john: james carville will defend hillary to the death.laire mccaskill has more of a complicated relationship with the clintons. they were trying to defend her. even if you are trying to defend her, you almost end up blurting out things that don't. those are people that are trying not to screw her. this is so tricky because almost anything you say, once you start talking long enough, something comes out of your mouth that is incriminating. mark: she had her thing at the u.n. and the feel of it was she was telling us everything she knew. her danger with democrats if something comes out different, or something that contradicts what she said, i think that will spook a lot of the democratic elites who say oh, no. on the current facts, those two gaps, she is on very solid ground with democrats. john: you hear it all the time -- there is still unease. they all feel what they always feel with the clintons which is somehow they don't know the full story and there could be another shoe that drops. it is not like we are already to go and everything

james carville, i'm sorry, the '90s are calling. they want their pr tactics back. they don't work nowadays. james carville, you tell me he hasn't given "the new york times" stuff on republicans? i don't care if the devil, himself, gave "the new york times" this information. doesn't matter where it came from. it's the truth. that she violates regulations, that she assaulted transparency. that they've been deceiving and lying about it ever since. her hinchmen out here. they've got to come clean. turn over the servers. hand back the foreign donations. the controversy is over. >> i've been frustrated by the elegance with which we spoke about the ideal press conference when you watch them, whether it's a convention -- the worst of the congressional hearings. they don't follow a logical transition from question to follow-up to better follow-up to isolate the person holding the press conference, phil. never seems to work that way. people ask one ding bat question after another and they ignore it because they're competing with each other. they don't want to help somebody g

there were several things carville got wrong there. start with right wing talking points -- >> your being sarcastic, right? >> a little you picked up on it. the fact right wing and "new york times" is carrying is farce farcical farcical. what journalists do is check out leads and tips and try to confirm it. everything the times reported about hillary clinton using private e-mail account and the a.p. reporting on the personal server is fact. it's not spin. it's not right wing talking points. >> and yet we're starting to get a feel for where they're going to go with it and it's straight out of the clinton playbook which is the media's bad, they want to hurt us unfairly. by the way here's a list of republicans that have done it. they point to jeb bush and colin powell. colin powell didn't have only a personal e-mail account, he did most of his business on the state department's e-mail servers. but in any event jeb bush was not working for the federal government, he was a governor. but in any event that's what they do look at them, look ov

answer them directly because unfortunately james carville does have a point.hout some of the answers coming out there will be continuing banter not that at this press conference or that this press statement will stop it because republicans almost have like obsession. we have seen that over the past 20 years whether it be a whole array of things that have come forth. so this, one, you know is interesting. it is different and one which she will be addressing. she will be addressing from what we understand today in a forthright manner. >> all right. this story came from the "new york times," rich, and you know, james carville make as reference to them picking up some right-wing talking points. i don't know "the new york times" does that very often. what do you think? >> that is not "the new york times" i know and get on my doorstep every morning. look this is just classic clinton defense. it is like hearing a pearl jam or nirvana song. takes you right back to the 1990s. this was the mo you attack accusers. you say it was old news. say it wasn't technically illega

. >>> there is nobody else for the democrats according to james carville. you know how well he knows the clintons. >> at this point hillary has a strong lead. i polled iowa and new hampshire. they have both very close with senator elizabeth warren should she decide to run. harris, there could well be more revelations about hillary. >> we have seen a lot of carville lately. he ran for a campaign at one point. >> james carville is out there doing the same stuff. all pardons remained. >> the e-mails don't matter. >> they are going to matter eventually and so is the money. all of this is going to wear down. we have a country that wants a revolt against democratic establishes and the republican establishments and we haven't seen anything yet. >> she is under pressure of her own and looks badly. >> and her numbers are -- >> john kerry will run -- >> we'll see what happens. i will see you guys next week. that will do it for us this evening. thanks for watching. i'll be back with you tomorrow noon eastern for unnumbered. have a fantastic week. >> it is monday march

