mean in chinatown the only square area we have such quality of professional and work area it is like for me, i have a bank at wells fargo we go to other stair bucks and in that chinatown the wells fargo is forever the vi

. >> supervisor campos supervisor chiu no supervisor cowen no supervisor farrell no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor yee supervisor avalos not to exceed no there are 5 i's and 60 notice that amendment fails the next one is supervisor kim's the proliferate right of action do we need a roll call for this supervisor campos supervisor chiu supervisor cohen supervisor farrell no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor yee supervisor avalos supervisor breed there are 8 i's and 430 notice this amendment is adapted the mexico one has to do with supervisor campos with the transit occupies this need to be received back to planning roll call. >> supervisor campos supervisor chiu no supervisor cohen no supervisor farrell no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no supervisor yee supervisor avalos supervisor breed no there are 5 i's and of nos this amendment has failed correction. >> just making sure you're all paying attention (laughter) the next one is supervisor campos prsht are short-t

with the transit occupies this need to be received back to planning roll call. >> supervisor campos supervisor chiu no supervisor cohen no supervisor farrell no supervisor kim supervisor mar supervisor tang no supervisor wiener no

. >> thank you so supervisor campos. >> i make a motion for both. >> sure so just asking for a second on supervisor campos first amendment regarding the trinity taxes seconded 3wi supervisor avalos and permitting the shortfalls subject to the ellis act evictions a second supervisor breed supervisor chiu. >> thank you colleagues let me first start by asking are there any other amendment you i think i need to ask the deputy city attorney he has amendments. >> john gibner, deputy city attorney stepping back to supervisor campos amendment i'm sure you're aware of there's been litigation go challenging various ordinances in the city involving the ellis act so as i mentioned supervisor campos amendment will require a revel to another k34e hearing and at or before that committee hearing provided the advice regarding the issue we suggest during the last two weeks we've looked electro the ordinances that is preponderance of the evidence and worked with supervisors office particularly supervisor chiu's office and had clean up amendments we'll ask the board to adapt may be the first amendment yo

will require a referral and a continuance at the board for an additional hamburger and supervisor campos talked about the ellis act evictions in the past 5 years from short-term rentals that will require a further hearing but not another planning commission hearing because the planning commission considered that proposal and finally, i understand supervisor breed as you mentioned at the grinning of the meeting you're considering proposing an amendment that will allow a private right of action without waiting for the administrative native action to cloud when the unit in question have had ellis act viethsz within the last 5 years that amendment will require another mags hearing and a continuance so happy to flag those as you go through those voting on months ago but that's itself aufrs thank you city attorney's office supervisor breed. >> i'm good. >> supervisor campos just a quick question in terms of how the issue of continuance going back to committee or planning relates to a file that's biff indicated are duplicate thank you. >> any simple or single of the board can dip a file if i ha

supervisor campos, i believe, had circulated written draft of the amendment. the language in the written draft doesn't exactly mirror the language that you had, supervisor campos, but it reaches the same point, so, i just wanted to clarify for the benefit of the public. the amendment essentially says that when contractors turn over information to us, if the information they are providing to us is a protected trade secret or proprietary information that's confidential under the law, the hrc or any other city agency cannot disclose that to the public. so, this ordinance can't override the sunshine ordinance. whether information -- whether a particular piece of information that's provided by a contractor is a trade secret or is proprietary is really a factual determination. so, the hrc will be looking at whatever data they have if there is a sunshine request, working with my office to determine whether any -- whether that information is protected trade secret or protected proprietary information. and if it is, hrc won't disclose it. so, this amendment, i think, c

supervisor campos? >> thank you. thank you, mr. chairman and again, thank you to all of the applicants. i know that a number of them, at least one of them could not be here today. you know, this is a very important task force, because it really is the task force whose charge is to ensure transparency in everything that we do and not do in city government. and i also know that it's a very time-intensive commitment and a lot of work goes into this. so i'm very grateful to all of the people that want to serve on it. i do believe it's important and i don't know where my colleagues are, so i will just share my couple of thoughts. normally i want to hear directly from an applicant, but i do believe that moving the new california media applicant forward is really important, given sort of where the task force is. so i will be open to that, even though pixie chopra is not here. i think the two applicants that we heard from for seat 11 are both outstanding and i certainly was impressed with the comments from fiona hinze. but i believe that j

i am a legislative aide for supervisor david campos. you're getting quite a bit of our legislative agenda this afternoon. thank you so much for having me today. and to present on our legacy business legislation. i'm sure as many of you know, so many of our city's valuable businesses, those that have served our neighborhoods and enlivened them for decades are struggling to survive. these businesses have become cultural institutions, created the character of the neighborhoods, for generations thriving business he have played an essential role in defining our communities. [speaker not understood] sky rocketing rents for retail spaces, unprecedented development are causing san francisco small business he to suffer and many of the long established businesses have been force today shut their doors. it is with this spirit that supervisor campos believes that something needed to be done. he believes that the city has a responsibility to protect the successful businesses he that are suffering through these unnatural economic pressures that have

. >> supervisors campos? >>supervisor david campos: thank you very much, mr. chairman and thank you to the department head and her staff and to all the applicants. as chair yee indicated anytime you have more applicants than seats it's eight -- it's a challenge because there are so many great people. everyone who applied and spoken here today i think can be a pretty effective member of this commission and i actually think that the immigrant rights commission is one of the most important commissions we have , and not only is it important for san francisco, but it's important for the state of california and country because san francisco time and time again continues to be a leader around issues on immigration and because of that, who sits on the immigrant rights commission is really important because the membership of that commission will determine whether or not we continue to play that leadership role. so this is what i'm thinking, i don't know where my colleagues are, but i think that continuity is important. so i would want to reappoint commissioners haregue

>> aye. >> breed. >> aye. >> campos. >> aye. >> chiu. >> aye. >> cohen? >> absent. >> ferrill. >> aye. >> kim. >> aye. >> mar. >> aye. >> tang. >> aye. >> weiner. >> absent. >> yee. >> aye. >> item passes. >> okay. let's go to the next item. >> item three, three chair's report, this is an information item. >> colleagues, in what has become a ritual i begin high report with the sad news that four pedestrians were hit by cars in the past couple of days, one of whom, 87-year-old, mr. louis van belson died of his injuries after being hit, and as he tried to catch a bus. and this is truly an acceptable and, we must act to make the streets safe and her to ask our drivers to slow down i appreciate the work of the sfmta the police department and the department of public health and other agencies supporting the city's vision zero team, around town reminding everyone that every intersection is a potential pedestrian crossing route, and enforcement is set up for the drivers, be aware of this. >> we have seen the rise in capitol projects but it is clear that we need

supervisor campos? campos aye. there are 11 ayes. >> thank you. the item is passed -- these items are passed. [gavel] >> madam clerk, please call the next item. >> item 9 is an ordinance to amend the administrative code to provide an exception for permanent residents to the prohibition on short-term residential rental under certain condition to establish procedures and an application fee for a short-term residential rental registry for tracking in compliance and to amend the planning code to clarify that short-term residential rentals shall not change a unit's type as re deckv and making the requisite finding. >> thank you. president chiu. >> thank you, mr. chair. colleagues, i know we he had a very lengthy discussion on this topic two weeks that go so let me very briefly say thank you. i want to thank you for your consideration of our legislation to regulate short-term rentals. and i very much appreciate all the work that all of you have done to tackle a very complicated and complex policy issue and to find a balanced solution to both allow peopl