my name is caroline duffy. i reside at 50 alta, apartment six. i have called this my home for ten years now. i have to say, by alta street standards, i am somewhat of a new person on the street. i was already pretty nervous to start off with. so this is going into, clearly a very emotional issue. what i like to do briefly is walk-through -- the reason as tenants we felt compelled to file an appeal. this is just to give you a visual of the property that we are talking about. you will hear 40 and 50 going back and forth. you can see that for the most part, i don't know about code regulations, but it is the same building. this is the backside of the building. so what i want to show here is, in the right corner, this is my unit. to the left is diane english she was going to be one of the appellants appear with me this evening, but obviously that will not happen tonight. this is the unit in question that has been stopped. this is where the property manager, management had their office for three years. the tenants living there passed away in may of 201