is it time for the clintons to tell james carville to stop talking. he may have added more fuel to the fire and you can call it hip hop diplomacy. we'll tell you why nelly was in iraq over the weekend. that and the weather when we get back to you. you could sit at your computer and read all about zero-turn mowers. click. scroll. tweet. or you could just sit on a john deere z435 eztrak and feel its power. you'll know it'll get the job done fast. when it's time to pick a mower you've got to get on one. visit your local john deere dealer for a test drive today. sign up to take your turn on a z435 and save 100 dollars on your purchase. nothing runs like a deere. do you want to know how hard it can be to breathe with copd? it can feel like this. copd includes chronic bronchitis and emphysema. spiriva is a once-daily inhaled copd maintenance treatment that helps open my airways for a full 24 hours. spiriva helps me breathe easier. spiriva respimat does not replace rescue inhalers for sudden symptoms. tell your doctor if you have kidney problems, glaucoma, t

i am really prouded of you for giving james carville such a pass. what carville did was give up the goods. he admitted this was not a matter of convenience. he admitted the reason she did this was so she didn't have to comply with the oversight of the house and with the natural laws of transparency. he gave up the goods. he sold her out. >> charles? >> the chinese donation is particularly troublesome because democrats in the previous campaign implying that republicans were using foreign money that was infiltrating our election because of the citizens united ruling. that was not true in the first place. they made a big issue of the chamber of commerce from outside the sources. here we have the clintons admitting and bill himself has admitted and said he doesn't see anything wrong with it. he is the charming scoundrel in all of this. she will deny any impropriity. this company built the chinese embassy in washington which as you know when you build an embassy in a semi hostile country you have to be careful about the security and the bugs and all of t

here is james carville. >> you wonder why the public is not following this? because they know what it was, something that was legal. i suspect she didn't want congress rifling through her e-mails. it amounts to nothing but people flapping jaws about nothing. >> carville suggests she did it to avoid congressional oversight and scrutiny and fox's ed henry caught up with clinton in manhattan. he is here on set with us. this is almost unprecedented. we are glad to have you here. this story has more holes than swiss cheese. greg is not here so bear with me with something better than that. what happened? >> we have a quick tape. she was going to this speech being inducted into the irish american hall of fame. i asked about the document reported about if you sign this document saying, certifying that you are accounting for all of your records before you leave it is perjury if you don't secure those records and take tens of thousands of e-mails with you. here is what she said. >> did you sign the declaration? did you sign that statement? >> you look so sad. >> you go

don't be fooled by that old fool carville because there is a ton to see there.irm, travel gate and now the presidential want to be is up to her political eyeballs in another scandal. this scandal is a big story with lots of legs. does she break the law was she hacked, is president obama complicity, does hillary clinton use the state department to fill the covers of the clinton 230u7bd asian and will those funds find their a washington i into her campaign. conservatives have a golden opportunity, now some advice, don't blow it for us once. stay smart stay on topic. there's enough real scandal to go around, you don't into he had to manufacture any. some dems are nervous, very nervous, they don't want to back hillary especially if there are knew surprises but they have to now. don't let them off the hook be patient and be ready to jump when the opportunities present themselves. the left's focus on the first female president has them on the ropes. what they should have put up is the most qualified candidate of any jepder or race, that unforced air opens up the field

. >> james carville has a of clintons' use, on sunday it appeared -- >> you wonder why the public is following this? because they know what it is. it was something that she did, it was legal, i suspect she didn't want louis gopper rifling through her e-mails, which seems to me to be a reasonable position for someone to take. so it appears -- just like everything else before it, it amounts to to a lot of people flapping their jaws about nothing. >> at her press conference, she was saying this was a matter of convenience. this is carville, saying they premedicated, but keeping -- he's saying republicans -- >> it's not just republicans, but the media too. >> the word he said was "i suspect" i think the key thing in that statement was that he suspects that she didn't want louis gopper rifling through her private e-mail. why choose louis gopper? >> that's exactly what i think. >> and private e-mails, something that the everyday american can understand. creeps in your mail. >> do you want some creepy guy rifling through your private e-mail? >> she's not just thinking about him. he's an eas

first the line of attack was from david brock, then james carville, the ragin' cajun.ook at the facts, don't look at the story, focus on where it came from. that was the first attack. then waiting about eight days, and she's come out today saying it was basic convenience. i'm not releasing the server, i only deleted private stuff dealing with my mother ace finial and my daughter's wedding. so i think it relies on this rorschach test. do you believe her or not. ? people in the middle will have to see. what's your view of thousand this will go over political? >> i think james carville would be happy if we used talking points that pro-clinton organizations send around and base stories on that. i think there's reasonable questionings that reasonable people have the e-mails and their provenance and the server. i think there are people who won't be satisfied, but there's a middle ground of people asking real questions, again, about security, government reports and her compliance with federal rules. >>> what about the question i raised this afternoon? will we ever get to the

