joan: we mentioned a couple names repeatedly today including paul clement and carter phillips and tom goldstein, who added just referred to. i think all of us, many of you and us, have noticed that we have had so many repeat players over the years coming up before the justices and having success with their decisions, we decided to do was actually try to measure this. our data team went back to 17,000 petitions and isolated on 66 lawyers who had a remarkable success rate. going back over one decade, we found that fewer than 1% of these lawyers had 43% of the cases it for the justices, and that 50 want of these 66 lawyers had deep, corporate ties. we were looking at who these people are, why they are so successful before the justices, and that raised the question of whether the justices have added a new criterion to their decisions on which cases to take and whether they goes to the merits of the lawyers arguing not just the merits of the case, so we were able to do a lot of data work. then i went and interviewed the justices about this saying, are you leaning toward repeat players beca