and to talk more about this we're now joined by political analyst from the carnegie endowment for international peace. thanks very much indeed for joining us now what is your assessment of the anti terror operation in the north caucasus is russia winning the war on terror is saying. well you know you think of it to them home to a living who is the sort of most of the civil war began not to us that in the but for us to do to begin well a lot of the fear was to go in the situation in the rules of the incidental roy by the way the need to feel as though from them because they are the proves once again their it's not a gangster they harm gangster it's not some men days old typical criminals it's surreally believe me it's a really. and islamic resistance and it's so much on islamic opposition and the beat goes up around his own kind of leader of a lot of time to promise to put in the many videos that he at least construct of his personal fear to go forward and be they able to control the situation i mean should know and don't want to control it and he failed now while the rules are first of first still fa