she had her attack dog, sydney blumenthal blumenthal, james carville. had three of the best-known private investigators in the country on retainer. they were part of it. they know how to do it. >> all right. let me ask you this. the clinton foundation has taken money from all over the world, qatar, kuwait, brunei, we're putting up on the screen the gender gap in terms of this is where they are ranked nationwide and how they treat women. saudi arabia women can't drive, they need male counterparts. i'm just putting it up there. what is your take -- she hasn't been critical the champion of womens rights has taken tens of millions of dollars from countries that have abysmal rights records for women. and what is your take on that? >> well, it comes down to two things. it's real obvious. everybody knows that money is the most important thing with the clintons. period. >> do you think she won't criticize because the money's more important than the principle of standing up. >> exactly. being womens advocate and, you know, the war on women attack is totally bogu

james carville and jerry brown both say no. but a lot of democrats right now aren't convinced their presumed front-runner is quite ready for primetime. >>> a story that's captivated the country, the arrest and what appears to be the stunning confession of fugitive millionaire robert durst. >>> finally tonight, president obama is doing it, so are 40 million other americans. time to make your final four picks. >>> and tonight, something you're not going to get anywhere else. we have got our blue state and red state brackets. the teams you should be picking if you're a progressive. the teams you should be pick if you're a conservative. we will unveil that a few minutes from now. this is "hardball." the place for politics. ♪ nice! gr-reat! a shot like that... calls for a post-game celebration. share what you love with who you love. kellogg's frosted flakes. they're gr-r-reat! lilly. she pretty much lives in her favorite princess dress. but once a week i let her play sheriff so i can wash it. i use tide to get out those week old sta

this is carville saying they premedicated, but keeping -- he's saying republicans -- >> it's not just >> the word he said was "i suspect" i think the key thing in that statement was that he suspects that she didn't want louis gopper rifling through her private e-mail. why choose louis gopper? >> that's exactly what i think. >> and private e-mails, something that the everyday american can understand. creeps in your mail. >> do you want some creepy guy rifling through your private e-mail? >> she's not just thinking about him. he's an easy villain. he's also talking about the press. she's also talking about reporters that might have questions. >> steve, steve, reporters, our colleagues got every clinton scandal wrong for ten years, completely wrong. the headline on the front page of "new york times," wrong. every aspect of whitewater wrong. >> which headline? >> the first one about whitewater. >> you're talking about whitewater. >> but the first story in the times about the e-mail was also wrong, in terms of she violated the law, they got the law wrong. this has happened to them over and

james carville and jerry brown both say no. but a lot of democrats right now aren't convinced their presumed front-runner is quite ready for primetime. a story that's captivated the country, the arrest and what appears to be the stunning confession of fugitive millionaire robert durst. >>> finally tonight, president obama is doing it so are 40 other americans. time to make your final four picks. and tonight, something you're not going to get anywhere else. we have got our blue state and red state brackets. the teams you should be picking if you're a progressive. the teams you should be pick if you're a conservative. we will unveil that a few minutes from now. this is "hardball." the place for politics. when you ache and haven't slept... you're not you. tylenol® pm relieves pain and helps you fall fast asleep and stay asleep. we give you a better night. you're a better you all day. tylenol®. doers they don't worry if something's possible. they just do it. at sears optical, we're committed to bringing them eyewear that works as h

nothing to see here according to carville. but don't be fooled by that old fool carville. and now the presidential want-to-be is up to her political eyeballs in another scandal. this e-mail scandal is a big story with lots of legs. did she break the law? was she hacked? is president obama complye complicate. don't blow it. stay smart, stay on topic. no wacky conspiracy theories. the democrats are very nervous. they don't want to back hillary, especially if there are more surprises. but they have to now. so don't let them off the hook. be patient and be ready to jump when the opportunities present themselves, which they will. the less focus on the first female president has them on the ropes. what they should have put up was the most qualified candidate of any gender or any race. that unforced error opens up the field so play your cards right, conservatives, like this. your move, hillary. and sit back and enjoy the show. it's going to be a good one by the way. this is it for us tonight. thanks for watching. i'm eric bolling in for bill o'reilly. please remember the spin sto

interesting james carville was on tv. yesterday, whole reason she set up private server didn't want to deal with republicans on the hill. martha: can you blame her? the problem she works for the united states government. >> when you're secretary of state there is congressional oversight. martha: they bought it an installed it, the business she was doing belongs to her boss, the american people and united states government. do you think we'll get to a point where trey gowdy takes it to full congress for a vote whether or not they subpoena the server? >> based on "fox news sunday," he is planning to do that. former secretary will be giving a speech. elected to the irish hall of fame. martha: hillary o-clinton. >> right. she will give remarksly l lunch midtown manhattan. first time we heard her speak for a week, 15 minutes. martha: what time is happening? >> 12:45 eastern time. unlikely she will rehash all of that she is the point. she is trying to obviously turn the page and talk about her time at secretary of state. republ

. >> james carville is a longtime political adviser to both bill and hillary clinton and joins me thousand. james, good to see you. >> good morning. >> good morning. first of all, isn't it time for hillary clinton to speak out? if you were advising her, should she address these issues? >> i wouldn't -- i don't know -- i don't know exactly -- it was legal. it wasn't against regulations. colin powell and jeb bush did the same thing, but oh my god, do you remember whitewater? do you remember foulgate? do you remember travelgate? do you remember pardongate? do you remember benghazi? all of this is just the same cook make cockamamie stuff that we go through. they've got to walk the story back. the chin scratchers go oh my god. the story's not right, but it says something larger about the clintons. this is never going to end. we've lived with this for 20 years. we'll live with it for the rest of the campaign. it's all about nothing. that's my view of the whole thing. >> james, to take this back -- >> okay. >> " -- the times" did say they could have put more detail in. >> of course. >> the public

howard dean. >> howard dean but also before that we -- >> james carville. >> james carville.ink it is the right or it is the constant narrative to pound against the clintons and howard dean even said she didn't break regulation. what's going on here because i feel like again, i'm on two different planets, those who actually you know, look at facts and those that are trying to drive a message to defend hillary clinton. am i wrong? >> no you're not wrong at all. it is understandable her defenders and this ring of surrogates around her would -- the first thing they would say, there's nothing to this and it's all a big hit job and you're all barking up the wrong tree? >> nothing to this? >> there is certainly something to it don't have to be a republican or even talked to one recently to have a question about why she set up a private e-mail system in her house. i mean when she was the secretary of state. i mean that -- she still hasn't answered what the original intent and thinking was and whether anyone approved it >> howard dean said she didn't break regulation. he hasn't seen

look james carville is doing his job.e has been a member, lead member, of the clinton posse since 1992. of course he is going to say that. and the truth is she is a heavy favorite. but we can't know what we can't know. you never know whether a big scandal that will really knock her off her perch will come to the for. you never know if world events will change voter perspective there could be an economic shock and landslides in politics and geology, so these things are unknowable. we're more than a year and a half out. that's an extraordinarily long period of time -- >> all right, all right. doesn't stop us from talking about it's every minute. we know history and know in 1968 everyone thought that lyndon johnson was going to run again and we know the only gay miking a realistic challenge was the guy, eugene mccarthy, all of a sudden lbj pulls out, bob kennedy is in there, everybody and his uncle gets in there because they sensed it was open season. i'm beginning to wonder whether we're at that or could be at the point wit

james carville was on this network basically saying he kept saying all of this, all of the questionsils and all of the things she has yet to address are right wing talking points and reminds me of her initial response to the lewinsky scandal, a vast right wing conspiracy and trying to bring that language back into this. can they do that? >> no, i mean, respectfully, no. i mean if it -- you don't have to have talked to any republican in the last week to have the same basic question i posed a moment ago, why did she set up a parallel e-mail system to the state department one? i mean, there may be an explanation for it. great. let's hear it. but that has nothing to do with it being a republican hit job. that's a simple question of public accountability. >> right, and especially when there's the fact here as well that the president himself, that this was his administration saying you can't be keeping things -- >> oh, and, by the way, the president was e-mailing with her on that account. >> ann gearan from "the washington post," thank you for your time tonight. >> thank you. >> when was t

such an outdated tactic she and carville are using to this point. they have run out of allies, not only this press. you have to realize the majority of voters in this country are independent for a reason because both parties have been so, so politicized they don't feel the obligation to back one party or the other. there for she will not see that support. >> ainsley, you cover news in fox, if you were in the room what would you ask her. >> i would ask her were you hacked? he definitely thinks she was hacked maybe by china or some other countries like iran and north korea. i would want to know why if she is not trying to hide anything why she hasn't turned over the server yet. why she didn't that a week ago when this all came out. i wonder why the state department is investigating this. why isn't there independent investigation. >> good questions. meantime, the white house is trying to clarify its story whether it comes to whether or not president obama knew about hillary clinton's private emails. in an interview over the weekend, president obama sai

. >>> let's dig with in james carville, long-time clinton ally. ana navarro. new yorker editor david remnick and fox news anchor greta susteren. >> if you take this all and put it together, and you subtract 3.1415 from pi, you're left with not very much. and that's -- at the end of the day, the republicans can't pass a budget, we have another investigation. just like we had the white water. just like you go through file gate. you go through travel gate. you go through seven or different eight congressional committees. you wonder why the public is not following this. because they know what it is. it was something she did. it was legal. i suspect she didn't want louis doumit rifling through her e-mails. which seems to me to be a kind of reasonable position for someone to take. it amounts to -- just like everything else before it, it amounts to nothing a bunch of people flapping their jaws about nothing. >> nothing? >> not one if it's illegal, it violated the spirit of the law. she shouldn't have done it. what i can't get over, how stupid. i mean, she must have k

listen to what she said last week and listen to what carville said on sunday. >> i opted for convenience to use my personal e-mail account because i thought it would be easier to carry just one device. >> i suspect she didn't want louis gohmert to rifle through her e-mails which seems to me to be a reasonable step to take. >> a reference to congressional oversight. congressman gohmert a former judge, is on the house committee to which the secretary of state reports in justifying her behavior. >> she didn't want him rifling through. >> she shouldn't have become secretary of state. >> doesn't work that way. >> so jim carville who we know at one time worked here apparently saying don't believe what she said last week. she was trying to frustrate congress's lawful authority. >> off script. last question they originally said last week that the way they determined what they were going to delete was just some keyword searches and if it appeared to fall within that keyword search and sounded businessy, they produced it. if not they deleted it. in to which response everyone says what? that's not

longtime supporters like james carville and lanny davis coming to her defense vociferously, and overast few hours reports have emerged that she will finally address the e-mail situation at some point this week, maybe within the next few days. so what should we expect? will it signal a turn ing point in hillary clinton's strategy and enough to curb the slew of bad press she's received? joining us now, anne gearan reporter for the "washington post" covering hillary clinton tonight. thanks for joining us. >> happy to be here. >> let me ask you what you're hearing then. we've heard nothing from hillary clinton publicly for a week now. are you hearing that we will hear from her in the next couple of days? >> well, i mean we haven't -- not that we haven't heard anything from her publicly. she has been part of a couple of the sort of scripted events that -- >> on the e-mail question, we've heard zero. except for this week. >> right. exactly. exactly. when dianne feinstein says you're doing it wrong, you have a problem, and she has to confront that problem because it's gone beyond the argume

james carville is doing what james carville always does. men and knocking them down. this -- we were talking to somebody really high up at the white house over the past week who said they had no idea how she did this. they were stunned that she did this. i was just talking about, you know, my time in public service when i was in congress. you know it bounced off the walls. i had all of these ideas. when it came to rules on e-mails, rules on bank accounts rules on this and that you just knew. it was black and white. there was no gray. this is the law. this is ho you you do it. that's how everybody else out there -- >> my question -- >> but the clintons. we don't have time for pushing him and pretty soon it dissolves to you calling him a baby and giving him a binky so we're going to go to al hunt instead. really quickly and then al. >> jonathan would you say you said i don't know. would you say that if it was dick cheney? >> good question. that's a good question. but again, what i was talking about in terms of the american people, it becomes

there are a lot of people that are tired of hillary clinton, and bill clinton, and james carville popping up and lenny davis, same old davis. kennedy: like a donald rumsfeld, and dick cheney. >> i hear you, here is problem with that, it is wrong, most people like her,. kennedy: you couldn't name a karris magic candidate. >> do they love her. kennedy: she is not charismatic. >> i concede, but -- kennedy: what does she have? >> you have a ton of money away up in poll, she is hugely higher than any democrat or republican in race, and she will probably win. kennedy: it kind of matters but if you want your president to be a good trustworthy solid individual. >> make that argument i don't like her, and view is good but don't pretend she is not a hugely potent political force. kennedy: i will say, the e-mail scandal has not touched her poll numbers, they have notoved. people say, she is not trust worthy, i would vote for her, what do you rack that up to. >> among her base, ellis said people like her, i don't know if there is a deep affect for her like when reactio reagan was al. she has that mom

carville is offering nothing to see here folks.s clinton, and yet we have news there may be a press conference which would seem to suggest the camp is taking it fairly seriously. >> they have to take it seriously. before the campaign has started here's this story that is seven days long. here it's been going on for a week. she has to put a stop to it. those who thought she should do nothing about it were clearly wrong and it's made her a loser. >> was there a sense of secrecy? people go back to this meme of the clinton world. how much of that was in play? >> i covered her for four years. i interviewed her 15 times. i never got an e-mail but we saw a very different person when she was at the state department. my experience from dealing with her and the people around her and other people in the building was there was relatively good accessibility. we got a lot of off the record chats on the road with her over dinner, over drinks. she came to the back of the plane to talk to us. my personal experience and that of my colleagues at the

appearing on abc news james carvil said her practices were legal, but was probably influenced by wantingo avoid congressional oversight. and that is a reasonable position to make about the email practices except that it is not something hillary clinton has been willing to say. finally, remember clinton supporter and former member of congress anthony weaner. the husband of a top aid who resigned after he was caught sending suggestive pictures over twitter? well, he recently filmed a scene for the movie shark-nado three. if you are unfamiliar with the series here is a clip of shark-nado two. and since when is anthony weaner an actor? well, he said, quote: shark-nado three with former congressman anthony weaner coming soon to a theater near you. >> david, thank you. >>> hundreds of thousands of more people in oregon will soon be registered to vote without doing anything. the governor signed in to law the most sweeping motor voter law in the nation and opponents are worried about potential fraud. >>> vladimir putin made his first appearance after disappearing ten days ago. the kremlin had tr

they are -- this is familiar territory to them, you had james carville saying, hey, maybe she hid thels because she didn't want lieuies gopper going through. >> lauren, were you going to say something? >> at some point the republicans have to link that are investigations to what people care about. i think peter king has sort of figured out that's not happening. do people care about benghazi? i think that's fairly unlikely. this is the 45 -- sort of the tea party wing obviously in the house, but there are a lot of republicans who do want to get something done and have a report to stand on in 2016. >> mitch mcconnell said the day after the election we're not going to use this congress to shut down the government and grind things to a halt. we have to achieve something we can run on. >>> the roundtable is staying with us. up next, the nasty side of social media. this is "hardball," the place for politics. amopé and its premium foot care line. the new amopé pedi perfect foot file gives you soft beautiful feet effortlessly. its microlumina rotating head buffs away hard skin even on those h

ironically she set this up, james carville admitted this over the weekend, to ostensibly avoid congressionalversight. she could have done that by just having her state department email and having her private email. none of it makes any sense. the fact of the matter is, we have virtually ready were to impeach nixon over 18 missing minutes. we have 32,000 destroyed documents. and this might not affect certain polls but this does come down to, as a presidential election, to judgment and, yes the clintons have gotten away with a lot but perhaps there is a tipping point. this kind of a dynamic is that tipping point. it is not about look the book tour was run badly. the press conference at the u.n. was horrible. she clearly i think, bill clinton's a smart guy. i met both of them when i worked on that campaign in 1992. she has never been liked. she has never had the same kind of charm or charisma her husband's had. that will also work against her. it worked against her in 2008. her judgment is clearly not very good either. jon: leslie, you don't have a problem with the former secretary of state wri

. >> i don't find it stunning that james carville sent that to you last night. i do find it stunning what mark halperin is saying right here. >> but it's true joe. >> it's also true -- >> she was required -- >> a manual that you just keep in your house next to your cereal. >> look it up! >> in 2009 -- ron fournier please step in here. this is turning into a cartoon. >> to be ironic here, with all due respect to mr. halperin, the argument that mark is making is like saying, somebody who robs a bank, once they get the money to their house, they get to decide how much to return. what we're overlooking here what she conveniently overlooked here is that she has total right to use a personal account. she wants to make that the case because that's not a problem. she can have a personal account. what she can't do is have that account stored outside of the government servers. so she -- against violation, clearly against violation, stored all of that on a private, dark server registered to her house, kept secret from foi requests, kept secret from the white house. and now

. >> carville and lanny davis, they are all out there spinning and saying, wait look, the right-wingalking heads media are blowing it out of proportion. we're not. it is important. think about this for a second. '09 to '13, she was secretary of state, benghazi 12, all the pz e-mails, everything with benghazi went through her private server and we don't know what was going on, never know what back and forth correspondence. she is the one that said nothing was classified, her words nothing she did on her personal was classified. >> doesn't matter. it doesn't matter. all federal records, doesn't matter if it's classified or not. >> we should have access to it agreed. >> yep. >> however how can nothing from benghazi or didn't send any benghazi e-mails which i find that more ludicrous. mention yesterday 1 billion, 1 billion e-mails the state department in those years and they only thought 71,000 were important enough to keep. 71,000 out of 1 billion. kim perry, listen to shannon coffin, if you put your prosecutor hat on could you make this case? >> yeah i think make the case. all you need

. >> it will come foreign minister carville and beg gala and lanny davis and everybody at msnbc and theal page of the "new york times." they will be carrying the sexism argue. to the american people. i don't know if it's going to work. >> well, we are going to keep a chart on how many sexism charges, you know, i think we will do that. we will update it. >> the over125,000 in the first week. >> we will start getting that chart together as soon as she announces. we'll have the sexismrnie goldberg, everybody. plenty more ahead as the factor moves along this evening. would you buy them dinner? featuring hillary clinton and secretary of state john kerry tonight. also ahead, gutfeld and mcguirk and the highest states in the union where marijuana is used the most. we hope you will stay tune to those reports. it's as old as our time on earth. and as new as tomorrow. you can have a yard. or slightly less. gardening isn't about where we choose to live. it's about how we choose to live. miracle-gro. life starts here. normally people wear pants. yeah that's why i'm hiding captain obvious. not very

she took a liking to me and i pitched an article about a leprosy hospital in carville, louisiana. she said sure. we will send a photographer down. go down and do the story so i went to cargill and stayed two or three days and wrote this piece and it came out about three days after i started my internship and two days before i met my wife, sonya. it was an eventful week. and corey dean would say why don't you write about your internship? i said okay. it turned out to be a great indication, because in an internship everything is new. as you go on in medicine you get jaded. you see things and you start questioning but when you are and in turn everything is new is rubles a year end up with i don't give a hoot what i write. i am going to write about what i see and the things that interest me and the things i am going to question. i remember one of my early pieces as an intern, there was a fellow in hospital and who was having difficulty swallowing and when he would swallow food would go into his lungs. everyone was getting ready to put in the feeding tube into his stomach. the thing wa

james carville revealed a truth by the way when he said on ax the reason why she had her own email was didn't want republicans like louie government rooting through them. that means she didn't want congressional oversight. if you are secretary of state you can't say i don't want congressional. >> all of those things pail, henry in comparison to the stupidity that we are witnessing. jen psaki has a nerve to get out there after 14 days and say she doesn't know come on. i mean, this is -- hillary clinton is the most famous secretary of state since daniel webster. all right? everything she does is chronicled. the state department knows whether she signed it or not. >> right. it is a simple question. and i get that it's been a couple of years. but as jen psaki says she wasn't a normal employee. figure that out. you have a file somewhere. what did mrs. clinton sign and what did she not? you would think there is a file somewhere. >> 14 days. and when megyn kelly first had this story we called the state department and said do you have it they said we need more time. >> more time. like bowe bo

that's not all, former clinton adviser james carville said this yesterday. >> it was something that she did it was legal. i suspect she didn't want louis gohmert rifling through her e-mails which seems to me to be kind of a reasonable position for someone to take. so it amounts -- just like everything else before it, it amounts to nothing but a bunch of people flapping their jaws about nothing. >> oh, that's right. conspiracy back. earlier today hillary clinton was in new york city for an event. our own ed henry tried to ask her a question. >> hello, mrs. secretary, did you sign that statement? >> tonight on the "hannity" big board, you cover hillary the white house? >> a little bit of everything yeah. >> didn't answer your question. >> sure. i mean, this is about the document that on the way out the door the secretary of state is supposed to sign certifying that she's accounted for all the records she has. in this case she left with tens of thousands of e-mails she deemed personal. she admits now some were personal and she has turned over some 50000 over to the state department. if she